Scattergories: MLB Edition (2.0)

Jolly challenges Shelfy, Joez, and Talkin Jake to a game of Scattergories! See who comes out on top.
Use code JOMBOYPOSTSEASON for 10% off on your next purchase at SeatGeek* seatgeek.oneli... *up to $30 off
Featuring: Talkin' Jake, Joez McFly, and Shelfy
Hosted by: Jolly Olive
Edited by: Mikey Rotunno
#JMBaseball

[@vegaskid9781]

2020 should not be considered 2010s.

[@Math.Bandit]

Especially that he spelled out "10 years"

[@bamadave11]

yeah Jake should have only had 4

[@alexisborden3191]

I mean he did say that 2020 counted, whether you think it should have or not, it was clearly communicated the range was 2010-2020

[@whippie3650]

@@alexisborden3191 yes but he also said there are 20 answers, if all years 2010 to 2020 counted there would be 22 answers, so I guess even Jolly was confused on the rules

[@alexisborden3191]

@@whippie3650 What's easier to count for you, 1986-1995, or 1968 and the next 15 seasons, you're seriously telling me that the second expression is a clearer statement than providing the beginning and end points? No one batted an eye, no one was agrieved here, this is such a non-issue.

[@jackabrams-dyer2618]

Mazeroski didn't win WS MVP actually, Bobby Richardson won it for the Yankees despite the Pirates winning the series

[@ShelfyTV]

WILD! I learn something new everyday

[@S4MVP22]

Hi Shelfy 👋

[@thomasroberts762]

I knew that instantly

[@Hehehaha2222]

I also knew this. Only because I got to meet Bobby and have a baseball signed by him.

[@ILoveMisty1985]

Congrats to Jake for the win then!

[@theburnetts]

Bill Mazerozki? Come on Olive. It’s easy to have a list of all WS MVPs right there during the game.

[@OwenKlco]

Shelfy and Jake both lose a point, Mazerowski didn't win World Series MVP and Abreu didn't win MVP in the 2010's.

[@perfectcell2061]

Jolly said 2020 counted for the range. Which is to say nothing about if 2020 should actually count for 2010s

[@stephenscanlon9763]

Either 2010 doesn't count or 2020.

[@dennismonk9559]

@@stephenscanlon9763 its just an 11 year range.

[@kourii]

@@dennismonk9559 He said 20 players though

[@ShelfyTV]

MY PEOPLE

[@righteous_factz5875]

YESSIR

[@z2001lhcjer]

Mazeroski ❌ Come on Olive!

[@yetigonecrazy]

"You guys BOTH got Cory Lidle??" These and Top 30 are my favorite games on Jomboy outside of the Warehouse Games!!

[@mattynoodles]

Maz didn’t win in 1960. That’d be Bobby Richardson

[@kourii]

Bobby Richardson won in 1960, not Bill Mazeroski. Only time (I think!) that the losing team had the MVP (playing along at home I picked Richardson for that reason, coz he always stands out to me)

[@charliep123]

I would love to see more of these going forward.

[@notsauer]

Let’s get an actual Scattegories game going where you roll a letter, and every name has to start with that letter. Two points for alliteration, like Mickey Mantle, Barry Bonds, or Robbie Ray

[@BongoShaftsbury1]

Mazeroski didn’t win the WS MVP in 1960. That was the one time a player from the losing team won, Bobby Richardson

[@buiesportscards5122]

I feel like I was robbed of the patented Joez rage fest at the end getting mad at Jolly for only hosting😂

[@TwimsFan]

This was a great game, fun to play along with. Would love to see more!

[@kicking222]

Imagine asking the first question, to which there are only 17 different answers, and NOT knowing all the answers or having the list in front of you. Fucking incredible work, Jolly. 👍👍👍

[@verde7595]

Probably does and just doesn't have the list memorised. Otherwise it would take a lot longer to verify those answers instead of just a couple seconds.

[@BennyintheBoothPodcast]

I want ref guess back

[@nolanwalker391]

The best game ever is guessing the Mlb ballpark in the background

[@kangaroodude34]

For ws mvp I would've went edgar enteria, pablo sandoval, madbum, big papi, and strasberg. I love these scattergories vids lol they're fun

[@ianrl_]

goldy was 22 guys

[@artaxAF]

I would like to see more of this kind of content.

[@Molorange]

Yankees Phillies: Sal Fasano, Tom Gordon, Miguel Cairo

[@LowQualContent]

Herd mentality would be a fun game for this channel

[@Veryintriguedviewer]

love these!

[@chasmn84]

Sure wish there was a tiebreaker, maybe the host could think of a name not listed yet and they have to try to guess it?

[@ryanandring2688]

Nice job joez!

[@benjaminkane498]

These types of games are great 👍👍

[@theflamboyantpotato]

Bobby Richardson won WS MVP in 1960, not Mazeroski! But there was no minute long freeze cutting out a decent amount of the video this time, guess that's an improvement for this channel

[@JamesTundra]

Goldschmidt didn't win in 2021, Bryce won that year and Paul won in 2022

[@rapalbumdepot7648]

If you can't name 5 World Series MVPs you should either stop- or start- following baseball.

[@asdfaeou]

Joez immediately attempting to play outside a set of rules and asking for special treatment? Nooooo……not Joez…..never.

[@eunholee2200]

Chang Ho park for the 09 Phillies and for Yankees and Phillies

[@DaBaltimoron]

This isn't soccer, you need a tiebreaker!

[@wintharrii]

GET THAT MAN SHELFY A CONTRACT!! SIGN HIM!!!

[@northofnashira2575]

Cory Lidle was traded from the Phillies to the Yankees and then died at the end of that season.

[@mattf3461]

I’m sorry, but what they’re playing is not Scattergories! It is not just naming random things (or names in this case) that fit the category. For those who have played the traditional game, the idea is to name things that fit the category that all begin with the same letter.

[@sgstoner]

🤓 Well ackshually

[@Faded_36]

I had Cory Lidle too RIP

[@nickothestove7029]

nick nelson is the reliever jake was thinking of in the yankees/phillies round

[@Molorange]

Stephen Ridings I think it was. Also didn’t David Hale get traded to Philly?

[@nickothestove7029]

@@Molorange Stephen ridings threw a splitter not a change up, and David hale does not have red hair

[@louisbailey1824]

Shodve had a tie breaker

[@voncornhole]

Isnt this ome of the tools that MLB The Show put in the game a few years ago?

[@alexborbas991]

needs to be a tiebreaker

[@DSTEWGOD]

Which Blue Jacket is Shelfy related to?

[@TheDuckofLaw]

Thanks for the fun games. I think the audio mix is super-low.

[@spicy9116]

Bill Mazerowski never won, Bobby Richardson on the Yankees won that year

[@jmacmall]

The first category should've been either 2011-2020 (the correct form) or 2010-2019. But as long as everyone is aware of the rules, it doesn't matter at all.

[@joshuaweaver3]

Love it.

[@VyeSpree]

do yall not have heat in the office? guys are bundled up

[@lukenocchi5147]

As a Phillies fan I played along and got 10

[@SuperHonestyTime]

Mazeroski did not win World Series mvp in 1960

[@baseballhistoria]

why do people consider themselves baseball "history buffs" but not know anything about baseball before 1990 lmao

[@sabercastpodcast457]

Goldy’s MVP was last year, 22

[@JamieAtSLC]

JC Romero didn’t play in the 2009 WS.

[@lovesgucci1]

Was he suspended for PEDs during the WS?

[@senatorvest5496]

JC Romero did not play in the 2009 World Series. That should not have been a point.

[@J_T_H]

How did no one say Mad Bum

[@daswaggotnumber1fan]

first question so easy bruh

[@pratt17648]

2020 is not 2010's. Clean it up boys

[@kevinj7899]

PLEASE make the *ding* quieter.

[@EitanYossiAshlag]

❤

[@mattmcbrayer2687]

I miss RefGuess...

[@kevinwright7728]

Mazeroski didn’t win WS MVP

[@ericv2327]

Shelfy wins! Jose Abreu won in 2020, not the 2010s.

[@OwenKlco]

Mazerowski didnt win world series mvp, so they still tie.

[@ianrl_]

yuh

[@AddMiller221]

He does specifically say from the years 2010-2020. So, even though it says 2010s, it was specifically stated that 2020 counted.

[@Math.Bandit]

@@AddMiller221 He also specifically says "10 years" though.

[@AddMiller221]

@@Math.Bandit Regardless of that, the players obviously understood the intent of the question. So, shouldn't count against him.

[@bamadave11]

Technically Shelfy won because 2020 isn't part of the 10s.

[@mikevanenglehoven6088]

Ben zobrist!!!!

[@basescleared]

nick nelson snubbed for phils/yanks 😪

[@traviskallan9318]

Is Joez intentionally bad at this?

[@JoezMcflySports]

Ya

[@traviskallan9318]

@@JoezMcflySports I figured, like I know this man knows baseball🤣

[@connorcoleman2111]

Not tryna be that guy but these are baseball guys and they couldn’t name 5 MVPs?

[@ruxp12]

Sometimes i dont believe that joez has them and hes just crossing out a blank row. I bet a lot of people think that.

[@Mr_Boyer]

For a channel about baseball which is all about statistics and numbers, you'd think the hosts would be able to count to 10. 2010-2019.