Sen. Tolentino: PH has no law penalizing classified documents leak | ANC

On The Scene: A Philippine Senator clashes with a former drug enforcement agent in a hearing on allegedly leaked documents linking President Marcos to drug use.
Join ANC PRESTIGE to get access to perks:
/ @ancalerts
For more ANC Interviews, click the link below:
• ANC Interviews
For more On The Scene videos, click the link below:
• On The Scene
For more ANC Highlights videos, click the link below:
• ANC Highlights
Subscribe to the ANC KZbin channel!
/ ancalerts
Visit our website at news.abs-cbn.c...
Facebook: / ancalerts
Twitter: / ancalerts
#ANCNews
#ANCHighlights
#OnTheScene

[@user-kt4jb1jq7b]

matuto na sana mga pinoy wag na iboto ang convicted! madami deserving na kumakandidato at karapatdapat iboto

[@EFrn2023]

Hindi importante yong nag leak ng document ang importante malaman yong taong subject ng leak, at yan ay si PBBM na ayaw mag pa drug test

[@lakbaypluma]

Dapat wala nang tanggapin na mga artista o celebrity na umupo sa senado. We don't need man of service with two identities

[@DheaDelaTorre]

Very true nanalo lng dahil nasanay Ang mga tao s knila iniidolo s mga pelikula nadala s knilang mga role. S madali't sabi popularity lng grrrrrr

[@tessiecastillo2377]

😮😅😅😅😅

[@LadjamaniCarolyn]

Tama!🙏

[@davidramirez1229]

palpak nga eh ang identies..

[@AlexanderDaloga-og]

RA 10173 or the Data Privacy Act of 2012. This too penalizes release of documents evidencing private content of information. But this is for the unlawful violation of one's privacy. But if deemed classified, that's another matter, as it affects public interest or national security.

[@tessiebermudo9935]

Senators should also pay respect to any Resource persons

[@EstherRecopelacion]

Morales nagsabi yan ng totoo base sa authentic forms bakit malayo ang tanong n Jenggoy sirang plaka pabalik balik ang tanong hindi na base sa pinag usapan lalo g malayo hinuhusgahan na niya c Morales

[@demostheneschavez8481]

Sen. De la Rosa seems to be very polite towards a resource person but sarcastic towards another resource person. Obvious!!!!

[@agentvoid6692]

@@demostheneschavez8481 This is so accurate. I couldn't stand how Sen Bato had brutally challenged and cast his doubt on those medical personnel 's account regarding the only specific Drug test conducted per patient's request.. Those people are from St Luke's, a very reputable institution...Bato didn't have to raise his voice nor dsplay such rude body language.... the same goes by his defensive tone and sarcasm towards the PDEA Legal service rep., Atty Del Valle and another resource person, Mr. Erik Tikoy Santiago, who had to be humiliated by Bato by his constant reminder of Mr Tikoy's crimes and other offences. On the contrary, Bato was never hesitant nor discreet in displaying how he would hastily jump on Morales' defence especially when speechless and cornered by other senators. Yes, Sen dela Rosa would reprimand Morales but he was always tactful and gentle in addressing related issues with Morales.

[@user-eg5gu5gg7i]

😂😂😂😂😂itsallclown😂😂😂😂

[@athenasam1316]

Magaling ka sen.Tolentino

[@DaniloCalinawan]

What have they done in the senate, it became a circus with all these clowns.

[@lucreciacalibusonepales4425]

True @ Danilo Calnawan

[@neliobello449]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@zarickoyjaztin]

O hahaha bogok classified document ng government involve then ang security ng pinas kaya logmok ang filipino kasi ung mindset at utqk hindi malawak un lang ang naririnig nyo..hahaah kawawa namn pag ganon kayo mag isip ..

[@geebert23]

wala na tayong magagaling na senator

[@dantecruz5287]

Mga non sense na hearing just a waste of taxpayers' money .. Isa lang ang intention ng mga maka Duterte na mga senador ang mapatalsik si PBBM at maupo ang anak ng EJK principal na si DUTERTE .

[@gildasicat6581]

KATHANG ISIP is not the TRUTH!!

[@user-rj7bt9vp5m]

Dig deeper Sen. Tolentino... Ask your legal staff to do research on the subject.

[@mannypakyaw3773]

Ganyan na ngayon ang senate hearing? Nakakahiya at nakaka awa ang Pilipinas at mga Pilipino kung ganyan klase ang mga senador ng Pilipinas :(

[@gerrygeraldez9712]

Nakakaawa ang pilipinas kung may duda sa mga leader nito.

[@liamvince1159]

Ung dating nakaupo abogado si gordon wala na gawang batas jan sa leak kaya now palang magkakaroon dahil kay sen bato

[@evelynrobillo8923]

Ayaw pagsalitain ni jinggoy si morales ,pero ang mga tano g ni ji ggoy ,namemersonal ,humahanap ng mali kay morales

[@taray4655]

papaano naging kawawa kung katulad naman ni senator jinggoy galing nga niya mag salita

[@lindarosamorales3043]

Nganga tayong mga pilipino kong ang iniupo dyan sa senate puro walang silbe

[@elmerlolo6844]

Sa lahat na admen.. Ito ang namulatan k na pinakabokok sa lahat

[@ellenchen3837]

❤💯

[@danielbabor]

agree 100000000%

[@melisasimbulan446]

THAT'S A FACTUAL OBSERVATION !!

[@eugenetongcua9345]

Ngayon ko lang nalaman ang kaso ni Dinggoy na ganun . Bakit ganyan ang avtuation nya magduro duro .

[@Tangnamo-q9t]

Bato has successfully accomplished his goal of creating and damaging the administration ..it is a playbook..

[@o.c.sun-theenaturals-spice9790]

Bato would like to create a law for such a leakage document, as Sen. Tolentino emphasizes, there is no existing law that will punish such an illegal act of IRRESPONSIBLE HANDLING OF CLASSIFIED DOCUMENTS. Do you understand when its being declared: IN AID OF LEGISLATION! ✅💯

[@user-np2vb9lt7w]

What is the use of the senate hearing about matters? You're wasting money .

[@robertsegismundo1419]

True nagpapaniwala sa mga Maritess,sinayang lng tlaga pera mga tax payer😢

[@user-pw1lv3hl6y]

Ang hearing na to ay in aid of legislation, para maka gawa sila ng batas regarding sa leaking of confidential documents, dahil sabi nga ni Sen Tolentino, wala pang batas regarding sa leaking of confidential documents.

[@Phejay-z1d]

Hahaha waste of time? Wala law na magpenalized...So Tama lang para makagawa sila ng batas para makulong ang mga nagleak.

[@meralyncaang2434]

​@@Phejay-z1dwaste of money kase di mo alam magkano gastos kada hearing millions ang isang araw nyan well kong troll ka wala nman kayo pakialam sa bayad binenta pa nga ninyo ang pilipinas di yan waste og time para sayo sinayang lng oras at pera ng taong bayan nagbayad ang taong bayan sa hearing na yan na yon pala walang patutunguhan.

[@ArthurSayo-kp5uc]

​ ni no

[@Ladybee-h4x]

Bakit ba kung senador sya may ka err apatan na sya magduro duro, respeto ka nyo? Respetohin nyo rin ang taombayan

[@Seis87648]

This investigation is the polar opposite of Senator Honteviros' POGO investigation. The decorum. The conduct. What a circus.

[@user-eg5gu5gg7i]

😂😂😂😂😂it is a circus only in pi😂😂😂

[@user-xo7my2bq5u]

😊😊​@@user-eg5gu5gg7i

[@marshawk9766]

yea, the investigation of Hontiveros is purely circus.

[@gildasicat6581]

That's right what you said Mr Chairman of the Committee. Differentiating their cases which the attacker is already convicted whereas Ex Agent is not!! 😅😅😅

[@OnodaYasuhiko]

Hindi nakakatawa na pinagbabantaan buhay Its not a joke

[@erlisod6314]

i disagree. there are laws prohibiting unauthorized revelation of confidential documents, such as: section 3k of R.A 3019; infidelity in the custody of documents under the revised penal code

[@gildasicat6581]

He's trying to make fool to all of you there this Pikoy. Why listen to him! He's crazy!

[@rosariovorsatz4130]

Mukha plang ni Pikoy, mukhang marami ng nabuwis na buhay dahil sa kanyang mga diskarte.

[@perlitaamores4701]

Dapat respitohin din ang resource person.

[@julietmananquil4463]

Magkano kaya bayad dyan????hahaha ang gulo nyu grabeh!

[@buddaejiggae6104]

Malaki ang bayad ng china dyan

[@elenamontoya5865]

.mga fake news walang evidencia wala na alam na ng tao sino ang iboboto

[@teresauy9170]

The government should file a case regarding the person who leaked the files

[@zoneofficial2001]

How can they file when there's no leak at all. They're wasting there time in there

[@gamingcentral2295]

meron diplomatic immunity

[@JaydenCien1211]

tama pra malaman ang katotohanan

[@user-pw1lv3hl6y]

paano sila mag-file wla nga batas sabi ni Sen Tolentino. Kaya sila nag-hehearing para makagawa ng batas regarding document leak.

[@josepheder9563]

Pinag usapan nga na walang existing law against document leak

[@Papa_wil]

Thanks Sen. Tol sa iyong inityatibo na maghain ng kaukulang batas para sa proteksyun ng mga importante dokumento at impormasyun.

[@julianacorpuz9490]

Sir morales God is with you laban lang sir ikaw ang tama hindi ang senador jinggoy

[@lucreciacalibusonepales4425]

Credibility of resource person.is a requirement sa hearing.

[@alwayssomewhere74]

So is the credibility of the person conducting the hearing, yes?😅

[@chaiamima]

So is the credibility of a senator. Bat kasi naboto pa ang convicted for bribery.

[@Tambayan842]

Flunder convicted galit sa agent hahah

[@iwaydelasalas1163]

Pauwiin si maharlika. Magka alaman na.

[@marianpatawaran9672]

May binabasa iyan ang taong walang isip.

[@FrReyOlaa]

There are constitutional provision and related laws that are related to classified information such as: Art. 229 - Revelation of Secrets by a Public Officer: Any public officer who shall reveal any secret known to him by reason if his official capacity, or shall wrongfully deliver papers or copy of papers of which he may have charge and which should not be published shall suffer the penalties of prision correccional and perpetual special disqualification 1) laws privacy of communication and correspondence shall be respected (bill of rights) 2) Art. 230 RPC. - Public officer revealing secrets of private individual. Penalty: imprisonment and fine 3) Art. 290 RPC - Seizing letters or papers of another 4) Art. 291 - Revealing secrets with abuse of office 5) Art. 236 RPC - Removal, concealment or destruction of documents 6) Art. 227 - Officer breaking seal 7) Art. 228 - Opening closed document 8) Art. 229 - Revelation of Secrets by an Officer

[@bong6129]

pakulong na lang ang mga liar.

[@christopherneilroca3437]

Anong documents ang ipapakita nya para magbigay linaw???

[@MultiSavebygrace]

Pag Si morales ang nagsasaluta binibigyan Mo Bato Ng maraming time Pero pag ang ibang Tao ang nagsasaluta patungkol Kay morales ay binabara Mo sila Mr Bato

[@kurttorayno6073]

Halos hinde na nga naka pagsalita si sir Morales dahil binabara siya agad ni jinggoy..pqtawa kaba.?

[@pacitacruz958]

Nakikinabang ka ba sa pera ng tao?

[@user-rj4sh3yh6b]

akala mo nga abogado ni morales binabara agad yong ibang nagsasalita. Pinapaikot nya mga tao dyan

[@albbauti7014]

​@@kurttorayno6073, sundan mo naoong wala pa si Jinggoy.

[@myriamcid3076]

Bskit ksilagan ni bato magpaalam kay morales

[@virgilioflor9136]

This hearing is a very good opportunity to make a legislation. It is counter productive to stop it due to some anxieties. Salamat po Atty Tolentino for your crucial information regarding leaks of classified information.🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍

[@AntonioMartinez-qi6hh]

Nakakahuya na Ang ating BAYAN !....

[@jansalvador9050]

They should start penalizing BATO DE LA ROZA

[@nestorpo6818]

The stand of sen. Zubire is lame. If you really want a fair hearing bato should present a credible witness. But as the hearing went on it is obvious that the witness is a fraud and a conman. The senate have endure so much damage under your leadership I believe this is the right time to put things in the right perspective. Otherwise you'll be Remembered as a lame and a weak leader because you just want to accommodate everyone in the senate to please them. But the most important thing is to protect the integrity of the senate like you said. Sa totoo lang ang tingin ng karamihan joke o wow mali ngayon ang senado.

[@josefinasiervo6219]

Tama ka Sen.Tolentino,dapat mayrong batas,ang,sinusunod.

[@imnnewtv8712]

JONGOY, JONGOY, JONGOY! COMELEC pwede e retract yong boto namin kay JONGOY?

[@petersonraymondfonte1444]

Convicted nopo🤣😂🤣😂🇵🇭❤️. Ofw watching from 🇨🇦 👊👊👊

[@raffydelfin1956]

Sa totoo lang parang nilagay ni bato sa kakahiyaan ang senado.

[@gerrygeraldez9712]

Sino ang nahihiya?

[@eddieking1778]

You may see what violet fake news or liar? Don Ang penalty s batas? If not senate must do her work regarding his happen?

[@prudenciadumaranlazarte-ca2571]

I agree withJM

[@prudenciadumaranlazarte-ca2571]

Bakit c jinggoy ganyan mgtnong kay JM? MAKINIG MUNA SYA KAY JM BAGO SY MGTNONG

[@robgucci_54]

Hwag ng bumoto ng artista. Ibalik natin ang integrity ng Senate! Mapanuri sa mga kandidato!

[@JonaHanz-u2hix]

Yes your honor, he planted evidence.

[@ginagonzales8866]

That's the real hearing ,no bias ,ilabas Kung ano ang totoo..thank you senator bato 👏👏👏👏

[@prudenciadumaranlazarte-ca2571]

This Santiago doesn't deserve a. Respect . Sen jinggoy, please respect J Morales

[@tessiebermudo9935]

Sana pangaralan mo na rin Sen Batonsi Sen Jinggoy on the way how He throw questions to any ot the Resource persons

[@giovannigomez2541]

Matindi talaga ang impluwensya ni marites hanggang sa senado😂😂😂

[@filemonasugas8146]

Ang galing senator tolentino very good you study very well

[@UKbaseflamingheartforneedy]

Bullseye. Sapul! Konyat! Bravo Mr. MORALES!

[@MovieFlixPHI]

Pahiya SI bato hearsay

[@ellenchen3837]

Paano mo masabi na pahiya si bato cgi magalit nga cla ky bato dahil nag imbestiga sya hind mo nainig sbi bato galit sa knya mga ksma nya dahil pinayagan ang gusto ng taong bayan kong ano katutuhanan tama ba bkt alam ba ni Mr morales maging pangulo so Marcos ngaun 2012 pa nga

[@eyes1181]

Tolen, subir, go, batoger, ARE FLYERS,

[@user-ek6dg6ml6l]

mas matalino pa c JM

[@rosariovorsatz4130]

That is a good chance Senator Tolentino to revise a new Law concerning violations of classified documents.

[@Seis87648]

More celebrity lawmakers = less laws to hold the corrupt accountable.

[@reyalayon2816]

There are provisions of penalties: For Unauthorised Processing of Personal Information and Sensitive Personal Information. (Jail term and fines) Otherwise basta basta nalang mag leak ng confidential information na makakasira sa reputation ng individuals.

[@michaelabiog8706]

Saan galing ang batas na yan? Anong article anong section anong RA

[@norbertocalaguas2640]

Sisihin ninyo si maharlika dahil sya ang pasomuno at kagagawan ng mga duterte ang aso dito si bato at morales ang mga kumakaol

[@reyalayon2816]

The law aims to protect personal data in information and communications systems both in the • government and the • private sector.

[@michaelabiog8706]

@@reyalayon2816 there's no law governing it, nullum crimen poena sine lege, theres no crime if there's no law penalizing it. Tulad ng sinabi ni sen. Tolentino maari lang syang kasuhan administratively if pdea agent pa sya, kaso civilian na sya.

[@reyalayon2816]

I am not a lawyer but noted that there is corresponding penalty for Unauthorized Processing of Personal Information and Sensitive Personal Information. - I may be mistaken but I think item (a) may apply: The unauthorized processing of personal information shall be penalized by imprisonment ranging from one (1) year to three (3) years and a fine of not less than Five hundred thousand pesos (Php500,000.00) but not more than Two million pesos (Php2,000,000.00) shall be imposed on persons who process personal information without the consent of the data subject, or without being authorized under this Act or any existing law.

[@Danzgamingandvlogs]

If there's no law punishing it then it's time to make a law punishing it.

[@edithpronuevo7517]

salute to u sir morales tapang mo po 👊🏼👊🏼👊🏼

[@user-hs6uc3li7r]

Patawag ung mga sasakyan at tanungin din

[@moto_BC]

😂😂😂 nagsasalita poba mga sasakyan?

[@dragonfly6217]

Hahaha😂😂😂😂

[@doloreskondo3088]

No to Bato, Go, Zubiri, tolentino, and dutertes and their allies . They are wasting money for this hearing

[@user-su7yg2sd4d]

Article 229. Any public officer who shall reveal any secret known to him by reason of his official capacity, or shall wrongfully deliver papers or copies of papers of which he may have charge and which should not be published, shall suffer the penalties of prision correccional in its medium and maximum periods, perpetual special disqualification and a fine not exceeding 2,000 pesos if the revelation of such secrets or the delivery of such papers shall have caused serious damage to the public interest; otherwise, the penalties of prision correccional in its minimum period, temporary special disqualification and a fine not exceeding 50 pesos shall be imposed. (Act No. 3815, Revised Penal Code)

[@juanitolantin5024]

Parang may umiiwas na mag invite pa ng mga resource si Sen Bato mula ng may lumabas na mga larawan ni kumar na may kasamang mga senador kaya gusto na itigil na mag invite pa ng ibang resource speaker.

[@UKbaseflamingheartforneedy]

Salute Sen. Tolentino!matalino at deserving to sit in Senate! Ito ang dapat na Senador!!

[@marianomingming2724]

Salamat Sen. Tolentino for law clarifications.

[@o.c.sun-theenaturals-spice9790]

The people should know that Sen. Bato is doing this for the good of the country and Filipinos, in real sense of his duty -ON AID OF LEGISLATION, as there is no existing law created on such act of IRRESPONSIBLE HANDLING OF CLASSIFIED DOCS, as CONFIRMED BY SEN. TOLENTINO! ✅💯

[@dodongrosal6611]

U can charge him of theft of government property if he took it without proper authority. Classified doc is a govt property.

[@danfergrandomega4342]

Stop the senate investigation, enact a law for this issue.

[@user-ic1ki9uq9i]

The Philippine Judiciary has No law penalizing the leakage of highly confidential documents to any individual or organization. documents. The duty and obligation of the Legislative Branch of the Government is to make and legislate laws pertaining to the leakage.

[@davidramirez1229]

remember senate is not a court and pls be warn ph has no law penalizing classified documents upon presentation per se..

[@pinaysaanman]

Nothing is classified in this case! In the first place no document existed!

[@edjiify]

sometimes it is a waste of time, efforts and government money ... the best is to put the jail right away ...

[@manuelarguelles3130]

Your a shame Mr Jingoy and a bully .

[@rolandotalens848]

Jinggoy cant stand the insult of POI J MORALES as a result of his insult to the former police officer one .

[@normastafford9716]

Gumawa kayo ng law penalizing the the person exposing or disclosing the classified documents that may endanger the safety of the country …

[@edralintalamayan3250]

TAMA PO YAN SIR, HUWAG TAYONG MAHIYA. DAHIL KASALE TAYO SA TAX, TAYO ANG NAGPAPASAHOD SA MGA YAN, THEY SHOULD DO THEIR JOB.

[@UKbaseflamingheartforneedy]

Binabara pag Tama!

[@bernardopinera8952]

If the Philippines has no law about penalizing document leak then you have passed a a law and implement ot if you want a solid and more strong vountry. Strong laws are better to implement for the welfare of the pilipino peple and secure the human right of the constituents. What sre you waiting for,law makers? Dont milked your house in the government 😂😂

[@FlavilineSabiano]

Bato is using the Senate for his/their personal interest..that is not fair

[@conniekern4615]

Sir Morales is honest person,we believe on him not you Estrada

[@lornaferguson4311]

You are a hero mr morales

[@liliapenora2909]

Tama ka Sir Bato,ikaw ang negotiator s kanila, hwag. pa apecto s dalawang batong nag uumpogan. POCOS,LANG S IMONG INVESTAGATION

[@marlonborbon3660]

TOL IS THE BEST, SEN TOLENTINO🙂👍👊

[@felycacal3882]

Bato must stop this hearing already. Nothing is coming out from this. It’s a waste of money and time.

[@Tambayan842]

Sa prescon kana manood when you think hearing is nonsense..

[@user-uh8zp1ig2k]

Ngayon na alam na ninyo na wlang batas na nagawa pa tungkol sa ganyang kaso eh ano pa ang hinihibmntay ninyo?

[@reyalayon2816]

The law aims to protect personal data in information and communications systems both in the • government and the • private sector.

[@moonflower1433]

Now you can make it true: ‘IN AID OF LEGISLATION’….. gawin nyo na po agad, bakit di nyo po naisip yan mga disclosures na ganyan..

[@bA-md7ef]

Not a credible witness its just hearsay. Hearsay. Hearsay lang

[@SALEMDiona]

SANA IPAGPATULOY PA RIN NI SEN RONALD BATO ANG HEARING PARA MALAMAN KUNG SINO ANG NAG - REMOVE NG FILE( BLUE BOOK) SA PDEA!

[@HeineBalcera]

Magresign ka na bato hindi mo kaya mag handle ng committee hearing

[@SalomeAntonio-bt9gf]

A waste of money of Juan dela Cruz, time and effort of the persons involved in this ... esp. the senators who are conducting the hearing ... our country has other problems other than this.

[@emmaelijorde9084]

Hwag po kayong bias mga senador ,the resource person should be respected !

[@manuelarguelles3130]

Jingoy is so bitter he could'nt accept the truth that the truth hurts .. Father Like Son 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@mariamercedescantu4639]

IT'S SO OBVIOUS THAT MOST OF THE SENATORS IN THIS HEARING ARE ON THE ADMIN'S SIDE. POOR 🇵🇭

[@victoriabinguet3176]

Insulting naman kay mr morales ths is one sided

[@BGC]

Just like sen Bato said, "convicted."

[@victorialoyzaga9012]

I WILL NOT VOTE THIS SENATOR FOR THE 2025 ELECTION.

[@adelllenos8445]

luh! di alam ng senators na to data privacy law?

[@reyalayon2816]

You are correct - (Mukhang mali itong si Tolentino) May corresponding penalties (jail term and fines) for Unauthorized Processing of Personal Information and Sensitive Personal Information under the National Privacy Commission.

[@Perfection212]

Pinanood mo ba ang whole video na ito bago mag comment?

[@sililabuyo771]

​@@Perfection212syempre pinanood nya! Kaya lang nagmamagaling,. Feeling nya magaling pa sya Kay atty tolentino.😂😂😂

[@bastosngabata012]

wow. pki explain po if sakop ba ng data privacy law ang government confi file 😅

[@PabloAbayan]

Chairman ka Sen. Bato, wag ka namang UNFAIR. Kung sinasasabihan mo si JM na magbigay respeto (kay Sen. JING-ONGOY) dapat parehas din si Sen. JING-ONGOY ay pagsabihan mo rin...

[@cecillealvarez2919]

Bakit ba natin pinagtyatyagaan panoorin at pakinggan itong nonsensical na Morales at Bato.

[@user-xb9sr8js4t]

dapat si Morales may kasamang atty... na tumutulong sa kanya...

[@user-pf7dc3fr5s]

jinggoy the softcopy confirmed by the who signed it is already an evidence.

[@joelemano2854]

Kagaling talaga ni Senador Tolentino.

[@killahbong]

Even falsified leak counted?

[@rolandotalens848]

Oh l love seeing POI J.MORALES returning the insults to " Honarable " Sen Jinggoy Estrada !

[@marlonjaudian3441]

Bakit ang congress Hindi investigate sa pedia leaks pero Kay pastor quiboloy atatnaatat cla mag investigate

[@rubybaltazar7940]

WALA N AKONG TIWALA SA MGA SENADOR NGAYON...SORRY PILIPINAS...NAKAKAAWA NA TAYONG MAMAMAYAN... .PLEASE, GOD, HELP US....

[@gerrygeraldez9712]

Mga butihing senador bakit hindi ninyo kausapin ang ating pangulo na mag pa drugtest para matapos na ang issue? Mayroon ba kayong tinatago?