संवाद # 177: Big myth of Indian DNA, Aryan Invasion, intercaste marriages | Gyaneshwer Chaubey

This संवाद was recorded at a beautiful homestay in Varanasi - Ratnakar Bhawan. Special thanks are due to Ratnakar family, especially Rahul & his mother for facilitating this. Check out RATNAKAR BHAWAN (HERITAGE HOMESTAY), Varanasi on MakeMyTrip: app.mmyt.co/Xm2V/2wmlcl5b.
Gyaneshwer Chaubey, a biological anthropologist, has dedicated his research career to unraveling the mysteries of human migration and population dynamics. Beginning as a Ph.D. student at the Estonian Biocentre and University of Tartu in Estonia, he later held positions as a scientist and senior scientist. He also served as a visiting scientist at the Sanger Centre in the United Kingdom.
In 2017, he returned to India, assuming the role of a full professor in the Department of Zoology at Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi. Chaubey's research primarily focuses on understanding the peopling of South and Southeast Asia, with a keen interest in various ethnic groups such as the Andaman, Austroasiatic, Indian Jews, Siddi, Roma, and Parsis. Employing a combination of genetic markers and computational tools, he investigates the impacts of migration, genetic drift, and selection on the demographic history of South Asia while also contributing to the development of new analytical methodologies.
0:00 Intro
2:05 How to find out our ancestors
9:32 Who came to Indian first
12:05 Half of world population was Indian, 25,000 years ago
15:30 North South populations evolved separately
17:46 Everyone who came to India assimilated
19:36 North Indians fair, South Indians dark - Why
22:31 Even brothers can have different skin colour
23:43 MP, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand - DNA & language variation
26:26 R1a gene - Aryan/Brahmin DNA?
30:12 Is R1a gene Indian or Aryan?
34:08 R1s gene’s origin NOT European
36:38 R1a & Iran theory Vs Southeast Asia
39:03 Rakhigarhi & Indus Valley DNA
41:09 Central govt not funding ancient DNA research
43:51 Aryan Invasion theory’s politics
46:19 When Professor tested his Brahmin DNA
48:02 DNA of Haryanvi रोड़ caste - most Aryan?
53:10 Genghis Khan’s DNA & Hazaras of Pakistan
54:44 Hindu Jat, Muslim Jat & Sikh Jat DNA
56:55 Moolnivasi & Rahul Gandhi’s DNA
58:00 Rajput DNA of different states
1:00:42 Intra caste marriages & genetic diseases
1:06:43 Rajasthan DNA
1:08:23 Terai belt DNA - Tibetan
1:10:11 Himalayan states ancestry - Siberian link
1:12:14 आपने Yeti देखा है?
1:12:58 DNA of Ahoms & Thailand link
1:15:39 DNA of Rohingyas
1:16:50 DNA of North East India
1:20:46 Sinhalese have Marathi DNA
1:22:55 Lakshadweep DNA
1:24:27 DNA of Telangana Muslims - shocking?
1:25:44 Heart attack in youth & DNA link
1:28:28 DNA & diet link
1:30:40 DNA, headaches & ulcer
1:32:08 Arranged marriages se pehle DNA test karo
1:33:05 Importance of DNA methylation test
1:35:58 Musahar community’s unique aspect
1:37:46 Shocking story of Ajnala skeletons - Indian soldiers
1:47:13 Brutality of the British - Indian Skull in a Pub
1:49:13 Indian DNA in Mesopotamia
1:54:25 DNA studies field is most exciting

[@shivshakti8r]

Every time I live in South in India I become Dravidian, as soon as I come to north I become Aryan. Even living in north in the summers I become Dravidian and in Cold I become Aryan 😅😅😅😅

[@Cosmic_Animal]

South have fair skin people like mahesh babu ,kamal hassan ,aishwarya rai

[@Cosmic_Animal]

You don't become darker if u stay in south .in south many have fair skin. It's just stereotype bro

[@ld904]

​@@Cosmic_Animal you are right

[@VivekSingh-rr3fr]

Everything is right except the fact Arya is shuddh, Aryan is ashuddh

[@truegod...]

I was Aryan some hours ago but I walked under the sun for some time and became Dravidian.

[@ushaReddy_2023]

😂

[@chandraprakashsinha7479]

😂

[@nitin9857]

Absolutely, mostly occurs in Summers. In winters I was Aryan.

[@truegod...]

@nitin9857 Yea you got it. We can change race like Nitish Kumar changes sides.

[@Aryan-qv8hz]

Hillana band kar dega to niggha bhi ban jayega

[@Cosmic_Animal]

Mein south indian hu aur mein gore hun😂 south mein gora ,kala sab hai bhai .aur north mein bhi kale log hai . Yeh sab stereotypes hai

[@tamashbeen6610]

On an average baat kar rha hai vo...vaisay what you say is correct.

[@Cosmic_Animal]

On average telugu people have lighter skin .don't know about other south indians .i have seen many dark skin northies my own friends i have seen. Anyways you wont accept it .leave it @@tamashbeen6610

[@sycrox5201]

Bhai mere family me hi different different skin ke log h koi gora koi brown

[@Cosmic_Animal]

​@@sycrox5201 Haan bhai india ka population poora mix hai. Aur natural selection ka bhi role hai .kich log farming Kiya, kuch log gold Smith job Kiya...tho skin exposure different hai aur bht mixing and migrations hua hai .isliye itna diversity. India bht diverse hai par yeh log kuch theories mein fit karna chahte hai .yeh log sab galat hai .aur samples bhi bht Kam hai .tho hamko future hi btayega ki kaise india populate hua

[@pradeepkharta5953]

I stayed in Chennai for 3days my skin got burned its so hot and humid there .

[@pankajkumarsingh5621]

मैं प्रतिहार राजपूत हु और मेरा गोत्र कौशिक है। हम राजपूतो में भी अपने गोत्र में शादी नही होती ।

[@AnkitKumar-vf6yb]

Haa sahi bola

[@shivrajsinghpuraniyanegi]

Pratihar rajput kaundilya gotra ke bhi mile mujhe kuch,pratiharo me kayi gotra hain kya?

[@googleuser4534]

So u r parthiyan

[@kusumkaul1966]

Same in Brahmans

[@jyotivyas9286]

कल देखती हूँ यह शानदार पॉडकास्ट😊👍👌💐ग़ज़व। वाह। अरिहंत जी। चौबे जी।🎉🎉

[@pankajkumarsingh5621]

मैं बिहार के जगदीशपुर से हु जो 1857 के क्रांति का केंद्र था । पुरबिया योद्धा बहुत देशभक्त और बहादुर थे ।इसलिए 1857 के बाद अंग्रेज उनको भर्ती करना कम कर दिए

[@Aryan_singh247]

Hum ara se🙏

[@VivekSingh-rr3fr]

Brahman Dev Gyaneshwar Chaubey ji 🔥🙏

[@abhaytiwari7369]

One of the best, thrilling and informative podcast I have ever consumed. Thank you Vaad team for bringing it to us.

[@jyotivyas9286]

बहुत सुंदर dr chaubey.ji. apni गोत्र को संभालो। 😊👌💐.धन्यवाद अरिहंत जी। 🎉🎉जय स्नात्तन धर्म संस्कृति।

[@Spiritualminds108]

In Punjab here there are Rules like don't marry in your own Gotra and Don't marry Anyone from Your Own Village

[@the_bhartiya_spirit]

Such a enriching podcast.....hats off to the choice of Guest....❤ GYANESHWAR CHAUBEY sir ko Koti Koti Pranaam 🙏🙌

[@somesshbahuguna9620]

This is a very informative talk. Prof Chaubey is very knowledgeable and he explains in such plain language. Noise in the background is very troubling.

[@aditibhardwaj8790]

I'm half Aryan half Dravidian. My sun exposed skin is dark like rajnikant and 24x7 covered skin is fair like tammana 😅

[@shailipandey9624]

I dont know but I wanna laugh 😅😅😅

[@dhruvakoti6280]

So you use ghunghat to become fair and bikinis to be dark!😂😂

[@Cosmic_Animal]

Rajanikanth is Marathi bro .he is originally from naharastra who acted in Tamil movies .his real name is shivaji rao Gaikwad

[@qwerty-yw1wc]

1:05:00 But Dr. Niraj Rai Sir, surely explained that we are moving to a disease burdened country. Specially this burden is more on few castes. He gave examples of Vaishya community that are more susceptible to side effects of Anesthesia. And inter caste marriages is the savior for this issue. Though, I more support Dr. Niraj Rai's words here!

[@TanviSanatani]

Same.

[@nennerundzahler3814]

He is not really disagreeing with Niraj rai ji on the problem. His solution is similar to what Jews are doing, that is testing genetics before procreation, which even Niraj rai ji advocates for

[@nennerundzahler3814]

The gene pool is large enough for people to find suitable people even within the caste according to him. So its not a must to do intercaste marriage

[@TanviSanatani]

@@nennerundzahler3814 I understand your argument, but this guy literally is suggesting NOT to do Intercaste marriages, he could have said its everyones choice. Gene pool would be even wider if hindus start inter marrying won't it be? He is sounding very TRaD. I would rather follow Dr Niraj Rai.

[@nennerundzahler3814]

@@TanviSanatani Listen carefully he said there are two choices one is to ignore caste and marry, other is if you want to marry inside caste then do testing like ashkenazi jews do to keep themselves healthy. He hasnt said anywhere not to do intercaste marriage, in fact he affirmed arihant when he said it is already in prevalence so issue will become less problematic. Do listen again

[@abhishekupadhyay478]

This is one of the best and informative episode so thanks a lot to Arihant bhai many times for bringing this kind of information.

[@ashishgautam3679]

Super exciting! NEED A SERIES ON THIS. This is the best time to be alive in Bharat! So many facts are coming out and false narratives are falling apart.

[@sourabhsharmaRJ]

सर आपके ज्ञान को प्रणाम।।

[@tejashpathak3539]

ज्ञानेश्वर भैया को विभिन्न माध्यमों पर देखना व सुनना ज्ञानवर्धन और प्रेरणादायक होता है हमारा सौभाग्य है आपका सानिध्य और आशिर्वाद हमेशा मुझे मिलता रहता है. सादर प्रणाम भैया 🙏 देश और समाज के साथ हम सभी को आप गौरवान्वित और प्रेरित करते रहे .

[@BlackWhite-bn5xc]

Excellent session....especially Queen Ketevan case and Ajnala case. Good job Arihant. Jai Shri Ram

[@KillerDrummerNike]

insightful and amazingly well hosted podcast

[@qwerty-yw1wc]

1. I feel, as we have a clause in Income Tax Deduction for Donation and everyone can claim the deduction, Similarly, Govt. should define a clause for donation and tax deduction claims for the funding of research institutions. Which can be so defined by the Institute Name and the Research title. This clause should be at all levels of income group. In this way atleast govt. can help funding of the scientific research whether it is case of Genetics, Archaeology etc. 2. Also, this study of our ancestry will be the greater one to ultimately end the caste divisions. Which will be beneficial for the society.

[@theoptimisticboy30]

Proud to be ROR 😍

[@iamtoxic5174]

Bhai kahan se ho

[@theoptimisticboy30]

@@iamtoxic5174 Village -kaul , Pundri , Haryana

[@iamtoxic5174]

@@theoptimisticboy30 bhai mera ganv Khukhrana , Panipat ha

[@iamtoxic5174]

@@theoptimisticboy30 kaul ganv je mere boht rishteddar ha

[@iamtoxic5174]

@@theoptimisticboy30 aap ka gotra sangwan ha kya

[@imvmmystery]

Very interesting, informative and a must watch.

[@rakeshmathur9035]

Excellent analysis 👍🏻sir your findings should be published for every one

[@ankitmundri7436]

जय राजा रोड जय श्री राम

[@humanitylover2156]

Preserve caste system but say no to caste based reservation 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@NativeVsColonial]

@@humanitylover2156 Well, you and the Pakhandis are both on the same page then, one wants reservations to be eradicated but not the fake “caste” pride and another wants caste to be eradicated but not the reservations, lol Enjoy, you both deserve each other 👍

[@ankitmundri7436]

@@humanitylover2156Jai Shree Ram ❤

[@jyotivyas9286]

​बिल्कुल वहीउठा रहा मज़ा​@@humanitylover2156

[@mikesheth5370]

Most of the Indians are brown dark brown and dark coloured people. Nose shape and lips are broad and big .. and beautiful!

[@Dhanush7rn]

Even the eye areas

[@user-th8dq1ev2l]

Great to get to hear about his work and diversity of his thoughts

[@malikharsh5909]

Bahut bahut dhanyawad air video kafi informativ tha Mainey is video ko save to watch later mey dala tha magar mila nhi Par after two weeks random reels watch kartey huey aaka chanel open krkey ye video pura dekha. Vo bhi raat 12 bje So again thankyou for this knowledgable ❤video

[@surinderbarana4318]

Ror aryans 🙏🙏 proud 🙏 हर हर महादेव 🙏

[@dineshpradhan624]

Caste System preserve karna chaieya kuch bhi😅😅

[@kumaraakash6047]

@@dineshpradhan624 kyu nahi

[@Atheism712]

​@@dineshpradhan624Aryan invasion......bahar ke log

[@adrianbelko7683]

​@@Atheism712 Yes, the taller, fairer, stronger sanskrit speaking Aryans came to this country and made it home, Ruled it for 5000 years. Glory Be to Indra 😎

[@Sigmachadgk]

​@@adrianbelko7683le mut diya tere invasion par💦🤓

[@rajeshwar4000]

Wow..... Lots and lots of information.

[@anuradham8435]

Very good information, thank you 🙏🏼

[@bonran]

R1 and R2a are originated in India. R1 is considered the Aryan gene. And hence the out of India theory of Vedic exportation of Insia

[@durgaashtekar1112]

exposure to sun light makes the skin go darker

[@TanviSanatani]

"Over generations". Ek white man aaj Africa chala jaye to black ni ho jayega bhai.

[@stalinsampras]

@@TanviSanatani not even over generations, then ab devillers and Markram and many south African players should be black like Rabada and other west indies players.

[@NativeVsColonial]

@@TanviSanatani The mutations take thousands of generations to reflect.

[@dvikauglaumishrauca]

​@@TanviSanatanigive it 40 generation. That is more than enuf to change Europe to africa

[@jigsaw2281]

​@@TanviSanatani1 saal uttarakhand k thandi jgh m rho sari skin bdlne lgegi ...ye sb division create krne k liye kiya Britishers aur Germans n

[@rahuldeovatsa]

@Gyaneshwer Chaubey sir, how to work with you, one of my closest friend is working in medical genetics and very keen on understanding human biology through DNA based research. How to connect with you?

[@rj-hd6hy]

Quite insightful discussion 👍

[@dvikauglaumishrauca]

Bhai inko vapis lao and in ur studio. He has so many stories to tell.😊

[@akmakm321]

This is not story. He is talking on scientific data...90% accuracy

[@Dev-tp7sp]

Varna and Jathi (caste) completely mix hoga ye hai is discussion mei. Should have been distinguished it before starting the discussion.

[@manavsharma1236]

Practically koi bahut difference nahi hai bhai. Ye dono ke beech ke gap ko exaggerate karna largely anti-caste RW ke kuch buddhijeeviyon ka kiya dhara hai.

[@Sol-ps8ox]

Aaj ke relation me caste=varna ho gaya hai. Isliye discussion usi ke basis pr hai

[@Gora_singh]

Brilliant podcast .. Great work .. carry on .. your podcasts are out of the box.

[@abhishek894]

It's so exciting to hear about this. Kudos

[@3ipl]

Castes today are different...castes were based on professions, so today's castes would be engineer caste, doctor caste, cab driver caste, maid caste etc. What is the use of preserving skills (genetically, through caste system) that are not in need anymore? What will potters achieve by marrying other potters in a modern city?

[@Sanatan_Truth_1]

You start earning from childhood if you are in the paternal, maternal profession, more competitive, skillful, and have the trust of customers.

[@Sanatan_Truth_1]

You don't require capital to start a business

[@Sanatan_Truth_1]

It was past.

[@anshupandit4490]

Potters can use their genetic skills to be top level artisans selling by exhibitions throughout world. No job is low see how ancient india potter guilda (shrenis) were so rich and great exporters.

[@Sol-ps8ox]

Caste itself is later concept. Vedic age had Varna system. This later got deformed into caste system.

[@meaninglesslife9024]

Malik Jat from Charkhi dadri got the highest steppe ancestry in entire South Asia...usme 30% EHG h...kisi ror ya or kisi bhi jaat me aaj tak nahi paaya...🤟🏿🤟🏿

[@meaninglesslife9024]

Jats got the highest steppe ancestry...

[@ujjwalyadav3783]

​@@meaninglesslife9024to usse kya hua?

[@14011997able]

But when it comes to R1a dna Brahmins stands tall.

[@greaterbharat4175]

And reason for jaat buddhi 😂

[@greaterbharat4175]

​@@14011997ablebecause of Steppe is not reason of r1a R1a oldest mutation found in Indian Saharia tribe (18000 year old ) Steppe ancestory came atleast in Vedic time mentioned the foreign people the dasa and danava ( steppe people daha people) And danavas were denyen ( don steppe peoples lived near black sea ) who mentioned captured the sapt Sindhu in Vedas

[@Candle108]

Very interesting discussion hai!!!!!!

[@plmnjioqazzsw7962]

🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 . Good discussion .

[@jaynandwana8878]

Bandh ke rakhne wala podcast Hai Pura khatam ho gaya fir bhi laga thoda aur lamba Hota to aur Maja Atta.

[@kartikkartik7130]

I’m from ror cast thankyou brother aapne dhyan diya nhi sbi ignore kr dete the Neeraj Chopra se pehle 🙏

[@Prachi-sha]

Neeraj chopra ror community se hai?

[@Ancestralvedic]

@@Prachi-shayep

[@KharKhuwa6]

Chaubey sir se agar baat karni ho phone pe yah fir koi bhi madhyam se toh kese kare.. I am from Assam and have some curious questions and it will be a great help if I could clear my doubts.

[@av1421]

AWESOME ....loved it! He is truely a "Gyaneshwer "!🙏🙏🙏

[@nish6106]

needed more of "Yeh toh latest news hai " jokes 😝🤣🤣🤣

[@RORBrandChannel]

रोड़ राजे 🚩 Top in North India

[@kuldeepjat1201]

Subcaste of jat

[@BalkarSingh-sd1cf]

Reverse is true.​@@kuldeepjat1201

[@TheAnkitDalal]

​@@BalkarSingh-sd1cffalse. You are just offshoot of Jats. Just like communities like Bishnoi, Saadh, Swami, Anjana, etc.

[@vivekmehla9879]

​@@TheAnkitDalal don't live in fool's paradise, both communities are different so don't debate unnecessarily.

[@TheAnkitDalal]

@@vivekmehla9879 oh really? Keep living in denial. The fact still remains the same. All evidence, all the studies point towards the same. Even your gotta is one major Jat gotra. The migration pattern of rors, aata-saata custom, some exclusive marwari words in your dialect and most importantly the DNA reports are enough to prove you're an offshoot. The only thing that's debatable is the timeline when you branched off. Even bishnois say they are different, but thankfully we have enough evidence to know when and how they were formed. Even your so called new gen scientist Anurag Kadian has admitted rors and Jats had same ancestors. It's only the terminology that they use to project how different they are from Jats when it essentially means that there is so much possibility of them steering a different path out of Jat fold.

[@sonycecube]

Thank you so much for such an amazing & extensive podcast! 🙏

[@AryaInk]

Awesome. Amazing.

[@vikasjha108]

Muslims of India Pakistan and Bangladesh have to watch this conversation.

[@akshaygilda3647]

They will call these Research as Shaitan ka kaam and Label it as Haram 😂😂

[@vikasjha108]

@@akshaygilda3647 😂😂

[@kapildave5361]

अरे छोडो भाई किन को समझाने की बात कर रहे हो, मोटी बुद्धी की कौम है

[@user-qg9tb6rf4m]

They have shaitan dna 😂😂😂

[@aviraljanveja5155]

Should also discuss the Punjabi Kshatriya communities like Arora and Khatri. Is there any relation between Ror and Arora as many Khatri-Arora people have blue green eyes as seen in Bollywood.

[@Drealworldd]

Brother Bcoz Steppe Genes are present in Khartis by 10% and they have very less % of AASI Genes in them. They also have Caucasian genes in high numbers.

[@Sol-ps8ox]

It is because of Greeks during Mauryan Empire. Many marriages happened due to their proximity with neighbouring greek kingdoms. Nothing about being Kshatriya or not.

[@krishnaarora5450]

I am too arora punjabi And this is true my punjabi relatives have blue and grey eyes I too have light brown eyes And my ancestors came from afghan border

[@anjoo67]

Amazing! Heard it twice…

[@sachintiwary2022]

Need to this kind of recordings 😊

[@jahnavimahanta6518]

Ahoms did not come from Thailand. Ahoms came from mong mao which is a place in yunan in southern China. They took 12-13 years to travel from that area to Assam through the tai-Shan ruled states of upper Burma. Many tai groups originated from that area in southern China that migrated into various south East Asian countries such as Vietnam, Laos, Burma . And that is not the first time that a population moved from those areas to Assam or north East, older northeastern ancient kingdoms had trading and relationships with surrounding eastern kingdoms, therefore the tai ahom through that information came to the west. Some people talk about tai ahom migration to Assam as if they took an overnight direct bus to Assam through the patkai range hahaha

[@Sonu_._Singh]

Guy has knowledge but not up to the mark. He has to reconsider his view of preserving the caste system. UP and bihar has the most abnormal child birth rate per thousand born child and Pakistan has the most abnormal born child country in the world

[@nennerundzahler3814]

He is saying it from an anthropological perspective. Plus he gave the solution to the issue of defects if you listened carefully

[@SarojSingh-nq5ql]

Bro plzzz every state has the same condition in terms of intercaste marriages except fews, so it's not like ki baaki ke log UP, Bihar se bade aage hai. One major reason behind such children is poverty. I'm in favour of intercaste marriages but ye jo tumlog UP, Bihar ko Africa dikha ke khud American banane ki kosis karte ho n stop this. I live in Maharashtra and meri colony mai sabse jada intercaste marriages karne wale log UP se hi hai.

[@darkprince2490]

@@nennerundzahler3814 defect issue in hindus is nonexistent. the problem with hindus is outbreeding which leads to certain issues. muslims have an inbreeding problem.

[@Kathakathan11]

Genetic issue can arise even in intercaste MARRAIGE. If you marry a Kutch person, Chances of anaemia are more. My friends family has genetic issues and if I marry in his family, my child will definitely suffer. Other friends family has a history of cardiac arrests for about 80 years. All male members died only through sudden cardiac arrest.

[@Kathakathan11]

We have different castes and now whether it is intercaste or intra, risk is inevitable, so better test kar lo. I had a MARRAIGE prospect from Uttarakhand, I stay in Karnataka, my last 5 generations are from Karnataka, and before that from Maharashtra. So if I marry same caste person from say Jammu or Tamil Nadu, how is that going to spoil genetic pool through interbreeeding? No

[@yogeshshidhaye7332]

All these stories made this rather complex and geeky subject very interesting thank you for this episode 🙏

[@vinithagodbole6321]

Fantastic n shocking info, eagerly looking forward to a followup interview

[@amitarya-vh5og]

Ror looking handsome other castes

[@Cosmic_Animal]

South indian sab kale nhi hai . Bhai .yeh stereotype hai .mein ,mera friends ,mera family mein bht log gore hai .north mein bhi apko dark skin milte hai .chalo teek itna ignorance hai tho mein kya karu . Thumbnail is misguiding .

[@mr.rathour6454]

ANI or ASI mix ho gye h Puri tarah se koi bhi pure ni h or maternal DNA to sare Indians ka same hi h 60,000 varsh purana

[@MrRahul6464]

Kaun keh raha hai sab kaale hai. Yadi kaale bhi hai to koi buri baat hai?

[@dreamingaboutjungkook3930]

Janha garmi padti hain sanga body ka rays se bachne ke liye melanin ka produce jyada karti hai. Jis se rang kala dikhta hai

[@nitin9857]

Russian hai tu to 🤣🤣

[@jyotivyas9286]

हां बहुत मलयाली बहुत गोरे हैं। मैं नार्थ से हुन पर मिली हुन

[@jyotiahlawat2608]

Informative podcast 🎉❤

[@narayanrajpurohit3399]

Sir plz health care me zenom kaise help krega 4k wala test hum kaise kaha karwa skte hai plz guide

[@mikesheth5370]

Strict Varna system had no merit. Dividing a Hindu castes of carpenter, godsmith,blacksmith to brick layer and numerous groups of vaishyas and Kshatriyas made Hindus divided!created 15000 endogamous groups! This forced many geographically isolated caste to marry among themselves!

[@MrRahul6464]

Nope. Varna Vyavastha encouraged entrepreneurship.

[@mikesheth5370]

@@MrRahul6464 Was talking about hardship finding brides and bridegrooms for small isolated groups living in remote communities! If they had married among Hindus living around , no harm would have been done to their craftsmenship! After all they worship same gods, had same festivals! In order to master any trade no need to marry within generations after generations within a bunch of 50 families to begin with!It was drilled into Hindus that no craftsman ship can be mastered unless marry within that castes for generations! Right kind of apprenticeship for 10 years should be enough to master any trade including agriculture!Many stereotype about trade mastery had divided Hindus in thousands of castes within 100 sq km! My point is Hindus should intermarry and should become united in this day and age! Our Shankrscharyas of today are number one villains who tell us to maintain small castes! Fortunately taboos are breaking down and Hindus are getting united! Nothing can stop them! Swamis like Dayanand and Vivekanand , Sri Arvinda etc has united us.

[@MrRahul6464]

@@mikesheth5370 i believe in genetic aptitude or temperament to perform certain tasks by certain people. Jats normally won't be good at being a vaishaya or a Brahmin won't be good at being shudra. I don't believe our ancestors were stupid to create varna vyavastha. I won't comment on this further as all my values are just my beliefs. I haven't studied my scriptures. So im no expert on this. But i wont start to dilute varna vyavastha just because it's a new trend to be anti varna. I don't buy that. Except for Dalits. I don't see any disadvantage for any caste for following varna vyavastha.

[@mikesheth5370]

@@MrRahul6464 I know prosperous Jat businessmen both in Canada and India! They are also good in research at university ! And Vaish in academia with no clue about business! Because they worked for others all their lives lives! Shudra by Karma!Brits brain washed us iin believing martial races! In Gujarat of 11 the century some Vaishya were warriors and minister under Solanki dynasty! As I understand ancient varnas were not birth based but karma based! Parshuram a warrior, Vishwamitra a sage. Any one providing service or an employee can be called shudra! By the way in modern day and age very few Brahmins live by r tradition of teaching and doing karma kand or Jajmani!

[@MrRahul6464]

@@mikesheth5370 i said "normally". Look at India's top entrepreneurs. Majority of them are marwadi baniyas. I'm not claiming that Brahmins or Shudras can't be a good businessman. I'm just saying that genetics defines your interest and inclination for certain type of work. That's it.

[@tayalogic]

Rors are the purest Aryans of India! Wow that's really interesting as some of my Ror friends have blue & Hazel eyes, & I never ever see a single Ror with dark complexion (beside some tanned ones) or short nose shape, they're really incredible.

[@Drealworldd]

Brother not purest but they have high Steppe % that's it even they also have AASI & IVC 60% Combined. Blues eyes or any what it means to you Brother than see Afghani they are more Aryan than you and if you what to see more Go to Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan Tajikistan Turkmenistan and Azerbaijan you'll see more Aryan lastly go to Southern east Russia.

[@tayalogic]

@@Drealworldd Rors have around 18-23% of AASI, & Rest is Steppe+Neolithic Iranian

[@noone6796]

Not rors but haryana jats, he is friend of anurag kadian(who is ror) that's why they are promoting rors, real steppe is steppe emba, steppe emba is mildly higher in haryana jats, while steppe mlba is equal in both of them

[@tayalogic]

@@noone6796 You're allegating one of the biggest Geneticists of Indian Subcontinent... 😆😆 they're scientists, they're not here to implement their friendship goals! 😂

[@noone6796]

@@tayalogic he is human who gets influenced easily. In their own study that single jat sample had higher steppe emba than average ror, there is no way ror can be called outlier to these haryana jats

[@RahulVerma-iv8ph]

If out of india theory is true, why Europeans don't have AASI genes, which is present in all indians?

[@stalinsampras]

Bro you cannot ask common sense questions like this to them? They will not understand

[@Code_red72]

​@@stalinsampras😂

[@aviraljanveja5155]

1. Because most of the people who moved Europe side were from the north. 2. AASI AANI itself has been called an inaccurate bracket to describe a population as diverse as India.

[@RahulVerma-iv8ph]

@@aviraljanveja5155 what do you mean by they are from north?. AASI is inaccurate? Who told you? Are you creating your own theory?

[@RahulVerma-iv8ph]

@@aviraljanveja5155 AASI is present in all indians be it north or south and it's the base and that's what this guy on the video told too. It's just that he is not talking about why Europeans don't have any AASI if out of india is true

[@vaibhav_Jat]

Knowledgeable podcast ❤

[@anuuptiwari945]

Great scientist gyaneshwar sir ki vidwata ko pranam 🙏

[@animeshbhatt3383]

Please buy a noise canceling mic.

[@Vaad]

Sir, these mics are quite excellent but what to do, Banaras is too noisy 😀

[@Ancestralvedic]

@@Vaad😂

[@animeshbhatt3383]

😂​@@Vaad

[@bhupendrakumar1753]

@@Vaadit was good. Not that noisy. Loved bird chirping in the background.

[@hindkisaanmunch7501]

​@@Vaad kya choubey ji ka Number mil sakta hai ? ya koi or tarika inse baat karne ka

[@jineshjillsgeorge]

Wow...This guy is advocating for the preservation of the cast system.

[@humanitylover2156]

Preserve caste system but say no to caste based reservation 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@adrianbelko7683]

​@@humanitylover2156 imagine denying a group of people their rightfully earned position just because they don't wanna marry where yóū want them to

[@user-bp1zq3ex4h]

Your podcast is fantastic. Do more with each in details

[@tanmoyrgrg]

Excellent....please keep it up🙏

[@rajatchoudhary5655]

Yess Ror(रोड़) are purest aryan race .They look like a warrior

[@humanitylover2156]

Preserve caste system but say to caste based reservation 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.

[@tamashbeen6610]

Aryan race nhi hai. Culture hai.

[@tayalogic]

@@shubhamji36 Bakwaaas! 90% of Ror population looks like Afghans, Tukish, & European kind, & you are compairing them wih Gujjars...lol stop propagating the things!

[@googleuser4534]

Marathas are sons of Mahars (The untouchable cast from 200 years in maharashtra)

[@priyammaurya6404]

​@@googleuser4534Marathas are basically of kunbi caste shivaji and sahu Maharaj of kunbi caste scindhia and gaekwad also kunbi origin

[@SurendraSinghArya12-1ddn-uk]

रूपकुंड में मील अस्थि पंजर जिस काल खंड की आप बता रहे हैं उसी कालखण्ड में हिमालय के केदारनाथ तथा जागेश्वर मंदिर के निर्माण का है और केदारनाथ के तोरण का जो रूप है वह यूनानी है नागर या दक्षिण शैली नही है।

[@biomind]

Greek DNA to indian logo me milta hi hoga obhi aaye the

[@Student-mx6hb]

Good podcast do more of such with gyaneshwar sir.

[@jalk1959]

Very interesting and informative video

[@declanharp9633]

Removing caste system endogamy is not about removing disease. It's more about allowing people to fall in love and choose a compatible partner from across the class and race, as we never know where we can find love and compatibility. Nothing is more fundamental emotion than love. everything else is just a side business to sustain the most important emotion humans can ever achieve. Moreover caste system creates an extreme classism and discrimination as well. Ancient indians developed a lot of awesome things, caste system is just not one of them and is an unfortunate development..

[@demorvie]

Fff falling in love BS. Shit wears off in about 3 months. Health is far more important.

[@declanharp9633]

@@demorvie health is important. But not caste definitely.

[@declanharp9633]

@@demorvie love is BS for you not for many like me.

[@kuldeepjat1201]

Kali ladki ke pyar me to nhi girte log sab white fair or sunder ladki ko hi kyu chate h 😂😂

[@user-md9hn7vk6m]

​@@declanharp9633there is nothing called as love these days ...love nowadays is purely physical...

[@krashal]

"Preserve caste system" based🔥🔥🔥

[@MrLikea8055]

Bring back the monarch. Even more BASED 🗿

[@humanitylover2156]

Preserve caste system but say to caste based reservation 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.

[@SarojSingh-nq5ql]

Listen bro if u wanna preserve ur genes go on u have right of it like every other people across the world. But caste system is different it should not be preserved.

[@krashal]

@@SarojSingh-nq5ql what do you know about caste system?

[@krashal]

@@MrLikea8055 Empires

[@preetishpai8647]

Excellent podcast. Interesting topic

[@praveenlakhe2471]

Very very interesting dialogue. Urge you for a follow up episode.🙏

[@rahul_yt615]

Looks like pura comment section ek line sunnke pura pagla gaya hai. Baki ka content discard krke ek hii line pe fixated hai and kuch toh woh line sunn ke speaker ka caste bhi determine kr chuke hai. 😂😂 Comment section meh beth ke intercaste marriage suggest bohot easy hot hai, but India is a 3rd world country, jaha pe basic needs bhi puri krna mushkil hoti hai, waha peh log conservative thought process ke hii hnge. Industrialization and urbanization would bring ppl out of poverty, thereby creating enough disposable income for ppl to think beyond caste, religion. Why do u think in Bihar a Brahmin CM is impossible but Bengal a neighboring state has one for 12 yrs, bcz bengal got industrialized (which was ruined by CPM). Capitalism would alleviate ppl out of poverty thereby solving all these problems as well. 😇😇

[@aditibhardwaj8790]

Konsi basic needs puri naa ho ri teri chore? Ghar toilet free rashan every month mauj sab kuch toh de ri yu sarkar, aur k free k baal-bachhe le kai mannega?

[@rahul_yt615]

@@aditibhardwaj8790 arey toh wahi kehe rha hu, sarkar de rhi free meh. Log khud seh toh nhi bna rhe, kyuki disposable income utni nhi hai. 😒 😮‍💨😮‍💨

[@aditya4120]

​@@aditibhardwaj8790😂😂 andhe ko hee nhi dikhega bharat ki gareebi .. kitno ke paas aaj v na ghar na toilet na koi rojgaar hai. 4 kg mufr rashsn hee bharat ka vikas hai😂😂😂😂 wah.

[@rakeshtamang6517]

One of the best discussions on human ancestry in India. Every second of this video is full of knowledge about the Indian population. Enjoyed thoroughly! Thank you "Vaad" and Prof. Gyaneshwer Chaubey.

[@sharan50000]

बहुत बहुत बहुत ही अच्छा ज्ञान दिया ज्ञयानेशवर जी ने 🇮🇳

[@jsrprima]

Ror aur Jat bol diya isne matlab ye community alag hai.

[@a3star800]

Jats(Highest Steppe_Mlba)Group of entire south asia

[@Cosmic_Animal]

No bro .brahmin mein zyada steppe ancestry hai .this is based on studies

[@PawanRao007]

Jats actually have highest steppe ancestory. It is a fact. ​@@Cosmic_Animal

[@a3star800]

@@Cosmic_Animal Bhai jat se jayda pure south asia me kisi me nhi hai @genz_asian chek karo page

[@a3star800]

@@humanityisdoomed Jats ke major Y R1a,Q,L1c hai 40% 40% ka ratio hai inka Jats me Huns mixture nhi hua kyuki inme ne Asian hai hi nhi ye Indo - aryans hi hai or aajke samay pure Aryavarta me yhi reside kar rhe hai Northwest india and pakistan

[@siddharthkharanger7608]

😂😂 Ror m h highest steppe . Sach sun kr bhi apna gungaan krna mtlb apne muuh mithu miyan bnna h. Ror’s are the purest Aryans present day. Baaki tum apni tareef khud krte rho sach nhi bdlega 😂

[@823Ami]

Why do you have such an important interview outside, the noise is so distracting!!

[@iamrktiwari001]

जबरदस्त।

[@ThomasSt40]

There's been no significant outside genetic influence into India after 5000 BC (some push it well before then), R1a originated in India... The Vedas were written well before the time of the majority opinion concerning AMT: AMT [Hypothesis] was posited after the end of the British Raj. It was a colonial replacement for the AIT. The Saraswati River is known to have flowed for thousands of years and then saw a gradual decline long before 1500 BC, causing the inhabitants to flee the environs to other areas. Satellite imagery (plus the study of sites along the river) has discovered its ancient channels. This river had a gradual decline from around 5,000 BC until it dried out around 1500 BC. The Vedic descriptions of it thus logically preceded the drying up of its ancient channels, thus those who wrote the Vedas described it long before the proposed time period of AMT and had to have lived their locally, continually, to report on it over time. AIT traces back to Seligman (who derived the second iiteration of the false HamiticHypotheses, which taught light-skinned people advanced Africa - similar to AIT/AMT), and the 1st Hamitic Hypotheses traces back to things taught in BC times.

[@RP027]

"Caste system ko preserve karna chahiye"..... Bruhhhh 💀💀

[@Cosmic_Animal]

Professor tho brahmin hai 😂kya expect Karoge

[@humanityisdoomed]

Timestamp?

[@nennerundzahler3814]

He says it from an anthropological point of view. Not as a social system

[@anujkurchania6955]

He said at 01:02:00 per , aur usk explanation bhi diya hai. Abhi researcher brahmin hai to kewal caste ke angle se hi dekhkar ignore maaro. Usne small small community per bhi to bola hai wo sab gayab. Community wise bhi to research kar raha hai. Last me queen waali baat prove bhi karti hai community or caste basis per bhi dna se bahut information milti hia.

[@vamsikrishna3855]

Niraj Rai who is a geneticist like him is also a Brahmin and he believes exactly opposite of what he says on caste system. Why are you blaming Brahmins on this? What advantage did Brahmins have in present India other than getting abused?

[@the_Indian398]

Brilliant work

[@amansingh18]

thanks for this podcast. we need several other with Sir.

[@aaditya4987]

Ham 96 kuli maratha (kunbi maratha or kshatriya maratha) he, hamare purvaj rajput he.

[@mehulchaudhari9964]

Dekho bhai R1a1 gene jat ror mein jyada hai steppes ancestry and Maratha ke pass majorly Ancestors South Indian gene hai

[@ROMI909]

Arey aaple ancestry south she jast close aahe. Rajput vagaire nahi.

[@Drealworldd]

हाल के अध्ययनों के अनुसार - अब मुख्य रूप से अधिकांश भारतीय आबादी में IVC, AASI, स्टेपी, भूमध्यसागरीय और पूर्वी एशियाई जीन शामिल हैं। भारतीयों में स्टेपी जीन 0 -17% तक भिन्न होते हैं IVC और AASI 25-85% (संयुक्त) तक भिन्न होते हैं भूमध्यसागरीय 0-8% तक भिन्न होते हैं बाकी सभी (मंगोलियन, पूर्वी एशियाई) 0-5% तक होते हैं। अधिकतम स्टेपी % 1. रोड़ 2. जाट (सिख, हिंदू) 3. उत्तर भारतीय ब्राह्मण 4. उत्तर भारतीय बनिया 5. राजस्थानी राजपूत/गुज्जर 6. यूपी के ठाकुर/यूपी के श्रीवास्तव

[@hindkisaanmunch7501]

Hamare yaha ek Ror Kisaan Ek Rajput kisaan Tyagi Kisaan , Jaat Kisaan or Brahmin Kisaan ko ek jagah khada kro toh bina Naam puche aap nahi bata sakte ki ye kon si caste se hai . iska kya matlab sub ek jaise he DNA ke hai .

[@Drealworldd]

@@hindkisaanmunch7501 Sab(Open Caste even Include Western OBC Caste) ek jese hi hai bs thoda bahut Steppe aur Mediterranean DNA idhr udhr hai.

[@hindkisaanmunch7501]

@@Drealworldd Fir ye log aapas me lad mar rahe hai ki Jaat Bade ya Rajput Ya Tyagi ya Brahmin ya Yadav ya Gujjar . kyon nahi logo ko iski Jankaari de kar ye ladai Band karayi jaye .

[@rajror6797]

​@@hindkisaanmunch7501bhai North india m sbme steppe h but baat ye ki kisi me kam h kisi m highest h

[@user-yh3ly5kc8w]

I learnt about myself a lot. Thank you 🌹. I am from east India. So sad to listen about our martial ancestors. RIP

[@Kumar-Abhishek0911]

What is the name of test

[@PawanRao007]

Guy literally said CASTE KO PRESERVE KARNA chaiye 😮 i mean shawa sir.

[@NativeVsColonial]

This concept of hereditary Caste division itself is not Indian, it's a superimposition of the Spanish/Portuguese caste system and the English Class system in India, intending to divide the natives and use them against each other while the English hold power and work as a mediator. Caste was a pyramid scheme that European Missionaries sold to Indians via their Christian Missionary schooling imposition in Indian society to divide and conquer. So don’t mix up Varna with Gotram, Varna is Profession, and Gotram is Lineage. Hindus are free to marry in different Varnas, only avoid marrying in the same Gotram because it is considered the same bloodline, hence we don’t marry between brothers and sisters.

[@PawanRao007]

@@NativeVsColonial bhai jis tareke se "britishers brought caste system" wala narrative consume kara hua h. Kash tune uska adha effort actually apni religious books padhne me lagaya hota.

[@Cosmic_Animal]

​@@NativeVsColonialvideo mein brahmin sir ne tho caste ko preserve karna hai ,inter caste nhi Karna chahiye aisa bola Hai. Ek bar video dekho .yeh brahmin sir ne hi bola Hai ki caste ko preserve Karo

[@NativeVsColonial]

@@PawanRao007 In Hindu Dharma, especially birth based caste is a recent times colonial imposition, however Varna (Occupation) was the original one, in Varna there was no upper or lower, people chose the work of which they are qualified for, and according to Bhagavad Gita, anyone can be a Brahmin (Teacher, Scholar profession), Shatriya (Warrior, Army profession), Vaishya (Trader, Business profession), Shudra (Other social workers) based on as per their skills, knowledge, and capabilities: 🔹In Bhagavad Gita 4:13, Krishna says that he created different Varnas [Profession] on the basis of one's Karma [Activities] and Guna [Characteristics]. 🔹Bhagavad Gita 5:18 “The truly learned, with the eyes of divine knowledge, see with equal vision a Brahmin, a cow, an elephant, a dog, and a dog-eater” 🔹Bhagavad Gita 9:29 “I am equally disposed to all living entities: there is neither friend nor foe to Me: but those who with living sentiments render divotional service unto Me, such persons are in Me and I am in them.” 🔹Bhagavad Gita 18:41 “The duties of the Brahmins, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas, and Shudras are distributed in accordance with their Guṇas [Characteristics]. (Nothing comes with the birth except some divine Characteristics). Caste is an English term derived from the Spanish term “Casta” which stands for 'Breed' or 'lineage'. During earlier times, “Caste” use to be Varna (Profession) and based on Guna (Characteristics) and not merely just by birth. Instances from the ancient times proves that a so-called modern day “lower caste” can educate oneself with knowledge and change their Varna (Profession) to “upper caste”, e.g., Guru Valmiki, Kabir Das were from a Shudra family but became a Brahmin based on Guna (Characteristics or Essence), Ravana and his younger brother Kumbhakarna were Brahmins (educated person) from Northern India but because of their notorious Karmas (activities) all were punished by Shri Rama (believed to be an OBC if we abide by today's caste categorization). Lastly, you have to understand the British motive behind imposing the caste system:- The Caucasians (Europeans) created Hutus and Tutsis in Rwanda, Africa, to divide and control the native population, and for this reason, the Rwanda Genocide occurred. The same attempts and inequalities Europeans also tried to create amongst Indians by separating Northern India and Southern India into “Aryans” VS “Dravidians” and further dividing Hinduism into 3,000 castes and 25,000 sub-castes. Read about Herbert Hope Risley who created casteism, racism in Indian society by one's facial features and skin color, and Bishop Robert Caldwell who coined the term “Dravidian” and propagated the “Aryan Invasion” in Southern India to convert Southern Indians into Christianity. And read these books (1) Castes of Minds by Nicholas Dirks, (2) Western Foundations of the Caste System

[@NativeVsColonial]

@@Cosmic_Animal Timestamps?

[@testprofile1840]

dhanyavad

[@pradeepkharta5953]

Ye test ka nam batao . Plz

[@TanviSanatani]

Sir subha ko Genetics padhte h 😂 Sham ko Manushmriti 😅😅

[@Knownasgod12121]

Woke rebel and chota bheem Spotlighted😅

[@TanviSanatani]

@@Knownasgod12121 lol not a chota bheem lol. Actually a kshatriya by caste. I guess actually having few brain cells isn't a norm these days.

[@TanviSanatani]

@@Knownasgod12121 thoda b logical baat kardo to chota bheem declare kar dete h kya?

[@TanviSanatani]

@@Knownasgod12121 agar bheem log me dimag h to I would actually be beem than be with you. Lol. BTW jati shayad tumse uchi hi nikle but gamand ni karna chaiye.

[@realsbs]

Bilkul sahi baat, Useless system ki promote kar re hai

[@oldandwesternreviews2823]

I never studied anthropology academically but it is one of favourite subject