Sarmaya Talks with Devdutt Pattanaik

[@rashrocks902]

I love listening to different versions of Hinduism - Sadhguru, Osho, Yogananda , Shivapurana, Amish Tripathi, Devdutt Pattnaik and aethists too. Each time I get astonished. There are so many similarities and some stark differences too. This is how we can do our best to understand our own reality. Listen to many but follow no one but our own experiences🙏

[@animeost9193]

Please it's a request. Do not follow Devdutt Patnayak. He's a distortion. He tells his twisted & manipulated stories to fit the narrative of defaming Hinduism & presenting it as Mythology. His translations are very wrong so avoid following him. He has already been exposed on Rajiv Malhotra's youtube channel.

[@rashrocks902]

I know what are you talking about. He is telling his interpretations. Honestly that's good. I know some of his tweets are controversial but the fact remains he talks logic only. He doesn't go beyond logic. As a reader or listener, I understand his limitation. And I don't go by his version of Hinduism and practically no one should. We have to seek our own way, rely on our own perception and experiences, if you are lucky enough you will find your Guru. I have found mine. I listen to Devdutt Pattnaik ji just for fun and for knowing a different permutation and combination of Hinduism. That's it. 😀🙏

[@sagarmairpadi5538]

@@rashrocks902 you can't say that a horse is a donkey , and then say it's my interpretation. Try to understand someone who is supported by all of the left and also against the ideology of right . This is not a coincidence or an interpretation, he is attracting people towards his work in the means of comman interest and then just to distort and completely say that it's just a story or make belief .

[@dhirajsharma5530]

@@rashrocks902 Amish is better than him, atleast he tells that I am writing Fiction...He says that its pure Indian mythology! But he knows how to communicate in English with classy people...and that's done!!!

[@milindu8919]

@@sagarmairpadi5538 but nobody knows the absolute truth...we are like the blind men touching the elephant...there is no one "truth". DP is giving his own interpretations and that is fine. You can accept it or leave it

[@Aman-et3rq]

What a fine lecture...impeccable. The way Mr Pattanaik has described the Hindu way of thinking is awesome.

[@rajanram1960]

There are so many things I can’t retain expect along an”ah yes I remember that.” How can I get your prodigious recall. But thank god for you to give me endless smiles and a greater understanding of the cultural background I come from.

[@tanushreenarayan365]

This talk is such a masterclass , it should have more views !

[@anilkumarputhran5300]

The best lecture of Dr.Patnaik.

[@satyarthpandey225]

Truely said sir well done😍👍

[@dipendrayadav6068]

30:22, it reminds me of the days when I was preparing for IITJEE in Patna, Bihar. I had a funny friend who would always say "J padhi uho maari, j na padhi uho maari". It was just out of fun but now I see that we have it in our sub-conscious brain. We really understand at least out of fun that everything is impermanent.

[@alokpramanik7634]

Dr Pattnaik openes the gate for more questions into my mind .I love churning all these through mindful state of mind

[@dwij23]

Alok Pramanik he is a beautiful mind.😍

[@ranvijaymehta]

Who is Devdutt Pattanaik kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqvWg6WGi8ipsLM

[@ranvijaymehta]

@@dnyaneshwargaikwad5158 Urban naxalite ke bare main kuch Jante ho ?

[@ranvijaymehta]

@@dnyaneshwargaikwad5158 Fake Gaikwad ho ya kuch malim bhi hain Gaikwad ke Bare me ?

[@ranvijaymehta]

@@dnyaneshwargaikwad5158 Pattanik ka asliya Janane ke liye ye video dekho .Or bhi bahut sare hain hain . kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqvWg6WGi8ipsLM

[@sridharansrinivasan2313]

Splendid and lucidly explained the Hindu mythology. फल की चिंता मत करो

[@rajinderrana46]

Now Devdutt u are talking gud sense! Asto ma sat ga m ya, Nrityo ma amritam ga m ya!! Jai Bharatah!!!🇮🇳

[@vishalghayal531]

Even on my worst day I can sleep while hearing this session❤❤🔥

[@panimeda245]

His views are in most circumstances very legible and people who listen to it should have open mind and heart to understand and also not to deviate from own beliefs etc.

[@hemlataseroha5807]

Very intresting,I could not resist and hear complete in one go, Very informative.

[@nagarajn.6091]

Awesome insights..

[@logandakshi2087]

Thank you very much for sharing this brilliant speech that explains the essence of our life. It expands our vision and approach life with Peace rather than trying to long for Peace in future. 🙏🙏😃

[@choudhary2k]

Subtitles are horrible, listen him mindfully. He has gems in this talk.

[@devidaughter7782]

"rebirth and uncertainty; there are no guarantees" - two key concepts of Indian thought .. there is no right way (and therefore there is no wrong way), and there is diversity (46:45) "so diversity is rooted in the idea of rebirth" . . . "justice is not a Hindu concept" (1:03:10) . . . "you cannot control the world" (1:13:00) and we desire control because we can't handle uncertainty, the fact that we are not significant (1:16:00) "but we are of value to the other- this is the only real . . . I can bring value to other people's lives" (1:16:36).

[@adityaiyer7405]

Ĺ11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111118kk

[@dsbdsb6637]

Tribes get created by the region, regional knowledge, by surroundings & the fears which even modernity has not been able to resolve i.e. of unknown.

[@rakeshsinha6810]

You held me spellbound!!

[@devidaughter7782]

"tribes are not created in hatred, they are created in meaning" (17:32) . .."karm karo phal ki chinta mat karo कर्म करो फल की चिंता मत करो (39: 39) which means no guarantee" (or 'do your job without worrying about the outcome, as the outcome is not in your hands'). . . "the name of God is Ananta, infinity" (41:36)

[@rohitkadam2968]

Wonderful speech 😇

[@sko259]

Great explanation Thanks

[@anuradhachanda3896]

What is important is that Hinduism allows each and every individual to interpret in one’s own way. That provides a diversity of thinking and living. The BJP/RSS like the Brahmanas want to bring their order and force it on others. A true Hindu will never accept it.

[@Kl_kanhaiya13]

In the name of diversity you fool following a idiot who doesn't even what Hinduism he doesn't even have any proof for his false claims I now understand IQ level who doesn't even know bhagwat gita 😂😂😂😂😝😝

[@sk-pg8zd]

dont get me wrong you look like a fool who just fasinated about language but never wanted to know the truth...

[@Tashaaprasad7619]

🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉good thanks 🙏🏻 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@nagaratnanayak6259]

If you can't convince people, confuse them.That is what Patnaik is at the most doing

[@prithvirajdixit4081]

Accha.. B's apke gyan pelna bacha tha

[@rajhegde5955]

Well said brother I 😂😂 He just keeps talking without any depth and respect to fpundatubal knowledge of the Sanathana Dharma

[@rahulloveannie]

Superb talk sir

[@rushikeshkale1259]

Stories about uncertainty and insignificance.

[@mintusaren895]

Bengal. Advaito to dvaita. Conflict to illumination. But to live INDIAN upanishad well explained. ITS CIRCLE not moksha .

[@pedrosotomayor5480]

brilliant !

[@alokpramanik7634]

One should find answeres from oneself not from others which was Debdutta ji narrated

[@vanibhupal]

He is a word spinning marketeer. He is not spreading the basic knowledge: Nature/God has the same design/software for life forms (microbes to dinosaurs) (A) Survival instinct (B) Procreation. All human activities are derivatives of these two.

[@reshranpise]

Buddha part was bang on.

[@madhavrale2518]

The parallels (civilizations) of Mo-hinja daro and Harrapa here in India which are in somewhere in Himachal and near Ludhiana which existed at the same time (thus parallels) had burials. Skeletons of humans were excavated recently and were found to be systematic along with their belongings (pottery and other stuff; cant infer the other belongings in detail). These same people were found (through genome studies) to be of a unique gangetic race and not related to the aryan race. What would you say about burials for this local gene?

[@ranvijaymehta]

Who is Devdutt Pattanaik kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqvWg6WGi8ipsLM

[@npjay]

Rebirth i.e cyclical , world is uncertain...action/cause will have reaction/effect( good or bad) you are insignificant , try to feed/help others...!!! that's it...!!!

[@badminton_tnl]

Is there any other speakers or writers belonging this category?

[@geetagilda9429]

Super

[@panimeda245]

I unsure about this fact as how many people are destined to critique the Sanatana dharma or Hinduism or Indian culture etc. the same way are there any person or people who dare to critique other major faith's if so, we should stop doing it on our faith.

[@entertainment55]

Once the audience have some knowledge on the subject he is speaking then one can easily predict he is doing all his creativity without logical sense And things which don't connect each other, And trying to connect today's world with mythology with forced creativity

[@k.sinformation3999]

You are right at your way. But what we can gain from the mythology which is useful then we should.

[@vanibhupal]

He is a word spinning marketeer. He is not spreading the basic knowledge: Nature/God has the same design/software for life forms (microbes to dinosaurs) (A) Survival instinct (B) Procreation. All human activities are derivatives of these two.

[@entertainment55]

@@k.sinformation3999 who will decide What is gain? What is useful? As the difference get subtle we may use something from mythology which can lead us to disaster

[@entertainment55]

@@vanibhupal just went 10 feet above from my head

[@shainypurushothaman6800]

I am just a spectator..could feel you are stepping through the tough zone..audience are confused! The intellectual will stir up. All the answers are there in your broader Spectrom but how many will capture is the question!!

[@ranvijaymehta]

Who is Devdutt Pattanaik kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqvWg6WGi8ipsLM

[@vanibhupal]

@@ranvijaymehta He is a word spinning marketeer. He is not spreading the basic knowledge: Nature/God has the same design/software for life forms (microbes to dinosaurs) (A) Survival instinct (B) Procreation. All human activities are derivatives of these two.

[@vanibhupal]

He is a word spinning marketeer. He is not spreading the basic knowledge: Nature/God has the same design/software for life forms (microbes to dinosaurs) (A) Survival instinct (B) Procreation. All human activities are derivatives of these two.

[@amanpreetsingh3877]

is rig veda on ganga plains or indus plains?

[@adityanrajesh2634]

earlier part of rig veda is around Sindhu River, in the later mandalas, the events are staged around ganga river.

[@RajVeer87156]

Please read mr nityananda misra too

[@tstanmoysamanta]

The main Concept is not Rebirth, it's Moksha.

[@AshokKumar-uc2hr]

Beware

[@sumanbachchas3145]

Sir hindi walo ka bhi khyal karo

[@ranvijaymehta]

Who is Devdutt Pattanaik @

[@madhusrinivas7958]

It's sattalogy not mythology

[@geetagilda9429]

Hallow

[@bharatupadhyay5006]

This speaker is bogus...

[@joshypanavally6803]

There is beginning, no end and there is nothing in between! What a rubbish presentation!

[@vanibhupal]

He is a word spinning marketeer. He is not spreading the basic knowledge: Nature/God has the same design/software for life forms (microbes to dinosaurs) (A) Survival instinct (B) Procreation. All human activities are derivatives of these two. To fulfill his survival instinct he has to do it because his benchmark is a mirage (wealth). He spins (not twist) words to impress & confuse people to sell himself more and more. He would never refer to Nisargadatta, Raman, Nagarjun & many more to avoid damage to his marketing potential. Being a doctor he should delve/explain the wonders like the flagellum and try to understand the power behind it. BEWARE OF HIM!

[@rajhegde5955]

Yes. Very much true. He is a dangerous ma and he is a disciple of Wendy Donegar who writes the whole shit about Sanathana Dharma. He has neither depth of religion, nor history nor any of the traditional systems other than just telling bull shit stories

[@captainna2133]

@@rajhegde5955 Have you read wendy doniger?? You should be happy she is atleast writing about hinduism. She is a scholar who read many books of and on hinduism. It is okay to disagree with me but I am saying that she is well learned and is not writing it carelessely .

[@divyangpandya6027]

Abe chutiye, there are number of books on Hinduism e.g. Vedas, Shrimad Bhagawat GEETA, Purans, Upanishad, Ramayan, Mahabharat etc

[@eswardora6563]

Akkal ke pedal....sale pura vdo dekh

[@sanna8300]

But Hinduism isn’t dependent on those books. Wipe all those books out, SANATAN dharma will still exist and be relevant.

[@sharanbasappa9365]

Why connecting ayiappa temple and a darga...isn't it wierd?

[@bishakhagoswami8353]

Don't misinterpret scriptures . People should avoid listening to you and better read the scripture.

[@sharanbasappa9365]

Connecting draupadi and muslim guard...what is he trying to do? Be careful...he seem to be dangerous

[@sharanbasappa9365]

Offlate..This guy has intention of creating hatredness about BJP/Modi subtly in his audience minds. Why would anyone lynch for saying rigveda is boring.... I was a great admirer of this guy.. He slowly losing it...

[@kushalshah4384]

He is good in manipulation 🤦 Don't listen to him Listen from veducation, Amarendra das amogh lila prabhu, ashutosh jha, shiksharthkam official to know sanatan dharam Jai shree ram 🙏

[@DoctorVerse1]

Lol😂

[@digitalmarketer9948]

How can I believe a Hindu mythology god as a true god?

[@125bbna8]

Same question but in different way how can i blv that only one god is true god not others gods and goddesses. Just because one book says!!!! How can i blv that 1 book is true not the others

[@digitalmarketer9948]

​@@125bbna8 Because you have to see is there any contradiction in those book or not? because god word can not be contradiction. another thing is two god can not stay co exist. If two god has some power than world will be destroyed. cause one god wants do another way others god want do another way. than they will start fighting. same thing we saw in Hindu mythology one god fighting with another god. sometime low power god defeated higher power god. For wining they have to do cheating or deceive others god. This is not true god attributes. it's one kind of harry pottor fiction. that god can not be true.

[@immigrantscholars118]

Let's consider one god scenario. Omnipresent, omniscient, omnipotent god. Can he make something that he can't lift? If he makes it than he is not omnipotent and if he can't than he is not omniscient. Just as multigod theory is flawed so is one god theory. Learn to appreciate idea. There is no theory that is full proof. It's the faith that matters.

[@digitalmarketer9948]

@@immigrantscholars118 For philosophy understand first you have to understand God attributes. At least we can say Hinduism mythology can not be true god.

[@immigrantscholars118]

@@digitalmarketer9948 that's a statement. not a valid argument. Plus I am not here to convert you. You can believe what ever you want. Atheists would say, there is no god and they are also living happily.

[@rajinderrana46]

Now Devdutt u are talking gud sense! Asto ma sat ga m ya, Nrityo ma amritam ga m ya!! Jai Bharatah!!!🇮🇳