Shields! - Top 5 Pros & Cons

Sword 'n board, the old classic in Dungeons & Dragons, other fantasy RPG's, historical games / movies, LARP, SCA fighting, etc. Why would you ever not use a shield or buckler? Well, it's great but no perfect...
So here are five advantages with a corresponding disadvantage each, based on martial arts techniques from medieval and renaissance manuscripts. Nothing good ever comes with zero strings attached, right? :)
Support the channel, get bonus content and other rewards:
/ skallagrim
www.subscribestar.com/skallagrim
/ @skallagrim
For one-time donations:
streamlabs.com/skallagrim1
www.paypal.me/SkallagrimYT
Books about history and/or martial arts, swords, knives, video/audio equipment, and other stuff I recommend:
US - amzn.to/2jAc0MB
Canada - amzn.to/2l7GHcr
Kult of Athena, my favorite online store for reproductions of historical arms and armor, fantasy swords, etc:
ww4.aitsafe.com/go.htm?go=kult...
Where to get HEMA gear and practice swords:
www.woodenswords.com/?Click=1799
Get in contact or see a list of my video uploads:
/ skallagrimyt
/ _skallagrim_
Channel-related shirts and other merch:
skallagrim.spreadshirt.com/
teespring.com/stores/skallagrim
My side channel (for rambles, vlogs, opinions, gaming, etc):
/ @skallhalla
Knives on Gearbest:
www.gearbest.com/knives-tools...
Intro song:
"Illuminate" by Vindsvept
vindsvept.bandcamp.com/track/...
Outro:
"Highland Storm" by The Slanted Room Records
theslantedroom.weebly.com/

[@blebscra5976]

I'm not seeing anyone else talk about it, but the camera angles in this room are ace. with the angles you picked you can really SEE what your talking about. This felt fresh and awesome and a lot like what I wanted to see from this channel

[@adam-bf8li]

Yeah, it's really awesome. We can see almost the whole thing fron that angle.

[@davidlewis2171]

I totally agree. This was my first time watching anything from this channel, and it was really great to get the different views. I also thought it was a great idea to put the camera mounted to the dummy's head.

[@RandyLeftHandy]

The beautiful hardwood floors help the lighting tremendously.

[@GonzoTehGreat]

Thank you for putting into words what some of us have noticed but not yet commented about - specifically, Skall's creative camera work and use of props when demoing. I've noticed his demos have grown particularly innovative over the last few years. It's a shame he hasn't been invited to show them in TV documentaries and such.

[@mohammedmenri2713]

Agreed. This guy is one of the best when it comes to demoing this kind of stuff. He is thorough and he takes camera angles and lighting seriously, and is also pretty objective, logical and thorough in how he does things. Sure he doesn't cover everything in exhaustive detail but that would take way longer and could get tedious. He is well detailed but not boring. Very nice

[@Leubast]

Skall: "Let's talk about shields." Me: "Let's talk about that house!"

[@Epicmonk117]

NekoVeil It’s his new house

[@irgendwer3610]

@@Epicmonk117 now its mine

[@mastathrash5609]

I cant be the only one to admire that nice hardwood floor.

[@lotoreo]

OMG can we talk about his dope ass outfit tho?

[@exlibrisas]

Those high walls and white rendering somewhat looks like renaissance estate or something.

[@EnigmaticPenguin]

I predict that hanging lamp in the top left corner of frame isn't going to live long with the amount of swordplay this new house will get.

[@Alpha.Phenix]

As someone with a hanging lamp, literally everywhere in my apartment (safe for the bathroom), I second this.

[@ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz]

Just wait until for some reason it isnt in the video anymore ;)

[@koloth5139]

Doesn't even have to be sword play. Hanging lamps are a threat to simple daily activity. I have literally punched out a bulb putting on a shirt a bit too fast.

[@mastathrash5609]

Long as that nice hardwood doesn't get dinged. The lamp may have to give its existence for the sake of the vids.

[@raymondpjoyce]

@@mastathrash5609 glad someone else appreciates that lovely floor

[@arthurlueck5709]

Camera work on this kicks ass. I loved both the dummy go pro and the over the shoulder view.

[@mastathrash5609]

Love the 1st (and third) person vs Skall thing he did there.

[@Haegar2o2]

I concur, great professional camera work! Well presented! Did you have the Hermione moment? ;-) getyarn.io/yarn-clip/f354a05e-934e-42ad-bc1a-a2f971fed6aa#r1UxidPKcwH.copy

[@aaronburnett2261]

Totally agree! Great camera work! Excellent!

[@danielalexander8402]

*insert annoyingly overwhelming praise* But seriously though, Skal looked so happy in this video and that made it even more awesome. It's good to see.

[@lentulus01]

The double camera angle is VERY helpful in understanding the maneuvers.

[@flodgey]

Wow, you finally have room to move around and swing your sword as you please for your videos!

[@l.ijspeert9040]

So much room for activities!

[@Morbak546]

Skall: hold my dane axe

[@cadehileman7640]

I cried when you ran with the two shields, like a total goof, but I love the new camera angle very nice

[@Mysticfox-wk2be]

Did it catch you... *puts on sunglasses* off guard?

[@callummackay4282]

Good old ‘Board & Board’

[@youtoob4life]

It made me laugh a lot more than it should have. Gotta love Skall

[@dbKneecapped]

It's called dual shielding.

[@grandarkfang_1482]

@@Mysticfox-wk2be *_YEAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!!_*

[@DrunkenCoward1]

“Armour implies a state of mind in which one acknowledges the possibility of being hit.“ - Cracknut Whirrun Same goes for shields, I reckon.

[@nevisysbryd7450]

A standalone sword implies that possibility just as much. A shield or armor implies a significantly higher likelihood.

[@handsomebrick]

To paraphrase Miyamoto Musashi: trying to avoid your opponent is for losers, what you should do is make your opponent unable to avoid you.

[@Teach59]

That house is a serious upgrade in every respect and a well deserved reward for you both :-) It's already made your videos burst into life with the extra camera angles :-)

[@RandyLeftHandy]

That hardwood floor is gorgeous.

[@PrimordialNightmare]

big pro: You can paint something on the shield to say: "It me!"

[@falscher2]

Family tree of opponent. And you are always, at mother, sisters and daughter marked as "affair/lover"

[@PrimordialNightmare]

@@falscher2 That's awesome! though it could be difficult to see what's going on from afar.

[@flannagan3799]

Nice house. I can’t wait until it’s fully decorated.

[@NotSoProishNoob]

With cuts and scratches.

[@reptiloidmitglied2930]

Can't wait to see what they've planed for helloween.

[@DerNomade1871]

Im seriously liking that padded tunic you have i have to ask, where did you aqquire such attire

[@zechariahrogers1199]

I believe that's the Asian Gambeson from Armstreet.

[@danogh2227]

I'd rock this thing on tha streets

[@DerNomade1871]

@@agoodboy2489 get the upper torso plate and the pauldrons, could be able to make the nilfgaardian version of the redanian halberdier's armor from the witcher

[@hawkticus_history_corner]

@@zechariahrogers1199 You would be correct sir. I have one and its very nice...except for the fact that the bottom two clasps were sewn on poorly and they fell off after about 15 hours or so of wear. Its great, but watch out for that, cuz Armstreet won't fix it.

[@wergar_the_warwolf6834]

@@hawkticus_history_corner Super/gorilla glue em?

[@bobsquaredme]

Just started the video and I can already see you're taking full advantage of all that new space. Love the camerawork

[@warped_rider]

Bat-On-A-String: +50 Aesthetic

[@alextrill5829]

Until Skall accidentally hits it with a sword.

[@mythguard6865]

Skall just wanted to swing swords around with a decent ceiling

[@camrendavis6650]

Love this room you are in. Plenty of space for practicing solo drills

[@bretalvarez3097]

Biggest con is the fact that it makes unscrewing your pommel harder

[@mennograafmans1595]

Why do you think strapped shields were invented?

[@gentleshark972]

But you can yeet your shield at your foes. I learned that from captain America!

[@Noob4745]

@@mennograafmans1595 what if you have some pommels attach to the shield, ready to throw

[@immortalsnail-xd7zv]

JUST THROW THE SWORD

[@gentleshark972]

@@immortalsnail-xd7zv you, my man, are ingenious

[@Neiot]

Whoaa!! Look at all that space for activities!

[@kattriella1331]

Skall: *runs at camera flailing two shields* Me: Ah, yes, there's the quality content I subscribed for.

[@cylith5627]

Absolutely love the space you have now. Especially multiple views for cameras. Your thermostat had me thinking my screen was dirty though lol

[@immortalsnail-xd7zv]

Absolutely no one: Captain America: 0:04

[@alextrill5829]

Two shields can actually be very effective. Consider this documentary kzbin.info/www/bejne/bXPKh3uXj91liZo

[@700killerkid]

@@alextrill5829 that was the second best video I've seen all day. Thank you for the laugh

[@immortalsnail-xd7zv]

@@alextrill5829 Holy crap that is some next level combat

[@xiii0722]

@@alextrill5829 made my day, needs more likes XD

[@dante_f4563]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4TYen96d95md5o says it all in the first 30 ish seconds

[@seanmiz6539]

Love the background. It’s got that “I just moved in” feeling

[@ambuknight1567]

0:05 the most amazing way to start a video that talks about Sheilds hahah.

[@thegreatlemmon7487]

holy crap skall the quality is so much more open, a nice room, dont have to worry about people or time, its cozy, its a more controlled space, this move greatly improves quality, i love it,

[@tobiasebastiantempella9792]

Wait, a video from Metatron and one from Skallagrim in the same moment? That's not bad at all

[@grotty9850]

All this new space has honestly breathed new life into your videos. This has to be one of my favourite videos from you

[@AL4RC0NR4MO5]

2:00 That mannequin just activated its Stand.

[@ColArana]

What!? An enemy Stand!?

[@boiman851]

ZA HOOMAAAN WIF SOORDOOO!!!

[@redfist2988]

You thought it was the mannequin, but it was me, Dio!

[@RyzawaVT]

Oh my goodness, awesome how you finally have a proper space to record and no pesky sound complaints to deal with.

[@dolphinboi-playmonsterranc9668]

0:00 I really liked the third clip. It looked like a devastating blow how it shook the camera. Thrusts are just the coolest.

[@griffian4454]

Glad to see you have space to move around in! I love the dummy GoPro setup so you can strike at the camera lmao

[@PinkieImpaled]

Skall going crazy with all the space to move around 😆

[@adriancontreras7523]

0:04 Lmao, this is why I love this channel to pieces

[@pjmeis5226]

Yaaaaay!!!!!!! New studio!! Much hype. Also, dual wielding tower shields is obviously the best loadout.

[@martijnvanweele6204]

The overhead view is such a great and elegant way of showing how you are getting your footage. It really helps the flow of the video that you don't have to explain that you're not threatening your camera operator.

[@DontKeeptheFaith]

Wow, that hardwood floor is top notch. I bet you're loving the new house.

[@Zorafin]

This is one of my favorite videos you've put out in a while. Informative and easy to digest, with lots of visual aid to get across points and keep the video interesting. You should put out more like these, showing the strengths and weaknesses of other commonly seen weapons and war implements.

[@viriatrix9874]

You can tell Mr. Skall is having fun with so much space lol

[@ChadKakashi]

Your camera setting is outrageous. Also loved the intro bit. Great video.

[@ninjahombrepalito1721]

0:07 game start 0:11 select mode 0:15 select character . XD

[@francescogulisano2917]

Nice video and all, but I was too distracted by how cool your new house is! Especially the hanging bat was too charming to ignore

[@ruzl108]

skall: "it obstructs movement" also skall: **shows how to have more movement with a shield**

[@Skallagrim]

There are ways to work around it, but a manageable obstruction is still an obstruction. :)

[@mrwindupbird101]

And even if you're an expert an equally trained individual will know about that shortcoming and would punish you for attempting it. Just because you can doesn't mean you should

[@spairus4492]

You look so... relieved in this video! You can even see it on the thumbnail. It has brought me back to your channel by itself (not to mention all the other stuff that also other people point out). I'm so happy for you, way to go!

[@doctorlolchicken7478]

This is definitely one of your best videos ever, just because of the camera angles. Takes everything up a few notches. That getup kicks ass too.

[@amp7778]

This intro perfectly represents the channel

[@Colonel_Klink]

Hahahaha! "No, how bout you don't?!" *stabs them in the face *

[@taintedmyth0s636]

That was my favorite part of the video too. He definitely has some of the same energy he used to have years ago and that slightly snarky humor :)

[@davewilson13]

Your videos are amazing, they were never "lower quality", but now they're just amazing.

[@themangix357]

Cheers for Skall, long hair + gambeson + round shield makes him look like a viking.

[@schonnj]

New place looks nice! Good points about shield use. Question tho: how much of a liability is a shield if the opponent grabs it? to both the shield user and the attacker?

[@DH-xw6jp]

Get a lightning shield. +5 to grapple resistance.

[@witherrose1566]

If I remember historically, during one battle of Caeser and the Germans, his men got so tired of the German's blocking everything that they pulled the shields out of their hands

[@yowza234]

Skallagrim fencing with an imaginary Erik Bailey, Nova Scotia - circa 2019 (colourised)

[@jklm011]

1st video in the new house, Awesome! You can already tell the difference and that shows how important this change is for skall's content. This must have been a real hard decision to make for him but boy does it feel worth it right now.

[@davidscott4919]

Love you new setup, Skalla. The 1PV is neat and really gives a good sense of your strikes, stances, and all.

[@shryggur]

6 +: You can gnaw it fiercely. It's intimidating and good for your image. -: Probably your teeth will go blue.

[@Toporshik]

I recall that there is a story of one LARP player using a crippled shield and a lot of bread to make a shield he could chew the pieces off before the battle. I hear it was really demoralising.

[@hans10yearsago6]

2:00 Haha he’s swinging sword at limbless mannequin like a dumb idi-

[@Sultaanash]

Must be the work of the mannequin stand

[@crodthesorrysap4165]

@@Sultaanash I see what you did there

[@Lira_man]

The quality of theses videos has skyrocketed! I love the new place and the space and angles!

[@cynicalpsycho5574]

This was amazing Skal really glad to see you have more space, all the best mate.

[@jarrodong4430]

Damn he is flexing his house nice oneeee

[@Barwasser]

6:57 *KNEEEEEEES!* - PewDiePie 2019

[@mandolore19]

Loving the gambeson and added camera angles. By far one of your best, Skall! Congrats on the move.

[@LeonM4c]

LOVE the new camera angles, very intuitive, I'm excited for the future of your videos and channel!!! Good time have you back.

[@VeganGains]

Congratulations on the new house. Not related to the video but how's the internet in Novas Scotia? I'm thinking of moving there but I need gigabit internet.

[@speedstriker]

"Would you like to walk around the street with this on your side or back?" How else am I going to fend off rabid grocery shoppers?

[@vincedunn9983]

Lol. Depends on where you live!!! Some places you actually NEED it on a daily basis!!!

[@speedstriker]

@@vincedunn9983 London?

[@vincedunn9983]

@@speedstriker yeah, there n many places in other countries as well!!!

[@geass765]

I just love the setup. That's a pretty nice upside that many other channel doesn't have. Pretty happy to see you back :D

[@simondahlberg7394]

Congratulations to the new house Sir Skallagrim, it’s so much better and enjoyable to se you be able to move and maneuver properly, the different angles bring a lot to it. Hope you find it as good as you thought in your vlog about it, good luck settling in and hope you’ll be able to keep das gud stuff coming

[@wyver5615]

Have you seen the mantis blades from cyberpunk? I would love to hear your thoughts and opinions about them!

[@dolphinboi-playmonsterranc9668]

Have you seen those warriors from Hammerfell? They have curved swords. _Curved swords._

[@thegreatlemmon7487]

xD i mean i would be confused as hell if some guy wanted to fight me with two shelds, so thats a pro in my book

[@Ranstone]

We still remember your deeds from past videos. All hail the great lemon.

[@fore5tr]

I love the new camera angle ! And all the space you do have now help a lot and makes your videos even better in my opinion!!

[@mattiabentivogli8144]

The quality of your video is just astonishing, and they are so informative! Thank you, Skall

[@Skallagrim]

Thanks, and glad you enjoyed it.

[@lyxar777]

Skal: Talks about acheological evidence showing frequent injuries to the legs Me: Pewdiepie was alive in the middleages?

[@memedaddy6189]

*KNEES*

[@benjaminthibieroz4155]

An excellent summary as usual. Thanks Skal. I'm glad to see you in fine shape at home. It's lovely. I wish you well for what's left of unpacking.

[@VIITHRONE]

Amazing Skall ! Love the new place. Very happy to see all went well with the move and set up. Seeing you in all that space, camera work, and doing what you want inside your own home without all the precious limitations is a delight to see. Stay positive and don’t give up on your hard work and dedication fellow swordsman. Wish you well, and thank you for all that you do ✊

[@biffures]

It was a good video Skal! I felt compelled to watch it until the end. It was informative, you looked super happy explaining the manoeuvres, the camera angles were perfect

[@2Cats_ina_Trenchcoat]

Glad your back. Congrats on the new place!

[@Adrian_Lee6113]

You have outdone yourself with this video, Skal, love the new place and I can tell you do too! Keep it up!

[@rhaege3957]

Great 3 camera footage about the clearest explanations this channel has ever given great work.

[@camilomiranda61]

I haven't watched a ton of your videos lately but the way this one was filmed is awesome. I cant explain why I feel this way but it seems so much more engaged then your other videos

[@DjalmaThuran]

Congrats for your new home Skall, it really boosted up the quality of the class you gave with more angles for the camera, and sneak Kara was quite nice too haha, I didn't noticed her until she parried. Very nice video, I hope you keep your good work, it's very pleasing and informative what you do, thank you for that, cheers from Brazil !

[@r.matthews594]

I agree with some of the other comments, the camera work in this one was great. I also can't help but see how happy you hare to be in the new house. Congratulations.

[@HazardEDM]

These videos about the practical aspects of hema are great. Keep them coming.

[@serpenttao]

This was a great video, it was informative, you had the space to show the moves you're talking about, and the double camera angle works insanely well to illustrate stuff. You look like you're having fun with it yourself, too. House is not just a personal upgrade but you're really making the best of it for your production as well. I know I'm a month late, but wonderful work Skall, keep it up!

[@senor.molina]

wow THIS IS QUALITY, looking forward for your next content in this new location!

[@Neptune0404]

I love the new camera format. It brings a lot of life to the videos and really adds to it. The educational part is as superb as ever, so, yeah. Good job

[@DRINKIWHISKY]

The new place is nice and the new style of video is incredible with the high behind the back pov and the dummy pov used like this. Awesome job Skall and i’m sure you’ll make even better as you get used to the new place even of this is a great start with this quality in the production. Molto Bravo!

[@TheriaultDave]

Duuuuude now this camera work is brilliant. The extra room and different perspectives are very effective. Well done Skall :)

[@Dir_Grobbman]

love the new place as well as the new camera angles. keep up the good work man.

[@adancein]

I really enjoy the clearly visible newfound freedom you have with the new house. I'd love some kind of house tour, as soon as/if you were ever comfortable with it.

[@Zuccus]

So much space in the new place! I'm excited for new videos going forward!

[@shaneorrison956]

This is one of your best videos yet. Maybe THE best. I'd love more of this style!

[@stevengager3501]

Very nice set and camera set up, great visual demonstration with her asistiance as well. I hope the move went well and that you both are loving your new place and the area. Best of wishes to you!

[@ericpetersen230]

Love the new place, so glad you have enough space to do demos indoors.

[@codybates2419]

Big fan of the new place and the new camera angles you can utilize. Awesome video

[@gawayne1374]

Okay, the intro deserves a like regardless of the rest of the content. Edit: I have watched the rest now, I love how this is filmed. Fantastic content Skall!

[@alicaido6616]

man it's so nice to see all that space for you to move - and that smile on your dial! :D looks like the new place is a success (also the new camera angles are great for understanding the movements)

[@FrostySumo]

Loving the new setup. Great idea as it makes these videos much more imersive.

[@wilowhisp]

Great vid. I really liked all the room you get and the camera angles in the new place.

[@hellopartypeps]

Really enjoy your content as always. Informative and such a soothing voice. Keep it up!

[@errantweeb2234]

Very nice video, Skall! I especially like the camera angles the new place lets you pull off.

[@ML1800]

Haven't seen ya in a while, but I love the new camera work, this helps me out way better in my own practice! Keep up the awesome work!

[@CAepicreviews]

I love the angles you used for this I had no idea this was so old, I thought it was newer. Great vid.

[@mattfick5502]

Great video Skall. As always, it's informative and entertaining in equal measure. And the new place is beautiful, and the camera work was awesome