Shinedown "Simple Man" REACTION & ANALYSIS by Vocal Coach / Opera Singer

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

We just released merchandise! Check out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com

[@krzysztofmedyna3661]

Just so you are aware, I find it so cute as to the way your eyes work in terms of expressing your curiosity and excitement to explore new music. FULLY WARMS MY HEART. One of the reasons you are one my favorites to enjoy reaction videos from. Thank you so much!

[@sgtpopo_5o_pig262]

Please check out the Acoustic version of this song from the album, now that you have heard this one. To me it's better because it doesn't feel rushed like this version! I know you'll love it too! Enjoy!

[@CrippledMerc]

You should really check out Ozzy Osbourne and Lita Ford - Close My Eyes Forever /foGkU6x3eSE 💚

[@Snowkobbie]

I would like to hear your reactions to these two performances: XOV - "Lucifer" : kzbin.info/www/bejne/g2jFhoqrn5V4j6c LÉON - "Come Home To Me" (Live From The Village) : kzbin.info/www/bejne/gXrMZ5StnZVoe9k

[@hdndndhdbddn9081]

А можно вашу реакцию хотя бы с субтитрами, если нет перевода на русский? Спасибо!

[@IvIidnight]

Not too many adults have the ability to tap into the child-like joy that great singing brings you. It's fun to watch.

[@ninjareynolds]

I'd say enjoying great singing isn't childlike joy when it comes to a song like Simple Man which is sung the way it is here. Its more of a release emotionally. This song can make a hardened middle aged man break down in tears if trying to sing it in a way that expresses the emotional aspect of it (with help of bourbon at least). It is one thing to hear it (anyone in the last 60 years from the southeastern U.S. that listens to rock radio has heard it hundreds of times) and something else to sing it with emotion. I think Elizabeth understands that. Although there are times when she expresses giddiness about the recording in her analysis I think Elizabeth makes it clear by her reaction while listening that this recording elicits an emotional response of lament that only adults generally know.

[@randyjon224]

@@ninjareynoldshere here, very well said right there.

[@nikuhotzel2677]

@@ninjareynolds i don't think the person commenting about "childlike joy" meant it in the way you interpreted it.

[@gerrynavarro8283]

muthafucken ditto

[@IvIidnight]

@ninjareynolds Ever seen the movie Knocked Up? When they are talking at Paul's "daughter's" birthday and he says "I wish I loved ANYTHING as much as kids love bubbles."? It is unfortunate, but in my experience true, that most adults don't LET themselves feel the pure, blissful joy that kids feel because they/we are too jaded by growing up and the responsibilities and insecurities that come with it. I was just commenting on the fact that Elizabeth seems to be one of the lucky few that know how to set that aside, truly let herself into the moment, and enjoy the release that the music is giving her instead of having that inner monologue hiding somewhere in the back mumbling about things that most children don't even know exist yet.

[@kurokubushi]

When she talked in the beginning about his pent up energy and wanting to see him expel it, and then seeing how giddy she was getting in the start of the song I was like "Oh...she's not ready" lol

[@logannienke2846]

Same😂😂

[@t.s.glasco7838]

My exact thoughts 😂

[@elysecoil3588]

Yessss!

[@youtubeconnollyfamily]

😂 so true

[@akarminius]

Haha, I instantly scrolled for this exact kind of comment

[@ashleighlalonde6394]

Fun fact, Shinedown closes every concert with this song. The amount of energy you get with this song with an entire audience singing along with the band is electric. I believe its captured in one of their live albums.

[@rahkwalarc-5281]

I have wanted to see shinedown live for about 7 years now, and this just makes me want to see them even more. Looking at tour dates now.

[@darkrealmrider]

I would love to see you critique. Little River bands song, it's a long way there. I would love to sing with that. I really enjoyed singing simple man I love working with you. Your demeanor is astounding

[@TheAFDevil]

Pent-up geyser is a great analogy. Saw them two nights ago for the third time. Brent doesn’t even need a mic to fill an auditorium. Hands down one of the most incredible voices in music today.

[@TheSupernaturalWolf41]

Of any day. Robert Plant, Steven Tyler, Axle Rose, Brent Smith. The voices of lifetimes.

[@x3wildcard]

Who else heard her say she's never heard Brent Smith and were like "Yeah, I'm about to watch a life be changed on camera."

[@zakuto731]

Yeah I was expecting something, her genuine response was cathartic.

[@rodneyowens4177]

I’ve always thought this cover was horrendous… not as bad as Disturbeds version of Sound of Silence… but close

[@sesh517]

@@rodneyowens4177 Nobody asked.

[@ThatGuy-vi8ch]

@@rodneyowens4177 Music is like food, not everyone gets it.

[@hyp1284]

@@rodneyowens4177 obvious troll is obvious

[@TheManslayerD]

There's just something so beautiful about watching someone who genuinely loves music react to it like she does..

[@bryanm5233]

Truth!

[@morganfitz7598]

Due to her reaction. I question how dry her seat is?

[@ttmusicchannel013]

@@morganfitz7598 Cmon. Have some respect.

[@12354rony]

@@morganfitz7598 Oh Morgan, you sweet summer child

[@aphaes1]

@@morganfitz7598 you have a gift of ruining moments.

[@ThaRealWorld]

For any Shinedown fan, when she heard 5 seconds of his voice & described it PERFECTLY.. THAT 🤌🏼

[@machielmarais]

Never has there been a better discription of Brent's voice. it was like an Ahah! moment. Just knowing how he will explode later in the song and how she picked up on it, within seconds, is just amazing

[@SteakSandwichFace]

Not only is this the greatest Simple Man cover of all-time, this particular version is one of the best covers of any song ever recorded, period. So good.

[@jdeal_ok]

It is pretty far up the list... But Johnny Cash's cover of hurt will probably be number one forever.

[@decypheryt3159]

No, lol. Just no.

[@lesterparker1594]

Disturbed sound of silence take the win for me. But this one is great. Above comment about Johnny cash is at the top too

[@himynameis3664]

​@@lesterparker1594 Agree with Disturbed. I also prefer Deftones version of this

[@ScalesOfaRam]

​@@jdeal_okJohnny cash, aside from the instruments, had one original part in that entire song. At that time, his voice and breath control were shot, too. I think the only reason that song is considered "good" is the story behind him and June. Johnnys personality, connection to the Carter family and ability to tell a story is what made him good. He was a terrible musician/singer.

[@mabatch3769]

This is one of the greatest covers ever recorded. You don’t have to like Shinedown, you don’t have to like the genre but there’s no denying this dude is an incredible singer. The way she described his voice in the beginning as a pent up geyser was spot on. I was thinking to myself just wait for it, girl. He lets it out.

[@matthewcadden1967]

Best cover ever made hands down

[@tristansigert9420]

They have a version in one of the guys living rooms. And he’s sitting on a couch singing it and I prefer that one for some reason. I love these guys.

[@69drguitar]

@@matthewcadden1967 While this is indeed awesome, for me, the best cover ever made is Disturbed's version of The Sound of Silence. Absolutely epic.

[@matthewcadden1967]

@@69drguitar nah I think this one out does that one by a little bit for sure but both are great

[@undefeatedgaul3201]

Absolutely. Beautiful. Also Johnny cash hurt, sound of silence disturbed, and Chris cornell nothing compares to you. Unreal.

[@samhainsluagh1685]

Find yourself someone who looks at you the same way she looks at shinedown singing 😍🤘🏻

[@Lorten1986]

She definitely looks twitter patted

[@ddyta2794]

@@Lorten1986 yyyup, lol. Makes me feel some sort of way.... 😂 could watch her react to songs all day 😍

[@thebobbyd]

Lol someone's sitting in a puddle😅😅😅 and we know who

[@seventallguitarist]

I was just thinking the same thing. Professional evaluation or not, to see the joy on her face as she hears great singing is almost as enjoyable as listening to it the first time yourself. Love her.

[@infinitesimotel]

I did. It turned out to be a frizzy haired walrus with terminal flatulence and a bit of an attitude. I'll keep searching.

[@God-ck5yo]

There is a little more of a connection to Skynyrd than just the Jacksonville one. Shinedowns original guitarist, Jasin Todd was married toMelody Van Zant, the daughter of the late, great Ronnie Van Zant, the singer from Skynyrd. Also, Shinedown got their first "big break" by regularly playing a local venue called Freebird Live. That venue was owned by Judy Van Zant, Melody's mother and Ronnie's widow. Shineown used to sing this song as a tribute to Ronnie and a thank you to Judy. Incidentally, in this video there is a little girl holding a picture of a man, the man in the picture is Ronnie Van Zant and the little girl is Ronnie's grand-daughter.

[@kimnoftle8620]

Adding to that back story, they did that cover once and never planned to do it again and then at a radio station they were asked to do a cover. They didn’t have any prepared so Barry said let’s do Simple Man. Brent wasn’t sure he’d remember the words. That performance went “viral” and they have been doing it ever since. Judy Van Zant let him live rent free for a year in an apartment so when they recorded this song he set it up so she’d get half the royalties to pay her back. This is from an interview with Brent.

[@jimpettit6310]

That is crazy

[@Eluna_moonstone]

All of this is just right in my feels, y’all. Thank you ❤️

[@craighenry2351]

I knew the connection between Melody and Jasin, I just didn’t know the got married. I guess I need to check updates on Wiki more!

[@trp2413]

Thank for writing this 😄😃😀😊

[@blackthorn357]

My mom was the most incredible singer that no one heard. She would only sing to me and my little brother. She used to sing this song to me when I was little and it always made me feel special. She passed away 14 years ago and I played the original at her funeral for my brother and I. When I hear this version, it always brings me to tears... But happy ones. It brings her back to me every time.

[@tonyfro23]

That is beautiful. Godspeed to your family and mother

[@DSmooth]

God bless my friend

[@greyk610]

Wish I had a mom like yours, mine has just torn me down my whole life.

[@alanmcmanis8324]

This was me and my mom’s first dance at my wedding but the original.

[@AA-pf9dh]

🙏

[@MarylandBornConstruction]

So many Shinedown tracks to enjoy: Second Chance, Save Me, Fly From The Inside, I Dare You, Burning Bright, & If You Only Knew.

[@gumielmgz]

Good list! I'd add What a Shame, Brent's definitely one of the best

[@crawleyman1117]

45 is a good one as well

[@kubabalcerski467]

Also Monsters

[@ericd1632]

@@crawleyman1117 45 is their best track in my opinion, but they have so many great songs

[@ericd1632]

Don't forget the Crow and the Butterfly

[@sin_pyro]

For a hard rock band, Shinedown has been one of the very few bands that have reduced me to tears. Brent has a rare gift for a singer where you feel every single emotion he feels while singing. It's just special

[@JDubz891]

My first intro to shinedown was a few years ago at a concert with Godsmack, Shinedown had tears in my eyes 3 times during their set, became an instant fan

[@rysbatcave6627]

Agreed

[@tylerlower5140]

45 gets me every time

[@christianjohns8352]

Another band that pulls the heart strings in the rock genre is "Nothing More", with songs like "Jenny", "Fade in/Fade out", and "God Went North"... it will have you in tears real quick.

[@TheGunner9545]

I think Brent has legendary pipes but ib think his song list is rather short and disappointing. They just don't have many hit songs and staying power. Ib think i know more songs by 3 Doors Down than Shinedown. If think he wasted most of his career with lousy songwriters.

[@karendoolin1294]

Played this for my son at his funeral. Forever 20. Forever loved and missed Andrew. 7/23/94-6/2/15. Nothing was ever the same💔

[@jonathanrex]

The song and your comment really got me. Even though my words only reach you anonymously, I am very sorry for your loss.

[@lindapellegrino1110]

May you find peace someday, so sorry for your loss.

[@karendoolin1294]

@@jonathanrex ♥️

[@karendoolin1294]

@@lindapellegrino1110 ♥️

[@stacybaldwin3346]

This one and free bird were played at my cousins funeral. Rest in peace Darby Sheldon.

[@brettneygibbs9047]

The "you can do this, oh baby, if you try" in the second verse gives me goosebumps every single time 😍😍

[@rektorik84]

the easiest lyric of all time .

[@robertomartinez8434]

I'm oldschool when i heard there was a remake of this song i hated it already. But when i heard this i was sure even ronnie was going DAMN. This is one of the most beautiful renditions of a classic I've ever heard. I stand corrected.

[@BaioWithMayo]

Very few times I listen to a cover and say "ah yes, this is one stands on its own"

[@MMGJ10]

I agree. I didn't even want to hear this version. Why would I when the original was brilliant?? But they did an awesome job. They're both brilliant versions of the song.

[@daydreamersdmmiller3064]

Smith and Myers cover of Phill Collins Something In The Air Tonight is also amazing.

[@SeanANolan]

I think it is better and I grew up on Skynard. The music is scary good as much as the vocals are. Listen to the original with eyes closed then this version.

[@DFWTF]

@@SeanANolan Think there from the same town ..I think

[@nightwolf2666]

I cry like a child every time I hear this song, it is basically what I try to teach my son every day as a single dad.

[@VictoriaKempPhotos]

Me too! It makes me think of my own grown sons. Especially my oldest.

[@greatwhitenorth762]

God bless all the wonderful single dads raising sons in our world today.

[@nightwolf2666]

@@greatwhitenorth762 Thank you for saying that. The world needs strong Dads. God bless.

[@bonesnekropolis6231]

stay strong you will make mistake but you will give your best every time ! make him proud of his dad

[@greatwhitenorth762]

@@nightwolf2666 You're very welcome sir. May God's blessings be upon you and your dear son. Much respect for you and the efforts you are making in raising him well.

[@Tonyvermette]

Was anyone sitting here listening to her in the first chorus going “It’s like overflowing with energy.” And snickering to yourself knowing that later on in the song he goes even bigger and you’re waiting for her to react to it… no? Just me, okay. 😂

[@BrottenGuy]

Naw. I did the same thing, only more of a “Oh my god!! STOP it!!! Just listen to it…you’ll get there!!! It’s even better, in a second!” She did it with Pantera’s “Cemetary Gates”, too.

[@Underoathgames]

Same

[@Co1eTrain84]

thought the same thing. Like, oh just you wait lol

[@danielwaggoner8467]

absolutely

[@ivytepes]

The constant stops before he really started had me yelling to STOP TALKING AND JUST LISTEN!! lol

[@tinman7065]

They took Skynyrd's best song and took it into another dimension. One of the best covers of classic rock ever (along with Disturbed's Sound of Silence and Metallica's Turn the Page).

[@Gunjack1440]

Turn the page wasn’t Metallica’sZ I believe seiger sang it before them.

[@ugh3381]

@@Gunjack1440that’s why he said “classic rock cover” lol

[@ernienegrete5702]

"Sound of Silence" is a Simon & Garfunkel song.​@@Gunjack1440

[@juanchavez8777]

I totally agree with you!! I love those 3 songs too!

[@gregpayne3770]

I feel that puddles pity party covered sound of silence very well also

[@n0xxm3rcyxx]

You should listen to his acoustic one where it's just him and the guitar in a friends living room. Its incredible. It's over 9 years ago but it's worth it. I go back and watch it all the time. My favorite rendition of it.

[@whiteasshonkey3534]

Same here. Shows that he isn't just a studio singer. Brent has one of the best voices in rock.

[@xifled63]

That performance is amazing. He’s just hanging in the living room

[@MarcoForesto]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/h5Dcc4d_oNyLpaM #TheCharismaticVoice!!

[@lorigarza8418]

That video is raw and just amazing! My favorite!

[@christianrashotte1605]

Is it a friends house? I always thought it was a fans house who won a private concert in a radio contest. Either way, I agree. It's my favorite version too.

[@d3adkamikaz3]

You passion and excitement for what the artists do with their vocals is so contagious.

[@luciferluci4570]

it really is!!!, learned a lot and enjoyed so much how much she enjoys this!

[@cloverraven]

Perfectly said

[@JamesSmith-fv6vb]

How can you not love Shinedown. Brent Smith's voice is unbelievable. He sounds just as good live. He is legit.

[@kimsylla5531]

I would love to see a video of Brent's reaction to HER reactions and have him see the pure joy and love she has for his voice. Now she knows how we feel. ❤

[@class5bodyworks]

That would be awesome!

[@melissagutierrez8137]

YES!!!

[@AlexBryant2598]

My brother tattoos on them and they've literally flown us out to shows so we could hangout while my brother worked on them. Literally grew up with these guys and they truly are amazing.

[@Oilcancap]

Until the autotune gives out... Saw them in Doornroosje in Nijmegen a couple years ago, was relatively dissapointed in the show and in the live performance...

[@jessicaqueer9473]

Saw them at Sturgis in 2015 and was not at all disappointed. Maybe an off night? Simple Man has been my favorite song since I was a child. First Skynryd and then Shinedown’s version. They opened for Skynryd and I got to see both bands sing it. I’m not a crier…. I sobbed like a teenage girl at a One Direction concert. Bucket list for sure. It was amazing.

[@Oilcancap]

@@jessicaqueer9473 could be, my buddy opened for them that night and once I got around to how the singing was live he told me the autotune on the board had died and Brent had to be on point. He wasn't. Still enjoy their album work though.

[@Voldrani]

I am also a tattoo artist. I do not have a famous, awesome band that flies me to shows. LoL. Career goals.

[@jessicaqueer9473]

@@Voldrani lol Also a tattoo artist… can we be issued a famous band to tattoo exclusively? My clients are amazing but they don’t fly me anywhere.

[@michaelscheunemann3425]

It was killing me when you kept backing up before the chorus. I just wanted you to hear it. Your reaction once you heard it was spectacular. Seeing them perform this song live is still one of the best performances I've ever witnessed. One of the greatest covers by one of the greatest voices in rock

[@Swollen_Goat]

Reaction edging at its finest XD

[@ItsHammer]

Welcome to the Brent Smith experience. His voice is on a complete different level than 99% of other rock vocalists.

[@CampingCats90]

The ways she gets giddy and fan girls over vocals just brings me so much joy. I love music so much and I notice these little pieces and when she brings knowledge to it just makes me learn to appreciate the sound even more

[@alexlicciardi13]

In high school, "Call Me" by Shinedown was a song me and friends randomly learned and would always sing together in the car. Very good song.

[@daltonevans3412]

I remember sitting in my tent the first night i was homeless when i was 16 and just listened to that song and what a shame as well and just cried when the realization of my situation kicked in, but the music helped calm me. Shinedown is something else and will always be a part of my life so long as i have ears to hear with.

[@gavinspalding]

He’s amazing live, close your eyes and you can’t tell if it’s studio or live. Was lucky to see them and Halestorm together

[@rysbatcave6627]

Yes!

[@chanceehuiet]

Seen the same duo. I try to watch every shinedown show within 4 hours of Houston

[@relentlessonespodcast1602]

I saw them in Houston too Carnival of Madness tour

[@Huhconduct]

I saw them and Halestorm but he was too messed to even sing, it was sad. Glad he got clean.

[@joshlansdown2810]

I watched Halestorm(who I met and hung with after the show) and Flyleaf open for Seether and Shinedown in 2005. Killer fucking show, he did this and dedicated it to Dimebag Darrell. Perfection.

[@Wanker527]

Once I saw them in Tulsa, OK and his grandmother had just died, so he got the whole crowd outside in the dark to look at the stars and chant her name while he belted out this song. People were crying all around. It was beautiful.

[@OrthodoxMidwife]

Wow. Amazing 😭

[@zombiiesque]

Oh, my. What a beautiful tribute. 🥺

[@jamesh2321]

I have just witnessed an eargasm in visual form. The pure joy and immersion you feel while watching the song. Brent wins another one. I went to see them live and it was amazing. The energy they can bring to the stage is like no other show. The girl I was seeing at the time reacted the same way. I am man enough to admit I got a little bit jealous. To that end, I tried to teach myself to do Shinedown songs to sing to her. The only one I think I truly *hit* right is 'If you only knew'. But I love this one too.

[@rscotta831]

Elizabeth, the way your eyes flutter... for us Shinedown fans of 18 years... it's like watching our 18-year old son getting married to the wife of his dreams.

[@trp2413]

35 👍 for you sir

[@lukeslayer]

129 👍 for you sir

[@X-Clipse97]

152 👍

[@evertopandus]

More shinedown songs: Second Chance, Through the Ghost, Crow and the butterfly, Enemies, amaryllis, and my personal favorite... 45. Also Shinedown with Lzzy Hale Breaking Inside

[@sgordon57xx]

YES, Crow and the Butterfly and Amaryllis show off his voice like crazy

[@brycebergstrom5035]

Shed some light?????

[@bloodsling]

Crow and the Butterfly is so brilliant,I love almost every Shinedown song I've heard,but that's my favourite.

[@Chaotic_Enigma]

You can't go wrong with any Shinedown song...What about Her name is Alice from Alice in Wonderland soundtrack? Great band for sure!

[@adamfisher9595]

@@brycebergstrom5035 I freaking love that song. Sooo underrated

[@tobicain7816]

brent is one of the best singers in rock right now, and his voice has just gotten better and better through the years. shinedowns acoustic show in kansas city is a prime example of how outstanding he's become

[@p.justinbruce2601]

We saw the Springfield stop of that same tour! Even though we listen to the KC show on the disc double set, it's a carbon copy of the SGF show, so it's like being there all over again!

[@beccapivonka1953]

We saw Smith & Myers in Omaha in May...holy heck. One of the best shows I have seen!

[@RELTIH88]

Imo Brent Smith, Adam Gontier and Corey Tayler are top 3# singers.

[@dewman1485]

Brent is easily in my opinion, one of the best voices in music. His range and control is next level. The man can belt

[@bakey42]

And it's not studio magic either. I saw them live years ago, before I really knew who Shinedown was, when they were opening for 3DoorsDown and they blew me away. Way better than the headliner IMO.

[@ericd1632]

Although "45" is my favorite Shinedown track, "I Dare You" and "The Crow & The Butterfly" are both incredible and not far behind 45, for me at least. Elizabeth I would love to see reaction videos of all 3, plus there are several other great songs.

[@ktsnironmangaming1217]

This is perfect. Best way to experience Shinedown in just a few songs.

[@Verias1983]

This is probably my favorite vid of 45 kzbin.info/www/bejne/qXK6mXVnlL-krK8&ab_channel=Dis2505

[@LawfulNugget]

Vitamin String Quartet do a cover of 45. Its amazing.

[@patg148]

Holy shit that must be amazing

[@emily.g.929]

Crow & The Butterfly is criminally underrated 😩😩😩

[@willl84]

Brent is such a powerhouse. He's so underrated I feel. They're popular but not nearly as popular as they should be. I can't wait for you to do more of them. They're also absolutely incredible in concert. The way he takes control of the crowd and nails song after song is amazing. The singer and guitarist also did an acoustic cover album called Smith and Meyers and it's so good

[@sgordon57xx]

Agreed. The dudes voice is phenomenal.

[@aparker7777]

I love Smith and Myers... it's just so freaking *pure*

[@JeremiahFrye]

I remember one time seeing them at an outdoor concert and he did this whole thing getting the crowd amped up. Like easily monologuing for 10 minutes. Came down into the crowd and everything. Not a lot of rock performers have crowd skill like that anymore. He even came right by my seat and even though security shooed me away I managed to get a fist bump from Brent. #worthit

[@wlprisbrey]

Amen, well said. I love their love shows. They are honestly my favorite band to see live, and I have seen many. Brent could sing the phone book and I would want to make a call.

[@jpreston22]

He is JUST as good live. He's truly one of the best vocalists out there

[@jakobfidler4510]

Was my first concert

[@luciferluci4570]

he really is seen them nine times!! wanna make it 10!! so amazing!!!

[@adamshea8380]

They're just as good live.

[@BrokenGodEnt]

And never took lessons either (at least that's what my Shinedown mega fan friend has told me). She may touch on that in this video, haven't watched all the way through. She's typically pretty informed so she may have mentioned it lol

[@jamesshride3158]

I would also like to call out David Draiman.

[@jasonsuter13]

I've seen this song live and I can confirm the voice is impeccable 😍

[@class5bodyworks]

Same here. More emotion live, I think.

[@cowboybigz]

It doesn't matter if it's Skynrd or Shinedown. These lyrics just hit home.

[@dquaidman]

Except for Brent changing the lyrics and thus changing the meaning of the song.

[@jessecrockett8127]

@@dquaidman what lyrics did he change?

[@dquaidman]

@@jessecrockett8127 He changed "all I want for you my son is to be satisfied" to "all I want from you my son is to be satisfied". So instead of wanting a good life for her son, she wanted her son to make her life better. It changes the whole dynamic of the song.

[@jessecrockett8127]

@@dquaidmanmaybe, I think it could also be interpreted as "all I was from you my son [is for you to be satisfied]" Because the same meaning can be implied with both versions. Although it would be neat if they deliberately changed the entire meaning of the song with one word

[@dquaidman]

@@jessecrockett8127 I'm just going by how it's sung. He should have left it as written unless he's got some strange reason not to. Unless, of course, he doesn't know the difference between "for" and "from", which is entirely possible.

[@stacyjohnson3489]

The guy has pipes, serious pipes. One of the few that sounds better in person. Like, completely blown away in concert. They have so many other songs that are amazing, Second Chance distinctly.

[@OGuselessrogue]

Yes. 100%

[@leejohnson7293]

I agree, live his vocals are on point!

[@RinniePere]

I was blown away when I saw them open for Velvet Revolver... best stage energy that whole night. 👏🏻

[@brianlee7713]

He has so much power he is louder than the speakers!

[@ApexofWar_]

Just saw him in concert 48 hours ago

[@sterling8298]

It's so fun to watch how excited Elizabeth gets on the songs. I like how she breaks down the song on a technical level. So rather than just being a react to the song video. You're learning how the song was put together on a technical point of view. And I like learning new things.

[@jeremyleverette6750]

The energy from this song is magical. Nothing but goosebumps while making you really emotional

[@kylwain]

"If You Only Knew" is another Excellent Vocal performance for Brent. The fact he wrote it about his Kid probably helped.

[@ShutUpandFight]

"Brent"... not Brett. 'Brett' is the lead singer of "Poison"

[@DJC955]

Not to mention that it wasn't just for his kid, but to honor how his kid motivated his sobriety is amazing! Such amazing song writers!

[@marktonk2]

Your emotion and joyfull expressiveness as you break this and many other great songs down touches me deeply. You are simply amazing at what you are doing here! I watch a few of your videos every so often and each time am struck by how purely honest your joy for music is. Please really consider how much you are impacting your fans for the better, we adore you and love being on this magical journey with you.

[@daffanurfauzan1220]

Yes, finally you noticed to Brent Smith! i remember back then listen them for first time by songs "Sound of Madness" and "If You Only Knew", his vocals hooked me up instantly!

[@lawrenceblunk2338]

Brent's articulation/dictation absolutely immerses your soul into moments indescribable! His abilities, fascinating!!!

[@crate3232]

'Call Me' is the ultimate Shinedown vocal song. My entire family attempts to belt it out every road trip.

[@mikeandersonwa]

Call Me is one of my absolute all time favorite songs, absolutely incredible!

[@hitandruncommentor]

Someone else that knows that fantastic song.

[@CrewChiefa0227]

This song is the best. It is so amazing.

[@zombiiesque]

Love that one!

[@class5bodyworks]

Elizabeth does a review of that song on this channel. Great song!

[@williamwarren7636]

"Save Me" is another great early Shinedown song that shows off his voice-- a beautiful song about addiction and redemption

[@yeahsureyoubetcha4684]

Just the sheer joy she exhibits makes me happy. The fact that it is my favorite band as well just makes it all the better. Good stuff.

[@bryanwulf8956]

Thank you for this analysis of Brent’s voice, I have always thought his voice was very technical, and absolutely amazing the way he sang that song! Lynyrd Skynyrd should be honored that he took it to the next level! Love what you do, keep it up!

[@randyjon224]

I absolutely love watching your facial expressions through every single note that is sung on all of the videos you share, and then listen to you break it down word for word. Outstanding Elizabeth!! ✌🏻❤🤍💙🇺🇸

[@Oh_its_Mike]

People who understand mastery of a craft always react with laughter when they experience it. I love that shit...seeing someone who fully understands whats going on be so blown away by the talent of what they're seeing/listening to that you just have to laugh at the absurdity of it.

[@babygandalf865]

This is nothing compared to his live singing. I’ve seen them four times and each time it was incredible. Absolutely incredible.

[@chrismcgee288]

Dude sung this song for 15 minutes at the end of his show when we went to see him. Amazing.

[@jordanmcdonald9366]

Every time I hear this song it gives me chills. I recently seen shinedown live and when they played this song it was so emotional and powerful throughout the whole crowd

[@class5bodyworks]

Great live singalong. Everyone in the crowd knows this one. Great energy!

[@Lonewolf-nv7tm]

"I'll follow you", " Miracle"...live acoustic. They do not disappoint live, seen them twice..once full show, once acoustic

[@Intercaust]

Saw them with Godsmack. Awesome show.

[@racheltassin2270]

I never miss a concert as long as they are in driving distance. They are awesome live. I watched them with Godsmack also. Great show

[@marcuswioncek2318]

In this crazy world we live in, you are such a breath of fresh air. I never realized how much there was behind vocals. Thank you so much for the great content!!

[@angelagustafson2270]

Everything this band touches is pure. Every part. Every nuance. His voice is pure emotion. Check out some of Smith & Meyers. Singer and guitar player's side project. Absolutely phenomenal covers.

[@awolfalone2006]

Yes! Completely agree on all accounts.

[@club3g82]

Brent Smith has one of the most incredible singing voices I've ever heard. No matter how much I try to emulate it it's just impossible, insane one of a kind talent.

[@jayminer9416]

This man has been the king of eargasms for years now. You 100% geek'd out, and rightfully so.

[@anabolical6521]

Here's a fact for ya, He covered this song and dedicated it to "Dimebag Darrell". There is a live version of this where he explains it to the crowd and that is why we get so much emotion from him in this song! You can feel his pain and loss!

[@ericm9211]

Favorite Shinedown song for me is ' What a shame". Seen them live 4 times live and once on the Smith and Meyers tour Absolutely fantastic live

[@Vetionarian]

What a Shame is severely underrated. It's my favorite song of all time. The transition into the new key change at the end is phenomenal and I get goose bumps like never before.

[@twinquist]

In my opinion "What a Shame" is their best song

[@twinquist]

I forgot about "I'll Follow You"...that song has slightly edged out "What a Shame" for the best Shinedown song. For me

[@abalogan]

what a shame, is one of the songs that gets to me the most, It feels like it's about me, i had a time when i was that guy, in general sound of madness helped me so much to get over depression and alcohol abuse and turn my life around.

[@stevenmansfield4824]

This dude can sing with anyone man. What a voice. Nice to see him getting the respect!

[@Frenzina98]

"I could become obsessed with this sound, woah" I felt that.

[@Bradbeard-nv1vo]

The moment she joined the family

[@BradR89]

You have such a visceral reaction to music. Like you actually feel each note in your cells. It's honestly so cool!

[@haven5144]

Might be sacrilegious but I like Brent's version better than the original.. Lol.

[@Hydepop19]

That’s cause it’s better

[@owlislike]

I second that emotion.

[@therealR.D.]

I have been a Skynard fan for almost 50 years, but I agree with you.

[@messagekeenenivorywayansvo3011]

Agreed

[@AlbirdBarrios]

Idk Deftones turned it into gold

[@bstech7888]

LOVED her reaction! Funny... that's how millions of us feel about his voice as well! 😍💕 Brent is Amazing! Looks like Shinedown has another fan snared by the voice...

[@ulventorden5293]

I was so close to the stage with them once that when the show was over, Brent himself handed me a guitar pick. I still have it to this day.

[@grizbear9519]

Those of us who are truly moved by music are SO lucky!! There’s nothing like being moved to tears or getting goosebumps from listening to a song

[@GenStrife]

I've said since the day this cover came out that this is how Simple Man was meant to be. The amount of vocal emotion and energy behind this version fits the lyrics and the tone of the song in an amazing synergy. It's ridiculous. The range once he lets his voice bloom and the control of the tones and shaping is entrancing and endearing.

[@alexmartin7873]

Same with "Hurt" when it was covered by Johnny Cash

[@merlin601]

I cannot really agree. Though Brent is a great singer he shows it a bit to much here. Maybe it is because I am a guitarist but to me the focus is a bit to much on the vocals and the way he lengthens "simple" and "man" in the refrain is exaggerated. I think the truth would be somewhere between the original and this cover. It is definetly not that clear like "Hurt" sung by Cash which was dedicated to him by Reznor later.

[@bigal7505]

This is a fantastic cover, I can't deny. I love it. But, I don't think I can agree with the comment "this is how Simple Man was meant to be. To me, it will always be Ronnie Van Zant's song. He wrote it with Gary Rossington after his (Ronnie's) grandmother died. It is the third most popular song in the Skynard catalog for a reason.

[@elinino5275]

Great cover but hard to beat Ronnie Van Zant and the boys. There are a few original live versions from Skynyrd that are phenomenal!

[@openyoureyes909jones6]

Gotta disagree. I like Shinedown's songs, they brought nothing to this song but a louder version. Skynyrd knew when to play it softly and deliver the emotion. I cant even tell if Shinedown heard the Skynyrd version, they just made it noisier. For comparison. the crappy remake of 'I will always love you' of Dolly Partons' classic by Whitney Houston. Another louder version of a classic that brought nothing new to the table but more noise. Again, Dolly knew when (and how) to soften the vocals and really deliver the emotion she was feeling....Whitney just sang loud, and less loud. I already know 95% will disagree with me, probably on both points. I urge you to listen to both originals, then the imposters. Perhaps you can understand what i am trying to point out.

[@jimmyv1753]

His voice really is an incredible instrument. Truly. I can listen to him sing anything. Enchanting Is a great way to put it.

[@HunterPro13]

So if you like this vocal range you should listen to 45 “acoustic” by shinedown

[@TheDiveDawg]

how about this one in a basement, with nothing but a guitar. kzbin.info/www/bejne/q4PElXqkatJ_isU

[@bobalberts8850]

Definitely a powerful song! You can feel the emotion! I hope you review it!

[@bobalberts8850]

The studio version is great, but the acoustic version is by far the more powerful!

[@dcskater180]

Yes. Such a good acoustic song!

[@Shady25X20]

Would definitely recommend checking on “Smith & Meyers”. It is a side duo that Brent Smith is a part of. Brent is awesome, but he really shines in acoustic settings. Smith & Meyers does a lot of covers with less instruments. If you really want to isolate his voice check Brent out here. As for Shinedown, I’ll Follow You is a beautiful song. Monsters is awesome as well. Call Me and Second Chance….really aren’t any “bad” Shinedown songs. Glad you found them.

[@aparker7777]

Yea, there is not such thing as a bad Shinedown song... everything that band and Brent touches is gold.

[@dan1648]

I think Zach Myers has a great voice also, very underrated when you put him next to Brent Smith.

[@AnthonyRidley2011]

I love the Smith & Myers version of Unchained Melody

[@AlexQuill63]

I swear like 50% of the fun in these videos is just watching you get so excited and happy about stuff in the song, particularly when you then start getting really animated in explaining why you like it so much :D EDIT: From Shinedown - 45, Miracle, Enemies, Devour, Second Chance, Sound of Madness, For My Sake, Call Me, What a Shame, Diamond Eyes would all be songs I'd recommend.

[@leighcollins636]

You felt exactly like I did when he sings "It'll help help you." The slightest drop in pitch & tiny break in his voice literally made my brows pull down and inward with pure emotion. It was a mix of compassion and nostalgia... and almost had a pleading tone to it... so much heart and soul! I could listen to his voice 24/7! 🤘🏼🥰

[@Wyndigayle]

Brent has one of the best voices in rock. LOVE Shinedown. So nice to see some more reactions to them. Don't see enough. Your giddiness at his vocals makes me happy. To see someone else truly appreciate his talent is rewarding. My favorite Shinedown track (They're almost all great) is Follow You Down.

[@armedrespect9737]

My first experience with Shinedown was the song Sound of Madness (highly recommend), and I've been a fan ever since.

[@travisprugh6347]

Of all their catalogue Leave a Whisper is still my favorite.

[@AlexQuill63]

Diamond Eyes was my first introduction. Still one of my favourites from their catalogue.

[@Daygall]

"What a shame" is one of my personal favorites in the Shinedown discography for the same kind of impact as here. Though to be fair and honest to your question what Shinedown to cover next? I believe "yes" is the correct answer. Thank you for a wonderful breakdown of the technical aspects of he song, but for also always being genuine and not trying to mask your emotional reactions on your face.

[@ThaneaPally]

I went looking in these comments to see if I was the only one that felt this way. Glad to see I'm not.

[@BuckDown603]

Glad to join you guys!! Lol 🤘🏼😜

[@mustangsally92781]

I love how much she reacts to the different parts of the song... It's almost like she has an eargasm!!! Brent Smith's voice is just amazing and I'm so happy to see her enjoy it and be able to break it down so beautifully. ❤️

[@kaitlyncall5995]

I've seen Shinedown 4 times in concert and they were brilliant every time. I really love the band. Brent has an amazing voice and vocal range. 45 is still one of my favorites

[@EricNeuls]

They are great when the sound guy does their job lol Ive seen them a few times myself and half the time the sound is awful and you can barely hear him. When its good though hes spot on

[@johnschaffer6968]

Hope you do some more Shinedown, Brent Smith is incredible. 45, Fly From the Inside, Save Me, Crow and the Butterfly

[@JarpsHellRider]

oh yeah, the acoustic version of 45 ....

[@martynbillings4924]

@@JarpsHellRider this x1000

[@miketurner7009]

Crow and the butterfly definitely

[@ericd1632]

I Dare You is incredible as well

[@slicksilver9441]

The way Brent sings is something he was born with. Yes, people can take lessons and get better but 99% of the planet could never sing like him with a lifetime of coaching/practice.

[@hunterwarner393]

The only band that could ever hold a light to Skynyrd. He has such a great cross between grungy rock and a southern womans choir on a Sunday. You can literally feel it when he changes pitches and tones.

[@amberkotcher8989]

Did you notice that after all that energy, he ends the song on the empty breath? He let it all go and there’s literally nothing left. Brent is amazing.

[@briancall8031]

Any Shinedown is amazing. Their music help me and my kids threw my divorce. It was something we would listen to daily. Raised them since they were 5 and 4 as a single dad and Shinedowns music was a great connection we had and help us through it. Love watching you do these makes my day. You are amazing and a joy to watch

[@ThaLostVerse]

Her amazing anime eyes, the super expressive face and breakdown of our favorite songs in a way we don't comprehend until that in depth explanation is why we're all here. I think we all want a person to look at us the way she reacts to these great songs. Proof that you can fall in love with art like music~

[@andersonjay2010]

Girl has fallen in love instantly.

[@advancedrescue1574]

I’m amazed no one ever does second chance, people act like this was there one hit that shows the power in his voice

[@zackerydempsey1280]

Whenever I listen to this song I imagine it’s my old man talking to me, he’s my stepfather but he raised me by himself and I often feel like he’s all I have. I owe everything to the guy and this song brings me to tears thinking that there’s going to be a day when he’s not here anymore

[@chadpelo7566]

Yes. I understand 100%. My stepfather did that for me, and I am now doing it for MY stepson.

[@mememe733]

How lucky you are to have such a man in your life! 😊

[@zackerydempsey1280]

@@mememe733 absolutely blessed for sure

[@gavinspalding]

“The crow and the butterfly” His voice is 🤤

[@Proudtman]

This is my favorite song by them! 45 is also an incredible song

[@derelictdiva]

This particular version of this song hits me in the heart every time. His voice sounds like the longing of the heart to me - the sustained long vowels, the steady pitch, and just the emotion of it - and it’s truly enchanting.

[@Lost_in_the_Blink]

When they played this live, i dont think there was a dry eye in the house. Never going to forget it

[@jeremytrotter3375]

The joy on her face the surprise and just the happiness that she gets from seeing/hearing these singers she hasn't heard before is like watching a kid come down on Christmas to the surprise that Santa has visited

[@esteiger1267]

Brent Smith in apocalyptica's "Not Strong Enough" will absolutely break you. You NEED to hear that one

[@nightsgrow6575]

Yes omg he’s so amazing in that one, like all the songs he does

[@donnamignemi]

Oh yes!!!

[@6atoH4ik]

don't forget about "For my sake" one of my favorites)

[@HK-ur7hu]

Love that song 😍

[@brigham1111]

I want to leave an unfiltered comment on your reactions, but I'm sure it would sound critical instead of complimentary. But I do love your excitement, especially how you are geeking out on all the details and nuances. You do have an amazing talent pointing them out and describing them verbally, and your facial expressions just add to the whole description. I'm starting to see a whole new level of details that I've never appreciated or noticed before. Now I'm geeking out. It's really fun! I love both versions of this song, the same way I love Disturbed Sound of Silence and its original version. They are the same, yet soo different. It elevates these great songs to Legendary status. So much fun

[@Rocketman9mm]

Shinedown is definitely in my top 10! you should also listen to sound of madness, 45, cut the cord and many more.

[@chachaj914]

I’ve have seen them twice in concert and his voice seems like it’s just getting richer and stronger as he gets older. I love listening to them.

[@Alifirecat]

Yeah, that's just Brent Smith's voice. He feels like a beast kept on check. His voice is straight power and emotion. Listen to ANYTHING AND EVERYTHING by him.