Shostakovich: Symphony No. 5 / Dudamel · Berliner Philharmoniker

[@thanosave7112]

EVERY SINGLE PART OF THIS OVERTURE IS HEARD . ITS LIKE ALL of THE INSTRUMENTS ARE HAVING A CONVERSATION!! THIS IS AMAZING!!

[@MultiRingo2000]

Beethoven playing the trombone at 0:35

[@meye_mc]

Stefan Schulz 😂😂

[@antonyschoolofmusic42]

MultiRingo2000 yeah, Beethoven in his early 30's.

[@andrelousada]

Lol!!!! Yes! A very young Bee! :)

[@LeoooGuedesssss]

KKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

[@joshuagill605]

0:42 that dude on the left of the bass section is feeling it

[@MsMickey2]

This is one of the greatest symphonies ever and love Dudamel.

[@andrelousada]

Shosty knew how to do it well! :)

[@Uilsbat]

Prokofiev playing Shostakovich's bassoon at 2:18

[@TM-rl5kp]

ここのチャンネルで同じ部分の演奏を幾つか聞くことができますが（関連動画で幾つも出てくるので）、概ね騒々しい印象なのに対し、Dudamelの演奏はハっとするほど整理され組み立てられていて非常に聞き易く、引き込まれていく。ショスタコが楽譜に描いた絵を初めてちゃんと見れたような、そんな気持ちになった。

[@limorco08]

I am so proud to see our son (at last), caught by the camera... Thank you! What a great orchestra! Priceless music and musicians 👍🏽👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@bentonpreciado]

Congrats! Where is your son in the video?

[@limorco08]

Thanks! As from 0:54 - 0:56 - right bottom - a younger violinist with eyeglasses . Later on also from another engel.

[@bentonpreciado]

@@limorco08 that's so awesome! Congrats again! I'd love to play with this phenomenal group!

[@astoriacub]

Congratulations... They're probably the best orchestra in the world right now

[@limorco08]

@@bentonpreciado Many thanks ! (again 😊) Yes, it's the greatest privilege !

[@rileycollier3400]

I loooove these bass section shots! Berlin phil is my absolute favorite.

[@cpg7566]

My favourite version

[@bass-mkti]

0:38 Amazing doublebass Edicson❤

[@snapfinger1]

That dude has got it together.

[@أزهارالفكرالحر]

That is great ❤

[@dianasolari8131]

Brillante,!!!!,orquesta y director...una interpretación

[@thanosave7112]

the first time ever i heard every single part in this overture . i have heard and played 100s of times . this conductor is brilliant!

[@dianasolari8131]

BRILLANTE..EXCELENTE LA ORQUESTA Y DUDAMEL UN EXCELENTE DIRECTOR

[@rinosquarzoni9438]

Dudamel, oggi è uno dei grandi direttori. Complimenti.

[@43mrssimba]

A breathtaking performance.! Magnifique*

[@franklinrodriguez3370]

Awesome!

[@miguelguillen1975]

Dudamel, the best.

[@axelx4770]

Miguel Guillén Not in this repertoire. You must be joking. This really is a pretty lame performance. If you don’t believe me, listen to Haitink, Bernstein, Mravinsky and Rozhdestvensky among others and you’ll hear what a difference it makes in the hands of a conductor who knows what the music is about and how it should sound.

[@miguelguillen1975]

Hi Axel X. Yes, Dudamel is the best in my opinion but taking into account the current context. Gustavo has a great musicality that he transmits to his musicians in both rehearsals and live concerts. Maybe Dudamel is the best live orchestra director with Nézet-Séguin (in my opinion).... Yes I have listened to Haitink, Mravinsky ... I think the versions of Mahler's symphonies directed by Bernstein are insurmountable. Bernstein was a great director in his time but I don´t like his versions of Mozart or Beethoven ... to give an example. I prefer the Karajan-Beethoven tandem even if it is not my favorite director's. There are very good directors who have adjusted to a certain repertoire: Mahler / Bernstein, Karajan / Beethoven, Giulini / Brahms ... On one occasion I had the opportunity to listen to Celebidache in 1993 in Spain with his Munich Philharmonic, in my life I have heard an orchestra sound that way. Anyway: there's no accounting for taste but I would pay to see Dudamel. Regards.

[@gcg8187]

@@miguelguillen1975 wow, well said mate. I agree with ur opinion, well performed

[@hectorberlioz1449]

Dudamel the most overrated Abbado- imitation! Listen to Svetlanov in Shostakovich....

[@gcg8187]

Great!!!!

[@anibalsolis9430]

Dudamel es increíble ésa 5 es de las mejores que e escuchado y eso que an Sido muchas

[@ptuner2]

It was good to see a conductor not needing a score. At least on youtube so far today.

[@rinosquarzoni9438]

Oggi, Dudamel, e uno dei più grandi direttori. Abbado aveva visto giusto, quando disse questo è il mio erede.

[@Baddbunnyfoofoo-j1o]

Maria munzo has taught me how to appreciate the cuoture of cultural Arrats

[@MrBruno7447]

That Eb clarinet comes straight from hell

[@marcelolima6657]

Sublime.

[@samybelhora4602]

Super musique

[@pranavpalleti6066]

0:40 goddam that bass on the left probably smoked all the weed he had

[@aritheick7775]

weed doesn't do that.

[@ramsesale7]

The entire string section of all the orchestras of Venezuela is characterized by performing any work with the same euphoria or feeling and we do not smoke weed. So you can see that I don't lie, you can play from 0:25. It's called Alejandro Carreño. It is the first violin of the Venezuelan Simon Bolivar symphony orchestra. As for the bassist, it's called Edicson Ruiz. . That's how Jose Antonio Abreu taught us and it's how Gustavo likes to see us feel the music every time he directs us. for performing that way the symphony orchestra of Venezuela Simon Bolivar is one of the best in the world and its musicians have export quality ... greetings and blessings to youb

[@TheDipperPinez27]

its just a joke yall chill

[@steveabrams777]

@@TheDipperPinez27 they do not get the fine art of humor ... 🤣

[@davidmunguia1020]

Did anyone else see Sarah there?! That was cool! She's in it...I forgot.

[@clarinet9127]

スマホの画面がぶっ壊れそうなくらい、握り潰しながらこの動画に没頭した。 ドゥダメルとベルリンフィル。 ドゥダメルが軽い。 ベルリンフィルが重い。 ドゥダメルが軽いのが悪い。 ただ、ベルリンフィルが背負う歴史が重すぎる。 私はこの演奏で初めて、ドゥダメルのタクトが悪いと思いました。 それだけ今までのドゥダメルは完璧だった。彼が世界トップの指揮者なのは疑う余地がありません。 ２度の大戦…。その間、今日までベルリンフィルが演奏してきたショスタコーヴィチの5番。 余りにも重すぎる。意味が濃すぎる。メッセージが完璧に決められている。 「もしかしたらドゥダメルなら…」そんな思いでこの演奏を聞きました。 ベルリンフィルが重すぎる。 否 ベルリンが重すぎる 彼らはそれだけの歴史を背負っている それは日本も同じではなかろうか。 我々はこれほど無頓着で良いのだろうか。 深く考えさせられました。 本当にありがとう Thank you very much.

[@jin12345678]

Is that Alejandro Carreno at 0:30 ?

[@jorgecarrera5565]

@@jordanwartell-composer Yes, He is! I don't remember if right now is the concertmaster of the Simon Bolivar Orchestra, but basically is he! hahaha

[@franklinrodriguez3370]

Yes,he is.

[@gabrielferreira5824]

Yes, he ran away from Venezuela.

[@gabrielferreira5824]

@Eaglett Until now, they do not recover this situation. I am a brazilian, wherefore I live in a country close to their's, I know their confrontional situation. I hope that they can bring down the corrupt government. Pardon my english, I'm not good at all.

[@matheusmacedo6214]

@Eaglett we got the WORST leader possible, an imitation of Trump

[@thanosave7112]

No part is lost everything is heard clearly !

[@andrelucas2208]

Som esplêndido!!

[@adelaidaperez7504]

Bravo basses

[@Loreto_]

👍🙏

[@isaacsamuel9520]

May I ask why SBSO Concertmaster is along with the Berliner Philharmoniker?

[@jazzuscorleone8797]

🇨🇴🇨🇴🇨🇴

[@bambino100011]

I wish the bass trombone and tuba could play out more..... just saying.

[@danielbald9695]

bambino100011 they keep themselves back a little, which is a tradition of the Berliner Philharmoniker, they rather focus on articulation than on volume.

[@joufaxerxes7966]

Everyone's doing the 4th movement so fast...

[@davidmunguia1020]

Yeah. My teacher would always make us play things twice as fast to supposedly get the energy out of us.

[@bensexton7350]

I think it sounds a lot better this fast

[@jvcpdl]

The new York symphony record is faster

[@leungyatchun9552]

Bernstein’s version is much faster..

[@vinskilindqvist4554]

Chun Mozart bernstein ist scheisse

[@wojciechkaamarz8919]

szybciej sie nie dało?

[@jsot1988]

Looks like Alejandro and Edicson feel like at home with Gus. in front :)

[@kurtreck2716]

1:53 why does that double bass have five strings? edit: I just realised, its a German style double bass

[@bennybalderrama7653]

Was that Beethoven playing the trombone?

[@MB-ci2qf]

♡♡♡♡☆☆

[@brucekuehn4031]

What a great excerpt! Anyone else hear a little "John Williams" at the end?

[@astoriacub]

No, you heard a lot of Shostakovich in John Williams...

[@AndyHjo]

Just compare the Sado version and this version here on youtube (both on this channel) - I mean the orchestra seems to like Dudamel and I am sure he is propably a nice guy but I cannot understand why he is that famous. Luckily Petrenko is exactly the opposite and I am really looking forward to next season (please pay a visit in Frankfurt again!).

[@hopeagainsthope9553]

He got a haircut!

[@andrelousada]

A few years ago!!!! :)

[@GVZGQosqoruna]

he got grey hair

[@axelx4770]

Not angry enough. Not Russian enough. Dudamel is overrated.

[@christopherjeon1918]

sounds pretty communistic? idk..

[@duntech7]

Tempi, zu schnell !

[@MildnerA]

This is fantastically played but at this speed a pure virtuoso piece devoid of any meaning. Sorry, Dmitri Dmitriyevich.

[@Jupiter-T]

Idk, I'm used to hearing it faster. This didn't feel slow necessarily, but more precise than the speed I'm used to hearing.

[@joehamill6743]

Crap