Shamsi Challenges Mansur Speaker's corner

Membership link Below if you would like to join, Jazaka allahu Kayran:
/ @sfdawah
Donate Generously to continue the Channel & Translations for Arabic Channel;.
Link Below:
www.paypal.com...
May allah Reward You.
Don't Miss New Uploades, SUBSCRIBE Share And Like...
******************************************
******************************************
• American Girl Travelle...
******************************************
• CHRISTIAN MAN AMAZED B...
******************************************
• Video
*******************************************
• SHAMSI CONFRONTS THE D...
*******************************************
Some Videos May Contain Strong Words, Some Viewers May Find Some Of The Contents Offensive Or Inappropriate.
*******************************************
Disclaimer: The Viewers and Opinion of Speakers or Debaters In The Videos Do Not Represent THIS Channel In Any Shape Or Form, The Channel Only Represent The Actual Image At Speakers Corner.
**COPY RIGHTS RESERVED!**
Donate for translation please: on the link
contact: [e-mail]
Original contents : @sFDawah
Copy Right Reserved : @sFDawah
Edited and Uploaded: @sFDawah
***THANK YOU FOR WATCHING!!!!***
***THANK YOU FOR WATCHING!!!!***

[@OppaiLover12]

When mansur said he is from Bangladesh my chest gets filled with pride that I am born in a country where such an humble and kind man is from… keep fighting for all of us. Love from Bangladesh ❤

[@rpruffryder]

As a bangladeshi i feel so shamed to be bengali.

[@imheretocausetrouble2156]

Sound like a nationalist

[@hamzaibrahim2986]

Pride is a disease on the heart fear Allah

[@sajidulislamskilled]

@@rpruffryder and may I ask, why is that you're ashamed of your motherland?

[@indram5384]

Mansur is an Indian Muslim, he is always claim when debating. Which is good.

[@robertomalone3222]

🇵🇸🤲 Our biggest problem is the fitna that we create for ourselves within our Ummah, this is how the enemy reaches us so easily, may Allah SWT guide us all...

[@Khalifah0896]

You're completely wrong akhi May Allah unite the ummah upon the truth and expose the grifting liars. One of the main problems with the ummah is that we are too reluctant to clarify the truth in regards to individuals for the sake of unity upon falsehood. May Allah guide you and all of the Muslims.

[@مجدابوبكر-ث5د]

بل مشكلتنا في الفوضى وقلة العلم

[@mzak23]

@@Khalifah0896 When you/we can "clarify the truth" 😂 Every person and muslim organisation are claming that " truth " for hundred years 😂

[@Sami-bs1go]

@@مجدابوبكر-ث5دمشكلتنا في المداخلة ا

[@Khalifah0896]

@mzak23 that's why we have study deen, in order to be able identify the false claimant from the true one.

[@ahmedbajaber471]

I see a lot of ppl commenting about how shamsi speaks and not what shamsi says. Yes he speaks with a lot of emotions but he dodsnt lie and slanders other. Rather he quotes Quran, Hadith and the scholars. May Allah preserve him and guide us and him

[@SiradjZoheir]

this is the religion cause the right aquida and tawhide is coran say prophet say the salafe and sahaba understanding and scholars not I think not my opinion or i see i feel finally no philosophy in Islam

[@badarasn4408]

Exact

[@fanatik2408]

The title is misleading Manshur in the one that challeging Manshur is the attacker Shamsi just defending

[@DJamz-xp7dc]

He is picking and choosing ayat and ahadeeth like buffet and ignoring the rest, this guy is the definition of jahel he follows "ulamaa"/juhalaa who supports Saudi state who is ruling with kufr laws and who only moves their army to attack other muslims like yaman the people who Rasool Allah alayhi asalaam praised

[@abdulrahmanabdulghani8833]

he is accusing others a liar....Shamsi must be patience...not need to shout..

[@nomar3708]

Thank you brother Shamsi. We Yemenis are example of this mistake of rebelling our leaders which 8 years now we are suffering many people died. Muslims listen to brother Shamsi, stop these criticising our Muslim leaders people revolt and cause destruction. We Yemenis are regretting. May Allah forgive us tor this mistake and retuYemen like before

[@Afif.anNayem.asSalafi]

Ameen ameen

[@amjidali588]

So don't rebel against the country attacking your country?

[@ekbalhussain3269]

​@amjidali588 he is talking about the revolt that happened against the previous president Abdullah Saleh during the so-called Arab spring. A group of ikhwanis instigated a revolt that led to his downfall. This set off a civil war which resulted in the houthis gaining ascendancy in some parts of Yemen. Salih himself sought the aid of the houthis even though he fought thempreviously , and then turned against them after he saw their true colours. Then the houthis seized power forcing the Yemeni rulers to call upon the gulf countries for aid. This current war with houthis started with that revolt back in 2011.

[@ekbalhussain3269]

​@@amjidali588it's amazing how short people's memories are! That's why common people have no business talking about politics. Leave these affairs to the Rulers and the Scholars!

[@greengardens1565]

So when do an oppresses ppl should revolt agaisnt these leaders who serve the west

[@indeed7]

Fear Allah my brothers, let's see this discussion as a gain of knowledge, let's not go around talking bad about our brothers in faith.

[@مجدابوبكر-ث5د]

الحق احقق ان يتبع وشمسي معه القران والسنة اما حماس معها الفوضى والهرج والفتن والشيعة

[@Bond786muslim]

Sunak hates muslims

[@lorddlorddd1707]

@@مجدابوبكر-ث5داتوسل الى الله ان يحشرك انت والكافر شمسي في نار جهنم. المجاهدين تاج راسكم ياعباد الطواغيت الكفار

[@slaveofALLAHPAKonly]

Yeah brother absolutely 💯

[@neomatrix4965]

Might allah bless you my brother shamsi.. you showed me the importance of going back to scholars and Quran and sunnah in every problematic issues in life . 🙏 🤲

[@alimiah4487]

I do hope you wrote this by mistake.. or maybe without realizing you getting brainwashed

[@BK-iu6ow]

@@alimiah4487no maybe you need to look back at history, prophet sallau Aleyi wasalam, companions, Islam is complete, if there is an issue you look for answers within the religion, none of that I think or emotions, you think you know better than Allah and what he sent to his messager?

[@MN-sc2uz]

​@alimiah4487 you cant fix stupid.😵‍💫

[@Topendcars555]

Yes facts

[@alimiah4487]

​@@Topendcars555 Do you even know what he wrote or what claim his making? The loyalty in shirk will get "in the lowest depths of Hell, and you will find no one to help them. 4:1 45

[@nazirmohamed1296]

lots of muslims criticising shamsi because they do like to go by desires and emotions some of them are ignorant they thinks that if daniel speaks calmly therfore daniel is right

[@abdulrahmanabdulghani8833]

he is calling others liars...is he a Saint?

[@jumperholics7688]

Its true

[@abutalsafuba2179]

"The prophet didnt say you cant give bayah to a woman leader." Which Quran and hadith text was shamsi quoting?

[@wonderwalls3565]

prophet PBUH aslso did not say you cant eat a baboon or a kangroo. Shamsi gives fatwa by quoting a hadeeth but when challenged about bayah to a women he says dont ask me I am not a scholar. bring your fatwas from all scholars about all Muslim countries and bayah, if you cant then stop imposing your yazidi and Aal-e-Umayya ways. BTW ask him what should happen to mawiya when he refused to give Bayah to the chosen Caliph and came to fight him? what shold have happened to Aisha RA when she came to fight against the chose caliph?

[@alimiah4487]

@nazirmohamed1296 It has nothing to do with "desires and emotions" but the proof that comes from the Quran and Hadith. You who believe, do not take the disbelievers as allies and protectors instead of the believers: do you want to offer God clear proof against you? Quran 4::144 The hypocrites will be in the lowest depths of Hell, and you will find no one to help them. Quran 4:145

[@abrarmd6243]

Never knew brother Mansur is from Bangladesh. Proud of you brother. May Allah keep always keep you steadfast, humble.

[@OCEAN-fc9wl]

Daniel: emotions and crowd control Shamsi: quran sunnah, sahaba said, prophet said etc…

[@boredalchemist]

lol shamsi lot lie

[@kaz4845]

Sahaba rebelled and battled with rulers, and they called upon laymen to follow them and fight other sahaba.

[@OCEAN-fc9wl]

@@kaz4845 lies, even if thats true, the actions of one or two sahabis are not a criteria. The criteria is the prophet and the sahaba as a WHOLE, just like how majority of sahaba agreed on having Uthman as 3rd khalifa

[@boredalchemist]

@@OCEAN-fc9wl stop lying its fine to rebel you can follow which sabah you like and we can follow which ones we like and we can let Allah decide if the Muslims should support the oppressor or not

[@paradisepeace9994]

@@OCEAN-fc9wl , 1) The obedience of the Muslim leader only applies to matters that are permissible in Islam. If they demand actions that are sinful, one is excused from their obedience It has been narrated on the authority of Ibn 'Umar that the Prophet (ﷺ) said: "It is obligatory upon a Muslim that he should listen (to the ruler appointed over him) and obey him whether he likes it or not, except that he is ordered to do a sinful thing. If he is ordered to do a sinful act, a Muslim should neither listen to him nor should he obey his orders. حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ، حَدَّثَنَا لَيْثٌ، عَنْ عُبَيْدِ اللَّهِ، عَنْ نَافِعٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ عُمَرَ، عَنِ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم أَنَّهُ قَالَ ‏ "‏ عَلَى الْمَرْءِ الْمُسْلِمِ السَّمْعُ وَالطَّاعَةُ فِيمَا أَحَبَّ وَكَرِهَ إِلاَّ أَنْ يُؤْمَرَ بِمَعْصِيَةٍ فَإِنْ أُمِرَ بِمَعْصِيَةٍ فَلاَ سَمْعَ وَلاَ طَاعَةَ ‏"‏ ‏.‏" - Sahih Muslim 1839a

[@YalvacliDelikurt]

Brother Mansur is an other level machaallah

[@supermarvelgainz]

This title is misleading. Shamsi and Mansur didn't challenge eachother rather Br. Mansur was asking Br. Shamsi a question.

[@nigo123]

true ma'sha'ALLAH but i dint get why they're not doing this privatley ! why in public ! @@supermarvelgainz

[@fayaqun0]

He's so humble and a man of sabr

[@emonGroup]

But mansour pushed him with that question, and he made him stuttering. What about my Bangladeshi president should I do Bayaa to her. 😮

[@supermarvelgainz]

@@emonGroup layman's like yourself love revolting againts leaders, doing khorooj, protesting, free mixing, listening to "halal music", joining in bidah, doing milad un Nabi, grave worshipping, calling on saints. Improvise on fixing your own home before you think you can fix a whole country. Women aren't allowed to rule a country and Ahlus Sunnah accept this however brother Shamsi showed humility and humbleness when saying ask the scholars. He doesn't talk from his desires to poetically seduce you into happiness. Allah over everything.

[@SaudiShanab]

To Brother Shamsi and Brother Daniel. I say that Shamsi presented evidence from the Qur’an and Hadith, and Daniel uses emotions and feelings and ignores the evidence from the Qur’an and Hadith! I am with brother Shamsi and I believe that he is right, and Allah knows best

[@shafaetferdousnoor1741]

There's a lot of evidence for Brother Daniels point as well but he was not there to debate so he didn't prepare to present evidence he was there to just have a conversation .

[@amensar5492]

Shamsi also against hijab

[@britishqueen94]

Madkalis toads

[@AbAb-me5wc]

NO SHAMSI DAYOOTH DON'T USE QUR'AN AND SUNNAH HE'S SNAKE 🐍 AND CAN'T ANSWER QUESTION 🤣

[@AbAb-me5wc]

MADKHALIS ARE AGENTS BE CAREFULL PEOPLE

[@abufuturetrunks5630]

May Allah bless shamsi and the brother Muhammad for clarifying the truth

[@Khalifah0896]

Ameen 💯

[@abdulkadir9319]

Ameen

[@kb4432]

Let's talk about the scholars who accommodate the wealthy and currupt rulers and don't speak out against oppression. "O you who have believed, indeed many of the scholars and the monks devour the wealth of people unjustly and avert [them] from the way of Allah . And those who hoard gold and silver and spend it not in the way of Allah - give them tidings of a painful punishment". (Qur'an 9:34) The Prophet (saw) said: “There is something more I fear for my Ummah more than the Dajjal: “Misguided scholars.” (Musnad Ahmad) Abdullah bin Amr narrates the Prophet (saw) said: “Most of the hypocrites of my Ummah will be its Qurra’ (i.e. evil scholars).” (Musnad Ahmad) The Prophet (saw) stated: “The worst ulama visit the homes of unjust and oppressive leaders while the best leaders visits the homes of ulama.” (Ibn Majah) Umar ibn al-Khattab (ra) reported: The Messenger of Allah (saw) said, “Verily, among what I fear most for my nation is every hypocrite with a knowledgeable tongue.” (Musnad Ahmad) The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: “Undoubtedly, Allah loves those rulers who keep the company of scholars (Ulama) and He hates those scholars who maintain ties with rulers. Because, when the scholars frequent the rulers then the scholars incline towards the world, whereas, when the rulers frequent the scholars then the rulers incline towards the Hereafter.” (Imam Daylami) Ubadah bin Samit (ra) said: “If a pious learned man loves the rulers, he commits hypocrisy, and if he loves the rich, he commits show.” (Ihya Ulum al Din) Ka’b ibn ‘Ujrah reported: The Messenger of Allah (saw) said, “Verily, rulers will come after me and whoever enters their abode, affirms their lies, and supports their oppression, they are not part of me and I am not part of them; they will have no presence at the Fountain. Whoever does not enter their abode, does not support their oppression, and does not affirms their lies, he is part of me and I am part of him; he will be present at the Fountain.” (Tirmidhi 2190)

[@jackjack-sh7uy]

*Sheikh Muhammed and Sheikh Shamsi spoke the truth masha'Allah. And its very sad and was unjust that brother Hashim and others interrupted and did not really allow brother Shamsi speak and answer questions that he was asked and defend hinself against that crypto extremist lies of that cringe lair Daniel Haqiqatjou who has little knowledge of Qur'an and Sunnah and that crypto extremist Daniel also called Muslims Scholars of Qur'an and Sunnah as tawaghit (kafirs)*

[@abdullahmahmud1298]

Ameen

[@AM-ny7rz]

Mansour is a legend alhamdulilah. And alhamdulilah for shamsi wisdom

[@samrock8567]

Shamsi is no scholar and he openly call the deobandi school a sect......the tabligh jamaat a sect.......any foreign scholar especially a salaf scholar who has no idea ABT India and other Asian countries don't know what he is talking ABT..........

[@hakz795]

@@AM-ny7rz Mansoor was wrong. Shamsi was right

[@ilyasancharad4285]

may allah reward shamsi. he opend my eyes. we are muslims. we follow qoran and sunnah. if you dont like it..thats your problem not islam

[@DJamz-xp7dc]

Shamsi calling to ta'weel 🤦🏽‍♂️ which Quran and Sunnah he is picking and choosing ayaat and ahadeeth like buffet directly against the Quran

[@knowledge8783]

Opened your eyes on what?

[@k.r.6800]

​@@knowledge8783on how to do bootlicking

[@k.r.6800]

May Allah get rid of the bootlickers

[@MuhammedfayizK]

​@@k.r.6800Salamah bin Yazid Al-Ju'f (May Allah be pleased with him) asked Messenger of Allah (ﷺ): "O Prophet of Allah! Tell us, what you command us to do if there arises over us rulers who demand of us what is due to them and refuse us what is due to us." Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) turned away from him, but he repeated the same question. Thereupon Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, "Listen to them and obey them. They are responsible for their obligations and you are accountable for yours."

[@TheMaximer16]

After reading the comments I notice that Shamsi has a lot of haters damn 😂 may Allah protect him.

[@jonathan27284]

Is madkhali He is leaders lovers

[@nazirmohamed1296]

Because lots of muslims do like to go by desires and emotions some of them are ignorant they thinks that if daniel speaks calmly therfore daniel is right 😂

[@hamzanocap]

Christians, Rafidhi Shia, graveworshippers and people of desires as always

[@badarasn4408]

​@@nazirmohamed1296wallahi

[@badarasn4408]

​@@hamzanocap👍👍🤣

[@FazalKhan-rq9ws]

We as muslim should stick together for the sake of Allah. may Allah guide us all, ameen

[@Khalifah0896]

We should unite upon truth for Allah sake, and a part of that is clarifying the truth in regards to those who choose to lie like Daniel.

[@deleonlibrado2462]

YUeah...muslims must stick to one another bec the US and the west not thinking to kick all muslims in their nations..

[@omanhakimi3321]

refute misguidance.

[@DestinyAwaits19]

If the Sahaba fought eachother what chance you got in this day and age?

[@mahashalgam9480]

We as Muslims must stick to the Qur’an and Sunnah

[@tekaashii3943]

May Allah Bless Shamsi wallahi Everyone's is Almost talking about Emotionals while shamsi is Preaching Quran And sunnah. May Allah reward him and Aid Him

[@drive-2786]

more like he is barking every time, all the times bruv ,he has a problem with every Muslims ...clearly something is not right with him.

[@tekaashii3943]

​@@drive-2786Fear Allah.. I don't know if we hear both the same guy? BARKING) ? While He always says Allah says and the prophet Says? Fear Allah

[@abustranger1789]

No he just waffles and cant clearly speak english or arabic properly. miskeen. Slave of the al saud

[@drive-2786]

@@tekaashii3943 Yeah i Fear Alllaah .who u fear , WHY U TAKING THE BOOTLICKER SIDE ? are u spubs member too ? He never represented ISLAM on a large platform with intellectuals etc.but brothers that put in works he wants to bark at them .did he not says/hold the stance ,that Palestine's is worshiping graves that's why they're being punish ? and who is this hamas he keep talking about .that he believes is a terrorist group to cause the killing of 1400 isreali .where is the evidence for this, why is he parroting what he knows not of . so far aside for the AI extreme jewy lies there is no evidence .of funerals or how hamas breach such a high tec security of israhell who shows up, some 1 hour after the attack ..u believe all this like him ?

[@HellllooKittttyyyyy]

Where in Quran and Sunnah should we obey Secular Taghout Rulers who oppresses the muslims and fights against the Legislation of Sharia law Modern day so "called" salafism is a joke

[@yrysf777]

I didnt know Mansour is Bangladeshi. Bengali and Syrians are most intelligent muslims i have met

[@embraceislamandeventuallyy1006]

What did you think he was

[@servantofallahthemostmerci7725]

I thought he was from Iraq I think I've heard it before. @@embraceislamandeventuallyy1006

[@muhtasimmahin5057]

What??! Mansur is Bangali!!

[@solslastcannula5665]

Bengali and Egyptians are most intelligent people I met

[@georgefrancis8602]

🇧🇩🐟

[@khamzatisrailov3428]

Subhanallah brothers, in this video Shamsi is the most knowledgable and the one who has studied the most directly from elders, Shamsinis not debating but clarifying Quran and Sunnah, may Allah make all these brothers upright

[@jaloulonex1898]

I know why shamsi gets angry , because people ignore the great scholars of ahl sunna wa jamaea and gives their opinions .. this is not christianity here to care about feelings and emotions and love and such things , it's about the truth it's about salvation !

[@ozzymadah2898]

100% truth coming from Shamsi's mouth! May Allah bless him!

[@داعيإلىاللهعلىمنهجالسلف]

Ameen

[@idontcare7922]

Shamesy is taghut, and coward

[@knowledge8783]

😂

[@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte]

he misuses the treaty of al-hudaybiyya, which was a unique one time event, under pressure of islam being wiped out, Allah giving wahy (surah 48:1), to claim that saudi can make normalization with isr4hell

[@ozzymadah2898]

You are not a scholar. You are just someone typing letters on the internet. Go away. If it was up to people like you, we would have lost all of our lands.@@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte

[@grahamhussain7020]

Brother shamsi has become very arrogant, brother mansour is a very humble calm guy who's only trying to make these discussions productive

[@sheikhshakilakhtar1865]

Really? I see advising Mansour very nicely. Can you tell me where he refused to accept daleel?

[@tekaashii3943]

Be justice akhi shamsi loves everyone for guidance that's why he is verry emotional to give dawah

[@drive-2786]

@@tekaashii3943 ...yeah like ali needs dawah .again stop worshipping as if he your prophet .fear your Rab as u like to tell others in your subliminal diss

[@hamzanocap]

​@@drive-2786You have just made takfeer of another Muslim and the Messenger peace be upon him told us that those who make takfeer unjustly it falls back upon them. You are a clearly a jaahil typing nonsense from the comfort of your home, may Allah guide you.

[@babammuadams9194]

I agree 👍 He get hungry so easily,and he should learn how to talk calmly just like other brothers on the park I use to watch him alot but now not anymore.

[@QairulIzhar]

May Allah bless Shamsi ❤

[@jamalhoshaim6663]

Shamsi israel 😂😂

[@jibriljibril2913]

You need Ruqyah

[@QairulIzhar]

@@jamalhoshaim6663 Do you insult your prophets..because the prophets are from the children of Israel..where do you put your mind..is it at your feet

[@QairulIzhar]

@@jibriljibril2913 you mean that I can't pray for my Muslim brother..

[@jibriljibril2913]

​@@QairulIzharI wrote this to the person who told to shamsi israil not to you

[@honest_user]

When Mansour ask about Bangladeshi ruler, Shamsi replied with ask scholar but when it's Saudi he knows the answer.

[@djamelcher7959]

He spoke about what he knows about rulers

[@eltr1665]

because he asked the scholars about saudi you idiot

[@honest_user]

@@djamelcher7959 and what he knows about the rulers?

[@asdfghj-df8hk]

​@@honest_userwhat do you know

[@Prayformetobeagoodmuslim]

Lol it’s not the same thing bro, the leader of Bangladesh is a woman that’s why shamsi said ask the scholars if You have to give her bayyah or not. Fear Allah

[@saymyra]

may Allah Subhanah wa ta'ala preserve our brother Shamsi and Keep him firm on the Deen and Sunnah and the Way of the Salaf and may Allah preserve mansur and Guide him to distance himself from the likes of Danniel (may Allah guide him back to the truth)

[@honestbeng4308]

Both ,brother Mansur N Brother Shamshi has their point cause they both base on the Holy Quran N Hadith. So this discussion is knowledgeable. Anyway they should do it behind close door to prevent the disbelievers from making fals allegations against this conversation.

[@BANGALI_BIXAN]

Alhamdulillah.Good to know that my brother Mansur is from Bangladesh.....

[@Alight_of_islam]

Same!!!

[@Xoggaar]

It is not about challenge as far as i can see it is brothers who are discussing the understanding of the deen..

[@iam_spindel]

i love shamsi and how he chew his gum😂😂❤

[@ShakeOneOfficial]

That's so 🌈gay 😅😅😅

[@iam_spindel]

@@ShakeOneOfficial istaghfiullah

[@Alight_of_islam]

Brothers and sisters, let's be honest with ourselves and not criticize our brothers in this manner. They're both better in their own ways and they are also human like us, they can make mistakes. Don't take this as an extreme!. They're doing best masha Allah. May Allah Bless our dawah brothers to spread Islam to the misguided people, Ameen 🖤❤️

[@geomattech7891]

shamsi have to improve a bit his way in dialogue and try to give other some space to talk, this the only issue for him otherwise for me his evidence does make sense i agree with him to not use some emotions as proofs .... but the problem here seeing some people here in comment section who abused him verbally is so unbelievable and its not attitude of islam, i call them to fear allah for what they said cause these small distinctions may lead us to big fitna ... may allah bless you

[@paradisepeace9994]

1)The obedience of the Muslim leader only applies to matters that are permissible in Islam. If they demand actions that are sinful, one is excused from their obedience It has been narrated on the authority of Ibn 'Umar that the Prophet (ﷺ) said: "It is obligatory upon a Muslim that he should listen (to the ruler appointed over him) and obey him whether he likes it or not, except that he is ordered to do a sinful thing. If he is ordered to do a sinful act, a Muslim should neither listen to him nor should he obey his orders. حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ، حَدَّثَنَا لَيْثٌ، عَنْ عُبَيْدِ اللَّهِ، عَنْ نَافِعٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ عُمَرَ، عَنِ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم أَنَّهُ قَالَ ‏ "‏ عَلَى الْمَرْءِ الْمُسْلِمِ السَّمْعُ وَالطَّاعَةُ فِيمَا أَحَبَّ وَكَرِهَ إِلاَّ أَنْ يُؤْمَرَ بِمَعْصِيَةٍ فَإِنْ أُمِرَ بِمَعْصِيَةٍ فَلاَ سَمْعَ وَلاَ طَاعَةَ ‏"‏ ‏.‏" - Sahih Muslim 1839a 2) Terrorist Israel and Quraysh are not the same. Israel is the illegal occupier but the Quraish were not.If you say the victim should have a peach of a deal with the rapist, then you're wrong. Why is Israel not like the Quraish? then Imagine: someone breaks into your's room, and you attempts to remove the illegal intruders to protect your family and yourself. However, enemies of you argue that the illegal intruders have a right to self-defense from you. -Means: Rapist has right to protect him from victims.If you say the victim should have a peach of a deal with the rapist, then you're wrong Because of the peace Treaty, normalization,Israel took this opportunity and Israel has already swallowed almost the whole of Palestine . Today, they have acquired the ability to cut off supplies at will. After that, the peace treaty with them?

[@yasinibrahim]

​@@paradisepeace9994ya akhi, the Prophet said you will have rulers with hearts of shaytan but you still have to hear and obey. And how a are quraysh and kufar different. Didn't he even make peace with the jews? Walahi please learn knowledge

[@Asiyah2000]

​@@yasinibrahimwhat do you mean by that and where is your evidence prophet said that 🤔

[@yasinibrahim]

@@Asiyah2000 Hudhayfah ibn al-Yaman reported: I asked, “O Messenger of Allah, we were living in an evil time and Allah brought us good in which we live now. Will there be evil after this good?” The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Yes.” I said, “And any good after this evil?” The Prophet said, “Yes.” I said, “And any evil after this good?” The Prophet said, “Yes.” I said, “How will it be?” The Prophet said, “Leaders after me will come who do not follow my guidance and my Sunnah. Some of their men will have the hearts of devils in a human body.” I said, “O Messenger of Allah, what should I do if I live to see that time?” The Prophet said, “You should listen and obey the ruler, even if he strikes your back and takes your wealth, even still listen and obey.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1847

[@yasinibrahim]

@@Asiyah2000 we can't critize the rulers because of the greater harm it causes to the muslims. we can only not obey in the haram.

[@UrFudher]

Allhamdulillah I'm glad for this as Shamsi cleared up so many things for me and calling rulers boot lickers etc. Our loyalty is with Quran and Sunnah and till we do not return to that and leave the love for this duniya we will not be successful.

[@fromtheperiphery]

Before Shamsi has us all giving bayah to the family of ibn Saud perhaps he should investigate how they came into power themselves. Hint: they didn't do it by not criticising the rulers.

[@-------....___]

LOL. And who helped them, and why they helped them. Hint: British.

[@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj]

They did it with legitment jihaad and not by rebelling. Some graveworshippers say that Saudi rebelled the Ottoman empire which is a lie. Thats why you shouldn't speak without knowledge

[@boxingplanet7637]

What? You don’t fear Allah? Stop making up lies against the akh.

[@T-19-]

They did it with jihad of the sword and the Quran and Sunnah.

[@HellllooKittttyyyyy]

​@@T-19-😂 Yeah those Bikini beaches i cant wait

[@al-hidayah7811]

"Shamsi Became Suddenly Arrogant i don't know why... He Became Stubborn"

[@kamarulamin3333]

Both need to discuss close doors and calmly without any distraction. This shouldn't be downloaded because this can create divided among the Muslims brothers.

[@Sami-bs1go]

But shamsi like fitna and divide the umma so is all madakhila

[@katyana92]

Thank you 🙏🏾

[@southernrealist5789]

Al-Allāmah Sh Salih Fawzan: “Being silent about the people of innovation and not clarifying their bid’ah is the greatest form of deception towards the Muslims... It is not permissible for the Muslim that has knowledge to be silent about innovation and deviations.”

[@Yahya-gw5qw]

Idk what world you live in brother but Muslims have been divided loony time ago … so it’s upon you to seek the true saved sect our messenger mentioned

[@asifkhanbdj]

Shamsi is not a listener. Just sticking to his arguments.

[@1924-b8x]

I THINK IT IS GOOD TO REMIND TO EACH OTHER LIKE THIS! ITS FINE, TO MAKE EVERYTHING CLEAR

[@ahmetkeskin6161]

we must UNITE and we must not fight out our differences in front of the camera ….Brothers❤

[@80HDpilled]

we unite upon truth not falsehood

[@terrence1616]

ALL the Time ! There Is Islam ☪️ and the Quran in the World! 🌎 There Can Be No Peace ! In The World is TAKBEER 🍺🍺Allahs Snack bar 🍱😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@iDeaticAU]

: Never knew brother Mansur is from Bangladesh. He is a good dawah man, may Allaah accept him.

[@khairulmuzzamirmatkassim4500]

Mansur always my fav. Hes super intellegent. Hes another level than everyone here to be honest

[@MrShawnamir]

Mansour style awesome for Dawa.... Calm and on point

[@healthnutrition7415]

Funny how Shamsis cameraman never speaks usually when he’s debating Kufaar but here with other Muslims he’s really vocal.

[@ManAmongMasses]

You mean when there are many others interrupting and trying to misdirect the flow of conversation? When it comes to the Muslims who are ignorant, and the Muslims who know better but refuse to remain silent, then his verbal presence is needed so that the Qur'aan and Sunnah is kept uppermost. Do you notice how so many Muslims open their mouths about matters of Islaam, but cannot utter a word of رشد of هداية to a disbeliever? Allah عز وجل didn't burden us with the affairs of the leaders. He left that to those in authority. As for us, the laypeople, we have been given a lofty hadeeth to act upon: فو اللَّهِ لأنْ يهْدِيَ اللَّه بِكَ رجُلًا واحِدًا خَيْرٌ لكَ من حُمْرِ النَّعم But instead people abandon what is better for them and instead strive and clamour to open their mouths against those whom it is haram for us laypeople to open our mouths against, and by doing so are entering into the pasture of the Lord that an-Nu‘maan bin Basheer, رضي الله عنه, informed of in his hadeeth where the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم said: "The halaal is clear and the haraam is clear..."

[@henriquesombiga4338]

Yeah that tall mulla is a bootlicker of Shamsi and Shamsi s Proved to be a bootlicker and hypocrite. I am shocked.

[@Abu-Kurdi]

​@@ManAmongMasses you always scream Qur'an and sunnah while it's all your ego. Jump on the line when there's a protest for palestine, but stay silent when there's concerts with naked women in saudi.

[@ManAmongMasses]

@@Abu-Kurdi the Qur'aan and Sunnah, with the understanding of the best of this Ummah, is clear in both affairs. Protesting is wrong and contrary to the religion. And likewise, naked women in public is wrong and contrary to the religion. We condemn and warn against both. If you're attempting to attribute the evil occurring in the world to the rulers of the lands within which those evils occur, then you need to understand the methodology of the Salaf when it comes to the sins/evil/oppression of the rulers. They are treated differently compared to the common man. Don't allow yourself to be deluded by the West's abandonment of respect (as is afforded by the Qur'aan and Sunnah, nothing more nothing less) of the rulers, or those in authority.

[@Abu-Kurdi]

@@ManAmongMasses 1. You're not being honest regarding "warning against both" when everytime a protest for palestine happens, you pop your head out. But when it's concerts in saudi, you only give a general ruling once and for all. Pretty inconsistent. 2. What is the abandonment of respect? Is it your favorite country's rulers inviting naked callers of shirk to dance while insulting Allah all in the land of mecca and Medina(same country)? 3. People, nowadays, out of their ignorance, have replaced the great cause(g had) with protests. You like to mention that protests are haram, but forget(perhaps) to mention what was the method used by muslims, or agreed upon(ijma, further more proving it's the latest solution as opposed to what people nowadays advocate for: being silent and peaceful, screaming in protests), to deal with the enemy in these situations. Why is that?

[@islamglobal01]

Both of them are good. Mashaa Allah. This is normal to disagree. Even the Sahabs and Scholars do disagree on certain issues. May Allah bless them all.

[@truthseeker630]

Kudus to Shamsi for referring to the scholar. Other 'Muslims' would generally 'know themselves', giving their own opinion, rather than being humble and search deeper for the truth

[@samrock8567]

He always refers to scholars who he things are right.....when Daniel told him sheikh Didou Said normalisation with Israel is not right, he said he is ashari or sth .....so anyone who is not Wahhabi he wud considers them not authentic

[@serkanalbayrak2972]

Why do they say barakullahu fihk after a question and before answering?

[@suhaybalmesmary6417]

😂😂 1st minute Shamsi contradicted himself CLEARLY!! Brother Mansour's question Finished him in what he accused brother Daniel with 😂😂

[@southernrealist5789]

What are you talking about. Because mansoor is bengali, he should have known if he can pledge allegiance to a woman. Shamsi hasn't come across that yet. It just showed you that mansoor knows more about the bible than the quran and sunnah. More like mansoor embarrassed himself in 1 minute. Also tried very hard to get Shamsi to say he gives an opinion, only shows you that thats how mansoor gives dawah - using his opinion.

[@bejustice5955]

Nice to see brothers coming together in goodness

[@kimsmaan6006]

Caring about the camera and caring about the truth àré two different things Baraka Allahou fikoum

[@abvoice9931]

قال الله وقال رسول الله وقال السلف .. . طريق لا يستطيع احد ان يسابقك ويكون هو الأول غيرك اخي المسلم . السلفية دليل المسلم الحق❤

[@ZubairMalsagov]

هل السلف قالوا تبايع حكام طواغيت؟

[@abvoice9931]

@@ZubairMalsagov يا ... فيه شروط ....ما اقدر اناقشك فالتعليقات .. لانه يبدو عليك لم ولن تقرأ .. خرجتم على صدام وخنتوه .. العراق دمرت و حرقت مكاتبها العلمية و الدينية . خرجتم على القذافي ..حدث ولا حرج ليبيا في اسوأ حال . خرجتم على سوريا ... اين التغيير ؟ خرجتم على اليمن ... ،اعانهم الله . فيه احاديث وشروط. اقرأ الاحاديث الصحيحة وتفاسيرها .و ستتعلم

[@ZubairMalsagov]

@@abvoice9931 ما علاقة الخروج في مسألة مبايعة حاكم كافر طوغوت لا يحكم بشرع الله، لست انت من قلت قال الله وقال الرسول والآن تجيب سيرة قذافي وصدام ومش عارف اي،انت لو لا تكفر هؤلاء الحكام الطواغيت فلا كلام لي معك

[@PakiFighter]

Shamsi: - been caught deceiving. In one video, he was reading from a book, and stopped DELIBERATELY mid sentence, because the rest of the sentence would have destroyed his stance on an issue. Was exposed by a guy named Bro Hajji, video is online. - Refuses to take any knowledge from known scholars if they go against his shaykh. - Called a senior scholar by Israeli zionists after showing them support because he loves MBS. MADkhalis.

[@Yanidschare]

Shamsi Soldier of the Renegade Leaders of Saudiyah. You are just done. Go and kiss the feet of your leaders.

[@alphatango8080]

Our leaders and public need to go back to quran and sunnah. Golden words. Those who think its easy, it's not. Those who think its not sloution to situation at hand... need to wake up

[@abm6072]

Soubhanallah I am so surprised muslims who read the Quran can agree to what Daniel stands for. May Allah guide us all. We have to follow the guidance of Allah. And that is by way of the Quran, sunnah, scholars who are upon the Quran and sunnah. And if you do these things then you see that Daniel has no islamic evidence to do the things he does. we need to first fix our selves and our familys. And then Allah will be with us. لَهُ مُعَقِّبَاتٌ مِنْ بَيْنِ يَدَيْهِ وَمِنْ خَلْفِهِ يَحْفَظُونَهُ مِنْ أَمْرِ اللَّهِ ۗ إِنَّ اللَّهَ لَا يُغَيِّرُ مَا بِقَوْمٍ حَتَّىٰ يُغَيِّرُوا مَا بِأَنْفُسِهِمْ ۗ وَإِذَا أَرَادَ اللَّهُ بِقَوْمٍ سُوءًا فَلَا مَرَدَّ لَهُ ۚ وَمَا لَهُمْ مِنْ دُونِهِ مِنْ وَالٍ For each (person), there are angels in succession, before and behind him.[] They guard him by the Command of Allah. Verily! Allah will not change the good condition of a people as long as they do not change their state of goodness themselves (by committing sins and by being ungrateful and disobedient to Allah). But when Allah wills a people's punishment, there can be no turning back of it, and they will find besides Him no protector. (Ra'd 13:11) We need to change ourselves back to good and our familys and supplicate to Allah the freedom for our palestinian brothers and sisters and be patient for Allah’s decree. And we should not do acts where we do not have the a precedence from the prophets and the sahaba like critizing other leaders, protesting calling for khurooj. May Allah guide us and aid us. May Allah give glad tidings to the palestinians and the whole muslim community.

[@burhankhan9866]

Brother Mansoor, mashaAllah 😊

[@honest_user]

You didn't answer the questions: is DH a khariji? Can you criticize the ruler? Wallahi Shamsi has changed.

[@hamzanocap]

No. Stay silent and obey. The Hadith is clear, will you submit or will you follow your desires? Whoever intends to advise one with authority, he should not do so publicly. Rather, he should take him by the hand and advise him in private. If he accepts the advice, all is well. If he does not accept it, he has fulfilled his duty. Source: Musnad Aḥmad 14909, Grade: Sahih It was said, “Shall we confront them with swords?” The Prophet said:You should listen and obey them even if the ruler strikes your back and takes your wealth, even still listen and obey. Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1847, Grade: Sahih No, as long as they establish prayer among you. If you find something hateful from them, you should hate their actions but not withdraw your hand from obedience. Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1855, Grade: Sahih

[@vortexlight8387]

@@hamzanocap firstly that hadith is about a khalifa that you have given bay'ah to, not a random king of saudi that we never gave bay'ah to, nor does he give us our rights here in the uk. so thats refuted. secondly, now that we established that this hadith has nothing to do with us not criticising saudi, i find it funny how the madkhalis never quote this hadith when they criticize the muslim rulers of Gaza, oh the madkhalis are following their desires.

[@hamzanocap]

@@vortexlight8387 Your lack of respect to the Messenger of Allah is disgusting. Are you really a Muslim or IDF bot looking to stir up trouble?

[@southernrealist5789]

Dh is a clear khariji and Shamsi said it

[@vortexlight8387]

@@southernrealist5789 shamsi is also a khariji for criticising the Muslim rulers of Gaza.

[@saadayaz1889]

Im sorry but im not able to understand what they are talking about and can someone tell me the opinions of shamsi and mansur brother so o can understand each side ..

[@murmurkh]

shamsi getting arrogance and he needs to get his understandings from the scholars not himself

[@abdulrahmanabdulghani8833]

you are right

[@tariquekhan7594]

Shamsi is a person of quran and sunnah...He doesnt tell from his desires..On his mouth there is always quran &sunnah and going back to the salaf and scholars...may Allah preserve him❤

[@MuslimDailyVids]

Mansour got embarrassed, Shamsi goat like always

[@akaykholwadia6411]

How is ur goat he literally said he’s not scholar

[@zahirkhan-yq3gr]

​@@akaykholwadia6411no one is scholar in the park

[@southernrealist5789]

11:35 listen from here. Very beneficial. See how hard the brother was looking to defend khariji. At least he let Shamsi explain

[@asavlogsalltruthrevealed7483]

Shamsi didnt challenge him,mansur was genuinely asking questions, a layman cud understand it very very easily

[@RockyFluffyWhiskas]

Replace “your opinion” with “your understanding”.

[@Sami-bs1go]

Mansur and sheikh Muhammad MashAllah other level

[@MEMUSLIM_SS]

They have no idea of what shamsi is talking about. And will never understand the way of the salaf cuz they do not have knowledge. They jump up and insults people of knowledge The discussion is cool within the brothers. But people who are commenting sometimes turns off water that will off the fire. May Allah Azza Wajall guide us all.

[@primetime2512]

Is shamsi the spokesperson for every leader in the muslim world? What is this?

[@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj]

Daniel calls all the rulers kuffaar. As muslims we must expose him for being a Khariji and calling leaders disbelievers. Thats why you shouldnt speak without knowledge.

[@primetime2512]

@@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj Take your heas out of shamsis ass! these leaders that we have to today are secular tyrants, they aint the sahaba you jahil

[@Seowneche-lh8ff]

​​@@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yjDoesn't the Quran said whoever doesn't rule by what Allah has revealed is kufar or are you against the Quran now? Cuz you don't believe music concerts, and celebration of Satan, Halloween, is ruling by shari'a

[@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj]

@@Seowneche-lh8ff The Quran says whoever doesnt judge by what Allah has revealed are the disbelievers, in the ayah he says they are the wrongdoers, in the next ayah he calls them sinners. The scholars have differenciated between muslims who become disbelievers and the muslims who still stay muslims but are wrongdoers and sinners. You might ask what do the scholars use as evidance. Firstly the ayah of them being disbelievers is general so we cant use it by itself as an evidance. So we go to the sahaba. Ibn Abbaas said it is not major kufr but minor kufr. It only becomes kufr if you believe the man made laws are better. Here is the evidance: Ibn Abi Hatim narrated from Muhammad ibn Abdullah ibn Yazid Al-Muqri from Sufyan ibn 'Uyaynah from Hisham ibn Hujajr from Tawus from Ibn Abbas who said: "{And whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed, they are the disbelievers}, this is not the form of Kufr that they (the Khawarij) think of." [Tafsir Ibn Abi Hatim hadith 6434] Imam Ahmad was asked about the narration of Tawus where he said: "It is not disbelief that makes a person leave the religion." To which he said: "That was said on the verse of Surah al-Maaidah verse 44: 'And whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed, they are the disbelievers.'" [Masail Ibn Hani 2042]

[@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj]

@@Seowneche-lh8ff Many major scholars said that the Khawarij use that verse as evidance to make takfir on the rulers Al-Jassaas said in Ahkam ul Qur'an (2/543), "The Khawarij have interpreted these verses (5:44) to justify the Takfir of the one who does not rule by what Allaah has revealed without wilful rejection, Juhood." And Abul-Mudhaffar as-Sam'ani said in his tafsir (2/42), "And know that the Khawarij use this verse (5:44) as evidence and they say, 'whoever does not rule by what Allaah has revealed is a disbeliever' whereas Ahl-us-Sunnah say such a one does not disbelieve by abandoning judgement by what Allaah has revealed." Sheikh ul Islam ibn Taymiyya (rahimahullah) said about this: “This ayah (5:44) is what khawarij use as evidence for doing takfir on the rulers who do not rule by what Allah has revealed, then they claim that they believe it is the Judgment of Allah.” -Manhaj us-Sunnah 5/131 Sheikh ul Islam ibn Taymiyya (rahimahullah) said: Therefore from the statements of the Salaf were: "A person can have within him both īmān and kufr" and likewise within their saying: "that one can have within him both īmān and kufr, it is not the kufr which expels one from the Religion." Just as Ibn 'Abbās and his companions (students) stated in regards to the saying of Allāh, "And whoever does not judge by what Allāh Has Revealed - then it is those who are disbelievers." [al-Mā'idah (5):44] They said it means: "They disbelieved with a type of kufr which does not expel one from the Religion", and Ahmad and other Imāms of the Sunnah followed him in that. -Majmu’ al Fatawa 7/312

[@yuuchannel1675]

Can someone list the hadith they are debating about? Im not getting the essence of the talk at all

[@JamesBond-wv9xz]

So basically, you are not allowed to think for yourself unless you are a scholar.

[@wardboxer6895]

You are allowed. The religion has some issues that must be dealt with by the scholars. When Allah described himself in Surah alikhlas, you don’t need a scholar to tell you what it means. But when it comes to politics, it has it’s people

[@syad911]

you can think, but u can't decide. that's the whole point.

[@Lucky-to7ly]

@@wardboxer6895scholars lol which scholars?? The ones that we never see or hear from. Lip service only. Seen it all. You man are new to this thas why u got passion.

[@Abu-Kurdi]

These scholars are only there to serve the rulers. The result of their teachings is naked women concerts and Halloween in saudi.

[@Alpin175]

Why as a muslim... We argue each other...

[@SOCCER2FOOTBALLCAD]

When Mansur asks Shamsi about a his opinion in a secular women leader (who burned Muslims in Bangladesh), he DOESN'T know!, but when they talked about shaikh Iben-Baz criticizing Saddam, he immediately said "no he is not a Muslim, he is a secular"!!! And he keeps repeating, stay with the truth, Unbelievable! 🤣

[@thenightsoul232]

always go back to Quran and Sunnah and to the scholars ( Aulama'a ), thank you so much brother SHAMSI for reminding our brothers in Islam that they never give their own opinion specially on big issues and problem and always referee back to QURAN, SUNNAH and Scholars ( Aulama'a ). may Allah guide us and protect us. Amen

[@CarFreakk95]

Daniel proven to be upon his own desires rather than Quran and Sunnah, and lying comes easy to him.

[@Khadidja...]

It's clear that you didn't watch the whole debate

[@Sau-lk2gi]

who is the guy they are talking about?

[@eddyyusuf7034]

Shamsi wants everyone to be a murji like him and accept the taghuts as muslims

[@yasinibrahim]

Alright man 😂😂

[@yasinibrahim]

Sound like a khariji

[@kutsc3792]

Yep they're the first line of defence for these rulers

[@ManAmongMasses]

So you have just declared the Muslim rulers kuffaar. Either provide evidence for your declaration, keeping in mind the hadeeth of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم that I'm sure you're aware of regarding كفرا بواحا, or take it back lest the true word of the Prophet applies to you regarding a declaration of kufr falling back upon you.

[@kutsc3792]

@@ManAmongMasses who's making takfir on them? According to the madhkhalis you can't even critices them hence first line of defence for them.

[@sirajkhatir8455]

we love you shamsi brother ♥️

[@SaidMetiche-qy9hb]

Shamsi again losing the debate, love to brother Mansur

[@utayification]

What ?

[@Reemqu4]

Lol Mansur asked him a question, there wasn't even a debate

[@SunniAthari]

Brother Mansur asked a question and wanted a answer from Shamsi even if it be his own opinion from what he understands. Shamsi gave the correct response in that he does not know and directed Mansur to return the question back to the scholars and his response is from the Qur'an and Sunnah. Brother Mansur is not happy with the answer as he wants Shamsi to give a response, that the answer is "obvious". If the answer is so obvious then bring the statements of the scholars on this specific matter.

[@syad911]

Mansur asked a question which isn't for Shamsi, that question is for leaders and ulamas, Shamsi said that and keep repeating it, if anything Mansur is getting worse now since he's no longer listening, he's there for a full hour and yet asking the very same question, which isn't for Shamsi to answer, Shamsi being consistent refused to answer because he has no position to answer that, it's for the leaders and ulamas. if u missed this obvious, u probably have hate toward Shamsi, you're so based you think Shamsi is wrong 100% of the time, even when he mentioning Quran and Sunnah. calamity.

[@SaidMetiche-qy9hb]

Shamsi said he doesn't know if it's halal or "its fine" to give aliegence to woman who is a pawn of the indian hindu mushriks and secular, but acc to shamsi we should 100% not give alliegence to hamas and the resistance militias in palestine because they are mushrik/shia even though he has no proof of that, clear nifaq to me from what I see, and im Algerian we don't like traitors

[@debaterobi4996]

1)The obedience of the Muslim leader only applies to matters that are permissible in Islam. If they demand actions that are sinful, one is excused from their obedience It has been narrated on the authority of Ibn 'Umar that the Prophet (ﷺ) said: "It is obligatory upon a Muslim that he should listen (to the ruler appointed over him) and obey him whether he likes it or not, except that he is ordered to do a sinful thing. If he is ordered to do a sinful act, a Muslim should neither listen to him nor should he obey his orders. حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ، حَدَّثَنَا لَيْثٌ، عَنْ عُبَيْدِ اللَّهِ، عَنْ نَافِعٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ عُمَرَ، عَنِ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم أَنَّهُ قَالَ ‏ "‏ عَلَى الْمَرْءِ الْمُسْلِمِ السَّمْعُ وَالطَّاعَةُ فِيمَا أَحَبَّ وَكَرِهَ إِلاَّ أَنْ يُؤْمَرَ بِمَعْصِيَةٍ فَإِنْ أُمِرَ بِمَعْصِيَةٍ فَلاَ سَمْعَ وَلاَ طَاعَةَ ‏"‏ ‏.‏" - Sahih Muslim 1839a 2) Terrorist Israel and Quraysh are not the same. Israel is the illegal occupier but the Quraish were not.If you say the victim should have a peach of a deal with the rapist, then you're wrong. Why is Israel not like the Quraish? then Imagine: someone breaks into your's room, and you attempts to remove the illegal intruders to protect your family and yourself. However, enemies of you argue that the illegal intruders have a right to self-defense from you. -Means: Rapist has right to protect him from victims.If you say the victim should have a peach of a deal with the rapist, then you're wrong Because of the peace Treaty, normalization,Israel took this opportunity and Israel has already swallowed almost the whole of Palestine . Today, they have acquired the ability to cut off supplies at will. After that, the peace treaty with them?

[@fromtheperiphery]

If it is a big issue as Shamsi says perhaps Shamsi shouldn't speak about it either.

[@rubixcube7234]

tes bro is double standard wallahi

[@IbrahimMahad-z7v]

@@rubixcube7234be just when Shamsi talks about these types of issues he quotes ulama instead of emotion

[@rubixcube7234]

@@IbrahimMahad-z7v I've seen him quoting ulama even if they're holding the weakest opinion on some issues plus shamsi likes to disagree with everybody. He thinks he knows more sheikh muhammad it's idiotic wallahi

[@southernrealist5789]

1:40 Mansoor wanting to interpret... Subhanallah After all these years, The brothers in speakers corner all finally found some courage and decided to challenge Shamsi in the presence of Haqiqatjou.... Lions interrupting him, with machine gun fire Subhanallah The quran and sunnah closed them ALL down. Now you all clearly see who is will the truth and who wants to follow their desires and interpret themselves. May Allah preserve brother Shamsi

[@ishtiaquerahmantipu8713]

All discussion supposed to be happened without filming . 😪. When any matter appears with regards to sunnah and aqidah, we have to discuss privately and this way, we can correct each other.. Not public discourse is recommended

[@tlawengmophosho4848]

But these Saudis were critiquing gaddafi when theor fathers were Britosh spies

[@aaee2683]

Most of the scholars are in prison.

[@Callingoutdeceivers]

Not a true statement. Pls justify with evidences.

[@muhammad608]

they are not scholars, they were students of knowledge who became khawarij, no wonder they were arrested for their deviant ideologies.

[@DestinyAwaits19]

@@muhammad608 They are not khawarji. They are muslims ready to die for Allah and his prophet. And unfortunately too many 'moderate' muslims don't have the guts to be the same. Are you willing to die for Islam? I say this as a disbeliever.

[@mrboss9105]

@@DestinyAwaits19. If they were willing to “ die “, Why didn’t they go fight instead of just doing emotional talk in their homes 😂

[@aaee2683]

@muhammad608 dangerous statement like this are tactics to make you a blind followers. Be a man or a woman stand for the truth 💯

[@roka7024]

We need the Ummah to unite, this is the reason why our enemies have so much power over us.

[@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj]

We dont unite upon falsehood, we only unite upon quran and sunnah. This is the way of the Salaf

[@ashsuri1289]

yet you live in the Kafir lands my brother speak less move more. @@AbuInayaAl-Athari-po3yj

[@ashsuri1289]

the brothers all confused they hold citizenship of a land where their told to watch the tongue they speak with. You see brother until we all leave nothing changes we only confuse one another. I refused the citizenship of Canada where I reside but Im to poor to move and I have goal this month that I will make my money to get myself out of here with nothing life will be greater when Im free. Where nobody can toy with my words what I try to mean. SHamzi is being cornered and this is not good for Islamic men to behave like Women.

[@farid-selefi]

exactly brother and correct understanding goes back to selefo saalih first 3 generations muslims and clear explanation of nowadays islamic major scholars like sh.fawzaan and sh.saalih sohaimi

[@farid-selefi]

dadew hizbi from mauritania is not a scholar of islaam

[@ahmedye00]

This should be a private discussion not a public

[@ashthanvi4137]

He is always fighting with other Muslims 😅

[@abdul-hadidadkhah1459]

Shamsi is just fighting other Muslims at such a time. This is why he gets names like "agent". If I dont live in a particular nation state then I dont have to give bay'ah to that leader, only to a khaleef of the entire Muslims, which doesnt exist. Therefore the hadeeth about the "Muslim ruler" doesn't apply to me as long as I'm not a citizen nor am I living in that nation state.

[@fanatik2408]

Manshur the one that attacking here! Shamsi jus defending

[@abdallamuawad6903]

Is that your opinion or scholar opinion

[@fethekerare8627]

شمسي أنت مع الحكام الطواغيط الذي قال فيهم رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم أن من اعانهم فلم يرث علي الحوض .. يعني لا يدخل الجنة من يعين الحكام الظلمة .. شمسي أنت لست مع الحق مع أنك تملك بعض الايجابيات

[@MoeedKhan1979]

Why shamsi discussing these issues at the time when whole ummais in trouble due to Palestinian tragedy

[@abutiyyyamah]

because he should warn against the ahl-h bad-h

[@UMAIRRAJA90]

Because he serves his masters in riyad.

[@abutiyyyamah]

@@UMAIRRAJA90 you should be honest brother when you are saying that brother shmasi takes money or he's an agent to the suadi government this is big lying man from where we get that

[@britishpakstar988]

Brothers you need to be strong together we have a bigger worry! Our brothers and sisters dying in Palestine please think about them before u argue with eachother

[@johnwilliams9402]

No brother. The goal is to uphold the Truth, to preserve the Quran and Sunnah in order that Allahs name is held the highest.

[@indram5384]

Mansur is a Bangladeshi Indian Muslim. I agree with him.

[@yahyahali8313]

When Brother Mansur asks shamsi a question he replies with ‘I don’t know ask the scholars’ but he can easily make takfir on Muslims which he doesn’t have the authority to do 🤦‍♂️. I don’t know why anyone even bothers with him

[@southernrealist5789]

When did Shamsi make takfir? Shamsi did not know, it shows wisdom to say I don't know. Shamsi has never had a women ruler. Mansoor has had one for a while. The question is, why doesn't he know.... Mansoor also tried to force Shamsi to say he uses his opinion. Shamsi said no. This should tell you a lot about mansoor May Allah guide me, you and them

[@Reemqu4]

Hi didn't make takfeer, don't lie against him, we watched the video too.

[@yahyahali8313]

I’m not referring to this video when I say he made takfir.. it’s common knowledge everyone knows he did, he himself said it too. Don’t just blindly follow someone just because they’re from the same ethnicity as you.

[@Reemqu4]

@@yahyahali8313 If someone says he's calling upon a human with Allah or worshipping a grave or cursing the sahaba or believing Quran is corrupted, should we be tolerant with them?

[@syad911]

did u even watch the video ? scholars called out Daniel, that's why Shamsi is doing it. you hate Shamsi so much u pretend not to listen the context, like WOW.

[@AIiculture]

The way of shemsi is truelly what we call akida because when everyone tell his opinion we gonna have many opinion but when we what oulama says in that way din dont change that what shemsi mean and i support this way

[@bjornexyaziz2055]

Brother Shamsi is on Rampage cuz he got owned by brother Daniel.

[@aftabkhan3334]

What Quran verse or sunnah did Daniel use for his proofs? Oh yeah none. So much for "owned" smh🤦

[@bjornexyaziz2055]

@@aftabkhan3334 have you heard the Battle of trench? He didn't say but you can research it for you own benefit. That's between the Holy Prophet and the Jews. And what the Jews did. You guys think about treaty of hudaybiyyah, you think a Zionists regime is same as those of the pagan Arabs?

[@peace2203]

They push to follow the desire and leave quran sunnah..

[@MAbs-ny7xi]

Brother Shamsi losing focus day by day. Maybe needs some time away from the park or arrogance has entered his heart?

[@southernrealist5789]

What? Shamsi is not giving his opinion even when mansoor tried very hard.

[@babammuadams9194]

Not true is rather shamsi

[@abdulrahmanabdulghani8833]

very true...remember Satan is watching

[@southernrealist5789]

@@Voyage.001 tell mansoor and the rest of the brothers. May Allah preserve brother Shamsi for being very careful with his speech and always referencing the quran and sunnah and the scholars

[@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte]

"Let's give bay'ah (oath of allegiance) to Tabboune, democratic president of Algeria who partly uses french law to rule" - Shamsi

[@ManAmongMasses]

Let's give bay‘ah to the Muslim rulers of our lands, righteous or oppressive, while bearing patiently the harm we face through this, in accordance with the blessed, pure direction our Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم pointed us towards with the Aid of our Lord.

[@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte]

@@ManAmongMasses is a ruler a muslim when he prefers kaafir laws over shari'ah ?

[@ManAmongMasses]

@@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte Does a Muslim become a kaafir because they like alcohol? Even though they still acknowledge alcohol is haraam to consume?

[@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte]

@@ManAmongMasses no, but if they force usury on the population and make halal was Allah has made haram, then they are kafiroon.

[@aminesbai926]

@@ManAmongMasses That's a terrible comparison. If you want to bring alcohol, a better example is if the ruler legalized alcohol. That's the point. If you're gonna use "democratic" laws before shari'ah, you're actively and publically going against what God commands.

[@GilesHartop]

Wow amazing the technicality of brother shamshi mashallah

[@jackjack-sh7uy]

Its really unjust and saddening that some of the speakers corner Muslim brothers kept interrupting and not letting our speakers corner Muslim brother Shamsi speak against the lies of that cringe lair Daniel Haqiqatjou Needs Dawah crypto extremist

[@wardboxer6895]

Imagine bro Shamsi speaking to 5 people at the same time and they keep interrupting even though that’s how Shamsi speaks. Me personally I would have gotten frustrated but Shamsi kept his calm

[@elafzal5866]

Who are they discussing about? Daniel?

[@alkashifalkashi6410]

Mansur why are you talking to this Madkhali agent?!!!!!!

[@haarith9090]

May Allah bless shamsi