Scrapbook Subscription Kit Comparison - Felicity Jane vs. Hip Kit Club

[@carolhodges9899]

Thanks for the side-by-side comparison of these two kits. I’ve been getting Felicity Jane kits for several months now, but had not heard of Hip Kit Club until recently. After seeing this, I may try a few of the Hip Kit Club kits for myself and see how they compare for how I use them! So glad you shared this!!

[@ScrappyWife]

Have fun!

[@mengmania]

Long-time subscriber to Felicity Jane. I’m never disappointed each month in the quality or quantity of product. 🖤🖤🖤🖤

[@ScrappyWife]

I totally agree!

[@vickielightsey5134]

I love Felicity Jane and the way each kit can mix and match with all of their other kits. A bit more cost but well worth it.

[@ScrappyWife]

True, true!

[@connies9847]

Love the comparison. Have never looked into Hip Kit Club before, but definitely will now!

[@ScrappyWife]

Glad it was helpful!

[@gloriannerusate9726]

Freckled Fawn because I have plenty of paper. Thanks for the comparison I’ll put them on my future purchase list.

[@ScrappyWife]

You are so welcome! I'll look into Freckled Fawn!

[@kellygarvey9976]

Thanks for such a detailed walk through of the kits. Both are wonderful!

[@ScrappyWife]

Glad you like them!

[@dawnmotakef3072]

I enjoy both of these kit clubs. Thanks for the comparison. Other comparisons I’d like to see are The Scraproom, My Creative Scrapbook, Scrapbook & Cards Today kits and How to kill a kit with style ( this one might be curated especially for you so it may be difficult to compare.) Thank you!

[@ScrappyWife]

I will look into those - thanks for the suggestions!

[@ChappyPlans]

I’m so glad I found this video! I did recently subscribe to Ali Edward’s stories by the month, but decided to use Heidi Swapp’s storyline chapters planner/memory keeping inserts. I also just subscribed to Heidi’s stop the blur monthly kit. I love how in depth this review was and the comparison at the end! Would love to see more of these!

[@ScrappyWife]

Yay, glad you liked it! I do like to help people get a little insight into what they are subscribing to. Stop the blur is such a great project!

[@evangelinetaulton302]

Thank You so much for doing this video. I loved hearing your take on each kit and how they can be used for daily planning, crafting, scrapbooking etc. Also, this video has help me narrow down what monthly subscription kits I want to invest in. This video opened the door to discuss Today’s Time and look at this quarantine time in a different light. We are going to Incorporate daily bible journaling together as a family now. Thanks again, and keep the videos coming.

[@ScrappyWife]

This makes my heart so happy 💕💕💕💕 I sure do love this family!!!

[@dee_ewell_pierce]

Thank you for this wonderful comparison between the kits!

[@ScrappyWife]

You are so welcome!

[@loriclark3755]

I have been a Club Scrap member for about 15 years. They have a scrapbooking kit, card kit, and digital. You get a video and cutting instructions to reduce waste. They're out of Wisconsin.

[@ScrappyWife]

I will definitely look into them!

[@louiseorr8963]

I am not subscribed to any kits purely because of the high shipping to South Africa. I have bought from both companies before. Although I am not really a scrapbooker, I loved both and its hard to choose! Felicity Jane I have used in art journaling and Bible Journaling during the lockdown. HKC only for documenting October grateful last year. FJ also has a digital option if I am not mistaken. Would like to try the Colour kit from HKC.

[@ScrappyWife]

Yes, FJ does have some digital files!

[@lindaruschmeyer5298]

Thank you for the comparison of these kits. I get FJ and wondered about Hip Kit Club. TFS

[@ScrappyWife]

Glad it was helpful! I am loving my Hip Kit subscription!

[@kathrynciavone6624]

I really appreciate you doing this video. I’ve been curious about Hip kit club.

[@ScrappyWife]

Glad it was helpful!

[@erengarard991]

Thank you for this comparison. I see soooo many subscription boxes, its difficult to decide or know which would suit me. I do subscribe to Planners Anonymous. Sami Gale is the owner/ creator. She is in Australia and has been creating these for 3 years now. She offers a tremendous amount of goodies in her sub boxes as well as member only digital files. She does cater more to the planner groups but her papers, die cuts, stickers, and stamps can be used in other craft creations as well. She was also picked up by Michael's and has a kit offered online only through Michael's (which you can also use a coupon). If you haven't already checked her out you might want to see her site.

[@ScrappyWife]

I have heard great things about Planners Anonymous....one of my friends loves her!

[@dottie1926]

I have previously subscribed to both HKC and Citrus Twist. I think all kit clubs that I have seen have great things about them; you just have to find the one (or ones) that suit your style the best. I had to take a break from the kits as I accumulated too much stash but once I deplete some of it, I plan on subscribing again. Thank you so much for the video!!!

[@ScrappyWife]

Agree, it is a great way to build your stash, but it can build up quickly!

[@Lubbehobby]

Love the Felicity Jane kit

[@ScrappyWife]

Me too💕

[@MLLatUtube]

Thanks for the comparison - I have ordered pieces of kits from Felicity Jane but had never heard of Hip Kit

[@ScrappyWife]

You are so welcome!

[@beingjennz6959]

Thanks so much for the video!! I wasn't aware of either of these two sub boxes. You did a great job!

[@ScrappyWife]

Glad it was helpful!

[@JessaCrownedByJesus]

Great comparison video! I love that hit kit club curates with different designers cause you can try a variety at a cheap price! TFS! ♡

[@ScrappyWife]

I totally agree!

[@kelliescraftythumb]

I subscribe to HKC but it was nice to see what felicity jane has to offer. I also subscribe to citrus twist because they are an all exclusive brand too. But it's more towards pocket scrapbooking it seems. But I love their colors and their ephemera packs too. Oh and HKC has only recently done stamps, it's not always they do stamps but I love when they do.

[@margiduffy3646]

Thank you for the video. I do subscribe to Felicity Jane and it’s beautiful. I have never been disappointed I also subscribe to Cocoa Daisy but it is geared more to planners After this video I’m seriously leaning toward a trying out the Hip Kit Club. thank you again

[@ScrappyWife]

Yes, Citrus Kits is beautiful as well!

[@SDH1970]

Thank you for this. Would love to see more kit comparisons.

[@ScrappyWife]

You got it!

[@charlenegriffith7391]

I like Felicity Jane kits but found that they tended to pile up as it was so much stuff. I do love that I have over a years worth of kits and they all mix so well I could not tell you which one was which month as I have used bits up I just keep them all together b/c they mix perfectly. I now subscribed to scrap-room.com and they are much more suited to completing small pages. Comes with 4 mini kits so you get a variety of curated goodies but small enough to make pages and not have tons of left overs every month.

[@ScrappyWife]

Awesome! I'll have to look into scrap-room!

[@dianemartinez7290]

I subscribe to both kit clubs and feel exactly the same. I just recently began with the Scrap-room kits and like having the mixture of different paper companies. I do find that I tend to purchase the extra add-ons though.

[@dimplesuit5385]

Good job comparing the kits Elesa. I once subscribed to a lot of different kits, including FJ, but had to cut back. I still have monthly subs to Bible Journaling Ministries and Creative Retreat. I have Echo Park which is 6 times a year. And, the can't miss releases without a subscription are By The Well For God and Illustrated Faith monthly kits as well as the Christmas collection from FJ.

[@ScrappyWife]

Yes!!!

[@CookieCoCo_OG]

I was a subscriber to Felicity Jane and I just used your link to subscribe to HipKit. Club. Thanks for the vid!

[@ScrappyWife]

Awesome!

[@davonnac2413]

I’ve tried the echo park subscription once. I felt like the die cuts and things are too big for me (I scrap 6x8). I’ve been subscribed to FJ since January and I love it so much!

[@ScrappyWife]

DIdn't even know Echo Park had a subscription! Yes, I love FJ...they are just so beautiful!

[@elenaknighton7094]

Great video! I've always admired Felicity Jane kits but after seeing this I think Hip Kit club is more my style. Thank you! Would love to know what's included in the mixed media kit...😁

[@ScrappyWife]

It changes every month! I haven't gotten that one yet, but I'll have to look into it!

[@luv3pugs]

Why I select Felicity Jane is that Everything is exclusive. You can’t find any of it anywhere else. Looks like hip kit club uses papers from other collections and a few exclusive items. Also it all coordinates with other kits. Same style, although different prints. Also not mentioned is that they also have extras that you can buy on their website. Also the stamp size is larger and standard. Felicity Jane has now gone to a smaller alpha which is perfect

[@ScrappyWife]

Felicity Jane is certainly a beautiful option!

[@Elaine-hq8uu]

Great comparison. Thank you. I dint receive either of those. I do receive Paper Pumpkin, G45 card kit and just started with scrapbooking store. Like them all. G45 is getting a bit repetitive so am thinking of just buying the paper collections I like.

[@ScrappyWife]

Wonderful!

[@GM-tu7di]

Great video! Thanks for the comparison ❤️ I have gotten individual kits from FJ and love them! Also have gotten Creative Retreat because it’s reasonably priced

[@ScrappyWife]

Agree, Creative Retreat is a great value!

[@Lubbehobby]

Beautiful papers

[@ScrappyWife]

They are!

[@theglamqueenskingdom5105]

Like them both, but the Felicity Jane kit made me super excited! Thanks so much for this review. Tonya 🙌👏👌👍❤️❤️❤️

[@ScrappyWife]

You are so welcome!

[@soveyrarosas1243]

Thanks for the comparison!

[@ScrappyWife]

You bet!

[@HeatherscraftyLife]

Awesome video! Thanks for sharing!

[@ScrappyWife]

You bet!

[@dropthecolorsonia3332]

I love hip kit club it brings so much with add on.

[@ScrappyWife]

Agree! I think next month I am going to add on the solid color cardstock to build up my stash of solids a bit.

[@dropthecolorsonia3332]

ScrappyWife that exactly what I did for the color kit know I have sets of lindys paint.

[@stacierisen8870]

So helpful! Thank you so much for the comparison ♡

[@ScrappyWife]

You are so welcome!

[@sandrafulton4351]

Thank you for the comparison.

[@ScrappyWife]

No problem 👍

[@danniellebrown4258]

Great review on kits... HKC doesn't always come with a stamp. Luv both kits very much!!! I have subscribed to both of them! :) I am still a subscriber to HKC at this time. hugs~Dani

[@ScrappyWife]

Good to know!

[@danniellebrown4258]

ScrappyWife Cant wait for more of ur vids! I still luv Felicity Jane but I can’t afford both right now but if I could those are the 2 kits I would get! 💯

[@angeltaraila6868]

I subscribe felicity Jane but haven’t taken the time to “do” anything with them. Even though I have alll the time in the world. 😔 I love the comparison. I am definitely going to look into Hip Kit Club.

[@ScrappyWife]

It happens to all of us - I certainly have a TON of supplies that are just begging to be created with!

[@angeltaraila6868]

ScrappyWife #TheTruthiestTruthThatEverTruthed

[@kimberlymarino8047]

L💖VE. L💖VE. L💖VE my HKC kits!!!

[@ScrappyWife]

They are a ton of fun for sure!

[@cindy44h]

I checked out the website and it looks like they are already sold out.

[@ScrappyWife]

For this month they are, but you can always sign up for future months!

[@cindy44h]

@@ScrappyWife thank you for your channel. I just found you yesterday and I subscribed!

[@kelliescraftythumb]

@@ScrappyWife yes recently they have been selling out so I would subscribe so that way you are guaranteed a kit. You won't request it. They have great customer service and a great community.

[@annsmith5625]

⚾️ very interesting but not into subscription plans

[@ScrappyWife]

👍🏻