silent book reviews

⭐️instagram: / haleypham
⭐️brand inquiries: [e-mail]

[@karlahaake2820]

This tells me everything and nothing at the same time

[@CalCipher_cLL0wm]

she had me at the gagging motions for the None of this is True novel 💀

[@EnergyGrader]

What’s the first one I’m confused 😂😂

[@jigglypuff_foryoutube1700]

@@just.me.111amen!! and everyone needs Him!

[@curatedbychai]

Same 😂

[@sakina-ym6lx]

@@just.me.111 Your reply isn't even related to the video nor the commenter.

[@lilyisswann]

The most creative book review I’ve ever seen 😭 good job haley

[@raqveel]

This type of review isn't her idea. It's been trend for a while, the idea it's from a girl on tiktok

[@GetawayDriver13]

Des actually did this first, so Haley may have been inspired by her, but yes wonderfully funny idea ❤

[@MissAmericanaa.]

@@GetawayDriver13I think I also saw someone do it before Des! The video might have been posted later and I just saw it before hers though

[@jesscscca]

this is a booktok trend!

[@GetawayDriver13]

@@MissAmericanaa. ohhhh yes you could be right, also I LOVE YOU USERNAME SO MUCH!

[@EmilySagan-ph5qm]

That first one was personal 🤣

[@Itsz_me_Mario]

2.9k likes but no comments?? That ends here.

[@EmilySagan-ph5qm]

@@Itsz_me_Mario bro trust i didn’t expect to get this many likes for no one to comment

[@HopeButMiserable]

Normal people was absolute shit I dont understand the hype about it 😭😭

[@lolilololhi4098]

@@HopeButMiserablethe girls that get it get it the girls that don’t don’t

[@ladymire]

@@HopeButMiserableit took me MONTHS to finish it just bc it was so slow and awful

[@CF-of7qf]

The way I had no idea what any of these meant🤣

[@mariamafifi2617]

But they all seemed horrible in their own way

[@mitza420]

​@@mariamafifi2617 isn't the first book praised, there even is a series made out of it?

[@milo3908]

@@mitza420it is

[@angelsxaesthetic9147]

@@mitza420o thought it ment she like it first and then started to get mad at it

[@Bella-wp7wz]

@@mitza420 I thought she was squeezing the book like she didn’t like it

[@maymayyyy]

I don't know if she hates them all or what 😂😂

[@merlin2946]

Lmfao same, I saw another one and I didn’t get it lol

[@lilypad431]

Not going to lie it makes me want to read none of them haha

[@angelashinner]

U guys are acoustic 💀

[@lordstormy77]

This is how i interpreted them 1. DEAR GOD UGHHHH 2. Hm okay 3. Hm not bad but THAT ONE PART 4. THE TWIST OH GOOD HEAVEANS w o w 5. Hm i don't hate this 6. This was sweet and cute I love it

[@Palikawii]

I can't tell if the first one is negative or positive 😭 when I love something I crush it and bite it in my mind

[@thethriftyfawn]

THANK YOU Haley for ensuring the camera is not flipped backwards in this short form video. It drives me NUTS when other creators don't take the ONE SECOND it takes to flip the image to the correct orientation if they're using a front facing camera! Especially on book channels- how are we suppose to read the words if the words are backwards??!? We are word people!!!

[@houstonhughes184]

If nothing else, they could at least flip it back in post.

[@idontknowabby]

oh my gosh yes!! i can’t stand when i have to squint and try to decipher the title 😭 (especially when they have multiple books in the video)

[@thethriftyfawn]

@@houstonhughes184 YES!!! That is option two, which also takes only ONE second to complete the task, to create an accurate and viewer friendly experience.

[@Ykibmh]

Oh and when the intro is obscenely long and then they show the cover for like 1 second! Like for God's sake, please just tell me what book it is.

[@LM.312]

I honestly don’t think it’s that of a big deal to be criticizing other booktubers for. Like I get that we’re word people but… titles are pretty short anyways and we can usually recognize what it is through the cover design. I get that it’s constructive criticism which can be helpful but that’s just my personal opinion.

[@a69flsi12]

This would be so good if I understood facial expressions😂

[@AllisonJones1875]

That's what I was thinking.

[@leiabrown7948]

The “✋🏼✊🏼✋🏼✊🏼” lol😂 thank you for ensuring me on what books to read😅

[@jessicabarger9069]

😂😂😂 the sound of that hand motion makes me wanna unalive myself

[@Adriem86]

I sincerely hope this starts a trend Best book reviews I've seen in a minute❤

[@zeldycakes954]

It already a trend a woman on booktok started it she's called stephreadsalot

[@sol_munoz]

It was already a trend...

[@TinyPrettyNini]

It’s already a trend😭😭 on IG and TIKTOK

[@birnapetursdottir2616]

you understand this? or is this sarcasm i can’t tell

[@JLiz-ie7tp]

Normal people’s lack of quotation marks was genuinely so upsetting

[@kurlykaitlyn]

Lots of books are that way. It can get frustrating but it’s actually quite popular in literary fiction

[@melxnielong]

It was done on purpose. To further exemplify miscommunication

[@L-tb9kk]

idk how ppl like it i found it extremely boding and badly written

[@constantinaheres-yv4hu]

@@L-tb9kkwell that’s just ur opinion, so no need to hate on it

[@L-tb9kk]

@@constantinaheres-yv4hu yeah obviously thats why i said i found it

[@-sunrosel-]

Now i know what books to get, thanks Haley

[@Trinitie_Faerie]

0 hate intended but you spell her name Haley I'm pretty sure

[@-sunrosel-]

@@Trinitie_Faerieoh yeah right my bad!

[@courtneyange202]

My neurodivergent brain isn’t sure what some of these mean..

[@asliyase]

Saame.

[@blacksheep9144]

Dw my neurotypical brain can’t even figure it out

[@IloveGardensandteaparties]

Same.

[@isabelcox-croteau444]

It's ok, the neurotypicals are just as confused.

[@hp_universe_obsessed6890]

I'm not confused. I just said, ok that means that and that means that and if it doesn't, well that's too bad.

[@Ki-KisWorld]

The clapping 🤣 also that was very insightful

[@desi_einerson]

This is literally the best thing I’ve seen all day… well done Haley

[@xXJunnaXx]

???? Bot

[@LalangelXx]

That fact that I understood everything was crazy 😂

[@Ur_Fav_Addie368]

I love the facial expressions 😂

[@LiahnaForbes]

this was perfect, you need to do more of these XD

[@SwavyCurlyCourtney]

Somehow I got so much out of this! I fully understand exactly how each of these books made you feel now. This was really helpful! Thanks.

[@gaayatrimenon502]

That was the loudest and most understandable book review I've ever witnessed😭✋

[@luna-qy5fg]

the way this made me wanna read some of these books, this was such affective advertising i swear

[@saintttbeats]

I hope this becomes a massive book trend 😂

[@millie4988]

first one was so real

[@jjvmxs]

i find a lot of my communication to be silent and physical and i get this immensely. i knew exactly what you meant every time

[@hayleighmorgans]

Bro is the loudest, quiet person

[@lylab1010]

I loved all in and the naturals series in general it was so good

[@jennabraseth]

Normal people is so accurate so frustrating yet good

[@litzy_lara]

i wanted to like it so bad but i dnf it

[@khushinagpal2989]

I didn't like the book but the last paragraph had some essence

[@94BlueGirl]

I couldn’t get through it

[@ludvig3242]

Nah, it’s shit 😂

[@mariajosenieto4079]

This is my new favorite way to watch book reviews

[@bta7658]

this was actually the best book review because I hate spoilers so much, I don't even read the back of the book also I don't want to hear people go on and on about their own view of specific things lol this type of review let me know the vibe and its perfection

[@awesomeadamfrom2099]

Awesome job Hailey with the KZbin shorts

[@rowlandranchers]

wow I’m here 2 mins after posted 😂

[@ShortRacoon]

Last looks happy yet desprete at the same time

[@Angry_one]

Not the faces! The first one and "none of this is true" 😂😂

[@stateofgrace4]

oh she did NOT like normal people 💀💀

[@AllisonJones1875]

I couldn't tell if she loved it or absolutely hated it lol.

[@cowboylikezinebivy4200]

Normal people: good but left her scarred in a way Second book: solid definitely recommend Third book: interesting Fourth book: plot twist plot twist and plot twist Fifth one: weirdly interesting Last one: heartwarminly beautiful and perfect for this season and her favorite kinda

[@boobee7907]

For me they're 1st: She wants to like it but she can't OMG this is so frustrating 2nd: Solid GOOD! 3rd: Great and it gave her another perspective of life 4th: OMG so many things happened here! a true masterpiece .. out of words! 5th: mehh... what is this.. but in the end it's okay 6th: it's so sweet and heartwarming

[@agregoris8761]

And I felt the first one ...she wanted to strangle both the main characters. They are both insanely frustrating and horrible at navigating relationships. First relationships are challenging but it doesn't excuse one of them for being a shitty person

[@cowboylikezinebivy4200]

@@agregoris8761 I feel exactly the same about that book they're both psychologically challenging but that's what made the novel a success lol

[@ariaisi4215]

This made the most sense to me, I know exactly which books I want to read now

[@menamisai5451]

I love this. Straight to the point!

[@hudakhan4532]

My depiction: 1. I wanna rip this book apart😠 2. Decent book😐 3. Started off normal then the plot twist😐😶 4. WHY WOULD SOMEONE WRITE THIS 😨😭😍 5. 🥴🥴 6. Cute cute cute🥰

[@sarahria]

Yes my thoughts exactly 😂

[@dimitrik1130]

Bro she’s so pretty

[@mylifeisslow959]

Finally! I actual silent review! I’ve seen many videos of people doing this trend but they are in fact, not silent. This was so satisfying to watch

[@CatieKatieCo]

this is my new favorite way to watch book reviews.

[@minahilali835]

This is so funny and creative. I haven't seen anyone do this before and I hope its a trend cause this was great haha

[@lotusstargirl5507]

These are the kinda reviews we need

[@sinnabon1]

Love how you beautifully explored the details ily😭

[@igaindah]

This is brilliant, made me curious about the book

[@gracie5983]

Please make more of these that was so funny and creative 😂

[@stellarines820]

Her face for "None of this is true" was essentially "nO cHiCkFaLaY sAuCe?!?!"

[@maggie547]

I understood every one of those reactions like they were my own

[@lilythebooklover]

I love your channel so much! You are actually my fav KZbinr!!!

[@brittneyheath158]

I’m crying 🤣 why is this so funny

[@pandamonium426]

The passive aggressive “silent clap” 😂

[@nurive]

The squeeze and smile at the beginning: me with so many books 😂

[@pragatiwadhwa2883]

You had me hooked at normal people i swear I LOVE IT SO MUCH😭😭😭😭

[@katerinamtl]

I LOVE YOUR REACTIONS MAKE MORE OF THESE💓

[@Clara-zg6ys]

This should be a series you do. Bahahha loved it!! ❤️

[@KaileyCurrie-jk7qb]

The little hand waves at the end are worth everything 🤣

[@lilybug2332]

I was waiting for her to start slamming one aggressively on the table

[@persialionheart]

I need more of these now

[@EmilyDraut]

Why are you so good at this 😂❤

[@shaizzypaizzy]

I’m never watching another book review who tf needs descriptions of the books anyway !!

[@BelLovesBroadway]

The way she reacted to “none of this is true” makes me want to read it.

[@Real_elgato]

The fact I understood her 😭 😭

[@Ng_Janet]

omg i love your books

[@callie.s.garrett]

This is such a fun and creative idea!

[@simontmiller]

this is some great ASMR

[@Halliebery]

Honestly I love this

[@yonahere4166]

Idk why but this feels somehow comforting and cozy

[@foolishfuuck]

makes me wanna read that first one real bad

[@missmollymedia]

This is so genius 😂 I feel this in my SOUL! ✨

[@Fluff]

I'm kind of obsessed with this format

[@Dantehaimoff]

The naturals is such a great series it’s so underrated!

[@flowing_burn9875]

Omg i used to watch your videos in high school and I'm about to finish uni. So nostalgic to see your videos again❤

[@xtr4t4r4stri4l]

I actually love this

[@abbybrown5073]

Imagine being in the library and seeing her doing this from a distance 😂 like wth is she doing

[@morganbarlow5722]

The silence is so loud for all of these😂❤

[@AdamandAly]

Made me feel like “tell me more!!! Ok, I know enough” Hahaha

[@BaylorReynolds-ho8nm]

The aggressive hand scrunching in the beginning and end 🤣🤣

[@TheSilenceOfHer]

i need everyone to do this, this is how i will pick my next books from now on

[@cheyennescottage]

The last one totally seems like my vibes ✨️

[@v-loves-paramore]

STOP IT I LOVE ALL IN OMFG

[@Brynn99xx]

This is the only way I ever want to see a review this is all the input I need thank you

[@gregputnam7243]

This is a trend I can get behind!... *gasps* and you showed them all at the end!

[@robynsecret93]

I love your expression, the first one with Normal People, I can feel it sooo much 😂😂😂

[@canniblanch]

Girl was so LOUD with this omg

[@GuacASMR]

This is really so creative I love it!!

[@MemeLord_5755]

I’m getting a lot of mixed signals here 💀

[@fantastic_fiona]

My (inside) reaction to finishing The Maze Runner series yesterday- ‼️😭😫🤯😓🥲🫠🔥‼️

[@clemmiereadsbooks]

I really want to have beautiful bookshelves like you! You are my icon I love reading so much.❤

[@mmmz302]

i really love this...hope there's more to come 😂

[@AliyahConnor-fm8pe]

I’m ready all in right now and this scares me 😂

[@Moonl.ght103]

The way I read her expressions like a book.

[@mimmidauria5405]

this is my new favorite thing

[@kimelisam9]

Love this!

[@Chickenbutt347]

I think her favorite was the first one you could see she even hugged the book with her hands!

[@H0R1Z0N_STARZ]

ALL IN IS ACUALLY SO GOODD

[@grantgreyguda]

You tell so much. It's amazing.

[@chloe-qo9py]

HER FACE ON LISA JEWLL KILLED ME, I WAS DEADD 😂😂😂💀💀💀

[@jonaekyoshee]

The way I was laughing lol 😂

[@EmmaArtois]

Makes me want to read the 4th one

[@mipiacionoicappotti15]

I’ve found my kindred spirit ❤😂

[@HungerGames_PJO]

The second one got me rolling.