Shekhar Argues with Dr Zakir, “If a Man can Beat his Wife Lightly, why can a Woman not Beat her...

[@Sturquotte]

You know it’s game over when he says: “VERY GOOD QUESTION!” 😂😂😂😂

[@saifsuleman8357]

😂👍

[@memyself7315]

😂😂😂

[@farfarhad1283]

Sign of Positivity 👍

[@clevereagle1911]

The answer itself "brother asked a very good question" 😊😅

[@ehsanulkabir2529]

😂😂

[@blaineBSL]

This conversation was a wonderfully enlightening one for me as a learning revert who aims to become a student of knowledge. جزك الله خير

[@dajo3032]

With all due respect just would like to ask you what you found enlightening and what you learned from from Zakir's answer. If you would put a light on it.

[@user-ph3mo7tl9y]

May Allah subhana wa ta'la greatly bless you and immensely safeguard you in this life and the next dear sister Ameen ya rabb Al alameen ❤️❤️🌹🌹👑👑🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀

[@sarvatzaheer8802]

Very nice MashaAllah.... Both the questioner and the answering person🤩. I liked the questions this man made may Allah guide him and bless him with iman.

[@awesomeblossom5775]

Though he's not a Muslim yet v mature n sober man , showing his great upbringing. May Allah guide him to the straight path. He's indeed a well-mannered and well-thought person :)

[@m.humaiz1114]

Dr. Zakir Naik you truly are blessed by Allah, the way you speak and answer and know the religion of Allah, it is amazing. I love you for the sake of Allah, may he forgive you, guide you, help you and make it easy for you, and may he give you a long life. you are really one of the most incredible Islamic students. Allah blessed us by keeping you among us, may Allah the Almighty grant you to be near prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.W) in paradise.

[@severinomierla4973]

Kilala ni zakir ang missiah sa presenya ni Jesus, blessid siya piro Kong hindi niya nakilaka si Jesus ang kaligtasan ng Ama hindi siya blessid,

[@IslamicHavenYT]

​@@severinomierla4973 Proof?

[@hirasef7127]

Yeah proof?

[@thejngaming1539]

Ioiuuij

[@LizzEsther]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Talha27]

"brother asked very good question" Dr zakir naik Zindabad.

[@MohamedMuzaahirAjward]

Brother is so intelligent had cross questions with our great scholar Dr.Zakir. I think the brother got the correct answer for him to convince…. May Allah swt guide the brother on the right path.

[@zafarahsan8885]

I am really delighted to find Dr.'s channel on the tube. It's running smooth like a piece of silk, with no ads and unwelcome interpretations by other individuals. May Allah bless Dr. Zakir and award him with success in his noble mission. Many thanks for his associates.

[@jsen6914]

i don’t know how much time he spent with yiu afterwards but he is so lucky. i hope he accepts islam inshAllah

[@SilentValley2023]

Lucky sister? You believe in luck too??

[@christfollower2504]

The prophet’s silence on woman beating is equal to being non affectionate, of being in acceptance, tolerance, and in justification of atrocities against Islamic woman and girls...

[@sadafsultani5884]

@@christfollower2504 he wasn’t silent cmon go do ur research and come back. You are a slave to the western propaganda that’s been ingrained in ur brain.

[@mute042]

@@christfollower2504 when did Hazrat Aisha said after complaining that prophet was silent?? The quote is cut right there..

[@mute042]

@@christfollower2504 do some research about women in Islam and you will see there place, their power, their greatness..

[@zainabbabantakko4621]

Jazakallah Khair Dr Zakir Naik may almighty Allah increase your knowledge and health. We are truly blessed to have you as a brother.

[@DaliliAlli]

Dr always uses logical ways of answering questions and if you are careful you will understand him very well.

[@islahudin-5980]

Alhamdulillah. Jazaakallahukhoiroon

[@mtjfans]

May ALLAHﷻ enlighten all mankind with the religion of Islam, Ameen 🤲 ❤🌹

[@大卫-d5g]

just mankind, what about other living things?

[@christfollower2504]

Curse prophet Muhammad’s and his allah for violence caused by spirit of confusion in Islam, Muslim killing Muslim, Muslim hurting Muslim, Muslim hating Muslim, Muslim not forgiving Muslim, Muslim stealing from Muslim, Muslim angry with Muslim, Muslim plotting vengeance against Muslim, Muslim repaying evil with evil, Muslim punishing a Muslim for questioning prophet Muhammad, Muslim loving the dead prophet Muhammad more than their own lives.... May the God of Christ as a light cast out the darkness in muslims life 🙏

[@gamerz8220]

​@@大卫-d5g they require our kindness and love while religion is only for a man's guidence for a proper life, because God made man as his best living being ever he gave us understanding and knowledge so we can implement them to know better to follow better to follow the truth about life to find God, but it's not really easy for everyone to get there.

[@mushrafchipy586]

Without lies, islam dies.

[@delontareeves3230]

@@mushrafchipy586😂😂😂

[@abdul-razakmohammed-yq2kf]

May Allah bless Dr. Nail and increase him in beneficial knowledge. AMEEN

[@TheOnlyReligionOfMonotheism]

الأخ ذاكر يقول الكلمات الصحيحة. الحقيقة دائما تنتصر على الأكاذيب

[@alaminalamin4433]

MAY ALLAH GIVE DR ZAKIR NAIK A VERY LONG AND HEALTHY LIFE.

[@rahmaehtisham687]

Allah hu Akbar, beshak Allah knows what we don't know and he has sent many prophets for us so we can become better Muslims by following their instructions and there are lessons for us from their lives, Masha Allah Dr Zakir Naik has read almost about everything about our prophets and their wives, and everything that is in our holy book Quran by the grace of Allah and he has always taught me and thousands of human beings about the Love of Allah and Islam that is PEACE for all who have faith in Allah, May Allah bless Dr Zakir Naik and his family in this duniya and in hereafter, Aameen

[@aimanabdullah5712]

جزاك الله خيراً... بارك الله في علمك و عملك

[@muhammadsalman-pz9dx]

Our Creator is only Allah, think about it before the Day of Judgement❤and watch more videos of Zakir Naik to know Islam and to Clear your doubts that having in your mind about Islam , Thank you❤

[@anilfarhan7697]

Haha Dr. Zakir asked him “did you get the answer” and then again he himself said i am not yet done with my answer. Haha ❤

[@anilfarhan7697]

@@always0Anonymous keep watching it, you know what i am talking about.

[@NazhaNazha-qn1ub]

❤ Allah & Quran 1st. Great Explanation fm Dr Zakir.

[@Kod1ark]

Allah does not command man to beat his wife but only to shun them if wife still continue her disobedience\ rebel against her husband good advice. Beat arabic word may also means Shun away and not always means Beat... Nobody loves to got beaten even if u beat them lightly but still inflict impact on her mental. At the starting of this whole statement, God said husband is protecter over wife. How come a protector beat his wife?

[@emeraldstarr4643]

That's the question all sincere Believers, male and female, keep asking. It's a sign of weakness that Prophet Muhammad didn't have (Allah's peace be on him). He would take time away from his wives, but no history tells of him beating them. Or any of his other female relatives, like some Muslim men think they have the right to do. These are some of the things that people use to give Islam a bad reputation.

[@abdullahabdurrahman7639]

The Hadith provides further explanation to Qur'anic verses. What conditions did the Hadith give?

[@MOHAMMEDLIMNA]

May Allah bless and more knowledge Dr zakhir

[@najathhullanajath8641]

Mashallah Dr Zakir Naik gives BEST answers for every time questions from non-believers May Allah subhanawatala give him the BEST life hear and HEARAFTER 🤲🏻 AMEEN And May Allah subhanawatala gives non-believers to hidayat 🤲🏻 AMEEN

[@MuhammadAli-ns4pb]

The dealing of Zakir Naik is best with respect to explanation

[@muhammadsalman-pz9dx]

JAZAKALLAH Sir❤

[@NazarMuhammadBalouch]

Mashallsh❤❤❤❤❤Dr Zakir Naik❤❤❤❤❤ from Pakistan sindh Karachi❤❤❤❤❤

[@niq7264]

He has a way of not answering people directly. This brother's question has nothing to do with father and child because you can't "refuse to share their beds". This question is about husbands who beat their wives badly, not lightly. Also Imams teach that the Prophet didn't hit his wives or a man (unless he was at war). The word daraba actually means "to go away from", which is what the Ptophet did. He would take time away from his wives. How many men hit another man if he disagrees with him?. This speaker did the same as others - speaking with forked tongue. Women should learn self defense to protect themselves against anyone who does them physical harm. Real men don't hit women.

[@catherinelynn5073]

I agree. There's no excuse for abuse.

[@j.j7185]

You are wrong, I am an Arabic speaker and the word In the Quran is “adrib” which means to hit

[@dr.Awaqas]

You either didn't listen to whole clip or didnt understand in arabic a single word can have multiple meanings and in order to get the correct meaning you have to look at the context of story. Father and children example was given so person can understand that in order for a person you love you go as far as striking to not let them make grievous mistake. In case if married women in Islam adultery, disbelief, and debauchery, using foul languages etc. are the things which requires a husband to do all the things to his wife to prevent her from making a mistake. Learn full context so you have better understanding

[@niq7264]

@@dr.Awaqas who hits him when commits adultery or does other wrongs?

[@niq7264]

@@j.j7185 strike the conscious, not hit physically. Plus there's a step before that, to refuse to share the bed and most men will beat a woman and still will expect to bed her,

[@osmansesay9870]

May Allah continue to bless you with lot of knowledge 🙏

[@bariq-alabidae]

ماشاء الله

[@alinasimon6399]

Ya Allah. Please fulfill the wishes of all insan all humanity in this world. Syukur alhamdulillah. Salam from Malaysia.

[@yaseennewyaseennew8020]

MashaAllah, may Allah SWT make us able to understand and act on islam.

[@Abd.Allah_D.Bockler]

Allahu Akbar. ☝🏻❤️

[@TheOnlyReligionOfMonotheism]

الحمد لله ، الذي أعطانا الفرصة للاستماع إلى الدكتور ذاكر

[@HFC786]

Jummu’āh Mubārak

[@madiel-ziab605]

We Muslims don't accept bidah

[@Xcbc4]

it's bidah to say that

[@HFC786]

@@Xcbc4 ok you prove that i have done something wrong and got sin for sending pleasant greeting in the form of have a blessed Friday

[@SukhdevSingh-ge5rj]

Alhamdulillah Alhamdulillah 🕋🕋🕌☪️ Allahuakhbar Allahuakhbar from Malaysia 🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🇲🇾🔻🔻🔻

[@audreyjean3676]

Is there a punishment for a husband beating his wife, if the wife did not do anything bad but he just so easily get angry and doesn't think before beating his wife? Does islam protects also the wife being abused by a bad husband? And if the husband doesn't support his wife financially , physically emotionally and spiritually. What will happen to the forsaken wife? If the man's reason for being bad to his wife is just he want to get another woman. He does bad thing to his wife. So the wife as he think will leave him because of his bad character, if it is by his own intention he hurt his good wife, ehat punishment does islam provide for the abused wife?

[@gotnoname704]

Yes, there is punishment for a man if he beats his wife for no reason. The wife can divorce her husband if he doesn't support her financially or physically.

[@gotnoname704]

It is accepted if she doesn't want to live with him as he doesn't fulfill her rights. Islam gives the choice to the woman that what she wants, she wants to live with him or not, the husband will get his punishment for treating her unjustly on the day of judgement. I hope this answers your questions.

[@بععببععبهب]

الله يعزك وينصرك على من عاداك ياخليفة احمد ديدات رحمه الله وغفر له ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@cooleasye]

My answer to Dr Zakir about if my son wants to jump out from a widow if I will slap him? I have kids and the love I have towards them will make me to call him and put him questions calmly not aggressive to understand why he wants to jump and kill himself, try to reason with him, correct and teach him , this is love . "I believe is the same love with God". I understand people these days are always aggressive to their kids, without knowing how to approach them. And trust me when you approach children in a good and calm way, they will never think of jumping out through the window to kill himself, unless if the parents are treating them wrongly then that will make the child wants to kill himself because the child is not getting love from the parents. My own opinion "pls don't bite me" 😊

[@cooleasye]

Please my beloved ones, we should stop slapping or hitting kids when they want to do what they don't understand, is our job as a parents to call them to their understanding, that's why we're parents. We can only hit or slap kids why they really getting out of control after getting many times warning from their parents. This is how I am with my kids, and everything goes smoothly and lovely. I believe is the same thing with our father in Heaven

[@naheenisapoet69]

Exactly

[@found2273]

i believe beating kids is necessary, very necessary, but it is a tool not a weapon, It is a tool to mold them, and we all know honestly, that children don't listen to words , sometimes they do, but most if the times when they don't. My parents beat me when I was a child, but in limit, I still remember I used to cry so much when they did so, but now I really realize that they especially my mom didn't do so to satisfy her anger, not at all, she did it to mold me into a good person, and I did become a good person because of her and my father's beatings, And I am so glad they did so, because child needs authority, children have less to no fear of God.

[@found2273]

but parents should beat their children when it is absolutely necessary, not for every small thing, I am so glad that I had such good mother who knew this.

[@naheenisapoet69]

@@found2273 💀💀

[@RCQazi]

Shekhar, Zakir you beauty, great questioning great answering.

[@ALzzanam]

جزاكم الله خيرا

[@mdshihabalimullah2352]

Jazakallahu khairon my dear brother, Zakir.

[@Mohammedali78170]

Ameen peace and love ❤️ to all families.

[@MuhammadTheFinalProphet]

Subhan'Allah☝🏾☪️

[@Loh_o_qlam]

مــاشــاءاللہ اللہ پاک آپ کے علم میں عمل میں عمر میں برکت عطاء فرمائے آمین

[@dawudaal-amin5825]

Masha'Allah

[@alihamzamohammadjabbar3648]

Brother ask a very good question 😂❤❤

[@cooleasye]

"16:55" Something is not right here 😯. Seems like we are being forced kind of indirectly to believe in someone's religion even if the answer to the question is not clear and don't have much right to ask questions. I feel this way. I pray to God in heaven who created heaven, earth, us and everything in it, to give us wisdom and good direction to have understanding and peace in our lives. I love you all as God do loves us all 😊

[@NADERXD-4]

he did not mean it by that way i think he meant that he hoped for that man to accept islam but he did not notice his scream but its not a big problem anyways

[@mubba1149]

How did you even manage to come to that conclusion when zakir litrally offered him to ask all 1000 questions and gave his word to sit with him all night? And let me tell you even though you wouldn't care about this part, the guy asking didn't complete single hadith he was quoting, he took single lines from google that's it

[@cinl928]

Agree

[@ryanarodrigues918]

You are absolutely true.Yes he us doing that exactly. But a religious minded can get into a trap but not true believers of Christ.Muhammad teaches sword for a sword.He indirectly fights and Christian pastors .They don't believe Holy Spirit. He answering the Christ way and winning people

[@chilipadi9530]

He rarely answer questions, beat around the bush a lot and if anyone question him he gets mad and starts raising his voice, talk over the person and belittle them

[@endoff2023]

These lectures can be seen in Urdu somewhere?

[@ottomanempirelives6566]

Ask the Hindus why a wife has to commit Sati, but a husband does not. Sati is a 5000 year old practice in which, if a man dies his wife is also pushed into the funeral pyre. Last incident reported was about 30 years ago.

[@nirvana3677]

Sati is not part of vedic religion

[@kannadafactstar]

5000 years lol, check your facts brother That was a cultural thing like caste not religious

[@leeanncotrone8369]

@drzakirnaik may Allah bless you accept all your good intentions you have gift knowledge gift commination Islam convey message of Islam religion of peace JazakAllahuKhayr Tabarak Allah feekum

[@jamirkhan1137]

Mashaalla ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@fahimredwan]

Love your videos dr naik sir🥰❤😊

[@mubba1149]

The guy asking questions isn't saying the full Hadith, he's only saying couple of lines of each hadith and trying to give different meaning. His heart is not clear

[@heavenspleasure793]

Full Hadith will have similar meaning sentences only. The more you read, the more violence you see. You dont get peace, only fear.

[@mubba1149]

​@@heavenspleasure793read and learn then come. Evil will always fear good

[@heavenspleasure793]

@@mubba1149 You should love God and submit yourself by devotion. Obeying instructions with fear is for kids and especially those who do not have the intellect to understand what is right and wrong. So yes my friend you need to learn more and then you can follow a more mature path.

[@mubba1149]

@@heavenspleasure793 blind preaching won't help you. as i said before, if you need fear to follow a good path that means there's already evil inside you. So educate yourself then come, don't be ignorant.

[@heavenspleasure793]

@@mubba1149 If path is good you will agree and submit yourself. You don't need someone to create terror... Because that's what terrorists do - create fear in hearts.

[@sm.pk90]

Dr Sahab ❤🎉

[@harunaumar1371]

It's like this is the second time this guy asked Dr Zakir Hussain Naik these questions. I've seen one other clip where the same guy asked these questions but then the mic was in the front and the answer and conversation was quite different than this. Hope Allah guide us and the man.

[@marklaraga6543]

i iove dr naik zaker he is good to delevered word of Allah❤❤❤❤❤

[@mohammad_niromand]

سلام .به ذاکر نایک.وهمه مسلمانان❤❤❤❤🌷🌷🌷

[@intercontinentaltimes]

Mashallah ❤️

[@abdulsattarqureshi6728]

Ya Allah Sab Ko Hidayat Dey Ham Sab Ko Bhy Ameen Sumah Ameen

[@Ellifiknow]

You have to have a lot of confidence and a massive amount of knowledge to stand in front of that many Muslims and take questions, and give answers that are accepted.

[@tgj42495]

After attaining that much knowledge, confidence would come naturally.

[@HQR_1]

“Hobby” respect the research

[@justinireland7202]

He just gives examples of different situations and acts like they’re all connected. I might say, “The water doesn’t run out of my yard after a heavy rain. What can I do to fix this?” He will reply by saying, “Imagine the water on your countertop. It isn’t so terrible having the water there as it may break up spilled foods by soaking in. Just as the water is on your counter, the water in your yard is perfectly fine.” You’re just left like, ummm yeah, okay.

[@InstantAirConditioning]

I was about to write that. He does it every time.

[@Leyla_Bat_Murrah]

*Matthew 10:34-35* 34 “Do not suppose that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I did not come to bring peace, but a sword. 35 For I have come to turn a man against his father, a daughter against her mother, a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law 34 אַל־תַּחְשְׁבוּ כִּי בָאתִי לְהָטִיל שָׁלוֹם בָּאָרֶץ לֹא בָאתִי לְהָטִיל שָׁלוֹם כִּי אִם־חָרֶב: 35 כִּי בָאתִי לְהַפְרִיד בֵּין אִישׁ וְאָבִיו וּבֵין בַּת וְאִמָּהּ וּבֵין כַּלָּה וַחֲמוֹתָהּ.

[@samtv6447]

34 Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. This sits fine with me. It is something I have personally seen over and over throughout my Christian life. But, in order to understand the translation, you need to look at the entire context of this scripture. What does Jesus mean by “sword”? His meaning is revealed in the following verses, which is why it is important not to take verses out of context. Consider verses 35-39. 34 “Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. 35 For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law. 36 And a person's enemies will be those of his own household. 37 Whoever loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me, and whoever loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me. 38 And whoever does not take his cross and follow me is not worthy of me. 39 Whoever finds his life will lose it, and whoever loses his life for my sake will find it. Jesus is talking specifically here about familial relationships, especially the interpersonal dynamics of a Christian’s closest family members. He is talking about a situation in which there are both believers and unbelievers within the same household, or within the immediate family unit. This creates conflict which is the “sword” Jesus speaks of. Consider verse 37: Whoever loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me, and whoever loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me. This is what a true believer is called to do, which is to love Jesus/God above all things including other family members. This creates friction and conflict. When one family member decides to follow Jesus in this kind of absolute way, other family members will likely despise this decision. Why? Because those who follow Jesus in this kind of way look completely crazy and are generally viewed as “having gone off the deep end”. If this unbeliever begins to then express these concerns to the Christian, it will likely widen the divide. This is actually a mild form of persecution. In islam, it is common for family members to be disowned or even killed for breaking with islam and following Jesus. This is a very real situation for many Christians all over the earth. Similar situations can happen in communist countries. If you look at the two verses just prior to to verse 34, you see that the context of these verses is indeed foretelling these things. 32 So everyone who acknowledges me before men, I also will acknowledge before my Father who is in heaven, 33 but whoever denies me before men, I also will deny before my Father who is in heaven. A person who decides to follow Christ must come to terms that he/she will face persecution for their faith. At best they will be ridiculed, and at worst they may be martyred. These verses are meant to be an encouragement from the Lord to His followers. He is saying these things so that they are not surprised when people hate them because of their faith. Just a dozen verses earlier in the same chapter, Jesus says: 21 Brother will deliver brother over to death, and the father his child, and children will rise against parents and have them put to death, 22 and you will be hated by all for my name's sake. But the one who endures to the end will be saved. I hope you can see clearly now the context of the “sword” Jesus speaks of in verse 34. It means that a Christian should expect persecution. These verses are both encouragements and warnings to believers. Verses 37 and 38 really sum up the issue: 38 And whoever does not take his cross and follow me is not worthy of me. 39 Whoever finds his life will lose it, and whoever loses his life for my sake will find it. The message for Christians is this: A relationship with Jesus is most precious, but comes at a cost. Yet He is worth enduring all of these earthly trials, which surely includes persecution and ridicule (or worse) from your own family members. This is the Sword Jesus speaks of. Truth is, if you have ever despised or hated a Christian, you have helped fulfill the words of Jesus.

[@riyaziaf]

wow, good knowledge session.

[@hudaamjad3025]

There is no God but Allah❤

[@dahmaneachour3951]

I don't know why we keep saying the wives of the Prophet are the best examples to Muslim women. This is completely wrong because the best example is Fatima and no one else. In a society of that time, it was custom to slap or hit women even in Europe or anywhere else in the world. So, Omar and Abu Bakar slapping their daughters is of no surprise. As for verse 4:34, most Muslims, sadly enough, interpret it wrongly. The verb dharaba doesn't mean beating or hitting at all. When Allah says, "dharaba allaha mithaalan" doesn't mean Allah hit an example but rather Allah gave or came up with an example. When Allah says, idha dharabtum fi sabeelillah ", it doesn't mean if you hit in the name of Allah but rather if you leave/depart/set forth in the name of Allah. So, you see here how the sense of the verb changes according to the context. Therefore, the verb "fadhribhunna" means leave them and not hit them because it doesn't serve any purpose but rather the opposite.

[@martychavis4859]

If a muslim beats his wife lightly. Then that means he had no reason to hit his wife. the muslim scholar in this post is giving a watered down excuse because he knows that back in mohammad's time muslim men did not beat their wives lightly. He is giving this excuse because he is trying to camouflage Muslim men in this present day.

[@AbdulRehman-rf2cc]

Source: "My dumb ass brain."

[@infodaynightconv1445]

And in Jesus' time you Christians claim that a "crucifixion" was the done thing - not a good comparison to "tapping lightly" is it?

[@martychavis4859]

@@infodaynightconv1445 women were not crucified. Your analogy does not fit. Now did mohammad beat any of His wives lightly?

[@infodaynightconv1445]

@@martychavis4859 No the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was known for treating his wife with utmost kindness never even asking one for any domestic chore, even sewing his buttons himself, washing his own clothese, sweeping the floor himself etc. However million dollar question for you: How many Christian priests have raped innocent boys in the 2000 years you have been perpetrating these lies about Jesus being God (Astaghfirullah)? A bit rougher than symbolic tapping one with a twig shall we say?

[@justsomeone14]

he never answered if the wife can "symbolically" beat her husband due to disobdience... (Or why can she not?)

[@lisalisa-w2c]

How do you symbolically beat your husband ? He did say she can boycott if that’s what you mean

[@justsomeone14]

@@lisalisa-w2c listen 7:00 onwards. Hitting with a handkerchief "symbollically" is what i reffered to here

[@justsomeone14]

​@@lisalisa-w2c listen 7:00 onwards, you might get what i reffered to here

[@justsomeone14]

​​​​​​​@@lisalisa-w2c watch 7:00 onwards, you'll get what i was referring to. Why the woman can't do the same? So many teachings are always about criticising and controlling women, while there is no sense of accountability mentioned for the men who do those same things, and this is because of patriarchal society and islam being for the patriarchal society. This is discouraging for women because what if the husband is a cheater and she wants to punish him? But no? She's supposed to just quietly separate? While he gets to beat her (even if "symbolically") and couple other things as well. For example: men who are righteous will get 72 angels for him in heaven, what about women? What do they get? Besides that what is already available for the man too, what's the "special reward" for women in heaven? Things like this are discouraging. Like most of the time there is punishment and degradation for women (lesser beings in intelligence and religion, lesser beings than men overall) and very little reward if you compare materialistically. Anyways, I'm just mainly emphasising things that are discussed mostly, I'm Sure that there must be special rewards for women too, and I'm sure that women are not "less than" men, its just how the religion is presented, and how it makes you feel. It feels unjust.

[@fehmidakhalid5867]

Allah apko APNI hifazat mn rakhe aap sabr SE logon k fazool aur time wasting sawal sunte hai Allah apka HR waqt madad agar ho

[@Allytwofivefour]

“Very good question” 😂

[@TheOnlyReligionOfMonotheism]

ما هي الكلمات الأسطورية "سأل الأخ سؤال جيدا"

[@rayq352]

The light "beating" is a last resort. A hit with a miswak (which is twig-like and less than the length of a person's hand) and when you're not allowed to leave a mark, is it really a "beating"? This is one of those questions that non-Muslims like to ask over and over again. The way they carry on, you would think that no non-Muslim man had ever hit his wife!

[@Pharmaline-m8g]

Mashallah

[@garyamalan4426]

What if all three methods don't work?

[@Ashmooni]

If the three methods don’t work, then separation (divorce) is inevitable.

[@garyamalan4426]

@@Ashmooni Thank you Mufti sir!

[@denissssss8579]

I want to ask zakir 100 questions as well 😭

[@k.r.99]

Came for a very good question, stayed for an even better answer.

[@SumitSky608]

12.19 very good question

[@ibn_aflah_owaisi]

MASHALLAH

[@Leyla_Bat_Murrah]

*Luke 14:26* If anyone comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters-yes, even their own life-such a person cannot be my disciple אִישׁ כִּי־יָבוֹא אֵלַי וְלֹא יִשְׂנָא אֶת־אָבִיו וְאֶת־אִמּוֹ וְאֶת־אִשְׁתּוֹ וְאֶת־בָּנָיו וְאֶת־אֶחָיו וְאֶת־אַחְיֹתָיו וְאַף גַּם־אֶת־נַפְשׁוֹ לֹא יוּכַל לִהְיוֹת תַּלְמִידִי.

[@sham112mi]

Love dr naik for the sake of Allah swt

[@Leyla_Bat_Murrah]

*Luke 19:27* But those enemies of mine who did not want me to be king over them-bring them here and kill them in front of me. אֲבָל אֶת־אֹיְבַי הָהֵם אֲשֶׁר מְאָסוּנִי מִמְּלֹךְ עֲלֵיהֶם הָבִיאוּ אֹתָם הֵנָּה וְהִרְגוּ אֹתָם לְפָנָי.

[@rahimfurqan9987]

I like this brother

[@aamirrimzi3227]

"brother/sister asked a very good question"😂...lailaha illalah muhammedur rasoolulah...😌

[@naheenisapoet69]

Zakir Naik didn't really answer the question part 2. He said beating wife lightly is akin to beating with a handkerchief anywhere but the face, so it's cute and ok. If the wife does it too, why would the man retaliate? Isn't beating with a handkerchief harmless and relaxed? Let's say she decided to hit a little harder, like just a tiny bit that doesn't leave marks. Why would this "stronger" human being who is her husband, infuriate to the point of retaliating which would hurt her worse than it hurt him. Do you compete with people who are lesser in strength or inferior to you? Would you compete in a race as a professional athlete with a rookie? it's stupid. Zakir's logic and psychology is weak. I would say you listen to Mufti Menk and Nouman Ali Khan instead of some Indian(yeah Indian men are twisted).

[@khikrum4201]

Even Nouman Ali Khan & Mufti Menk are Indian origin. You didn't understand. it's symbolic as a final warning to discipline a disobedient wife, even after this if wife doesn't change her behaviour she can be divorced. I think you are a r a c i s t against Indians.

[@Xcbc4]

Norman Ali Khan amd menk are only good for reverts,for fiqh u need a actual teacher

[@naheenisapoet69]

@@khikrum4201 You didn't read what I said. I have no problem with the symbolic part.

[@Ali-cz4ld]

You should learn diff of emotions in male and female and learn if god made us then he know better than us then ourselves and it is a order to Muslims women not to non Muslims and if you know what is the meaning of Muslim(submission to god) you shouldn’t question Allah as it is the order from the one who created you

[@naheenisapoet69]

@@Ali-cz4ld I questioned Zakir Naik, not Allah. Not all men are angry and impulsive, some are patient and calm and compassionate

[@Kratonhelps]

Hello sir, I am uneducated on this subject so I just have a quick question for you. In the Qur’an it says “if anyone slays a human being-unless it be [in punishment] for murder or for spreading corruption on earth-it shall be as though he had slain all mankind;”- Question- does this mean that killing anyone of another religion, or someone who just doesn’t believe is accepted? - extreme- “can a Muslim walk into a church and kill the priest because he is spreading corruption in the eyes of allah?” I’m asking these questions because I truly don’t know the answer. Thank you for the free education khuda hafiz ❤

[@bigcheese5057]

Corruption as in for example a king commanding his army to invade a muslim city just for oil. No other reason. That's what the corruption refers to. But you can't just kill. There's many alternatives before killing which you can research, but the last resort or worse case scenario is killing.

[@bigcheese5057]

And logically speaking it won't make sense to even have this sentence in the Quran if it meant anyone who isn't a muslim that is religious is spreading corruption and should be killed. Thats like 6 billion people. And that goes against everything in the quran. The word "murder" wouldn't be relevant if it's permissable to kill over half of the population.

[@SilentValley2023]

Brother has asked a very good question………😊

[@NADERXD-4]

no it is haraam becuse that priest may accept islam in one point of his live and if that priest accepts islam and marrys a women and have kids and tought them about islam now that priest is not spreading courrupsion he is spreading islam

[@SilentValley2023]

@@NADERXD-4 I am a bit confused! So, the only reason a Muslim should not kill a Christian priest is that he could be a potential Muslim in future ❓ So, how about all the Islamic suicide bombers killing innocent people? How about Muslim nations fighting against each other? how about ongoing fight between Palestine and Israel? Are all these killings “haram” ?

[@lutvijahrnjic9670]

Although a lot was said, I feel that the answer was not really given.

[@elsa-d4k]

Chapter (22) sūrat l-ḥaj (The Pilgrimage) For indeed, it is not eyes that are blinded, but blinded are the hearts which are within the breasts.

[@mrsfaisalwaheed3132]

Great

[@spamscamdetective1848]

Sahih Bukhari, Volume 1, Book 12, Number 770: - Quran says that all Muslims - every single one of them - will be taken to Hell. The “Day of Resurrection” or “Qiyamah” refers to the time of the end. This means, even as you are reading this article, Muhammad is in “Hell” awaiting to be rescued. This fact is further substantiated by the admission that even pious Muslims who pray regularly will be consumed by fire, leaving only the “marks of their prostration” untouched. According to the above Hadith, the bodies of those in “Hell” will be consumed by fire. “At that time - the Day of Resurrection - they will come out of the Fire as mere skeletons.” In corroboration with the above Hadith, the Qur’an says that all Muslims - every single one of them - will be taken to Hell. Surah 19:71: “It is the inevitable decree of your Lord that every one of you will be taken to hell.” (Sarwar) “There is not one of you who shall not pass through the confines of Hell.” (Dawood) And the very next verse tells us:

[@Stefan_Samim]

From Kolkata ❤

[@GebbahKosiah-eu8lw]

Please give the proper answer

[@aralmajid3851]

Comparing miswak to handkerchief is such bad faith lmfao they are very much capable of causing significant pain

[@Mohammedali78170]

I LOVE ALLAH MORE THEN MY LIFE.PROMISE.

[@purplelove3666]

What happens when the husband disrespects the wife?

[@EatMazedaar]

شوہر کو سمجھائے کہ میرے حقوق ادا کرے

[@vornach1532]

Bravo ❤

[@Leyla_Bat_Murrah]

*John 15:6* If anyone does not abide in Me, he is cast out as a branch and is withered; and they gather them and throw them into the fire, and they are burned אִישׁ אֲשֶׁר לֹא יַעֲמֹד בִּי הֻשְׁלַךְ הַחוּצָה כַּשָּׂרִיג וַיִּיבַשׁ וְיִלְקְטוּם וְיַשְׁלִיכוּם אֶל־תּוֹךְ הַאֵשׁ וְהָיָה לְבָעֵר.

[@JERRYTAU-gh1br]

Doctor knows that answer but he's hiding it 😢. Unanswered question.

[@intercontinentaltimes]

Nice 👍❤️

[@abdikaremibrahim9963]

Mnsha allaha ❤️

[@apnachannal301]

Wah

[@yussifyahaya6016]

Good

[@abdulsmith1569]

People be reaching