Sherlock Holmes (2009) - What Can You Tell About Me? Scene (2/10) | Movieclips

[@toofless4541]

But, but she insisted.

[@Luciferdesrea]

She did.

[@gibicutey1606]

Well if you insist *shot*

[@yogasucipta9166]

Toofless true

[@gabbar51ngh]

He knew the last part wasn't true. Sherlock said it anyway to sabotage the relationship so he can be with his best friend Watson.

[@Crypton16]

EXACTLY!!! This ALWAYS pissed me off whenever I see that scene. It was the one time in the movie Sherlock showed restrained and the woman insisted.

[@azathoth528]

in his defense, she insisted... in her defense, he made that mistake on purpose

[@copperbeard7196]

how do we know it

[@typicalviewer9702]

She just test how smart he its

[@JohnLee-fb7gt]

@Urrcreavesh Meow!!!

[@Kronos0999]

@Urrcreavesh Smart people tend to be like that; possessive.

[@Bangla_te_Shob]

He was biased in his reasoning from the moment the ring came up, the reasoning as to why she was not wearing it, the one Holmes gave was not following the same train of reasoning, he at that moment tried to reverse calculate to justify his prejudice against her. Though he probably did it on a subconscious level

[@irisce2799]

I love Holmes's expression after his meal comes.

[@WJstudios04]

Tanhlei no fucks given

[@onedaxster]

He knew it would happen and ordered in advance

[@sadmanpranto9026]

@@WJstudios04 I don't think that's what his expression tells us. His expression and attitude seemed like a mixture of confusion and sorrow being covered by the fact that he's used to being such social outcast. His regret led him to go in that bar-ish place (whatever it is called) to fight a drunken brawl, his self destructive attitude fueled by his regret led him to a situation where he can punish himself.

[@justaloner9033]

Somehow makes me sad.

[@xordux7]

A very sad scene. 😕

[@SprikSprak]

Couple of great details here for me - first is that she only decides to throw the wine on him after his assertion that she was a gold digger - she was not offended by his embarrassing insights but by the presumption on her character. The second is that the single meal arrives for him without any others - he'd ordered a meal for one since he'd surmised he would have alienated his guests by the time it was ready to be served.

[@Firefax]

What most people fail to realize in this scene is that Holmes worked out how this entire encounter would go. He knew that Mary would be aware of who he was and of his particular relationship with Dr. Watson. There was still a part of him that wanted to drive a wedge between Mary and John so he planned to make Mary angry so that she would leave, forcing Watson to leave as well. The proof of all this is that, shortly before they arrived at his table, Holmes can be seen checking his watch, ostensibly to check the time, but in actuality checking the timing of John and Mary's arrival. Afterward and with perfect timing, Holmes' meal arrives almost the instant they leave showing that Holmes ordered his meal - and no one else's - beforehand, in the complete assurance that he would be dining alone.

[@clueanalysis2596]

Good observation

[@thespacemangames5144]

Hello Sherlock, nice disguise BTW!

[@Amaberean]

Damn, you’re GOOD. Lol

[@tonga_stone312]

He’s a wingman in disguise

[@mjlotus]

A convincing analysis. Bravo.

[@QualityMasters]

This is such a marvelous character. Not even just because it’s Robert Downey jr. But Sherlock Holmes is one of the best characters to ever have been written.

[@r0yce]

Quentin Martinez may I just point out..... It's marvelous simply because it's Robert downer jr

[@oceane.pagnon9765]

Yeah it's MARVELous 😂😂😂 sorry 😂😂❤❤

[@raisins7976]

Watch hbo's sherlock holmes

[@luckyeddy350]

Definitely goes to show that you haven't read a single Sherlock Holmes story or novel. The actual Sherlock Holmes is absolutely nothing like this character played by Iron Man played by RDJ.

[@RxlredE]

@@r0yce Cumberbatch was born for this character. Downey nailed it too.

[@Testosterooster]

Seeing him get prepared to eat after that is a bit sad, his intellect and detective skills are to no match. And with that, loneliness is sometimes a partner he dines with often.

[@KennethWebb8822]

Well said

[@norm3844]

papercutz6 agree so much, for me that’s always the hardest hitting emotional moment in the film

[@michaelwesten1351]

sherlock doesn't care about being alone

[@norm3844]

Michael Westen this is a different Sherlock to the socially inert version of the BBC. This Sherlock loves Rachel McAdams’ character as a romantic partner and he loves Watson as a friend, as Downey Jr has himself confirmed. As such being abandoned at dinner would have at least a small impact on him surely.

[@aidanjanemcintosh6919]

he doesn't care, nothing he loves more than himself

[@blockmasterscott]

Hey! She said she insists! That’s no fair!

[@adambutts2608]

blockmasterscott when do they ever play by rules? The name of the game is ironically the only rule, “I win”. The only way to play is not to.

[@davecrupel2817]

She underestimated him

[@yogasucipta9166]

Damn true

[@klausoshaunacey8429]

This is true, but he still assumed that they split instead of him dying. That jumping to the worst decision is his emotion getting in the way because he dislikes Mary as she will take Watson from his life.

[@devilpupbear09]

Women right?

[@kume1985]

Yes, she insisted for his deductions but he did not tell her just his deductions. He went a step further and started with assumptions (that she left her previous fiance because of the money). I guess it is a habit for a detective who deals with crimes, to assume bad things by default.

[@ravensquote7206]

Thus leaving the question of weather he knew better or intentionally lied. Mind you that of everyone at the table, he _doesn't_ want this wedding to go through... or at least we are lead to believe such (there's a chance he's attempting to help strengthen their bond through reverse psychology, but I digress). If that's the case then attempting to slander her name by saying she was motivated by riches would be perfectly in line with Holmes' personal goals. She spent time abroad- long enough to get a tan that would last for some time afterwords- with someone who supposedly didn't have money. Holmes would not likely have missed this contradiction. Hence the possibility of deceit.

[@martkbanjoboy8853]

Anyone who has ever had a retired cop friend can 100% relate to this scene 😂

[@CB-lw7ty]

Deductions ultimately are assumptions, as with Watson the blade and neatness says military man, the stub says gambler, however the blade could be brought if a solider died or sold it, neatness could just be OCD and the stub could be a 1 off night out with a friend. Ultimately a deduction is the most likely assumption and if she's working with a governess could mean she has money as its a high position, can go on holiday in those times to a location to get a tan will infer money as well, so the deduction that she might have left a man who pretended to be well off but turned out not to be, in a society that was very much about women marrying for security more than love, is ultimately the most likely assumption and deduction. She threw the water because she knows from Watson that Homes is against their marriage so she tries to indulge his curiosity to get him on board but he takes it as another opportunity to try and sabotage the wedding rather than as an olive branch.

[@matasa7463]

@@ravensquote7206 He was deeply distrusting of women in general - he refused to even really talk to women other than Irene Adler. He would have easily assumed she was up to no good the moment he spotted something off to him.

[@nikhilgudadur4113]

Even in the original Sherlock Holmes stories written by Arthur Conan Doyle, Holmes gets everything right except for a very minor detail. Usually this detail has no bearing on the case or situation itself but usually creates an awkward situation in the room. This theme is continued in all the movies and TV shows as well including the modern adaptation "Sherlock". And also, in the original stories, Sherlock Holmes is very calibrated in his response and demeanour, whereas in all the films and TV shows, he's shown as rash and blunt.

[@ginsan8198]

Sherlock Holmes 3, PLEASE!!!!

[@riley8704]

Boy do I have news for you.

[@yogasucipta9166]

I hope so

[@altafkingkhan2426]

2020

[@kingrichard3990]

We have another one with Ian Mckellen

[@NG-nf2mz]

It will come before Christmas 2020

[@austinhuber3131]

There's no way this movie is almost ten years old?

[@devilpupbear09]

But it is, don't you feel old?

[@TBStudios91]

I remember going to see it with my uncles

[@cgme7076]

That’s crazy...

[@loop5720]

Just saw the movie yesterday, such a great movie, and I was a bit shocked on the exposed Blackwood scene

[@kashmiramorar1621]

@@loop5720 please tell me what the name of this movie is.

[@christiann4412]

"Those days are behind me" "Right behind you" 😏

[@finmat95]

Behind you -> yesterday

[@half.blight]

Mary : *throws wine at Holmes* Holmes : "This must not register on an emotional level"

[@donutwolf5450]

D I S T R A C T T A R G E T

[@ItsMrBozToYou]

​@@donutwolf5450DISCOMBOBULATE

[@derllock]

@@ItsMrBozToYou employ elbow block

[@BladeCrossEXE]

Counter with cross to left cheek.

[@SpinoAdri2001]

​@@BladeCrossEXE *Discombobulate*

[@debjitpaul8580]

Every scene of these 2 movies are beyond perfection.

[@dingdingwang1723]

Mary: "I insist" Dutch: "insist?" Arthur: i- Holmes: D I S C O M B O B U L A T E

[@madocofcatarina7190]

I got a plan

[@Morbid.Angel710]

@@madocofcatarina7190 *”YOU ALWAYS GOT A PLAN DUTCH”*

[@jotaroackerman3447]

have some GOD DAMN FAITH

[@Kyle-hf7ji]

"Loyalty Arthur it ain't... I HAD A GODDAMN PLAN!!!!!"

[@tangydestroyer]

T A H I T I

[@Luciferdesrea]

My person rule: If you can't handle my honesty, then don't ask me to do a run down.

[@duyvan247]

Luciferdesrea his last conclusion was wrong and insulted both her and her dead exhusband

[@ollei8838]

duy van thanh well the fact that the prediction or his criticism was a mere guest so if you said he insulted her past are wrong and also she insisted him, thus her action of blasting wine on Holmes face was a complete act of selfish and stupid

[@Luciferdesrea]

I repeat duy van thanh, if you ask for an opinion and don't like it, then get angry, you should never ask for it in the first place. like Olle said, she insisted on it.

[@duyvan247]

Luciferdesrea plus that was the meaning of the scene,to show that Sherlock sucks on social relationship and always screwed up his conversations.I bet you don't understand more than the director himself

[@Theri4444]

it was not ok at all, he went to far in this scene right here. Cause all he was doing was assuming which he was proved to be wrong and so she was insulted

[@MrValz0]

Love how he wears the wine as a badge of honour. No apology, but quiet acceptance of his mistake.

[@stupidgranny997]

what mistake?

[@MrValz0]

@@stupidgranny997 Holmes presumed she was a gold digger. That she was engaged and broke it off after learning the man she was marrying wasn't as wealthy as she thought. She corrected him with the fact that he had died. Hence the wine in Holmes face for the insult.

[@georgearaujo6532]

I think the guilt of his mistake

[@EP_mc]

@@stupidgranny997 he guessed wrong about why she no longer married

[@golem3273]

​@@georgearaujo6532 nah it was planned

[@NekoEmy]

0:03 Holmes' expression always get me 🤣😂

[@paul_rymar]

Holmes is simply strengthening their relationship through reversed psychology; the more Watson thinks Holmes is separating them, the stronger he will hold to her. If Holmes really wanted to break John-Mary relationship, he would have already done it. This is Sherlock Holmes we're talking about, not some random psychologist.

[@bogdandamaschin9381]

I think he tried to reveal her ex husband to not be some story Watson finds out later. And he made the mistake on purpose to let her explain what happened. So according to Watson it was his fionce that told the truth, not Holmes. He might have saved their mariage in this scene

[@NikolaAvramov]

@youngfischer She doesn't love Watson. She sees him as prey and loot and she doesn't even hide it.

[@charliefarmer4365]

You're a genius

[@charliefarmer4365]

@@NikolaAvramov I think you are indeed wrong. Watch the film again. She clearly loves him. He is not a rich man whatsoever,

[@NikolaAvramov]

@@charliefarmer4365 I've watched it plenty of times. Yeah, you can see love in the way in which she insists that he drops what he loved doing for a decade and insisted he cut his ties with his best friend. Pure love, right?

[@peaveyst7]

cursed with knowledge

[@michaelcueva530]

I see what you did there😂😂

[@bindu9111]

I see what you did there😂😂😂

[@egeorgiades93]

Robert loves to play characters Cursed with Knowledge.

[@raetekusu1]

He even calls it a curse in the next movie too.

[@AdilHusain]

1:34 the expression of doctor ...is like. See I told u not to 😂

[@jqyhlmnp]

This scene is important to show that he can be wrong. He’s still human, maybe that’s how he won the fight against Jared Harris

[@srwllamray2359]

nah fam, he was spot on, thats why she threw the drink on him...

[@scottmatheson3346]

@@srwllamray2359 nah, fam, he was dead wrong, that's why she threw the drink at him.

[@bernardlawrence4985]

Not dead wrong but wrong still and Holmes is as human as it gets with his ignorance of the obvious.

[@marionarda2790]

@@srwllamray2359 he got the last one completely wrong ! Did you watch it

[@bilginyesilcay8952]

I think he know his observations are wrong but he did it John and Mary to fight

[@lumberluc]

When she said "I insist", I immediately said "Please, don't."

[@Gerraint]

This is one of the funniest scene ever. She asked for it and Watson totally knows what would happened.

[@hawkeye4359]

Loved the chemistry between Mary and Holmes in this movie

[@BlitzHacker]

Мэри держалась достойно

[@BlackDiamond2718]

Despite being sad for Holmes, I did admire her restraint on her anger even with just throwing a drink at his face. She explained without any change to her tone. He was wrong, but of course there is always a chance to be wrong. Even then he was explaining the why part which is usually far trickier.

[@201hastings]

“Restraint” more like acting like a toddler

[@PaulSchober]

@@201hastings Yeah if Holmes had tossed a drink in her face for insulting him, I doubt anyone at that table or here would be admiring his "restraint". :)

[@scotth6814]

@@PaulSchober The double-standard applied by woke society.

[@akshayrathore2882]

HOW DARE YOU!? HOW DARE YOU!? HOW DARE YOU!? HOW DARE YOU!? this is what you should except in this age.

[@TippedScale]

​@@201hastingsyeah she asked for it too lol

[@djledward5386]

Robert Downey Jr. was born to play these kind of characters. He nails both the roles of Sherlock Holmes and Tony Stark. 😂👊🙏

[@CyberCheese392]

Damn I need subtitles. He is mumbling!

[@hackzhunter4525]

you should listen to cumberbatches version

[@mojo5723]

HackzHunter don’t compare bruh

[@bingesquad1]

*Dialogue Transcript for this scene.* - Take Watson... - I intend to. See his walking stick? Rare African snakewood. Hiding a blade of high tensile steel. Few were rewarded to the veterans of the Afghan war, so I can assume, he's a decorated soldier. Strong, brave, born to be an adventurer. and neat, like all military men. Now, I check his pockets. Ah, a stamp from a boxing match. Now, I can infer that he's a bit of a gambler. I'd keep an eye on that dowry if I were you. - Those days are behind me. - Right, behind you. It's cost us the rent, more than once. Well with all due respect, Mr. Holmes, You know John very well. What about a complete stranger? What can you tell about me? - You? - I don't think that's... - I don't know that, that's... - Not at dinner. - Perhaps another time. - I insist. - You insist? - You remember we discussed this. The lady insists - You're a governess. - Well done. Yes, well done. Shall we... Waiter! Your student... It's a boy of eight. - Charlie is seven, actually. And he's tall for his age. He flicked you with ink today. - Is there ink on my face? - There is nothing wrong with your face. There are two drops on your ear in fact. India blue is nearly impossible to wash off. Anyway, very impetuous act of that boy, but you're too experienced to react rashly, which is why the lady for whom you work lent you that necklace. Pearls, diamonds, flawless rubies. Hardly the gems of a governess. However, the jewels you are not wearing, tell us rather more. - Holmes! You were engaged. The ring has gone, but the lightness of the skin where it once sat suggests that you spent some time abroad, wearing it proudly that is, until you were informed of its true and rather modest worth which then you broke off the engagement and returned to, England for better prospects. A doctor perhaps? You're right on all counts Mr. Holmes, apart from one. I didn't leave him. He died. - Well done, old boy.

[@소준호-f9s]

@@bingesquad1 well done indeed old boy

[@risbanmoosa3495]

@@bingesquad1 why the last one is wrong

[@husainjam]

No respect for people’s feeling but utmost respect for food on the plate. Sherlock Holmes had his priorities set straight.

[@CeltycSparrow]

I love how she picks up the wine and then holds it until he turns to look at Watson....almost as if she planned to throw it at him for insulting her. In all fairness though, she DID insist. lol

[@niveditayadav2731]

Every scene of the series is gold...but have to say the way she says..."I didn't leave him. ..... He died.". Feels!!!!!! I like that part of the scene really.. ofcourse alongwith them discussing till the lady insists 😂👏👌👍

[@easyenetwork2023]

Hard to believe Mary is the same lady as Beth in Yellowstone.😂 Truly, a very gifted actress.

[@stormcutter59]

Just realized that Holmes doesnt bother to try and wipe the wine off his face. Not once, not even a little bit. To me I think that speaks volumes to what hes thinking

[@longebane]

What is he thinking, wise one?

[@kunalsingh4418]

@@longebane that he deserved it.

[@AzureRoxe]

@@longebane He's thinking that it all went according to plan. Look at how the meal arrives ONLY for him, he knew both Mary and Watson would angrily leave.

[@lightweight2467]

Watson:Those days are behind me Holmes: right behind you

[@nickc3096]

I love at the end he’s just like, alight time to eat

[@spongeman1512]

1:59 his hair not wet. 2:07 now his hair wet

[@ramking7869]

LOL

[@jibranalvi6810]

Sponge man Excellent observation.

[@e.m.p.3394]

I cannot ever unsee that

[@savithau9144]

We got an observer

[@sreekarpradyumna]

The only successful observation in this scene. :P

[@Shadowkey392]

“Take Watson-“ “I intend to.”

[@Emper0rH0rde]

"Not like that."

[@djledward5386]

Mary: What can you tell about me? Sherlock: You? Watson: I don't think that's- Sherlock: I don't know if that's- Watson: Not at dinner. Sherlock: Perhaps another time- Mary: I insist. Sherlock: You insist? Watson: You remember we discussed this- Sherlock: The lady insists. LMAO! 🤣🤣🤣

[@divyeshshukla6387]

Watson is truly great person because he tolerates Holmes whole time while he can easily escape. If Watson is lucky that he got Sherlock then vice versa is also true.

[@Mm-dn5gc]

So many comments saying she asked for it and calling her names without realizing she didn't give him carte blanche to insult her without justification, but to make deductions. He deliberately crossed the line by choosing the worst assumption without being sure that she was a gold digger, and he knows it. Hence why he didn't bother wiping the wine. It's funny that Holmes realized the mistake but part of the audience didn't.

[@TheRohnjackson]

_So _*_Rachel McAdams_*_ was cast against both _*_Sherlocks_* *Beneddict* and *Robert*

[@jaspreetdigpal2777]

Also Benedict, Robert, Jude and Martin are now all in the MCU

[@ariyatabassumabdullah1143]

@@jaspreetdigpal2777 As well as Rachel McAdams

[@toso69420]

Even Ian McKellen, who played Magneto, also played the role of Sherlock Holmes in the year 2015. The name of that movie was, "Mr. Holmes"

[@toso69420]

Also Jared Harris, who plays Moriarty in this movie, plays a character in the upcoming MCU movie "Morbius"

[@anhphi100]

I hope she comes back in the 3rd movie. Since I don't think we will see her in the next Dr Strange

[@WJstudios04]

1:57 me around girls

[@PrOdRgZ]

same lol

[@cgme7076]

I was hammered and got slapped one time. That sucked.

[@bernardlawrence4985]

This thread is sad even after 2years. 💀

[@youngforever7219]

🤣

[@shahdeen-en5qn]

​@@bernardlawrence4985 make it 6. XD On a more positive note, hope ur doing well now

[@psulion31]

Even more amazing is how his white shirt dodged the red wine

[@ApoorwVikramDwivedi]

If this was a younger Sherlock Holmes I'd have believed that he made the mistake of assumption rather than deduction. A younger Sherlock Holmes might would've got carried away in his bid to impress through his power of deductions. However, by this age Sherlock Holmes wouldn't do such a mistake unless..it's intentional. I like to believe that Sherlock just got a bit jealous of her and simply didn't want both of them to have a good time together. That reveals his emotional connect with Dr. Watson as well as his emotional immaturity to deal with separation. Sherlock is actually afraid of losing people he loves and therefore deliberately never even accepts his love for Irene Adler.

[@voices5956]

Just want to say love Kelly Riely's character in Yellowstone ❤️

[@presidentpotato222]

Every roll i have ever seen her in ..she is just a smoldering mess .. in the best possible way .. she played a young detective in a British series ..and my god you think she is beautiful now ..look on IMDB ..for it ..

[@michaelw4861]

Can't wait for the third film. RDJ is so good in the role of Sherlock!

[@benmorgan8890]

Notice the attention to detail when his food is served. He clearly ordered before Watson or Mary even arrived, suggesting that he planned on them leaving in the first place.

[@bugmaster05]

Yep, when girls ask you if they are fat but you answered them honestly and truthfully.

[@fhfs]

She's expecting you to lie, You knew when she walked into that dressing room. So you're already wanting to hear that ominous question.

[@jaspreetdigpal2777]

This needs more likes

[@nicholasmolnar8312]

""Does this make me look fat?" "No, your fat makes you look fat."

[@roumyapratap7227]

Hehe

[@iBloby]

it broke my heart when he was alone at the table, didn't even wipe his face as if he thought that he deserved it

[@katymbeke8400]

I would gladly allow Sherlock to tell me about myself. 100%

[@bijudasfrancis3496]

She insisted and now she says that he insults her

[@sitcomchristian6886]

Well....I mean, didn't he? There's some question as to whether he was intentionally wrong or not. But there's being honest, and then there's being cruel. One wants to injure, the other doesn't.

[@lukecalumlyonwrath7723]

Truth is sometimes cruel, ain't it.

[@-_Haider_-]

Holmes told her indirectly and intentionally that she's a gold digger....by saying that she returned to England for better prospects like a Doctor.

[@krishkingdom8683]

thats called women's logic.cant handle the facts.

[@TheMasterNinjaRyu]

I love the way he starts digging into his tucker immediately after.

[@tennoshenaniganizer9234]

She did insist. She can only blame herself

[@roamer1389]

and yet they never do.

[@scottmatheson3346]

She can blame him for his deliberate dishonesty, and she should.

[@alinac5512]

It was wrong of sherlock to assume the worst of her but I would have been far more impressed if she just smiled and corrected him instead of throwing a drink in his face.

[@AnimeViewer181]

@@alinac5512 Yes it was but she started it. She has no right to complain.

[@taralang1776]

Holmes was being unfairly rude because he’s possessive of Watson and manipulates him many times throughout the movie in an effort to convince Watson to stay.

[@tomk4t]

Mary: *Throws wine in face* Holmes: _First distract target_ _Discombobulate_ _Weaken Right Jaw_ _Now Fracture_

[@TheHardik112]

I like how Watson chugs wine 🍷Before Holmes about to start.

[@podsmpsg1]

She insisted, so she's not exactly blameless or innocent here. Granted, he went a tad too far, but she started it. Think about it, she's a widow in her 30s and works as a Nanny, Watson is a wealthy Doctor in his 40s. Didn't take a genius or expert to figure out she was a gold digger. He saved Watson from making a big mistake.

[@motokoyubari2158]

Asks to do something and then overreacts. Ladies haven't changed lot since

[@duende29]

He suggested she was a golddigger.

[@TchaikovskyFDR]

"Ladies haven't changed lot since" Holmes: *Proceeds to let his emotions cloud him*

[@RikkiTikkiTavi290]

She asked for it, and they both recommended she not. If you can't handle the heat, get out of the rocket propulsion test chamber.

[@bramakumbara1185]

Yokai wow wow easy there

[@luqas99]

Brama Okay, maybe a bit harsh. But the original comment was pretty dumb.

[@theoz-zone7470]

Robert Downey Jr. absolutely nails this role.

[@trevorcook8374]

You remember we discussed this ..The lady insists Watson: *UGH*

[@SentinelGhost]

I love these movies so much. The cast is great on all counts. But what shocks me the most is when I see Kelly Reilly go from this to the charter that is Beth Dutton

[@aidanjanemcintosh6919]

No matter a scientist or a wizard, a sherlock will always be annoying-- in a possitive way~

[@lampham5525]

Love how his mind is completely frozen for 20 second before he regained conscinouness and tried to figure out what just happened.

[@alexandermathieson4774]

the perfect example of " don't ask a question that you don't want to know the answer too" and after all, she did insist.

[@multifandomperson8703]

Honestly whats her problem? She wanted him to tell her

[@ivy-queenofworms]

Anna Schmitt she was insulted that he assumed the worst of her just because of a few clues. He didn't have the full picture yet painted her as a gold digger with no heart in his approximation of her when the truth was actually quite the opposite. Everything Holmes was doing in this scene was purposed to sabotage the relationship, intentional or not. Mentioning John's gambling and love of action insinuating he'd be poor at settling down and wouldn't be as wealthy as she'd like (since Holmes assumed she was after his money). Holmes' guess work showed that he had no intention of approving of her and, despite knowing little about her, already had a prejudice towards her just because she was in a relationship with his only real friend. Holmes was afraid of being alone again just as he ended up in this scene, with no one to blame but himself.

[@arjentromp12]

this is what happens when "it registers on an emotional level" sherlock lets emotions cloud his judgement leading to loads of assumptions that are wrong.

[@dewanmdurnto3592]

@@ivy-queenofworms great my man

[@alemedina4243]

@@ivy-queenofworms my hero

[@userone7603]

Well this wouldn't happen if Sherlock Holmes was here

[@kanatk5772]

*Sherlock Holmes* anticipated that moment and even calculated time of the end of their conversation. Therefore, he got his roast beef/ stake right after they gone. A perfectly played chess round :-)

[@DrianTheGuy]

"I see everything, that is my curse"

[@cinephile9885]

1:56 is how women usually greet me.

[@jayh6382]

I feel sorry for you, unless you're a A-hole, then i do not.

[@cinephile9885]

Jay H, I am not. I'm very timid.

[@ShiningCatProductions]

Held a door open for a girl, didn't even get a blowjob. So sick of being friend zoned. *tips fedora*

[@st-ko5zo]

His lonliness is so obvious at the end, love this portrayal of Holmes...wish him back on screen asap❤❤

[@MMerajHossain]

Girls: What Can You Tell About Me? *When I start Telling* *Gets angry*

[@marionarda2790]

Do you make incorrect assumptions too

[@ruifcarneiro]

And now we see Kelly Reilly ( Mary) outsmart everyone in "Yellowstone". The role of a lifetime, I might add.

[@-_Haider_-]

Sherlock: "Take Watson" Mary: "I intend to" Sherlock: 😀 😐 😑

[@MrKase420]

Mary: *Throws wine in Sherlocks face. Sherlock: *Discombobulate...

[@PBurns-ng3gw]

This mustn't register on an emotional level. Anticipate Mary's intent to hurl contents of wine glass at face. Grab Watson by lapels and pull him in between myself and flying liquid. Watson takes full brunt of '63 Bordeaux Cabernet Sauvignon, becoming enraged and turning to face me. Turn to face Watson. Discombobulate. Staggered, he'll lash out with wild haymaker. Deflect with forearm strike, follow with left hook to jawline. Discombobulate again, for good measure. Mary screams, nearby diners flee. In summary, attacker neutralized, dining room in chaos, Watson unconscious on floor with shirtfront soaked in red wine. Check on Watson. He stirs. Discombobulate.

[@mathblaster1897]

This was a great scene

[@charlesvanderhoog7056]

When I was 41, I learned the hard way that when a woman asks you to tell her something about her, you should proffer nothing but nice compliments for that is what she wants to hear. No woman ever wants to hear the truth about her.

[@akhilnair1137]

He wasn't telling the truth though. He deliberately chose the worst case scenario based on whatever observation he made.

[@xMohJeex]

It took you 41 years to learn that?

[@redrevanantarcdemon441]

That would be emotional damage for Mary Morsten after she insisted Sherlock's deduction skills.

[@grimm6176]

there's a difference between deductions and assumptions. my nanna was watching this with me (she loves sherlock holmes) and she's an actual psychologist. i told her (i'm translating and it was a while ago so excuse me if the english isn't right), "i thought sherlock holmes was clever" and she says, "yes, but he wasn't being clever, he was being a know-it-all." i, of course, was confused and she explained it like this: "deduction" is using what you have and finding the formula to solve the question. what holmes does is he has the equivalent of a sum in front of him and has to figure out the order in which to deduct which then can help him solve for the solution. there is always a margin of error but he has become so good at deducing his "sums" that he knows what an error looks like. what he was doing in this scene is very deliberate by the way he ignores the margin of error and goes the more human route - assuming. he doesn't have a formula, just the sum and just tries to answer it based on what he sees and knows rather than what he can figure out by creating a formula. i know this is random, but this is what i always think of when watching sherlock and i thought someone else might find it to be an interesting perspective!

[@diegofkda199]

Thanks for sharing that. Very interesting perspective.

[@llody7777]

Most interesting indeed.

[@grimm6176]

you guys are so nice, i'm glad you found it interesting! sorry if i get anything wrong or it sounds funny, i am not native English.

[@gopalram9400]

"And I am Iron.. uff Sherlock Holmes"🔥

[@sebastianfitzptraick7395]

RDJ was a brilliant Holmes.

[@muneebnajam6020]

The lady : I insist Holmes : so you have chosen death .

[@TragedysHalo]

Love the ending Lmao He knows that, at the end of the day, she did ask him.. & he's only human lol

[@DevMeloy]

This is amazing writing an amazing acting, it explains the whole situation of the movie. Sherlock Holmes is afflate of losing his friend and she's showing him that she's actually in charge, explains that Sherlock has no control over how he feels everything at every moment of every time and that Watson is his only escape from that hell.

[@madpanger7257]

I feel like he made a mistake. He looked sad at the end.

[@vikkipakki]

Lady: “I insist” Sherlock: “omaewa moe shindeiru” Watson: “Nani!?”

[@amarudawant6522]

I INSIST Sherlock Holmes 3.

[@limerence8365]

Yes, she insisted, but she didn't expect his speculations to go as far as saying she only agreed to marry her dead fiance because he was rich

[@lmaoiwaslikelmao1132]

Robert Downey Jr. is meant for this role. Cumberbatch's version can't ever compare to this version

[@presidentpotato222]

I find this actress to be just so enchanting .. i every role she has ever played

[@sudiptochakma3351]

The last scene The legendary actor

[@ZEUS-xt3dt]

One of the best actors out there

[@kangleinganba_official]

Phenomenal acting. Expected from Downey Jr.

[@iamitchoudhary]

"I didn't leave, he died." "Who?" Potts: "Tony."

[@Dogquack]

Holmes : take watson Mary: I intend to Holmes : uh heh...... I kind of empathize with Holmes... my best best mate since high school is getting engaged and i'm still single and an underachiever, I'm meeting them next sunday and to be honest i really dont want to, but he "insists" that i meet her :/

[@sadmanzaid420]

RIP

[@justins8634]

Maybe I'm reading into it too deep but when Holmes says "Take Watson" and Mary responds with "I intend to", his initial reaction at the witty response was a chuckle and a smile, but it quickly faded. To me, that shows how Sherlock actually approves of Mary but doesn't want to admit it, still intending to sabotage her relationship with Watson.

[@oumaima353]

... I've just realised this is Caroline from the movie Pride and prejudice...

[@lazyboy293]

Sometimes your greatest gift is also your greatest curse.

[@creamypotato8737]

Sherlock Holmes, expert detective: " I can deduce by this boxing ticket in his pocket that he went to a boxing match. Aha my genius knows no bounds!"

[@ConnorLonergan]

No, he deduced that he was a gambler from the ticket

[@srwllamray2359]

Damn, that boy spittin, he's good...

[@grahamyodude]

Right on all counts apart from one... you questioning my loyalty to my husband *splashes drink in face*

[@piglet2548]

I have watched all the series and movies ever made about Sherlock Holmes.