संवाद # 188: Why Agniveer is a big blunder, problem in J&K | Major General GD Bakshi

#agniveer #agnipath #jammukashmir
Major General G.D. Bakshi is a retired Indian Army officer, renowned for his service in the Jammu and Kashmir and his role in the Kargil War. He has received the Vishisht Seva Medal and the Sena Medal for his distinguished service. A prolific author and defense analyst, Bakshi has written extensively on military history and strategy. Post-retirement, he remains a prominent commentator on national security issues.
0:00 Why Jammu is under attack
4:57 General Bakshi on 90s Ops
9:03 Reasi barbarism
12:58 Ops in Rajouri Poonch
14:45 Troops reduction in Army
19:00 Problem with Agniveer
21:17 Big difference in Ops in Kashmir Vs Jammu
23:22 Don’t be defensive PLEASE
28:49 How Brigadier Acharya was punished
31:40 Manpower is critical in mountains - Kargil example
33:45 Don’t cut down army strength
34:52 Indian Army won’t get good soldiers with Agniveer
37:30 Reforms in Agniveer
42:54 Pak’s Modus operandi has changed in J&K now
44:20 Army has to go on offensive
47:00 Narco angle - new method in J&K
49:07 General Bakshi’s recommendations

[@iXpress]

Maj Gen Bakshi is a True Patriot ❤🚩🙏

[@harsh2266]

True Nationalist

[@user-mi4el1qd8s]

Modi aur Raj nath ji sena ko Kum kar rahe hai in dono ne 🦉 owls ki tatti kha Lee hai inki budhdhi bhrast ho gai hai 😂 inko ye lagta hai ki sena jiyada kha rahi hai agar ye sena ko poora huk de denge tou inki Jeb Khali hi rahegi inko to khud ki jeb bharni hai sena jaaye bhad mein

[@vinayhnbgu2966]

General sahab you may be the expert of Army operation but if you are reading let me tell you, you don't have Information regarding quran, islam and jihad

[@SagarSinghLalotra-rt5zj]

Bhai kyon aisa Bol kar Shabdon ki Toheen kar rahe ho ye sab k sab Baniya hain . Gen Bikram Singh , Hanut Singh va Financial Welfare & True Caretaker Gen OP Malhotra jaisa ab koi nahin hai Varna OROPs , Grade Pay , Rank Pay , Military Service Pay aur un par DA aur iin k Amount mein itna difference aur Duty mein kamiyaan hi kaam rah gaya Varna OROPs jaise & Pay Com ki Anomalies ko kabhi b apni Pay / Pension mein nahin aane dete .Desh ka Vafaadar hamesha Middle Man hi raha hai , Rich aur Poor to Pasha Paltu hi hote hain . Jai Bharat🙏🙏

[@csunilu]

Agniweer is a blunder by modi govt. 2.0. Only Weapons don't fight war / defend nation but the soldier's MORAL and commitment to nation also fight war. Agniweer will not let the trainee disconnect from fear of death and worry for family after his demise and it will weaken the connect of soldiers to his duty and sacrifice if needed. It appears as a scheme by foreign funded agents in defence & gov. / intoxicated / insane personals. Defence is last option, why was this not tested in other forces like RPF, CRPF, Police, etc. Railway understands the value of the group-d who inspect's and mend railway tracks, as outsourcing may cost lifes, so they are permanent staff, but defence 🤔 don't have those big picture thinkers. Yes if there is 100% consumption of combat trained Agniweers in govt. jobs then it's OK. Having stary Agniweer vulnerable and available for G@ngster/M@fias/Dac0its is scary situation. Anpad don to bhari padte hain police/prashashan par, Padhelikhe-Don main sochne se bhi darta hun.

[@IDooMBring3R]

It seems the government is isolated in an echo chamber laden with leftist “Babus” and bureaucrats who come up with such horrendous policies. This country needs a complete overhaul of the British era bureaucrat system. Not to mention these so called “Babus” are against the lateral entry of extremely qualified individuals into the system to serve the country.

[@the.king.of.pirates]

Lol govt selected 10 ias for reviewing agniveer scheme

[@Akon1998hell]

IAS ke bina desh nhi chalta inki lobby strong hai, UPSC jesa zabardasti ka tough exam dekar koi apni power dilute nhi Krna chahata, ek wajah hai log itne bawle kyu hai iss exam ke liye

[@adarshsharma6699]

सरकार फौज में भर्ती खोले अग्निवीर योजना पर पुनर्विचार करे और हथियारों का लगातार आधुनिकीकरण करे नेतागिरी में फौज का सत्यानाश न करे फौज में लाला गिरी न दिखाए तो ही अच्छा होगा ।

[@adarshsharma6699]

फौज के लिए कंजूसी स्वीकार नही है ।

[@SanataniVegnMuslim0]

Lekin minister bjp ka nai tha Policy military hi banati he qutiye

[@umeshbhat6540]

He is only busy speaking "Man ke baat" to kashmiri converts and avoiding Hindus of jammu and Kashmir

[@extreme4642]

Exactly. It's dismaying he's constantly ignoring his staunch stalwarts, whereas trying to appease his haters even though we have clearly seen in the recent lok sabha election that those people never gotta vote for him.

[@AnkitKumar-nu7ry]

Yes

[@kushagrasrivastava8432]

Pm modi: *calls all muslims as infiltrators, zyada bacho wale, kapde se pehchan* Meanwhile his supporters: Why are muslims angry with bjp and pm modi??

[@hindutva-oo9ez]

​@@kushagrasrivastava8432buddhi hai tere mein? Bangladesh mein muslims rehte hai woh illegally ghus rahe hai. Unko bola tha unhone muslim illegally aa rahe hai na ki indian muslims ko

[@jkrmnegi81]

नेताओं का खर्चा गिनोगे तो दिल फुखेगा।।

[@sachinshishodia6548]

सही कहा आपने

[@Auchitya01]

This discussion is much better than the previous one. This covers a broader spectrum of issues related to Agniveer. Salute to Bakshi Sir.

[@chanchalsinghchauhan2047]

😢😢😅

[@aniketmishra2564]

The passion with which he speaks shows the king of commander he would have been in his times. Salute to him and the indian army.

[@VinayPareenja-ew5ss]

I'm fully supported the point of views of Maj.Gen Bhakshi. Govt should rethink over Agniveer policy and take good positive steps for the Army.

[@SharmaRsRaiyan]

bhai kuch log pta nhin kiun nhin smjh rhe ye baat .........

[@greenocean9039]

​@@SharmaRsRaiyanmera bhi yahi kehna. Iss scheme ko wapas lena chahiye.

[@SharmaRsRaiyan]

@@greenocean9039 bilkul faltu m carrot dikha reh h ki agniveero ko ye milega vo milaga but as a family belongs to soldier is agnipath scheme jitna ghtiya kuch bi nhin h isse competency fauj ki comprmise hori h ....agniveer competent soldier nhin h or dusri baat coordination bilkul khrab hoga isse moral bi down h unka

[@LordofKings-Raj]

Absolutely perfect analysis from G D Bakshi sir

[@TheLastPrime03]

It is sad to see reforms badly hurting our Indian Armed Forces.. Do not play with an Institution who has saved you since last 75 years.. Threat is increasing from all borders and we are deducting the number of soldiers..

[@aditierpconsultancy7124]

This interview Should be on mainstream T.V. As civilian never knew the challanges faced by the armed forces. Finance austerity in defence will impact the citizen and economy drastically.

[@blkuril6728]

शायद मैंने आज तक इतना बेहतरीन इंटरव्यू नहीं देखा।

[@user-zc8bo3sg9w]

ये कुछ नही कर पाएंगे जब हमारा होम मिनिस्टर एक शब्द मणिपुर, पंजाब, पुचिम बंगाल, दिल्ली में दो दो बार सांप्रदिक हिंसा हुई पर कोई एक्शन नहीं बस देखो। अब समय चला गया यहां पर पब्लिक को तुरंत रिस्पॉन्स चाहिए।

[@shalini4945]

Ense nahi hota sir, sab kuchchh government batati nahi hai ...

[@iamdesi-kx4ei]

और देलो केजरीवाल कांग्रेस को वोट

[@ShaktiTamwar]

​@@iamdesi-kx4ei 10 Sal se BJP Stta mein hai . Manipur pe Kuch Bola Modi? Kitne Maitei Hindu mare gye pucho ? 10 Saal se Kitni Scheme Hindu Ko di? Hindu Mandir KO Tax free Kiya? Ulta ye to Chote Mandir se bhi Tax lene ka plan bna Rhe Hain.

[@gauravsharma_7]

Bas kar tu! Mai Punjab se hu.. yaha Army deploy kar di thi Punjab may Jagah jagah jab amritpal ka Arrest hua.. Punjab Police toh Napunsak hai.. Kuch nahi kar rahi thi.. Vo toh amit Shah ne Danda chalaya tabh Pakad may aya vo..

[@ShaktiTamwar]

@@gauravsharma_7 😂😂 tbhi To vote krenge BJP ko. Khalistani Jo Blacklisted the unko bhi BJP ne White Kr Diya . Simple hai Bhai Jitna Tum Droge Utna BJP ko Vote Kroge

[@birendersingh1260]

It's always a pleasure to listen to Gen Bakshi

[@yagnikpatel7811]

Totally Agree with Sir GD Bakshi ji.

[@Pankajsanatani94]

सरपंच से लेकर प्रधानमंत्री तक इन सबको सैलरी di जाती है क्या जरूरत है इनको सैलरी देने की सबकी सैलरी बंद करो और किसानों को और जवानों के लिए सारे काम करने चाहिए। लेकिन ये सरकारें कभी नहीं चाहती हैं। क्यों कि किसान अगर अमीर हो गया तो फूल कि मालाएं कौन डालेगा। और जवान अपनी जान हथेली पर लेकर 24 घंटे रहते हैं उनके लिए और उनके परिवार के लिए आजीवन सारी सुविधाएं मिलनी चाहिए। और सब बात करो लेकिन ये बात हमें समझनी पड़ेगी कि ये तंत्र हमारा नहीं उनका है फिर हमारा कैसे भला होने वाला uai

[@NandlalAhir-yz3kg]

😂😢😮😅😊😂😢😮😅😊😂😢😮😅😊sellery bandh hona chahiye 💯%

[@hunsraajyadav843]

U R tiger sir

[@Vishal-]

‘Agniveer’ was a mastermind by ‘bureaucrats & doval’ to shift the limelight from lateral entry in ‘bureaucracy’ to ‘pensions in the army’

[@varunkhugshal9049]

Absolutely no correlation between two

[@sameer-fk8oy]

Hmm

[@Vishal-]

@@varunkhugshal9049 they clubbed the pensions of ‘MoD bureaucrats’ in the data and showed that army spends 55% in pensions & no one paid attention to it till date. Doval is a genius

[@varunkhugshal9049]

@@Vishal- it's not a secret, it's always the practice that MOD civilian payment is made from defence budget (which is wrong) , but it's no secret

[@Vishal-]

@@varunkhugshal9049cutting the pensions of ‘soldiers’ over ‘bureaucrats’ needs some different level of ‘vishwaguru’ mindset.

[@vijayvats100]

Major General Bakshi ji bilkul sahi baat kah rahe hai.... government ko is par dhyan dena chahiye or suggestions ko follow bhi karna chahiye... Jai Hind

[@vikramaditya0]

4:55 I am from Kishtwar he was talking about. This man and his team really did an amazing job in eradicating militants. Once he was a chief guest in my school in kishtwar too

[@rishabthakur5786]

you should have had a talk with him dude!...if you did, then you are fortunate person

[@SukhdevSingh-xo2di]

Very valuable advice by Gen. Bakhshi Sahib.

[@arjunram368Jarora]

एक तरफ युवा फौज की बात करते हैं, दुसरी तरफ बुड्ढी फौज को पैंशन जाने से रोक दिया, काश सैनिकों की पैंशन से बहुत ज्यादा चिंतित हैं, सरकार। जवानों की पैंशन बंद करने के लिए अग्निवीर प्रपोजल लेकर आयें, काश नेताओं की पैंशन बन्द क्यों नहीं कर देते।

[@devkumar-fq5qi]

Acha hua bjp ko sabak Mila.....aisa hii milna chahiye....pension kebal foujii ko milna chahiye aur sabka band sabse pahle poltician apna band karein

[@Tamanna_Kaushal08]

Absolutely right 👍

[@extreme4642]

Politicians ka pension toh bilkul band hona chaiye

[@sunderlalchaudhary9597]

Inka hukka paani bhi band hona chahiye. Plitics Desh Seva ki jagah profit Industry ban gaya hai.

[@petercarey5857]

Gen G D Bakshi great military expert!

[@sonasharmaraina5097]

Before any reforms in other services, we need reforms in indian bureaucracy; just passing an exam you cant become invincible and become secretary in any department from defence to health; first of all we should try Administrative veers instead of Agniveers

[@Infinitive-iu6pc]

अग्निवीर योजना तो बिलकुल समाप्त होनी ही चाहिए । यदि देश बचाना है, और भारत को सिरमौर बनाना है,तथा बी जे पी को बचाए रखना है तो ।

[@user-yk5lz8ib1b]

और Pjane जी आपने आइएसडी पर संदीप देव जी के साथ डिबेट देखीं तों उसमें बीजेपी गर्वनमेंट अमितशाह और नरेंद्र मोदी ने कश्मीर में टूरिज्म प्रोमोट कर रहे हैं और कश्मीर में Normansee आईं हीं नहीं हैं बिल्कुल और सचिन तेंदुलकर कों Face बनाया टूरिज्म प्रोमोट करने के लिएं कश्मीर में यें भीं बात लोकल मुस्लिमों ने मदत की मदत की शिवखोड़ी का अटैक में और कश्मीर पूरी तरह से एक अलग स्ट्रेट बनाकर उसमें जम्मू संभाग के साथ और पाकिस्तानी ऑक्यूपाई कश्मीर कों मिला कर एक अलग राष्ट्र बनानें की मोदी सरकार कर रहीं हैं नॉर्मनसी आईं हीं नहीं कश्मीर में पर क्लेम कर दिया मोदी और अमित शाह ने और कश्मीर पीओके साथ मिला कर एक मुस्लिम स्ट्रेट होगा और उसके लिएं अग्निवीर के ज़रिए आर्मी में मुस्लिम भर्ती करवाना और कमांडो ट्रेनिंग देना मदरसा स्टुडेंट कों जिससे की Pok कश्मीर कों Base बना कर वहां से हिमालयन का क्षेत्र हैं उत्तराखंड और हिमाचल प्रदेश उसको टार्गेट किया जा सकें और सरकार इस के लिए मदत कर रहीं हैं

[@ajay007singh1]

Isko 7-8 saal ka karke kuchh na kuchh pension deni chahiye Jawan ko ::: ye band ki gayi to 5 saal wala Short service commission bhi band karna padega ,, Agniveer ko 7-8 saal karne ki Army commission ne recommended kar diya hai ,,,Aap Google pe dekh sakte hain

[@SharmaRsRaiyan]

@@ajay007singh1 ji bhai ye sarkar khud ko bchani ki liye kuch bi krega ab itna dogla sarkar kese desh bhgt fauj ka bura haal kr dita

[@shantilalpokar6698]

@@Infinitive-iu6pc dogule??

[@pjane9231]

Modiji, BJP is ready to spend 10 Lakh corore for Pasmandas Jihadists. Why did Govt Punish our Army personal for dealing with terrorists sympathizers??? Modi has several times apologized to terrorists in Punjab, Kashmir, Mizoram to criticize congress and previous Govt...!! Modiji money spent on defense is re-circulated back into economy and helps economic growth!!!

[@pjane9231]

Because India does not manufacture it and Indian traders and customers are selfish they ignore national interest.!!

[@DonzaiNoHana]

Chodi Ji ko apme voters k muh pe mootne ki adat hai. Unhe uski validation chahiye jo unke muh pe moot ta hai. Ex: Foreign press, K2Uaa voters, leftists

[@kssps2009]

​@@padda1349Do not blabber. Sixty Years Congress ne kya Kiya. Kuch bhi nahi kiya

[@msbisht3469]

Requst to Rss to Remove Modi sooner or latter he is not capable to protect countary

[@ShaktiTamwar]

​@@kssps2009😂😂 10 Saal full majority BJP ne kya Kiya ? Sachar committee Congress layi or Modi ne use Lagu krdiya

[@dhaneshwarrawat6849]

पूरी आर्मी खत्म कर दी इन्होने अनपढ़ नेता ओर भक्त बोलते है की देश की सुरक्षा मजबूत हाथो मे है उद्योग पतियों के हाथो बिकी सरकार 🥹

[@ashwanikumar9410]

Bilkul sahi

[@iXpress]

Local support hota hai yeh sab me. India me Hindu Vaishno Devi, Amarnath nahi jaa sakta par Muslim ko Hajj ki subsidy milti rahi....flight se

[@annapurnakar7376]

Eha hai moulana modi ka masterstroke, hindu vihin karna bharat ko

[@ravindragandhe1624]

Excellent interview. Thanks .keep it up .

[@RamnarayanChoudhary-io1un]

Jai Bhavani, Jai Eklinga ji ki, Jai Rajputana.

[@johnsebastino4659]

Agniveer is not a blunder but a master stroke Unemployment is high so what happens is young men around 18 to 19 years old will join agniveer - get basic training in small arms and retire in 4 years - so when the retire they will have no job - and they will be well trained in the use of small arms so millions of unemplyed youth with arms training == Opportunity for Adani Adani will create a private army then - and will send Indian youth to fight American wars - Russian wars - any nation that can pay Adani money to fight wars for them India will become the biggest mercenary corporation in the world. Adani and Ambani will become bigger than Blackwater or Wagner group. now tell me is this not an opportunity for Adani and Ambani and the Indian youth to make India the vishwaguru ?

[@knowledgebabag]

Jai Bharat ma 🫡🙏🏻

[@jassasinghswordking6014]

Bro Eklinga ji kon se bhagwan hai ... Kirpa karke bataye

[@RamnarayanChoudhary-io1un]

@@jassasinghswordking6014 Shiv ji ( ek-linga)

[@shresthyadav3468]

jai bharat bhul gaye bhai tum

[@user-gk1xc1jl7v]

यदि इन्होंने इन हमलों का बदला नही लिया और अग्निवीर में सुधार नही किया और सैनिक संख्या नही बढ़ाई तो भाजपा को समर्थन खत्म।

[@DevVlog.Official]

10 shal lagbhag chalega,ye chhidi baxi ko retirement diya gya hai ki ap ab sena layak nahi hai,nahi to abhi Tak sena me hote.

[@YadavShivam11]

​@@DevVlog.Officialtere jaise bache usse training lete hain😂😂

[@jayudarukhanawala2519]

Problem is policy decisions are taken by IAS sitting in the office. Few defence people should be decision makers

[@jyotibanarsilal2586]

Bakshi sir should be the home minister of India. Please he will handle each and everything. Great person Always speaks truth. Salute to you sir ji

[@vikashray6008]

Maj Gen GD Bakshi is very brave and seasoned officer.

[@knowledgebabag]

Thank u so much , we r addicted of Bakshi sir conversation

[@ramavtarkashyap8093]

जय भारत, आप सभी आदरणीय जनरल साहब सहित राष्ट्रवादी बहनों और bandhuo को, हृदय से राम राम, आप सब स्वस्थ रहते हुए, दीर्घायु को प्राप्त करें l वह हमारा सबका भारत सहित, सब का मार्गदर्शन kriyega l

[@manjulkumarsharma1432]

GDB is almost always correct in defining events and finding solutions especially those happening in J& K Big Babus siting in Delhi should listen to his advice & implement it in time frame otherwise Pak Jehadis with Chinese Athiests will govern these Big Babus ,Elections will disappear along with politicians....

[@pramodpawar8633]

Yes जब कुछ भी नही था तब x सर्विस मॅन को पेन्शन थी और अब तिसरे दर्जे कि अर्थ व्यवस्था कि बाते करते हो तो देश कि सुरक्षा करने वालोको पेन्शन दे नहीं सकते ,, तो फिर देश डुबाके भाग जाने वलोको कैसे बचाते हो, सही कह रहे है मेजर साब

[@madankumargood4180]

👍💖🇮🇳

[@DrPraveenSharma]

Due to Covid no recruitment for 3 years and now Agniveer scheme. What they are trying to do with Indian Army...

[@abhinavjain3226]

Raja babu Islamic countries ka patta isi liye pehenta hai

[@mak29mba15]

Now this episode is truly eye opener...Even I also got some insight for issues like Agniveer.. Now I also think it shoulb be reviewed urgently and there need some changes as Gen Bakshi sir said... १)७-१० years service at least २)५०% retention and ५०% to Police forces ३)battle casualties should be treated equally... These are must

[@sunilsaxena9609]

50% retention कैसे होगा? जब सरकार 10% आरक्षण दें रहीं? 90% कहाँ जायेंगे? वहाँ खुद लम्बी लाइन लगी हुई हैं। सीपीओस ने बोल दिया हैं कि हम absorve नहीं कर सकते।

[@Vijaykumar-wy9ss]

Major Gen. Bakshi talks makes patriotic the people's🧡🇮🇳🌄🌱🌳😍✌🙏

[@pankajjoshi4855]

❤❤ Hamare Real Hero G.D Sahab..❤❤❤❤

[@NomadNash]

Smack ❌ Vaad ✅ is Highly addictive

[@sunilrampuria1637]

I love listening to Maj Gen Bakshi. A true soldier.

[@BittuKumarjha31]

जब शिक्षा और सुरक्षा कमजोर होगी तो देश कमजोर होगा

[@mukundsingh4200]

बख्शी साहब, क्या आप जैसे लोगों को लेकर, एक राष्ट्रीय सलाहकार परिषद का नहीं किया जाना चाहिए था? अब तो सेकुलर बैसाखी वाली लंगड़ी सरकार है!!!

[@vikas312yadav]

Nice discussion

[@deepakbhardwaj1751]

सर आपने अग्निवीर के लिए बहुत अच्छा बोला 18 साल के बच्चे 6 महीने में क्या चीज आएंगे उनको हमसे साल 2 साल की ट्रेनिंग चाहिए बॉर्डर पर जानेके लिए

[@pawanmanhas9254]

Gen Bakshi Sahib absolutely true right massage given to govt ...Desh ke achhey future ke enki baton par gour kare .. dushman se larhne ke liye trained active army chahiye..na ki thaki Hui aur future ke bare insulted fouj .....Jai Indian army...🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️

[@DJNU888]

Modi have not guts like yogi ji because he's is kshatriya jai shree ram,jai bholenath,jai maa kaali.

[@ashwanikumar9410]

Modi sabse bekar

[@JamesBond-lf4bj]

Salute to General G D Bakshi and Arihant ji. As a citizen I feel Agniveer plan must continue. Thanks to Modified Bharat for behaving like a virtual superpower. When Britishers lelf they left behind a dog(,who used to hurt us very often) on our western border and same same dog is behaving like a BHEEGI HUI BILLY.

[@shirishbapat181]

The multiple terrorist attacks in Jammu, Doda etc areas of lower Kashmir is a huge failure of Indian Intelligence. Ever since Pulwama attack on Army convoy hundreds of attacks by Pakistani terrorists have happened on Army and civilian targets in Kashmir. NSA Doval has failed in huge way. Doval should be sacked and kicked out. A new NSA should be made from retired General from Para SF Commando who have operated in Kashmir and is war experienced himself.

[@naveenchandrapathak9274]

Someone who doesn't knows the Ground reality or the Battle field scenario,but gives his opinion.... What he should be called as.... I think.. an Ass.

[@sivanandaraja7098]

Thank you sirji, For the information and strategies suggested by you Jai hind 🙏

[@tusharshinde1785]

सरकार ने लक्ष दिलेच पाहिजे फौज जर नीट नाही तर कसे होणार नुसतं आपले सरकार म्हणून चालणार नाही 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@rscsingh7848]

I was in favor of the Agniveer program, till date. But now i think that i need to reconsider. This is really hurting.

[@rscsingh7848]

@@user-thakur870 Hindustan mein Katűaā log bhi ghar milta hai . Isiliye faltu ki bakchodi naa kar.

[@nasibsingh5115]

Salute General Bakshi Sir. Agniveer policy ki vajah se Armed Forces ka beda garak ho raha hai. Agar khacha ziada hai to desh(Country) bhi to bada hai, kharcha bardaasht karna chahiye. Thanks Sir H/Capt Nasib Singh Retd.

[@bhagwansingh4093]

धन्यवाद!

[@manojdandriyal9101]

सर ये सरकार कोई पलटवार नही करती है अब तभी पाकिस्तान ये हिमाकत करता है बार बार हमे इजराइल से सीखना चाहिए हमारे जवान शहीद होते जा रहे है कब ये काम रुकेगा समझ नही आता है कब ये सरकार ये काम करेगी इतने निर्दोष मर गए किसको क्या पड़ी है

[@olivia8989]

जय हिंद भारत माता की जय 🇮🇳🚩 बक्षी साहेबांना सलाम.

[@akashpawar189]

Great discussion

[@iqbalsinghshahi]

Maj Gen GD Bakhshi ji please give pressure on Govt to withdraw Aganiveer scheme.

[@pubgaf3356]

JAI HIND

[@GoodTimesAhead27]

pure wisdom ✨

[@shikhasaraswat3790]

Great to hear you sir 🙏

[@user-hb4ub8qf5o]

Its very intelligent person of my j&k

[@nrusimha11]

Jai Bhavani!

[@RamnarayanChoudhary-io1un]

Jai MA Bhavani.

[@jitendrasinghjambe5850]

Superb video sir ji ❤❤

[@purusottammahanta1415]

Jai Hind,Jai Bharat jai jawan

[@moonlight-qq1yo]

Modi khud to 80 tak retire nahi hoga, magar agniveer mein soldiers ko 4 saal mein retire kar dega.wah re modi sarkaar, jaha kuch bhi hota hai😒

[@shantilalpokar6698]

अग्निवीर एक स्पेसियल योजना है,जो चार सालके लिए बनाई है। उसकी तालीम लेने वालो को उस दरम्यान उनको ना की फुकट मे तालीम दिया जाता है पर उनको पुरसकार दिया जाता है।

[@ashwanikumar9410]

Sabse ghatiya pm

[@Mykdwid]

Thanks for bringing Maj Gen Bakshi sir. It's a pleasure to hear him. I hope to meet him in future but don't know how😅

[@knight_rider326]

One of the most underrated officer of the armed forces 🙏🏻🤍 Salute from heart 🇮🇳

[@abhishekbahuguna7085]

Jai bhavani

[@RamnarayanChoudhary-io1un]

Jai Bhavani⚔️

[@5669ashish]

Thanks for bringing bakshi sir

[@sunilsaxena9609]

@जनरल GD BAXI सर आज आपका इंटरव्यू देख बड़ा प्रसन्न हुआ।में आपको सैलूट करता हूँ। अन्यथा आप पूर्व में केवल मोदी / भाजपा की चापलूसी ही करते रहते थे। आपसे निवेदन हैं कि सरकार से कहे कि पेंशन बिल कम करना हैं तो डिफेन्स सिविलियन की बंद कर दें। 45000 करोड़ वैसे ही कम हों जायेगा। और मात्र 60000 करोड़ रहेगा। एक पूर्व नोसैनिक

[@jyotiswarmitra9362]

Thanks Sir. Jai Hind 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪

[@Anil-to2fh]

I subscribed VAAD today. The discussions on this channel are deep and clear

[@GAURAVSHARMA-du7sj]

Very well said.. Why this government is listening this. Gen Bakshi has cleared the air.

[@devenderkumar8937]

All the citizens must pressurize the government to scrap of the Agniveer scheme. This is not only about the job but also the security of our country. No one can work efficiently when they have the sword hanging over their heads of getting fired. The old system of recruitment have proved its might to the enemy multiple times. Please don't bring changes in the Army just by sake of saying we are abolishing british traditions and practices. Those practices were workable and gave results to the British and the Indian army too. So if we use them there is no harm in it. If you are so eager to bring reforms cut the pensions of the politicians, don't wave off the cooperate taxes, bring changes in civil services and police which is the most inefficient institution of our country. Just leave the army, don't bring ridiculous changes in it. If these people get a few thousands extra in their salary there is no harm in it

[@ashwanikumar9410]

Very interesting views

[@iamindianindian8286]

❤

[@ManinderSingh-lp6sg]

Jai hind sir good sir

[@Thomas84686]

Rightly said General, Offence is the best defence. जिसको जो जुबान समझ आती है उसी में समझाइए।

[@debasishchakravorty5357]

Maj. Gen. Sahab. Jaise. Illustrate. Kar. Rahe. Oh. My. God. Thanks.

[@rajdudeja7326]

Utilize the intelligence and experience of people like Maj Gen Bakshi in a Defence Steering Committee to take the country to a next level. Similarly, take the intelligence and knowledge of SC Advocate Upadhyaya and give him a position of Law Reforms Minister (not Law Minister). In the same manner, involve the knowledge and patriotism of Nazia Elahi Khan. Don't ignore such diamonds which are very precious for the nation building. Come out of jealousy and laziness which is built in us Hindus.

[@mayankkumar9190]

This man must be the head advicer of PM regarding Pakistan and Army issue.

[@ashwanikumar9410]

Poonjipati adviser h aur unke saath khush h bewakoof

[@educationiswealth1506]

The energy we feel from sir ❤❤

[@suprovatbanerjee5648]

Congratulations sir . For your straight forwardness

[@aryansingh7188]

good

[@rpsrivastava2234]

We gave safe passage to terrorists during kargil war when our forces surrounded them.This type of treatment given by us would never bring normalcy along the Indo Pak border.

[@NareshkumarSidar]

Wonderful sir ji

[@akashdhakarey1374]

🙌Take a bow Major General GD bakshi Sir🙏 Huge RESPECT always❤️

[@madanchoudhary8108]

Bakshi Sir namaste. Jai shree Ram

[@girjesh0]

Major General G.D. Bakhshi ji 🙏🏻🙏🏻🌹🇮🇳🌹🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@sunnykumar4189]

Amazing ❤

[@user-hl4bg8mp2j]

Bhaut badiya sir

[@user-gk1xc1jl7v]

मोदी सरकार भी कांग्रेस बनने का प्रयास कर रही है क्या

[@ashwanikumar9410]

Usse bhi ghatiya

[@kuldeepprasaddobriyal7578]

वर्ग विशेष को पटाने की कोशिश कर रही।

[@rajeshchauhan7453]

Stop free distribution of food , and other things invest in Army

[@mehtabsaxena1180]

I agree and thanks a lot for a detailed analysis of our Army affairs explained by Maj. Gen. GD Bakshiji. Indian Govt must spend 2 percent of GDP on Army. Agniveers be retained for 10 years, thereafter 50 be retained in Army and 50 be recruited in Police/ BSF/ ITBP/ CSIF etc. Army Strength be upgraded in manpower/Weapons ASAP. Defence Minister/ CDS/ Defence Chiefs must act. To counter terrorists attack, our force must be offensive rather defensive.

[@sunilsaxena9609]

10 ईयर ok

[@anirudh1040]

In simple language it is called “Deshdroh” done by changing framework of institutions.

[@boomboomboomboomer]

there are entire villages and districts in India where the men have been joining the army for generations. it is a massive loss to the country if their contribution, skills, and generational experience and attitude are no longer taken into service.

[@ashwanikumar9410]

Poonjipatiyon ke liye kaam karne wali government se poochho

[@adwaitvedant3297]

I propose 3/4th retention and after 8 years 1/2 shall be retained !! Then after 12th year 33% will be remain!!

[@devenderkumar8937]

Not at all viable!! Just look from a soldiers perspective, unit of the soldier is the second home for him. He live there, fight there, No one can work efficiently when they have the sword hanging over their head of getting fired and here we are talking about the army which is life and death. Agniveer should be scrapped completely and we should shift to the old system which have proved its might to the enemy

[@gauravsharma_7]

​@@devenderkumar8937Completely Agree!..

[@apoorvaditya3048]

Hello Mr all knowing civilian , why do you think one will be ready to fight for you , die or kill for you when you don't feel attached to the force you are serving with and that doesn't happen in one day , it happens with regimentation something which you people won't understand.

[@ohboeeboee]

Yup be the ill supplied army, spent 70% on salaries and pension, 25% on operational expense and 5% on r&d and modernisation...it's all about Sarkari job,,,keep pushing the fighting age upwards , wah re wah👌...just like how we vote? What's in it for me and then my caste....the world adopted your of duty when you were in primary school...​@@devenderkumar8937

[@vineetkumar8221]

Thank you sir

[@JaspalSingh-or3lf]

Happy to hear a soldier speak his heart out on most important issues . Each word needs to be paid attention to. But in the last minutes he is back with the outbursts that he is known for after his retirement. Most people may not agree with the last part. During his field posting at Jk border , once there was a heavy military firing from Pak . The then General , Gen. Bikram Singh had visited the site & if l am not wrong , scolded Maj .Gen Bakshi , GOC , as to why he had to wait for orders for immediate retaliation . Pak may be at a very low economically. We were also in that condition in the 1990s. Were we militarily weak during that period. Absolutely not. Do not underestimate enemy.