EWS कोटा कैसे खोखला करता है SC/ST/OBC आरक्षण |

[@kumaranmol8729]

Very good analysis by Disha Maam

[@bhagwatraonarnaware5358]

Salute to you Madam। आज तक मैने ऐसा argument नही सुना,how upper castes are reserved by name EWS

[@ramniksingh10]

Very knowledgeable information

[@shivbratchoudhary979]

Madam ka mindset anti brahman hai, inke according constitution only dalit sc,st ke liye hin bana hai baki brahman, musalman aur christian country ke liye alien hai.

[@KaustubhRayrikar]

Brilliant Analysis of EWS Judgement.Also Got new sources to study this issue in detail.Thanks.

[@Indusvalleypeople]

Super💐

[@जयभारत-च4श]

3️⃣0️⃣.0️⃣8️⃣ ➡️ ये कह रही है कि EWS से Cast Based Reservation खत्म करने का दरवाजा खुल गया है। शुरू में कह रही थी कि EWS पूर्णत: जाति आधारित आरक्षण है लेकिन SC - ST - OBC को मिला आरक्षण जाति आधारित नहीं है। विरोधाभास ..........

[@tanmay771]

Superb! Thank you!

[@cinefile0075]

OBC SC ST should be added to ews if government wants it in first place. EWS shouldn't be there but if it's there then economical weak section of OBC SC ST should be added and it will be added in future for sure.

[@Chad_kafir]

First of all patriarchy has never existed in india before invaders bkame islamists for patriarchy and also no reservation should exist or it should only exist on basis of economic conditions 🇮🇳🚩🚩🔱

[@MdSohel-ve8bs]

Supreme court bjp government ke pressure m ye faisla diya hai

[@ajaynagarade]

Super Interview👍. Disha Akka explained everything very simply , easy to understand.

[@anshuman355]

Great Analysis Mam

[@prabhu5299]

Govt need to do proper servey..which community is backward in social and economic then afterwards gave them reservation.. Par Govt toh manuwaadi aur nikkammi h.

[@Anityam]

Enlightening talk

[@athotagunateja6023]

Leaving India is better. let it be under developed, let’s make US more powerful by paying taxes to US. no use of paying taxes to India

[@Sibu_MusicOfficial]

Good idea. U should go there

[@athotagunateja6023]

@@Sibu_MusicOfficial yeah we should leave India as abandon

[@Sibu_MusicOfficial]

@@athotagunateja6023 you should definitely! I’m not going anywhere . I ❤️ india

[@AJEETKUMAR-nq1fz]

Thanks Ad. Disha Mam.

[@jegannathanmillerirs9182]

Stop atrocities against dalits and tribals,Permit entry in temples, Stop untochability , give power , Political power We are ready to forego reervation. we dont want reservation. we want respect and dignity.

[@anurodh_lal]

Are you serious 😂

[@uppinkayiranga]

She claims that sc/St/obc reservation is not caste based reservation. And it goes unchallenged. That's why Sharma and Mishra who are feeling internal guilt should not conduct interviews on such topics. Apparently Caravan magazine couldn't find any dalit interviewer who could freely talk to this woman without fear. Nothing new came out from this. Also cannot understand why he wrapped up the interview saying that time is up? Ppl are doing 2/3 hour podcasts these days. Q to this woman - if sc/St/obc reservation is not caste based, will beneficiaries get reservation without caste certificate?

[@Sibu_MusicOfficial]

Bro tera engineering ke time pe nahi hua iska yeh matlab nahi hai ki tu historical systemic discrimination ko ignore karega. kitaab padle 😂

[@uppinkayiranga]

@@Sibu_MusicOfficial mene to engineering nhi kiya. Reservation for Historical injustice and all is fine. But It is clearly caste based. Could not understand why had to lie that only ews is caste based.

[@moe00711]

thank you for an excellent conversation/explanation on the current EWS reservation passed by the supreme court. 💯👍🏽

[@Myavepea]

EWS examples upper caste in Undeserved

[@anurodh_lal]

Do you support CREAMYLAYER like concept in SC and ST? If NOT then STOP BARKING

[@sameer4937]

Excellent analysis

[@शंकराचार्य-भक्त]

EWS ko 25% करो

[@guris7327]

Very informative

[@mpclasses6661]

EWS reservation has been well compared as reservation to poor men of upper caste only. EWS is flood gate where upper caste people getting at lowest cut off marks...

[@nxclipes4447]

ya st ,sc wali h ky🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@wishyr5940]

Articles के बारे मे यहाँ कई लोगों ने लिखा है

[@anshikasaxena3510]

If EWS is for he priviledged ones then what about SC/ST reservation. In a household of general caste, you will hardly find a single person working in govt jobs and when you survey on the occupation of sc st households you will find every adult in government jobs be it a teacher, doctor or any other profession .

[@burneracco]

You say every SC/ST household got Govt employee through SC/ST reservation. TRUE. So could you please tell me why was SC/ST is applied on it in the first place? which Castes are govt employees before this reservation was applied? Do you understand what you are trying to argue? Let me explain, SC/ST reservation were applied in govt because it was DOMINATED BY UCs in the first place.

[@shivbratchoudhary979]

Madam kya ews me only savarn hindu hai aapke according....? Aapko pata hona chahiye iame muslim aur christian and other religion ke weaker section ko bhi shamil kiya gaya hai. Mam puna pact ki baat kr rahi hai baar baar is pact me daliton(although they are hindus) ke liye ek 74 and 143 ke around seat ko reserve kiya gaya tha, us pact me kahi ye nahi tha ki daliton ko to reservation dEdo lekin kisi other class ki uplifting nahi honi chahiye. Mam biased dikh rahi hai.

[@atulhundoo5635]

I disagree ews reservation is not for privileged ones.

[@Anityam]

Aapse anurodh h ki aise important topic ko 1/2hr mein na samete kyonki Ma'am aisi baatein kar Rahi h jo ki kahi nhi milta h

[@aurangzebansari3007]

Very nice discussion

[@drsandeepbharti]

Atrocities has been inflicting upon Sc/St from thousands of years & Jury is saying it's been 75 Years & the reservation has not working & needs to be changed. Caste based census data also should be available in public domain

[@Videos.islamic121]

Is Reservation is justice?

[@Sibu_MusicOfficial]

Is reservation justice? No it’s a compromise. They should get reparations and all upper caste should acknowledge the abuse caused by them and privilege they have. Isse kehte hai growing up

[@dipenduhalder7491]

What about GENRAL cast????

[@bhagwatraonarnaware5358]

अब लोकतंत्र नाममात्र रह गया है। Judiciary ब्राह्मण्यवाद पर काम कर रहे हैं। Judiciary अभी beyond constitution and law, भावना के आधार पर फैसले देते हैं

[@athotagunateja6023]

First of all, we have to remove reservation to her because she is privileged now

[@aloksahu5660]

Constitution mein OBC reservation kaha hai??

[@arvindkardam685]

Article 16(4) and 15(4)

[@aloksahu5660]

@@arvindkardam685 It mentioned backward Classes but doesn't give Defination of it. EWS can be defined in this backward classes as they are economically backward.

[@cynicalcare8518]

@@aloksahu5660 social criteria...

[@vinaypal3310]

340

[@aloksahu5660]

@@vinaypal3310 it allows President to make a commission to defined who is backward class & who isn't. EWS bhi aise hi mila hai.

[@booksquotes948]

Stop all quotas. Y quotas r needed in 2022 ?

[@cenationofjnu]

Ews is purely reservation for svarna/upper caste people. How? Because only upper caste people who make less than 8 lakhs can apply for it. Sc st obc people are excluded it despite the fact that vast majority of poor people in India belong to these sections. In fact, ews is a reservation for rich svarnas. If it's not actually for poor people, then why vast majority of people are excluded from it. Second, it's unconstitutional. The fact that supreme court didn't object those is a proof that judges don't care about justice and constitution when it comes to their own upper caste brothers. They had problems when reservation went above the limit of 50% for sc St obc people but when it comes to their upper caste people, all is fine. Second, patriarchy. Patriarchy is necessary. Patriarchy is natural order. Patriarchy is the base of civilizations. Without patriarchy, there would be no civilization because women can't build $hit on their own. Please don't get confused with caste system and patriarchy. Caste system is evil. Patriarchy is not. Women will never be able to understand it because they are incapable to understand the plight of men. They can't think above their own oppression. If patriarchy dies then what would replace it. Matriarchy? Matriarchy is for fools and weak people. Matriarchal society can't survives for long. Patriarchy is necessary to save women from all kinds of dangers. It's because of patriarchy that women lived safely in the past thousands of years despite wars. Patriarchy protected the society, protected the women from themselves and other dangers.

[@nelsonth]

Patriarchy produces the very dangers it claims to protect women from. Patriarchy is moreover deeply tied into casteism, most deeply in the patriarchal, Brahminical policing of the reproductive powers of women, so that caste lines are maintained. And nobody is seriously advocating for matriarchy, it speaks volumes that a demand for equal political and social rights is automatically interpreted by people like you as attempt to foist another hierarchy. "When you are used to privilege, equality feels like oppression."

[@Sibu_MusicOfficial]

Patriarchy is not the original order. It’s an unfortunate and backward state of mind. Just like racism and making fun of disabled or casteism . It’s discrimination at mass. Aur agar original order se itna pyaar hai toh KZbin pe comment mat daal, jungle mei jaakar shikaari kar na!! 😂

[@booksquotes948]

Leave india & join uk usa canada where hard work is respected.

[@athotagunateja6023]

Waste of time

[@Vimukta]

great points put forth by Disha ma'am👍🏾

[@studentstudent5233]

Ye great point tb kha gayab ho jate jb sc obc se ne ias ips ke bache reservation lete h