Should Hindi be India’s National Language? | India Development Debate

Does India need an official national language or a link language? And should that language be Hindi? It is a question that becomes controversial whenever it is brought up, and this time the furor is even louder. Watch the big debate on India Development Debate.
Subscribe To ET Now For Latest Updates On Stocks, Business, Trading | ► goo.gl/SEjvK3
Subscribe Now To Our Network Channels :-
Times Now : goo.gl/U9ibPb
The NewsHour Debate : goo.gl/LfNgFF
To Stay Updated Download the Times Now App :-
Android Google Play : goo.gl/zJhWjC
Apple App Store : goo.gl/d7QBQZ
Social Media Links :-
Twitter - goo.gl/hA0vDt
Facebook - goo.gl/5Lr4mC
G+ - goo.gl/hYxrmj
Website - www.etnownews.com

[@RamaChandran-zl9zd]

Garga Chatterjee's arguments are wonderful.....he knows how to handle hindi chaunists

[@cbabu6102]

Garga..... Superb!

[@SunLightSunRavi]

Garga chaturvedi is mental

[@thegargaist]

All non hindi people must unite against Hindi imperialism

[@RamaChandran-zl9zd]

@@thegargaist you can not oppose fellow citizens in a democracy....the only option available to non -hindi speakers is demanding right to self-determination to people

[@123pocco]

North Indian politicians language imperialism Thu... U loot our tax revenues, now u loot our culture too.. shame on u...

[@ಕನ್ನಡದೇಶ]

Correct bro

[@mysterymagnet6614]

Excellent

[@skullcrusherm7425]

Àgreed

[@parmindershah4484]

not north indian only hindi belt .. i'm punjabi and i hate hindi imposition

[@orphan9334]

@@parmindershah4484 rightly said its the Hindi belt

[@suvam4uable]

INDIA is the union of diversity... NO HINDI IMPOSITION..... Proud of my Bengal..my Bangla language

[@SonuSinghmirzapur]

@Soren Utpal translate what ever you said in Sanskrit.

[@SonuSinghmirzapur]

@Soren Utpal I love to speak in English.

[@SonuSinghmirzapur]

@Soren Utpal And I feel proud when speaking in my Mother tongue -: Bengali

[@sujalpednekar6820]

@@SonuSinghmirzapur then speak Bengali why u want to speak hindi?

[@nireshm4933]

I'm from tamilnadu but that bangal guy perfectly talking about hindi imposition really proud that guy support all our regional language..

[@ngangomdorensingh1837]

You know that In the Manipur, Hindi movies are banned the last 3 decades...

[@3oranges4]

Thank u bro..Love from kerala...

[@mamtasrivastava2018]

From where are you?

[@queueueue8938]

@@mamtasrivastava2018 obvio he'll be from manipur

[@easypesy9169]

If North indians like only hindi language please don't collect tax from another language state. If you don't like us no problem but don't collect tax

[@vinodkumarbm8911]

They want everything for free bro !! Money (tax) and Power (in parliament)

[@ಕನ್ನಡದೇಶ]

Using our money and pushing garbage Hindi on non Hindi speaking states

[@anandank8192]

Southern states which not speaking hindi is well developed then hindi belt they need English and regional language enough need not useless hindi.

[@pranav.m.warrier7407]

Don't call any language useless man.. Regardless of the issue, it's still a language to be respected like all

[@MrHerojit]

Once upon a time in Manipur those who can speak hindi consider themselves as well educated n well known people.. But now we realize that our language becomes threat n endangered... This is how we suffer so we protect ourselves from hindinisation... Which is sponsored by Central government.. Through media and movie.... So we the North East people should support south Indian to prevent the imposition of hindi as national language..

[@nikkinikhitha2540]

Thank you 😊 love from AP

[@mamtasrivastava2018]

Tell me one thing, you know English very nicely which is a foreign language and that too from the country which ruled in India for around 2 centuries. You like this language as much that you are even writing comment in this language and Hindi which is our Indian language is becoming threat to your language. What a person you are! How nice my country's people are! ( I wrote English only for your sake of convenience, otherwise I didn't want to write English in this comment.)

[@keralanaturelover196]

@@mamtasrivastava2018 we must ban hindi in central jobs 80 percent hindiwalas

[@mamtasrivastava2018]

@@keralanaturelover196 Kya Hindi language se dushmani hai tumhe?

[@ankankumarpanja5004]

@@mamtasrivastava2018 north indians satrted calling us Bangladeshi cause our mother tongue is bengali😡😡😡😡

[@ngangomdorensingh1837]

Hey, Mr. Green, I'm from Manipur. Do you know about Manipur? In the northeast never accept Hindi happily that is too much... Don't stupid again... India Is not a Hindi country... We don't need Hindia...

[@manish6535]

Hindi should be national language

[@prasanna2562]

@@manish6535 it can't be,we south I don't allow that

[@user-fg9xu6os7f]

Tamil language is the very old language which was spoken in ancient time throughout the entire part of world....The civilization found in sindhu Harappa is tamil culture.

[@prasanna2562]

No one accept it,but the letters in there are exactly same as the tamil civilization letters in south

[@jackreacher4766]

Old is gold is not accepted by entire world. Being the oldest language.. How many ppl spk Tamil today?? The entire world shd hv spoken Hindi.... But major part of world derived their own language and avoided, boycotted, disliked, Tamil language

[@ngilirajesh]

@@jackreacher4766 That's why we are keeping our language with us, and you keep yours with you

[@jackreacher4766]

@@ngilirajesh FYI ...hindi won't belongs to any individual

[@ngilirajesh]

@@jackreacher4766 absolutely it doesn't belong to me,

[@bibekdas7449]

I am Bengali and I don't know Hindi. Often the Bihari people of my place criticise me for this even calling me illiterate. Someone even hit me for knowing English and a little of Japanese but not Hindi (ofcourse he was jealous of me). Plus a lot of central governed schools priorities Hindi over english (which is alien for our school) Hindi speakers go mess with your own stupid language and stop promoting it among us!

[@haraprasadghosh4692]

We want Bengali is national language

[@skylarkm5149]

At least now people of other non Hindi speaking states are realising what Tamil Nadu realised long ago and faught for the cause ever since.

[@sriluballa393]

Hindi = 500 years old; South Indian Languages not descendants of Sanskrit have over 4000 years of history that can be tracked. Honestly, I wish India stayed as a sub continent (like EU) while each state became its own country retaining its history, language, culture and empowering its people. Instead these idiots who do not want to learn a new language, but want to homogenize everyone to bring everyone to their level.

[@3oranges4]

True bro...Support from a proud malayalee speaker...

[@thomasranjit7781]

Why no South Indians not invited in debate ?????

[@doremon1670]

Thomas Ranjit because they want to show to the nation that there are more hindi supporters right. They don't want to show the reality.

[@thomasranjit7781]

@PS 4 Pro Gamer U r BJP IT cell worker.....go and get a life

[@soulislight]

PS 4 Pro Gamer : very funny; but look at your comment it is surely nonsense

[@skullcrusherm7425]

@PS 4 Pro Gamer but you are much more

[@easypesy9169]

@PS 4 Pro Gamer you don't like South indian language but you like South indian money, his knowledge,

[@pargunanl9130]

TN people or TN politicians are against learning Hindi.. we are against imposing Hindi.. for us both Hindi and English are foreign language.. we cannot accept Hindi as national language as it will benefit only Hindi speaking states.. states like TN will be treated as 2nd grade citizen as it’s not our language.. English is foreign language for everyone one and it linking language for overall world..

[@senthilmurugan3687]

Kamal fuck vani rekha, gowthami and 3 women run away from him shows his fuck and go move! He act multiple languages and earn, but polarized language politics n Tamil nadu

[@sriyakalicheti9900]

@PS 4 Pro Gamer why hindi?

[@rajtadvi7344]

@@sriyakalicheti9900.....so why do you South Indian people speak hindi in Maharashtra

[@Attitudezero884]

@@rajtadvi7344 becoz without hindi we cannot leave in mumbai yes you can leave without marathi that’s the situation you guys have made for yourself. The same situation we don’t want in our states.

[@gargikalita5840]

The person in the green coat says that we Northeasterns speak Hindi very happily. He's not a northeastern and hence he's not our representative. We speak Hindi but we don't accept it as our national language. We just like Bengalis and South Indians would prefer to preserve our mother tongue. Enough of this linguistic imperialism by North India.

[@rajeshranjan5170]

Ok Your tight slap on me

[@karta1229]

We can't tolerate this Hindi imperialism. Trust me all non-hindi states are becoming and will second grade citizens in our own land because of this Hindi imperialism. This is very dangerous for a federal country like India.

[@ebenezergeorge5685]

7:08 - He doesn't know the difference between 'Malayalam' and 'Malayali'...🤦‍♂️. Please pay a visit to a nearby high school !.

[@Shivambasu]

My mother tongue is Bengali, India is not a Hindi country. Stop Hindi imperialism.

[@Asifalikhan2]

Maharastra.marathi Gujarat.gujrathi West Bengal..Bengali Karnataka..Kannada Kerala Malayalam Andhra.telugu Telangana.telugu Tamilnadu.tamil Bihar.bhojpuri Jammu and kasmir..kasmir Punjab.punjabi.. 8 northeast states ..their language Rajasthan..marwari Orissa..oriya Now before speaking..think..do you really believe indians talk hindi

[@nikkinikhitha2540]

Hindi percentage increase because of their uncontrolled production they keep on producing as if some one conducting competition for them

[@rajeshranjan5170]

This is a tight slap on my face

[@nikkinikhitha2540]

@@rajeshranjan5170 y is it so 🤔

[@rajeshranjan5170]

@@nikkinikhitha2540 we have uncontrolled production on competition basis. As you said

[@nikkinikhitha2540]

@@rajeshranjan5170 oooooo kk

[@nikkinikhitha2540]

@@rajeshranjan5170 UP and Bihar alone occupies 25% of India's total population and also fertility rate is very high that's why I mentioned like that

[@MrVipins]

The man in green overcoat doesn't even know which language is spoken in Kerala and yet he has the full survey that it's usage is dropped :)

[@arumugamjaipal2327]

Why a tamil guy isn't there in this debate??

[@sanjeeverde8066]

There were many shows and debates having Tamil people

[@arunkk004]

What will happen if India becomes an only Hindi speaking country? It will probay become one of the most poorest country in the world. Because there are higher chances that just like Korea India will become North and South permanently. Ironically, in Korea also south is doing pretty well!

[@shin-ishikiri-no]

S.Koreans and N. Koreans speak the same language...

[@surojeetchatterji9966]

​​@@shin-ishikiri-no Their issue was economic & political ideology. India can become like them based on language. Then there will be 2 India. Hindistan(North India) & Bharat(East & South India). 😂

[@karta1229]

Kannada should be given equal status as hindi

[@petagonkyi]

Northeast have lost their mother tongue as the government refused to recognize their mother tongue as langauge to supplant Hindi. Same in Sikkim where the original people of Sikkim - Lephchas and next Bhutias language are not recognized while migrant Nepali dominate due to the British population transfer (Nepali to Sikkim).

[@RamaChandran-zl9zd]

Hindu chaunism is embedded in the heart of the constitution of India (part 17)... as long as part 17 remains in the constitution.. Hindi speakers don't have any moral right to call anyone as chaunists...

[@ಕನ್ನಡದೇಶ]

Three language formula is the real another example of 370 article we should remove this thukali garbage formula

[@subhankardebnath3019]

We Don't want Hindi Use Hindi in Up And Bihar The Hindu Heartland belts in india

[@369aryas]

Bihar has already lost its own diverse languages be coz of this hindi only . who told u that Bihar has just one language ? Its just that biharis didn't resist and let their languages grow so if u don't know the culture of Bihar plz don't speak

[@debashishdas4865]

Magadhee and Bhojpuri are languages of Bihar.

[@naveensidda3200]

I think the govt. Is trying to make trivialize the main issues like brutal diminution in economy by bringing and popping up these type of ridiculous issues.

[@nikkinikhitha2540]

Exactly. 💯

[@satishct6857]

Garga rocks.....the two hindi chauvinistic should be sent to correction centres. I liked when Garga quoted CN Annadurai the man because of whom we have all not been subjected to the hindi medium education which would have been a reality had Hindi been allowed to have become the national language in 1950.

[@toshiyanger4121]

You want to impose Hindi on whole India but northeast people are still called Chinese & Corona. Discriminated on every level even by kids, especially in northern India we face this problems.

[@johnson0ajar]

I am from Tamil Nadu, I have listed few details how imposition of Hindi will affect Tamil, this is applicable for other regional language. Below I have provided explanation as to why the claim that Hindi is good for future survival of tamil culture and prosperity is a false propaganda by the Hindi belt politicians. Their agenda is to strength their political base in the south by imposing their language. In doing so, they will have a political future in the southern states at the expense of regional parties. Already we are losing the use of our language in several fields due to English, with Hindi there will not be any requirement of Tamil in the future. Let us imagine Tamil language is in a coffin. I will list the nails that has been slowly added to that coffin since the British and Indian independence. 1. Children who study in English medium schools, science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology, engineering all are taught in English. English being the world language it is good for our future survival. People who take tamil as secondary language in english medium, will be able to read and write tamil at basic level. They’ll not be creators in tamil as their language of thinking would be English. Their knowledge creation would only be in English. These people live in the cities who jump from one city to another for their economic prosperity and survival. 2. Children who study in tamil medium will have English as their secondary language and will be able to read/write English at basic level. These children live in secondary cities and villages. They find it difficult to pursue higher studies in science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology in English when they join colleges. Forced to create new knowledge in English. To fix this the number of children in English medium in secondary cities and villages has increased in the last 50 years. With this increase, tamil in future will not be required to explain science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology and would only be used for communication, basic reading and writing. If Hindi is going to be introduced, we don’t need tamil for communication, everyone would prefer Hindi after 3-5 generations. 3. In our society, Tamil is currently being used in religion, entertainment and literature (This will fade) with the growth of English and Hindi. Tamil literature will slowly decline as the number of reader move to English and Hindi. If there is no market for tamil literature there will no longer be any creative writing in it. Only copying and translation in the future. 4. No knowledge creation in tamil (i.e. scientific, technical paper, journal) in the following field science, geography, physics, chemistry, history, maths, biology, engineering. All scientific paper has to be published in English. Reference to knowledge is only available in English. 5. Administration will slowly move towards English/hindi. 6. High court in Tamil Nadu cannot use tamil language to interpret the law and provide judgement. Only English/hindi. Tamil vocabulary will not grow in this field of law. The requirement of tamil language has been reduced to the following field Communication, religion, entertainment and literature. This will also die in another few generation and would be replaced by other language English/Hindi. Tamil requirement in science, technology, business and law field has been slowly eroded because there is an easy replacement (i.e. english). The question is do we accept that status quo. If we accept it and continue then slowly the tamil language will loose it significance as it’s vocabulary will not grow in the above field and because of that their will not be any new literature and knowledge in tamil language in the coming generation. So it will be avoided by the coming generation for their survival. BJP/RSS peoples are spreading false message through news channel regarding the benefits of learning Hindi, when there is none. I agree the state politicians for their selfish gain has given away the state rights, which is hurting the public. Why should we burden our son/daughter to learn additional language in their childhood when its benefits are minimal in the future, it would be required only for socialising and entertainment. When we are paying taxes to the central government what has the central government done to promote the regional language so its usage can be strengthen in various fields. In high courts we can't use our language for arguments and judgement. There is a hidden agenda to reduce the use of regional language as official language so that usage of Hindi/English becomes the main language in trade, education, business and administration.

[@PoonchNZ]

None of the Indian languages are fit for being an official language on an Indian level.

[@Fact_Checker_F]

How many languages you learnt to come to this conclusion?

[@PoonchNZ]

I can speak 6 languages.

[@lingambalaraman2544]

The perfect solution to solve this is Make English the only official language and to abolish the status to hindi

[@cbabu6102]

Garga Chatterjee, u r the Great👍👍👍👍👍 very informative....

[@SunLightSunRavi]

Pagal hei garga chaterjee

[@thegargaist]

@@SunLightSunRavi গুটখা খোর

[@123pocco]

Professor nios is in fantasy world, he need a psychiatrist help..

[@satheeshbabu7724]

Garga Chatterjee's wonderful speech.

[@mehmoodaslam9160]

Debating for hindi language in English lol

[@murugangurusamy719]

Person who participated from west bengal.he clearly pointed out all about northies.thanks to that particular person.

[@kitarvin770]

The common link language of the earth is Love.

[@muhammedshahir1148]

The professor of nios is liar English percentage is 12%

[@nagrec]

Tamil is the only language we breathe..we don't bother about Hindi..Tamil is our identity..no body can change it..if any Shah imposes Hindi on us, country will be broken into pieces...

[@manish6535]

Please try, indian army and Sri lankan army teach you a lesson

[@Fact_Checker_F]

@@manish6535 Kamal haasan made the statement in public, why didn't he get punished yet? I'll share the youtube link if you need! North usually begs money from south to their survival, No armies can f***k us babe

[@athimulambalaji4803]

Wow 99.99% against Hindi 🤙👌✅✅✅✅

[@parthibans4969]

We really need a south party who can form a gov in central. Also the law that allows to have number of seats based on population in a state must be removed. Only when south is United we can protect our identity and rights or else those who resist them will be treated as second class citizen and will be made to taxes for their evergrowing population. North didn't change, past they doing Sanskrit supremacy now since it's dead they have shifted to Hindi supremacy.

[@SathishShanmugam79]

Hindi not official language in type c region of article 343 please check what is type c region in article 343 . next point you are saying mad that its spoken 15 times than my tamil. Tamil is national language is some countries but hindi didnt attain national language status in any country also tamil has been highly recognized in countries like Fiji, Mauritius, australia, cannada, UK, USA. So Tamil has diplomat and high social status in many countries but not your Hindi not even in India . English is there in my Laptop, phone,programming language, Television, international airport. What is the need of hindi, can i able to write C,Java,or any language in Hindi, getting hindi keyboard in my laptop. I have need of english so learning, Tamil is my identity so learning tamil. Hindi is neither my need nor my identity then why should i make it as mandatory. If i have interest i will learn hindi, or telugu or kannada or french like eating dish which i love to eat not the one which you feed into my mouth Comedy no:1 Hindi uniting India My friend went to kerala and learnt malayalam then spoke to the people in malayalam . another friend came to chennai from karnataka learnt tamil and spoke tamil to all. what is mean by hindi uniting india to stop these people in speaking local people language just making malayali to speak in hindi with kannadiga is uniting india. Intention is making hindi people grab all opportunities and spread finally dominating india Comedy no 2: People will be benefited by Hindi Hindi people could not get proper job opportunity in theri hindi speaking states like UP and Bihar who are all coming to south india (non-hindi states). Hindi people themselves did not get any benefit Comedy no3: Lets make hindi as national language Initially states divided based on regional language then slowly added hindi as official languages , now they want hindi to dominate othe languages making it as national language. Comedy No4: Hindi is not imposed. But even LPG cylinder has safety instructions only for the customers who knows Hindi and English. So government forcing rural area customers to learn either english or hindi which means imposing. Comedy No5: Hindi will be link language So funny already i need a large link language connecting to global countries called english , can i speak hindi as link language when i visit USA ,Cannada or Australia. when i already have a large link language connecting whole world then why a small another link language specific to India, is India not in the world? Comedy No6: 45% of Indian population speaks Hindi language Great survey and census taken, So what. Did you take any survey to those 45% of the population whether they agree to make hindi as link or national language. please take that since there are lot of people among 45% hindi speaking population against this idea, example hindi speaking people in karnataka, maharastra, kerala, west bengal told they are against in making hindi as link or national language. Comedy No7: Hindi is the only language can be made as National language to roam around India Is it? Tamil is the national language is some countries but hindi is not attained national language in any countries. Even tamil has become highly recognized language in countries like fiji, mauritius, australia, karnataka, germany, USA, UK,China,etc. If we claim this way i bet all the hindi language state people will fire like anything if tamil do the same they will stamp as Chauvinist. but i never say any language of India should be made as National language since we believe in Language equality not uniformity

[@manassanyal462]

Down with the slogan Hindi Hindu Hindustan which would have been implemented if NDA won 400 seats in the last Lok Sabha elections

[@Dazak]

How is making a factual point dealing in regional chauvinism? The reason for the drop in percentage of southern languages is due to effective population control where as there is a spike in population in the Hindi speaking states. The facts are facts. The increase in usage of English has no role in the decrease of southern languages., no one speaks English at home.

[@malarrganesan2008]

First the BJP government that the people elected should carry out its responsibilities in these areas first before trying to show the world what India is by hindi language. First improve the Housing . A robust housing mo istry in every state that people that provides a safe and clean environment - standard of average Indian need to be raises Health services. A robust health ministry in every state. Good and reliable hospitals for average Indian A robist transport ndusyry. With proper roads and good lighting and ads and proper lighting excellent regulatory body overseeing the safety and speed limits. A robust water system that drains away floods. A robust education ministry to provide for each state. Provide clean air, water and hygiene before talking about unifying India with HINDI. YOU HAVE 5 YEARS. INVEST YOUR TIME WISELY. ONCE THE ABOVE IS DONE, PEOPLE WILL K OW WHAT LANGUAGE WILL UNITE THEM

[@12345678965732]

we dont need Hindi

[@thekhalsa1316]

We don't need you

[@thekhalsa1316]

where has gone Apostrophe😄😄😄😄😄

[@MrPoornakumar]

It is raising a non-issue to the level of a national issue, just because an individual or two want it so.

[@stevenrawin4830]

European Union doesn't have common language they have 24 official languages. If english isn't official language in malte After brexit English will be removed from official language status in European Union

[@The_final_Boss-z4i]

No Ireland speaks English as first language and hence it makes English a official language and it connects all diversed European Region .

[@rez1953]

His this important Now When no employment DGP ????? Why the hell have Hindi Just think which language gives more GDP And fallow to come up in life Later think of the National language

[@vivekanandgorle3770]

what is the problem that govt is trying to solve by making Hindi as a national language except creating useless controversy ? till now, every one is happy with their language.but now there is unnecessary controversy and conflict to divert the attention from actual issues and to polarize the voters based on language. our students in government schools are not getting quality education in the schools but that is not the problem for the government but how come language becomes the problem that needs to be fixed ?

[@rpaul8497]

Not language but economy is

[@pargunanl9130]

They want to divert the economy slowdown issue

[@Fact_Checker_F]

Because Modi could not learn english!

[@arjunreels655]

now north states are slaves of hindi...lost some of their own states, Languages..and cultures..for hindi...but no use...they are not devoloping, for what they took?.. for improving popularity of hindi?....we should avoid hindi forever it's pakisthan language....With English, I can learn science, math, politics, economics, history, medicine. I can hold conversations with people from around the world.with my language i can speak with my people and my family....i can know my language ethics cultures.....What will I know from learning Hindi? becoming poor mindsets like them....we won match on fighting hindi imposition

[@thomasranjit7781]

All the bjp Hindi goon squad send their children in English medium school

[@SathishShanmugam79]

Hindi not official language in type c region of article 343 please check what is type c region in article 343 . next point you are saying mad that its spoken 15 times than my tamil. Tamil is national language is some countries but hindi didnt attain national language status in any country also tamil has been highly recognized in countries like Fiji, Mauritius, australia, cannada, UK, USA. So Tamil has diplomat and high social status in many countries but not your Hindi not even in India . English is there in my Laptop, phone,programming language, Television, international airport. What is the need of hindi, can i able to write C,Java,or any language in Hindi, getting hindi keyboard in my laptop. I have need of english so learning, Tamil is my identity so learning tamil. Hindi is neither my need nor my identity then why should i make it as mandatory. If i have interest i will learn hindi, or telugu or kannada or french like eating dish which i love to eat not the one which you feed into my mouth Comedy no:1 Hindi uniting India My friend went to kerala and learnt malayalam then spoke to the people in malayalam . another friend came to chennai from karnataka learnt tamil and spoke tamil to all. what is mean by hindi uniting india to stop these people in speaking local people language just making malayali to speak in hindi with kannadiga is uniting india. Intention is making hindi people grab all opportunities and spread finally dominating india Comedy no 2: People will be benefited by Hindi Hindi people could not get proper job opportunity in theri hindi speaking states like UP and Bihar who are all coming to south india (non-hindi states). Hindi people themselves did not get any benefit Comedy no3: Lets make hindi as national language Initially states divided based on regional language then slowly added hindi as official languages , now they want hindi to dominate othe languages making it as national language. Comedy No4: Hindi is not imposed. But even LPG cylinder has safety instructions only for the customers who knows Hindi and English. So government forcing rural area customers to learn either english or hindi which means imposing. Comedy No5: Hindi will be link language So funny already i need a large link language connecting to global countries called english , can i speak hindi as link language when i visit USA ,Cannada or Australia. when i already have a large link language connecting whole world then why a small another link language specific to India, is India not in the world? Comedy No6: 45% of Indian population speaks Hindi language Great survey and census taken, So what. Did you take any survey to those 45% of the population whether they agree to make hindi as link or national language. please take that since there are lot of people among 45% hindi speaking population against this idea, example hindi speaking people in karnataka, maharastra, kerala, west bengal told they are against in making hindi as link or national language. Comedy No7: Hindi is the only language can be made as National language to roam around India Is it? Tamil is the national language is some countries but hindi is not attained national language in any countries. Even tamil has become highly recognized language in countries like fiji, mauritius, australia, karnataka, germany, USA, UK,China,etc. If we claim this way i bet all the hindi language state people will fire like anything if tamil do the same they will stamp as Chauvinist. but i never say any language of India should be made as National language since we believe in Language equality not uniformity

[@satheeshbabu7724]

people's tax money is not for gambling: ------------------------------------------------------------- English and Hindi being the official languages of India, why Central government spend more money on Hindi alone? Only 4% of the 43% Hindi-speaking population is literate. high population and poor economy in Hindi-speaking states are causes of Terrorism, Caste, Honor killing etc. The number of students failing in Hindi was around 10 lakh in 2019. Nearly 7.97 lakh students in the Uttar Pradesh - known as the Hindi heartland - have failed in Hindi in the UP Secondary Board examinations for class 10 and 12. in 2020. Around 2.39 lakh students of High School and Intermediate of the Board had skipped their Hindi papers.

[@rez1953]

Taxes been given by south India is more and have Hindi as one language

[@suniljayashankara996]

Jambudveepa untold mysteries: Sanskrit is the mother tongue of all languages ​​in ancient Vedic culture. In ancient times, Female rulers had mothers of all languages ​​in Tamil and Kannada. Majority of Tamil speaking practice around the world during Kumari Kandam Lemuria & Jambudveepa. The vast majority of Kannada and Sanskrit languages ​​are used for mantras to worship God. Later Jambudveepa peoples give rise to Hindusium Buddhism Jainism. Hindi is not National language of India.

[@thomasranjit7781]

This channel is BJP dhalla

[@leemi8931]

Indian govt degrades Non Hindi medium ppl in every Union govt exams and Services..

[@om_2020]

Only Marathi in Maharashtra Stop hindi imposition

[@thisiskaos9249]

Hindi speaking belt has the highest TFR (Total Fertility Rate). As per Govt. of India's 2021 Family Health Survey, TFR of Bihar stood at 3.0 (almost double) against West Bengal's 1.6. As the cow belt or the Hindi speaking belt continues to produce babies at a far greater rate than the non-Hindi speaking population, the ratio of Hindi speaking population is increasing for obvious reason. TFR of Jhharkhand: 2.3, UP: 2.4, MP: 2.0, Rajasthan: 2.0 - need we say more?

[@MymobilePhone-pc9nl]

I went siliguri nepali was telling .india is hindi. I understood there education.

[@mrithun15]

The anchor seems to be biased and rooting for Hindi.

[@world_conquerer]

Right term it's Hindi imperialism

[@MymobilePhone-pc9nl]

It's mental concoctions of hindi wala hindi is the national language. No sorry .Hindi is north india language.

[@jayaprakash6850]

Northeast speaking Hindi happily? Tamilnadu learning Hindi by choice not for making national language

[@biplabnaskar6509]

No hindi

[@MymobilePhone-pc9nl]

Pakistan was divided in to 2 parts because of language. Govt don't press hindi on non hindi speaking states .

[@ngangomdorensingh1837]

What the stupid debate... Remove Hindi from India... Stop occupied theory....

[@manish6535]

Chup

[@aldrinpeter7461]

Look at the development of hindi speaking states..English is a better link language as it links to international needs too

[@jesto8672]

ഹിന്ദി നിരോധികകൂക, (Kerala) Ban Hindi We South indians are also Indian citizens Hindi is also a regional language

[@garvthakur7662]

All the south indians hate hindi but we don't hate their language I even want to learn telugu and tamil I like their culture but they don't like us So sad but it is reality 😔😔

[@OrcaPod-ge4yq]

​@@garvthakur7662it's not true. I am a south Indian from karnataka, most South indians like Hindi but don't want hindi to be national language of India as it hives other languages of India inferior status. For communication we can use English or create a new language which is not the native language of any Indian

[@garvthakur7662]

@@OrcaPod-ge4yq sorry for the comment if it hurt you. I am very ashamed for that comment 2 years later I wasn't mature enough to understand these things 😞

[@OrcaPod-ge4yq]

@@garvthakur7662 ji kohi baat nahi sanskrit behtar option hain kyunki wo lagbhag kisi bharatiya ka matra basha ya mother tongue nahi hain. Lekin mulle aur Rice bag converts nahi managey kahengey yeh sanatanio ka basha hain

[@jayaprakash6850]

Hindi supporters have lot of vengeance

[@srinivas2182]

Sir can you please make a video on who can become a prime minister of India. A person or party which as won less than 10 percent seat's are dreaming to become prime minister. All parties should become national parties On party should stick to regional party label In future these party may hurt the country unity Please share your views on this issue

[@thomasranjit7781]

First impose Hindi then conquer south India

[@dcmhsotaeh]

Thomas Ranjit Keeping part of the population under their belt is inbuilt in the psyche of some North Indian elite Now all tricks are being tried to subdue 60 %if their own countrymen using Language as a pretext Whereas south had Basaveshwara s Lingayat movement a millennium ago which spelt out equality of castes and genders and also primacy of local language even above Sanskrit That movement happened a thousand years ago Cowbelt North India never had anything like it Dravidian movements of tamilnadu in recent years also was also bulwark against one group people dominating others

[@srb909]

South,east and north-east India will beat the shit out of your north India

[@MymobilePhone-pc9nl]

Day dreams. Hindi is for north india. Not all india

[@jayaprakash6850]

Amit Shah do not have concern for this own mother tongue. That's why he is promoting Hindi. Hindi should not be National language. Here Hindi supporters point is invalid

[@aman6828]

Why should you impose Hindi.All can be equal without imposing other's language.We don't identify ourselves as Hindi Speaking.Garga Da knows how to shut up these Hindi Chauvinists of North.

[@akhileshbudakoti8753]

Dear south indian brothers .. plz do not fight .. its not imp what u and we speak .. what is imp is we all breathe under the same tricolour 🇮🇳 with pride .. I am against English ..its a British Raj language ... plz dnt fall prey to some regional parties who just exist because of such controversies .. BTW I AM A GARHWALI which is a Dialect in Uttarakhand .. u wouldnt have even heard of it .. the point is ... I love Tamil telgu Malayam Bengali Marathi and all indian languages and dialects ... and Hindi 🙏 Vande Mataram .. 🤘🙏

[@anbuk8265]

Dear North Indian brother, we are not opps to hindi, the fact is we don't want to learn hindi.Hindi is just one of the regional language in Indian.See I'm ready to learn another regional language Hindi . You hindi people ready to learn tamil?

[@lila-A]

South Indians are always ready to learn another language but if u force we will not. Hindi is just another language that's it nothing to do with us if we want if there s need for us then we will learn it ourself. Everyone telling us not fight first learn our language be it Tamil,telugu,kannada,malayalam n then tell us.

[@nagrec]

Please don't follow Hindi imperialism..don't fall to Hindi dominance..India does not need any link language..we have English..if u don't like English learn the language of land where u live..If u want link language, then learn Tamil and Bengali...u can survive in no. Hindi lands..

[@debjitbhowmik5805]

Motherboard u r typing ds lecture in English and dts why everyone is understanding ds..I hv no business in Chennai or kolkata..if u need job here first learn the local language..Tera hindi tere gar ke andar suraksit rakh..nikal a to fir gar me ghusaunga

[@GodTheMaster1989]

Hello Guys... Respecting any language is nothing but wherever you go try to learn and speak in their local language... Otherwise you don't have any moral right to stay in that state ( South/North/East/ West State)....

[@ankitsanyal9832]

GARGA CHATTERJEE EXCELLENT REPLY

[@MymobilePhone-pc9nl]

Hindi speaking states are getting benifits suckling by other's states. From central govt. Plz check it.

[@athimulambalaji4803]

All here against hindi is leader ✅✅✅✅

[@chandanguchait8948]

জয় বাংলা🐯

[@souravbanerjee5270]

জয় বাংলা ।।

[@dr.vedpalsingh1530]

Why hindu hate hindi?

[@leemi8931]

Coz Bimaru Bjp Cong Politicians intentionally deny our languages in every union govt jobs and services *just to promote Hindi*

[@shin-ishikiri-no]

@@leemi8931 Then why do you accept English?

[@leemi8931]

@@shin-ishikiri-no for the same why you accepted English.

[@shin-ishikiri-no]

@@leemi8931 Colonialism and slavery... OK. At least Hindi is a choice.

[@leemi8931]

@@shin-ishikiri-no For Us Tamil is the choiCe.

[@rameshtr1202]

In our country tamilians and Hindi speaking people are hate other languages people's all' other people's are united supports national integration and nothing wrong in learning other of the state to know each other.we Karnataka people are having own alfhabatic and numbers in kannada laungvage ಸಂಗೀತ, ನೃತ್ಯ ವೈಭವದ ಸಾಹಿತ್ಯ ಸಂಸ್ಕೃತಿ ೧೨೩೪೫೬೭೮೯೧೦ . Only kannada people having Karnataka Sangeetha and Hindustani sangeet, Bheemsen joshi,Kumar gandharva,gangavva hangal, Seshadri gavai,panchakshari gavai, basva Raj Raj guru,Balappa hukkeri and kannada is shastri ya bhasha. won 8 ganapeeta award,on Bharata Ratna parasthi,great history chalukyas,rastrakutas, gangas,hoysals,kadambas ,krishna devaraya.kumara vyasa ,pampa,rana Jana,amarashilpi jakanachari,,ಟಿಪ್ಪು sultan, Hydarali, sir Mirja Ismail,VShantaram, Mysore kings kittur Rani chennamma,chitra durga port,bijapur sultan,golgumbaj shravana belagola ,Arabian sea, kaveri krishna,mahadayi, Tungabhadra,Hospet family, gokak falls ,shravathi jogfalls, bababuda giri,kudremukha ,gokarna,Karwar port,kaiga plant,Udupi krishna temple, Dharmasthala ,chamundi hills , beautiful palaces, museums Dharwad, Hubli Karnataka univercity,Dharwad peda,kunda,jawari roti, Mysore pak,Mysore silk sarees,,molalmur sarees,sant shisunal sharief,illkal saree ,Ragi mudde, roti, coffee and Hanuman birth place Ramayan ke hanuman kannadiga,basaveshwara brahman vatu , established Veerashiva dharma,Kempe gowda,sangoli rayannaa, ancestors of Chatrapati shivaji originally from Kannada origan from soratur in Karnataka gadag district Madhava chsraya Raghavendra swamy,,pandara pura vittala, are kannadigas etc this is the history of Karnataka is having own state antham ,nada geethe.

[@nagrec]

As long as Tamils,Bengalis survive in this world Hindi can't be imposed on us..Hindi chauvinism has to be eradicated..

[@MymobilePhone-pc9nl]

If learned hindi consequence puchka wala

[@jayaprakash6850]

This anchor is clearly biased

[@jayaprakash6850]

This anchor and 2 supporters goes to correction home

[@lokendrasingh6468]

Sbhi angrej h yha To hindi kyu

[@msr7373]

I agree with Garga that Hindi shouldn’t be implemented in the country but he is blatantly racist when he says that: 1. Hindi is useful for Marwari and Gujarati businessmen to link cow belt people (how will he feel if someone starts calling Bengalis as Machhi (fish) belt 2. Urdu hasn’t been given its due share as Urdu is being eaten by Hindi in its own homeland (UP Bihar Delhi Etc.) in addition to the onslaught of people who call Urdu as islamic and not suitable as per Indian ethics 3. Hindi belt plays a very important role in economic generation of many non hindi states as they send their products to West Bengal and other port states for exports. And if Hindi belt isn’t producing any revenue then even Bengal is just a former shadow of its past, Calcutta is no longer an important city as it was before independence , Delhi is generating more revenue then Kolkata , West Bengal ya a lost revenue in past 3-4 decades to other states hence garga has no right to attack others

[@surojeetchatterji9966]

U just needs to Cope Abdul with reality Garga was bang on target. 😂 though it was racist, but racism needs to be treated with counter racism like Garga did. 😂

[@AshutoshKumar-re2bc]

Gorga he is not omit shoh his ne is Amit sah...

[@nitinitsme]

This shud hav been done in 1990

[@pratapkesharipal1121]

its just a saying that hindi overthrone other languages,but the real fact is english is diminshing our all indian language.

[@shin-ishikiri-no]

I don't understand why they hate Hindi, but accept English...

[@Attitudezero884]

@@shin-ishikiri-no becoz hindi is a shitty language.

[@rez1953]

Don’t stop with populations

[@thekhalsa1316]

Say proudly we are hindi.Hindustaan is our

[@nagrec]

Say proudly we are Tamils and Indians

[@nagrec]

India belongs to Tamils..rest all migrants

[@shin-ishikiri-no]

If India wants to benefit from this debate, they should have each state compete to build the best infrastructure and education system (15 year period). The winning states language becomes taught in every state of India (but of course each state keeps regional language also). English should be optional 3rd language for most Indians. Otherwise, your culture will become diluted by alien Western European culture more and more... Christians will get more than Hindu.

[@Attitudezero884]

Oh fuck off northie we are already developed in every terms you mentioned now learn our languages.