Seat Ibiza vs Seat Leon comparison REVIEW with TGI CNG Erdgas feature - Autogefühl

In today’s Autogefühl's episode, we present you a Seat Ibiza vs Seat Leon comparison REVIEW with TGI CNG Erdgas feature. See how Thomas is fueling up a CNG car and find out what are the differences between Leon and Ibiza.
Related videos
►Also watch Polo vs Golf: • VW Golf GTI vs Polo GT...
►FULL REVIEWS 2018 Q2
• FULL REVIEWS 2018 Q2
►FULL REVIEWS 2018 Q1
• FULL REVIEWS 2018 Q1
How to support Autogefühl?
►Subscribe and/or bookmark our direct channel: www.autogefuehl.com
►Support us on Patreon: / autogefuehl
►Exclusive supporter: Ajlan Saeed
What is Thomas wearing?
► Noah shoes www.noah-shop.com/
Autogefühl viewers get a 17 % shoe discount with the following code: Autogefuehl-17
► Alpina watches www.alpinawatches.com?rfsn=692489.54bbe
► Startimer Pilot Big Date, Seastrong Diver 300 Big Date, Startimer Pilot Automatic, Startimer Pilot GMT quartz(wristlets in Metal, Rubber and Synthetic are offered)
Social Media & Blog
►Facebook: facebook.de/autogefuehl
►Twitter: / autogefuehl
►Instagram: / autogefuehl
►German Blog: autogefuehl.de
Autogefühl is your no. 1 resource for in-depth car reviews and your no. 1 community to discuss cars.” Each year we present you 150 cars from every segment and from a wide range of brands. If you have any suggestion, just write a comment or contact us on our other socials. Even if you have further remarks, just let us know.

[@markmd9]

I enjoy when you review budget cars in the same way as the luxury ones

[@autogefuehl]

appreciated!

[@oscarinthemiddle]

In Spain Leon and Ibiza with TGI engines are being sold quite well, they include the eco label to be used under pollution restrictions and the gas costs per 100 km is under 3,5 euros.

[@jansingh9680]

Never ever a dull moment watching an Autogefuhl review. Fair, Neutral and Unbias reviews.

[@autogefuehl]

Thx so much!

[@DavidMorley]

About to order the 2020 Ibiza CNG (more gas, but only a small petrol tank). Seems like a great solution for being ecological but still enough range for longer journeys (5 min filling up at 450km if filling both tanks) It's also a great looking car.

[@MrYouness09]

Very good and very professional review as always good continuation Thomas and the team u r all really one of the best reviewers if not the best 😋.

[@autogefuehl]

thanks, enjoy!!

[@InteriorDesignAnderson]

Hi autogefuhl, I’m a huge fan who’s been around since 2014, the channel is always fair, well edited, continues updated and has a great community feel. I’m really happy to see that your pushing for animal friendly materials in cars. I’m a massive supporter of better animal rights. But I’m Intrigued to hear how effective you are in convincing manufacturers and how they react to the issue, weather they are willing to embrace the idea or rather stay in the past.

[@autogefuehl]

I know, great you have been with us so long, thanks! :-) The wool thing has more dimensions. First of all, in the RR Velar they use 30 % wool and 70 % recycled plastic bottles. That's a big step forward and already a good idea. The question is just why they couldnt use some other material. Anyway, the seats are great, we had them in our review. And definitely better than leather. If you first think about sheep in a natural environment, it becomes pretty clear that no single sheep would shear themselves/each other. So it's nothing that would normally happen. However, if you think as a single owner, like sheering your dog (which isnt naturally either) and taking care of the sheep, carefully taking it off like a human hair cut - o.k. Problem again is mass animal farming and the industrial production, which then leads to possible brutal shearing, workers are paid by sheep to be as fast as possible, often insulting in bloody wounds etc. Plus, the sheep breading is connected to the meat industry, so when they arent used for their wool anyway, they are slaughtered. Etc. etc. There are a lot of resources on the web explaining the wool industry. So my conclusion: Almost everything you can buy in a store or in a finished product will probably be involved in some animal harm, so I try to avoid wool unless I would personally give a nice a gentle hair cut to my potential home-kept sheep myself =)

[@InteriorDesignAnderson]

Autogefühl thanks for the comment

[@cadenguyen463]

Truly is the number resource for in-depth car reviews.....my wife and kids also love watching Thomas, "Let's Goooo!"

[@autogefuehl]

awesome, best greetings to the whole family :)

[@dr_pari]

Very interesting to see alternative fuel sources, the comparison to petrol and diesel, and how refilling works at a CNG station. Thank you for a holistic approach.

[@MsPinkcat7]

I can't thank you enough for your detailed reviews, exactly what I was looking for today, comparison between the new Ibiza and the Leon. Really helpful, many thanks :) , with thanks from a British viewer :)

[@autogefuehl]

Great . Recommend us! :)

[@seanpatrickmccarthy1]

An incredibly thorough review yet again. Good job.

[@autogefuehl]

cheers keep recommending us!

[@Amfibios]

great review! can't ask for more really, thanks

[@user-ic1jk3le2h]

These are the TGI engines just for Fridays. 😀😎☺😂😅

[@doniv7926]

Και τις υπολοιπες;

[@jhz94]

Thanks for the great review!

[@01pavlo]

Great and very detailed review! Danke schön :-)

[@jeroenvantwestende2532]

once more a great review from Thomas. Seat are building a great line up with the recent cars. love the new ibiza, the leon is also a great car

[@autogefuehl]

Thx!

[@NuhanHidayat]

The scenery is gorgeous! 🤩

[@autogefuehl]

sure is! :)

[@quanchau381]

Thomas, you are correct, WRC does push to downshift and pull to upshift. Many other performance vehicles do this also. The reason is that when your weight is transferring forward during braking, it's more difficult to pull than push, and vice versa.

[@autogefuehl]

excellent explanation!

[@dizd4770]

Very good review. Thanx

[@akaChriss4L]

I like those little details like when the reviewer said the reason why you can't choose the alcantara seats!

[@DancinJim]

Thanks for the very detailed review. In terms of the Horsepower difference, how noticeable is it between the two? Ibiza has 90 which to me seems a little low and underpowered for motorway driving and long journeys with overtaking required?

[@monikawiedmann8594]

Great, I was undecided before I watched this, but I like the Leon better.

[@hamishdunham]

Hi Thomas! Since you ask, there is no tangible CNG structure here in the U.K., sadly. However, your video was very informative about the fuel and I'd certainly be a fan if it was introduced. Thanks for showing us the beautiful countryside of Sylt.

[@autogefuehl]

appreciated!

[@gordonbennett6057]

Hi Thomas - CNG, Electric, Petrol, Diesel! Love your informed discussions, and your live-on-tape detailed video explaining refueling. Do you have to move pumps to refuel both tanks? Does the engine now use a particulate filter when using petrol? Great driving images, thank you. 31:29 you didn't remark on the DSG 'stall' again (only guessing, but it may have been changing between fuels just as you were stopping and the computer had to compensate?). Hamish - agree, it's a shame there's zero infrastructure for CNG in UK (except within certain contractor's premises). Enjoyed the Northern Frisian Islands scenery. Thanks Thomas and Katharina.

[@hamishdunham]

Hi Gordon! Good question about refuelling. My local filling station in Somerset has their LPG hose conveniently alongside a petrol nozzle at the same pump position, enabling customers to fill on both without having to move their vehicle and causing confusion with the cashier. I like the idea of a dedicated CNG station, as Thomas visited (especially one without a mini-supermarket attachment where we have to wait for someone to free a pump after they've completed their weekly shop -grrrr!).

[@gordonbennett6057]

Good point Hamish! Weekly shop - he he! And yes, of course, I'd forgotten that Thomas was at a dedicated CNG station, which explains why I couldn't see an accompanying petrol hose! Cheers!

[@autogefuehl]

yeah if the tank is empty it just pumps longer. Yes maybe about that stalling, I didnt experience it anymore again. Cheers!

[@giselasilva5415]

In Portugal CNG is almost forgotten which is a shame, we can only found a handfull of stations around Porto and Lisbon. We have big agricultural and animal husbandry companies which could also produce biogas and make us less dependent on imported crude oil, at the same time improving those companies revenue and helping the environment, so all wins!! Good on VW for investing on this tecnology

[@giselasilva5415]

By the way, I'm replacing my oldest car, small car (Peugeot 206 1.9d) for a new LPG one (Dacia Logan MCV), since that LPG is well catered for on our petrol stations, and the savings are too good to be true. But If I had a CNG station near me I would have gotten a used VW Touran CNG ou Leon ST CGN...

[@Lauryncorr]

Thanks for the comparison. It’s been really useful. The only thing that's makes me think twice between GNC and gasoline/diesel is that the only models that you can buy are Reference and Style, not Excellence or FR. At least is what I have saw on the Seat web.

[@autogefuehl]

Appreciated! That's true for the Leon. U gotta pick Style and then upgrade the extras on your own. Afaik for Ibiza and Arona, you can also get FR?

[@Lauryncorr]

Autogefühl I saw Ibiza can be FR but Arona doesn't.(not yet at least). Thanks for your answer!

[@androo4519]

Very interesting review between smaller and larger cars in the range. Would be interesting to see others like this. Thomas, you have a very calm and soothing manner. I could listen to you all day! And I would definitely let you into my car on a sandy road! One thing you didn't mention was safety - I suppose the larger Leon might do better in a crash? Do they have the same safety features? I would choose the Leon for its extra refinement, comfort and safety, if I could afford the extra. Here in the UK, I don't know anyone who has a CNG car - and just one person who has LPG. And what do you mean by 'more sovereign'? Upmarket?

[@autogefuehl]

Appreciated!! Good point, both have AEB (auto emergency brake), but Ibiza standard and Leon beginning mid trim. But ibiza doesnt have blind spot monitor afaik

[@WallabyWinters]

im really keen to see what the new golf and leon will bring to the game right now theres no reason to get one over a polo or ibiza except for a more potent engine maybe, but that's of little concern to the average consumer.

[@4stars2014]

Hallo Thomas. Vielen Dank für den ausführlichen Vergleich. Wie immer top informativ und gut gemacht! Ist die Ladekabelvorrichtung in der Mittelkonsole des Leon Style Standard, wenn man das Navi bestellt oder muss zusätzlich die Connectivity Box ausgewählt werden? Mach weiter so!

[@autogefuehl]

Vielen Dank! Gute Frage, müsstest du mal im Konfigurator ausprobieren, teilweise werden dann ja Sachen automatisch an- oder abgewählt

[@tipazas]

I had previous car with LPG, also with about good 300km. range and it was very annoying for me in comparison with about 900km. diesel now I have. It was more sense to make petrol tank just as reserve and make all CNG, with good range, because anyway you would always try to avoid using petrol, so actual range would be always 300km.

[@LemmingTommy]

Ich persönlich bin kürzlich einmal Golf und Ibiza zur Probe gefahren...es stimmt, insgesamt vermittelte der Golf den ruhigeren Eindruck. Am Ende meiner Testfahrt hatte ich mit dem 1.0 Motor 5.0 L Verbrauch laut Systeminfo. Was mir aber nicht gefallen hat, war die leichtgängige Lenkung des Golf, die sich bei steigenden Geschwindigkeiten nur mäßig änderte. Da fand ich den Ibiza angenehmer..man merkte zwar deutlich, dass die Servounterstützung zurückgefahren wurde bei Landstraßentempo z.B. - aber das fand ich viel angenehmer...eine leichte Lenkung wie beim Golf kann auch "nervig" sein, wenn man nicht in der City fährt.

[@cristianbonucci2692]

The pump price of CNG here in Italy is currently around 0.94 euros/kg.. I wouldn't say that CNG stations are so capillary in Italy: there is a considerable difference between the distribution of CNG stations in northern and central Italy as opposed to southern Italy, where they are few and far between. In any case, at what threshold of annual mileage would a bifuel CNG engine be more suitable than a mere petrol one?

[@Pembrey33]

Fun review

[@JA-zr9xu]

I'm using Skoda Octavia 1.4 TGI G-tech in the Czech Republic. My minimal CNG usage 3.2 kg per 100 km, and average is 3.7-3.8 kg per 100km. It's roughly 4 EUR per 100 km. Underground parking is a biggest problem for me. Some parking still prohibits CNG. Anyway I got better TCO vs old Toyota Prius :) I afraid Seat Ibiza come with 5st gear... It's not good for fuel consumption.

[@NAKMUAYACADEMY]

Very curious which one is the best Ibiza Vs Leon Vs polo Vs civic ?

[@-EvoII-]

@Autogefuhl, some ibiza's (included my fr) have a small storage compartment right below the light button. This one haven't. Is it depending from the version? First time this take my attention. I thought every ibiza has it. @16:16 you can see what I mean.

[@autogefuehl]

Seems to be an extra

[@thcyprus]

Hello Thomas/ Autogefühl, I am trying to choose between the Ibiza FR (115hp Auto) and the new Kia Rio (1.4 Auto), both with about the same features and price. Ibiza has much better performance and is a bit more spacious, but Kia has a much nicer interior with leather seats (as you said the Alcantara option on the Ibiza is not available now) and also offers longer warranty (7 vs 5 years) and has a much better reliability track record (for the earlier models). Any suggestions?

[@autogefuehl]

hey m8, our review of the Kia Rio is here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/lXS8dqlvbLZ4rNk The fabric seats are the best pick for climate comfort in both summer and winter, plus the other negative aspects of leather I think I dont have to mention again :) You can still have the sports seats with fabric in the Ibiza if u want something special

[@thcyprus]

Hey, I watched all your reviews about these two cars (and others.) I watched your video about leather also, but Rio has "man made" leather, not real leather. So, would you say that the Ibiza is a better car overall?

[@autogefuehl]

ah I see, cool. Thats helpful then if u have kids and need to wipe the seats quite often. Both cars will be nice for sure, personally I d take the Ibiza, but maybe u just test drive both and then check your feelings :)

[@skagerstrom]

Or leahter made of man? :o ;)

[@samers6296]

Thomas. I suggest you get a Sound Meter to measure the noise in every car you test. This will help to know accurately how good noise cancellation in each car.

[@autogefuehl]

We did some tests with that, problem is that you have to consider tyre size, weather, road surface, wind conditions etc. to make it somehow comparable

[@samers6296]

@@autogefuehl mmm what we can't get it entirely, we get it partially bro.😉

[@autogefuehl]

haha ok - well we can do it with the App again on the smartphone

[@samers6296]

Dude. Thanks alot for your great and rich review. You helped milions of hesitant people. Only one point, i hope you use more cars- common words. For example you say feel more sovereignty? I wish you use common words like firm suspension,,,,,,etc. Thanks again

[@autogefuehl]

I use sovereignty for "effortless" or "calm and collected" ;-)

[@samers6296]

@@autogefuehl we use Sovereignty in International Law. 😂....

[@RixisLV]

In Latvia there is no CNG filling option I know of. Only LPG. I would say in all Baltic region it is the same.

[@rivadav]

Thanks for another great review! Is CNG more popular than LPG in Germany? In Poland it is the contrary and I’m curious why CNG gets more attention now.

[@autogefuehl]

Well, it is now rising. LPG is 3rd party retrofit only with small companies doing those, so there is not much industry focus and no organised buying possibility. CNG is being pushed now as Diesel alternative and it is the more efficient and cleaner technology

[@rivadav]

I see, thanks for reply! :)

[@rivadav]

I was also curious about LPG vs. CNG impact on health and one study says that "The gaseous fuels LPG and CNG show the best overall results, especially CNG shows (very) low impact potentials on almost all effects in all driver situations." and other (see the link) seems to confirm that. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352146517305513

[@autogefuehl]

yes CNG burns very cleanly, thats why it even doesnt need particle filters etc and CNG is burning better than LPG (methane vs propan/butan)

[@SantiagoAntonutti]

Hi Thomas, in Argentina more than 30% of the vehicles of the entire country runs on CNG, pretty much every gas station has CNG, and some of them have more CNG pumps than regular gas and diesel ones. Its a very harmful fuel in the long run, the newer generations can last longer, but in comparison with petrol you do loose a lot of power and top speed.

[@autogefuehl]

Interesting! What u mean by harmful fuel ?

[@SantiagoAntonutti]

The thing is that engines are not prepared in the most cases to inject compressed gas, as in every car here, it leads to problems with the ECU and more wear in the injection sistem and pistons, if its not done correctly it could damage the engine. Its probably not the case for the tgi engines because those are built like that and its probably different of what im used to see in my country. I had a VW Suran, wich is a brazilian state version of the lupo, and I put a 12 cubic meters tube for CNG at a cuestionable shop, and it end up literally blowing up the ECU. If you want a sporty car CNG its not an option, its not that useful in highway because of the low response of the engine making it a great city usage for most people and cheaper

[@emiliendurand640]

If need to buy one of these now I will choose the Ibiza no doubt, the Leon is going to have a new version next year, you're gonna lose a lot of value.

[@terry308a]

Seat ibiza tgi, how much kg 's cng from empty to full? it would be nice if you had it instead of the leon on cng fuel fill 😉

[@autogefuehl]

check the engine part for all those details!

[@kitsoshamsterkitsoshamster1927]

I want tgi,so I am between seat leon,kamiq,Octavia but honestly I should compare leon with Octavia or hold cause same ~130hp,but I let golf and octavia,and I go for kamiq and seat leon,one gives space comfort,the other hp,kamiq virtual cockpit,leon dsg,last but not least which one has less problems in years of use(not talking about kamiq or leon but in general seat vs skoda)I have never been owner of any skoda or seat before,just Japan so anyone who can help me i will be very thankful cause as I said I am looking for cng,so those are pretty much my options,I would put vision x also from skoda but I guess this one will worth a fortune!!!

[@skagerstrom]

It's amazing how VAG can't get the shifting directions correctly on their automatics. Even the old first gen VAG-Lambos had it wrong. I do think Porsche put it the correct way.

[@supernova52565]

Thanks Thomas for the in depth review! Not familiar with the cng in Canada tho lol

[@autogefuehl]

thanks!

[@christill]

CNG doesn’t seem to be very prevalent in the U.K. There’s a map but I don’t think there is a station within 50 miles of me. And I don’t think they really compete with EVs unless a country has a really dirty electricity grid. But even then you can use a renewable energy plan or charge from your own solar and battery if you go that route. It’s strange that no manufacturers really push CNG as an alternative to diesel at least.

[@autogefuehl]

Yeah. Volkswagen Group now does push it as alternative to Diesel ...

[@christill]

Autogefühl I looked on Seat and VW UK websites and couldn’t see any way to configure a TGI engine. It’s really not good.

[@autogefuehl]

Seems that the UK importer doesnt take part in that yet then! Strange

[@zenithred9731]

I have actually ordered the Ibiza TGI in FR trim level, looks way better than the aging Leon to me but it's true it's just my city commuting car among other sportier vehicles in the garage. If you can afford just one car, I'd probably go for the Leon ST which is handsome as well. This tech is way more realistic than the whole electric demagogy bull and, mostly!, allows you to drive a clean, crispy hybrid with a manual box. Ps: 3 cyl Ibiza sounds quite better than the Leon I4. After all it's half a 911 boxer engine when you think of it ;)

[@autogefuehl]

cool !

[@globalwarming3187]

In the Netherlands is the tax of a gas car more expensive than a benzeen car, but cheaper than the tax of diesel car. The tank of a gas car is cheaper than benzeen and diesel cars. So tax is expensive but tank is cheap.

[@autogefuehl]

strange that they dont lower taxes on that tech! Thx for the info !

[@globalwarming3187]

Autogefühl yes it's very strange, no problem!

[@doniv7926]

In Greece both taxes and refueling are lower than petrol and diesel..but here still lugging on the CNG stations(only Athens ,Thessaloniki and Larissa)😐

[@Dan-or3ls]

what is the point of producing almost exactly the same car

[@laurinleitner2701]

A7 vs CLS?

[@autogefuehl]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qYTCqqN8ibiXmrc kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2e7mnWsi9qkbc0

[@tonyali4715]

What about Leon mango

[@chubbybrown4real]

Scotland =poor lpg =nil cng No one has grasped lng yet

[@trevitrevi9367]

Thomas - do you have Polish roots? ;-)

[@autogefuehl]

yeah, quite a while ago though

[@trevitrevi9367]

Have you ever been to Poland? Anyway - you do e GREAT job! Love your test.. and I'm happy to see Leon quite often :)

[@autogefuehl]

great u are joining us! Sadly no, what region would u recommend to visit? The region around Szeczin is supposed to be nice i heard

[@trevitrevi9367]

Seaside trip should be nice for a start: Szczecin -> Kolobrzeg -> Koszalin -> Sopot -> Gdansk... Give me a sign if you decide to take one.. it wolud be great to meet and have a beer or coffe and have a chat about cars ;-)

[@frankd.3035]

Irre ich mich, oder hat der Ibiza die größeren Felgen drauf? Bei Autotests gibt es wenige, die den daher rührenden Unterschied im Fahrgefühl herausstellen. Es heißt dann einfach, der eine ist sportlicher, der andere komfortabler. Auto-"journalisten" heutzutage...

[@autogefuehl]

Egtl sagen wir immer wie gross die Felgen sind die drauf sind

[@Mizaeducation]

I live in Algeria and these two cars are so so expensive So sad living in this sh***y country 😔

[@akucatlas]

how much does Ibiza cost in algeria? in morocco the diesel version starts at 14700€

[@danielmauer6463]

Seat ibiza is better

[@soultanasmaga9661]

ZggagaaggayGa

[@adrianliviu1801]

Leon its The golf 5.....ibiza its polo....

[@user-rj5cg5cb5u]

The pest is leon

[@god8003]

Arrrghhh. Stop trying to make "Sovereignty" happen. It's not going to happen!

[@Maybesure]

G OD FETCH! 🙈

[@adinova7274]

No corect comparatione.. Ibiza, its model stock.....leon.. Its golf... Ibiza. Its polo.