Shaykh Uthman Addresses The Issue Of Music

[@randomdawah]

Assalamu Alaikum! Please share and spread the Dawah. If you wish to donate: t.ly/Xpqey (PayPal). This channel isn't monetized.

[@Islam-pq8pw]

This is great information but my question is regarding Anasheed nowadays where they sing about Allah, the messengers, Sahaba and Islam in general not about evil and bad things. Nowadays they use voice backgrounds and sometimes a small bass beat. What does the hadith and quran say about this?

[@ay_yowth]

probably no music listener is gonna tell you that but believe me, as an ex-addicted listener I can confirm that it's the reason number 1 of sadness and depression. I replaced it with memorizing Quran and making sure to understand every verse that I'm reading, and believe me when I say this was a life changing, even my family and friends noticed the differences within a month or so. start from now and quit for the sake of Allah.

[@LARESCIV]

it can sure serve as a anesthetic for the sad heart, especially if you listen more upbeat and entertaining type music, that is correct

[@EB-gt1pq]

💯 I used to feel so depressed when listening to sad songs… And I felt very aggressive listening to rap songs. It’s a terrifying form of mind control.

[@ItoSorich]

You seem to be missing the point. Pls define music.

[@JackFrostIsHere]

​@@ItoSorich 👈 misguiding troll spotted. Ignore this shayateen (and others like him beautifying sin) and you will be prosperous

[@tazmania1066]

😢The day I have up listening to music was the day I started my path to going to Haj and righteousness...

[@TheRockeyAllen]

Quitting music took me fighting my desires for nearly two years. I'd quit, start again, quit again... but once I successfully quit properly, I haven't turned back, Alhamdulillah. And, it has been one of the best battles I've fought. I now spend 3 hours every day listening to lectures: 2 hours a day commuting and an hour day at the gym. Quit music and open up space for massive growth!

[@EB-gt1pq]

Absolutely!! Your last statement says it perfectly!

[@omarmasedrati8751]

MashAllah bro

[@lonesameer13]

Same here I watched more and more Islamic videos and Quran recitation now I have got rid of music or those ""Islamic Sufi songs"""

[@Harry_sung]

My thoughts on this - kzbin.info/www/bejne/eXOrlJKroJufY8ksi=7NuFOEcYk2r0Xj8q

[@EB-gt1pq]

I used to listen to music for hours every single day. You name it -I listened to it… From Rap, hip-hop, R&B, rock, alternative, salsa, Middle Eastern music, classical, etc. I’m happy to say… It’s been two years now that I have not listened to a single song! The biggest challenge was working out and not listening to music, but alhamdulilah i replaced it with Islamic content. Music is mind control!

[@m.hassan8145]

Same I used to listen 🎧 then I replaced it with zikar

[@faseehyooseff1732]

When I read your comment, I was thinking when did I write this. SubhanAllah, this is literally what I also experienced . Maya Allah keep us steadfast . AMEEN.

[@heerarodriguez9563]

Black Rap music is the most disgusting of all music

[@zcs7676]

I used to consider music my religion before I took my shahadah. Alhamdulillah I only listen to Quran now

[@EB-gt1pq]

Yes, sometimes I get the urge to listen to it again. But I know if I start again, I’ll do it more and more. It won’t be just that one time.

[@slsa915]

To the brother who made the video thumbnail: My advice is to remove the face of the other person because the Sheikh chose specifically not to name any Imam or Sheikh in this matter. So you should respect that and not use the other persons image. Im not a fan of the other person and don’t consider him a scholar or an authority but you should respect the Sheikh and his words.

[@ryanmwanza5439]

Agreed!

[@Abdulwahab_ad]

Yes please

[@ahmedsaffah5222]

Yes. This is what bothered me too. Well said.

[@SeekingAjar]

Yes, @randomdawah please do this.

[@talhamalik2092]

Well said

[@noursh6290]

I was addicted to music for 20 years everyday I listen for at least 6 hours even when I'm studying.. now I'm free of it for about a year without even forcing myself to stop listening.. I've heard that the only way to leave this habit is to replace it with the Quran.. I didn't take it seriously until I've started memorizing the Qur'an..it's effortlessly replaced music in just about one month.. That was like a miracle for me and my life since then has been so much better in every aspect

[@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543]

Same thing with me, when I put Quran on my phone and memorized I was happy, sleeping better, remembering better etc. musiq is bad for study etc.

[@bayezidtalukdar]

May Allah bless you

[@nazeemsultan1038]

I wish i was like you, my dear brother

[@sazzadahmed2297]

@@nazeemsultan1038 Don't think you can't be. Allah has given us capability in the first place. We did not fashion our intellect or our bodies. The closest thing we have about ourselves is the choices and the consequences of actions. Wallahi if you're sincere Allah can make it very easy for you so don't think "This will be hard and I will miss it." Delaying is how we stop ourselves from achieving triumph over our nafs, as Allah will always aid and reward the effort. If you think about it, what would the purpose of revelation be if we couldn't be changed? Chapter 53 (Najm, verse 32) Sahih International: Those who avoid the major sins and immoralities, only [committing] slight ones. Indeed, your Lord is vast in forgiveness. He was most knowing of you when He produced you from the earth and when you were fetuses in the wombs of your mothers. So do not claim yourselves to be pure; He is most knowing of who fears Him. Prophet Muhammad (SAW) gives us the advice to replace an evil deed with a good one. This is not only helpful for the account, but you need to fill the void of stopping a sin with something. You should fill it with a good deed. Assalamu-alaikum

[@sazzadahmed2297]

@tubba-dg7to "Music has been around far longer than Islam" Your evidence for your statement? Or do you think Islam starts with Prophet Muhammad (SAW)? That already shows ignorance. Furthermore look at what rap music did to U.K. From one of the safer places to live, into the reputation for knife crimes. As for disbelievers they led a lifetime of disobedience to the Most Merciful. They had been given multiple signs and chances and non will enter hellfire except that they had openly rejected what they knew in their hearts to be true. If Allah had punished them for their disbelief right away they would not exist. Yet Allah provides for them. Out of what? There is nothing that can hold Allah accountable as Allah is the Exalted in Might. You only have 2 scenarios. What is said about Allah is true or God doesn't exist. There is evidence behind this or Muslims wouldn't obey and lead a lifestyle of discipline and morality. The "followers" of other religions are for the most part liberals who want to maintain the identity with their faith but can't believe in it fully after science has debunked false claims and myths. The foundation of atheism is proving false claims in religions to prove religions are false. But it will never do that with Islam as Allah promises the preservation (which we have carbon-dated evidence to back up).

[@Omaima782]

Music it’s definitely an addiction, been fighting with it since reversing. I realized that the more I listened the more I didn’t get the same dopamine in my life and don’t feel fulfilled because things aren’t how I want to. When you detach yourself from reality and let the emotions, the words of the song guide your imagination and thoughts you are unconscious and conditioned. It’s literally like drinking and doing drugs your brain is not connected with your present state. I stopped 2 times and got back at it, when I get depressed I seek even more music and reassurance from people. Music will play a bad influence in your way to find balance how Allah swt wants us to be, it’s literally going against all Allah swt want for us. May Allah forgive us and guides us to detach from sins and find a way to keep our hearts safe

[@Harry_sung]

My thoughts on this - kzbin.info/www/bejne/eXOrlJKroJufY8ksi=7NuFOEcYk2r0Xj8q

[@AbdelAzizAlih]

The Ummah needs this kind of clarification. This is a gem of a gift for the Ummah. To Shaykh Uthman and the uploader, jazakhallah khairan katheeran.

[@whatifoundout]

Yep. Literally nobody talking about clarifying Entertainment and Entertainers. Many people watch and listen to so much entertainment and many Muslims want to be Entertainers (Musicians, Actors, Authors, Filmmakers etc). There needs to be great detailed clarification on these subjects.

[@mrnomad1737]

Is Sidi Uthman a Jurist? No, Does he have qualificaiton of a jurist? No. He is simply stating general view of muslim scholar. Nothing extra ordinary about it? Muslim with reductive evagelical dogmatic view of the text do not understand neuance and context. Islam is living tradition and speculative branch uses context and takes into account of tradition whilist respecting the secondary textual source. I doubt the likes of Sidi uthman does this or even have the know how.

[@abakadabrahoho8815]

​@@mrnomad1737 how would you do that or approach understanding it.

[@fahadluqman1529]

Salam Brothers, I would highly appreciate it if some one were to help me out with this, I’m addicted to music too. But I’m trying to change my life for good and live my life according to Islamic teachings. At the moment I’m a bit confused about something and I’d highly appreciate it if someone could explain it to me and guide me to the right path, I’m doing research on whether music is Halal or Haram, everywhere I go people talk about songs with lyrics, I myself agree that we should refrain from those kinds of music cuz they’re the most misleading. But I wanna know if music itself is Haram(without any lyrics), at the moment i have a playlist of some popular music but converted into Arabic versions of themselves, those attract me a lot and I wanna know if they too are haram. If you’re still confused about the music I’m talking about here’s a link to one of them kzbin.info/www/bejne/nZPQfXmYp9tkoNUsi=tddbC2pxJ-VGYXUY I wanna know if this type of music is Haram too cuz in the background there are some musical instruments being used that some scholars have declared halal with evidence from Hadith. So that is my question I would highly appreciate it if someone helps me out.

[@DanishSyawal]

MashaAllah. Everywhere our Sheikh Uthman gives explanation about the khilafs that has been done by our other da'ee, he always corrects them with respect. May Allah bless you Sheikh. I've never understand so much about Islam until I met your channel, One Message Foundation. May Allah rewards you for giving dawah offline and online to all humans who are searching for His guidance.

[@Harry_sung]

My thoughts on this - kzbin.info/www/bejne/eXOrlJKroJufY8ksi=7NuFOEcYk2r0Xj8q

[@محارب-ه4ذ]

Freeing myself for music was life changing , it's so addictive and impacts the mind negatively ... I always questioned why music was prohibited, but the answer arrived quickly , _it corrupts the heart_... May Allah Guide Us.

[@malikosman1003]

Music is the best gift of Allah....

[@محارب-ه4ذ]

@@malikosman1003 then why he prohibits it ?

[@malikosman1003]

@@محارب-ه4ذ who prohibited music....do u know the difference between haram and halal...

[@محارب-ه4ذ]

@@malikosman1003 allah prohibited music surat luqman verse 6

[@malikosman1003]

@@محارب-ه4ذ what is written in this ayat...

[@MistaT44]

One of the best lectures and explanations on this topic. JazakAllah

[@SayidMuhammadIbrahim]

The biggest problem of modern world is that sins are not sins anymore. everybody is trying hard to justify his or her evil deeds instead of taking accountability and face consequences and ask for forgiveness from Allah

[@lawrencebrazier4888]

Thank you sheikh for breaking things down with knowledge and history. May Allah make your burdens easy

[@BirdmanFL]

May Allah unite our hearts for the right understanding of the deen. We’ll done talk this was needed. Jazakum Allah khayrun

[@Likya17]

May Allah protect us from arrogance and stubbornness

[@AhmadEdinHodzic]

If you listen to music keep it to yourself. Do not spread it to others it’s your struggle and your sin.

[@JackFrostIsHere]

Exactly. But the shayateen (devils) will still force the misguided Muslims to misguide other Muslims with weak Iman regardless

[@AhmadEdinHodzic]

@@JackFrostIsHere everyone is being tested no matter how righteous we think we are.

[@katonguyen3029]

@@AhmadEdinHodzicyou are right brother.

[@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543]

@@JackFrostIsHere this si why Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him said bida is the worst of sins.

[@AhmadEdinHodzic]

@borabora9304 Wa Feeka BarakAllah, I understand your concerns and people that are mindful of Allah AWJ will understand my comment.

[@JustThinker7]

22:04 This is true. Whenever I read the Quran, when I read the translation to understand what the contexts are, there are some meanings where I don't quite understand, so I would look up on either google or yt (I don't yet have tafsir books) to find what the interpretations said about such ayats. But in general, I could understand what most of the revelation by Allah sent in the Quran, it's just maybe I could interpret it wrong, so when I am in waswas (doubts) I would research it myself via internet or asking my teachers Hopefully this is the right approach in sha allah. And we shall thank and give regards to our prophet Muhammad PBUH for giving dawah to all of us. May Allah guide us all, Ameen

[@JustThinker7]

Also just to add something, from what I heard and learned at this dawah from shaykh uthman : We should not put our hearts before our brain. By finding something that we don't have a general or in-depth understanding, our first instance should be to seek truth for the sake of Allah, and not following what we want rather than what we should follow and abide by. And Allah loves those who think, as said in the Quran.

[@hyderabadiurdu]

Check out tafsir as Sa'di. Simple language, very good for beginners. kalamullahDOTcom/Books/Tafseer-As-Sadi-Volume-8-Juz-22-24.pdf

[@kashifalhaq5974]

May Allah preserve our beloved Shaikh and keep him firm. His explanation for the use of duff as Khaas was excellent

[@thedifferentiator7004]

Sheikh uthman is one of my favourite person. Love him for the sake of Allah

[@masterlee6828]

I agree that music is haram no matter what, even though I liked singing and listened to the music but gradually reduced it, pls pray for me to get rid of singing and music completely.

[@Mister.a1]

❤those who are honest and don't give excuse to there sin ,May Allah guide us

[@Brett_Bond]

I completely stopped 8-9 months ago. I don't have any depression now, my prayers have become more regular. I still do have some other sins please make dua for me. Music can manipulate our mind. The beats makes you feel high and then later we feel low, it causes sadness, depression. It also causes dependency on music and many people need it at many different times, some even listen to it while in washroom or bathroom. The lyrics stick to our mind and those lyrics are lewd, or someone crying about love or abusing their ex or some other liberal or stupid stuff and we may find ourselves repeating that. Astagfirullah. Just delete the apps, delete music, stop watching stuff with music, skip it, forward it or whatever you can do and inshallah you won't need it. Also, listen to the Qur'an and read it. and try to minimise or delete social media use.

[@Bilal-ys6df]

Ameen. The more you get away the more your heart gets tighter when you listen to it إن شاء الله.

[@masterlee6828]

@@Mister.a1 Aameen

[@masterlee6828]

@@Brett_Bond Aameen

[@JackFrostIsHere]

*Sheikh Al Aseem and Sheikh Uthman are the two brothers whom I respect a lot for their Islamic knowledge based on Qur'an & Sunnah sources only with references & evidences. Both of them agree that music and free mixing are 100% haram. May Allah (Subhanahu Wa Ta'Ala) keep us aloof from such sins*

[@PoesieIslamique]

al aseem been refuted times and times

[@refayatul]

​@@PoesieIslamiqueby whom? Are they scholars ? Or some random KZbinr?

[@2fast4u818]

Aseem thinks mcdonalds is halal. Be careful with his fatwas

[@fauzistudentofknowledge]

I successfully stop listening to music, Alhamdulillah! And now I'm struggling to stop free-mixing. I'm in online community, we're learning English as non-English speakers. And we're all together in that community wether men and women mingling as normally. And I saw a lot of Fitn happened, such dating relationship because the intense mingling brought people into that way. May Allah guide me and us in His path.

[@SeekingAjar]

Ameen. It’s difficult and as a native English speaker, I would advise looking for a different English class for men only, or studying online.

[@chaosinfernoid9008]

Oh yeah you are right how should you avoid it? I mean your Intention here is not looking at woman but taking online sessions. Still it's very sad.

[@emadmoghrabi5306]

Alhumdulillah, Allah sbwt guided me away form music. Thumma Alhumdulillah. May Allah sbwt make it easy for our brothers and sisters to leave it for the sake of Allah sbwt. Ameen

[@GSTargetSwe]

To me the evidence is clear. You can even feel the effects😢 from music and how it effects your iman.

[@niloferkhan5275]

The quran is clear about haraam and halaal and the same goes with music..I used to love listening to music even though I knew it caused me to shake to some beat especially when exercising but as my imaan increased I was able to cut it out totally with not even a shake of my head.Alhamdulillah Allah do indeed test us and is most merciful

[@muhammadsharif7990]

Music is and ADDICTION! Some folks dilute/water-down to please their listeners/followers and make them stray to wrong path! Don't justify a sin ever!!!

[@beggersu]

Beautiful clarification Shaykh barak Allaahu feekum. الله يحفظك

[@raedhjh]

السلام عليكم شيخ عثمان، the ayah from surah Luqman reads in full as " وَمِنَ النَّاسِ مَن يَشْتَرِي لَهْوَ الْحَدِيثِ لِيُضِلَّ عَن سَبِيلِ اللَّهِ بِغَيْرِ عِلْمٍ وَيَتَّخِذَهَا هُزُوًا ۚ أُولَٰئِكَ لَهُمْ عَذَابٌ مُّهِينٌ" the ayah is very clear that those people that are into what could include singing (not music) have the intention to guide people astray from the path of Allah sobhanhu wa ta3ala and make a mockery of his path. If those people that are into singing are not with the stated intention in the Ayah then the ayah does not apply to them. In other words , the ayah has nothing to do with instrument's playing I.e. music Also , you can't limit the meaning of an Ayah to what Abdullah in Masoud thinks, he is only a human and has been given no messages from the Almighty that we did not get. The Quran addresses the reader and we should use the brains that Allah gave us to understand it not follow the understanding of our fathers. رحمنا الله واياك و السلام عليكم

[@raedhjh]

Notice how the argument you put is about this person opinion and that person opinion. We have the Quran to refer to which is written in arabic. It is not difficult to understand. people opinions are good for them and their understanding. It does not apply to us reading the Quran and making our own understanding. Add to that, that those people are ot the Prophet, they are people just like you and me. They don't determine the religion, only the Almighty Allah subhanhu wa ta3ala does. When Allah subahnahu wa ta3ala mentioned the Ayaha he could have told us that " لَهْوَ الْحَدِيثِ" means music or singing, but he did not. Tafsir Alsaady is a good one because he did not bound it to music or singing. It is a generic condition that requires that the person also applies "لِيُضِلَّ عَن سَبِيلِ اللَّهِ بِغَيْرِ عِلْمٍ وَيَتَّخِذَهَا هُزُوًا" and if music or singing does not have those intentions then they do not fall under the Ayah. Singing and playing instruments with no intention of diverting from the path of Allah and mocking Allah'a Ayat has nothing wrong to it based on this Ayah's pure arabic meaning. Regarding "Samedoun", the Ayah is clear about those who ignore the quran with their form of entertainment. It is very consistent with the Ayah from surat Luqman. Its is not the musical instruments or the singing that is forbidden or discouraged, it is what these methods of entertainment are intended for, when they are intended to ignore Allah's ayat and his straight path, then they are leading to severe punishment in judgement day. If the intentions are good, words of the song are good, they encourage obediance to Allah, they are not used to mock Allah's ayat then there is nothing wrong with them.

[@KaanfitnessUk]

@@raedhjh very well explained, it seems the people in the comments can't distinguish that there are various types of music and genre. Some can bring you closer to Allah.

[@legend6943]

You can't limit the meaning of an ayah to what Abdullah ibn masood thinks? Do you know who Abdullah ibn masood is? He is the one who understood the quran better than any sahaba, any muslim after our prophet pbuh. Our prophet would choose Abdullah ibn masood out of all the sahabas to recite the quran to him. Do you think you understand the quran better than the sahabas let alone abdullah ibn masood. Please try to be wise with your words from now on.

[@raedhjh]

@@legend6943 Salam brother, I saw your reply and I am amazed. You believe that someone said , that a person said, that another said that ibn masoud, a character you never saw or knew is more knowledgeable in the 7th century of the quran than you are today in the 21st century. You can literally find more information about any Ayah in the quran using a Google search than what any sahabah ever knew, and that is how it should be because understanding the quran should be science and we should always improve on our undertaking of the quran. Did the sahabah understand the numerical arrangements in the quran , they certainly did not, did they understand the reference to multiple darks in the ocean, they certainly did not, did they understand the stages of human development in the womb , they certainly did not , did they see the reference to black holes in surah Takweer , certainly not. I hope that answers your comments . Salam

[@legend6943]

@@raedhjh Waalikum Asalam. Brother you are trying to justify something that is clearly haram. Google search finds most of it's answers on the interpretation of Quran and Hadith from the 4 Madhabs. What do the 4 Madhabs say on the ruling of music? All of them agree that it is haram. The 4 Madhabs are present in the 21st century are they not? Your analogy is very dangerous and it comes from doubts created by shytan and tolerance in current society. With your analogy I can say that weed(THC) is halal if my intension is halal. Little bit of Alcohol is halal is my intension is halal. Do you see where this is going?

[@ahmadyusufzai9985]

I was addicted to music in my teenage, at that time I was under impression listening to music is the only way to git rid of stresses and depression, But honestly I was completely wrong and I ended up being depressed by listening musics, As soon as I gradually stopped this habit, I become more conscious, active and closer to Allah (SWT), therefore we have to understand any deed or activity which contradicts with the teaching of Islam is defiantly harmful and we should refrain it immediately.

[@yusuufff]

Allahuma barek Shaykhhh

[@mrfarooqkhan8454]

JazakAllah shyiekh ❤

[@yufusman6909]

Ma Sha Allah........ May Allaah increase you in knowledge and understanding of His deen.

[@Ugaas3]

@@peshat9243music are harem but there certain some are probated only with vocals or in weddings with drums but am not a 100% certain but we have our great shaykh uthman who have knowledge and showed us evidence we should never listen to some one especially when it is about the deen without evidence inshallah by Allah bless shaykh uthman.

[@ibrahimagadjukic7627]

Since I stopped listening to music I`m other person. There is no depretion, nothing. Elhamdullilah!

[@thetruthnothingbutthetruth1]

Music takes one away from the remembrance of Allah Subhaana Wa T'aala.

[@021.sohanurrahman6]

Thanks for the thumbnail.. i was looking for a response

[@longliveliberty2257]

I think that Ayah encompasses more than just music, especially nowadays. Such as movies, fictional books, other forms of entertainment and so on.

[@al-Huwariyun]

So you believe entertainment is haram?

[@fevad1246]

"Don't justify your sins" is exactly what more ppl need to know about. Still ppl even my family members are like justifying by saying scholars like sheikh othman are just clown . I am very very thankful to Allah swt that I am one of the ppl who isn't into modernism(music,semi nude cloths,birthday celebration, any other western celebration).

[@ihab505]

Thank you for sharing, from someone who spent most of his life listening to music from the classical to hard rock and metal to someone who doesn't seem to enjoy it anymore, Subhan Allah it was just taken away from my heart and now I don't even understand the need of it, again Subhan Allah Ta'ala I used to listen to music to enjoy and have a pleasant time now I'm always satisfied and feeling content without it, in no need for its stimulation, time to pass, and edgy emotional booster effects, just listening to it now is like listening to noise vibes Alhamduliilah elazi la yohmad ela sewah.

[@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543]

Same thing with me, when I put Quran on my phone and memorized I was happy, sleeping better, remembering better etc. musiq is bad for study etc. life is short, May Allah guide us!

[@ihab505]

@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Ameen

[@Raf-xd4ut]

Ma sha Allah... May Allah subhanahu wa ta ala protect you akhi,

[@AdnMoko]

MasyaAllah.... Tabarak Allah..... Barakallahu fik

[@ooze91]

Thank you for showing the evidence, Shaykh. May Allah SWT reward you and spread this knowledge throughout the Ummah

[@nashcomp]

As we grown up and learn how to find an amusement for our mind and heart with all the influence of sekular life style its pretty hard to break the habbit to consumes music, smoking, medicine and the hardest part is riba, may Allah give us hidayah.

[@ihab505]

Amin, always going to be hard when you try achieving it on your own always pray for it and let Allah Az wa Jal help you find your way through them, bro.

[@kirk3056]

Brother, instead of Frequencies produce by Music instruments, Music also promoting, admiring infact worshiping,idolizing singer/band and make you stay away from Remembering & Worshiping Allah.. That is why Music is Haram.. So simple even my 3 year old kid understand this..

[@sohaibkhan4033]

Brother change the thumbnail .. we all make mistakes , however one should not roast one another . Ustadh Nouman is a Muslim right , why such hate .. At least he is trying to serve the ummah ...

[@raffatperveen3150]

Shiekh Uthman jazzak ALLAHU Khairain Khathera bring this issue and clear Alhamdulilah

[@whatifoundout]

There needs to be many more many many more talks clarifying Entertainment and Entertainers.

[@Israel-IS-Socialism]

I’m so sad as a Muslim because of how two faced many muslims have become like Nouman and many others.

[@ezioFANable]

why would you say he's two faced? he even said in his video that he's not a reference in the field of hadith... be careful of how you speak of other muslims my friend, Allah is listening

[@Israel-IS-Socialism]

@@ezioFANable brother when 3 out of 10 Nigerian men (a Muslim country) found out that their child isn’t theirs through a study that was conducted in Nigeria- I suggest that our awareness between people even have to do with our own accountability and making it happen between communities of men and women that are Muslim. So don’t talk to me as if you’re speaking from Quran or hadith yourself or the actual FACT(not “my reality “) that someone’s mistakes can even lead to bigger detrimental opportunities for lying and cheating to be made an opportunity out of as some sort of twisted ideal of “democracy “ or “women’s rights” or “freedom” (even though freedom is a by product of existence and is limited based on circumstance. ). for people to make more false opportunities and secret ideals out of in the future and begin to mix it in as something permissible to the betterment of men and women when they urge towards things that cause inevitable insecurity-if it goes without acknowledgement. How would your four witnesses be able to make up for those women who cheat and go behind closed doors and privacy with the amount of men they afford just because they’re attractive as most women are to most men naturally and now that they have the Internet they have an entire access of options of men that they can use, however they want and have multiples of lives and fantasize and urge towards these things- most men can’t do this as much as a Muslim woman who claims to be chaste will ruin your reputation just cause you don’t trust her sexually in marriage and therefore want to divorce. The amount of humiliation that is taught as “being humble” to men and telling men “it’s your ego” has a lot to do with ideas that don’t match the fundamentals of Islam and how being kind and in equity with women is only up until they are caught doing disgusting things But what’s hilarious is a lot of people can easily hide things by knowing how to gain your trust by saying words or doing something for you and then waste 20-30 years of your life being with a woman who fetishized other men and was truthfully ungrateful for her husband or has to overlook such things and the humiliation that men face. What do you manipulated men of these cultures that come from histories of worshipping women more than worshipping men do besides use mens desperation against him to get him to find a woman that he can’t know about as much as he’s told to BELIEVE. How do you think all of these sects exist in the first place? What about those kids who don’t know their father is not their father? Is that not ok to reassure on when paranoia on that is just as reasonable as men not trusting women who can’t prove they are virgin like us or expect us to tolerate being with a woman who treats us with nothing but our humiliation just by knowing how they are in the places of THE UNSEEN. We aren’t supposed to allow these things to happen -in a just way. There is no compulsion in our religion, and you know this, but to assume that my judgment is mistaken when he’s someone that speaking to groups of Muslims and giving advice without even referencing the Quran and the hadiths-yet you’re going to advocate for a Muslim who doesn’t even know that he’s doing what he’s doing and technically sounds like those racist Nation of Islam goobers that many racist women love to fetishize as some sort of weird cultural ritual while humiliating certain races of men as unappealing based on their genes. But now you live in a culture where we’re being told to tolerate Muslim women who we know nothing about and even if it’s our preference and Islamic right to not get involved with a woman we’re unsure of -you’re still going to say that we are the ones who are wrong, and we are the weak ones. When there are studies that even show you that Egyptian women happen to be more abusive than American women towards their husbands and probably not their lovers or fantasies they keep to themselves through. The fact that women are being given more money just to make up for the man that they’re being with and yet we men are fooled into being with unknown women saying things in secret like black men and white men are more appealing for sex and then separating them from the man that they want to have children with and hide their intentions as “mistakes “ or something unfair in it’s observations. Which is completely humiliating regarding how men and women are carrying themselves, and how you speak about Muslims is all based on observation itself and making sure that Muslims as brothers and sisters and families in general - Qur’an 2:190: “And fight in the way of God with those who fight with you, but aggress not: God loves not the aggressors.” 78:40 ) “Indeed, We have warned you of a near punishment on the Day when a man will observe what his hands have put forth and the disbeliever will say, "Oh, I wish that I were dust!" “O you who believe! You are forbidden to inherit women against their will. Nor should you treat them with harshness, that you may take away part of the dowry you have given them - except when they have become guilty of open lewdness On the contrary live with them on a footing of kindness and equity. If you take a dislike to them, it may be that you dislike something bad Allah will bring about through it a great deal of good. (Quran, 4:19) "Do not abuse the dead, for they have reached the result of what they have done. Sahih al-Bukhari 6516 "AND LET THERE BE [ARISING] FROM YOU A NATION INVITING TO [ALL THAT ISI GOOD, ENJOINING WHAT IS RIGHT AND FORBIDDING WHAT IS WRONG, AND THOSE WILL BE THE SUCCESSFUL." [3:104] (O you who believe) . . . help one another in piety and goodness and do not help one another in sin and aggression Suratul Mai’dah (No. 5), Ayat 2 And those who do not judge by what Allah has revealed are ˹truly˺ the disbelievers.(5:44) “There is no compulsion in religion, the right direction is clearly distinguished from the wrong." (Quran 2:256). “O you who believe! Be afraid of Allaah, and be with those who are true (in word and deeds).” [al-Tawbah 9:119] “To you be your religion, and to me my religion (Islamic Monotheism).” [109:6] Btw- if “divorce never existed before Islam was reintroduced to the world” - then The good are those who are being truthful and are good in their deeds, and that is a righteous person. And peace is being able to turn your back and can easily trust the urges of those you value and they can trust you in that regards too. But when believing isn’t knowing - then that makes an issue as well. Good luck finding truth for these things as much as truth is abused for it’s value no different than freedom being used to justify lying and cheating in secrecy to be healthier for people…. “It’s going to happen” “It is what it is” “Leave it to Allah” No- the devil was right but wrong for “his pride “ on speaking truthfully about how fire can completely weaken flesh… which is a simple FACT. If you really read the Quran - where does it say “men and women were thrown out of heaven AS ENEMIES OF EACH OTHER”. When cheating has increased- and rebelling is seen as a good thing We get labeled as weak or “too agreeable “ Like how is that an issue? Oh right- we’re also taking advice from Jordan Peterson who was an alcoholic who turned into some pseudo Christian Guru that is being threatened by people who gave him his psychology license and are trying to strip it away from him for going “against the grain”… when the entire groups of scientists are also saying it’s ok to humiliate your self to compensate for a lack of physical and emotional reassurance between men and women. When they’re as corrupt as the cultures of people are and how much they urge towards instability as women. We have bigger problems that are connected to how women are men’s weakness

[@ezioFANable]

@AhlulAlHaqq-cj4me I agree with you, stills one can make a mistake and still shouldn't be called two faced... Also we don't really know his exact situation, he even said that he spoke to 'oulama ... although nameless ones it seems... but we shouldn't make assumptions on his intentions... we should critique the "fatwa" rather than insult the guy

[@Spiros_Angelaki_II]

@Israel-IS-Socialism I advise you to learn more about capital, namely from Karl Marx ie: Das Kapital. Zionism in the modern day nation of Israel would be a type of religious National Socialism, similar to what the Nazis had, and it is incorrect to call it Socialism. Also, becareful how we speak of that word, Israel, and look into Islamic Socialism, lest you think an economic system is something it may not be.

[@ftmm933]

Thanks for the video❤️ finally i got the truth.Few weeks ago i just listened the brother you mentioned and got confused..may Allah protect us from this critical fitnah.

[@ebutariq99]

That "brother"is faaaar away misguided in Aqida particularly!!!He is a caller on the gate of Hell!!I listened to a lot of his lectures and he is really lost in the Creed.You just have to pay attention to Aqida"Tafsir". Like for example when he talks about Taghout,Allah "forgives"shirk to Banu Israel WITHOUT them asking for forgiveness,on Day of Judgement Prophet Muhammed saws will take anyone out of the Jahanam who pronounce Shada even if they are forced to say it without believe in it and so other Kufr "Tafsir and believe"

[@Nagasyari]

This is good. I hope the halal camp presents their reasoning and arguments and then we can have a big proper debate on stage.

[@Jimmothyhalpert]

I honestly don't think they will unfortunately. Causing fitnah and then hiding from ownership. It's heavily influenced by ego sadly.

[@kenkaneki9138]

What debate? this is not a debated issue. The Hadith is very clear and the Hadith is sahih or some regard it as Hasan of a famous sahabi explaining a verse of the Quran. Now If you say you are not a scholar of Hadith and then say the Hadith has a drunkard which means the Hadith is weak and thus must not be used as evidence then this is really a cheap shot for no reason.

[@Brett_Bond]

Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari: that he heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of *musical instruments* , as lawful..... Sahih al-Bukhari 5590 Book 74, Hadith 16

[@GoodOne4All]

Perfect timing. 👏

[@alchemistbrotv1707]

I would like an expansion on the hadith of the duff beaters. Because it is not seeming logical to allow duff but not other tools that can make beats. For example, you mentioned there are some beats that can lead ppl to increase in lust, but what if one person makes a beat like this on the duff? Also, to have duff players, they undergo musical training, so then will you sponsor musical schools to teach duff? Also, if music from the duff is permitted, what makes it different from music from other instruments. Isn’t the indication the prophet saws allowed this kind of music at the celebratory event revealing that there is permissibility for some kind of tune, as many scholars have noted about this Hadith on Tarb?

[@Ntwadumela266]

Enjoyable, it would have been nice to have a video that shows the other opinion that it’s halal and how you see the haram evidence as stronger and the problems with the halal evidence, and vice versa, like a very balanced approach that lets you hear both arguments. Maybe even bringing an acceptable scholar that has the other opinion.

[@HiriHM]

Jazakallah Khair for the video. I was just debating this topic last night, it isn't great to see that the Ummah is trying to justify music, something that obviously distracts us from the remembrance of Allah. Music (even if it doesn't contain any bad words or any words at all) is an immersive experience that you indulge in so much that you lose sight of your Deen (Listening to music, not hearing it)

[@MM-mc8hs]

بارك الله فيك ❤

[@serialstrp9563]

will not justify music, but the sahabah's interpretation of Quran 31:6 is clearly written in arabic as ghinaa. and ghinaa is singing, not music. Ghinaa is singing voice without instruments and music is singing with instruments. Why don't the scholars prohibit singing entirely when the sahabah clearly said it is lahw al hadees. So don't say the sahabah said Quran 31:6 is music, it is singing. Also, music (word) is there in the tafsir of some ayah, not the words of those sahabah you mentioned.

[@AlexOjideagu2]

The Hadith says that wearing Silk is Haram, yet women are allowed to wear silk. So does that mean women can play musical instruments? It's a totally flawed hadith. Something must be 100% clear to be Haram. Idle Talk is not music. Poetry is halal yet is more idle talk than Music.

[@DrWoofOfficial]

*Ouds, flutes & drums from Hadeeth & Tafseer!* Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her), in a long hadeeth (read Bukhari 5189 and Muslim 2448a) narrates in one part her friend saying her husband played the Mizhar. An-Nawawi and the Jumhoor said the Mizhar is the Oud (a type of stringed instrument). In the same hadeeth, Aisha mentions the Prophet ﷺ made a comment on one part of the hadeeth; we don't know if she narrated the hadeeth entirely to him ﷺ or just that part, but it's very possible, but in any case it is for sure this occurred during the time of the Prophet ﷺ. In the final verse of Surat Al Jumuah, Allah says "and when they see Tijarah (trade) and Lahu (in this context: amusement and entertainment) they disperse towards it leaving you standing [on the pulpit]. Say "what is with Allah is better than Lahu and Tijarah". And Allah is the best of providers". - Jabir (may Allah be pleased with him) said "when the girls would marry they would pass by with the Kabar (drum) and Mazameer (flutes)". - Imam At-Tabari, the author of the great Tafseer book, accepted this narration as a tafseer of the Lahu in this verse. - Note the usage of Lahu here which is more appropriate to refer to musical instruments, whereas Lahwul-Hadeeth in Surat Luqman refers to the speech and not the musical instruments, hence why Ibn Abbas said Ghinā (singing). [good observation by the original commenter) - Ibn Tahir Al Maqdasi mentions the fact that trade is halal and that if two things are mentioned like that as "trade and lahu" were mentioned here, then they take the same ruling on their permissibility. He also said "...it is not possible that the Prophet forbade it then people passed by the mosque on Jumuah, then Allah reproaches those who left the Prophet ﷺ standing to go and listen to it, and that nothing of a verse was revealed on its prohibition, not even after a year had passed? From this we know that the state of matter was kept as is (i.e. permissibility)".

[@Spiros_Angelaki_II]

​@AlexOjideagu2 Idle talk would be pointless words, falsehoods with no purpose, speech totally lacking righteousness and utility. Clear as day, most lyrics used musically, or with the primary intention of being musical, would fit into this category. Poetry alone, whether written or recited, can be created with the primary intention of serving a righteous purpose, or purposes, such as Worship of Allah, Subhanahu wa Ta'ala, without the influence of shaytan from musical intentions.

[@azizasgarden7471]

People make mistakes even Imams. Making mistake is one of the sign of being human. The only people who don't do mistakes are the ones who do nothing in their life. But the most important thing is admitting and repentance.

[@funfacts-ph9lu]

Nouman Ali Khan didn’t say to listen to vulgar songs. He meant to say that most of the Imams are not being clear about what type of music you can listen to. Then he mentioned what type of instruments they used at the time of the Prophet PBUH. Go and listen to the lecture of what the Ustadh said! This Imam is sadly making a big issue out of nothing.

[@legend6943]

Most of the imams are being clear. The quran is clear. The Hadith is clear. We are afraid of that clarity. It is we who are at fault. Ustad Nouman ali khan is a man I respect and have learned a lot from but he has not made a wise decision by uploading that video. There is no drunkard person is that chain of narration which was his whole argument therefore his arguement is flawed, sorry to say. Benefit from everyone but remember to draw the line despite what family and society is telling it is your responsibility to find the truth for yourself. You will be held accountantable on the day of judgement so let us prepare and not be wishful and neglecful and desireful.

[@Zak-gl4ig]

I like the Sheikh and applaud his Adab. I also agree that the reasoning used by the brother whom he countered was weak. Much of the music out there is bad and mixed with bad. Furthermore, like video games and the internet, music can distract you from your obligations. However, I have not been convinced by his arguments for _the complete prohibition of _*_all music._* Firstly, the Hadith attributed to Ibn Masud (r) may mention, that in Surah 31:6, 'Lahwa al hadithi' is a reference to music. The problem is that the verse clearly adds 'Li yudilla 'an Sabilillah,' i.e. 'to lead people away from the path of Allah (SWT).' As Ibn Hazm stated, anything that might have been used to distract people from listening to the Prophet (pbuh) would have been Haram. We cannot derive general prohibitions from such incidences. He even compares it to the prohibition of alcohol, but that prohibition is *direct and explicit.* Secondly, he mentioned the Hadith from the Sahih of Bukhari, and mentioned "silk for men," but that is NOT what it says. On the contrary, it simply says "silk." So, as Javed Ghamidi pointed out, why are we interpreting one of the listed things (i.e. music) as _completely prohibited,_ and the other (i.e. silk) we add conditions? Thirdly, if musical instruments are from Satan because Abu Bakr (r) said so, why would it be allowed at all? Eid or not Eid, if something is "satanic" it should be shunned like alcohol is shunned. The fact that the Prophet (pbuh) allowed it during Eid suggests that music is a passtime that we should not lose too much time with, but on special occasions, there is no harm in it. Fourthly, saying that "only the duff was played therefore all other instruments are prohibited," is like saying "since they only travelled by foot or camels and horseback, commuting by any other means is prohibited." However, modern transport was not around at the time, and neither was the piano or the guitar, but that's not a valid justification for their prohibition. Can you imagine them pushing a piano through the desert? No, their common instrument just happened to be the duff.

[@Emsyaz]

Kinda agree with you but its best to avoid musical instruments at all times. Music is a tool thats beloved by shaitan to turn people away from Islam and righteousness.

[@Faith_is_powerr]

I appreciate this video a lot. The brother sheikh is referring to is someone who’s knowledgeable as well. With respect to this video, I will not mention his name but his thoughts on music weren’t very convincing and hence many people I know always use that to defend their love of music. There are some people who use prophet David’s example of his love of music and his ability to sing to defend themselves on the topic. Some people say , if music was haram, why would Allah use surrr on the day of judgement? Sheikh, can you please explain why prophet David’s love of music was okay and praised while even clean music for us is abandoned. ? This video explains a lot and it’s very important we learn and share. Jazakallah, Allah bless you.

[@istriver.]

May One day we witness Shaykh Sneako addressing the Majlis

[@rohimabegum3772]

Jzk for this video, very informative.

[@LargeBanana]

Really scary all of these comments that are trying to make the haram into halal. They don't watch the video. They disagree with any contrary proof. They justify their desire this way so they can listen to music. It's insane and even more insane is that they will try to justify themselves commenting on this comment.

[@mz6137]

ull see alot of them unfortunately. May Allah سبحانه وتعالى guide them and us

[@ihab505]

nothing scary though bro, الحمد لله الذى عفانا if anything it is rather pathetic to anyone with a clear mind and a true purpose of existing that Music as a subject is not even a priority or worth the time advocating for unless to perhaps the deluded or worse.

[@Mister.a1]

Wallah kt upset me

[@Brett_Bond]

Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari: that he heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments , as lawful...... Sahih al-Bukhari 5590 Book 74, Hadith 16

[@naufalhakimi1558]

There are differences of opinion from amog scholars, that is a fact. Here is what I found on scholars who authored works on the permissibility of music: (1) The proof of Islam, al-Ghazali [may Allah grant him mercy] said: “Entertainment is a help to relieve the stress. Only the Prophets, peace be upon them, can endure absolute seriousness and hardships. Entertainment is the medicine of heat against the disease of weariness and restlessness; so it should be permissible. But there should be no excess, just as there should be no overdose in medicine. Thus, whenever entertainment is for this purpose, it becomes an act of piety bringing one close to Allah. This is so even in the case of one in whose heart musc and singing do not rouse a praiseworthy quality-the arousal of which should be sought-but who only seeks to obtain pleasure and rest from it. So it is fitting that it be obtained in the manner we have outlined. There is no doubt that this indicates a falling short from the peak of perfection, for the perfect man is he whose soul does not need to be rested by anything other than Allah. But “the good deeds of the pious are the evil deeds of those closest to Allah”, and he who has mastered the science of dealing with hearts, and the different ways of leading them gently to the truth, knows well that resting them with such entertainment is indispensable.” [Revival of Religious Sciences by al-Imam al-Ghazali 92/2260].

[@knowledgeofquranmahmoudeis9034]

maa shaa allah best bsst best teacher

[@moinuddinkhan593]

I love noman ali khan, & About music, he says nothing wrong. If you watch that particular video, he didn't say it isn't haram. He just says, there's some ikhtilaf & a scholar should put forward every hadith & classical explanation on a topic, Agreeing or disagreeing from his point of view.

[@Crazy88277]

So basically Khan doesn’t uses a lot of words but doesn’t say much at all. The usual preaching then for him. You must be one of those watered down Muslims I suppose. Good luck with that.

[@jurairbhat2158]

One of the best lectures.

[@sR-kf9ib]

And I have tremendous respect for the outstanding contributions of sheikh Numan Ali Khan. He tries his best and is honourable.

[@zuhrasherally2824]

Sheikh Uthmaan always crystal clear 👌 and very humble

[@sabelogiven5250]

One authentic proof is enough for a truth seeker🤐

[@Jimmothyhalpert]

The "in my humble opinion" people are at it again. Always claiming humility while speaking from everything besides the Quran and Sunnah as understood by the sahabah and not by modern re-interpretations. May Allah guide us all and protect us from this fitnah. Aameen.

[@Jimmothyhalpert]

@@DonDiiiii so do you reject the hadiths referenced in the video while accepting the comparison you mentioned?

[@itskyloren]

it is clear from hadiths and Quran verses that music is haram. those who say "music isn't haram" lol 😂 despite so many evidences their eyes see, deep inside their heart they know it's haram but they're addicts, which is why they try to twist words and interpretations of hadiths and Quran verses exactly like Qawm Lut/LGTV-HD range people to fulfill their sinful desires. if you think it's not haram, okay then you listen to it etc your opinion doesn't matter. keep your opinion tk yourself. stop dragging others to the sins you take pleasure while committing it.

[@waqasikhlaq7424]

who even cares about this anymore ? can u drive without music? or workout without music ? or watch news without music ? this is some Real BS ,

[@shahriar0247]

@@waqasikhlaq7424simple answer Waaaeee Eee Assss Yes

[@rake1840]

What about singing Nasheeds?

[@itskyloren]

@@waqasikhlaq7424 are you a Muslim? yes or no? if yes, then you should have known this basic knowledge that for Muslims, our morality; our guidance comes from Qur'an and sunnah. if it doesn't matter to you, and you want to follow your desires, bruh why even are you a Muslim then? clearly you haven't submit your free will to Allah. if you're not following Quran and sunnah, you're not even part of ummah. you're not a Muslim xD and your use of cuss words just shows what moral of a person you are 🤢 (probably music's side effect) you're at a point where you just say these filthy words so easily without even any hesitant. and also based from your comment, your logic is so DUM DUM like "oh this sin is widespread, so why even bother not to do it? let me also indulge myself in this sin cause everyone's doing it"- (in a james charles voice) lol 💀😆🤣 nahh fr you liberals are funny. go and be an atheist then ig? cause they don't have a moral compass and you being a Muslim, having a moral compass and still choosing to be among those ignorant people who earns wrath of Allah, idk bro just why even are you a Muslim then? anyone, who is a Muslim, submits their free will to Allah. this life is a test. can't control yourself and follow your sinful desires, you fail your test and get the destinations of those many generations who came before us. i don't get why humans like to follow and be a slave to their desires or ANYTHING just EXCEPT their Creator, the One who deserves to be worshipped. just bunch of lame comments and waste of time. i'm not replying any futher to these lame kindergarten logic comments bruh 💀 these lame comments just coming from pure ignorance and of people who became so comfortable to disobey Allah.

[@waqasikhlaq7424]

@agentyearsago Evidence ? well we both know that its not possible to live without music , can u stick your fingers in your ear when traveling in public transport while drivver is banging some songs throughout the journey ? can u do it ?

[@alexanderoneill6160]

Listening to music while watching this 🎶🎶🎶😎😎😎

[@marselona]

destroying yourself while watching a video on why listening to music destroys u? congrats big brain

[@marselona]

@@DonDiiiii LOL, you are comparing music from the time of Prophets with the present Music So you are trying to say, we should judge the current music culture (with all those filthy words, curses, gang and violence culture, girls nude and twerking, etc) with the music culture present in the times of Prophets (where it was only about musical instruments and not any false speech accompanying the rhythm) Do you lack common sense or did you fell on your head as a kid? No sane scholars will approve of the music in present times, its filled with degeneracy and haram stuff Your progressive ideologies don't make sense in any way possible.

[@thehourglassfan3515]

Background theme. 😂

[@kisamehochigaki3150]

Damn you are so cool

[@entityarif8404]

The Prophet PBUH is the best example. He himself did not indulge in music in any way.

[@owb_9731]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@Mister.a1]

Thank bro, some people are just blind follower taking people like angel etc...

[@chegayahsalleh5910]

Alhamdulillaah very clear explanations with evidences, jzklhyr.

[@englishwithmuzammal3596]

On the Arrival of Prophet Muhammad, girls in Madina played Tambourine (Duff). Isn't music? Kindly advice. Anas ibn Malik reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, passed by some of the girls of Medina and they were playing their drums and singing the words, “Muhammad is an excellent neighbor! We are neighbors from the tribe of Najjar!” The Prophet said, “Verily, Allah knows that you are dear to me.” Source: Sunan Ibn Majah 1899 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani عَنْ أَنَسِ بْنِ مَالِكٍ أَنَّ النَّبِيَّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ مَرَّ بِبَعْضِ الْمَدِينَةِ فَإِذَا هُوَ بِجَوَارٍ يَضْرِبْنَ بِدُفِّهِنَّ وَيَتَغَنَّيْنَ وَيَقُلْنَ يَا حَبَّذَا مُحَمَّدٌ مِنْ جَارِ نَحْنُ جَوَارٍ مِنْ بَنِي النَّجَّارِ فَقَالَ النَّبِيُّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ يَعْلَمُ اللَّهُ إِنِّي لَأُحِبُّكُنَّ 1899 سنن ابن ماجه كتاب النكاح باب الغناء والدف 1553 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث صحيح في صحيح ابن ماجه What about Hz. Dawud whose voice was so melodious. "You were indeed given one of the mizmars of the Prophet Dawud (David)." (Mizmar is actually a wind instrument like flute. In the hadith above, "mizmar" means nice voice, tone, timbre.) (Bukhari, Fadailul-Qur'an 31; Muslim, Salatul-Musafirin 34; Tirmidhi, Manaqib 55) "It was We that made the hills declare, in unison with him, Our Praises, at eventide and at break of day, And the birds gathered (in assemblies): all with him did turn (to Allah)." (Sad 38/18-19) "We bestowed Grace aforetime on David from ourselves: "O ye Mountains! Sing ye back the Praises of Allah with him! And ye birds (also)..." (as-Saba': 34/10) What about the following Hadith: Hadith on Songs: The Prophet allows singers at weddings By Abu Amina Elias / October 24, 2012 / Ansar الأنصار, Community الجماعة, Ease اليسر, Greetings التحية, Manners الادب, Marriage النكاح, Moderation الواسطية, Music المزمارة, Poetry الشعر, Singing الغناء, Women النساء Ibn Abbas reported: Aisha gave away one of her relatives in marriage to a man among the Ansar. The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, came and he said, “Did you send them a girl?” They said yes. The Prophet said, “Did you send someone to sing with her?” She said no. The Prophet said, “Verily, the Ansar are a people who love poetry, so you should send someone along with her to say: Here we come, to you we come, greet us as we greet you.” Source: Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900 Grade: Hasan (fair) according to Al-Albani عَنْ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ قَالَ أَنْكَحَتْ عَائِشَةُ ذَاتَ قَرَابَةٍ لَهَا مِنْ الْأَنْصَارِ فَجَاءَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ فَقَالَ أَهْدَيْتُمْ الْفَتَاةَ قَالُوا نَعَمْ قَالَ أَرْسَلْتُمْ مَعَهَا مَنْ يُغَنِّي قَالَتْ لَا فَقَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ إِنَّ الْأَنْصَارَ قَوْمٌ فِيهِمْ غَزَلٌ فَلَوْ بَعَثْتُمْ مَعَهَا مَنْ يَقُولُ أَتَيْنَاكُمْ أَتَيْنَاكُمْ فَحَيَّانَا وَحَيَّاكُمْ 1900 سنن ابن ماجه كتاب النكاح باب الغناء والدف 2/136 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث حسن في صحيح ابن ماجه I might be amiss; I am open to other notions. Thank you for reading.

[@slowliving2041]

Tambourine is halal for special occasion. Human voice is halal, this covers poetry and song. Still, anything excessive that takes you away from remembering Allah should be avoided. Music covers more than human voice and duff and ijma' ulama says haram. Research more bro. Wallahu a'lam.

[@englishwithmuzammal3596]

@@slowliving2041 This is where the question arises - for a special occasion - then who is going to decide about the special occasion! Maybe the day, event, or occasion which is not for you special is special for others. Anything that makes you forgetful of duties as a Muslim is Haram. Following that, if someone sleeps and never prays, then sleeping is HARAM. No way. We need to understand the value behind our Prophet PBUH saying something, doing, or asking. May Allah guide us. Ameen. Our Prophet PBUH let the girls sing on EID, whence arrived at Madina, and Asked Aisha to send for a poetess/singer to the wedding of Ansar. This is way confusing for those who are learning about Islam. Thank you for reading.

[@Ibnathar_]

@@englishwithmuzammal3596 something that the messenger permitted for particular scenarios, and occasions, and this is concerning the duff, the fact that poetry and beating the duff equates to music is really absurd, furthermore when you bring forth a hadith bring forth its explanations. Additionally, i'm sure your understanding of this isn't comparable to a companion of the messenger.

[@englishwithmuzammal3596]

@@Ibnathar_ I am still waiting for arguments with evidence.

[@zeeeez888]

Sounds like your finding yourself an excuse to go listen to Drake

[@MasudKawsar-k6k]

Fair enough. I acknowledge that half-knowledge is more dangerous than ignorance.

[@QuranLiveToday]

You are giving your own meaning to the Quran. There is no a single word about music in the Quran, but you can find hundreds of hadiths saying music is prohibited. The Quran did not back your claim.

[@each1teach1]

Hadith & quran have 2 different sources? Lol. It's like there are 2 prophets involved?

[@QuranLiveToday]

Anything Speech, Conversation, Music, and whatever you may think of, that includes the use of profane language is prohibited. But there is nothing wrong with a music that does not cross the boundary of morality. Music is used as medicine for thousands of years. Scholars of Islam today are interjecting their own way thinking, and that does not necessarily mean the right way.

[@nazis69]

Music is turkish bullshit

[@Spiros_Angelaki_II]

The Glorious Quran advises us to stay away from idle talk. Ahadeeth can give us further understanding into some other specifics to stay away from.

[@Handleneeds3ormorecharacters04]

MasyaAlllah, JazākAllāhu Khayran

[@thaknobodi]

I learned about islam through hadith online by chance while in computer lab. Not long after i read that music was haram. Destroyed $3,000 worth of musical instruments. Step father was shocked. The Imam tried to tell him what i did was wrong... 🤦‍♂️ those were my guitars and keyboards anyway so what does it matter

[@Brett_Bond]

$3000 worth of haram astagfirullah. Great that you destroyed, I had a collection of music, and I also deleted them. I have some maybe in computer or phone etc but I don't listen to it nor do I crave for it, I actually hate it. Music led me away from Allah, I was getting sad and depressed, found myself repeating stupid lyrics and stuff Astagfirullah. Subhanallah, life is better now.

[@thaknobodi]

@@Brett_Bond yes always move towards Allah and He will move towards you faster than you come to Him. Repent always and you will find baraka and contentment in what you have

[@NoNames824]

Give up something for Allah and He will replace it with something better. May Allah reward you with goodness.

[@thehourglassfan3515]

@@thaknobodi You’re not very smart.

[@thaknobodi]

@@thehourglassfan3515 that's like saying the sky is red. Good luck opposing reality

[@zaidxdesign4744]

NAK needs to listen to this insha'Allah

[@kushiali6578]

You should also listen to his complete lecture not ten minutes clip cropped from a lecture.

[@zaidxdesign4744]

@@kushiali6578 have listened complete one not 10 minutes. All he did was gave vague answer and did not make it clear that it’s haraam. His job was done, confuse the listener on the prohibition of music so none of them can make a claim that it is haraam. He also straight out lied about hanafis, in hanafiyyah listening to music if someone enjoys it equates them to committing kufr. He lied on the Hadith reliability. How in the world are you defending this mate? Don’t be too blind in someone’s following.

[@bibifatimayusufzai92]

Thank you so much shaykh Uthman .

[@JohnDoe-jb5ko]

Jazakallah Uthman Ibn Farooq!

[@Onemessagefoundationismyfav]

Easy Question; Who wants to die with ‘Na Nah na na naaa’ in their mouth? Or any lyrics from a singer? Who wants to die with ‘La Illah IL Allah’ In their mouth? I know my answer! And that gives me the answer about music being haram.

[@ReckonRealLight1]

Barakallahou Fik ❤ Saheeh !

[@thewaytosalvation145]

Imagine an Imam advising muslims to BUY music!? Suhaib Webb did this, but calling him out means we have no Adab!

[@natheemalbertus7988]

Salaam Shaykh can you please provide me with the actual verse of the quran in S Luqman & not an intepretation thereof. Thank you

[@randomdawah]

🔴This channel is not run by Shaykh Uthman or any of his representatives.

[@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543]

Alhamdulilah. This why true Sunnis refuting ahl bida (nak) Iying on Islam is important. Islam is preserved we say alot, why not Muslims learn to verify info like salafis say to act on true din & not be emotional fans when a person is corrected, it leads to unity we all speak of too with the Mercy of Allah.

[@alyarrf]

Please read my comment, and remove the fitna from your name, for the love of Islam.

[@exterminatic]

The fact that He himself mentioned after several times by not mentioning the guy's name or organization, why would Random Dawah channel add NAK's photo's on the thumbnail ?, Is it for views or Click-baiting. It may could have been some one else. I am not here to define or to support NAK. I am asking the a basic question and try to learn. Only Allah (SWT) knows our intentions.

[@barjeestariq8132]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/f36cgGWIpd6Yr5I

[@Abd-al-Qadr]

​@@alyarrfnow that you mention it, the 2 words used as the account name for this channel don't belong next to each other. We are Muslims. One of the Six Pillars Of Iman is to believe in The Divine Decree, or The Divine Command. This means we believe that EVERYTHING that happens, only happens by The Will Of Allah Jalla Jalaluh. Even if we don't comprehend The Wisdom within. Most certainly, there is no such thing as "random".

[@muneeburrehman4690]

Nowadays the best one can do is not play the music deliberately. There's music everywhere, even in the schools!

[@planetunie6397]

NO ONE WISHES TO DIE WHILE DOING MUSIC.

[@tiandi5359]

Same with food no one wishes to die while eating food

[@muslimalhamdulillah5433]

​@@tiandi5359lol what, id rather die eating food then listening music

[@husseinmongolare3417]

Shukran

[@qintharaadikancana9057]

People here in my country seem to ignore that music is haram.

[@AlexOjideagu2]

It's not Haram

[@DrWoofOfficial]

Fun fact: there's a difference opinion since the earliest times!

[@baheejtsk7314]

When it comes to music and musical instruments, there is no clear-cut evidence in the Qur’an or Hadith that explicitly states they are haram. This lack of explicit prohibition is why we see differing opinions among scholars. The problem arises when we dig deeper into the language used in the Hadiths and how these terms are interpreted. Let’s talk about the specific words used to refer to music in hadithes, such as *ghina*, *shir*, *ma'azif*, *mizmar*,mizhar and whatnot. The issue is that these words have been used in Hadiths both positively and negatively. What often happens is that some scholars focus only on the Hadiths where these terms are used negatively and then conclude that all musical instruments are haram. For example, take the word ghina*. In some Hadiths, *ghina might be used in a negative context, and those who oppose music might translate it into English as “musical instruments” to support their view. But ‘ghinacan also mean singing or a type of vocal music, which can be used positively in other Hadiths. Similarly, the word shir usually means poetry. There are Hadiths where shir is criticized severely, and by that logic, one could argue that poetry is haram. But we also have Hadiths where poetry is praised, showing that it’s not inherently haram. The same applies to the word ma'azif*. This term has also been used positively in some contexts. And you mentioned *daf as the only permissible instrument, but we also see mizhar and mizmar in the Hadiths. These terms refer to musical instruments like tambourines and flutes, and there are Hadiths where they are used in contexts, such as when guests come to a Sahaba’s house, not only during Eid or wedding ceremony as you claimed before. Furthermore, I brought up the example of Abu Musa, a Sahabi, who was reciting the Qur’an beautifully. The Prophet (peace be upon him) praised his voice, comparing it to a *mizmar*, which means flute. If the flute were haram, why would the Prophet compare something as noble as Qur’anic recitation to it? It’s like saying the Prophet would compare a pleasant drink to wine, which is clearly haram. He wouldn’t do that because he wouldn’t compare something good to something that is haram. So, when the Prophet compared Abu Musa’s voice to a flute, it indicates that the flute was not considered haram. This example shows that the blanket prohibition of musical instruments is not as clear as some might suggest. The arguments against music and musical instruments often rely on selective interpretations of the Hadiths. When we look at the broader context and the varied use of these terms, we see that the issue is not as black and white as it’s often portrayed. That’s why I believe that music and musical instruments are permissible, and why I feel it’s important to approach this topic with a nuanced understanding.

[@iam4mark852]

How can singing be 'idle talking' if wives will sing to their husbands in Jannah according to the hadiths while the Quran says there won't be idle talk in Jannah? "There they will never hear any idle or sinful talk, only good and virtuous speech" - Quran (56:25-26) Ibn ‘Umar (may Allaah be pleased with him) narrated that the Prophet sallallaahu `alayhi wa sallam (may Allaah exalt his mention) said: “The wives of the people of Paradise will sing for their husbands in the sweetest voices that anyone has ever heard; among the things that they will sing is: We are the good and beautiful wives of noble people; we look at them (husbands) with delight in our eyes (i.e., with satisfaction).’ Another song will be, ‘We are eternal women who will never die; we are safe and will never feel fear; we are settled and will never leave (our husbands).” [At-Tabaraani, and Al-Albaani classified it as authentic]

[@bananagotya]

I get your point but there will be rivers of wine too in Jannah.... doesn't make it halal in this dunya.....

[@abdul-hadidadkhah1459]

​@@bananagotya the wine of jannah isn't like the wine of this world. It doesnt make you drunk.

[@Emsyaz]

​@@abdul-hadidadkhah1459same goes to music. Its haram in this world but its not haram in jannah because music in jannah will be different

[@hamzagodfrey2034]

Absolute gold, a well presented detailed explanation

[@alamjehangir]

Why would you use the picture of the other person in your thumb note... we know who the brother is talking about but you shouldn't outed him by using his picture

[@jamaladen7738]

Norman is wrong. He has poor knowledge

[@zeeeez888]

It’s a good thing he used the picture so no one mistakes for another celebrity sheik.

[@alamjehangir]

@jamaladen7738 Each one of these guys have their own fields of studies, and his is not the same as shakh uthman. We can't judge them it is not our job... but as shakh uthman did is advice them with evidence.

[@hamdmuhammed7149]

@@alamjehangir "there is no word as aqeedah in quran therfore idc of it as much as i care of drugs and pornography being spread in the ummah and the disunity of ummah" and there many more, did you know that these were made by your sheikh nouman ali khan?

[@amirishamal7154]

ماشاءالله شيخ ❤

[@niloferkhan5275]

Sheikh Uthman you make me proud to be a muslim.May Allah keep us steadfast in His Deen

[@swaroopkunduru8557]

Building narrative!!! Change should be inevitable..

[@sumayrak5652]

Why did you put Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan’s photo in the thumbnail when Sheikh Usman didn’t name him himself? You’re causing disunity and hurt just because there is ghil in your heart. People will just look at the thumbnail and assume things because you have put up a suggestive thumbnail.

[@sufiruhul]

What about the hundreds of thousands of people who were misguided? When you're an imam(leader) you must lead according to shariah, not feelings or confusions...

[@kenkaneki9138]

We all know who he is talking about, many already refuted him. In fact, this shows unity because everyone literally started refuting him after he made the stu-pid video of misguidance he made.

[@hamdmuhammed7149]

there is nothing wrong in publicly refuting an individual who publicly spread a falsehood and may allah guide you and all our other siblings of islam from our misguided "scholars" and may allah forgive them and guide them

[@NoNames824]

Stop with this disunity talk. We are already disunited. 73 sects and all of them are in the fire except one. We unite on the truth and that comes from the book of Allah and the sunnah of the Prophet (alayhi salaam) according to the methodology of the salaf. There is no unity without that.

[@HussainFahmy]

*_The so-called secular liberal Imams must be exposed to protect the misguided fans of NAK._*