संवाद# 205: Dark truth of Subhas Chandra Bose's death, geopolitical analysis by Iqbal Chand Malhotra

[@abhishekprasad5359]

Please call Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghosh. Netaji death mystery discussion is incomplete without them.

[@rashmiranjannayak8983]

How many times do you want to listen to the same things over and over??

[@AJJYTHEGREAT]

​@@rashmiranjannayak8983exactly

[@RajagopalanKrishnan]

They have summarily dismissed this video as a nonsensical rant of low quality!

[@RajagopalanKrishnan]

​@@rashmiranjannayak8983because that's the most likely theory and it has supporting evidence... Not personal opinion only like this

[@User_877]

What this guy is telling isn’t it completely contradictory to what Anuj and ghosh claim ?

[@SuhailBhattacharyya]

Subhash Chandra Bose had a complex relationship with communism. While he was influenced by socialist ideas and admired certain aspects of communism, especially its emphasis on social equality and the upliftment of the working class, he was not a communist in the strict ideological sense. Bose believed in a form of socialism that was adapted to Indian conditions, combining elements of both socialism and nationalism. He saw the need for strong state control over the economy to ensure social justice and economic development, but he also valued the role of individual initiative and private enterprise in certain sectors. His concept of socialism was more nationalistic, aiming to integrate economic planning with the broader goal of achieving Indian independence. Bose was critical of the Soviet Union's rigid and dogmatic approach to communism, but he respected its achievements, particularly in industrialization and social welfare. He was also wary of communism's potential to disrupt India's traditional social structure and the unity needed for the freedom struggle. Ultimately, while Bose advocated for a form of socialism, his ideology was distinct from orthodox Marxist communism, blending elements of various political philosophies to serve India's unique needs.

[@nikhilthakur7317]

He has clearly stated that India wud adopt the ancient Bharateeya system of the Panch (panchaayat) in his book the Indian pilgrim.

[@parthajyoti7560]

Thats it 🙏

[@suvadipbiswas9556]

Thik bolecho..

[@Bikram_Riya]

Rightly said

[@harshchanchal8011]

Please do a podcast with Anuj Dhar, any discussion on Netaji is incomplete without him.

[@BirenPanchal]

Please call Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghosh for in depth clarity on Netaji's life and times and the most important death mystery. They've factual evidences available to prove it to anyone.

[@prashantpratap8179]

100% netaji is the greatest leader produced and the reason for Indian independence. He was definitely alive & in india till 1985.

[@siddharthsingh37]

He is making all claims out of assumptions. Put him in front of Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghosh, they make a monkey out of his claims. Gumnaami Baba was Netaji.

[@vs_916]

You are right Sir. @Vaad Should bring Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose for the actual story. They are the most authentic source on the Netaji case period. Despite all the nonsensical claims made by both sides of the ideological spectrum, they have been successful in scientifically putting forth the final evidence that Gumnaami Baba was indeed Netaji. Previous podcasts with Mr.Iqbal Chand Malhotra have been insightful but this one is just half baked and incomplete.

[@nikhilthakur7317]

​@@vs_916.. Arre yeh bhaajipao waale kya layenge Anuj ko

[@RajagopalanKrishnan]

They have dismissed iqbal jis statements

[@MrSouvickadak]

Correct, he does not have any evidence

[@vs_916]

​@@nikhilthakur7317if he could bring Sai Deepak and Shiv Kunal Verma, why not Anuj Dhar?

[@Nair_]

This guy manufactures history out of thin air. The patent is worth billions.

[@nikhilthakran]

Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghosh have done extensive research and written extensively! Please call both of them on Netajis mystery. Also Prof Kapil is running the museum in Red Fort for INA and Netaji! Talk to them.

[@srivastavaapoorva4613]

I visited 2 days before to last residence of Netaji उर्फ़ गुमनामी बाबा..वही नेताजी थे। please do visit to that place in अयोध्या

[@kratiksharma_1019]

Most awaited podcast. I don't no when indians will realize that we got independence because of S C bose.

[@73HE]

We got Independence because of the Naval Mutiny & what the Maratha Light did when asked to fire on the mutineers

[@vs_916]

​@@73HEwhich was driven by the INA trials btw

[@abhinavjain3226]

​@@73HE We got independence because Hitler bled United Kingdom and they made a deal with US to pass over the 'great power' baton to them.

[@bally1asdf]

We got independence due to geo politics. When british can handle 1857 this was nothing

[@73HE]

@@vs_916 no

[@jitenrawat007]

महान व्यक्तित्व नेताजी सुभाष चंद्र बोस

[@lokesh9563]

Totally different from what Anuj has written in his book Conundrum..

[@vidushisharma2695]

I am currently reading it and this is very different

[@vijaykumar4500]

I always admire the new perspective shri malhotra ji brings to us audience.

[@Deshprem25.]

I don't agree that Bose was communist. Bose was hindu ideology. I m from odisha so I know how he was spiritual. He had left Cuttack his hometown to meditate. He used to help and serve the Cholera suffered peoples in Cuttack .He was follower of Swami Vivekananda. He was influenced how USSR revolution happened. He wanted to uproot Britishers from India. He needed help from Hitler it doesn't mean he was Jewish phobic. He was in ally with Japan it doesn't mean he was china phobic. He was a Hindu. He was out of each and every ideology. He just needed help of Russia to free India from Britisher. He may help to communist party to establish it doesn't prove that Bose was communist.

[@sanjeevgupta5926]

correct analysis

[@nikhilthakur7317]

Bam Bam BholaaNaath

[@SeekerSeeker]

He would have uprooted castism.

[@surajitroy2123]

Very high quality effort to find n dig out historical facts. It's a tribute to the freedom fighters who wanted India's freedom at all cost. Salutations

[@subhajit0]

Netaji lived 2 lives: 1. As Netaji Bose or Chandra Bose till 1953 or so when he returned to India. 2. As a Tantrik Sanyasi Mahakaal who referred to himself as "bhoot". Like many revolutionaries of the freedom movement Netaji lost interest in politics in his later avatar which is why he preferred to live anonymity.The most important reason was Partition and the politics developing in India post "independence". This is not the India they had fought for. I think Mr. Malhotra needs to study more about Netaji's life before his 1941 disappearance including his life and work as Mayor of Kolkata in the 1920s under the guidance of Deshbandhu CR Das. Swami Vivekananda was a major influence in his life and Gita was his constant companion.

[@nikhilthakur7317]

It's not that he hasn't read. He's a stooge

[@dipanjanachoudhury9126]

I have been looking for the book , Mahakal kathan or oi mahamanob ase , do you know where how to read the pdf ??? Any chance you have it. ???

[@subhajit0]

@dipanjanachoudhury9126 I am only aware of the work of Charanik: "Oi Mahamanab Ashe" which is available. Netaji/Bhagwani related Bengali books including his own Taruner Swapna urgently need Hindi and English translations. Will let you know if I hear about this particular book. Jai Hind. Vande Mataram

[@subhajit0]

Bhagwanji

[@dipanjanachoudhury9126]

@@subhajit0 also oi Mohamanob ase , book , I was looking for

[@ishan_r]

Any talk about Netaji disappearance without Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose is totally incoplete. A humble request to do a podcast with them.

[@HarinamForever]

The biggest mystery of india. Netaji is still relevant and will be, he became immortal, Netaji lives in the heart of every indian ❤ Very very fascinating story 👏 I was sticked to the podcast till end like glue.

[@abhishekpratapsingh3303]

Do a podcast with Anuj Dhar.

[@sanjeevsharma-jh8jo]

परदे मैं रहने दो। पर्दा जो ग़र खुल जायेगा… नेताजी की तथ्यों पर आधारित है विवेचना और मूल्यांकन अभी तक नहीं हुआ है। श्रद्धा और भक्ति के भाव से नेताजी को पूजित कर सुरक्षित कर दिया गया है। इन्दिरा का “ जय हिन्द “ का नारा क्या नेताजी के लिए मात्र श्रद्धा सूचक है अथवा कुछ संदेश भी छिपा है। इन्दिरा जवाहरलाल जी की बेटी थी पर विचारधाराओं की घेराबंदी से मुक्त उपयोगिता के सिद्धांत पर काम करती थीं। जय हिन्द।

[@chandrarajsingh-ux8ee]

Last 2 minutes best of podcasts... Arihant Bhai ye do minute par ek alag podcast karwaiye

[@sudeeppareekclasses2755]

देश की आजादी में किसी व्यक्ति का सबसे बड़ा योगदान था, तो वो थे नेताजी सुभाष चन्द्र बोस।।

[@Sohambando]

Bring Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose

[@abhilashn2993]

Thanks Vaad for wonderful series with Malhotra. Really enjoy his narration and opening secrets.

[@tejsinghjaglan5503]

नेता जी का सारा जीवन ही रहस्य और रोमांच से भरपूर है। कोई भी असली तह तक नहीं जा सका है। जिस व्यक्ति के बारे में इतने देशों मे फ़ाइलें classified है वहाँ से असलियत बाहर आना ना मुमकिन है।

[@invinciblesoldiers5654]

Invite Anuj Dhar and Chandrachud Ghosh they will provide you clear documented evidence. Anuj is the pioneer of Netaji disappearance case Or read Conundrum

[@himangshuarnheimbora4150]

There is no place for the British Empire in the world of tomorrow- Subhas Chandra Bose

[@anindyamukherjee9971]

Wonderful discussion

[@mayukhsarkar4386]

Last part of the discussion that "it would have been a violent India".....hurts us. Firstly Netaji won't have allowed the countries to have been separated and second this 2 nation theory won't have existed. Almost all the troubles that we face today inthe sectors of defence & security won't have existed and the nation would have been far more developed!

[@BhaiyaBabu-zm8jy]

No no. नेताजी के प्रति सम्मान है। पर उनकी ideology के कारण एक तरफ़ communist तो दुसरी तरफ non-communist होती। सच में अखंड भारत नही रह पाता। बाकी पता नहीं क्या होता?

[@sonalsharma5743]

​@@BhaiyaBabu-zm8jyRead books by Netaji to understand his real political ideology in Indian context. He believed in combining the best elements of different ideologies and his inspiration was ancient Indian democratic systems of governance. He has given examples of how democracy was rooted in Indian ethos. With Sardar Patel by his side, Subhash Chandra Bose would have achieved the impossible for India.

[@BhaiyaBabu-zm8jy]

@@sonalsharma5743 ok

[@hrishikeshgokhale7428]

I love your videos very much and I am 1st

[@contemporarymatters8106]

Most colourless and rich narrative thus far. Excellent.

[@ManjeetSingh-lk7uv]

Real... Father... Of... Nation... Bharat 🚩🚩🚩🚩

[@vipinsangwan7074]

Bhaisahab aise hi podcast late raho, Tank you

[@amalendusinghnaik5585]

Malhotra saab you are great

[@RakhRakhke]

Greatest podcast congrats to host ❤❤❤

[@GauravSingh-zd9dr]

सादर आभार 🙏🌹

[@karmamoksha369]

💠 40:50 I have not seen anyone on YT taking clearly in detail about why *🇮🇳 is still part of 🇬🇧 Commenwealth?** I request VAAD team to make a vlog on this topic with Iqbal Chand Malhotra Ji. ✍🏼

[@HimanshuKhatri_IITD_IRS]

Bose was deeply religious in personal life. He was secular Hindu. Had left home at an early age to be a sanyasi. He was fan of Vivekananda. The work is not fully researched by interviewee

[@viguabsent]

He was married to a German woman and had daughter with him, what Sanyasi ?

[@HimanshuKhatri_IITD_IRS]

@@viguabsent

[@HimanshuKhatri_IITD_IRS]

round the age of 15 or 16, Bose became increasingly dissatisfied with the material world and began contemplating a more ascetic, spiritual life. This led to his decision to leave home for a while in 1914 to seek spiritual guidance. He went to the Himalayas, where he hoped to find solace in the company of saints and monks

[@chingariapkaapnaraju]

Correct ​@@viguabsent

[@parthajyoti7560]

​@@viguabsent It still a controversy

[@apurbasinghthakur9821]

Both of you didn't study enough Bose life..

[@ameyapte8533]

Requesting you to connect with Anuj Dhar sir and Chandrachur Ghosh sir for correct information

[@user-The_amazing_world086]

Wow amazing

[@73HE]

Thanks for getting ICM again

[@sanjeevbhattacharjee1936]

Awesome research n analysis...opens the Pandoras box n the worms therein ...

[@samdes678]

I’m wondering why you think that Bose was hard leftist? He had seen Japan and Germany developing rapidly. I feel with him at helm, we in fact would have had a true republic firmly on development path similar to rapid industrialization of Japan or Korea post war.

[@lokeshkumarray7560]

This is by far the best explanation of Netaji's disappearance.

[@apurbasinghthakur9821]

You should make one separate podcast on Bhagha Jatin who is more pratiate than Gandhi, Patel and Neheru combine..

[@justbehuman9491]

वास्तव में... १. *_कम्युनिस्ट = चीनी सैनिक_* २. *_इमानवाले = अरबी सैनिक_* ३. *_सैकूलर = १,२ की राजनैतिक टीम_* ४. *_एक्टिविस्ट =१,२,३ की कानूनी टीम_* ५. *_लिबरल = १,२,३,४ की प्रोपेगैंडा टीम हैं_*

[@pramitsarkar3164]

Please call Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghosh

[@sadityas1]

45:45 bilkul sahi kaha aapne mai bhi isi conclusion p phocha hu ke netaji Indian Soviet union relationship netaji ke influence me chalti thi...aur 1971 ki war India ko pura Azad karne me sabse aham saal tha...

[@lifestruggle2304]

Neta Ji Ko Sadar Pranam Jay Hind Jay Bharat 🫡 🙏

[@parthajyoti7560]

Netaji was influenced by swami Vivekananda. If he was a communist then why communist people hated him and mocked him ???? A devout hindu ,For Subhas Chandra Bose, Hinduism was an essential part of Indianness. He considered Vedanta and Bhagavad Gita as his sources of inspiration in the fight against the British .

[@COSMICTUNECOMM]

Fifty percent true in above podcast but original is different. Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose last two hundred years most dynamic global leader. He never married and wife and daughter Hitler relationship.

[@AbhishekYadav-yw3vm]

Call and Ask hard hitting questions (specially DNA and hand writings) to Anuj Dhar, it would be really enlightening for your audience regarding this subject. IB played its role but there can be alternate reasons (as it has been established they were reporting to MI6 liasion officer).

[@rashmiranjannayak8983]

How many times do you want to listen to the same reasons from Anuj? Ok whatever happened we can't change it, but what is it we are doing now??

[@chaitanyathinks]

@@rashmiranjannayak8983 He has not appeared on Vaad. And if the host and others don’t agree with Gumnami baba angle What’s wrong with talking about it again. Once we establish what had happened, only then we can decide what should be done in present and future.

[@rashmiranjannayak8983]

@@chaitanyathinks barring Vaad, dhar has already done more than 10 podcasts talking about the same things. By appearing here what more intriguing can he say about the gumnami baba which he hasn't said before

[@Anil.Ramani]

Best podcast channel in India ❤❤❤❤ gujrat

[@milindjanawade9098]

very good...

[@atulsharma-zp9tc]

Everyone commenting Bring Anuj dhar..... .............

[@sourabsharma503]

Bring Anuj Dhar

[@BhaiyaBabu-zm8jy]

अब कुछ-कुछ बातें clear हुई।

[@3_6_9Aarya]

भारत में अवतारी होगा, वो अति विस्मयकारी होगा. छद्म भेष में वो विचरेगा जीते जी कई बार मरेगा. वे दशावतार है 🚩

[@BatukaBhairavaSevak_Tuhin]

Netaji was a big devotee of Ma kali, and this person marked him as communist???? What a joke, plss stop 🛑

[@pijushkashyap4411]

All information provided in the podcast is based upon "Trust me bro". Very factual.

[@abhishek_083]

Favourite guest on this podcast, Iqbal Chand Malhotra

[@apurbasinghthakur9821]

Gd Bhaksi will take care both of you guys podcast conclusion...

[@shubhamrawat-sj8bo]

Good video

[@beamaster4235]

According to my calculation he is still alive ACTUAL ALIVE ...

[@socialhealth9079]

This man knowledge blow my mind

[@sharvilmore6802]

Bring Anuj dhar

[@daipayanchakraborty288]

I was hopeful that Indian Government would come out with the truth of disappearance of Netaji Subhash Bose when Modi came to power in 2014 but I'm completely disappointed now that even Modi is covering the misdeeds of Gandhi, Nehru and Congress.

[@monkeymindat]

There is only one NETAJI and no one ever would take his place. 🙏🏼 to the FIRST PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA 🚩❤️🇮🇳 And as a Bengali we are always proud of him. He is a Nationalist and he is a Rightist in my heart. Jai Hind Jai Bharat ❤🇮🇳🚩❤️ Sir is right he would have been extradited and Nehru's government would have fallen then.

[@BaljeetSingh-rx7hr]

जय हिंद

[@balinderloan4937]

Good🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@banerjeesiddharth05]

Nice video 📹 👍 👌

[@ManjuYadav_]

Netaji ko lekar ab itne kisse kahaniyan media mei hain ki samajh mei hi nahi aataa kis par vishwas karein aur kis par nahi! Akhand Bharat ke Pratham Pradhan mantri thei Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.

[@vikrantchaudhary1214]

Mukherjee commission, not Bose commission. Samar Guha, not Samar Sen.

[@williamhunter7131]

Samar sen guha…

[@subhajit0]

​@williamhunter7131 Samar Guha was a well known MP. Also a Chemistry Prof.

[@jaspalsingh8154]

Very very nice sir

[@Advaitaaditya-99]

Bro you have not called an authentic person to talk on NETAJI'S life and on death (1985 Ayodhya) the only persons who are well qualified and authentic to talk in these matters is @anujdhar sir and @chandrachurg sir none Other than them...!!!

[@proTN.]

Please give an intro to your episodes, it starts abruptly and the listener is left without any context. Guest intro should also be there.

[@pratyushmishra6243]

मेरे दिमाग में भी कभी कभी ये विचार आता था कि अगर नेता जी का शासन रहता तो क्या होता?? मैं समझता था कि चीन से हमारा युद्ध नहीं होता ??? पर हम तो उससे भी बड़े गृह युद्ध में पर जाते ऐसा कभी विचार नहीं आया मेरे मन में😮

[@nikhilthakur7317]

Kuch nahi padhte. Yeh do bickey huey logon ki sunke apna dimaag mat banaao

[@pratyushmishra6243]

@@nikhilthakur7317 Nahi bhai bat to sahi hai agar neta ji kaman sambhalte to paridrishya kuch or he hota

[@dhruvmalhotra17]

With due respect to sir, Anuj and his team ki books and seminar sunne wali audience iss se zyada conclusive podcast kr deti. Extremely sad to see this quality on your channel

[@amitavkanungo5738]

I think Anuj Dhar is more knowledgable about Netaji. And Netajee isn’t left ideologist

[@ethenhunt4257]

Agar Shubhash Chandra Bose was secular then Gandhi was the greatest warrior of all time..

[@Deshprem25.]

Mk Gandhi was No 1 Hypocritic person

[@muditarya]

​@@Deshprem25.Yes u r right

[@apurbasinghthakur9821]

Why Rasbihari Bose and Savarkar is not mentioned while discussing Bose ideology..

[@divyomchauhan9253]

I mean, if you are calling this guy, try Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose

[@RajaLal-jm7je]

Why Lila roy,pabitramohonroy, sunglasses das such Person touch CONTRACT THAT UNKNOWN SHADHU? CAN YOU ANSER THIS QUESTION?

[@RajaLal-jm7je]

Sorry sunil das

[@biswasb1611]

I’m found this a very poorly researched talk on Netaji, and it seems the moderator is also equally unaware of facts about Netaji. Usually the talks are very informative on your platform sir. But, this is far far away from any of your average podcast in terms of research.

[@straightfromkota]

Sir it is to complex to understand can you please simplified it for further vaad episodes

[@nikhilgautam6963]

My fav guest 😍😍😍😍

[@omjidwivedi4184]

Bose anti hindu the aaj pata chala .. thanks 🙏🙏 is podcast k liye...

[@maverick1413]

Netaji was never a leftist, his ideology may similar to socialism but he had no interest in left leaning ideology.

[@SanjaysharmaPillalamarri]

He mistook project 731 as 371 and the unit was known unit 731 and they were later absorbed into the US and their findings are classified till now

[@SanjaysharmaPillalamarri]

And Major general kalisnikov might be the famous inventory of the Ak series

[@SanjaysharmaPillalamarri]

And nazi wtich hunts continued as israel took revenge and in the rule of Trump a 96 year old Nazi was sentenced

[@aryakumar3815]

Not full information provided by Mr Malhotra, please do podcast with Anuj Dhar .

[@aks_ashutosh]

Please invite anuj dhar and chandrachur ghose

[@DINESHPAL-el1me]

Bring Anuj and Chandrachud ji...without them Netaji's discussion is incomplete

[@suchbol-u2s]

नाम्बियार अखबार का प्रतिनिधि बन कर रहता था अंतिम दिनों में भारत आ गया था दिल्ली में मर गया मरने के बाद भारतीय गुप्तचर एजेंसियों ने उसका घर पूरा कब्जे में ले लिया था गांधी परिवार का खास था

[@sujitsinghpardeshi2093]

Khongress party, Gandhi or Nehru parivar hamare desh ko milla hua bahut bada abhishaap hain. Laanat hain inn logo par.

[@nrprabhu555]

Vaad is bringing on people with SUS background and motivation. Not sure if it is by design. Or????

[@aaaddyant]

Good saas bahu drama story narrated in this podcast

[@anupkumar6714]

The last German Submarine to surrender was U234, which was a cargo submarine. It was carrying unenriched Uranium from Germany to Japan. But after German surrender, U234 captain surrendered to the US. The submarine was taken to the US and was sink in 1947 by a torpedo because of uranium contamination.

[@balinderloan4937]

Good day

[@Bikram_Riya]

Seeing this Podcust it is clear He does not understand Netaji. Netaji was Leftist but not not atheist. He had deep flow of Hindu spiritualism inside him inspired by Vivekanda. He used to read Bhagvaad Geeta Every day.