What Is The BEST Sugarcane Farm In Minecraft Bedrock Edition? (Easy Sugarcane Farm Tutorial)

[@silentwisperer]

Thanks for watchin! Hopefully you enjoy this format, I might do more like it! :D sugarcane farms are fun to design, but are they really worth it? Checkout this video for more! kzbin.info/www/bejne/h32mkHt5i6Zqi7M Also all the farms shown in todays video can be used for cane, bamboo, or kelp! I made a similar tutorial with designs for each:) kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZoLHl5uaqbV9eaM Have a great day! 😊

[@aplacewherefunandfunkythin705]

Sugar cane is kinda useless It has some uses but you can just tear down the library's in th stronghold Or mansions

[@Puss_pog]

I think you said it's overrated lol

[@aplacewherefunandfunkythin705]

Lol

[@totoplz]

are the furnace xp farms fixed in 1.18.10?

[@Puss_pog]

@@totoplz yes

[@buckethead60]

why spend 10 minutes making a sugarcane farm when you could spend days creating a 15x30 block wide sugar cane farm extending from sky height to bedrock.

[@Puss_pog]

Why idk

[@dtslawyer6970]

Toycat moment

[@migjordanpayawal7856]

Without redstone, of course.

[@buckethead60]

@@migjordanpayawal7856 Of course

[@bomma2694]

Because!!!

[@Infinite_Curiosity00]

Your bonemeal sugarcane farm is the most compact I've seen. Very good use of space and simple design compared to other creators. I love how you can easily mirror for double output, and you even thought of an alternative bonemeal chest placement.

[@SemiHypercube]

toycat's sky-high one easily competes for the best, that's for sure

[@kitlaurencelorilla2831]

the bad side of toycats farm is its just too tall to harvest

[@jochenroeder669]

Toycat is yes.

[@YesName_1]

Yeah

[@cleryfrey]

I'd like to know how you did the ultra compact farm. It fits my current sugarcane farm perfectly.

[@blackhawk15897]

Kinda made a hybrid of design 1 and 2. It has 8 sugarcane and each has a bone meal dispenser, but there's also an observer at one end so it harvests periodically, providing a passive source of sugarcane when I don't put bone meal in. Also, observers can detect when the bottom sugarcane changes its growth stage, so you can actually place the observer below the piston and compact design 2 down to a 2-high farm.

[@vix_2572]

Sorry for asking this but can you show your design?

[@everyonestech]

Definitely useful for the STUPID amount of time it takes to get enough sugarcane for a full enchantment table lol!

[@alanredversangel]

Which is why I just go on chunkbase and find a stronghold library. That's right I'm a cheater.

[@joseandre4603]

@@alanredversangel no

[@yoannesleonardi6799]

Cure a librarian that sells bookshelf

[@novaenricarter705]

@@yoannesleonardi6799 Literally, then just cure him like 4 or 5 times and get a bookshelf per emerald. Best way to get books in the game

[@yoannesleonardi6799]

@@novaenricarter705 or if you're on a budget, direct cure the bookshelf villager and instantly get a 1 emerald trade

[@hobbitjaffa]

Very easy and simple to build. Just make sure to spend hours gathering materials and building Silent’s moss/bonemeal farm so you can power the sugar cane farm! Might as well start with the iron farm so you can make all the pistons for the moss farm 😂

[@silentwisperer]

welcome to the minecraft rabbit hole of resources 😂

[@Sycis357]

My rabbit hole started with building a 1024 item filter system, which lead to the iron farm, a bonemeal farm into an auto tree farm, then into the dark oak tree farm. The sugarcane farm, cow farm, and witch farm are just pleasant side projects enabled by the other farms lol.

[@bapple.]

for the last design (ultra compact), how many items should be in the hopper clock?

[@neilpeart9322]

***⭐️ NOTE : if building the ultra compact replace the walls with signs (only have to do top row) in 1.20 the items will get stuck on the wall, still basically lossless. Also he didn’t mention how much time is on the hopper clock, after some research I found that two hopper clocks paired together to get around a 12-16m harvest time is optimal ( could be wrong)

[@neilpeart9322]

Also built on realms works fine (360 pistons/plants)

[@MissingStripy]

Wdym replace the top wall with signs? Don't signs have no item hitboxes?

[@Shenanigans78399]

thank you was wondering why mine stopped working

[@exportedcard]

Pin this comment holy thank you neilpeart 🙏

[@Makesomethingworthmaking]

I just made the compact one and connected it to the bonemeal moss farm. Filled a double chest with sugarcane in about 15 minutes

[@Canufindnow]

how tho? like how do u install dispensers into that compact structure

[@channelnotfound403]

Just for fun I turned the repeater down to its slowest speed and just left the farm on (the mini farm that needs bonemeal ). In a few hours it produced a stack of Bamboo and about 11 Sugarcane (as I have a farm for each of these items). So it's nice to know I could get "something" from these mini farms when I'm bonemeal poor.

[@pandashark07]

You could get more by setting up a separate hopper clock with a longer timer to allow things to grow more. Every tick the pistons are extended is a tick the plants can't grow, so you're essentially cutting your "rates" in half for the non-bonemeal part

[@nightshadefern162]

For the observer based farms... its efficiency suffers because the cane has to be three tall before it triggers. A single observer looking at a daylight sensor or a hopper clock trigger can boost its output big time and its cheaper to build.

[@everyonestech]

Hmm Never thought about that. Good tip!

[@silentwisperer]

when you harvest, either 2 tall or 3 tall doesn't really matter. Only matters in farm size and resources needed. Also if you only let it be two tall, then you are much less likely to get lost items!

[@novaenricarter705]

@@raymondstheawesome That's what I thought

[@nightshadefern162]

@@raymondstheawesome Try a side by side comparison. My good guess is that the clock based farm (observer looking at a daylight sense) will produce 25- 35% more over any given span of time vs a three high observer growth farm. (A hopper minecart on tracks under the sugar cane dirt block so both versions are lossless).

[@carlogeuna2211]

There's actually a better disposition for dirt blocks/water sources in the flying machine one. I'll try to explain it here: basically you start from a 2x2 square of dirt blocks, then for one of the two blocks on each side of the square you place a water source making sure that each block has only one adjacent to it. That is going to be one "slice" of the farm. What you have to do next is put all the slices next to one another making sure that each water source has 4 dirt blocks around it and each dirt block has only one water source next to it. What should come out is a pattern where the sources are on a diagonal that would connect the angles of a 2x3 rectangle (i don't know if it's clear but that's the best way I can explain it) I'm not sure about what this would imply with the redstone, but is shouldn't change much, if not at all. Hope this has been helpful :)

[@dedo1247.]

the ultra compact version of this farm broke with 1.20 btw, the canes don't get sent to the water, they just lie down in their grass blocks

[@rjayde4832]

figured out how to fix it, replace the walls with fence gates. also, not sure if it needs to be 2 blocks tall but just having the upper part works fine for me. but probably have 2 if possible just to be sure

[@michaelwest5596]

I tried it with gates on walls and sugarcane still sits on top of the wall. You’ll need two layers of gates.

[@punkyggo7]

​​​@@michaelwest5596 kinda late reply but I just tested it and 1 layer of Gates in enough to make it lossles

[@davidfwooldridge3430]

I built the second design because everyone has once, but really I always go from the ole manual Day 1 sugar cane plot straight to the bone meal farm. Most sugar cane farms mostly serve to make your base look smart and automated, not actually efficiently make sugar cane.

[@oceandawgz]

Excellent video and great format! I really like how you have 3 designs that differ from each other and explain the pros and cons very well. Want to build the first design now and also try this out with bamboo and kelp, as it looks even simpler/smaller than your previous design, highlighted in your pinned comment. Also enjoy very much how you always strive to simplify and make these farms cost effective and as efficient as possible!

[@elijahanonymous4596]

Is the bonemeal farm from the event calendar better or worse than this one? Or are they pretty much the same?

[@Mel-mu8ox]

7:28 *singing* 'I got a brand new combine harvester'

[@ninjac4120]

Hey don't know if you look at your old video but this is very useful thanks and you deserve the subs you have and more

[@heatercrafter8455]

Planning to make a flying machine sugarcane farm using your design in my industrial area. I already have the bonemeal powered sugarcane farm which I design so that it will turn on or off automatically base on bonemeal input.

[@zaraphehe8109]

it been months not play minecraft but still i like silent discover new things in minecraft

[@AshleyHope4More]

I was just looking for a sugarcane farm! Perfect timing, thank you!

[@WilliamMessick-tn3iv]

6:56 replace bottom blocks with mud, add hoppers underneath leading to collection chest, this works because mud is technically not a full block, items are sucked into the hoppers underneath, and are led to the chests. easy way to combat the losses.

[@rjayde4832]

that only works on java

[@WilliamMessick-tn3iv]

@@rjayde4832bruh, I am a bedrock player and this works for me.

[@mak6_350]

THERE IS NO WAY! I was literally about to build one tonight!!! How is ur timing so good !! Silent ur the best youtuber... keep up the good work!

[@silentwisperer]

Always here to help 😊💙

[@BoyWhoBreathes]

Thank youuuuuu, such a big fan of all your videos! Amazing work keep it up

[@biplobsapkota]

Where is the tutorial for ultra compact one? It would be great to get it with materials list as well

[@mysticalmaid]

Works great, thanks for clear instructions and explanations

[@metallikalm4336]

The observer one, we can use +1 slime ball and -1 redstone dust per slice, and it triggers individually and a little bit lossless. Sugarcane tries to grow on 16 step per height, so activating all pistons at the same time makes the rates worse.

[@adrianpena8362]

Best tutorial. Thank you very much.

[@hc6242]

I just tried the compact farm from the start of the video on Minecraft Bedrock 1.18.12 and it doesn't work. The clock/repeater gets a never ending signal and doesn't clock it. Anyone know why?

[@matthuston8194]

I have the same problem what did you do to fix?

[@morojkiller5418]

Same

[@bmurda8677]

Great video! I built the compact design in my bedrock survival world. Endless sugarcane extremely fast.

[@luigiborrelli1613]

how

[@realphillipcarter]

You can make the little farm 2 blocks thinner by putting the water source under a top slab which the repeater then goes on top of.

[@stargazer-elite]

For the ultra basic farm you could put a hopper minecart underneath the sugarcane to make sure you get every last piece of sugarcane

[@kingsoltani9307]

I made a salmon and cod farm yesterday so the compact sugarcane farm fits perfectly

[@jochenroeder669]

The problem with bonemeal based farms is thatyou need another farm to generate bonemeal in the first place. I usually just have a big ordinary sugarcane field somewhere near my base that I harvest by hand.

[@shrektiddies_6932]

Skeleton farm

[@d10king94]

Hey silent, ik this doesn't have anything to with the video, and I'm sure you've already noticed, but if possible, could you find another way to have an xp "bank" like the smelting items xp dupe farm? If this a possibility that would be amazing and I'm sure others would also love this, if not that's alright, you have some great content and I think I speak for a lot of people when I say you do a lot for the community and it's much appreciated, keep up the great work 👍

[@silentwisperer]

use a guardian farm or other actual exp farm:)

[@aplacewherefunandfunkythin705]

But y

[@d10king94]

@@silentwisperer alright, sounds good, ik you have plenty of tutorials for those so it shouldn't be difficult to find one XD

[@siinstroze8274]

@@aplacewherefunandfunkythin705 cause the smelting bank is cheating no matter how you look at it just like zero tick. Your using bugs in the game to get what you want

[@QWERT8552]

@@siinstroze8274 I think the smelting bank is an intended feature

[@ChiefCax]

Super useful, will probably end up throwing one of these into my realm. Thanks!

[@hammygames077]

Silent is magic. A few weeks ago I needed a mob farm design Guess what he uploaded? Now i needed a sugar cane farm and wasn't sure what was the best. I rest my case

[@patron9657]

I just finished building a giant flying machine sugar cane farm, wish I’d waited.

[@daveschenkel1446]

Great Video, What is the add on you have for the hoppers to show the lights on them I would like to get that?

[@ZyberWarrior1961]

Do any of these farms need to be Chunk Aligned?

[@MrOut4astroll]

Just a thought. Sugarcane will grow on mud. If you put a hopper under mud , it will go through and The Hoppers will pick it up

[@ccurtis0152]

i’ve literally stayed up all night building a different sugar cane farm😩 ig this one will look cool on the other side of it

[@WazzaNZ15]

Went to make the large flying machine farm near where i afk to get lots of sugarcane while doing nothing. I noticed the auto dropper doesnt work anymore? Either ive done it wrong or the redstone no longer works. Do you have another good auto dropper design?

[@ayoutubechannel962]

What texture pack are you using?

[@EnchantedPlayzz]

The first one got me so much sugar cane in my survival world inf fireworks lol

[@qwerty934]

Does it still work? For me it’s not

[@KATE-hv1wg]

I am still confuse which one should i make can u help me? My heart says to go with tht 1st one bt then those big giant farms divert my mind......plz help Or anyone plz help? Btw u r the best at making farms for bedrock like omg whtever i make from your videos wrks like charm.. Thank u so much for your hardwork... And plz from now on i will call u 'Bedrock Mumbo Jumbo'

[@johnrichardson6033]

I have a bonemeal based sugar cane farm. Yes it does use up a lot of bonemeal but I do have a skeleton spawner farm. So I’m not hurting for bone meal. **P.S.** it is built on my realms

[@mred-a7297]

Where did you get the skeleton farm

[@johnrichardson6033]

@@mred-a7297 it’s a simple spawner farm. Found a skeleton spawner near my main base.

[@jaraidonagon]

I've been looking for a realm SC farm. Which one do you use?

[@johnrichardson6033]

@@jaraidonagon I use one similar to what silent builds in the beginning of the the video, I use a single piston with an observer.

[@hurryingglint23]

I can not tell you know many times I’ve built the Ultra Basic farm.. thing is I don’t just build a strip of 6-8 I built it under my base.. and I will make a very deep hole.. and put a row of about 10-15 and at least make it 3 farms deep… I also do that 4 times to make a square.. the most recent world I make it around the center of my double iron farm and it’s 4 farms high and about 10 wide but I did it in 8 sections of at least 10 wide… basically 20 sugarcane Per side of a square

[@rudrodeepchatterjee]

Built the second design three days ago, was doubtful about it's rates, watched this video, and now I feel like smashing the farm down!

[@silentwisperer]

its not so bad if you got a hopper minecart, but its also... not great haha

[@rudrodeepchatterjee]

@@silentwisperer I do have hopper minecarts running...but man does it take time for the sugarcane to grow up to the 3rd stage.

[@DrJuanMontoya]

@silentwisperer over at wattles he stated in his newest video that with the current Update the „XP in furnace“-Bug is fixed. Did you by chance already checked this?

[@nyaoyaoya1374]

Godsent to this newbie thanks!!

[@jerhurricane]

I have 3 sugar cane farms for my needs :/ I am trying to save some space. How do you turn it into a dual function sugar cane farm so that oberservers are doing it when you dont need the mass bonemeal?

[@alejandrozavala2742]

For the bonemeal one you can connect it with a kelp farm using comporters instead smokers

[@frenzt0131]

Wdym

[@TheTrueKingofScotland]

@@frenzt0131 create a separate farm for bonemeal. So something like kelp, moss or flowers. Then transport the bonemeal to the sugercane farm (water stream/hopper/manually)

[@frenzt0131]

@@TheTrueKingofScotland ah ok thanks a lot

[@ItsCyclonic]

Guys, I think he meant using the zero-tick kelp system that grows kelp instanly. It was patched in 1.18.10, but that comment was made before then.

[@masonwilliams8888]

bro thanks to me coming to this video i was able to find out how i built it wrong "flying machine" thank you silent for this build stay blessed and be safe

[@dadinareasonablypricedcar]

Thanks for this i needed sugar cane for paper to trade with my villagers on our family realm. Didnt realise how quick the bone meal one was!

[@zordalpha]

Ig all the three works.. Observer is for starters... After you have bonemeal farm.. Go for it and later flying machine.. As ull be needing much in future

[@deepanshusharma6219]

Hey Silent!! Can you make a skeleton farm in a soul sand valley biome... As a ton of them spawn there...

[@NWB3175]

Not gonna lie, a double version of the bonemeal farm right next to the moss/generator build you designed is really putting my One X through the ringer🤣🤣. Everything is working great though. Here's to hoping I can just swap out the sugar cane for some bamboo once I have a few chests built up. Thanks as always bro!

[@therealofficialcaz1900]

I’ve got a fish farm and many many many bones, so #1 for me

[@EnzoPlayZ01]

Hey Silent! Can I Get the world download of the world you are in? Thank You

[@acuraman25]

Building the first compact one with bonemeal, cause it can feed itsself. and produce a tone of paper for more then my needs.

[@Jorscam]

Can you do an easy creeper farm?

[@nyaoyaoya1374]

Do you think if I mod this well enough I can turn this into a Kelp Farm? Also is there an easssssyyyyy way to make flint?

[@jpro6413]

I think so... Did you tried it? Did it work? Best wishes jpro

[@ieatleftytears1953]

Put the water under the dispensers in the first farm to make it smaller. Put the clock behind it so it's I tile

[@JisMortal]

I use your micro farm for any crop i need. with your mob farm and villager crop farm (carrot, 5 layers) for bonemeal. its a no brainer

[@andrewchestney]

Hi silentwesperer I am still new to playing Minecraft bedrock edition do you need to couch to place the hoppers ? When you are building this farm?

[@_sgk.150]

Yes

[@Edylinkin357]

Hey silent, man, you're giving us many ways to get tons of sugar cane but, we might need tons of gunpowder as well, can we get a gunpowder farm next? A non-ghast based one maybe?

[@shenzhong3078]

Witch farm is actually suprisingly good at supplying you with gunpowder, try that instead!

[@GenDuck]

What texture pack you use?

[@Shogi_12]

I got 18 stack of sugarcane(2 double chest rows) by using 9 stacks of bonemeal (1 stack of bone blocks)that I got from my bonemeal farm, so its pretty efficient.

[@silentwisperer]

yeah it should always be 2 cane for 1 bonemeal :)

[@grelaria58]

Love the micro bone meal farm!

[@MRNOISY]

I built your flying machine design x3 stacked just because lol one harvest is over a double chest of sugarcane

[@GameParrot]

A bonemeal sugarcane farm with a skeleton farm is a LOT of sugarcane!

[@jaraidonagon]

Do these work on realms?

[@energyweaver6616]

yo this bonemeal farm is op af i was able to eliminate my sugarcane farm alltogeather. thank you

[@ishanpatwal9033]

Please do a video on the best bonemeal farm, thank you 💓💓

[@alvinmolina8025]

unfortunately this farm no longer works with 1.18.30, Can you repair it?

[@Hardhat_137]

Which farm??????

[@mubt4sim]

Bonemeal sugarcane farms are the best. Early game you only need sugarcane for the books which can be farmed manually. And late game you can just bonemeal them. 2 stacks of bonemeal gives you like one full chest of sugarcane. Seriously how much sugarcane someone needs

[@Countrified_Shorts]

This Farms Is So good. but I will Only build the 1st and the 4th. As I already have the second one and! The 3rd one is expensive..

[@frankrossdeutscher]

Silentwisperer: Are sugarcane farms overrated? Yes! Also Silentwisperer: I try to find the best sugarcane farm ever!

[@gamingwithsaad1506]

Do gunpowder farm comparison in bedrock we need it!

[@AtonRestin122]

I miss zero tick farms

[@Yosu_115]

Did the kelp farm and xp bank get fixed with the new update? My kelp farms and xp banks don't work anymore.

[@lorddrin9939]

Btw wattles keeps on shouting you out, his recent video is at least the second time.

[@silentwisperer]

:0 how nice!!

[@chubbygardengnome]

I miss zero tick sugar cane farms soooo much... But you can get pretty close still since zero tick kelp farms still work, fastest version feeds the kelp to double chests(i do at least 4 cells, but can do up to 16 but changes design a bit), then from double chest to two composters for bonemeal, to two double chests, then from those two double chests, feed to your bonemeal design sugarcane farm above (i do one on each side) and it works pretty well and keeps up with the speed of the sugar cane farm.

[@HXC62]

This got patched in the last update =(

[@chubbygardengnome]

@@HXC62 wait so youre saying even the kelp farms dont work now?, i haven't used mine in a month, Man, why do they keep screwing over bedrock players...

[@HXC62]

@@chubbygardengnome yes sadly no more 0 tick farms and no more xp banks

[@thargaret_matcher2111]

It really would have been nice if you explained the redstone on the compact one

[@MikoDiane]

Thanks for another great and useful vid. And for sharing a server friendly tweak. I have just the place to build that. And definitely gonna make a flying machine one on solo. Cuz why not. 😎

[@J0K3R_the_Nerd]

Looking for tips on the last design, is there a good way to make it auto harvest so you don't have to keep an eye on it. My goal is to have a farm as reliable as my old zero tick farms, where you can go mining for a few hours and come back to a full chest

[@pandashark07]

Hopper clock

[@MrBabadook035]

Just needed this very nice just build the iron farm with villagers works like a champ

[@jerhurricane]

Is this before dirt?

[@zarda1484]

Just don't leave the clock running on a flying machine if you're loading and unloading an area. Having to constantly fix a farm is a massive design flaw and bedrock has enough of those built into the game.

[@silentwisperer]

yea best to only leave it on when afking and stuff

[@seanduck8073]

I miss the zero tick sugar cane farm

[@BlackDragonWitheHawk]

Soo... I wonder what would happen if you combine the flying machine one with the most efficient pattern to place sugarcane, that beeing the one where you put a waterblock and around 4 plants which creates a diagonal pattern of 4 plants touching...

[@CMinorOp67]

Oh, how I SO miss the zero-tick sugarcane farms that needed no bonemeal. 😐 (Or, if only kelp farms wouldn’t constantly break at the source.)

[@ravenvoid3463]

My kelp farm had that issue, but a timing fix helped

[@dirrology]

Do you need a link for the updated zero tick kelp farm

[@Tammicci]

The second design would be better if an observer is put below a piston. Also in that case one observer is enough because every update doesnt grow the sugar cane.

[@Ohi3]

Does it work on latest version bonemeal based

[@PuppetMaster8707]

The best sugar cane farm is the one you as a player prefer like me I love me a nice and tall sugarcane tower but I also like gathering everything manually but wow this was such an amazing build

[@not_devil1730]

Plz tell the texture pack u are using plz

[@OPGamer12288]

Hey Silent! I was wondering what resource pack your using that shows the direction the hoppers are facing?

[@gigantskiced3907]

U can find it on bedrock tweaks