Screw It - Go Get Myles Garrett!!!

[@pinacoladatime5915]

Justis is the best! As much Justis as humanely possible please!

[@greenmenace9666]

Trade for Miles Garrett or no? Take a big swing, let's go do the thing! *Justis Love it.

[@gregsandell]

Always a great show with Justis and Andy.

[@rickardred17]

Justis is the best guest, love it

[@Cheeseheadmatt93]

Why in the world does everyone keep acting like if Green Bay trades there first round pick and other capital for a player like Garrett. Gute cant hit on a 1st rounder to save his life. Getting Garrett would be equivalent to Reggie white. Go get him, players like this don’t become available everyday

[@PackerBacker911]

A few of the guys around here would start tearing up if we got a 30 year old instead of a 21 year old. They would rather go with the young unproven player than one of the best in the league if it messes with us being the youngest team!

[@cortezthebrave2349]

Yeah. Big swing but could be Gute's White or Woodson. Or maybe X is Woody and Garrett could be White-esque.

[@frankleyJ]

People worried about picks but I'd trade every 1st round pick Gute has made, minus jordan love, for Garrett. It would be more difficult if we had a history of turning them into good players

[@derekschenk4296]

Absolutely agreed sir. All of those first round picks combined wouldn't come close to equating the value of having myles Garrett on this team

[@williamhermann6635]

Its not just about the picks. Its about the fact theyre gonna have to pay his monster contract too. Thats too many assets dedicated to a non-qb

[@305mikemagee]

Heck yeah!!! And we will be able to move off Gary and LVN in 2026 if they continue to be mid to below mid with Garrett taking double and triple teams. Sadly, Kenny has another 2 years before we can move him, hopefully he would help the interior pressure too!

[@jefferyzielke7665]

​@@williamhermann6635I just started the episode so I haven't heard what Andy thinks but if they would take Gary, It would offset the money a little bit.

[@MarkWarriner-yt2yz]

Yes 2 x1 + Gary.

[@drgnsclwot1447]

Great convo. We get to wait and see what happens

[@nickj2561]

I feel like I always learn something when Justis is on. Thanks for the great conversation Andy

[@gonzUSA]

S tier episode of Pack a Day

[@peterharmon6778]

Love Andy loving he’s geek out with Justis!

[@RedMo46]

With the 23rd pick in the NFL draft the Green Bay Packers select....... 3-4 years of Myles Garrett. Yeah sounds goodnuff to me. This reminds me of the Reggie White scenario just the Eagles didnt want draft capital in return. If anything, thats advantageous to this Packers team being its not a matter of him going to the highest contract bidder but the one most willing to part with draft capital. Will Gutey go against his generally conservative ways?

[@christopherweise438]

Reggie was a free agent. That made the signing so much more simple. This is far more complicated. One edge rusher does not get you to the SB. You have to add alot more pieces. We aren't even close to being a serious contender. We got wiped by ALL the good teams.

[@jameswarner261]

@@christopherweise438we are a healthy corner and a WR away from contending… what?

[@christopherweise438]

@ - and a QB.

[@Crossfire-GoBlue]

a proven player like miles garret, even at 29, is worth much more then a couple first round picks. he will produce way more in 2 years then those other 1st round selections likely would. hes the best player in the damn league

[@karlvanbeckum9029]

Love these sessions with Justis. Keep 'em rollin'!

[@jonievans5453]

We need elite absolutely take this swing here on Myles . This is a a game changer on that side of the ball ..

[@donDubP]

Agreed Gutey has to Send it!!! Edgerrin should use the Texas A&M link & hit Myles DMs

[@NemoHoes-nn5ww]

Putting Garrett out there would elevate gary's game too

[@Next.level.mindset247]

I don’t see a world where the packers host the draft for the first time in forever and they give up all of their early picks for an aging veteran.

[@dannyjoherrin4559]

They said 2026 first that's the reason

[@packers0611]

Aging? The reigning DPOY lol

[@jeffwubker7445]

💯 It's a fools move. He blows out a knee, and then what? Besides, this isn't a one-piece away from a bowl situation. We're still weak in too many positions.

[@packers0611]

@@jeffwubker7445 We really aren't many pieces away. We need Jaire back healthy and the defense is set, maybe another corner in the draft and some DL help. Grab a WR

[@matt_valentine]

Another excellent episode! Justis is the greatest guest.

[@johnshay9527]

That's a awful trade for Garrett lol. He is not coming to GB let's just get that out of our heads

[@IsaacMSingleton1]

Offer 2 firsts, Gary, Willis, couple mid round draft picks, it's alot and Garret is 30 at this point..how long does he stay at this level?

[@hellysteiner8035]

I don’t care if the packers give up Two 1st round picks for him go get him pack!!!!!

[@mosthatedminnesotan]

Keep Jmosq on all off season!

[@brizzle5257]

I would hope getting a great edge rusher no matter who it is elevates Gary’s game cause he hasn’t lived up to his contract thus far

[@Brandon-rg1vz]

You have some of the best guests on this podcast. Justis and Carmie are tied for the number 1 spot

[@rickhook2860]

2nd this year, first next year, anticipating that will be a very low pick, and 2 injured players plus a bad backup for Myles Garret. Of course the Packers would go for it. Heck toss in a ham sandwich as well. C'mon get real🤣

[@RealJotaEme]

The Browns would never take that lmao

[@JoTrev1]

There was a reason no team wanted to trade for Watson 😂

[@Will-q7c]

We do this every trade deadline and every off season and it’s a complete waste of time. This front office doesn’t make bold moves,they will keep their picks and continue to be average and Myles will end up in Philly or somewhere not here.

[@IsaacMSingleton1]

Probably end up across from bosa on the niners or something absurd

[@stephenweiss6001]

If history repeats itself, the Packers will get outbid for Garrett. Would be great to have him, but I don't see it as likely, and I would not blame Gutekunst if they're outbid. I will blame Gutekunst for other things, like trading Rodgers a year too late and for such a poor hitting % in round 1, but not for not giving away the whole farm to get Garrett.

[@nenosdeewa2048]

He tried for Taylor too (colts RB)

[@TimMorgan5150]

Love the idea of the '26 First rounder being the basis of a Myles trade. That was my first thought too. Do it.

[@dannyjoherrin4559]

I don't understand why you can't just trade anyone at any time? You need money to trade people?

[@PackADayPodcast]

When you trade a player, any prorated signing bonuses immediately count against your salary cap unless it is after June 1st. So in the case of Myles Garrett - he has $36.2 million in prorated bonuses that would all accelerate to the Browns current salary cap if he was traded. Now his cap number if he's on the team this season is $19.7 million - so the difference is only $16.5 million but the Browns would take on that additional $16.5 million in salary cap hit if they traded him right now - and they don't have that money - therefore they would need to find a way to cut over $16.5 million from their salary cap before they could actually trade Myles Garrett.

[@zacharysmith608]

Best Episodes

[@briansischo]

Guys, there are some damn good pass rushers in this draft. Green and princely we could get.

[@briansischo]

The big key to this next season the absolute most important even over a Myles Garrett trade, is Jordan Love improving. Fundamentals, footwork, and decision making. Nothing else matters if he doesn’t improve. Get Jordan an amazing coach.

[@packers0611]

Sick of waiting for a draft pick to hit, go get one of the most dominant defenders in football.

[@dougpearson9602]

The way gutey picks in the 1st round. Trade 2 years of first rounders for Garrett, no loss. It will more than likely be stupid picks anyway

[@IsaacMSingleton1]

It's not going to be enough, every team is going to want Garret and if it only takes 2 firsts, multiple teams ahead of green bay in the draft will have the advantage.

[@josephgleason6534]

Get him. All of Packer nation will forgive you for not having a first at the draft. Just show his face on the projector screen as the browns go up with the 23rd selection.

[@jefferyzielke7665]

I always prefer dominant guys who play on the line of scrimmage. I would say it would be money and capital well spent.

[@peterharmon6778]

As much as Goody hates doing these kinds of deals, if you can stop the QB, he won’t be able to make the throws to the deep receivers. Therefore, our weakness at cornerback could be easier filled, than get a couple lineman DK TAE and then the s s Super Bowl graphic will be green!. Then Lefluer should get a little gutsy in his play calling. Then fill the team with the good you find elsewhere. Go all in

[@transrightsbaybee]

its not gonna happen but it would be so fun!!

[@Swizz12]

Give up what (besides the cost of the contract) for Garrett ? A first round pick, probably more, and likely a player too. What for ? A 30yr old player. Sure Garrett is very good (or at least was) but for how long ? Very short term thinking.

[@jimmylegs06]

I know we are early in this Love Era. The team is super young. But its be 15 YEARS since GBs last super bowl It was super bowl 45. Next year will be 60!!! Go do what gets you there NOW

[@KalThuemler]

Green bay needs to do it, but do not execute until Draft night so that way they can build suspense and give us something to talk about.

[@robertswisher6311]

We may need more than one player but a Garret would DRASTICALLY improve our defense by helping the other Dl/Edge by taking the focus of the offense and this would help the LB and CB with a better pass rush.

[@davidcaby9042]

Wait for the Bears to sign him, then say Aw shucks!

[@gregcox9556]

Mack is the answer on the edge. Fits perfectly. Sign Dalman (center) from Atlanta. Bolstered both sides of the line. Keeps you in the market for free agents in 2026 and 2027. Plug and play.

[@chadink]

Myles Garrett is a beast, but he is turning 30 years old this year. Something to think about when it comes to the picks and the contract. What if he starts to get injury prone? There's a lot of variables here. I wouldn't be mad if we did though.

[@ahhhereleaveitout]

Love me some off season Justis. GPG

[@TripleXonly]

Guys, you're overlooking the landscape of the division! The Packers are the 3rd best team in the division. The 1st place Lions are also gonna be taking a swing at Garrett! If the Lions pull that off the Packers will not be a 1st place team again for the next 4-6 year facing Garrett and Hutchinson twice a year. If the Packers bring in Garrett without losing much,we will be toe to toe with the Lions and the whole NFC. This is important to pay attention to.

[@mattdunn4881]

Let’s goooooooo love Justin!

[@isolationradio1911]

Would be great to have him. Somehow he ends up Detroit or Minnesota

[@Scott-sb1xi]

Boy, was I wrong about Myles leaving Cleveland last week. I hope the Packers get him but there's alot of competition for him.

[@Power4Bravo]

What happened to going after Maxx Crosby ? Did we or do we have a chance to get him ?

[@johnnyo5915]

Stay away from Mack...Jack! Way too many Myles on him.

[@georgecarr4633]

"Let's go do the thing!!" Altogether now... "Let's go do the thing!"

[@starstart23]

Love the DK pick but I also think we would be giving up too much for Garrett. I’d give up a 1 and a future 2 and that’s prob not gonna get it done

[@blueflameSM]

Paying Garrett if you trade for him does not break it for me. You pay great players, I’d trade and pay him in a heartbeat.

[@rokbeast4291]

Go get our next reggie white!

[@MrHeeebz]

Thanks Andy. We as Packer fans are so lucky to have both of you guys, but you guys together are like majic. As far as Garret? No way Gutey is doing that. I don't mind trading 1st round picks away because his history with them are not that good. But the draft being in GB especially not. He wiil sign a CB and drart about four of them and a couple of tackles and turn them into guards. But Garret, aint happenin.

[@kevinbrown0090]

Philly has been to the Superbowl 3 since our 1 time,but we are so called title town,let that marinate in your head...🤔😔😩😭

[@PackerBacker911]

We're called Titletown because we won most of our "Title's" before the Super Bowls era.

[@kreed4480]

Oh now we want to sell out for Garrett?? Lmao I been saying this

[@Pnw208]

There is a zero percent chance the packers trade their first and second round pick in the first year they’ve ever help the draft in Green Bay

[@PackADayPodcast]

Which is why Justis' proposal was a 2025 2nd and a 2026 1st ; )

[@matt_valentine]

You know what, screw it -- let's get Cooper Kupp! Haha.

[@adamphillips6865]

I’d like to keep Malik Willis if possible

[@shanebuske3311]

Man the amount of people that think we are 1 pass rusher away from the championship game is crazy. None of your Wrs can beat man coverage besides Watson. Coach refuses to feature a TE, what a waste of draft capital. Nah im signing Mack, and drafting Savonn Williams and Prater from Maryland.

[@dougpearson9602]

Garrett would be great. Don't see Gutey giving up 1st round picks. I don't think he's ever done it .

[@hasamikun]

Regarding the trade proposal by Justis: I dont think teh Browns are interested in an injured CW9 and I would like to keep lloyd in this offense. Maybe put someone like LVN and Doubs in there.

[@IsaacMSingleton1]

I think browns taking Willis, Gary, 2 firsts, and maybe something later would interest them, a veteran Willis for a bridge QB and start over. can dump Gary's contract at the end of the season, but I think they will get a better package.

[@hasamikun]

@@IsaacMSingleton1 I dont think they are able to take on Garys contract given their cap situation. They need cheap contracts, not a behemoth contratc like Garys, especially with the added dead cap due to a potenzial Garrett trade

[@IsaacMSingleton1]

@hasamikun Ah I see thanks for clarifying. Willis isn't under contract either correct? I think the chances are the browns end up with a top 10 picks this year, a first rounder next year, a 2nd rounder somewhere in these 2 drafts, and some mid level picks plus 1 NFL starting caliber player. I think this trade is going to be absurd

[@gregjankowski2115]

Why would they want Watson, he is not going to play almost all year

[@bowlofsoup12]

I would not make that trade Justis had said. Nah. Giving up to many players

[@jacobmckevitt6735]

Stupid Question: Can the Browns and Garrett negotiate a restructure, and then trade him? Something where it makes it easier to trade him, and then he signs another new contract with his new team? Is that even possible? If Garrett really does just want out, the Browns can maximize the capitol they get from him, Garret is happy because he will then actually get traded-- hopefully to the Packers-- and both parties split amicably. I doubt this is possible with NFL rules and whatnot, but I wanted to ask.

[@PackADayPodcast]

Theoretically yes, but in this scenario it doesn't help anything. You can't change the prorated signing bonuses that are the main issue here and his base salary is already as low as it can go - so in this case there's no way to make that work.

[@jimmyd102000]

No, the Browns cannot do anything to lesson the cap hit on Garrett if they trade him. The cap hits are almost entirely from previous years bonuses that have already been paid but were prorated to hit later. You can push cap out to future years, but you always end up paying it eventually.

[@KalThuemler]

Besides Gut has a tough time with 1st rounders so why not?

[@Javen2600]

Khalil and DK or Myles? Which option would you fans rather have?

[@willelkins8225]

Romans 10:9-10 "That if you confess with your mouth, "Jesus is Lord," and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For it is with your heart that you believe and are justified, and it is with your mouth that you confess and are saved

[@danielrblend]

Gutey will not trade away a first rounder for any player, period... will not happen. We need to develop our current pass rushers besides throwing more players at it. Our ability to draft and develop players is the problem, so more players won't fix it, just bandage it temporarily.

[@ccarrol1881]

I’d rather trade Doubs than Watson, and no one will trade for Watson anyway. Try and resign Watson to a 1 year prove it deal. You can find a Doubs in every draft, not to mention his concussion history

[@clintjefferson4391]

Still wouldn't be enough to beat the Bears.

[@robertswisher6311]

what about Hendrickson of the Bengals? free agent.

[@PackADayPodcast]

Unfortunately he's not a free agent.

[@Pnw208]

Would you rather have metcalf and Adam’s or Garrett

[@pedromartins4185]

BG needs to be aggressive and get him - he is worth at least a 1st and a 2nd round + a starter such as CW9

[@verkaimarshall4463]

3 kicks missed...had a crucial miss in the playoffs against Philly.

[@daviddemeuse5660]

A fruit punch Mountain Dew kickstart! Have you tried the orange pineapple mango Andy?

[@PackADayPodcast]

I haven't but the orange ones are the greatest thing on earth.

[@benswanson5394]

I disagree. Picks, not those players for Garrett. BUT, I'm also in the neighborhood of bring Davante home and try to draft Jaylen Royal(s)? As the speed option while Watson is out.

[@benswanson5394]

And they could be a premium pass rusher away from seriously contending. If they have a Garrett or Crosby, they might not need as improvement in CB room.

[@jeffwubker7445]

Ah no. Do not get him. I want draft picks. Garrett is one major injury from Brian G losing his career

[@orangeofmars2835]

I would like to see Myles Garrett but not at the expense of Day or 2 draft picks. If they can get him in FA then fine. If not, then not. There are some saying 2 firsts. No way. Teams that pay double first round picks for any player (or even 1st and 2nd), QB or whatever, works out badly so often. No way. Just ask the Jets, Browns or Raiders if they would do it again. I would stop watching Packer Football if the Packers did that and I have been an avid Packer fan my whole life and look forward every weekend to watch them. A 1st and 2nd for Garrett is a swing and a miss and a loss of the game.

[@Matt-yq3gq]

Go look at the list of first round picks for like the last 40 years when they didn’t need a QB. If you’d give up your fandom cuz they gave up 2 picks in the mid to late 20s for a 29 year old already HOfer, that’s quite sad sorry to say lol

[@mart8441]

Gute won't make this happen. He loves to draft his 1st Rd projects. He surely lands in Detroit or Washington

[@joeo4496]

Hes drafted three projects in the 1st round: Gary, Love, and LVN and the first two of those hit.

[@christopherweise438]

@@joeo4496 - Did they though? They both had one good half season. They got paid off of just that.

[@mart8441]

@joeo4496 Walker, Wyatt, Stokes, LVN...4 first Rd picks I would EASILY swap for Garrett. Not sure about Morgan yet

[@Matt-yq3gq]

@@joeo4496while getting minimal ROI on their rookie contracts and then paying them a boatload of money.

[@SigmaNuHE481]

I'd rather trade for Kupp if we're going to trade for someone

[@leehemmersbach8018]

Really? He is 31 yrs old. Davante is better

[@xShinobiRonin]

Kupp was terrible last year. He is washed.

[@christopherweise438]

@ - Davante is not better than Kupp. Packer fans need to get over these nostalgia signings.

[@clayhohertz9742]

Give up 2 firsts, LVN, and Doubs. Screw it im ready to win!

[@christopherweise438]

The draft is finally coming to GB......and you want us to have no 1st round picks?

[@xShinobiRonin]

@@christopherweise438he didn’t say which year the picks would be

[@christopherweise438]

@@xShinobiRonin - They will be at least this year and probably next year if it's two first rounders. Do you not know how trades work? Teams want their picks ASAP.

[@mart8441]

@@christopherweise438 Who cares? If we get Garrett instead, I can easily wait for day 2 of the draft

[@christopherweise438]

@ - We trade away our draft capital for maybe 3 years of Garrett. We are more than just an edge rusher away from being a real contender.

[@El-hefe_]

i said in the trade window during the season we should have gone to get Garrett.

[@anonymoushuman3004]

One issue with this trade. We have big questions at QB and WR, and until this is resolved, investing to much resources D# might be the wrong move. There is a good chance that next season, we are looking for a new QB. I would say let's invest I'm WR, CB, DT, LB, OL

[@IsaacMSingleton1]

What an absolutely dumb trade proposal.

[@ripack78]

Trade Willis Enagbare and a 3 for Denzel Ward and a 6. Trade Walker LVN Jaire Doubs and a 2 for Maxx Crosby and a 5. Sign Tae if cut. Qb: Love - Rush (FA) Rb: Jacobs - Lloyd - Brooks Wr: Adams(FA)-Wicks-Melton Wr: Egbuka(24OhSt)-Reed-Shenault(FA)-Watson(IR TE: Kraft - Gyllenborg (239Wy) TE: Musgrave - Sims LT: Morgan - vet swing T LG: Jenkins- Monk C: Myers(2yr12mil)-Majors(161UT RG:Rhyan- Glover/Telford RT: Tom - Barber (144UF) DE: Crosby-Swimson(123LSU-Cox DT: Clark - Brooks - Wooden DT: Wyatt - Phillips (140Maryland) DE: Gary-Turner(FA)-Mosby LB: Cooper-Hooper-Kiser(200ND) LB: Walker - Wilson(FA) Hybrid: Bullard CB: Ward-Nixon-Alexander(206OR CB:Valentine-Harris(160IA)-King FS: McKinney- Anderson SS: Williams - Oladapo K: McManus(Resign) P: Whelan KR/PR: Shenault (FA)

[@ripack78]

Raiders need a rebuild. They can use picks to trade up to get a QB. Maybe Sanders. They get a LT for future. Gute isn’t giving Walker big money. LVN project DE with their high pick Wilson. They don’t have any WR. Doubs closer to home and nice fit there. Jaire can redo deal. They need a corner

[@RaymondBrean-z4d]

For the Green Bay Packers and Brian Gutekunst, making a phone call to ask about Myles Garrett’s asking price should be a no-brainer. Giving Myles Garrett a new deal would eat up a large portion of the team’s available salary cap source, but if they found a way to acquire him, it would give them one of the NFL’s best edge rushers to pair with Rashan Gary. The Green Bay Packers may be unwilling to give up their 1st-round draft pick in 2025 , but their other draft picks and even future draft picks in 2026 could be on the table. An elite pass-rusher could do wonders for the Green Bay Packers’ defense. It’s unlikely to play out for a number of reasons, but it’s hard not to think about what this defense could do with a player this caliber of getting after the opposing quarterback. Go Pack Go 💚💚💛💛

[@PackerBacker911]

Gute is lacking the seeds it takes to pull of a trade like this.