Critical analysis of Sufism and its origins - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

www.yanabi.com - Urdu - Critical analysis of Tasawwuf and its origins. An insightful endeavor into the world of Sufism.

[@qaisarmasood1425]

غامدی صاحب! میں اہل تصوف کے بہت سے نظریات کو ایک عرصے تک اپنے عقلی فہم کے مطابق تشکیک کی نظر سے دیکھتا تھا لیکن آج آپ کا یہ لیکچر سن کر میری اچھی طرح تشفی ہو گئی ہے۔ اللہ آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا کرے۔

[@hafizmalik335]

read a book by Maulana thanvi "Ashrf u tareek fil shariah wal hakikah" urdu. may Allah save you from this fitna. he stands no where in comparison to great sufiya e kiram. it is the domain of enlightenment not mere logical math

[@korikrali]

Every single word of this lecture is worth in GOLD. What a scholar he is MashAllah.

[@rabifaraz]

Awesome academic, philosophical and to the the point approach towards the "Sufiism". Never heard anything like that so complete... Jazak Allah.

[@ahmedhassan6943]

Subhan Allah, What a scholar, may Allah guard you against all evil and grant you a long healthy life Ghamdi sahib.

[@ikramabbasi3370]

Thanks Ghamdi Shahib for such a great analysis. You have exploded the myth of Sufism. Our Ulemas must learnfrom you. Thanks once again

[@justmohsin]

I am glad I come cross this video. My mostly friends belongs to tassawuff and I was discussing these matters with them. First they have very wrong interpretation of Quran and about Prophets. He said the same thing as Ghamidi sahab mentioned that these sufi wrote in their books. They have their own concept on Jannat and their all sufi has blood relationship back to Hazrat Ali RA. I was telling them the same thing how can you have hightest rank than prophets?. And how you can have different jannat than what Quran says and Prophets told us but he said the same that this is for normal people. I can't believe Ghamidi sahab explained the same points. hats off to you Sir. I am even more clearer than ever and more louder than ever that sufism is parallel religion and it has nothing to do with Quran and Prophet MUHAMMED PBUH rasalat. Jazak Allah al akhair

[@waqeeaqeel]

This *is* Ghamidi Sahib in his youth 😄

[@Adept.maneuver]

Mai ustaz Ghamidi ki muqallid nahi hu par mujhe dar hai k mai in se 💯% agree krne lag jau g. Koi to aisi baat ho jis mei mai ikhtilaaf kr saku. Jitna inko sun rai hu, mujhe in se muhabbat hoti ja rai hai. Ye mere rohani baap hain. Allah inko sehet wali zindagi aur dunya aur akhirat mei aafiat e kamila ata farmae. Aur hamay b taufeeq de huq baat samjhne aur kehne ki.

[@neutral3023]

no doubt he is a modern Islamic scholar. unbending all the misinterpretations made by our facade society. Agree with you

[@gulfamhussain7751]

Apko aur ghamdi sb dono ko apne nazriyat pay shadid ghor karny ki zrorat hy.Ghamdi sb ilm e kalam ky mahir Hain aur ek raij shuda aur tasdeeq shuda ilm ko jis ky natijay Mai aksriyat Mai khair nikli hy apne ilm e kalam ky zor pay osy rad karty hain.aur baton Mai inki shadid contradiction hy.ek aam musalman ko inki baat bohat bhali aur logical lagti hy khas kar west zada logon ko magar haqiqat iskay bar aks hy.shak ki gunjaish nahi ky sufion Mai bohat quake's hue jis se sufizm ko bohat nuqsan bhi pohncha magar yeh molvion ki interpretation se phir bhi bohat behtar hy.Agar ap inky nazriyat ko theek manoo tu duniya ky 95 % musalman kafir ho Jayen gy.

[@gulfamhussain7751]

@@neutral3023 mohsin kush mat bano bhai.agar koi cheez apko samjh naa aye tu iska Matlab yeh nahi ky wo cheez haqeeqat nahi rakhti.alama iqbal ny tmam umar sufizm pay believe Kiya magar osky corrupt elements ko critisice bhi Kiya.

[@Adept.maneuver]

@@gulfamhussain7751 kya bat hai apki. Dil ko khush kr dia apki taqreer ne. Bethey bethey kufr k fatway! Keep it up bhai.

[@sheikh_in_Vr]

JazakAllah brother, May Allah SWT bless you Ameen

[@tahirasiddiqui1210]

May Allah subhano ta'ala bless you for this great effort. Indeed a great learning. May Allah safe us from these innovations and guide us to the right path. Amen.

[@phlegmatic...4057]

Ameen

[@hajimuhammad6423]

Allahhummakhfaz hum. Thank Wasalam.

[@TheUsman141]

Got rid of my many years old confusion. May Allah bless and protect Ghamidi sahib

[@gulfamhussain7751]

Actually now you are in great confusion my dear brother.ghamdi is 100% not an ideal islamic scholar.osky apne nazriyat Hain Jo ky kisi khas qisam ky tassub py mabni hain.yeh duniya tu hy he confusion aur contradictions.clarity tu bus Allah ki zaat hy.sufizm ki islam ki interpretation molvion se baddarjha behtar hy.molvion ny logon ko deen se dour Kiya un se nafrat ki sufion ny unhyn galay laga kar deen aur shariat sikhai asal sufion ka rutba bohat buland hy.jo had se tajavuz nahi karty bus wo sufi.jese mirza qadiyani kar gya tajavuz aur randa e dargah hua.sufizm islam se alag koi cheez nahi hy yeh islam ki rooh ki taraqi yafta shakal hy.jo namaz Mai niyat aur khazu o khashu hy osi ka naam sufizm hy.jiska natija khair niklay wo cheez kese ghalat ho gi.nikah Mai niyat na ho tu nikah nahi hota namaz Mai niyat na ho tu bus ek exercise hy.ustaad wohi hota Jo tadbeer se Kam lay woh ustad nahi jis ki jamaat Mai koi bethna na chahy

[@mujahidhussain9581]

@@gulfamhussain7751 Lagta h aap bhi koi sufi h, agar aapne is pure video ko dekhne k baad is tarah ki nazariyat ko pakre hue h tab bahut mushkil h aapko samjhana. Quran aur sunnat me is tarah ki koi baat nhi h. Aap Quran aur sunaat ka mutala kijiye tab ja k baat aapko khud hi samajh me ayegi

[@gulfamhussain7751]

@@mujahidhussain9581 bhai agar ghamdi sb ko mana jaye tu Kam az Kam 90% musalmano ko phir se kalma parhna parry ga aur apne bazurgo ko bhi kafir declare karna parray ga.ghamdi sb ki apni soch hy apna ilm hy .magar onhon ny jis zaviye se ilm hasil karny ki koshish ki hy wo zaviya he ghalt hy.sufizm ki islamic interpretation hy ya mullaizm ki interpretation ap pehly pory dhehan se dono py ghor karo ky sufizm ny islam ky liye Kya khidmat di hain aur mullaizm ny kya.jawab mil jaye ga

[@gulfamhussain7751]

@@mujahidhussain9581 duniyaon ko musakhar karna quran Mai he likha hy karo.ilm hasil karny ki kitni talqeen nabi saww ny ki apko batanay ki zrorat nahi.sufizm bhi ek ilm hy bus.shariat ky khilaf agar jaye tu soo lantyn bhejo shariat e nabi saww se opar kuch nahi.ap pora vedio ghor se dekho.sufi ek khas ilm ki baat karty aam logon ki samjh Mai nahi aa sakti aur onhon ny 99.9% kabhi logon ko os taraf lanay ki koshish nahi ki.5th grade ky bachy ko phd ka syllabus nahi parhaya jata.''خاصاں دی گل آماں دے نال نھیں مناسب کرنی۔ میٹھی کھیر پکا محمد کتیاں اگے دھرنی

[@InstantPsyche]

@@gulfamhussain7751 جی اس شعر کو ہی لے لیجئے دوسرے مصرعے سے یہ بات سامنے آتی ہے محمد الرسول اللہ نے پورا دین نہیں پہنچایا، محبت بھی جھلک رہی ہے۔ اور تصوف تو ایسا ہی ہے کہ سمجھایا نہیں جاتا بس دہرایا جاتا ہے۔ بحث اس بات پر نہیں کہ کس نے کس کو کیا دیا؟، کس نے زیادہ یا کم دیا؟، بحث اس بات پر ہے کہ حق کو پانے کا یہ طریقہ دین میں ہے یا نہیں؟

[@rickhson8463]

thank you javed ghamdi sahib best speech and eyes opning about right aqida.

[@sophosalpha]

This man has a gifted intellect

[@khamisakbar]

Ab Dilawar - He is a big threat to the mullahs! May he stay safe from them. People like Ghamidi do not come every day.

[@o56_idress_ahmed_ee32]

Yes, he is hero of the Muslim ummah

[@aarifboy]

Ye video Ghamdi ki mullaiyat ko nanga kerne ke liye kaafi hai kzbin.info/www/bejne/rprRhoKebsmDfpo

[@aarifboy]

@Tech mdanish Ghamdi Mullah bechara Pak se bhaag ker America kapde lene hee tau gaya hai lol. Mullay nange ho gaye sab hehe

[@mohammaddar4773]

@@aarifboy کُتے تم اپنی بکواس بند کرو

[@Drsalmanzafar]

may Allah bless you it is really a eye opener lecture with facts and references

[@gulfamhussain7751]

Jis cheez se aksriyat Mai khair bramad hua wo ghalat kese hui ???

[@muhammadomer9648]

Khair ko maapney ka alaa tu batayay key tassawuf sey Khair hey phootey tassawuf key intiha shirk hey aur shirk key Koy muaafy Nahin fana FIL shaikh Kya hey Zara batain

[@onedirectionlover08]

This is the best critique on this difficult topic. May Allah protect you and give you the ability to guide ordinary muslims everywhere. Ameen

[@atiqahmedkhan5569]

جزاک اللّٰہ اتنی وضاحت اتنے سادہ الفاظوں میں اتنے واضح دلائل اور اقتسابات کے بعد تصوف کی اصل شکل واضع ھونے کے بعد تصوف سے ھزار بار توبہ اگر اپنا ایمان بچانا ھے تو۔

[@mohdshafi6044]

The speaker is a loyal person What an understanding and truthfulness

[@mellownuance]

Ajj ke baad se tassawuf bhi ''Haji tariq full Farigh'' - Big up for my man Javed Ghamidi Sb. knockin off biddat from the feet up!

[@JunaidSalehHayat]

May Allah bless Ghamidi sahib!

[@aarifboy]

Ye video Ghamdi ki mullaiyat ko nanga kerne ke liye kaafi hai kzbin.info/www/bejne/rprRhoKebsmDfpo

[@anerkant]

@@aarifboy why do you post your qadyani videos everywhere...you in your video speak nothing for 2 hours except hate and anger.

[@aarifboy]

@aner kannt Truth is bitter, u heard it thats why u r spreading hate for me lol. Just read 4th verse of Surah Qadar, dont follow uneducated fools like Ghamdi hehe.

[@mohammaddar4773]

@@aarifboy پرانی کہانیاں پرانے بانے قرآن ہی میزان ہے اور دین وہی ہے جو محمد آل رسول اللہ نے دیا اور صحابہ کرام نے عمل کیا اب لوگ کشف الہام کو نہی مانتے جو صحابہ نے کبھی دعوہ نہی کیا

[@aatifkazi139]

JazakAllahu khair sir ...what a great wisdom Allah grant u.Really how deeply ur explanation.An eye opener for ummah

[@zaheerahmed9549]

Excellent, can't find words to praise you, may Allah bless you for this beautiful work.

[@hafizmalik335]

the greatest logical philosopher of our history was Imam Ghazali he accepted the fact that it was only because of tasawuf that i became transformed and was saved from doubt.

[@sheikh_in_Vr]

Totally agreed, May Allah SWT bless Ghamidi sahb & team Ameen.

[@raanimughal8405]

Aankhen khol dene wala tajzia... is lie nhi k ap ne biyan Kia is lie k ye haqaiq p mabni tha..Muhtaram Ghamdi sahb Allah ap ko lmbi seht wali zndgi de..aameen..

[@doctorsabir5]

THANKS FOR SHARING.... JAZAK ALLAH FOR YOUR HONEST RESEARCH...AND TELLING IT LIKE IT IS.....SABIR SINDHU/ LAHORE

[@hujjatullah1978]

Mashallah.out standing...Allah ne ap se apny deen ki khidmat li.

[@iZeeshan]

Best analysis of sufism...great job sir....blessing for u...

[@mohammadrubanimalik4548]

Mr Ghamidi Sahab the level of intellect 😱

[@bawa_jani]

*Bulldozer for Batil* Salam for Ghamidi Sahab - Ustad e Muhatram

[@letstryapple]

Well explained the roots of Sufism...travelling back in time, 32 years back in 1989...

[@buttaurangzeb7221]

Javed ghamidi just love it Allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti dey all time great for me I don't think any another better prayer than this prayer Allah qabool farmaye aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤️ ♥️

[@TM0425]

Looks like an old lecture of Ghamidi Sahib. He is probably the best Islamic scholar of present times. Don’t know whether he has any change in his views since the recording of this video. His approach is the most rational. Being a rational person myself, I like him very much. The problem though is that as soon a person grows spiritually, the first realization dawns that the intellect, rationality and mind are created to help us live effectively in this reality called life. They are not effective in experiencing other unseen realities. Mind is nothing but a tool like eyes, ears, nose to sense and perceive the world in a certain way, human way. The reality is beyond the seen world. Quran defines the believers as those who believe in the unseen. What the unseen mentioned in Quran 2:3 means? Allah. One cannot see Allah with human eyes even though he is nearer to man than his jugular vein (Quran 50:16). Mind is the barrier between our human self (or ego) and our soul. Sufi practices which are aligned with Quranic concepts like Ihsan (perfection), sacrifice, forgiveness and repentance (Astaghfaar), as well as rituals like prayers, zikr, salat and fasting attempt to silence the mind. If a person is able to quiet the mind, he or she can feel the soul which is our connection to God or the Unseen.

[@justmohsin]

Tanveer Mansoor : no he hasn't changed his views. He still believes that tassawuff is parallel religion. and I fully agree with him.

[@TM0425]

@@justmohsin Good thing is that Tasawwuf is parallel to religion and not against it. What this means is that one could still follow religion while being a Sufi. This is proven by the lecture itself since he has quoted from renowned and well read Muslim scholars who were great religious teachers as well as sufis.

[@justmohsin]

@@TM0425 But Islam based on Quran o Sunnah and we get it directly from Prophet Muhammad PBUH. At that time the full Authentic Hadith knowledge was not compiled that is why 4 great imams issued same fatwa that if any of their fatwa goes against Authentic Hadith then throw our fatwa on the wall and follow the authentic hadith because they themselves based on Hadiths and they didn't had all the hadiths because the companions of Prophet Muhammad PBUH spread out on different locations. Later imams like Imam Bhukhari, Imam Muslims , imam abu dawood etc done great work to compiled them. But this knowledge was compiled on later stages and in authentic Hadiths as well as in daef Hadith you will not find sufism concept at all. Sufism itself based on personal experience and by scientific facts your experience is different than my experiences we are humans but different individuals the simplest example is you may say half glass full and I would say half glass empty but in Islam the glass is full and completed. You can't add or subtract anything from Islam and your personal or my personal experience doesn't has any value in Islam. Even if you study tassawuf you will see there is already different groups who disagree with each other on many things. The Truth is Allah is one, he made one religion and he sent last one prophet PBUH to who we should follow. The great 4 imams said themselves you cannot disagree with Allah and his messenger but you can disagree with anyone. You can disagree with me I can disagree with you but I haven't compiled any of sahih hadith and I am not author of it but if I read Hadith of Prophet PBUH and some scholar, imam, sufi said something else I will follow Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Obey Allah and his Rasool PBUH. may Allah guide you people. Ameen

[@TM0425]

​@@justmohsin okay?

[@prakharprabhat585]

This is absolutely true. In Hinduism awakening is defined as the death of the mind. Limited mind dies and merges with the cosmic mind.

[@mnraies3646]

ہر شخص کو چاہئے کہ اپنا جائزہ لے وہ کہاں کھڑاہے ایسا نہ ہو کہ حق کے واضح ہوجانے کے بعد بھی گمراہی کو ترجیح دے ۔

[@drjollygood]

In short this person is “ imam asr i hazar”

[@badermunir5944]

This century is ustaaz Ghamidi's century.

[@aarifboy]

Ye video Ghamdi ki mullaiyat ko nanga kerne ke liye kaafi hai kzbin.info/www/bejne/rprRhoKebsmDfpo

[@anerkant]

@@aarifboy why do you post your qadyani videos everywhere...you in your video speak nothing for 2 hours except hate and anger.

[@aarifboy]

@aner kannt Dont follow me everywhere just like u follow Ghamdi lol. Follow Quran, read 4th verse of Surah Qadar hehe

[@badermunir5944]

@@anerkant Sir ! once again Bader Munir with u. This bloody subman is void of humanity respect tolerance khowledge logic & healthy discission. I wanted to learn as a humble student & gave him full respect but in response I received insult. I am so sorry , sir , then I had to reply him in his tone & language in Urdu. Such a nonsence animal is having his own channel I did not expect ? Sir if u know urdu, u may have a look my replies for that I m sad. With my best wishes..Bader Munir.

[@tabuwaseem336]

The only content doesn't need any editing even background sound isn't disturbing just appealing directly to heart......

[@zdrashdi]

ہمارے لئے بس قرآن و سنت کا دین کافی ہے۔ ہماری دعا ہے "ربنا لا تزغ قلوبنا بعد از ھدیتنا و ھب لینا من الدنک رحمۃ انک انت الوھاب" آمین۔ "الھم ارینا الحق حقا و رزقنا اتباعہ و ارینا الباطل باطلا و رزقنا اجتنابہ" آمین۔ "الھم انی آعوذ بک من جمیع الفتنہ ما ظھر منھا و ما باطن" آمین۔

[@truthlover423]

اللہ تعالی آ پ کا حامی و مددگار ہو. کوئی شک نہیں آ پ نے حق بات کی ھے. آپ کی بہادری جرات کو سلام.

[@abdulhaq3793]

Sufism is amalgamation of pantheism. Greek philosophy . It has has no concern with Islam

[@mms0254]

also derived from judiaism Kabbalah

[@umairhasan8671]

This philosophy has always been in some form with every religion

[@shafirahaman]

That is why they Jews and Shia use it to betray the Muslims and take them to Hell Fire. The Shaiatan is an open enemy to the Humans (every human).

[@muhammadashfaq9697]

EXCELLENT, Young man, true speaking.

[@asmaasma1105]

Great scholar of this era

[@KhuramRazaAbadAli]

اللہ پاک جانتا ہے کہ آپ کو سننا بہت بڑی نعمت ہے،جزاک اللہ

[@truthlover423]

Great speaker, intellectual, and honest. It is absolutely true that Quran is a message of Tauheed.

[@ms.k7807]

Amazing'''also astonished' why 39 dislikes? Even he presented honestly with references .

[@shahidnisarhashmi7716]

شیطان دنیا سے مکمل ختم نہیں ھو سکتا اس دنیا میں۔

[@shahidnisarhashmi7716]

شیطنت تو ساتھ رھے گی نا تا قیامت۔

[@aarifboy]

Ye video Ghamdi ki mullaiyat ko nanga kerne ke liye kaafi hai kzbin.info/www/bejne/rprRhoKebsmDfpo

[@anerkant]

@@aarifboy *why do you post your qadyani videos everywhere...you in your video speak nothing for 2 hours except hate and anger.*

[@Iqbalqazi2012]

Assalamualaikum you can expect anything from gumraah brainless people

[@swdsandhu]

Jazakallah khair 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰 the Great scholar Sir Ghamdi Sahib

[@JalalUdDin-fo5db]

Great lecture! Wow Masha’Allah, JazakAllah

[@yousafkhalid4870]

Very good knowledge 👍 thanks love for Ghamidi Sahib....

[@hafizmalik335]

Lakho logo ko andhere se nikal ne wale sufiya e kiram ki azmat ko salam

[@mohammadnaeemkhan3671]

One just wonders about Allama Iqbal's "Quran fehmi" on one hand, and eulogising sufi aspect in his otherwise sky high literary poetry. Will this pollution be ever purged out of Islam before QIAMAH! The impression is, with tasawuf's deep roots it will linger on forever. May Allah bless you Ghamadi Sahib.

[@WaqarAhmed-jo3bv]

I thought Tasawuf was the only right path until I saw this...lol

[@mianmuhammadathar9669]

Subhaan Allah, what a study and what a wisdom. Allah has granted a great vision to Ghamdi Sab.

[@aarifboy]

Ye video Ghamdi ki mullaiyat ko nanga kerne ke liye kaafi hai kzbin.info/www/bejne/rprRhoKebsmDfpo

[@anerkant]

@@aarifboy why do you post your qadyani videos everywhere...you in your video speak nothing for 2 hours except hate and anger.

[@aarifboy]

@aner kannt Dont follow me everywhere just like u follow Ghamdi lol. Follow Quran, read 4th verse of Surah Qadar hehe

[@gmkhan7647]

Yery good Bay

[@drcolmunirahmed9065]

MashaAllah very detailed discourse of tassawaf

[@adeeljaved7979]

Deepdive analysis, beautifully explained with references. JazakAllah

[@SajidPirzada-it7ii]

I wanted to know about Tasawuf for many years. Totally confused. Could not find answers. Modudi and Ghamidi SAHIB are two scholars to whom one can reach for answers on subject. I am so grateful to you for providing this gem.Audio quality is poor.I will be grateful for provision. If you have original recordings this can be improved by software. Kindly make it possible

[@Thinkoutsidethebox1840]

No brother it is original audio this lecture is from 1980s on ordinary microphone that’s why it feels like this but audio is clear just a little wof noise in the background anyway just a reservoir of knowledge

[@DrAneesAhmad]

Excellent, deep and different

[@bestoddlysatisfyingshorts8729]

this guy is a legend

[@muhammadomer9648]

No doubt waqiay Allah ney nawaza is admy ko

[@sheikh_in_Vr]

May Allah bless Ghamidi sahb Ameen.

[@darjaved2961]

peace upon u sir javedahmad Gamdhi

[@ameermirza1254]

kamaal Allah qaim rakhy apko ghamdi sahib

[@RizwanAhmad-cy5yo]

Great scholar indeed

[@hafizkhurram4456]

We are agree with your analysis,

[@4311446]

Best scholar of our times.

[@librastar2003]

A Superman for justice League of Islam

[@Ayan_quraishi]

Masallah ustad sahab

[@eng.muhammadali3476]

Origin of Sufism 7:43 Wahadat ul wajood 36:55 Sufism expose 58:27 Conclusion 1:13:54

[@mianzarrar3796]

Glt ino nay kbi nai kha alag parallal deen khtay.

[@Babarmeer18855]

محترم استاد محترم جناب غامدی صاحب اللہ آپکو صحت والی دراز عمر عطا فرمائے۔ تصوف کا پھندنا اسلام کے ساتھ ٹانگا جاتا رھا۔ آپ نے پورے سیاق کے ساتھ صوفی ازم کو ثابت فرما دیا کہ یہ اسلام نہیں بلکہ ایک متوازی دین ھے جو لوگوں نے لوگوں کی عقیدت میں کھڑا کر دیا۔ جو عقیدہ توحید سے ٹکرائے اور انسانوں میں سے کسی کا قد کاٹھ نبی مکرم اور اللہ کے پیغمبروں سے بڑا کرے، وہ اسلام نہیں ھو سکتا۔

[@advocateasfakahammed6685]

Great analysis

[@Ali.848]

Alhamdulillah beshak deen islam sirf quran or sunnat k mutabiq e h 💓

[@gulfamhussain7751]

Jo quran o sunnat se bahir ho wo sufi he nahi hota

[@jchvdmerwe]

why do you not have these things in ENGLISH

[@imranahmad360]

J.C Hugo van der Merwe the views of this man must be available in English as well. In written translation I guess. I appreciate your interest and this guy is the true person and the greatest ever scholar of all times. I am sure you are going to find it very interesting. God bless you my friend.

[@mubasherhassan790]

This is a detailed account of his study on how Sufi practices were adopted in Islam. He has spoken about it in other lectures as well. I cannot give you a word to word translation of this lecture but I will certainly give you a brief account of his views on Sufism. Please keep in mind that this account is "my understanding" of "his views"..... ======================================================= THE ULTIMATE QUESTION OF MAN: What is the purpose of life? Why are we here? Where are we going? Humans have sought answers in THREE types of traditions/methods..... METHOD ONE: Man used his intellect to answer these questions -- philosophy is born. Philosophy has a history spanning over more than 2000 years. METHOD TWO: A tradition emerges in the Indian subcontinent where it is believed that "the self" can open the door to all answers i.e. the outside world is the physical world but there is also a universe that exists inside of us. If we somehow unlock the secrets of our own self we might be able to reach where the divine self is located and experience the ultimate reality. Practices, meditations and chantings were developed overtime to unlock the secrets of the self, purify the self, travel through the self and reach reality/answers. The most prominent figure in this tradition is Buddha. The crux of this tradition is that the only real reality is God (which is also known as the Higher Self), all else is just illusion. This tradition considers “our body” as an obstruction in reaching the reality. Therefore they focus on "minimizing the body" by opposing all material desires to a point where the body no longer is an obstacle in connecting with the real reality. METHOD THREE: A third tradition emerges in the Middle East where a supernatural being (God/Allah) himself makes a contact with humans and tells them answers to all questions -- Abrahamic faiths are born. In Islamic tradition the scholars who created a patchwork between philosophy and Islam were known as "Mutakalimeen". They gave birth to Ilm-e-Kalam or 'scholastic theology'. Similarly the scholars who created patchwork between Islam and religions of the "self" were known as "Mutasawifeen" and they gave birth to Islamic Sufism. This scholar in the video also belongs to a Sufi family as his father was a Sufi Master of Junaidia Order himself. He received his early education in Islamic Sufism and rose to a position where he began teaching the key texts of Sufism to others. He also claims to have tasted all the wonderful experiences Sufism has to offer. But later on he came to a conclusion that Sufism and Abrahamic tradition are poles apart. He now considers that all the Sufi experiences and wonders are nothing more than gimmicks of the self. At one point he compares Sufism with "dreaming on steroids". All the voices of God that you hear during meditation and souls of the prophets that you meet are nothing more than "elaborate dreams". You may even perform miracles or predict the future accurately with your mind powers but again that is just an art and wonders of your inner self that anybody can learn. According to him the only correct path to reach God is through METHOD THREE that has been taught to us by God himself.

[@salmantahir7317]

Why do u want these in English? I can help u

[@shahidnisarhashmi7716]

May you find these things in English. Please check sites relating to Sir Ghamidi. Almawrid.com or ghamidi.com etc

[@mohammadnaeemkhan3671]

Because, sir, the West on the whole,is pantheisitic

[@ismailzahid5585]

He is no doubt a great scholar but understanding his extra ordinary vocabulary is difficult to understand for some. does any one have a link in which it is said in simpler words?

[@asfandyaralijutt706]

thanks sir !

[@rehanahmed4531]

Thank you so much sir i was jahil before litsinig to this lecture

[@ahmedshahzad8840]

Excellent Arguments! Anyone share the books which quote in this video?

[@Mohammadnaim1974]

بیسیار زیاد تشکر از معلومات ضروری برای هر مسلمان . دیره دیره مننه. 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@abidiqbal1385]

Allah AP ko ajar at kray

[@hafizmalik335]

Hadith may aata hai "Aakhir zamane k log apne pechlo ko bura bhala kaha karenge " tum ko dekh kar yaqeen hogaya. wala hu alam.

[@zaheerahmad3896]

GOD bless you all 💕

[@exposecrime4688]

یہ مضمون کس نام سے چھپا ہے اور کیسے مل سکتا ہے اتنی نیکی تو کوئی شاگرد رشید کر دے اور نیکی کما لے اور اگر pdf میں ہے تو لنک یہاں لگا دیا جائے

[@malikawan19]

غامدی صاحب کی کتاب برہان میں چھپا ہے۔ باب کا نام ‘اسلام اور تصوف’ ہے

[@muhammadrehman6985]

How a Muslim can dislike it

[@hafizmalik335]

indirectly this self styled scholar is trying to say that he knows more logic and Quran than Imam Ghazali, Allama ibn taimiyah, imam qushayri, shah waliullah and Allama Anwar shah kashmiri. Ahh ......i feel painful to see people praising tou.

[@akhtarshad3903]

Koi shak nahen tasawaf is the very right path to leed children of Adam to the Hal fire which has been set for the friends of Eblees

[@muhammadyounas740]

Azeem Insaaan

[@dr.muhammadansar9582]

Jazak Allah ghamidi sahib

[@abdulhaq3793]

jazakallah o khaira. less said well said

[@Drop_Easiest]

Before i was also following sufism, but now ism muslim, sufism bht barhi gumrahi hai

[@muhammadharees2225]

When this lecture was recorded?

[@IslamicVideosForAll]

my fav ❤️❤️❤️👌👌👌Tasawwuf تصوف وڈیوز۔ 🌺👈👈ضرور دیکھیں 👈👈

[@mohammadnaeemkhan3671]

It is extremely unnerving that, Allma Iqbal, accepted, rejected and then practiced WahdatulWjood till his last breath. Should a Muslim relinquish Quran or accept Allam Iqbal no more than the best of Persian / Urdu poets and no more? No sane person can afford 2nd opinion after this video.

[@WaseemAhmad-xk3po]

Tasawaf aik dean nahi ha .... Dean wohi ha jo Rasul e Pak na Quran o Sunnat ki shakal mein dia ha.... Yeh Ghamdi Sahib confuse ker raha hien. Mein na b ankh tasawaf ka mahol mein kholi ha aur Quran o Sunnat ko hi apni base rakha ha magar shariat ko follow kertay hoaya b bohat say haqaiq daikha aur moshahaday b kia magar at the end of the day we have to reach Allah via Radool ul Allah. Ishq make this journey quicker. Iqbal is prime example who keeps both side by side. Ghamdi Sahab is a very good scholar but could not reach the level of a sufi unfortunately. This is something which is decided by Allah Subhana Tallah.

[@Drop_Easiest]

Main ne b tasawuf ko qareeb se extreme level py daikha, yeh gumrahi k siwa kuch nahi hai

[@Abraar_ahmad_]

Ye khtm kyu hua yaar

[@saleemrehman9001]

Mula wali tasreeh farmai aap nay Ghamdi Sb.

[@nisarshaikh7807]

( ختم نبوت ) کے بارے میں (صوفی مذہب) کا فلسفہ کیا ہے ؟؟ یہ سچائی بھی لوگوں کو بتانا چاہیےء 🔼 " فاِنَ النبوۃ الّتي انقطعت باوجود رسول اللہ ﷺ انّما ھی نبوت التشریع لا مقامھا -" جو نبوت نبی ﷺ پر ختم ہویء وہ محض تشریعی نبوت ہے۔ یعنی کہ شریعت لانے والے نبی کی نبوت ہے۔ نبوت کا مقام باقی ہے۔ 🔼 فلا شرعَُ ناسخاً لشرعہ ﷺ۔ ولا یذید فی حکمہ شرعاً آخر وھزا معنی قولہٗ ﷺ۔ اِنَّ الرسالۃ وَ النبوۃ قد انقطعت فلا رسولَ بعدی ولا نبی -" نبوت کے ختم ہونے کا مطلب یہ ہے کہ اب کوئی نبی نیء شریعت نہیں لاےء گا۔ نبیﷺ کے بعد آنے والا کوئی نبی ایسا نہیں ہوگا جس کی شریعت نبی ﷺ کی شریعت کے خلاف ہو -بعد آنے والا نبی، نبیﷺ کی شریعت کا پابند ہوگا - Book Name 📕: Futuhat Al Makkiyh ✍️Writer - Shaikh Mohiyuddin ibne Arbi / founder of Sufism tasawwuf غلام احمد قادیانی نے اپنے دوسرا نبی ہونے کی دعویٰ داری میں صوفیاء کرام کی کتابوں کے حوالے پیش کےء ہیں📕۔

[@merajuddin5417]

Dear sir! You didn't say a single word about Awais Karni. Is he also annhilated? Is he also flowing helplessly in the mighty deluge of your research and analysis? The way you brutally kick Sufism out of the great universe of Islam is not only awesome and hair raising, it is also shocking and painful for Its lovers. The pinching question that now arises is that were Junaid Baghdadi and Shah Waliullah suffering from hallucinations?

[@hammadbutt8614]

Sufism has nothing to do with Islam you must study Quran with neutral translations, you wd know about reality of sufism

[@alimansoor6459]

Meraj Uddin watch this and also the second part, u will hve idea wht even imam gazali had written kzbin.info/www/bejne/jXmlgmCpfc2gg9k

[@aarifboy]

Ye video Ghamdi ki mullaiyat ko nanga kerne ke liye kaafi hai kzbin.info/www/bejne/rprRhoKebsmDfpo

[@hassanmohiuddin4495]

Just want to say that Imam Ibn Taymiyyah, (who is considered as the Sheikh of Salaf Ideology and known to be the most anti taswauuf) was part of qadri Silsilah of Taswauuf and states that sufism is not bidah.

[@rosh70]

This is true. I respect Javed Ghamidi Sahab and regard him as amongst the most (if not the most) well-read Islamic Scholar of modern times. But, some of his understanding and interpretation (analysis, critique) of some aspects like Tasawwuf are tertiary level (meaning, not in-depth). On the other hand, some Sufi texts have taken few things like Wahdath e Wajood, etc. too far, in trying to explain the concept. We need to stop with The Noble Prophet SAWS teachings - and his teachings INCLUDE rectifying our heart, before we die and return to our Creator.

[@thephilosophermma8449]

Excellent

[@hafizmalik335]

ooo blind man of heart . look at the life history of Maulana Rumi,sheikh attar,Abdul Qadir jeelani,sheikh Ahmad sirhindi and khawaja moin udin chishti (r.a.a) and tell me what is wrong

[@pakistancyberparty7244]

MUSLIM SHOULD FOLLOW THE TEACHING OF PROPHET MOHAMMED (PBUH) ONLY AND DO NOT NEED TO GO BEYOND.

[@ghulamnabi0]

I believe he now has a different opinion on tasawwuf

[@hassanlife4054]

Solute

[@badermunir5944]

Helmet ! a slight sugar blended authoritarian but favourable arrogance lies within your persona. Keep it up pl.

[@walishahbaz9292]

JazakAllah

[@muhammadjunaidali9449]

awesome

[@hafizmalik335]

tasawuf k munkiro ko ye baat qayamat tak khatakti rahegi ki Imam Ghazali jyse azeem alim o imam ne bhi sufiya e kiram se aqeedat rakhi hai.

[@afzaalmultipletv7988]

good nice great

[@shahzadsaleemi5691]

Sufi woh Hain ke Jin ke mutabiq un ke seenoo mein 4 Dil Hain aur khoperi mein koi demaagh nahee

[@mohammadnadeem1492]

Tremendous

[@shafirahaman]

Dimaag ke Quraafaat