SEPHORA BEST SELLERS MASCARAS TESTED || Best & Worst || Reviews + Close Ups!!

Just in time for the Sephora Summer Sale 2019, here are the reviews of Sephora Best Sellers Mascaras with close ups! All very popular mascaras from the Too Faced Better Than mascara to the Benefit Roller Lash but also some from Milk, Dior, Marc Jacobs and Hourglass! If you're looking for a new mascara recommendations, hopefully this video helps you find a new favorite!
More Mascara Reviews: bit.ly/2SpoH8E
♡ PRODUCTS MENTIONED ♡
Too Faced Better Than Mascara
bit.ly/2Nf58AG
+VS Dupe L'Oreal Lash Paradise
• Too Faced Better Than ...
Benefit Cosmetics They're Real Mascara
bit.ly/2NluOf6
Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Mascara
bit.ly/2VjmPnT
+ Wear Test • Benefit Roller Lash Ma...
Milk Kush High Volume Mascara bit.ly/2Nlpc4c
Lancome Monsieur Big Mascara bit.ly/2Z6SKK3
Benefit Cosmetics Bad Gal Bang Volumizing Mascara bit.ly/2Z5x5Sr
+ Review • HONEST REVIEWS || Bene...
Marc Jacobs Velvet Noir Major Volume Mascara
bit.ly/2KKIYXc
+ Dupe • LIKE THIS? TRY THAT! |...
Dior Diorshow Mascara bit.ly/2VaruIy
Tarte Light Camera Lashes Mascara bit.ly/2Z5xowz
Urban Decay Perversion Mascara
bit.ly/2Z1wYHI
+ their new waterproof version (I need it!!) bit.ly/2Z766py
+Wear Test • First Impression: Urba...
Hourglass Caution Extreme Lash Mascara
bit.ly/2Nm9KoO
+ Review • Worth the Money? Hourg...
Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara bit.ly/2ViFAaS
EARRINGS: bit.ly/2Ihwinm
♡ FOLLOW ME ♡
Book Channel: bit.ly/2a9TOmQ
Instagram: bit.ly/1MpDv1H
Facebook: bit.ly/29N6eAF
Twitter: bit.ly/1KQqL43
__FAVORITE SHOPPING SITES__
♡ MAKEUP ♡
SEPHORA: bit.ly/2aB0U11
Makeup Geek: bit.ly/2ERg6Fh
ColourPop: bit.ly/2O8kd5d
Target: bit.ly/2PhbhyG
♡ SKINCARE ♡
YesStyle (International) bit.ly/2CFX4zQ
SokoGlam bit.ly/2M8PNl8
Mikeala Beauty (Canada) bit.ly/2M0O8P9
♡ CLOTHES ♡
ASOS: bit.ly/1X77n4j
Dynamite Clothing bit.ly/2M6QVFO
Target: bit.ly/2PhbhyG
FTC: This video is not sponsored.
If you got here you get a virtual hug! :D

[@Tinyhands_mcgee]

You could donate your old wands to animal rescues! In October and February, Wands for Wildlife accepts used (cleaned) wands for their program! You just mail them in and they use them to groom babies and clean delicate fur/feathers!

[@Tinyhands_mcgee]

Marine so did I but when I looked on the website a few weeks ago they said they were getting so many that they have started to only take them twice a year! Which I suppose is a good thing, haha

[@caramelkisses8857]

Tiny Hands McGee I had no idea 😮. I’m going to do that!!

[@Anyoneouthere1]

Emily THANK YOU SO MUCH for all the effort you go through in your review videos you definitely are the BEST KZbinr when it comes to reviewing products! 💯❤

[@liiinduhhh]

i’ve struggled so many times using the better than sex mascara , it flakes so muchhhh and it always makes my eyelashes look clumpy . thank you for this video !!

[@catladylion5186]

Benefit they are real mascara has been my holy grail for years. Yes it hurts my eyes sometimes when it touches my waterlines , but it gives my lashes length and volume , it’s the only mascara that makes my lashes visible and long lasting too

[@lindsayguillen7]

Use coconut oil to remove! I've tried removing REALLY waterproof mascaras and they rip out eyelashes, I've tried removers that claim to take off waterproof and it just barely comes off and takes off many lashes, coconut oil immediately wiped it off, I rub it on my lashes with eyes closed with my fingers like I'm washing my face but just on the lashes and it works so great, I recommend, I haven't lost any lashes since

[@ivoryandgold88]

I've never even been tempted to buy a high end mascara until the Thrive Causmetics one. That one I want.

[@honeymonkey6105]

Love this one. Will only clump if I put on a 3rd coat!

[@tiffanyphuongkhanhta9395]

3:28 we need a Lash Routine, this is insane

[@officialsofia2486]

I'm looking for a new mascara and this helped SO.MUCH! Thank you for this review and for reviewing SO MANY!!!!!

[@beautywithemilie]

What's your favorite mascara from Sephora?

[@rita6297]

BeautywithEmilyFox I keep going back to the “they’re real” mascara from benefit! I don’t know anyone else who likes it though 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@leoniecote9221]

Monsieur Big sans l'ombre d'un doute !!

[@Nadanmasakali29]

Ysl the shock mascara. Best high end mascara . Plz try and review it

[@ginja1109]

No one talks about this one but the Tarte Lifted mascara is AMAZING. I generally only wear drugstore mascara because they go bad so fast. I LOVE the Covergirl Flourish mascara. Its so natural looking.

[@whutzat]

Emily you should try LASHCRAFT mascara! It is a Sephora brand. I use the one with the pink designs on the tube...I got it as a sample and as blown away. My all-time holy grail mascara though is the It Cosmetics Superhero Mascara. That's Emily Noel's Holy Grail one as well.

[@dianab3005]

You gotta try Tarte's Big Ego mascara! Picked it up on a whim the other day and I've been obsessed with it!

[@hannahvillanueva8757]

The UD Perversion mascara looks AMAZING on you

[@m5ri5lis5]

I've been wearing the tarte light camera lashes (waterproof and regular one) for about 5 years. It is the only mascara that dosen't make my lashes fall out. I love it! 😍🙌

[@maggiec5400]

Bag gal bang is my go to right now. But roller lash is definitely my second favourite out of the ones I’ve tried!

[@Farhanah24]

IT Cosmetics superhero mascara is the best one for me so far! 🙌🏻😋

[@QueenOfShovels]

You're the only KZbinr that mirrors my exact experiences with mascara's!!!! I've been waiting for new video 👍👍👍 spot on! So happy to hear about the ones you love! Same!!!!

[@rubennadevi]

Got the UD Perversion mascara thanks to your video. Can’t wait to try it out. Update: I finally got the Perversion and tried it. I think this is one of the best mascaras I have ever used. No clumping or flaking either. Will be throwing my Benefit TR mascara out.

[@VivienneFung]

I love love love Urban Decay Perversion! Great recommendations!

[@caro8463]

I love the They're Real mascara 😂 I'll admit it does take long to remove it... don't find it 'hard' as you say but it's definitely not quick. Regardless of that, I just love how my lashes look when I use it, they're long and super black, I don't particularly like clumpy lashes so this is perfect on that... it doesn't smudge or flake on me... And it lasts many hours looking exactly the same as when I applied it 😍 (that's why I can accept it takes some time to take it off haha) I've teared up and it held great consudering it's not a waterproof mascara, no raccoon eyes! And it holds the curve so good! I have pretty straight lashes but once i curl them and put this on 😍 is win for me👌 About the brush....... Yeah 😂 I poke my eye a few times with it and it hurt like f**k 😂 but it was only like 2 times, then I got the right way to use it. I've recently restocked on this one funnily enough; I've tried some drugstore ones but none are as good as this one imo so I had to buy it again when I finished it 😅

[@cristals8340]

The milk kush mascara always gives me raccoon eyes

[@Amelie-mm4kr]

ME 222 and i have the waterproof version

[@j383]

SAME OMG IT GOES EVERYWHERE

[@Elf_maxxx]

Same

[@my_2_cts]

I really like the Better Than Sex only on my upper lashes. I find putting it on my lower lashes gives me the flakiness you r talking about.

[@amandal3762]

It’s smudged and flaked even when I don’t put it on my bottom lashes though.. I’m glad it worked for you though (:

[@cemre5360]

I certainly am in love with Lancome Monsieur! I wore it today for the first time and it is the best mascara I have ever used

[@f-lrm]

What kind of lashes you have? Long thick? Long thin? Short thin? Short thick?

[@Ok-ef2bc]

Cemre Sağcan wore**

[@cemre5360]

I would say medium thin

[@Ohkeh640]

I love Lancome hypnose drama

[@jerinetan4875]

The tarte mascara is my go to daily mascara and I do think that the dryness was probably a one-off situation because I've already gone through two tubes and they only get dry towards the end! Will definitely be picking up the Lancome monsieur big mascara when I'm done with my current one :-)

[@nzgirl2105]

Better than sex used to be fenomenal mascara when it came out and thats exactly why it is so much hyped. But then they changed the formula..thax Too Faced. Great review Emily as usual 👌👌

[@mahazabeenkhan7073]

Yes! The tarte mascara has a drying formula and dries up quite fast but omg it’s soooo good though! Definitely holy grail status, but definitely will try the ud pervertion and monsier big one per your recommendation. Love your reviews and please keep trying more. Genuinely love your videos❤️

[@nikigray8134]

I have been loving the stila huge lash extreme 😍 I would love to see an updated favourite mascara video!!

[@maybellinewilson7455]

Niki Gray me too! I don’t hear anyone talk about that one!

[@carliehunt6198]

I LOVE Lancôme Monsieur big it is definitely my holy grail mascara!

[@lpg8518]

LOL I thought I was the only one!! The benefits mascara, I like it but I "stab" myself in the eyes every time I use it too. I prefer soft bristles over the plastic ones, I feel like they comb your lashes better. And yes, I've bought the tart mascara twice and it is a very dry formula because it's supposed to be natural without chemicals.

[@ursula.m8265]

I only use drugstore mascaras but I do like Roller Lash.

[@noorazimah9443]

I love the drugstores too! Whats your fav? Mine gotta be Catrice! Eversince they discontinued essence lash princess here in Singapore.

[@ursula.m8265]

@@noorazimah9443 ... For length I like L'Oréal Telescopic carbon black for volume... Lash paradise but I also like Lash sensational and Exibicionist.

[@Ohkeh640]

Ursula. M I love exhibitionist which colour bottle do you use?

[@Ohkeh640]

Ursula. M which ones best for drama volume and length

[@kaylapootz7698]

@@Ohkeh640 paradise is the best for both!

[@AnikoVargaMakeup]

Rollerlash is alright, at least not clumpy. Badgal Bang gets suuuuper clumpy when I try to layer it. I have the Perversion one but haven’t tried it yet. Better than sex doesn’t flake on me thanks god, but it’s really messy to apply. My favourite one is Essence Lash Princess 😅

[@NestingInNashville]

I’ve been loving Marc Jacobs velvet noir for years. On the hunt for a dupe since it’s now discontinued.

[@briannaroebling5773]

the funny thing is i love and prefer the hourglass shaped brushes (my favorite is the exhibitionist and then the monsieur big for high end) but i HATE the lash paradise.... I've never had any mascara EVER flake on me in my life but that one.

[@a.h.4746]

I've tried the lancome monsieur big one and the ud perversion and I've got them because of your recommandations. And I'm loving both of them . So thank you😘

[@karenporteous3626]

Great video. I especially appreciated how you showed the look of each on your lashes.

[@eleftheriaC]

Omg yes! Monsieur Big is so good! Thick black lashes and it doesn't smudge! I always get it when it's on sale though...I think it's ridiculous to spend 30 euros on a mascara :P

[@ioannarapti5460]

Συμφωνώ απόλυτα! Με το -35% νομίζω βγαίνει γύρω στα 19-20 ευρω. Έχεις δοκιμάσει μήπως την Hypnose Drama;

[@eleftheriaC]

@@ioannarapti5460 Όχι, γιατί γενικά δεν ψωνίζω high-end mascaras :)

[@timothycat9379]

It’s gonna be 50% off on Ulta 21 days of beauty

[@hannahjane8275]

i love lancôme monsieur big & i like benefit roller lash.

[@rebeccawebb2298]

Same!

[@nikkimorris]

Oh rollerlash is my holy grail!! The maybelline lashblast is kind of a dupe like I get the same effect but roller lash is still better lol

[@tumnekahakaise221]

I loveeee your makeup here, its natural yet beautiful.. specially your eye makeup. I hope you are doing good with the jaw surgery. lots of love Emily ♥️😘

[@Ceccan97]

I love that you always do close-ups in these! ❤️ Roller Lash is seriously so good, I recommended it to one of my friends and now she's hooked too haha! 😄 And I really like the Monsieur Big too, it's the mascara I'm currently using. Next on my list of high-end mascaras to try is the Tarte one and the Benefit Bad Gal Bang! 😇

[@miaclement7147]

This is such a useful video, comparing the mascaras side by side so that I don't have to go broke after buying all of them one by one. I prefer my mascaras a bit on the dry side and want both some length and some volume. Which would you recommend that I try? It doesn't necessarily have to be any of the mascaras mentioned in this video 😉 I usually also buy waterproof mascaras in order to prevent a lot of smudging on the lid and under the eyes 😊

[@evsodopex3]

Literally the same thoughts on the better than and they’re real mascara!!! Never could love it!

[@filmchicaksl]

I hate Rollerlash. It's super wet, smudges everywhere, and the wand is uncomfortable. It looks like it should give you wispy lashes, but it doesn't. It's just very black, but surprisingly clumpy. However, I love the Monsieur Big. That stuff gives me perfect lashes. For combing out lashes I use disposable mascara wands. They're really useful for brows, flyaway hairs and to separate your lashes since you're not adding any more product.

[@XxsamasarusxX]

I have actually tried the tarte lights camera and lashes 4-in-1 mascara and it was a wet formula when I recently purchased it. I tried the travel version of it and loved it for my lashes.

[@jessejames6688]

The Too Faced Better Than Sex flakes on me, too! So many people love it, but I can’t deal with stuff falling into my eyes throughout the day.

[@donadf4597]

I'M SO READY FOR THIS!

[@irinaermolaeva5520]

Roller lash is so amazing! I honestly love they are real too. If i want sth more glamorous, I gravitate towards they’re real. But it’s really hard to remove and it sometimes hurts my eyes too. I used perversion too but didn’t like it.

[@lavayuki]

i found that the Benefit Bad Gal Bang mascara to be insane, it's literally like false lashes and I can't find a Dupe in the drug store. I've tried all the Maybelline, Loreal and Rimmel ones so far but none were as dramatic

[@apryl9481]

Does/did it clump up badly? I usually only buy drugstore mascara but I’m looking into a higher end one.

[@lavayuki]

@@apryl9481 Yeah it gives a very falsie look, certainly not natural and is very black too. The downside is fallout

[@apryl9481]

@@lavayuki because of this, I ordered roller lash instead. I prefer a natural look so thanks for your feedback!

[@Mcoogie]

Bad gal is the sh!t!

[@swed-t-pie8206]

I think you are going to make me buy my first Urban decay product

[@potati8503]

Ud perversion looked so good. I hope they have a waterproof version since I have really watery eyes.

[@EstelasMakeup]

They have a waterproof version

[@briannaroebling5773]

they recently came out with it but ive seen SO many reviews lately that have said it is awful and nothing like the original. i recommend the covergirl exhibitionist in waterproof if u want a volumizing and long wearing mascara

[@potati8503]

@@briannaroebling5773 well shit maybe I'll just stick to loreal beauty tubes then. I can't get covergirl here D:

[@huang3925]

I think the urban decay and the tarte one looks good

[@ugbad1277]

Wth I’m so SHOCKED I only know Emily from booktube but she also does makeup😂 This woman does a lot

[@lac_maj]

I really want to try the last mascara, the wand looks interesting

[@JuliasBBeauty]

I have the same problem with Better than sex and I liked the Roller lash, the rest I haven't had tried. I appreciate the work that you put in your videos, is not like just sitting and talking but I know how much time it takes to film and edit all of these. I always play your commercials ( which are not even too many comparing with others ) because I feel that you need to get paid for the work you are doing for us!

[@TheYNirvana]

I really like the Benefit Bad Gal Bang mascara as it does not smudge and it's easy to take off. The They're Real mascara creates beautiful lashes but it's so difficult to take off even with my amazing eye make-up remover that usually takes off any make-up with ease!

[@bridgetnorris3025]

I love to layer two mascaras. I first start off with essence lash princess and layer on top of it L’Oréal lash paradise.

[@katieshearing6015]

Me too!

[@bridgetnorris3025]

Katie Shearing it’s the best result!

[@vanessaleininger4902]

oh! that's a great idea!

[@naraira__1397]

My fav is tarte lights camera lashes mascara A LOT. it makes my lashes looks really beautiful all day long!!! 😍

[@wajihasarfraz4608]

The one I got is dry. I need to put in alot of effort while applying. How long does it last

[@MsLinnXX]

The urban decay perversion gave me the prettiest lashes ever, but sadly ist smudges like crazy on me and I always look like I have terrible dark circles under my eyes.:(

[@thitsarmin]

Huda beauty and Thrive mascaras are my two holy grails.

[@tugceerylmaz9922]

The BEST mascara review I have ever seen!!!! Thanks xx

[@suzg7425]

Urban Decay hands down!

[@Helen3691]

Thank you for the detailed review. Years of extensions have made my once thick lashes thin and short so I’m looking for a decent mascara. I do prefer a drier formula since I curl my lashes and hate it when a wet formula takes the curl out. I’ll be trying the Tarte and Urban Decay. 🙏

[@SaraDeneault]

Late to the party but also love the roller lash mascara! A sephora employee recommended it to me a year or so ago and I've tried others since (drug store) but I love the roller lash.

[@xristinazdouf]

My all time favorite mascara is Better than sex and then I really like Lashes of the day from Essence! 😍

[@CammieMay]

Amazing! Thank you so much! EXCELLENT review!!! Saved me so much time. Very grateful. Great job!!! : )

[@kendrakinsey6833]

With the taste mascara I haven’t tried that one but I tried their big ego one. That brush is huge and it was a dryer formula, it only lasted me like a month or two

[@daysofourlives8966]

your lashes are crazy crazy loooooong

[@shokolatitavideoz]

My favorite is the lancome one' *.*

[@itsybrittc]

What is on your lippies!? 😍 such a pretty color 🌈✨

[@MalexOFFICAL]

Omg the mons. Big from Lancôme and roller lash from benefit is my combo for mascara and it’s the best!!!!!

[@ccilsolero8364]

I love the results of the UD Perversion BUT i can't were it with lenses, 2/3 hours after application it goes in my eyes and under my lenses. Not confortable at all but with glasses it's fine

[@piliitis]

Was looking for a mascara to replace my discontinued Mac Haute & Naughty mascara I’ve had for ages and really can’t thank you enough because now I’ve found at least 3 new ones!! Excellent review 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@Staciek76]

I love roller lash. I also enjoyed the Lancome one. But the last tube i got wasn't very good. The tarte mascara is a drier formula.

[@vpdq]

I am an eyelashes fan: I take care of them and I don't buy any mascara. I would say Benefit and Lancome have the BEST mascara, totally worth it

[@mcrmcrmcrmcr]

My favourite is the velvet noir of Marc Jacobs but I will try the urban decay one !

[@manont2345]

Allo, Personnellement,le meilleur démaquillant pour les yeux que j'ai trouvé est celui du Body Shop. Celui qui est liquide, pas en gel dans un tube. Mais le liquide qui est dans une bouteille blanche comme leur bouteille de gel douche. Ça vaut la peine que tu l'utilise. Il enlève tout. J'aime tes vidéos !

[@HotApplePink]

I love perversion.

[@jennykim719]

lights camera the tarte one is known for being very dry

[@wajihasarfraz4608]

Why dry ? Please tell

[@kgstudioproductions]

Yes the UD Perversion mascara is great!!

[@dittek.6513]

Will definitely take a closer look at perversion from UD 👍🏼

[@emasobrino3542]

the urban decay one looks the best on you

[@breeh8299]

bad gal bang used to be my favorite mascara but it dries out SOOO quickly. you only get 2 weeks before it is pretty much unusable

[@nzgirl2105]

My one stay wet forever. It is been a year and it is still like new

[@gabriellec7813]

5:53 omg I do the exact same. Those mascaras look great together.

[@isabelflores5950]

So what is your favourite mascara ?

[@evie1887]

Thank you . Video very helpful. Appreciate the detail so much. Just ordered the urban decay one

[@haileyjadecordova8378]

I kinda like dry mascara because I can coat it

[@Mizzmaefly]

I’m not sure if you’ve tried (this is an older video..) tart Maneater, one of my absolute favorites! Big Ego by tart and then Thrive’s mascara HOLY GRAIL! And Fenty Beauty. Those are all amazing. Ooohh and iT’s big ego I think it’s called. One of the iT ones, is also phenomenal. Thanks for the reviews and hope if you haven’t and do try sowmthing I’ve suggested you love as I do.

[@dionnesantomauro7024]

What is the name of your lip color? Love it!

[@marycarrella5705]

Roller Lash Team where you atttt ⬇⬇⬇

[@jennaann5175]

Emily, pretty please do a swatch video on the new Milani Keep it Full nourishing lip plumper glosses!!!!! I can’t decide which ones to buy because they all look so good and I can’t find any videos to refer to!!!!!

[@Kim-pj9ln]

This makeup look looks beautiful on you♥

[@michellemana777]

Hello ~ I really like Ur compare ! Do U ever try the " Trish McEvoy High Volume " one ? Giorgio Armani also got a black package one & a red one , CHANEL Le Volume De Chanel Waterproof , Surratt got lil one . Its just I m still looking 4 which one is the best of the best !

[@thebeautywitch9155]

Can you review the Dam Girl Mascara ??😭😭 love your videos.

[@beautywithemilie]

For sure! I'll be back very soon and I have a bunch of products to review :D

[@ayysenn]

Like whatever you described, I felt literally the same when trying them. With the 'They're real' mascara the sellers said its made on a waterbasis and you don't need waterproof make up remover. Still I'm not able to remove it properly. I recommend a Guerlain mascara.

[@zeejbender5480]

All these mascaras look really great on you.

[@creativitybycarilyn6634]

My fav is Loreal Telescopic. Mary Kay Lash Love is very nice too. Now I want to try the Urban Decay Perversion you showed. Never been impressed with high end mascara so far. BTW, you should try MAC Matte Lipstick in Marrakesh promotion color from Macy's. Free with $50.00 MAC purchase. Reminds me of Chili, but better.

[@bblissd]

Thorough review but could you tell us what YOUR top 3 are from this list?

[@Princesstayler9]

I love the Lancome High Definition mascara better than the one you talked about. I use either that or Maybelline Great Lash usually. I like a Loreal one that is a red/maroon color and Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes is nice. I like Too Faced Better than Sex, but people say the Loreal Lash Paradise was a dupe, but on me the Loreal smudged so bad and got everywhere.

[@briannaroebling5773]

agree...the ONLY that has ever flaked and smudged on me in my entire life is lash paradise and everyone seems to love it?!!!

[@chelseamoneill7717]

This was a good video. I liked the close up of the lashes with one eye having the product and the other eye without. Please show the packages up close so I don’t have to pause the video and follow the links just to see the package.

[@susanreid9857]

Love mascara videos xx Miss you Em xx

[@emanichantel6149]

I want to like monsouir big but it flakes and smidges so much. And the they’re real is amazing