S2 EP. 6: The Eyes (Remastered Edition)

[@Thomas1Edward2Henry3]

For those asking about remaking Search for Smudger, I've considered it but it's quite complicated with aspects like voice actors no longer being active. I feel like I would have to recast some people too and that itself brings a whole moral dilemma. I have thought about doing it in Wooden Railway like Haunted Henry but I would need to do a large rewrite because I feel like the original story was wayyyyy too complicated.

[@kernowpictures2002]

May I be in the cast?

[@JohntheLNERP2]

You shouldn't remake Search for Smudger it's too good for that

[@user-DeLorean-Dude2024]

Andrew who voices Duke in the original still does voice acting if do you decide to remake Search for Smudger he is still doing voice acting.

[@kernowpictures2002]

@@user-DeLorean-Dude2024 I can be Duke and my version of his voice is basically OJs from tugs

[@angelobates601]

Can you remake the search for smudger

[@MiguelTrainfan]

2014 Duncan: r ya f**king kidding me?! 2021 Duncan: oh u got to be jokin?!

[@matthewhahn1132]

Oh?

[@MohdAdil-k8l]

Both: you u have to f**king joking

[@HM-mt9tn]

2014 sir Handel damn it 2021 sir Handel fiddle stick’s

[@NathanielPiscian]

2014: RRRRUN for ya life it’s the eyes!! 2021: run for your life it’s the eyes

[@ShortPuff]

Probably my favourite remaster so far. That ending was chilling -

[@amitysluzara2022]

Oh my goodness you made an already terrifying story even more chilling

[@Planetkid32]

I miss when Duncan said: *“ARE YA F#*KING KIDDING ME?!”*

[@ianprice1744]

Where was this?

[@JustCallMeHeavy]

@@ianprice1744 Original

[@ellieandronansvlogs7081]

@@JustCallMeHeavy yeah guys it’s linked in the desc

[@ava6278]

Me too

[@NATETHEMATE2nd]

Percival: I'm afriad you'll have to spend the night here. Duncan: ARE YA F***IN' KIDDING ME!!!

[@istvannagy748]

Sir Handle: DAMN IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Atleast we have a shed.

[@WesleyO05]

Sir Handel: DAMN IT!!!

[@lidoislandstudios2635]

@@istvannagy748 “I don’t agree with the language but, yes. You do have a shed.”

[@QueeNGWR]

@Sir Handel Productions (Said) damn youtube new rules suck sometimes

[@matthewfender1993]

Duncan: You Gotten Been Kidding Me!!!

[@comicfan1324]

Bertram offers to tell in Egnor Allen Poe story. “I meant a scary story.” In what way are those stories not scary?

[@Reading3412Studios]

I’ve never really considered Edgar Allen Poe’s stories to be all that scary, just really depressing.

[@titanicboy2722]

I read a story made by Edger Allen Poe, it was called the Black Cat. it wasn't that scary, but one of the most spine chilling parts of that story is when everyone is gathered at a wall where it appeared that there was a silhouette of a cat with a noose around it's neck on a wall. That part wasn't that scary, but it was unsettling. I mean if you saw that on your wall one day, why wouldn't you be unsettled.

[@WesternOhioInterurbanHistory]

Cask Of The Armadillo

[@johnathanedwards9054]

The Raven, The Black Cat, The Tell-tale Heart, The Pendulum, these are all scary stories commonly told on Halloween. Edgar Allen Poe is often called the Father of Horror but he also wrote a few modern detective stories.

[@martinkredl3794]

As the simpsons said about the raven: What was scrary then may not be scary now

[@wolfzillaproductions4563]

1:15 Duke’s reaction to Sir Handel’s suggestion killed me XDDD

[@WesleyO05]

That won’t scare anyone; that’ll make us sick!

[@pokebreeder2517]

first time i've seen someone bring on bertrum X3 glad to see him get some love from the fans

[@YukariAkiyamaTanks]

I still die in laughter when hear duncan scream and sir handel looks like he shat himself. I kind of miss the swearing but I get you remastered it. However bertrams face is honestly terrifying

[@Thomas1Edward2Henry3]

What are your guys theories for what happened? That end shot of Duncan was supposed to be a nod towards him making it up and playing a prank on Sir Handel but I didn’t want to make it too obvious.

[@Douglas57647]

To be honest, I don't think Duncan is that good of an actor to be able to fake something like that. I think it's more likely that he either hallucinated as was stated in the episode, or he really did see a pair of eyes in the mist. To whom those eyes might have belonged, I can't say for sure...

[@JohntheLNERP2]

I think Duncan told a story without actually knowing his story really happened on the MSR

[@DarkBlueEngineProductions2024]

that really scared me

[@Trollingdemon_07]

Duncan couldn’t get the image of the eyes out of his mind so he had a nightmare of himself with red eyes (It’s my head-canon of what I think happened in the end)

[@c.trains4785]

Obvious it was real all along and I have a feeling that sooner or later the narrow gauge engines will encounter him again someday

[@Douglas57647]

That was so good! The original was definitely one of your best stories, but it's nice to see a remastered version. I always liked how Duncan acted all tough for most of the episode, then got scared of his own made-up story! I also remember how this episode led into The Search for Smudger - good that you kept that foreshadowing at the end!

[@J.Tstudioproduction6375]

This remastered episode of the story was very spooky, just like the original episode. Very nice job on making this remastered episode.

[@angelhuerta1626]

Now This is a true and extreme awesome Halloween special I’ve never heard duncan scream like that in year Lucky that he survived and sir handle to even though he had no idea what has happened

[@ps7372]

I prefer the original versions of the remastered episodes, I know u cringe at ur older videos but I prefer them over the remasters. But that’s just my opinion. The main oreason I like the original version of this episode is because of Bertram’s voice.

[@Thomas1Edward2Henry3]

Yeah I totally getcha and that’s why I leave the originals up. I also agree that it’s completely different without EE93. The main purpose of these remakes are just to align them more with later events and take out some cringey immature jokes that dont fit the tone. That’s why I’m not doing all of them.

[@charimew3745]

I like the way you replaced Albert and Jim with that frowning blue engine with Edward's face.

[@moonlightrider24]

Agreed but this remake definitely had some strengths over the original like the music, effects and editing,

[@ryanlister1244]

@@Thomas1Edward2Henry3 Nice remastered there, Thomas1Edward2Henry3.

[@Junior_IV]

Who the hell burn the Shed

[@samster4044]

i only just realized the bit with Bertram after Duncan goes to sleep is foreshadowing the events from the search for Smudger

[@braydensrandomvideos1628]

Bruh Duncan’s possessed at the end

[@Gamer-1-2024]

The scene where sir Handel's eyes widen used to make me laugh 😂

[@ilikecheeseilikecheese727]

IKR lol

[@joshuabenjamin2484]

I decided to screenshot his reaction! It gives me the shivers even the original.

[@carterher8082]

8:47 XD Sir Handel looks like he wetted himself

[@Rocketman1583]

11:32 YESSS YOU INCLUDED STONED DUNCAN

[@mousekuteerkhylert.n.p1228]

Remastered vs Original There both Spoolfully Great!

[@Trickshotter]

The ending was such a nice setup for The Search for Smudger

[@dimitrismpouloumpasis8854]

Duncan: ARE U F(BEEP)ING KIDDING MEE!!?? D:( SH: Damm it ):(

[@foxxyboi21]

This makes me so happy. The eyes was my favorite episode of this series for years. Thank you!

[@Hiawatha_Productions]

I love your evil laugh on this vid, it sounded pretty good in my opinion

[@Kanefan701]

thanks for crediting me for the evil whistle old friend.

[@JohntheLNERP2]

A remastered version of one your very best episodes I can't wait for this T1E2H3 mate

[@SodorMusicalProductions]

I remember watching it and I thought it was really good.

[@AshleesBathroom]

Ooh! This was my favourite episode in this Series and it was remastered on my birthday! This is sooooo goooooood

[@Douglas57647]

Happy birthday!

[@traindude57theb12]

I think the eyes is the class as Duncan, but he didn't want to say that.

[@MrRocklover18]

Love the fires animation Great halloween episode

[@CillianCleary-y1i]

8:51 Sir Handal:WAIT FOR ME, DUNCAN!!!

[@catcat1352]

This face as duncan was shockt the next morning🤣

[@YoutubeChannel-dh7tb]

Oh yes. Cannot wait to see this!

[@mattfabbs]

Hey man, have you considered giving NWR Origins another go, this time with Emily, Rosie, Salty and whoever else is available for an origin story?

[@edwardjenkins5421]

I would love to see stories on Neil, Stuart, Falcon and Duke. (Also it is actually possible to write both Smudger and Stanly into the Mid Sodor Railway lore. Smudger came in 1898, turned into a generator in 1902 and disappeared in 1926-27. Stanly could have been Smudger's replacement around 1902. He didn't get turned into a pump until 1928. )

[@JosephRailwayStudios2000]

Would you mind not asking him so many questions because if he wanted to end his own series

[@1v1_Empire]

Who wants a remastered version of the worst TTTE Classic Era episode, Middle Engine, where Percy and James both trick Arry and Bert and make them middle engines, they get embarrassed and scolded by The Fat Contoller and then are sent packing. Who wants this?

[@keegantaylor9742]

Me

[@e2tankengine528]

I actually tried doing that back in 2018 but it was bad but I would love to see someone do that

[@1v1_Empire]

@@e2tankengine528 well then, let's get T1E2H3's attention about this and maybe he may take notice.

[@jonathankennedy]

Favorite episode!

[@kcore1427]

I really like another Thomas fan who was a lot in common with me making videos for former fans like me who are on the Autism Spectrum and live in California. I hope you make more TEOS and NWR Origins episodes in the future, even though Wrath on the Rails was such a great movie to end on. Perhaps doing NWR Origins on some of the Skarloey Railway engines would be optimal.

[@williamseaman176]

Awesome remake!

[@AceW.Kermitcat]

I’m so glad you did the evil laugh at the end again!

[@bluebellsfan8704]

So spooky but so amazing!

[@saadahmad913]

8:38 Duncan's Scream is Priceless 😆😆😆😆🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Canadianobjectshow]

Fr

[@bowlerstuff9589]

The end was such a foreshadow to the search for Smudger.

[@Rocketman1583]

8:48 OMFG🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@callum110597]

Wow, what a spooky story.

[@hunterknobelcatholicknight3006]

I miss the part where Duncan says r u 🤬 kidding me and the scream wasn’t interrupted

[@matthewfranks2198]

Epic! Even more scary that we don’t see the evil engine

[@randoburr5201]

Yeah i mean can we just see it like i dunno like a teaser or a jumpscare

[@ilikecheeseilikecheese727]

Poor ducan is suffering from ptsd

[@tuckmanstudios]

Happy Halloween too thomas1edward2henry3. 🎃💀👻

[@TheTrainChasingPoet1999]

Much better evil laugh this time, IMO.

[@mikesreviews844]

Something about the origin of the ghost makes me think of The Omen

[@EmmettDoyleDDR435]

This one is a Halloween story to me and so creepy. 😨💭💀🚂

[@gameboy7072]

Sir Handel: What was his name Duncan: I don't know idiot

[@sonjawalker1977]

I was scrolling down your channel when I saw this video, I thought it was the old one. But boy was I wrong. I have been admiring your work since I was around 3 years old. Yes you heard me. I remember watching one of the Alfred Crisis back then. I was thinking: Oh, Just timothy. Until that new guy "Alfred" In my life.

[@limeddasch382]

7:07 Where did the "Are ya fucking kidding me?" go?

[@allisonkrueger8330]

11:10 Sir Handel and Skarloey have the same face 😂🤣

[@matthewhahn1132]

Wow that terrific and scary

[@matthewhahn1132]

Happy Halloween to you

[@RoxyBloodMoon]

Always loved this story,gave me shivers and poor Duncan at the end. ITS THE EYEESSSSSSSS

[@catcat1352]

Could it be that this locomotive is a mix between smudger, Alfred, 87546 & Duncan😂?

[@catcat1352]

Or is it thimothy in nerrow gauge?

[@Im_here170]

Hell yeah!! I remember this 😳😳😳😎😎😎

[@allisonkrueger8330]

11:10 that reason was because he’s Bertram and was found by workmen from the Mid Sodor, the day after he fell and the day before the Skarloey workmen searched, and rebuilt and given to the quarry on the Mid Sodor.

[@ellieandronansvlogs7081]

Yup that’s why it was all explained in The Search For Smudger, the Skarloey Railway workmen searched and found Bertram but left the driver and fireman’s bodies because they didn’t want to deal with bringing them back, without anyone knowing, so when the Mid Sodor Railway workmen searched the next day, their was nothing but the bodies.

[@ellieandronansvlogs7081]

Sorry the Mid Sodor railway workers found Bertram, and the Skarloey Railway workers searched the next day and found nothing but the bodies. I got them mixed up.

[@ellieandronansvlogs7081]

Also there instead of their

[@allisonkrueger8330]

@@ellieandronansvlogs7081 it’s fine we all mess up sometimes lol

[@ellieandronansvlogs7081]

@@allisonkrueger8330 yup what would our world be without mistakes

[@totallythomasfan10]

The Engine Is A Freelance Design

[@clarkray7735]

I think that Duncan freaking out after seeing the eyes of the of the demon engine he told the story about and it turning out to be a fear induced hallucination due to the story he told is exactly what would happen if anybody was scared out of their minds like the scene in the Disney movie snow white and the seven dwarfs when the huntsman told snow white that the evil Queen is out to get her for being more beautiful than she is when the huntsman told snow white to run away into the forest the reason snow white saw all those scary faces in the trees is because of fear induced hallucinations

[@thomasfan2054]

That was amazing!!

[@thi141]

8:38 I can imagine Duncan screaming this way out of fear. That stock scream fits him so well for some reason XD

[@zackschulz6448]

8:37 Duncan: No! AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH!!!

[@Rocketman1583]

You need make a sequel to this PLEASE

[@aJunctionMalfunctionProduction]

Ah, this brings back memories! Grant it the original one was far scarier, but this one had a nice humorous touch to it! In fact, the post-credits scene had me burst into laughter. Although it seemed to be some of the TRAINZ models used were out of scale with each other. You probably could've just used the SI3D ones. While out of date, it would've made everything more consistent. That's just me though.

[@Thomas1Edward2Henry3]

The SI3D engines have trouble in Trainz 2019 where their eyes don’t change direction, hence why Duncan was looking forward throughout the whole video. And the Rusty SI3D model only had one face when I installed it so I had to go with CogRaiway 3Ds model. So far no 2019 Duncan model has been made so I had to go with SI3D for him and Duke.

[@DanielTheShunter]

@@Thomas1Edward2Henry3 There are ways to fix the eyes. Have you tried it yet?

[@quarrylocomotiveproduction5439]

@@Thomas1Edward2Henry3 you should feel ashamed of yourself you gave up on Ivo hugh

[@TrainsandAdventuresTV]

Oh man the nostalgia

[@kcore1427]

Maybe also you could do your own TATMR rewrite based on the mix of the original and deleted storylines like 2020'S TATMR Parody and TATMR Rewritten. You can find all the information you need on your 20th Anniversary Blu-ray.

[@CommunityBrightHunt328]

11:29 -> Duncan cackles evilly

[@Trainboy11]

I prefer the old version too

[@LoneWolgon1991]

I really want to know what that mysterious unknown engine looked like and what his or her face looked like

[@Thegaminator348]

Where can I find the part where Duncan screams no after he sees the eyes

[@HunterCarrell]

8:38

[@WesternOhioInterurbanHistory]

Sir Handel's face is somehow funny and mildly creepy at the same time.

[@ivohughadventures676]

very well done mate

[@user-DeLorean-Dude2024]

This is so funny!

[@kadenrobinson7067]

Oh hell yes

[@bigbigarchive]

Rusty’s tiny

[@roaropgard8575]

Run for your lives its the eyes😨😨

[@GameyYTB]

Duncan is really likable surprisingly

[@TrainFanProductions4935]

Is it me or does Bertram sound… different when he isn’t voiced by EnterprisingEngine93? (In this video at least). No offense.

[@CommunityBrightHunt328]

The ending was hilarious

[@zmpjacksoncomics2077]

Imma go watch the original and see the difference

[@PivotBoi.]

Haunted Hengry remake?

[@f-1492]

Loved it! Make this a tradition and do a ghost story every year!

[@matthewhahn1132]

Poor Duncan

[@catcat1352]

I love to be outside when its dark & foggy😊

[@jaanshersaeed4541]

Well at least the ending wasn’t terrifying like Godred was at the end of “The Slopes of Culdee Fell: Cliffhanger” If anyone’s wondering what I’m talking about, then feel free to search up what I just wrote about but just watch the end of it at your own risk, I’m still terrified even after 6 years and I was only 11 when it came out

[@charimew3745]

Boo

[@jaanshersaeed4541]

@@charimew3745 Did you see what I was talking about

[@charimew3745]

@@jaanshersaeed4541 yes

[@jaanshersaeed4541]

@@charimew3745 Did you find Godred at the end terrifying

[@charimew3745]

@@jaanshersaeed4541 very lol

[@keianakbar9892]

Finally you're back

[@joltythegamer1519]

i thought this was the older one lol i was so confused why it looked different lol

[@Boni.]

This story' is just like an Indonesian diesel that keep crash to each train,car and truck,people,and even animal this engine is call BADER but now he's already healthy

[@daniela-tj1cu]

8:43 bro sounds so sarcastic💀💀💀💀

[@nanazavina370]

Lol its still funny XD happy Halloween 🎃🎃👻👻🕷️🕷️🕸️🕸️🕷️🕷️🎃👻🕸️🎃🕷️🕷️👻👻👻👻

[@e2tankengine528]

2:23 I’ve seen that engine in wales

[@JohntheLNERP2]

Still like the original way better but regardless I still think this one is brilliant

[@theotherrailway]

will you do a remaster of Stuck! ? i like that one, its really funny

[@Thomas1Edward2Henry3]

Yes in fact that was the next planned one before I decided to do this. I just have to install all the snow.

[@theotherrailway]

@@Thomas1Edward2Henry3 wow, thank you :D and please keep the gag with I Want to Break Free xD

[@tesha9138]

@@Thomas1Edward2Henry3 What about Bill and Ben the brave twins?

[@ilikecheeseilikecheese727]

👁👁 Da eyes

[@jankington216]

I love the trainz X lmao you could probably get rid of it by editing the texture file to be transparent

[@TrainFanProductions4935]

The orange text in the credits was a really nice touch. Still, I kinda prefer the old version.