Silent Circles by Starchman and more | Preview 3 (read description)

We have found a verifier! Thank you to all who reached out.
Here's the 3rd and final preview of Silent Circles, sorry it took so long but we are nearing completion, final showcase will be soon! The corridor part was honestly what I was most nervous about considering how unorthodox the gameplay is, but I think it turned out awesome thanks to @RemecArt. We also have an endscreen now that is not helping me beat the space-theme allegations, but it just looks so cool lol. That was made by the amazing ‪@v0lt4r1s‬
I'll give a little list of the things that are gonna be done/changed before the final showcase:
-transition part (25-33) will be decorated by Xlimax
-2nd wave (50-64) will be decorated by Shey
-my deco part (77-82) will be upgraded by Tripforweekly/Shey
-endscreen will be edited to show all decorators
-transitions will be fixed and cleaned between all parts
-Rzsnt's part, Tripforweekly's ship, and Acomet's part will be polished and cleaned
-easter eggs maybe

[@starchman8758]

We have found a verifier! Thank you to all who reached out

[@artdecos9]

That's amazing

[@Mason-e2p]

Who

[@starchman8758]

@@Mason-e2p will be announced when they start going for it

[@NPTNEGD]

what difficulty will this be?

[@starchman8758]

@@NPTNEGD top 5

[@toshdeluxe]

it's impressive how you maintained the intensity through the wave sections, just like the original level. looks nice so far

[@starchman8758]

didnt expect to see you here lol thanks

[@DSH__]

💀

[@XaioIingGD]

OMG TOSH

[@TheTristanGuy]

Finally, a silent circles remake that doesn’t completely replace the impossible spam section :D

[@starchman8758]

yeaaa i tried to keep it similar to the old version while also making it interesting to play, was inspired by a version Saviorz made

[@TheTristanGuy]

@ reminded me of diamond blade and I think that’s a good thing in this case!

[@bluex6095]

This is what Zynvire Silent Circles failed in doing, which was making a good Silent Circles remake that actually felt like Silent Circles. Incredible level so far

[@starchman8758]

tysm brother

[@zAlexHere]

Real!

[@zismale]

no spam :(

[@Compinvr]

@@zismalethe spam is humanly impossible, bad gameplay, and not fun to play, so they incorperated a bit of tight gap wave resembling the spam in the priginal level, while making it fun and realistic for a human completion

[@zismale]

@@Compinvr it would be better for the level to have it's name changed so that it isn't so affiliated to Silent Circles because the spam IS the iconic part in SC, so making this level "inspired" instead of a "humanly possible remake" would be better in my opnion. and by the way all the spams ARE humanly possible if you allow something like drag, bolt, or scrollclicking (which i don't think that the full last spam is ever gonna be done since you cant really control this types of clicking methods, so it would only be done if someone gets impossibly lucky, finds a way to control those methods or a whole new clicking method is created). sorry for the 150 paragraths essay

[@MykrasOtherStuff]

The way you remade the wave spam was super creative, I loved it!

[@starchman8758]

tysm brother, your videos are great btw

[@Vanish_Playz]

The deco at 1:08 is absolutely beautiful. I can’t wait for the final preview.

[@starchman8758]

thank you friend

[@zzx_den]

мыльно но прикольно

[@starchman8758]

что означает мыльно? я вижу много комментариев от русских

[@MisterSmith31]

Soap-ish glow is when the glow is blurry and makes the quality look worse

[@starchman8758]

@@MisterSmith31 aaah, I haven't heard of that before it seems like a very Russian gd term

[@v0lt4r1s]

Glad to keep the space allegations going 🙏

[@starchman8758]

you curse me with your talent

[@ZappyCH]

This looks sick can’t wait for full deco

[@starchman8758]

tysm friend

[@lemortez]

I absolutely love the way this level is going. It keeps the feeling of the original and the design is looking incredible so far. Can't wait to see the final results one day. Keep up the great work!

[@starchman8758]

thank you friend

[@Tirmot]

Уровень с душой

[@vVoidHaze]

This looks sick! I'd love to verify, but my hardest is oblivion and I'm currently going for deimos which is sadly just below slaughterhouse. I'll probably try it once it's out though!

[@starchman8758]

gg on oblivion bro that shits hard af, im glad you like the level

[@maybe_sl]

65-100 is actually fckin nuts and I CANNOT wait to see this level finished!

[@starchman8758]

thank you brother

[@fake_emperor365]

That remade wave at 66% looks so damn satisfying to pull off

[@starchman8758]

its very fun imo but Im maybe a slight bit bias considering I made it lol

[@Luke__28]

Oh my oh my, finally a version with the spam part just about tweaked to make it possible and actually doable while keeping the theme of the part. Thank god for it. This needs to get into top 5, or even top 1 spot after verification, exactly where the original deserved, and this one really deserves to be. Can't wait to see the final preview and verification process!

[@starchman8758]

thank you brother, and yes it will be top 5

[@noodleshelf]

why is this getting so many dislikes? way better than my version thats for sure edit nevermind i forgot immature russian kids are a thing

[@starchman8758]

they're just drones sent from cherry team coz a member of cherry said it was bad

[@noodleshelf]

@starchman8758 LOL figures, cherry team and their followers are so damn elitist its insane

[@Vanish_Playz]

@@noodleshelfFr, like just let people make levels

[@MuhIbnuAbbas.]

Okay just 1 part is undecorated but wow, love the progress. I think the original creator will be proud if they seeing this

[@MuhIbnuAbbas.]

The original creator what i mean is sailent and cyrillic

[@starchman8758]

thank you, yea we're very close to finishing now

[@maxx0nicGMD]

Да начнется веселье) Reasons why this level sucks 1. Terrible glow use on the pre-drop 2. The usual nc style will no longer surprise anyone 3. on the part from 0:55 everything merges into one color, the author of this level does not know how to select normal colors (maybe this is due to the poor quality of the showcase, I don’t know) 4. Also on the same part there is a very bad block design (what are those skulls in the saws lmao) 5. on the same part there are enlarged blocks from 2.0 in the background, and it looks clumsy and terrible 6. On the drop, the design of the block is also very terrible (where are the lightning in the center, what are those bars on the bottom, am I in prison or what?)Also a terrible glow use. 7. Default saws look simply terrible, especially in combination with flashes next to them. 8. Some kind of slime flashes in the background hahaha 9. what kind of block design is at 1:16? Not only does it not fit into the composition of this level, it's also just empty blocks with no filling lol. 10. From this moment on, huge saws appear on the fg, which generally look disgusting. Just moved them from layaut lmao. 11. I can’t say anything about the desk from 1:30, since it’s just almost all black ahaha, but it’s better than the previous desks. 12. notes at 1:39 good if version 2.1 were starting now. Otherwise this is a boring and outdated part 13. 1:42 (brilliant distribution of offsets, some ats take 10 seconds, some take 3 seconds xD) one of the worst parts in the level. There is no point in talking about glow use, it is very terrible, and again, the block design is very boring and not interesting. Endscreen is a total laugh. Worst endscreen I've ever seen in my life lmao In conclusion, I want to advise the host to listen to criticism, and try to defend him, rather than attack people who criticize your level. upd: at 1:16 the level turned into Niwa hahahahaha

[@starchman8758]

apologies for deleting it before, was a mistake

[@maxx0nicGMD]

@@starchman8758 okay

[@benitez6626]

i have to be honest and say i agree with a lot of your criticism, i believe this level still needs polishing, but god bro you come off as such a dick with how you deliver your thoughts 💀 then you finish off with “i want to advise the host to listen to criticism, rather than attack people who criticize your level” when you’re the one attacking the host. i hate seeing newer creators getting demotivated to create because of mfs like you

[@benitez6626]

i agree with some of this criticism, i do think that this level still needs polishing, but god bro you come off as such a prick 💀 then you have the balls to say “I want to advise the host to listen to criticism, rather than attack people who criticize the level” when you’re the one attacking the host. I acc hate people like you because you demotivate new creators when they’re just trying to improve. Also i thought you were like an elitist like creator who actually had good levels and an insight on creating, but no you’re trash at creating 😭 the only full level you have (bogxxon) is actually painful to look at

[@artdecos9]

It was never that serious 😭

[@wisesthacesha2791]

Actually a good faithfull remake to silent circles, good job. I really wanna verify this, i may not have beaten any extreme demons yet, but i kinda wanna try anyways. Seems fun. ❤ keep up the good work my brother

[@starchman8758]

hey you can beat it eventually, don't give up on extremes

[@wisesthacesha2791]

@starchman8758 thanks man. Workin on ACU, but still tho, i dont know why, but i really wanna verify this level. But its probably just some delusional thought i have, still wanna do it tho

[@starchman8758]

@@wisesthacesha2791 unfortunately you can't verify it but you can play it when its out

[@wisesthacesha2791]

@@starchman8758 akr then

[@Prometheus_Alt]

Finally the kind of silent circles remake that fits the level

[@starchman8758]

tysm

[@theprimeyeeter]

an ldm in the level's original deco would be absolutely awesome

[@starchman8758]

maybe idk

[@triologixyt7831]

Yo this level goes so hard bro I'm hyped as hell for this. Hopefully this gets enough attention because I would love to see this completed and on the demonlist in the future.

[@binku09]

UFWM is good candidate for this since he already has more than 30% progress on the old silent circles

[@starchman8758]

I asked him he wasn't interested unfortunately

[@binku09]

@starchman8758 sad, but we must keep looking 🔥💯

[@purplepyro8950]

this level appeared in my fyp and i have to say, this is the first silent circles remake that does the original justice. i would absolutely love to see this finished and rated and placed so that silent circles finally gets a nice resolution. might reach out to a few friends and see if any of them would want this verification

[@Korfy404]

do you agree that Inex is really bad? Sosal?

[@starchman8758]

was he the guy whos comment i removed? i dont have any thoughts on him ive never met him, i just didnt like his comment

[@adbi2312]

this looks actually so sick

[@starchman8758]

tysm

[@XrearK]

Let's go! Silent Circles making a new comeback! Also, I love this remake and difficulty level. 🔥

[@starchman8758]

tysm brother

[@zAlexHere]

This is the Silent Circles we deservd! TY guys, great job!!

[@starchman8758]

tysm im glad you liked it

[@MothNeo]

this is what i love to see, my goodness. absolutely amazing. can't wait to play it when it comes out, i've been playing silent circles redux for a couple months now and i really want to play something a little better 😭

[@starchman8758]

lmao silent circles redux

[@MothNeo]

@ it’s a decent level though 😭

[@alexanderx1ta]

Finally a cool silent circles remake, the spam part is awesome

[@starchman8758]

thank you brother

[@RemecArt]

ty

[@LegendoLight]

Bro this looks so dope, I love the corridor sections

[@RemecArt]

ty

[@LegendoLight]

@ goated!!

[@starchman8758]

thank you brother

[@elisyyy]

Любитель жрать отборное дерьмо брух

[@wackylol1]

looks amazing i’m looking very forward honestly

[@starchman8758]

ty wackster

[@Lil_NoobieGMD]

Can I make one way overdecorated spike for this just for no reason except it’s funny

[@starchman8758]

that would be very funny actually dm me

[@Lil_NoobieGMD]

@ what’s your discord username?

[@stratsboneless6270]

@@Lil_NoobieGMD read the pinned comment its just his name

[@critterd]

i really like what was done with the iconic spam part. i hope this is finished and verified fast!

[@starchman8758]

thank you

[@FoloNn]

Мiльно но прiкольно

[@IAmDavidus]

Рот болит и попе больно

[@ItsLuminousGD]

I’m not a potential verifier, but I would love to decorate a part in this!

[@starchman8758]

thank you but unfortunately all our deco parts are filled

[@F4CT_57]

Wow this looks amazing! Huge props to everyone who built in it, great atmosphere and gp, represents sc a lot! Hopefully you find a verifier soon :D

[@starchman8758]

thank you brother

[@DigyetGD]

Honestly... This is beautiful, much better than Zynvire's Silent Circles, I like how you adapted the spam part

[@starchman8758]

tysm man, the gameplay there was inspired by a video by Saviorz

[@TimoshGG]

О господи это шедевр робтоп 100% даст ему мифик

[@солесоселовелей]

не ну эта падпiсон

[@Drugdiller75]

Ливай с гд

[@smackinthekraken]

This is absurdly cool, I hope to god it doesn’t get canceled or anything

[@starchman8758]

don't worry we're close to finished

[@MajX.]

This looks really sick

[@starchman8758]

thank you

[@Vanex798]

Space gauntlet looking fire🔥🔥

[@starchman8758]

real shit

[@aerogd]

bro can't take criticism lol

[@starchman8758]

I can take criticism if its criticism, people just saying its bad without saying why or how we can improve it isn't criticism, so ill remove them

[@RompeReal]

​@starchman8758 but you deleted the comment with a full critique of this masterpiece

[@starchman8758]

@@RompeReal yea that was a mistake, he reposted it

[@aerogd]

@@starchman8758 okay, but still, removing comments that just say the level is bad is weak af. you just want to think that everyone likes your "masterpiece"

[@aerogd]

@@starchman8758 not saying you can't do that, but that's weak

[@CloakingRhyme84]

another silent level bites the dust! (could be my new fav level in the game)

[@starchman8758]

tysm brother

[@CloakingRhyme84]

@@starchman8758 Nah ty this is so good!!!

[@alsanali3975]

glad to see this coming out even though i was so closed to getting a part in this amazing collaboration wish you the best in the future

[@JackPawlik-l7w]

unreal work. hopefully you can find a verifier

[@starchman8758]

thank you

[@gdbliss]

This is one of of the greatest nine circles levels I have ever seen in Geometry Dash

[@sesc-urfu]

A worthy competitor to zinvaer's silent circles

[@Bigbroplays]

This is the best silent circles remake I’ve seen ever, this is really good except I feel like the balancing is off in some parts

[@starchman8758]

thank you brother, do you mean gameplay balancing or deco balancing?

[@Bigbroplays]

@ I think just the gameplay, it feels a bit unbalanced in the wave parts

[@starchman8758]

@Bigbroplays yea the first wave and corridor part are quite a bit harder than the rest, dont worry though that will get sorted out during verification we'll make sure the level is fun

[@Bigbroplays]

@ yeah i think that’s the only part that should be needed slightly, otherwise the level is great so far

[@zeyadnada6742]

Bro call zoink

[@starchman8758]

he busy with thinking space 2

[@zKishi01]

at 1:30 the deco is so sick, amazing

[@RemecArt]

ty (:

[@aldrichsheehan7369]

👍​@RemecArt

[@artdecos9]

The spam part looks great

[@RemecArt]

ty

[@starchman8758]

thank you, remed did a great job with it

[@ananas-nevermind]

I love this so much. sorry i had 0 hours of sleep and would dpure more efort onto comenting but j i just almosg fell down the stairs cause i passsed out yiuueieieieieiwio so idk

[@starchman8758]

oh dear hope you're alright lol

[@Eyessoul]

Wow, your voice is so nice!

[@starchman8758]

lol ty

[@ritLoe4222]

YO ITS ALMOST DONEEE

[@starchman8758]

yeeeaa

[@rezeryxrat]

its unfinished, but before i read the description i didnt even notice it lol, incredible level and super underrated for its views and likes you have a new like and sub

[@deltafoxofficial2012]

I suggest the host rename the project “Wet Circles”.

[@starchman8758]

real shit

[@MikkelisNOTfunny]

the spam section looks so good wtf

[@RemecArt]

ty

[@starchman8758]

remed did a goated job with it

[@br_skibidi_dop_dop_es_es]

Wow, I think it's in the top 30 for deco and gp, and it's definitely better than the old silent circles. I hope you will find a good verifier and it will become a top 5

[@br_skibidi_dop_dop_es_es]

but in my opinion, the part at 0:58 needs to be slightly redone to be more detailed and less red, and the 1:39 part should be made more glow

[@tedecti]

i think you're blind and brainrot

[@starchman8758]

thank you

[@starchman8758]

@@br_skibidi_dop_dop_es_es the ship is red in the original

[@ethanbullonguerra5651]

Amazing decoration

[@starchman8758]

thank you

[@dasdas221_]

These colors especially in the first two parts are complete crap. Also the glow use is very bad. And yes, deleting the comment of inex, who clearly expressed his opinion about the level, was completely unnecessary

[@starchman8758]

I delete comments that don't express actual criticism

[@Korfy404]

bro, but at the same time you deleted that huge comment with detailed criticism on the timecodes.

[@starchman8758]

@@Korfy404 if I did that it was a mistake, if you know the guy you can tell him to repost it and it will stay up

[@d1rpy]

this looks mad fun to play especially 66% onwards lol

[@starchman8758]

tyty

[@solaraloe]

some parts of the level need work imo (first ship is way too bright & fairly unpolished imo & the red feels kind of out of place) but the way you adapted the gameplay into humanly possible gameplay while still retaining the general essence of it is really cool

[@starchman8758]

thank you, and yea I agree with you about the ship, trip is planning on upgrading it soon

[@mp40equipped]

Better than the other forgotten one lmao really noice

[@starchman8758]

thank you brother

[@LichiGD]

Oh yeah, this is good, this is the rated Silent Circles we need

[@starchman8758]

tysm

[@juanedington6144]

Welcome to demon list

[@adriantheo7654]

Will you add mirror portal to the ship part?

[@starchman8758]

no, I considered it but it makes the level flow weirdly and makes the part less fun

[@Placek38]

absolute cinema

[@LiamMitchellSmithPlaezzz]

yall need a verifier 😉

[@starchman8758]

yuhuh

[@anonymousg.5613]

Awesome parts :)

[@P1LLGD]

omg this is amazing wow!!

[@starchman8758]

thank you

[@TeamNebulaPD]

what zynvires silent circles shouldve been

[@starchman8758]

couldnt agree more

[@Nirowa_]

oh damn this is amazing bro

[@starchman8758]

tysm

[@SingularityXVI]

Oh my god, this is one of the levels of all time

[@starchman8758]

it truly is

[@jamalhebeebhebab]

this is cool

[@starchman8758]

ty

[@cyblurrgd]

Whizkid could probably be the verifier. Awesome remake 👀 Can this level have a different name instead of just Silent Circles? After all this is just a remake.

[@starchman8758]

eh tried to come up with a different one for a while but I think just silent circles works

[@Błiz.mp3]

I wish i could verify but my hardest is only SWI :( Awssome level tho!

[@tmth09]

вообще, задумка декора очень хороша, но реализация посредственная, очень жаль

[@starchman8758]

Не волнуйся, друг, мы будем усердно работать над полировкой деталей и тем, чтобы каждая часть плавно переходила в следующую. Четыре части находятся в стадии обновления

[@tmth09]

@@starchman8758 good luck dude❤️🙏

[@fri2k]

this is beautiful

[@2763cmc]

pretty neat i love this level

[@starchman8758]

thank you

[@CrazyyzaiiMB]

I like how this feels like a mix between the original SC and the one from zynvire. Rob is prob only gonna star rate just because this doesn't have some crazy block designs

[@starchman8758]

hey idc ill take any rate lol

[@letztiz]

I liked zynvires deco more, because it had more „quality“ for its time and felt really unique for nc theme, but the layout here is better so good job

[@eljales]

now this is a silent circles remake.

[@Vembet]

Probably best silent circles remake

[@starchman8758]

thank you

[@NicoSteamCad]

Peak level. Goodjob

[@starchman8758]

tysm

[@ItzYanderGD]

Выглядит неплохо, но стиль декора разный, в некоторых местах на Пенумбру похоже

[@broitsmetylerd]

i have like 52 and 23-86 on slh hopefully i can do that soon 🙏

[@AliBilalAbdallah]

This is cool. Idk why I find that it resembles to Andromeda in terms of colours, but it’s still good

[@starchman8758]

yea I get that resemblance kinda

[@Knockoffgdplayer]

!!!!!!!!!!!! THIS IS AMAZING !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@starchman8758]

tysm

[@Silent_Circles_Bride]

I like how you tried to stick with the original!

[@starchman8758]

thank you, we try to strike a balance between the classic feel and a modern style

[@goldboyfour]

amazing

[@starchman8758]

tysm

[@nsidk-f8c]

fire

[@Poulen]

this is really good

[@tansjghpool352]

Ufwm defo would’ve asked if it had been when he was trying to beat silent circles (get to the spam part) XD

[@starchman8758]

lol I wish

[@tansjghpool352]

@ me two

[@nickalusoliveira117]

What a Silent Circles remake needs is both a high difficulty (preferably in the top 10) and the spam part (nerfed, more playable and less repetitive as i think it should be). The Zyn remake removed the spam entirelly, so the level looked like a generic NC and its only hope was its unnerfed difficulty. Also, i think he thought the level's outdated deco was enough to get rated in 2022 because it was made in 2018's "standards". It should have been redecoed by thst point.

[@starchman8758]

yea I did not like zynvires one at all thats part of why I started this

[@ImFeelingGreen_GD-im6bs]

omg this is awesome!! i absolutely cannot verify but can i try to get some runs (my hardest is rust)

[@starchman8758]

definitely try some when the level is out, its a pretty approachable level imo since its mainly wave

[@ImFeelingGreen_GD-im6bs]

@ i will if i can idk it looks just a tiny bit difficult

[@gameplay-0115]

Will this be top 10? I hope it can be like Top 10 Lol

[@starchman8758]

it will be top 5 in fact

[@gameplay-0115]

@ Nice!

[@JoeAverage_]

Do you need any more decorators?

[@starchman8758]

nah all our parts are taken unfortunately

[@JoeAverage_]

@@starchman8758 ok 👍

[@Bravlov_AkaneDash]

Looks a bit messy, but it's a lot better than Silent Circles by Zynvire.

[@starchman8758]

thank you, don't worry we agree that its a bit messy, it will be cleaned up in the coming part upgrades

[@lqt-xinim4238]

this make it the 6th or 7th silent circle remake, lol tho gotta say your look a lot cleaner than mine, but well mine is developed from 2.0 to 2.1 so eh

[@starchman8758]

lol yea there's a lot of them but I just didn't see any that I liked so