SCR vs BR | Unbiased | The Final Part

[@SirAxel.]

SCR follows an arcade-ish style, whilst BR aims to be more realistic. They’re both just as excellent in their own ways.

[@user-bo4kg9od6x]

True!

[@exploderendekippenproducti3370]

Completely true, they aren't to be compared.

[@Deletedm1z]

W

[@madbanana2495]

both really great Games. I love British Trains. and both are in my top 5 fav games (SCR being 2 and BR being 4)

[@The_pitch.]

BR Definitely wins if you want a realistic and mature playing experience. SCR is a more chill game where people have fun and dont care. (BR is new and still is this good and realistic so it wins)

[@matmat_rpblox]

SCR = Stepford Country Railway BR = British Railway

[@lonelystickman856]

underrated comment, thanks so much!

[@aalstom]

County*

[@matmat_rpblox]

@@aalstom Oops

[@Farleigh1050]

country 💀

[@lonelystickman856]

@@Farleigh1050 imagine a country called stepford xD

[@ArrowProds]

It doesn't particularly mean much, again BR is newer, and neither are in competition with each other - they occupy two different sections of the same market.

[@Specton1825]

Precisly.

[@Railwaystar_Roblox]

SCR playercount: ~61.9 Million BR playercount: ~6.1 Million SCR years since release: 5 BR years since release: ~0.41 (5 months) =) Avg. Playercount= Total Playercount / Years since release =) SCR= 61.9/5 = 12.38 Mil/year =) BR= 6.1/0.41 =14.87 Mil/Year

[@tflandplaneslover]

Bro You Should have added one More: Liveries

[@odzergaming]

@@tflandplanesloverthis is just about playcount and age not livery

[@tflandplaneslover]

@@odzergaming I know but Like He Could Have Added it in the First Part

[@Railwaystar_Roblox]

@@tflandplaneslover it comes in rolling stock

[@tflandplaneslover]

@@Railwaystar_Roblox Ok Thanks For Informing Me

[@SouthKoreanSanta]

As of 2023 December 31th SCR has a average of 29,250 players while BR has a average of 16,423 players so more people like SCR

[@thatone_boi5063]

Just because people play SCR more than BR, it doesn't mean that everybody likes it. And Vice Versa.

[@SouthKoreanSanta]

@@thatone_boi5063 I am just pointing out stuff

[@SG-tq2vy]

Bro everything else was just normal where the first one was a math exam 😭

[@Skullman53532]

What???

[@VincentYT889]

Mobile players(including me): why dis Thing so laggy

[@Ello90909]

As long as I enjoy playing the game,I don’t mind what wins.

[@The_Unknown_Spotter]

How about BR vs GCR?

[@MattijsVandebroek]

I honestly prefer SCR because of the systems (like announcemznts and stuff) , the easter eggs and the map. I just love someplaces in their map. For sognalling I prefer Roblox Dovedale Railway. It's with levers and semaphore signals and stuff.

[@JaNieWie]

Then there's me who haven't touched either since 2020.

[@spockbetter]

i just wish there were some games with eastern european locos and some freight games that are actually good like br and scr

[@user-it8ht2je7y]

SCR is better

[@Romasultpl1]

Well, SCR is better in terms of sheer size of trains and stations, but BR is unbeatable on realism and the sounds produced by trains on points, to me They are both Beautiful, but BR has and small qualities that surpass SCR.

[@thelegendaryguest]

bro im banned from br so i play only scr and wcr

[@boeing747_23]

How did you get banned

[@ismailonurerturk5422]

Why did you get banned?

[@That1person810]

And I hope u continue getting banned

[@Specton1825]

Same, why did you get banned? If you did something wrong, hope you understood your mistake. Don't do it again now!

[@Farleigh1050]

why?

[@exploderendekippenproducti3370]

Subbed❤

[@tchuryproductions]

Realism is actually a bit of a disadvantage because it causes a lot of lag, especially low end devices.

[@Specton1825]

This is the era of game realism. I understand low-end devices cannot handle, thats why SCR doesnt expand-- for better optimization

[@Sgoinneil]

@@Specton1825scr is already big enough don’t think it needs another expansion

[@SosgamingYT1]

@@Sgoinneilthats the point the devs only have options to make branches into the center map

[@Sgoinneil]

@@SosgamingYT1 the game has enough branches and after the James street extension there is no need for another branch.

[@SosgamingYT1]

@@Sgoinneil i know what else can they do tho ? If they just keep adding updates on stations they will lose more playerbase

[@theclass171guy]

both are great games

[@Drive_n_Crash]

Hey, i’m developing my own train game in Roblox, its in Sweden. What do you think it needs to be good?

[@TrewStudios21]

BR has had a new update and it’s AMAZING. But train sim world 4 and train sim classic are the best

[@Suad47]

Team scr

[@Ameliathehorsegirl]

Scr is more fun while BR is more realistic

[@haydenkincer-mf7rn]

Guys if you want to song it's after dark

[@lance941]

As a SCR player, BR makes SCR look like dogshit

[@osamakhlifi-xw1hn]

whats the full name of br?

[@Farleigh1050]

br is pretty good, but if realism is all you care about, train sim world or ts classic is what youre looking for

[@izarayanbebe]

British railways is more realistic and im so noon to play at that rare of realism💀💀💀💀 So i play scr because of bigger map and more stations but both are good ngl

[@user-cg1dr5mn9b]

Br = my phone lags (its released) SCR = same as one at lbts

[@hypeeegaming]

Bruh, why do you think BR has so many players? That’s right. SCR created this whole sub-genre. +1 to SCR. Game doesnt send your train to heaven. +1 BR. Visits. +1 to SCR Not much nepotism probably. +1 to BR The father of all of it. +999 to yrrebRBLX’s Trains. The grandfather. +1000 to yrrebRBLX’s Trams.

[@iDislikeAlotofThings]

No it does not, there are quite a few railway games that predates SCR.

[@hypeeegaming]

@@iDislikeAlotofThings That’s why I mentioned yrrebRBLX’s Trains, dum dum. I meant scr was the first super popular one.

[@iDislikeAlotofThings]

@@hypeeegaming Eh, BR gives the superior driving experience, SCR is good at the operation side of railway lines. SCR isn't a very good simulator if you want an accurate driving experience (even yrrebb's oldest game has a more accurate brake system than SCR) BR isn't a good experience if you want to work as a station employee. Both games are good on their own right, but i dont care about train simulators anymore. I have better interest in buses and bus simulators.

[@0B2K]

tbh tho BR is still better than SCR when it comes to loads of stuff

[@SosgamingYT1]

@@iDislikeAlotofThingsscr is supposed to be arcade br is driving sim thats the thing pepole get mixed up also scr has ranks unlike br

[@Mcquenn456]

Team scr 👇

[@comengtrainmelbourne]

Scr is shit😂😂😂

[@Ozzy-does-stuff]

Noticed how no one liked

[@Ozzy-does-stuff]

@@Owen_trains2010 I'm sure it was you that liked after seeing my response

[@Owen_trains2010]

@@comengtrainmelbourneThat's what u are

[@Everytwo_]

SCR is an Arcade Game while br is a Simulator

[@Driftingairways]

👇 Team SCR

[@Farleigh1050]

'BR has a more mature playerbase' the BR playerbase: 'im obsessed with br but i hate you so much because you like br. stop lying and just admit it, you are married to scr' (worth noting i dont even like scr thst much)

[@OOFUS4103]

If BR was better optimized for low-end devices, it would definitely win. However, right now, it’s not very accessible to the majority of users on roblox because of the poor optimization.

[@realfrowz]

It's.not meant to it's meant to be realistic

[@Olivers_RailAdventures]

It’s now more optimised for low end devices in its recent update runs more smoother for me now

[@OOFUS4103]

@@Olivers_RailAdventuresyeah I agree, but the new memory leaks that popped up near freston junction freezes my game for 15 seconds straight

[@OOFUS4103]

Although SCR doesn’t do much better with optimization

[@thedayofthetweenie7196]

There both equally as good 👍

[@dpadjoystick]

non br is better

[@Ello90909]

@@dpadjoystickThey’re Both Good

[@dpadjoystick]

@@Ello90909 br is better in every f-ing way (graphics, physics, train models, sound, immersion, guarding, door opening etc.

[@SlowediOSringtones]

@@dpadjoystickno both are good kid

[@Abandoned23345]

No BR is better than that trash game for clowns called SCR 🤡🏳️‍🌈🤢

[@elsamachado2160]

I like the music

[@Specton1825]

Yea.. fire song 🎵

[@protoon8576]

What is it called?

[@Specton1825]

@@protoon8576 After Dark

[@OwnittEdits]

i tell ya, the br community IS NOT bias if your in the discord community, full of kids mate.

[@CloudAlcazar-rs3re]

Everyone for SCR

[@Owen_trains2010]

Yes

[@Lachafan]

@Niewiem471 That is true gonna give you that, but SCR is kind of a great game, not for realism just for driving. But BR is Waaaay more realistic

[@Lachafan]

@@DiegoGonzalezMengual-pw5vr 👏👏👏👏👏

[@Finnstrains]

I prefer br but it’s too laggy on my pc

[@torrenstransitenthusiast6985]

I think British railways is the best

[@jantv7155]

Team BR 👇

[@joemercedeschannel196]

SCR I like better because BR is so laggy anywhere you go

[@knownfishyplayzscr9234]

i feel SCR is starting to flop with iconsistant updates lots of bugs and not as relestic as BR

[@WillowCSC13]

I don't know how to play br actually I tried it and I still don't know

[@Badhumortophat]

You took playerbase 2 times

[@Bodie-zf3sk]

Br won 4-3 YOU WASNT COUNTING 😡

[@Meehan2023]

Scr is alright but br is good i gonna give it too Br

[@Owen_trains2010]

scr is way better than that game

[@CaffeinatedMoustache]

@@Owen_trains2010name one reason why

[@Owen_trains2010]

@@CaffeinatedMoustache Because the map is bigger and I can drive way easier, No affence

[@Ozzy-does-stuff]

​​@@Owen_trains2010except BR aint meant for wee kids on there mums ipad such as yourself BR is for the pros also might wanna check your spelling

[@Owen_trains2010]

@@Ozzy-does-stuff Don't need to, I have a better spelling than you anyway

[@snowy67992]

SCR

[@paganini18]

I prefer SCR over BR

[@Owen_trains2010]

Same

[@comengtrainmelbourne]

Scr- trash can Br -chad

[@comengtrainmelbourne]

Scr is a sloppy poor mantained game and ugly trains go play br instead kids

[@DerEi1290]

⁠@@comengtrainmelbournewtf bro respect others opinion

[@Owen_trains2010]

@@comengtrainmelbourneDon't such be such a big baby because of people's opinions

[@Lachafan]

SCR is better, there is no debate

[@Rowan66109]

there is in fact a debate if you look in the comment section

[@Lachafan]

@@Rowan66109 I noticed the 50 messages

[@Lachafan]

@@Rowan66109 so yes, there is

[@LiamRobloxSubscribe]

BR is basically focusing on its realism and advancement of trains, while SCR is focusing on its arcade based leaderboard of trains, in my opinion I think I would say that....if you want a game that is focusing on graphics and realism, go for BR or if you want a plain but lot of stations and larger sized map, go for SCR.

[@axolotlgamer615]

BR is good as it isnt as laggy.

[@ExtraCarInsurance]

british railway got botted multiple times and has gotten like an extra 4m visits (getting botted 1000 concurrent users at some points) technically scr wins if you factor the botting in

[@Railwaystar_Roblox]

Do you have some solid evidence? If it really is true I need evidence to make another video for my mistake. And yes even if you don't thanks for your point. I will do more research now.

[@DelinquentRevenge]

it is true, but it wasnt botted BY the game devs, its some random people.

[@Intercitygaming]

Hey whats this song callled

[@user-bv6fp5gh9c]

After dark

[@yuritrainspotting]

Bugs tho so many bugs in SCR

[@B87333]

BR long name? Idk it

[@SWTrainspotting]

British Railway

[@youronurowndorothea7]

british railway

[@rifathalmusaj5879]

Scr

[@josduardo371]

SRC IS VERY GOOD BUT Realism is not good them BR trains stop more fast in SCR in real life don t and my favorite CLASS 802 AND 221

[@ryanburghouwt7262]

I kept count and br wins

[@aaaibaramkikasaatorrodeshh6629]

Scr stays best

[@DiegoGonzalezMengual-pw5vr]

​@@_32-_. It's actually the best Roblox train game since 6 years, 2023 BR community came and ruined all

[@DiegoGonzalezMengual-pw5vr]

@@_32-_. Do you think SCR is getting Sneak Peeks every Week like before? Do you think SCR is getting the same effort like before? Do you think we are getting nice updates with a lot of new things like before? Charlie leaving was like a 2008 economic fail and months later BR community came up to Roblox and I finish it, until 1.11 is released I will not have the same hopes for SCR that I had in 2018

[@PigeonsandCapybaras]

Opinions don’t exist

[@ndundamalangwa5725]

Blud SCR has more players what 😂☠️

[@jboxgaming444]

Wow compatiton for these 2 are high Shame about SCR bugs rn

[@Railwaystar_Roblox]

Yea

[@NotNewReally]

well bug is because of new roblox mechanics

[@kerrygahen7880]

Who said br is better than SCR not me😂

[@guillermoerdelaburger7636]

BR 4-3 SCR The best is BR

[@Owen_trains2010]

Not Particually

[@lucahofmann9694]

SCR ist COOL 😎 😎

[@VergiePangilinan]

Nah scr is the best thoughr

[@ANASbaldosos]

Scr Good

[@user-zn3kt6pq2y]

Scr KCIC

[@user-fh2on8cu6o]

SCR is weather

[@maidenhead7760]

A month later you still stand with your point?

[@Greggs30806]

Bro SCR doesn't have weather, only Day & Night, not like BR that actually has weather like Rain & fog, definitely BR for weather

[@pachycakes]

im pretty sured i saw 5 n word in br

[@Railwaystar_Roblox]

What??

[@pachycakes]

@@Railwaystar_Roblox yeah...

[@Pomeranc470]

And what? You've never heard or sayed it? I'm from eastern europe where people are really racist, so I'm just asking.

[@pachycakes]

@@Pomeranc470 I'm pretty sure the UK is at the western

[@Pomeranc470]

@@pachycakes ik

[@rowanmsfs]

BR is better

[@Lachafan]

No

[@rowanmsfs]

@@Lachafan Yes

[@Lachafan]

@@rowanmsfs no

[@Rowan66109]

@@Lachafan skill issue 😹😹😹

[@Lachafan]

@@Rowan66109 Oh, so we got something in common!

[@VergiePangilinan]

Its just easy ro control than br and br has no dispacth

[@kaedenthechampion4668]

br has actual effort in driving the train.

[@Lachafan]

​@@kaedenthechampion4668But its too hard for some ppl

[@DelinquentRevenge]

​@@Lachafan its too hard fo4 toddlers.

[@Lachafan]

@@DelinquentRevenge it's too hard for ur mom

[@Lachafan]

@kaedenthechampion4668 Its a good game but I just like SCR better, just an opinion.

[@trainlover1291]

SCR is netter Thai BR because is OG Game Fromm 2017 nur I miss the old Stations RIP : Winstree

[@swtvic]

shut

[@SWTrainspotting]

Invalid point, just because it’s older doesn’t mean it’s better statistically, BR has grown faster in less than a year then SCR has in 6.

[@taiwanRoC822]

@@SWTrainspotting dude that is his opinion

[@SWTrainspotting]

@@taiwanRoC822 btw you can stop saying dude

[@rowanmsfs]

That’s not a valid point

[@comengtrainmelbourne]

Br 👇

[@Owen_trains2010]

No way, BR sucks, It's the worst game ever lots of skill issue and the map size is too small as a car, EWW

[@Owen_trains2010]

@BrthegoatDefine is the used word at school, I hope the teachers doesn't catch you or you will be crying 😂

[@DelinquentRevenge]

​@@Owen_trains2010 tf you on about, y9u speak like you got thrown at a mountain at mach 1.

[@maxinebates4566]

British railways is clearly better

[@Owen_trains2010]

Or is it?

[@DelinquentRevenge]

​@@Owen_trains2010 it is better.

[@Kingol180]

SCR better wth

[@rowanmsfs]

BR is more realistic

[@Kingol180]

@@rowanmsfs more bugs 🐜

[@captaincactus5247]

@Brthegoat this is one of the things i can actually agree on in this comment section filled with scr fanboys and br defendants, i don't have any side, because they are different types of railway games (scr being arcade, br being realistic) and also br being a lot newer, but that is one of the only things i will agree on, br has it's fair share of bugs, but scr has too many im not sure if it'll recover from them

[@Kingol180]

@Brthegoat nah

[@Kingol180]

You should look at their dizzy

[@thesplat-_-2403]

SCR >>>> BR, end of it

[@Owen_trains2010]

Yes

[@DelinquentRevenge]

br solos scr. first of all, br has way more detail, scr is way more arcadish and has many pointless features.

[@deividasverbickas6233]

British Rail is good but you cant beat the OG

[@That1person810]

Scr sucks in all

[@Owen_trains2010]

@@That1person810I know someone else who sucks, you

[@Greggs30806]

​@@That1person810Yes because how dere anyone actually like SCR. Oh please stop being such fanboys, and feeling the need to say stuff like 'SCR sucks' just let people have there own opinion and move on with your day

[@DelinquentRevenge]

accounting nostalgia is being biased. trust me ive played SCR for 4-5 years and ive seen good stations turning in5o shit but trust me BR is better from an unbiased standpoint.

[@bbykiss]

SCR better, no debate

[@Ozzy-does-stuff]

​@BrthegoatI stand with you

[@Owen_trains2010]

What amateurs, I've been playing SCR for a very long time and you amateurs just have only one or two operators in BR

[@Ozzy-does-stuff]

@@Owen_trains2010 Ive got Stepford connect Airlink waterline and express and I've been playing SCR for over 4 years kid

[@Ozzy-does-stuff]

@@Owen_trains2010 try and compare to that

[@Owen_trains2010]

@@Ozzy-does-stuff Sorry, It's 5 years lol try compare to that

[@jerzyk3520]

Team SCR 👇

[@comengtrainmelbourne]

Mate scr litteraly crashes and br is realistic graphchs

[@Subi_58]

Team scr

[@ashbhatt6927]

SCR

[@tonybishop1870]

SCR is better

[@ynight8218]

BR is better

[@Owen_trains2010]

No

[@Owen_trains2010]

@Brthegoat wup

[@Owen_trains2010]

@K0rp0lityWES NES

[@copsaretops]

Scr

[@adrimoma4568]

SCR

[@TarikAlmasri-tg4qq]

SCR

[@TarikAlmasri-tg4qq]

SCR