Shah Bano, Triple Talaq & UCC: Secular Law Reigns 'Supreme', Why Politics Over Equality? | Newshour

In this episode of Newshour with Navika Kumar, we will discuss the landmark verdict of the Supreme Court of India on alimony for women. On Wednesday, the Supreme Court ruled that the "religion-neutral" clause applies to all married women, regardless of their religion, and that a Muslim woman may request maintenance from her husband under Section 125 of the CrPC. Soon after the verdict, a debate broke out among political parties, with Congress and BJP targeting each other and reminding who had done injustice to women. Who 'betrayed' women for votes? A panel joins us to discuss this in detail. 'Rajiv Gandhi did not do any wrong by bringing in the famously known as Shah Bano Act in 1986 because the same SC in the Danial Latifi Case upheld the constitutional validity of the 1986 act...' Kamru Choudhury opines. 'The Act of 1986 diluted the rights of Muslim women, and the intent itself of bringing that law was anti-Constitutional...' BJP's Gaurav Bhatia shares. Watch!
Connect with Navika Kumar On X (Formerly Twitter): x.com/navikakumar
Follow Navika Kumar On Instagram: navikakumar...
#supremecourt #alimonyformuslimwomen #muslim #equalrights #righttomaintenance #navikakumar #newshour #timesnowshows #debate #timesnowdebate #bjp #congress #bjpvscongress
Times Network takes the lead with its ground-breaking innovation and disruption of a new content category. The Times Network channels, which have a global footprint in 100 countries, inform, entertain, and engage viewers of all ages with fascinating and intriguing content, news, and information.
Subscribe to our channel - / @timesnow
Check out our website: www.timesnownews.com
Facebook: / timesnow
Twitter: / timesnow
Instagram: / timesnow

[@knnpillai7438]

Who betrayed whom? That question does not arise. At length, justice is meted out to muslim women, not by Congress or BJP but by the Supreme Court. Let us celeberate the triumph of Justice.

[@thombabu3914]

Rajive Ghandhi Cruvelty to towards Muslim Women to Appease Muslim Gents ?. What a Curse ??????

[@kidiyoormadhukar]

Muslims having more than two children in a country with 140 crores population is far worse curse than denial of alimony or money from Ali

[@Virtues128]

Not 'gandhi' but 'Gandi'

[@nagendranshanmugam239]

Super anchor, super lady Navikaji. May God bless you and all your loved ones forever.

[@Rabonykannan]

@@nagendranshanmugam239 Worst lady ,selfish traitor ...Godi journalist ..sold her for money .shameless Navika

[@thombabu3914]

What the Bloody AiiM speaking ????? Bloody Hell

[@spinnerlake]

Irony is he is lawyer

[@safesecure2570]

Why Tehseen poonewala not came to debate, is he hidinding because can't support supreme court judgement or either support congress anti muslim women act by Rajiv Gandhi.

[@varunreddy8225]

Rajeev used his 414 seats to stop the pension of some old lady

[@nigelgomez3705]

Abdul Reezak keep ur mouth shut, let the woman speak.

[@sasma50]

India needs a leader who will be courageous enough to take on the corrupt, the fundamentalists and make completely foolproof all the anti corruption and anti secular laws in the country. Till now unfortunately no such leader and leadership has come to the govern India.

[@kajorisen6144]

Good decision by supreme court..

[@madhavant9516]

We should be happy that Congress is not in power today. Great judgement by SC.

[@Binodhazarika-bg9vh]

Advocating secularism by Congress is Irony of fact.

[@deepaksaxena3256]

AIMIM spokesperson didnt bother to read the judgement before coming tona debate about it. Exactly what Aimim is all about.

[@devdasshegde2799]

People who didn't want to live together with Hindus demanded separate country and opted to migrate to Pakistan Those opted to live with India are bound by Indian law framed under Indian constitution.

[@renuprasad8967]

I really pity at Abdul Razzaq's wife/ wives!!

[@paintremedies4216]

India seems to be only country where merit holds little importance be it study or divorce. Sab jagah kisi na kisi rupees se arakshan hi hain

[@saenchai5071]

One nation should be legal practice one common civil law, foreign laws should not be allowed here!!

[@ramleshrr6002]

Why this supreme court force to apply ucc,i don't understand

[@geetasuvarna3958]

I don’t understand why waste time on all this . Concentrate on population control

[@vatsalaraj1406]

Who is wasting time muslim women claimed alimony in Supreme Court n court passed the judgement

[@PP-zr3ih]

Please implement ucc

[@rajasekhardandamraju599]

Don’t call a 10 nap ka beta AIMIM spokes person

[@anwarhussain-wl7gb]

Kisi ki biwi kisi ke saath bhaag gayi aur husband ne talaaq diya to kya woh biwi ko guzaara bhatta bhi dega?

[@rijumukherjee1870]

Why the saria supported muslim don't loud their voices about criminal laws which is against to saria criminal laws.

[@vishal_pho3nix]

whats the point, muslim people will never vote for Modi its just like a good will, non profit task for some people.

[@user-bq2of3cu5r]

So happy poor ladies got justice Modiji🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@madhukarpothula3243]

Navika you should not allow this suedo secularists to speak in these flatforms

[@mohanbist3826]

Wow. Tripple Talak is part of quran

[@AdiChintalapati]

And these same women still vote foe Congress. What an irony

[@jhabadrinamemjmkkkok6362]

Tha man in suit is leaving 1400 yr old tribal age.

[@Blessings..........]

WHATS UR INTENT

[@krishrao9169]

AM BJP supporter, but a nice word for RG, who has been approaching in terms of our NATION but for Banu's case like liabilities, otherwise he who has been one of the pioneers for our Digital prosperity, Note Little, MAJOR goes to then JS (bjp)

[@sanjaybhat7004]

Many states in the Christian USA allow child marriage. Likewise Muslims and Christians should be legally permitted to marry children in India.

[@Rathina1122]

Why not hindus, other religious group and atheist too

[@sanjaybhat7004]

@Rathina1122 because Hindus are far more evolved than monotheist religion followers. The Abrahamic faith has simplified the religion into one book and set out some rules so that even the most stupid can understand. In marketing we call it the KISS principle

[@noorahmedmaka7080]

Does Modi gives money to his lawful wife regularly ???????

[@eternalthoughts-wu5lo]

ye choice waala clause mujhe kuch Modi Modi khokhla Khokla lagraha hai... No choice should be given to saibooo laws...Only secular law shaould exist

[@coursefacilitator2342]

What about the Bilkees bano case? BJP government played a similar role ? What a godi media!

[@user-uw7vu5fv9k]

May I know which new law they created? In case of Bilkees bano. May be BJP made wrong against one woman. But when it comes to Congress by making a new rule, they effected all the women of the community.

[@Rajchikku]

india vs Modi's navika and white skin rubik's thak the kyoun nahi

[@hopkins3642]

Congress should apologize

[@Madhukumari-sb4wv]

Want to see pappu with red book😂😂 With slogan jai samvidhaan 😂😂 This people always thinks religion is above the country

[@ritasharmabansal8987]

Vivek is most stupidest in your panel because they only know how to attack BJP

[@Rajchikku]

Navika you are the sisickest 😮ever born in 2000 to 2024 if you are last

[@madhukarpothula3243]

Don't allow Razak to speak

[@breeks2116]

The Congress party and Nehru Dynasty are waste

[@imlimerenjamir8479]

What about rest of the Indian woman who's devorce?

[@neharathore4160]

They already have the right to alimony. Only ur community women were left behind.

[@sanjaybhat7004]

Ms. Sherwani, Ms Bark Bark Dutt and all international supporters of the INDI Gang must force the Govt to change the law and follow the wonderful Shariah law which is so so beneficial for women. Mamta Banerjee has already put the Shariah above the Indian Constitution.

[@Udayzeus]

[@sureshchandramishra5159]

Perhaps BJP has not any responsibility without criticizing Congress,do something

[@kkabra7578]

Mr vivek you are there to go against hindus.

[@rabisethi1481]

Mf bjp n sc let muslims do what want...let them be..focus on hindus what cong did with us plz chang it..

[@A1S2A3F]

Please do not spread fake news and hatred.

[@abaoj]

Godi media will never stop talking about Congress untill it exist in india please stop it And talk about the real situation indian people is suffering like hell.....

[@Rajchikku]

Classic tunnel

[@ranjitlalloo6188]

Islamic law Abdul! Then go to Afghanistan!

[@varunreddy8225]

Implement UCC

[@renuprasad8967]

AIMIM representative is so jaahil. Aise log kaash Pakistan kyo nahi chale gaye.

[@PP-zr3ih]

😂

[@anonymousanonymous7993]

Ranga is a true Modi bhakt, he gives speeches in T|V debates reading from a teleprompter! If he has to speak without a teleprompter, I am sure he will struggle like Modi.

[@premakuttalam8243]

Is it because he talks sense which u don't understand. Counter one of his point and then we will talk. At least Anand and modi talk sense unlike others

[@anonymousanonymous7993]

@@premakuttalam8243 Let me give a few examples of Modi Ji talking sense: Aaloo se Sona, Naali se Gas, Clouds making Radar ineffective, extra 2ab, not born biologically. And Anand Ranganathan comes every day to support and defend Modi Ji.. How one could be tallking sense when he has to defend a leader and his comments that don't make sense? So next time you should come to troll me oonly if you want to be exposed further!

[@premakuttalam8243]

@anonymousanonymous7993 I don't know what ur religion is but I care a damn. In hindu we believe tgat everyone is born for a purpose and this is exactly what he meant. He said he feels that his duty is Towards the nation so leave u are beyond to understand. Stop listening to rahul for a change and get into fact check on whatever he says and form an opinion of ur own. Don't be crabs

[@Rajchikku]

Adverse tunnel..

[@swayambhusrilanka9812]

Adil Hassan real the judgement but exposure not wanted!!! 😅😅😅😅

[@ranjitlalloo6188]

Anand Ranganathan educated the Maulanas!

[@yalpidoddayerrenna2182]

Ask the elements to speak to the question. Not bark rubbish

[@vinayakkumar8541]

jihadi personal law, for spreading jihad

[@swayambhusrilanka9812]

Hindu divorced patni ka kharch😂😂 uthaye moja moja tha!?!

[@Uskulakdituskutappa]

Vivek you are such an hypocrite. But why take a stand for women forget religion. I don’t want to see you in debate

[@lakshmikanth4501]

Nonsense talks.......strict to topics......Modi went Russia for Nation benefits not for his personal gain......

[@kkabra7578]

Go to islamic country if you want to follow islamic laws

[@ranjitlalloo6188]

Abdul is just a clown!!

[@ranjitlalloo6188]

Abdul is so insecure and uneducated!

[@lgthm2062]

Puri Gandhi family ek jaisi hay by god ..

[@madhukarpothula3243]

Hasan is a radical fellow

[@madhukarpothula3243]

Navika don't allow this idiate vivek to speak

[@Rajchikku]

Legaty vs modi and his tele promoter

[@anonymousanonymous7993]

I hope this judgment also helps Jashodaben finally get justice

[@hopkins3642]

Where is womens leader pappu

[@PP-zr3ih]

99 baba

[@unkalpaddy481]

Abdul kitna bhi suit & tie pehen le, uske dimaag mein chhota pyjama hi hai

[@a-r-t7855]

Vivek miya ji Ping ka langoor will start barking just wait 😊😊

[@RajenthiranGovindasamy]

One nation one law and the Constitution shall take precedence over all other laws , rules edicts, decrees or any other written proclamation by any state, body cult or faith.

[@Rathina1122]

Pakistan is also one nation and one law. Whatz the progress there. Never been one stable govt. Its a total regress state Cant go the pakistan way.

[@madhukarpothula3243]

Hasan shut your mouth

[@geetasuvarna3958]

Nehru Khan supported Pakistan

[@freesoul3160]

What kind of religion is this ??

[@madhukarpothula3243]

vivek is worst fellow

[@vasudevantk3433]

Anand R is great👍🏻💪🏻💪🏻more power to him

[@narendramarkale7908]

For them women are just production machine to increase their population everywhere around the world & particularly in Bharat

[@KAvinash-lc9ou]

What amount is being paid to Yasoda Ben by Modiji? Before going to this verdict,think on this matter and implement the hindu law to m/s Yesoda Ben.

[@varunreddy8225]

So you are ok Rajeev using his 414 seats to stop her pension, budhimaan

[@geeta8889]

This is great news! Shazia elmi 🙏🙏🙏

[@Uskulakdituskutappa]

Constitution of India should prevail over any law.

[@coursefacilitator2342]

MODI SHAH are mediocre.

[@MahishyaS]

Hahah burnol moment for jihadi joker 😂🤣🤣

[@KrishnaKumar-sr2nc]

Fortunately for Muslim women congress government is not there. Otherwise the Supreme Court judgement would have made ineffective through parliament for appeasement politics.

[@kkabra7578]

What these men are meaning is that we have moved on, married again so the women get lost from our lives.

[@vinayakrao2881]

The children of such sufferers must get all monies for their wellbeing like school fee clothing etc.

[@kkabra7578]

Why did nehru not apply the same rule for muslims also and restrict them to one wife

[@bhimasena8172]

Anand and vivek Srivastava chatting in betwen discussion and they are laughing 😅😅😅

[@mrinmoydey4904]

Islamic n shariya law is Unfortunate, hats off amana .

[@Blessings..........]

BEAUTIFUL ACTING AWARD GOES TO ANCHOR.

[@WalletmoneyOnline]

Muslim Jelous 😂😂

[@shivas9600]

Nothing like assssssmani kitab 😂

[@kakolipaul2021]

I want see Bengal CM 's reaction who wins elections by muslim appeasement

[@vivekmuradayil5594]

Rahul will stand with sisters of india

[@yalpidoddayerrenna2182]

Send out the lier

[@Hes12378]

UCC is undemocratic

[@unkalpaddy481]

Earth is flat

[@parthachem83]

Typical madrasachaap logic 🤡

[@shivas9600]

Rangela rasool was a pedo 😂

[@Rabonykannan]

Talk about Bilkis Banu Navika

[@tamilindian921]

Talk about chinese secret deal between pappus whole family and xuixing pinggggggg...and ofcourse the clony deal wit that baasta...rd george soros

[@flyingsraco]

Today the court gave judgment on paying maintenance to divorced muslim wife and not on Bilkis Banu. Maybe too hard to understand coz of your mental capacity??

[@pedadasiddardha9655]

Does you have dare to speak on Girija Tikoo

[@shivas9600]

Talk about 4 year aisha and 70 year old momo the pedo aka rangeela rasool 😂

[@Rabonykannan]

@@pedadasiddardha9655even though i am not a journalist..as a common citizen I condemn the rape of Girija tikoo ...I feel sorry for her as I feel sorry for bilkis banu ...but Godi journalists like Navika should be ashamed of her for not condemning the bjp governments and Hindutva terrorists atrocities all over India ...

[@herophoenix]

Oh this is Godi Media 😅😅😅 let me go out from here ... Bye 👋

[@munirajc3575]

India Full of Godi Media .whr will u GO?

[@shivas9600]

​@@munirajc3575 in aisha 😂

[@munirajc3575]

@@shivas9600

[@a-r-t7855]

Tehsin puthawala chuha ban ke bill me ghus gaya

[@a-r-t7855]

Mazak khand get lost 😊😊

[@Tufluv7]

Bilkis baano ke saat kya hua bhakto

[@DoleshSao]

1 vs whole community U know the difference???? Madrasachap Was there a new law created, was constitution amended for vote sake??? Jaahil Madrasachap

[@Hes12378]

UCC is undemocratic

[@sakshikale1006]

Get a life dude😬😏🙄

[@parthachem83]

Madrasachaap life is great. No idea, no knowledge, no work, no life 👍