SB19 is not AUTHENTIC they said...

[@CashualChuck]

Do you agree with them? 🤔 This project took serious time and effort to make. I won't earn money through ads because of COPYRIGHT. If you want to support the channel and want more quality content like this. PLEASE DONATE or BECOME A MEMBER. The highest tier of membership will get you CREDITED as an EXECUTIVE PRODUCER on EVERY VIDEO. Please donate: Gcash: 09294075315 Paypal: paypal.me/chucktudz Bank Transfer: Bank Name: BDO Account Name: Charles Edmond F. Tud-tud Account Number: 002112880884

[@martin4374]

No.

[@rayjejeremillo7911]

No I dnt agree with a MEDIOCRE group who say things that they dnt even fully understand.

[@xavierkrantz1098]

I don't agree with them. To me, SB19 really is trying to be SB19. This is exactly like when Blackpink is trying to be Blackpink or when Boy Story is just trying to be Boy Story. Honestly, these are the kind of people that would say 4Mix is authentic because they are lgbtq, which is blatantly wrong in every possible way, that is their gimmick, a terrible gimmick but it's their gimmick

[@leaj_mm6639]

@@xavierkrantz1098 true

[@leaj_mm6639]

Never agree but I respect their preference. Support lng tayo sa boys. Because SB19 is one of the AUTHENTIC artist I know. They struggle at first finding their identity. But now they're most potential and promising artist here.

[@teelov7670]

I'm from Nigeria,I discover sb19 last year and since then I've been a fan supporting them in ways I can. And no Matter what others say about them, I will always support them. Sb19 made me discover ppop and even other genres as well. So sb19 will always be in my heart forever. So haters should keep on hating while sb19 will keep on going higher and higher. A'tin for life.💙💙💙💙💙. Love five.

[@CashualChuck]

I appreciate you

[@SeendyLao]

Thank you for loving our boys! 🥰💙

[@melodydeleon5072]

And that’s why BAZINGA the haters 😂

[@lorenaracan7307]

Yes, indeed!☺💙👍

[@ranmaringo2428]

Gosh you would enjoy, appreciate, and love them more when you see their live performance. These boys are just awesome to watch. since not many artists can dance and sing at the same time!!

[@malikachantalreacts1538]

I’m shocked and disgusted!!!! Imagine SB19 who sells out concerts and this group who can’t even sell a record judging them!!! We can’t be this audacious in 2023

[@minorakoraj8809]

Please let me know what's their yt ,

[@rsbcryptotv9870]

Dahil sa ginawa nyo sa mga idolo ko sisipagan ko pa Lalo mag stream. Sa SB19 at A'tin 🇵🇭

[@ervinamisolasuarez3149]

Yung word na not AUTHENTIC bagay sa kanila! They just listened to the music sadly hindi nila naiintindihan yung lyrics. Juskoo! They're not even DAMN FAMOUS!

[@snzp9356]

At this point, it doesn't really matter what other artists/people say. SB19 is successful. The others are still struggling to get that recognition. The reactors in this video are in that position, still struggling to get even the slightest recognition. So their opinion, they can express, but their opinions won't get in the way of SB19 success. Their opinions count for nothing compared to the success of SB19.

[@ethanyamson1686]

true 100%

[@leaj_mm6639]

📢 it won't get on our way instead it energizes us to support the boys more. The boys don't need to prove that they're genuine about their craft they just have to continue what they are doing. It just like the song in bazinga, these things (I don't see them as haters) but more on they didn't connect with the music and preference is different and lack prior knowledge about the group, "Gasolina", it fires me to support SB19 even more and reach wider audience they deserve.

[@ethanyamson1686]

@@leaj_mm6639 agree kaps

[@snzp9356]

@@ethanyamson1686 I had the pleasure of seeing their concert in SFO, the venue is not huge, but that made it more personal and meaningful. I had to go see them before they blow up which means bigger venues, more crowd less personal interaction. Had a group photo-op after the show. Great LIVE vocal performers. Fantastic!!!

[@Ghiesweet_18]

To all REAL vocal coach and REAL dance choreographer who reacted to SB19 AND AMAZED TO THEM ON HOW HE DANCE AND SING SHOUT OUT to them.

[@mindofmyown2514]

who are they again? oh.. nobody. so next vid pls.🤣

[@jo-anne.j.s.8888]

I'd rather watch Waleska and Efra... They have BETTER and WIDER UNDERSTANDING about music in general... They DISSECT and EXPLAIN song/music/vocals in a very INFORMATIVE and INTELLIGENT WAY/MANNER...

[@miladivinagracia9572]

Yes I agree with you Waleska and Efra is smart when they react to Filipino Artist they explained in details and I like how they react to SB19

[@ladyingrid8842]

True Waleska are better but this vlogger are trying to downside ppop as they still want kpop haha

[@martin4374]

Omg I love them. They're very articulate. I like their street interviews too.

[@CashualChuck]

I'm a fan of them and they're one of the reasons why I became a reactor in the first place. I watch their stuff to this day.

[@rhonzcervantes4808]

Waleska and Efra are way better by a mile. Real talk.

[@becky7319]

For a group who wrote their own songs, does their own choreography, hands on in producing and directing their own music video.. "Inauthentic" is quite contradicting! 😂 Keep on soaring MAHALIMA 💙💙💙

[@pamilyajohnson3472]

Yeah!! Louder!!

[@turquoisemoon3654]

I know this sounds extreme- but when the woman in the video said "I'm actually getting a very Stray Kids feeling on this, right off the bat" I felt that the comments sounded as absurd, ridiculous, and childish as saying that every time Mariah Carey belts out a song "I get a very Whitney Houston feeling on this." Truth be told, this was how the rivalry between the two artists started until the comparison became so cliche it just died a natural death. Now, let's be honest. Maybe we felt tempted to say things like these before... so we should know what OTHERS really have in mind when they say such things. But the words INAUTHENTIC and FAKE are just INSENSITIVE when these are not just ordinary listeners but artists saying it- artists who are very much aware that SB19 is an all-Filipino group. Are they expecting Filipinos to dance and sing like aliens to be "authentic" enough? And yet when they hear something different and unexpected, they think it's hilarious just like the way SB19 pronounces their words. Maybe they don't care about the slightest possibility that Philippine English can be just as different and "authentic" as Australian, Jamaican, Indian, Korean, or Thai English. There are as many Englishes as there are native and non-native speakers using the language as their first, second, or third language. Then there's another comment that SB19 is "trying so hard" to come out as "hard," but they're "not hard." That, my folks, is downright BS. Do we need big biceps and huge abs to come out as "hard" to you, guys? May I infer what "authentic" means from our reactors' own videos and music? For one, I noticed that their gloves and black net stockings look as "authentic" as costumes worn by Black Canary and most of our DC Marvel superheroes. Their rap is so "authentic" too, gosh. It's the first time I've heard so many "oh baby" lines in a song. And that bathtub- yeah... it's the first time a bathtub was EVER used in a music video- that's for sure. ^_^ I'm sure these lines and props have DEEPER meanings than the lyrics and props used in "What" and "Alab." Yeah, right. Who cares about Pablo fusing all those brilliant PUNS (like "What" for "watawat" and MAPA for "ma" and "pa" or the map) to make SB19 songs thematic? Let's just sing "oh baby." ^_^ As for their other "condescending" comments like "hey I tried to get into it, but I just can't" and "oohhh, how cute" are no different from what immature fans from rival camps would say if they already have a bias, are checking out a group in the same music category/genre that they know they won't like anyway because they already have a bias- but want to come across as honest, objective, and "nice." But here's what's FUNNY- If they're using K-pop and other boy bands as a standard for P-pop then they're like kids saying they don't like bananas because apples taste better. Bananas can't be apples- and it's not the banana's fault. If bananas make them cringe because it's not their kind of fruit- then even the BEST banana would be a huge disappointment to them Then I remembered- even Madonna didn't like Lady Gaga very much. Kanye West made fun of Taylor Swift. A lot of artists didn't like what their fellow artists were doing- but only Elton John was objective enough to say he didn't like Madonna because you can't be an artist if you can't sing live or if you just lip sync when the audience deserves better. Let's just admit it, folks- entertainment is subjective and personal. No matter how popular some other idol group is, if it's not to your liking, then no one can force you to like it. But the catch is- entertainment preferences aren't like gadget preferences. A bad review of a product is justified if the intention is to warn customers of defects or inefficiency in the product and to make sure they get their money's worth. In music it's just TASTE that differentiates one product/creation from the rest- so a BAD review MAKES SENSE only if there's a STANDARD of QUALITY that's performance-based, which must be maintained- regardless of the subjective appeal of the music/pop idol group (e.g. BlackPink audiences complaining about the "idols" making a lot of mistakes during concerts when the ticket costs $699). But being turned-off by Ken because you feel like he's a poor imitation of a Stray Kid member whose "vibe" seems to be your personal standard is just- UNFAIR. That's like saying "Oh, god, Dreamworks- stop putting songs in your animation, it's so Disney." It's like asking Morisette to stop belting out songs because she'll never reach Dimash's high notes (that comparison is not just absurd but cruel). Looking at the brightER side of things- most artists who have been unfairly compared to big names during the start of their career usually end up outdoing their rivals. Let's just hope SB19 gets vindicated as always. Again, sorry for the long comment- and more power to you, CasualChuck~~😇😇😇

[@CashualChuck]

Enjoyed reading every word in this comment lol.

[@ethanyamson1686]

hoi kaps ang haba namn 😅😅😅😅

[@jupiterpluto3959]

Very well said

[@joemiris5355]

NOSEBLEED AKO😂🤣

[@leaj_mm6639]

📢📢📢 good input there

[@nbacct22]

I just don't think a group who heavily relies on post-production technology to make music can criticize a group about their authenticity when they have zero knowledge about them. How can you criticize a group that composes their own songs, choreograph their dance moves, produce and conceptualize their own MVs and call them inauthentic?

[@CashualChuck]

Exactly my point. Their words hold no weight

[@Cassie-tj8jp]

As English speakers, RiVerse got lost in translation 🤣

[@tibeklucio3418]

Those who criticized have no sense .

[@bmona7550]

I'm American and all I can say is that racism and bigotry is still a huge reason. You think most Americans really respect or understand kpop? Nah. Most of the time kpop gets noticed here because of visuals and because they fit that stereotype of what an attractive Asian "should be". More western less Asian. It is what it is. Deep down these artists in particular are insecure and actually feel threatened by artists elsewhere that challenge western music/popularity. You see these feelings the further you go deep South. Also it has to do with the fact most Americans all think Asia is just East Asia and f*cking Bali. Anyone remotely resembling an East Asian person is automatically either Chinese, Japanese or Korean. If they aren't they feel surprised and just think they are all the same

[@marilyncanoy9388]

Dudeeee!!! You're head on, like.... Tamaan sila duhhh hahaha...

[@joemiris5355]

DONT EVER COMPARE SB19 TO KPOP INTIENDES?!!!!! coz SB19 can sing LIVE....no AUTOTUNE NO LIP SYNC...

[@CozyGameJunkie]

ramdam ko ang galit.kakampi mo ako.ahaha

[@3lle1112]

always choose to be kind pero kung authentic lang ang usapan amplastic nila sa totoo lang🤪

[@raczsb1927]

matagal ng ayaw nila sa ppop lalo na sa esbi

[@ellennaparan1362]

Bhe I feel you gigil nila ako 😢 😅

[@josellegatchalian253]

That true !! Those 4 vlogler Stuggle e For Thier success until now. Just look at Thier music video it's sucks ! I tell you,,. MayayaBANG YAN they are not professional.singer Para mag criticism! INGIT Huh! IDoL KASI NILA KPOP Kya kahit Hindi mo maintindihan kinakanta ok sa kanila. ..OK YUNG GINAWA MO CHUCK ! SANA POST Mo Yan sa vog Nila pero wag kng mag subscribe! para m Kita Nila Yung video Nila Kung gaano ka pangit! Huh! Hindi Kasi Nila Kya mag LIVE PERFORMANCE TULAD NG SB19 Kya putok butchi Nila Bigla talaga bulusok pataas Ng sb19 becouse of Thier music and humble personality Hindi Nila Kya Yun!

[@tiTABAba792]

Waleska and Efra truly appreciate Filipino talent ❤️

[@jeizschey]

I love those two. They're technical and appreciates art at the same time, they know what they're saying. Unlike some uhm..people. They can't relate to the vibe of Bazinga because the song is for them.

[@altonamano6871]

I love them, they truly respect filipino talent

[@mathewolpindo3329]

my personal favorite is Reactions by Kelly, she is a very good reactor. She is very good at pointing/appreciating even the smallest of details.

[@thinkinginsideout4053]

at this point wale and efra (son of janno gibbs) are filipino step siblings

[@mitchyhanjoy]

I am not a YT Reactor but it is always a rule of thumb na everytime you comment to someone especially to someone else talent, hardwork and craft at least magresearch muna dapat if ano meaning Ng finished product kahit ayaw man nila Yung mismong gumawa.. And that was their biggest mistake Kasi they themselves are group of artist at alam nila how hard it is to be in that position.. Tlgang literal na reaction ginawa mata at bunganga lang gamit and not commenting which requires logical thinking 💪💙

[@leaj_mm6639]

True po yan, background knowledge is important lalong lalo na hindi American or english speaker ang pinanonood.

[@liezellaurente1976]

I agree with you.

[@millimilli9679]

✅✅✅

[@melrosepark4463]

Those 4 were just formed to cater to the woke ideology. Was not talent or even making money.

[@rlamata86]

Hi Chuck! About a year ago, I made a very long comment on their reaction to the boys' What's MV because I felt the need to. Their reactions were very annoying and for a silent viewer who barely engages on the comment section, I had to air out my thought. I was just a new fan back then but I had this urge to defend our boys because this bunch right here seems to have big opinions on artists when they can't even break the glass ceiling of the music industry as artist themselves. That comment of mine caught A'tin's attention and posted it on Twitter and backed my comment because they have felt it too. I had to say something, just like what you are doing now. Personally, I don't subscribe to them anymore after that long comment. Waste of my time and view tbh.

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you for supporting SB19 brother

[@tykiamda]

Dont subscribe them even views and commenting their reaction that four white block American Bully group,even themselves they are not good who is that group i even not know them.

[@lorenaracan7307]

Yes, ignore them that's the best thing that we could do.☺💙👍

[@tibeklucio3418]

Agree

[@rowenanardo343]

Oh yes naalala ko name nyo. And 100% agree ako. In every comment section tlgang pinapatamaan ko ang mga Craby bashers/ haters. Na ha highblood ako lalo na sa mga kapwa Pinoy na halos magpatirapa sa pag iidolo sa mga banyaga at nangmamaliit sa kapwa Pinoy. Ano kaya ang magiging itsura ni Gat. JOSE RIZAL at ni Supremo ANDRES BONIFACIO pag nakitang ganito ang asal ng ibang Pinoy ngayon. Hindi na nga invaded physically pero mentally. Hay naku!

[@eagleatin7640]

Your right! Lets unite A'TIN and soaring higher heights for SB19. Let it be what others will said. Focus to our goals for SB19 to we known around the world and spread their great music!

[@iceiz0543]

Your last sentences in these videos really gives me goosebumps! Very inspiring words 👏

[@renatodelavega3015]

I'm not an Atin, but I followed SB19 since 2018 until now. Even now I'm still not an Atin. I really like SB19 I always watched on KZbin about their music, interviews,concerts. As a Filipino I support them because of the pride they gave to our country, we don't need to pull them down. Thank you casualchuck for defending them. I am very proud of SB19.

[@Mimi-qe1tj]

These OLD guys don't know the NEW generation.

[@breal6885]

THAT’S THE EASON WHY “SB19” IS ON THE BILLBOARD CHART NOT THEM!!!!!

[@donnaserrano8215]

Like Straykids but their music and style is so different with SB19. Love both groups, got to know them both just during the pandemic and there's no comparison with KPop. SB19 may have started by a korean entertainment company in PH but their overall musicality is definitely promoting the Filipino culture and talent. Love SB19 songs!!!

[@macicedog]

Just ignore them, no views when they react to SB19, not canceling them.. just ignoring them.. Leave them to their own opinions.. We just rise up..

[@fredengaymusic7242]

Quality content. Parang documetary. Not only this vid but pati yung ibang vids mo sir. Galing.

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you brother.

[@seurn7801]

LMFAO, I literally wheezed when they said Ken's part was INAUTHENTIC. PLEASE. ALMOST ALL FILIPINO RAP SONGS HAS THAT FLOW. Deep voice, calm beat, menacing aura (hint; Al James). Filo rappers have been doing that way before Stray kids got popular. ALSO, and it's MUSIC. It's bound to sound the same. That's like saying Lady gaga is inauthentic because she's so much like Madonna.

[@erusenp6i640]

ikr! pero may nauna pa kay al james dagdag mo pa yung rapping na parang nakanta tagal na din nun dito kelan lang nauso sa kpop

[@marydiosca576]

Ken BULAN is semi-metal yun. Hahaha What are they talking na inauthentic. Mga bobo. Mas magaling pa ako kumanta sa mga tabatsing na yun.

[@bmona7550]

Actally the singing while rapping thing is largely a OPM thing. Most rappers in other countries don't do that (except American old school rappers from like the 80s-90s). Filipino rappers do that singing melody the most to this day and it evolved. Kpop does that too but it's not common. It's only known or thought to be uniquely kpop because kpop is more popular.

[@whitepouch0904]

That kind of rapping tbh I heard from Gdragon 10yrs ago

[@erusenp6i640]

@@whitepouch0904 yan ayaw ko sa mga kpop fan e kaya ako na totoxican sa inyo dinudungisan nyo pangalan ng mga idols nyo lol sub-genre ng phonk song ang ginawa ni ken dyan na sub-genre ng Memphis rap noong 1990's na nag sanga-sanga na sa underground kaya anong 2010 pinagsasabi mo

[@aileenm9213]

I was initially upset about this but then I thought, I needed to step back and consider other people's point of view without my emotions clouding my opinion. I had to ask myself this, "What matters most to me now?" I love to listen to music. I have a wide range of music styles/genres that I like but I'm quite picky when it comes to my personal list of songs that I really love. I am my own award giving body when it comes to songs that will make it to my playlist. Currently, most SB19 songs if not all are in my playlist. Why? It's because I gravitate towards music or songs that have more substance, songs that speaks to me in a meaningful way, songs that I feel are intellectually conceptualized with a lot of time and effort put into it, music that elevates, inspires and touch people's lives. I may consider the melody, beat or style (genre) but I go beyond that. I also look up to artists that not only have the talent and skills but have the right attitude and character that I can admire and look up to. And so, SB19 versus Riverse? No doubt. SB19 wins.

[@larahpark9631]

same. :))

[@thirdworldnurse]

Mga kapwa A’TIN, we know that our Mahalima are not trying to be the next BTS, Stray Kids or any other Kpop group we could think of. Our boys are carving their own paths and let us light their paths with love, tolerance and kindness. Yaan niyo na si rIVerse. Comparisons are always unfair. While it is not inherently bad, one of the parties will always end up inferior against an individual’s personal biases. After watching this video, I had to pause and ask myself (maybe you can ask yourself these questions too): - What was my initial reaction when I saw SB19’s viral video? - How did I feel about SB19 and their music? - Did I compare them to a Kpop group? - Up to this point in time, am I constantly comparing them to any or my fave Kpop group? - What does SB19 mean to me? - What do I like about SB19?

[@mitch4348]

Nice one Sir CasualChuck... Lahat ng videos mo pinapanood ko at palaging thumbs up s akin... The best k talaga.. thank you for making videos about SB19.....

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you po

[@danschronicles]

We just can't really please everyone because each will have differences in our tastes in music. If BTS, currently at the pedestal of global superstardom, had and still has its own share of critics, SB19 will definitely not be an exception. And these critics will never be the last ones also. Alas, these critics/bashers can all say what they want to say but as Ken will always remind us, "SUCCESS IS THE BIGGEST REVENGE". No amount of criticism will ever outweigh their achievements and that's the only thing that matters. Whether these critics will change their take on SB19 after all the accomplishments, it's their call, not ours. Love your videos, Chuck! That one is non-debatable, for sure! 😇😊

[@pocketofpoetry297]

Nice! Im glad kuya cashualchuck is here to open our eyes🤘.

[@youandme439]

it's hard to please people who doesnt want to be. lol. itong apat na ito kala mo gagaling nila. hahaha I LOVE SB19💙💙💙

[@aizarizalinaaguete714]

Hahaha😂 for me sb19 is very GOOD.

[@vanetmae]

Sinabi mo pa! Watching the clips Chuck included here, I can give them the same emojis to what they rate SB19. Deym, they are trying hard and boring. They have good voices yes but they don't have energy when dancing just how I like from SB19 and other PPop groups.

[@notoprochinatraitors]

not an Atin pero d ko nga kilala riverse n to.. akala mo nman sobrang sikat ni billboard nominations wala.. sb19 ilang beses nag top 1 s billboard ung bazinga.. tapos sila lng mang o okray??? h 🙄😅😅😅 sobrang feelers ah 🙄🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jacquejuanico1231]

Jusko ang Music video nila🤣😅 ayaw ko nlng magtalk🤣🤣🤣

[@keng223]

We appreciate you, Chuck. As always, you're here to support and defend SB19. ❤️

[@CashualChuck]

Always

[@rsbcryptotv9870]

Ok lang naman sakin kung hindi nila trip Ang SB19. Hello almost 8 Billion na Ang tao sa mundo its means many people can appreciate and support their talents.

[@annademesa]

Kaya Nga.. In a nice way naman Sana.. Ung di nkakaoffend.. Saka y nmn Ung ibang reactor na din nila para sakanila Ung songs pero accepted nmn kasi well explained sila

[@leaj_mm6639]

We cannot please everyone but the problem with this rv, they're Closeminded, meron n clang prng nasa utak nla na negative. And to speak na PPOP group ang pinag uusapan they still associate it w/ kpop. I just think they should have atleast research a little like how other rv do, they could have do better sa rv nla.

[@keikurono9354]

Chuck salamat. Iba ka talaga. I'll always support your channel.

[@ayahkathrina]

I dont agree with them but they have their owns opinions and we have to respect that. Kung iba yung tingin nila so be it. I didnt see any disrespect sa mga sinabi nila. They are just trying to speak their minds, so wag masyado sensitive a'tin. Dont spread hate just because magkakaiba tayo ng gusto and opinyon. Again choose to be kind.

[@ethanyamson1686]

noted kaps

[@琴子-k08]

new subscriber here... i used to react to their reacts to Filipino like mori and kz... didn't know they suck with autobtone

[@yosei2386]

I am glad you made a video about these clowns as I remember very well how they reacted very badly the first time to SB19 which made me actually unsubscribed to them. These 4 reactors I think is a group who performs (very trying hard at it), sorry but not sorry to say that, and yeah, I mentioned they are performers and guess what? these 4 are a nobody Haha, the nerve how these clowns commented against the boys as if they know the hardships and challenges SB19 went through, oh well SB19 happens to be KINGS reaping popularity left and right and soon to become a global icon, so there!

[@melrosepark4463]

Those 4 doesn’t have any talents. The two fat women and the two pedo badings are groups to satisfy the Appetite of woke culture. That’s it.

[@mchlurn]

Kudos Chuck, let's protect our MAHALIMA at all cost! Bazingaaa!

[@ojnab85]

The commentary about the overenunciation is something that can be made more gracefully. We like to enunciate every syllable, it's just something we do in Philippine English. We don't do a lot of silent letters. SB19 touched on this in the Front Row interview. I've seen other reactors mention (not necessarily with SB19 but other groups, too) that the phrasing in English sometimes sounds awkward to them but in a way that sounds like they understand that's their issue, not a problem with the group. Because they're used to hearing English one way, so it stands out. So they prefer hearing the Tagalog or other Filipino language parts of the song. But they do it in a way that shows understanding that it is a function of the group being authentic. It's the sound of Filipinos speaking English. It's how we cut up syllables, it's where we put emphasis and pauses. Sometimes we codeswitch to something more "American" sometimes we don't, neither is inauthentic. It's something Filipinos do without trying to be something they're not. The accents aren't put on and everyone secretly sounds like Jo Koy's impression of his mom, it's just that's how we speak. I admit I've sometimes personally listened to some groups lines in English and my thought is "That sounded very Filipino." But as a Filipino, the observation isn't meant to mean I think it is therefore bad. I think the problem for me with that particular comment is that it was dangerously close to being culturally insensitive out of being uninformed, that it was almost like being told sounding like that, the way many Filipinos would sound normally in English, is incorrect when it isn't. It is harmful because we already do that to ourselves, we don't need others to reinforce that. I think it's good that SB19, BGYO, 1st.One, Alamat, etc don't really try to "sound American" when they do English, and when it seems like they do it's in the service of the song like some of - as an example - Justin's lines in Live it Up. Otherwise, Justin just has his authentic Filipino accent. They somehow homed in on the accent - one of the things that demonstrates they're being themselves - as an example of why it sounded inauthentic.

[@mrscitrine3592]

Do this people ever complain about English enunciation etc by other foreign artists ?

[@thylabyrinth3998]

@@mrscitrine3592 Exactly my thought. I don't think I've ever heard them say anything or criticize about someone's way of speaking english when it comes to other Asian artists. Why just SB19? 🤔🤔🤔

[@JRD888]

💯 I agree.. 😎💙

[@shasong4970]

@@mrscitrine3592 exactly my thought too....they reacted to a lot of k...but 😩😩😩 If they doesnt like sb19 from the very first time they react they must not do another reaction period thats it..

[@ujanemorales3863]

@@thylabyrinth3998 because we are Pilipino and in some way we are simply unique! 😊

[@ujanemorales3863]

Honestly, I’m that person who’s hard to get when it comes to music. They were my inspiration in life, they taught me not to give through their music. They brought joy every morning when I wake up listening To the music buzzing my ears and motivate me to focus more on positive side. That’s all that matter to me. Who cares what other people say! Let’s give them a challenge of how much language they can speak, like jokoy’s mom said.

[@carmenfajardo2876]

so true ,, no one can please everyone,,, me as A'tin, such negative opinion doesn't matter at all...the ending message is always worth noting... "those who can see the invisible, usually can do the impossible"..commendable as always Chuck

[@longhairfen]

They seemed so disappointed they didn't exactly fit the Kpop mold. They won't. Ever. Why? They're Filipinos.

[@ethanyamson1686]

haha natawa pa kaya ako sa kanila kasi di nila alam na sinampal na sila ng kanta BAZINGA 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@my.vonnelea]

I used to watch their rvs but ever since they first reacted to SB19, I know right away that they won't appreciate SB19's artistry so I never watch their videos anymore. We only need people who can truly recognize SB19's talents and good personalities. Thanks to this video kuya Chuck, I was able to hear what they said without clicking their rvs.

[@smulemaster]

Is it legal for me to say that their music and MV is inauthentic and a copycat of Lizzo, Nikki Minaj and other western music? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@martin4374]

🔉🔊📢

[@CashualChuck]

lol

[@smulemaster]

@@CashualChuck HAHAHAH ISN'T IT?

[@judithmirafuentes3599]

Korekkkkkk,ang beauty nila ang aunthentic

[@leaj_mm6639]

Haha bakit natawa ako dito, sorry

[@Panda18carat]

"What we bring to the table is the journey or the experience of the Filipinos. 🇵🇭 Every time we try to create or write our music, it's always about our journey, our experiences in life. That's what makes P-Pop highly authentic." - PABLO

[@wall-e9962]

It’s OPM, not Just P-Pop

[@Eyeleaf]

Copy paste mo to kaps sa lahat ng RV nila ng SB19 hahahaha

[@prettyu2657]

hi jeonghan

[@jeddelariva]

Definitely

[@gurLems]

I used to watch their "video reactions" and there are Filipino artists that they truly applauded and praised. They even watched KZ' Tandingan's concert, can't remember if, in Canada or US, they even interacted with the Filipino concertgoers well. I guess they are just being honest about how they feel about SB19. As a follower of SB19, of course, we might feel a bit off with what they commented, but as a life rule, you cannot please everyone. Let's not feel bad about it and not lose the momentum of supporting SB19. For sure our mahalima is doing their BEST to be the BEST of who they are and true to their craft and artistry. Thanks, CashualChuck for creating this video. Always KUDOS to your craft!

[@mupamtv486]

2 Corinthians 11:12-15 . Even Satan masquerades as an angel of light...so as his servants. Riverse propagate lustfulness while sb19 is spreading inspirational/religious songs. Good vs. evil.

[@ojnab85]

Yeah, I think we should all remember what Pinuno says and "remember to choose to be kind" before letting our emotions get the better of us in our comments.

[@gurLems]

@@ojnab85 True, I truly believe that "A'tin" are kind people and a respectful community. At the end of it all, our love and admiration for #SB19 remain. Keep soaring high #SB19!

[@lorrainegeraldino8859]

They just gaining views when reacting like that. Kc matitrigger mga Atin. Mas di nga sila authentic kc the way they sing may gingaya sila. The more the bashing the more they got what they want. VIEWS AND COMMENT. MINDSET BA mindset guyss. Sila lng kikita kpag pinatulan ng Atin reaction video nila

[@rosaaballe9457]

Pero as I observ them ginamit nga nila sa title nila puro sb19 tapos nd nman sb19 topic ,ginamit lang una,the FF.ndi nman pero nkalagay prin sb19 sa yt title nila akala ko ng atin,na ngolekta ng vews,so lahat ng Atin na nak subscribe ,,paki UNSUBSCRIBE lang nman ng ndinna.sila dumaan sa timeline

[@mt.4445]

We cannot convince everyone to like SB19. But SB19 can fill their concert venues with supportive fans who actually like their music and that's what matter.

[@SB19fans_love]

Tama kung ayaw wag ipilit , ang mahalaga,andito tayong A'TIN to support SB19 and we know them more at tiwala tayo sa galing at talento ng mga,batang ito..

[@rinesse8292]

I have a lot to say but as a fan of both, with the amount of times I listened to their music, not once did I ever feel like they're similar. And accents, gosh, not everyone needs to conform to a single specific way of english speaking. But still I respect if they don't like sb19 as this is really subjective. Be the better person. Simply stop the requests since they clearly have made their stand already. If they still make a video about sb19, don't engage. Don't torture yourselves. Sb19 is getting bigger and more successful in their career, let's focus on them and their growth. Bazinga to the haters and slmt to all the supporters

[@allit8472]

Hopefully no one else requests that they react to SB19 again. Like you said, they've already formed an unfavorable opinion of the boys. Everyone is not going to love SB19 and that's fine.

[@lolaganda5100]

Ha ha🤣 dobt mind them. They don't know what their saying. Besides its a reflection of themselves who are unauthentic and lousy singer themselves. They're just jealous 😡😡😡

[@PAGTATAGera]

I literally watched all of their reactions to SB19 and i think they were all engaged to K-pop so much. They might be a superfan of K-pop that they literally compare everything about K-pop quite annoying but their consistency of rejecting SB19 is pretty much noticeable they might belong to a group of fans supporting K-pop.

[@serenity4moi921]

I agree! All they did was compare and forgot to understand what the P-pop culture is all about.😥

[@matriksist]

Pinoys should stop messaging request to foreign vloggers to review our artists, they are only making money out of the views and if pinoys kept on sending their request those baffoons will never stop criticizing because they themselves are insecure, from their looks and not so good talent. TBH some of those foreign vloggers are not even sincere, they're only after the views and contents.

[@kjshizniz9197]

I think not all kpop, they don't like seventeen songs at all

[@valeriedizon3897]

Syempre, naging popular na ang kpop pati k drama. Ganun talaga. Ang ppop kasi ay nagsisimula pa lamang. Medyo late na.

[@warriorprincess6926]

prejudices. okay lang. they can live their lives with that all they want and earn their keep in the end.

[@judithmirafuentes3599]

All i can say is that BAZINGGA!!!!!!!!!!! Thnk you haters and GOD BLESS SANA MAGANDA ANG TULOG NYO !PPOP LANG SAKALAM, thnks CHUCK and more power GOD BLESS US ALL

[@markpenaflor6311]

All I can say is that nothing they have said to SB19 is significant. Our boys are already at the top of their game; they have unquestionably established themselves on the music industry not just here on the Philippines but now even GLOBAL, and I don't believe that negative comments would hinder their career now. The truth of the matter is that they cannot come close to the achievements SB19 has already achieved and will still achieve in the future, no matter how loudly they protest.

[@stanberry4000]

True. It can only be significant if, let's say, Mariah gave this commentary, or David Foster, or Sir Elton John. But no. We just can't be reactive to every insignificant comments we hear about our boys. It's tiring you know. Hahaha 😄

[@user-fv5or3yg4v]

Well, naniniwala rin ang Mahalima na " Success is the best revenge." Sabi nga rin ni Ken na makakain rin nila yong mga pinagsasabi ng bashers nila so I think mas magandang focus muna tayo sa positive side kase if mahawaan pa tayo ng negative then Mahalima won't be happy for that. Naging patient yong lima despite all the bashers kahit galing sa kapwa pinoy kasi naniniwala sila na someday kikilalanin rin sila at irerespito so dapat tayo rin A'tin we have to be patient and have faith nalang sa mahalima. I believe na someday they'll conquer the world 💙 Ang mahalaga we don't fail to show our love to them in away na di natin sila masasaktan 😊

[@chanpodz9696]

Thank you kaps 💙

[@CashualChuck]

No problem 😊

[@piamarieramos6924]

Got hooked with SB 19. Fully supporting SB 19 now. Love them. They are authentic, unique, multi talented and hard working. They create and compose their own song and lyrics, choreograph their dances, Josh as creative director too. You cannot get more authentic than that. Continous streaming of all their songs in all music and social media channels. Bought all their group and solo songs. Happiness with SB19’s authenticity.

[@christinabautista4328]

Nakakagigil hahahaha 😂 pero sige lang Ang siyang binababa ay tinataas Fighting Sb19 💙 more blessing god bless 🙏🙏💙 and ATIN MAHALIMA 💙💙💙💙💙

[@manorsyrel8242]

For me as a fan of Sb19, I don't care what people say about them what I love for Sb19 is their songs & humbleness. My phone ringtone is Love goes. Don't mind the negative mindset just turn it into motivation.

[@Mspromises]

I agree. .love the part where you said "don't care what people say"

[@glendareserva9930]

Watching this back made me think that this group now should be ashamed of themselves

[@lyblank]

They haven’t even posted anything for awhile now lol

[@yukufuna5895]

I am triggered honestly! All I have to say, SB19 is authentic in every sense of the word with how they carry themselves in front of their fans and in their music. SB19 who went through different trials and hardships to get to where they are now and is blessed with recognition and awards. By the way Cashual Chuck, who in the world are these reactors? I never even knew they ever existed!

[@AGeezyTV100]

A Canadian music group called rIVerse.

[@CashualChuck]

I literally just found them last night

[@yukufuna5895]

@Canadian Couple Eh! 🇨🇦 - I agree to this.

[@yukufuna5895]

@@CashualChuck - My take is, SB19 do not deserve the comments these (who ever they are) are giving the boys. People say everyone is entitled to their own opinion, well I say to those four clowns to keep their opinions to themselves because SB19 don't need them, there that is my opinion! And thank you CashualChuck for all your nice video reactions to the KINGS!

[@glymbirthyting8030]

@@CashualChuck thats savage bruh 😂😂😂 but love that 🤭

[@abigailmaglaqui9631]

😂😂😂 No matter what they say, SB19 is SB19.Extremely talented, successful and yet humbled.and that is just one of their Aces, by not letting their fame, success & achievements eat their system..

[@gladysoshii679]

I watched their RV before but now they are just sad to watch. They are never heard musicians so let me borrow Josh's line "look at you, look at you!"

[@bunnykissme]

I'm gonna check it if I was subscribed to their channel so I can unsubscribe.. lol

[@amylopezsalvador1180]

@@bunnykissme yes please what's the channel🤣🤣🤣who are they ewww daaa

[@maidaraman7726]

Exactly! 😁 Mga KSP lang mga yarn 😂 sino ba mga 'to? And let me borrow one of BTS songs, Soooo Whaaat!!!! Since they too shared ample of haters before they became big. 💜💙

[@Just2Curious]

If I can try to understand where they are coming from... A lot of A'TINs became fans of SB19 on an emotional level, because we understand the lyrics, what they want to convey, and their emotional journey to get to where they're at today. But in the sense of just casually listening to one of their songs for the first time even without understanding what the song is about, it may not be something you'd bop to, and say, "let me add this to my playlist". Millennials and Zoomers prefer to listen to beats, rhythm, bops, groove, something they can bob their heads to, rather than what the message of the song is or how good the vocals are. Even though many k-pop songs are mostly auto-tuned and have meaningless lyrics and onomatopoeic words like "boom boom, bang bang"; listeners don't seem to care. This is why so many people, even many filipinos, like k-pop because it's easy to bop to. To be honest, some of SB19 songs are rhythmically confusing for me because of the many rhythmical changes in one song, like in What? and even Bazinga. But anyway, these reactors are already biased and closed-minded. They think k-pop is the the standard, yet SB19 can't be k-pop because it would be "inauthentic". So I'm so confused because to me, SB19 does NOT sound k-pop at all whatsoever. If they did, then shouldn't they like them? I don't get it. But you know they are already biased against SB19 and so they just say whatever crap that comes out of their mind. Perhaps if they understand the lyrics, the message, the SB19 journey, maybe they would like them, even just a little bit, maybe.

[@shanemin1791]

This made me so irritated but I agree, not everyone will like our MAHALIMA 💙 so let's treasure those who do. In the meantime, let's just continue to love and support them until all those haters envy them for reaching the top. Thank You for this video 💙💠

[@vanetmae]

They should refrain from reacting when requested. They just sound toxic.

[@rosaaan]

@@vanetmae More like people should refrain from requesting for them to react to SB19.

[@therandomlog2010]

Nice job Sir! , great content.. I like it.

[@CashualChuck]

Much appreciated!

[@mupamtv486]

Of course, they will hate sb19 simply because they propagate lustfulness and sb19 songs are inspirational some are religious like MAPA and Bazinga. It's like darkness versus righteousness.

[@ROUTE_888]

Ay talaga love this comment ❤

[@user-fv5or3yg4v]

You got the point haha

[@marilynsmith9955]

All I can say I'm not a fan of their music kung and man yong mga mga kanta nila at ayokong alamin. Disgusting yuk. Eto laang ano ba talaga mayroon ang mahalima kasi all they songs nasa playlist ko. Kahit yong cover song nila add din sa playlist ko, yon nga lang ibang artist yon kumakanta kahit nga yong christmas song nila kahit hindi pasko pinapakingan ko eh. Lahat ng advert songs nila nasa playlist ko din, napabili tuloy ako ng acer dito. Hindi ito ang pinapakinggan kong song before, pero napalitan ng sb 19 songs. Ano ba talaga meron ang sb 19. Wala akong twitter account pero ngayon meron na para maka boto sa kanila. Kapag nasa computer shop ako inilalagay ko yong photos nila sa screen para makita ng ibang costumer. Pero hindi lahat ng nakadisplay kasi and dami kaya non. Pero sa iphone ko ginagawa kasi yon yong popular maraming tumitingin na costumer. The seller dont care kung ano yong pinaggagawa ko. Kunwari trying the product but i put sb 19 sa screen.

[@melrosepark4463]

Nadali mo. They cater to woke culture. The culture of Lust fullness, craziness and hypocrisy.

[@berryisveryy]

Ironic how they use the word "unauthentic" but they are likeeee HAHAHAHAHAH buset huwag na nga lang

[@nuevalising9139]

if i have to pay for the tickets just to let them see SB19 concert, I will... i wanna see them BAZINGAfied, hehe

[@DarkR0ze]

it's just not their preference so save the money for future concerts

[@jdumlao-raval4840]

BAM!!! The last few sentences says it all💯. “We don’t have to be worried, upset or bitter at all…..Because those who CAN see the INVISIBLE…tend to be SOMEONE who can do the IMPOSSIBLE!!! Great content again Chuck!!!! We 💙 U #SB19

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you

[@LinTVx]

They're reacting without any support on their words ... They don't exactly know what they're talking about

[@atin8584]

They of bunch of bi…es talking rubbish

[@JeanroseASolen]

SB19 is not fake we love SB19 have own style and original song❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@rosemariejimenez8727]

Let them...what's important our boys hits the billboard..😂😂

[@noreenmayb.gelito1857]

Yeeees, Very-well said!! Not everyone will like them abd their music. Lets continue to support SB19 and promote Filipino Music.

[@Gigi_Waechter]

They never even see them perform live!!! 😂

[@eee7002]

You can't please everybody. The most important is what the majority says. What they say does NOT affect me or my opinion about SB19. No point being defensive, not worth it. Let the numbers speak for themselves.

[@sandz116]

You can't please everyone. And that's ok. No big label backing from the beginning, no funds, no previous ppop groups paving the way, no kdrama influence to soften it, just basically trailblazing all by themselves (with unbelievable support from fans), what an achievement. They have improved so much and they know there is much more to improve on - but now with more budget :) I'm still on a high from their NY concert and that was 3 weeks ago!

[@jgmgotera8865]

I am waiting for the day that they too would ride the coat tails of SB19’s fame in the future, that would be the best clapback 😅😂 I’m waiting for karma to do her thing.

[@ruelcostina9187]

Thank you for sharing. Now we know how some strongly opinionated persons look at SB19. I am a senior citizen. Never really listened to SB19 before. Even heard that they were at the Billboard Charts for 7 weeks, but never listened to them as I thought that they were just trying to follow popular Kpop styles. But when I heard their song Mapa -- I knew from their lyrics that these are serious artists, serious about their craft. Why, they were able to move me. I was able to catch their emotions from the way they wrote the song and how they executed the song to convey their sentiments. From then on, I got hooked. SB19 carries with them Filipino values and upbringing and they display these in their craft. These are just some of my thoughts. Just expressing mine too.

[@glennharveyco]

I like the video🇵🇭💪

[@virgilialim1513]

I love this Cashual Chuck. I only watched just two of rheir RV. Its obvious they love korean pop.

[@comangalindan1349]

Chuck, you did it!! I've been waiting for someone to react to RIVERSE's RVs to SB19's songs. If I'm a content creator, I would have done it. But I'm not. So thank you for doing this, Chuck! I've watched all their RVs to KZ's performances in The Singer. This was way before I've known SB19. So when I got introduced to our Mahalima and became an A'tin, I started watching different reactors to SB19's songs. This brought me back to RIVERSE. I knew already that they were musicians, so I was kinda thrown off by their negative reactions to What? And then, this again with Bazinga. I wanted to leave a comment in their RV to Bazinga (bec I really had a lot to say.) But then again, why even bother. I think they're so into KPop Idols that I have serious doubts they'll ever appreciate our boys. As we all know, we can't please everybody.

[@warriorprincess6926]

I love Korea and dig Kdramas, but Kpop, I draw the line.

[@UKnwNothingJonDoe]

Well for me, as long as any artist conveys the message that they wanted to send through their craft, then that's what you call authentic. Because every form of art right now is pretty much a copy or inspired by decades of accumulated influence from past works of art. Then if what they mean with being inauthentic is because they've seen or heard those styles from other artists before, then no artist right now or in the future would be authentic, including themselves.

[@mupamtv486]

Very well said.

[@cheonsarang5354]

Well said!!!

[@dnmark09]

What matter is the success and the support the Boys are getting worldwide. Dont mind them.

[@cheh6124]

For me, they've made their judgement already even before doing the RV. in that bazinga rv, they even can't "remember" the name of the group they're reacting to. To think it was not the first time... that means something. They just reacted to shame the trying hard "cute" boys. And this video sums up all what I was thinking while watching their rv. I found them funny, and ended up checking out their songs, nah, their words are empty....

[@bobocah69]

Lovin' the new studio set up of yours

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you

[@arbeemergo2469]

Ken have these deepest voice so natural u can see that raw in their videos in the past!

[@nanoeyes21]

ALWAYS CHOOSE TO BE KIND. Hater rani sila oy, basta kahibaw ta layo na ang naabot sa sb19 even bts has many haters din naman. "they like the music pero in the end hate diay gihapon ang ending" kani nga mga reactor atik2 raman ilaha.

[@mariavelez7511]

To me SB19 are the best, I saw them perform live twice. I don’t care what other said, that’s their opinions. I love SB19❤️💜🖤🤎🧡

[@sonnysendonvlog]

We love our boys, Chuck. Let's end fhe cycle of hate and start by ignoring. Thanks

[@peekabbyu]

All I can say is… they barking up at the wrong tree 😎

[@susansotto4134]

Very well said Chuck ❤️❤️❤️ I'm an avid SB19 fan... I love Pablo❤️❤️❤️

[@expressionsunlimited6045]

well, i remember when SB19 just started and many Filipinos are so hard on them because they think SB19 is a copycat from k-pop and even up to now there are still some think about that. SB19 survived from filipino critics so for sure they will survive from rIVerse comments as well. As long as SB19 continues to do their game and vision others won’t matter.

[@fortdy8932]

Okay lang yan mas MAHAL pa rin namin ang SB19 solid hanggang huli!💪🇵🇭❤️

[@martin4374]

You know, I get it... It's your own history and experience that develops your tastes. How you feel about a song is personal. But maybe they're projecting. You know, making criticisms of themselves but overlaying it other artists that are *cough* younger, better looking, agile, and on a world tour.

[@leaj_mm6639]

I remember Toni's interview w/ the boys, similar idea. Ilang years na cla nag rv but didn't improve they should atleast have a research about the group. They only cares about views

[@Gigi_Waechter]

Exactly! Well said!❤

[@CashualChuck]

LOL!!! HOY!!! HAHHAHA

[@ashungot]

@@CashualChuck naku sir mabait pa nga sya. Ako nga nagpigil na lang sa comment ko kaya sabi ko n lang di natin sila bati. 😂😂😂

[@AgentMiracle]

IDK but ever since they started reacting to SB19... I unsubscribed and never watched anything from their channel ever again (I used to like them since I am also a Kpop fan) ...something was really off with their reaction 😅 Like they were not their cup of tea but why the heck still push themselves to react to them? I thought they would actually stop and ignore the requests to react to the boys...but 🤷 they still did and the fact it's a different genre from the boys 🤦and they still didn't like it.... A'tin should really just stop requesting reactions from them because it's only going to be something similar to what happened to Music Game News. FYI I don't have any problem with constructive criticisms but theirs was just 😬 and you're right they're projecting

[@bmona7550]

I'm American and all I can say is that racism and bigotry is still a huge reason. You think most Americans really respect or understand kpop? Nah. Most of the time kpop gets noticed here because of visuals and because they fit that stereotype of what an attractive Asian "should be". More western less Asian. It is what it is. Deep down these artists in particular are insecure and actually feel threatened by artists elsewhere that challenge western music/popularity. You see these feelings the further you go deep South. Also it has to do with the fact most Americans all think Asia is just East Asia and f*cking Bali. Anyone remotely resembling an East Asian person is automatically either Chinese, Japanese or Korean. If they aren't they feel surprised and just think they are all the same

[@dennisj892]

So smart of you to bring to the surface a truth that admittedly most A'Tin is afraid to confront and even harder to accept...that is not everyone will be a believer in their talents, some will be dismissive of their artistry and many will not be appreciative of their craft. Yet just like what you said this reality should not be a source of bitterness, resentment or worst hatred towards those who will never take Mahalima to their heart. In the end what's important and what counts is for the PPop Kings to remain thriving and becoming more excellent artists and to finally realize the goals that they have set for themselves. That will only be possible if all true A'Tin never tire of accompanying their stan on their journey which undoubtedly will be more arduous and difficult as they become more global in their reach. As they say the climb to the top is the hardest because it is where the slope is steepest! Thank you for reminding us of what we should be accepting of and what to be grateful for as an A'Tin. Keep safe and stay blessed!

[@CashualChuck]

Thank you Dennis for the insightful comment. You're absolutely right, we need to be persistent as well just like SB19.

[@SaraiAndKeonShow]

Sending much love…thank you for always supporting SB19….🥰💙

[@mcbapbabe]

LOL, I watched a couple of their reactions, not that I follow them, but the curiosity just got the best of me, but I decided not to be irked by their comments as I kept telling myself, the accomplishments will speak for the boys, I chose to be kind (tongue in cheek) and let them be Bazinga'd.

[@RuthPOdias]

pet mo talaga kuys chuck! Keep it up! ATIN is here!

[@MrJake4u]

Success is the best revenge, and as for their group, nobody listen to them. A'tin we know what to do