SHINee Marathon (Replay, Sherlock Clue, Note, Everybody + Atlantis) | REACTION !!!

[@zackbregman4947]

SHINee is my favorite group. been a fan for 15 years. Jonghyun is their 5 member who passed away 6 years ago on 12/17/17. He truly is a vocal king, and they are known as the Prince's of KPOP.

[@milindawilson9175]

Just a correction, Jonghyun died 12/18/17. Monday was the anniversary.

[@spectrum4524]

Just a small personal add on: Princes of KPOP and Kings of the Live Stage

[@ForThoseThatHaventReadTheBook]

The 18th in korea, the 17th in America realtime. I'm in America, too

[@fleurbibie]

i miss him ;-;

[@sure6333]

4:38 8:52 14:30 he is jonghyun 💔😔 He have an amazing voice 🤍

[@leadan5170]

Imagine having the best dancer and best vocalist in kpop in the same group 😌

[@Sayuri8663]

💯 ❤

[@Lintletse]

Also one of the best stylists and custom designer, amateur opera singer and good actor...They just have the IT factor and have taken their journey and grown with bumps along the way...but have stayed the course and have paced themselves to be at this point....legends with no comparisons...

[@ahgacababeumetiny-Lshawol]

SM thing

[@babywol_3782]

Onew has record of holding note for 40 seconds , longest in kpop history

[@babywol_3782]

Sherlock was choreographed by Micheal Jackson's choreographer and at that time it was most expensive choreography bought by sm

[@lionelcrews1422]

If you'll notice at 19:08 - 19:11 Taemin has is left arm extending outward. That is a spot for Jonghyun because SHINee will always be 5. You see this sort of recognition in all of their more recent concerts/MVs.

[@Hanbinahceah]

EVERYBODY: a song where they fight who is the main VOCALISTS 😅

[@miniemin86]

The girl in the "Replay" mv is Victoria Song. She is a Chinese singer, dancer and actor, and she was the leader of girl group f(x) which was also under SM Entertainment.

[@jamesrawlins735]

I'm still angry over what happened to F(x). It's not all SM's fault (Victoria has a part in it) but SM still did them bad.

[@crochetmittens]

onew is the kind of leader who supports his group rather than leading them from the top. that's why you see him very so often letting his members shine and giving them the support they need to be their best in the team. this is why onew is an amazing leader and why the members love him so much

[@alekaonu]

The guy with the cool hair is KEY, the guy with the good voice is ONEW, he's the leader of SHINee and Onew is my bias in this group.

[@bxssbxby]

The way I kept screaming “that’s jonghyun!” at the screen when he kept saying onew. Lol.

[@0RGEL]

ME TOO FR 😭😭😭

[@Jiashuai_exo]

*Replay is originally released in 2008 and it's SHINEE’s debut song actually it's just that SM entertainment open new YT account and re-uploaded some old song from their groups that's why* 1:40 - 3:09 - 3:32 That is JONGHYUN (MAIN VOCALIST)❤😇🕊️ *adlibs mostly from him and onew in Replay* 1:49 - 3:14 ONEW (Leader and Main VOCAL) 2:03 - 3:22 KEY (LEAD DANCER, LEAD VOCALIST) 2:23 Yes, that's TAEMIN. (MAIN DANCER) 3:06 - 4:27 MINHO (RAPPER) 18:15 MINHO 18:22 This year all of them are over 30+

[@2222titia]

Back when SHINee had a "main" vocal, it was Jonghyun, Jinki (Onew) was lead vocalist.... then as Jonghyun himself said SHINee has 5 vocalists. Those "roles" do not apply anymore, they all main/lead sing, all are soloists... You did recognized the "main" singer tho

[@Gyu_wasnt_born_yesterday]

OMG I just started checking them out this month. So far I love their music a lot

[@RDD09]

They are all amazing in SHINee and as solo Artist also. Their discography is incredible, enjoy your time discovering them.

[@Gyu_wasnt_born_yesterday]

@@RDD09 yess I'm really enjoying. Can't wait to discover more of them

[@田田-h7j]

OMG SHINee 🎉 Can I recommend the following songs to you: 1. Ring Ding Dong & Lucifer remix from SWC5 concert 2. Please don’t go from SWC5 concert 3. Why so serious from the same concert 4. Dear Name cover @ IU palette ❤ 5. Nessun Dorma (opera) by Onew

[@ayenayen3806]

just when I thought that another song has replaced 'Replay' as the best debut song (for me, at least), I was reminded that it's still the best debut song. 😮‍💨Just got chills again. Any 2nd gen fan here? 🤧🙋

[@Chiyeonchaelisa]

I got into kpop in 2019 but i'm a big shawol and v.i.p and for me replay is the best debut song.

[@kathy3459]

Me, me I love 2nd gen groups and sound, maybe cause I'm older than the average KPop fan 😆. I also like 3rd gen, EXO, BTS, BtoB, MonstaX, but haven't gone deep into 4th gen yet. SHINee is my home, no other group will replace them as my top favorite 💙💙💙💙💙

[@yoonrose07]

2nd gen will always be iconic, my god how I miss those PERFORMANCES How 2nd gen performed, that's what you call a performance, everyone was actually having hella fun, true screams. You can't compare 2nd gen stage presence to anyone

[@BLOOOOZ]

I started listening to Kpop in 2017 but the 2nd Gen is the best Gen so far, I love it so much, the songs are so iconic 🔥🔥

[@niyetz228]

Shinee ❤️❤️❤️ thank you... Bec in shinee the leader doesn't need to be in the spotlight.. His the one who let his members shine.. That's how he leads them. You can see how his members especially taemin really shine😍😊.

[@blehbleh3471]

December is a month shawols cry and smile at the same time. Thanks for reliving those beautiful memories we had with these legends❤

[@arayahrobinson3733]

I'm trying my hardest to not break into tears watching this 🙈 forever our moon 🩵🩵

[@babubohay]

You have to watch SHINee Stranger SWC IV live performance. It's also one of their amazing performance.

[@ahgacababeumetiny-Lshawol]

Shinee has the best dancer , best vocalist, the stylist , the actor , the athlete, the most unique vocalist voice , most beautiful lyricist . Shinee has everything

[@yesicaramirez1565]

onew is the leader as you already know, jonghyun is the one you mentioned the most because of the high notes, onew in everybody has black hair, key has red hair in everybody, but it's better to react to a guide so you can get to know them better, it would be great, thank you very much

[@evangelinhutamaningtyas5979]

The main vocalist who always run highnote is Jonghyun

[@samsmith2346]

Shinee and Exo are obviously from the same company but they’re also really close! Jonghyun (main vocalist in shinee) was extremely passionate in singing, composing, and producing and he literally helped train/shape the vocals of Taemin (baby Taemin didn’t even get lines when he debuted, the amount of work this man has put into his vocals is honestly pretty unrivaled in kpop) as well as Exo’s Baekhyun and more! He also wrote many songs for other artists across K-pop - he wrote the song Playboy that Exo sings!

[@gsandoval11]

Fun fact. Suho the leader of EXO was suppose to be in Shinee. But he was injured when Shinee was close to debut. Lol He is very close with Shinee. Sadly the guy who did the crazy high notes in the live performance is our angel Jonghyun. One of the best vocalist. Everybody is in their 30’s now. Taemin is the maknae, youngest in the group. In Atlantis Onew is the one who did the 8 second note. The leader and oldest member. Without knowing at the time Shinee help to put kpop on the map. They are known as Princes of kpop. :)

[@essaytutoring6699]

Yess! More SHINee please

[@dadatosu4702]

Following them from their debut ❤... I remember Jonghyun enjoying a candy asking kids around to "please listen to shinee, support us"... he was an unique artist ❤ Ps. I was a teen, now mom of two boys, we spent the weekend listening old shinee songs 😂 kids enjoyed.

[@sedie94]

Trying my best to answer your questions here because SHINee was the first group I properly became a fan of in kpop. The guy with the nice voice at @1:50 is Onew @2:16 yes, that's Taemin lol @3:05 Yup, Onew's voice is so smooth

[@Lintletse]

That was beautiful...😊

[@Donatella87]

Shinee's vocal is from another world. 💙

[@2222titia]

Replay is from May 2008 so 15 yrs ago, was SHINee debut. Taemin was 14 yr old.

[@taysehunmark]

More Shinee🙏🏼

[@laraibahmed3090]

the eternal princes of kpop! love them dearly! I hope you continue to get to know them. Truly the vocals will never disappoint but that isn't shocking considering them are from sm! haha

[@springsummerautumnwinter2555]

Onew is the one who is singing with Rosé in Sea of hope vs and you also like his voice there too.

[@fatiissaad1770]

Yeah I was about to say the same thing he didn't recognize him 😭

[@OttersAndOreos]

Onew, who is the leader, is the voice in Atlantis that holds that note. Onew is known for holding a note up to 40 seconds. He also can sing Opera. Shinee, always 5.

[@Lintletse]

Thanks for rhe reaction...made my pre Xmas vibe nice..Thanks again. These guys under any incarnation are that good. They can cover for each other....and yet are irreplacable as they fit so perfectly to create what os Shinee. Yet powerful and iconic individually.

[@AH-xq9gc]

Jonghyun has crazy vocal power and onew ist the one who has nice voice. They are two vocal members in shinee and also best vocalists in kpop.

[@jessalam8824]

More SHINee please!! Each of them got amazing solo's too, like Taemin.

[@aniumar5964]

Being Leader in kpop is not abt being in the centre...its abt leading the group and taking care of the members and the communicating with management. As this is in Japan...Taemin is centre n face of SHINee. In the old days in Seoul centre is hold by Jonghyun...he was the main vocalist and the one that do the high notes...but they all can do high note . As u will learn a kpop group can hv more than one vocalist, so Onew is also SHINee's main vocalist. Taemin is SHINee maknae...the youngest...every member n fans love him!!! All SM concerts r wonderful...be it Super Junior TVXQ SHINee Exo NCT.

[@universe986]

Taemin was the center in Japan, Jonghyun was the center in Korea and on the pictures. idk about 'face' of the group but the visual was Minho

[@sofiagiraldo2906]

in shinee there were 5 members but one is in heaven

[@dewidelisa9236]

Replay is the best debut song ever

[@babywol_3782]

Princess of kpop💎💎💎💎💎

[@nuurya8387]

The member you're asking for in Replay is our dear Jonghyun 🩵

[@sinsy9556]

Yeah!! Finally SHINee❤.. Please do react to their "JUICE" performance and "HARD" song!!

[@paulaidahbiancaabundancia1910]

The one doing the high notes is Jonghyun which is one of the kpop singers that has the best voice. Onew is the one that has the rounder and distinct voice. You should watch their live concert when they sang Excuse Miss.

[@paaaaji]

I would really really love to see you react to Jonghyun - Y Si Fuera Ella. it was the anniversary of his passing this week, so I'm sure fellow shawols would love to see it and celebrate his talent. ❤ That performance is so incredible and legendary, if it doesn't make you tear up, I'd be shocked. Lol. Jonghyun was truly a one of a kind artist and is missed so dearly. He was so involved in writing and producing music for other artists too so the whole creative industry really suffered a massive loss that day. You could make a whole video out of diving into his catalog.

[@lavegz]

YEAAAAH THIS ONE

[@girloftu0]

shinee is nothing more and nothing less than the princes of kpop 💪🏻

[@sofeels_]

12:14 someone being the leader of the group doesn't mean they have to be/stand in the centre all the time. Onew is SHINee's leader, Jonghyun is SHINee's centre and Taemin is usually in the centre for performances/choreos. Someone thinking of Taemin as SHINee's leader is so funny to me 😂 He's forever their baby.

[@anatoledo6459]

A SHINee guide reaction perhaps 🫣🙏

[@skylar3578]

8:20 onew 8:27 key 8:52 is Jonghyun

[@phoebeyuu4525]

Right now they're basically blurring their position since all of them nowadays are equal monsters in dancing, singing, and rapping. But when they're first debuting, the official positions are like this: Onew : oldest, the one whose voice you love/caught your attention, Leader and Lead Vocal (then), 2nd main vocal (mid career - now) Jonghyun : the one you keep noticing doing the high notes, Main vocal / main vocalist, SHINee's composer and lyricist Key : the red hair in Everybody, Triple Threat (lead vocal, lead dancer, lead rapper) Minho : yes, you already know him, main rapper--and also visual Taemin : the youngest (maknae), main dancer, now also main vocal Can't wait for SHINee marathon!

[@mariaa5887]

The girl from replay MV is leader of SM group "FX"Victoria is her name. She is now singing in China after her team disbanded.

[@typosaidiloveya3853]

Man I feel so special when I see someone discovering shinee for the first time ❤ they were my first k-pop group and still remain my top 3! I love these boys(now men) soo much and jonghyun angle you are missed dearly ❤

[@sofeels_]

18:22 their ages in the Atlantis MV: Onew 31 Key 29 Minho 29 Taemin 27

[@dora14tor]

It's better not to even imagine Taemin as the leader of the group, It would be pure chaos😂😂

[@wenvell_decoded]

You can’t go wrong with any of SHINee’s vocals…

[@giselacaceres7247]

SHINee Kings for ever..!!!

[@universe986]

Replay is from 15 years ago, and Taemin never was the leader, he was a literal kid when they debuted (14 y.o.). he was the center during Japanese promo and in the most choreographies. right now they don't have a fixed center they remind you of EXO because they're also from SM, vocal powerhouse. fun fact the main vocalist Jonghyun wrote/composed one of EXO songs, Playboy (he also was an exceptional writer and composer, and had a big impact on SM and the industry). they're all friends with each other SHINee are the kings of live stages. their level of energy is unmatched. each of them is insanely talented and creative and has an amazing solo career too

[@Renia3_13]

In Replay, the girl is the Leader of SMs' girl group F(x). The members are Amber, Luna, Krystal, Sulli (RIP) and the leader Victoria.

[@ShawolBaabyx]

More SHINee lives please!! 😍😍😍

[@opx.-.wedad.]

thank you for the reaction I loved it 🫶 plsss more shinee

[@eyla107]

I had to subscribe as soon as I read the title ! Thank you for reacting to SHINee aka THE PRINCES OF KPOP 🙌🏽

[@BLOOOOZ]

4:57, 7:08, 11:33 & 14:14 it's Jonghyun :) Onew is him : 7:58, 11:30 & 19:48 8:34 & 11:31 it's Key (btw if you could react to the livestage Born To Shine, it's amazing (and so hot ngl) !) Minho is here : 11:32

[@fajarkurniawan6623]

"Replay" iconic forever

[@kauneyli]

For SHINee top notch vocals, you should react to their most popular "Like a fire" Live 👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼🔥

[@LIUSKAEditz8410]

Yes Legendary Shinee ❤ Want shinee , nct , exo reactions

[@Melisa.18]

Dewet more marathon pleasseee🤗 One song is not enough 😭

[@sofeels_]

11:22 from left to right: Onew (black hair) - Jonghyun (blond highlights) - Taemin (blond) - Minho - Key (fuchsia hair)

[@sofeels_]

In the Sherlock live the one with the white hair going crazy vocally is Jonghyun, the one with the pink-ish hair is Onew and the one with the "cool" green hair is Key.

[@ForThoseThatHaventReadTheBook]

the big open throat voice is Onew cool hair is Key vocal runs is Jonghyun (Jong Hyon (Honey))

[@afrfaiths17]

fyi the mv replay came out originally in 2008, but it got remastered in 2022, so the 2022 part was the date of the remastered version. hope this helps.

[@emanuelapar]

Taemin: you know which one he is Key: One with cool hair, he also has a nice vocal Minho: the rapper, tallest Onew: one with the nice voice that you like, he has sweet voice indeed Jonghyun: crazy vocal, he always has the insane part. he passed away in 2017 (rip❤️) will forever remain an icon thank you for the reaction!! i’m so excited for more shinee / taemin reaction videos from you 🙌

[@leteflondondu92]

the girl he chasin in replay was victoria leader of f(x) who debuted in 2009.shinee debuted in 2008.

[@1Льоля7]

Where in Sherlock you thought that Onew was the main vocalist, it was actually Jonghyun... I love him with all my heart..

[@raven_1485]

You felt the similarity between EXO and SHINee because they are from the same company, since SM entertainment is the home of vocals both of them have amazing and incredible vocals and they are friends, also SHINee is EXO's seniors, they are considered as if they were EXO’s big brothers. so they give you the same concerts vibe

[@حليوووه]

SHINE always be 5❤

[@sofeels_]

5:00 that's Jonghyun, SHINee's second oldest member and he was 18 years and 1 month old at the time lmao

[@jkk4303]

Shinee is still popular and awesome group! JongHyun was a leader and big loss for them and was a great singer and a good friend to many people including IU. JongHyun was part of IU song, eight showing how much she misses him and cherish their friendship. JongHyun gave IU a song he has written because she really liked it when he had her listen to it and they ended up singing together. The song is called a gloomy clock and it shows how he felt back then. Now Onew has a health issue and having some time off and I wish his fast recovery!

[@universe986]

Onew has been the leader since debut

[@jops1004]

need more SHINee content 🙏 their live performances are the best, their most recent is the MMA one :)

[@Jeusyao_Seon]

The girl in the Reply MV is Victoria❤ She is the leader of the group called F(X). F(X) and SHINee have the closet friendship.

[@restufadhilah6919]

You need to watch shinee evil in concert!!!

[@AimieNeyra-pn8el]

That Girl in the Music Video,she's Victoria a member of F(x)girl group and she's A noona to them.F(x)and Shinee is from the same company SM entertainment

[@Moonlight-gs7ti]

SHINEE ONE OF THE BEST GROUPS EVERRRRR

[@esmagozkeser8720]

Jonghyun ❤ I miss him so much 18/12/2017 ❤

[@vanebenitez8314]

Shinee y EXO son de la misma empresa y derrochan vocales a morir ❤

[@jonghyunoutdid]

i recommend watching the excuse me miss live performance! in the end jonghyun introduces all of the members !

[@sharycapetillo5619]

Hello, I hope you can understand what that I said, because I dont speak english haha, but, ONEW is the guy from the first video with the voice, he does the high note in atlantis, KEY has the red hair, and btw he designs all their clothes to the concerts, TAEMIN, well we know him, and JONGHYUN is our angel, he has the high notes in every video, he was the most beautiful person and the most talented man in the music industry, he passsed away in december 1th 2017, togheter are amazing, because still are 5, forever five.

[@kitsune112002]

In the Sherlock performance, the one you thought was Onew was actually Jonghyun. The one with the icy blonde hair in a backcomb is Jonghyun, who, until his passing was one of the main vocalists of Shinee.

[@Yoonmincouple.bangtan]

Shinee ❤❤❤❤

[@AimieNeyra-pn8el]

The one who you said has a cool hairstyle is Our Angel Jonghyun his really has the best vocal in kpop and his a songwriter too.

[@tokaemadel-deen7443]

The girl in replay is Victoria from fx

[@Mendoxie]

1:34 it's Victoria of F(X) from the same company SM entertainment

[@Diamante316]

In Japan, Taemin is the center but in Korea its Jonghyun. The one who's doing all "those notes" is Jonghyun (the main MAIN vocalist lol). In pictures, you'll 99% always see them from left to right: Onew, Taemin, Jonghyun, Minho, Key. But ofcourse if its in Japan its: Onew, Jonghyun, Taemin, Minho, Key. Onew is like a "go get your spotlight" kind of leader.

[@puspitaD]

I missed this live singing era of SM😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@puspitaD]

**Someone replying my comment by telling me to stop mentioning this lipsync thing cause taemin just did 2 days concert and sing live apparently. That's not him/her exact words, but the point is like that. And he/she deleted the reply. So in case he/she come back, down below is my answer. @mie6437 don't be over sensitive over people's comment. You can't command anyone to do what you want. If SM artists already start to do live singing again then great. I'll come back to watch their TV performances again. I'll see are they still worthy to watch. But you can't make me stop saying anything about SM behaviour for the past few years. Watching the groups performances is traumatic. Their amazing vocals is wasted just like that. The TV performances only pleasing to the eyes. But they are singer afterall, so don't blame people if they feels dissappointment over the vocal performance. Imagine, SM is known for the gods and goddess of live vocals in k-pop but suddenly the company didn't even try to hold onto the name anymore. I honestly stop watching their TV performances when even BoA have to perform by lipsync-ing with Got the Beat. Auto tune, loud backtrack, and lipsync is not uncommon at all. Rookies with short trainee time and the untalented ones vocally can get away with it but what about SM vocal giants? So don't get mad/lashing out at anyone saying things about this. You have things to say about this, other people also have their opinion about it.

[@universe986]

SHINee still sing live on their concerts

[@puspitaD]

@@universe986 it's good to hear🤗

[@marie-deborahonema1864]

The best debut song ever is replay 2008 ❤️

[@_mys]

The one doing crazy notes constantly (that you thought was Onew) was Jonghyun. Both Jonghyun and Onew are main vocalists, but Jonghyun usually took on most of the high notes. After his passing, they now tend to distribute high notes pretty evenly between the members. In Kpop, the leader isn't the one that that is usually the center (it might coincidentally seem that way sometimes). The leader is instead the one in charge of decision making, conflict resolution, and overall the group's representative for interviews and intercompany relations. In older gens, the leader was typically the oldest because of their culture of the oldest person automatically being in charge of a group, in this case it was Onew.

[@anatoledo6459]

Well being a center is a separate thing from being a leader, a leader is more like keeping the guys in check and leading them where the center is kinda like the face of the group

[@Wyb-le6ve]

Omg wasn't expecting this

[@hunniesanr]

That girl in Replay was Victoria Song. She’s one of the F(x) member, together with Krystal Jung. But now they are disbanded, they debuted few years after SNSD & Shinee. Before EXO.

[@jonghyunoutdid]

shinee debuted in 2008 with their single replay! Onew is their leader and Lead vocalist ! Jonghyun (2nd oldest) is the main vocalist, Key (3rd oldest) is the lead Dancer and lead rapper, Minho (2nd youngest) is the main rapper and visual, Taemin(the youngest) is the main dancer and sub vocalist! 14:15 is jonghyun ❤️

[@jonghyunoutdid]

14:40 , far left is minho, next to minho is key, middle is onew, 2nd to right is taemin , far right is jonghyun !

[@jonghyunoutdid]

you talked about exo!! fun fact, suho was supposed to debut in shinee instead of taemin but they changed it last minute. jonghyun vocally trained chen , baekhyun and d.o! chen actually wanted to become an idol because of shinee’s “Please don’t go”!! i recommend the performance ITS AMAZING!! it’s a duo between onew and jonghyun, amazing song

[@0RGEL]

yoooo i just subscribed to you and i LOVE that you're checking out SHINee, been binge-watching your Taemin/SHINee reactions today !! :) would LOVE if you kept doing SHINee marathons, would love you to hear their other iconic title tracks like "Juliette", "Ring Ding Dong", "Lucifer", "View", "Good Evening" and "Don't Call Me" !!

[@emanuelapar]

please do more shinee reaction! ❤ i’d recommend more of their live stages comparing to mv though. their vocal and the music usually sounds much much better especially the concert videos :)