Simon and the makeup debate! who's wrong?

Watch the FULL Clip here: • Simon’s Brutal Honesty...

[@EmGee67]

Looks fantastic without all the makeup and has an incredible voice.

[@uggabriela3761]

She still have makenup. Wake up

[@lizettebreytenbach8433]

Beautiful girl, the little bit of makeup make a big difference.

[@hannaspeaks327]

She literally still has eyeshadow, base, MLBB ( my lips but better) lip tint in nude coral shade and subtle contour done

[@EmGee67]

@hannaspeaks327 The point was it's not caked on.

[@tonyamedsker213]

@@uggabriela3761they said without ALL the makeup... meaning less than she showed up with🙄

[@sammie6481]

he stopped a teenager from being sexualized as a woman

[@lavenderportals]

Eyeliner isn't what was sexualizing her, you were. Freaks.

[@oliverearthur3192]

He was right. Her entire attitude changed as well. She is also simply beautiful without the artifice. Does not need it..at all!!

[@Blackgoldart1]

I noticed the "attitude change too!" 😄

[@Germanatolia]

Dude knows more than just music.

[@Ann-o3p1d]

Artifice. 😂

[@oliverearthur3192]

@@Ann-o3p1d makeup these days qualifies...some can be layers deep as to reveal a completely different person underneath...in her case it aged her and not in a good way

[@oliverearthur3192]

@@Ann-o3p1d makeup these days qualifies...some can be layers deep as to reveal a completely different person underneath...in her case it aged her and not in a good way

[@petrathornewill1761]

Oh man. Simon says he wants to see more of what Samantha is deep inside and then he goes and has a facelift and she comes back natural. How ironic !!

[@mimimustermann1696]

You are 1000% right.

[@len2489]

She's a young girl.... he's a older man.

[@emily.letsendbslintheuk554]

He's a hell of a lot older than 17, she looked far to mature with what she had on her face and clothes wise, I'd of said she was more like early 20s not 17

[@valenlevalenle6394]

She was also only 17 while he’s in his 50s. There’s a big difference. She doesn’t need all of that makeup! She’s a beautiful girl naturally.

[@PetrsKnauf]

He’s old enough to mask himself whatever he wants. She’s a rough diamond, needs nothing to hide🌷🌷🌷

[@annabellejanssen249]

From 25 years old, she went back to 17. Much more beautiful naturally!!!

[@stephaniecarter6997]

She is 17, and she wants to look more mature for her singing audition- I don’t see any problem with that at all.

[@KUKISTANIS]

​@@stephaniecarter6997 change your mindset bro...

[@stephaniecarter6997]

@@KUKISTANIS I’m not your bro 😎

[@KUKISTANIS]

@@stephaniecarter6997 r u gay?

[@0117NUMBER1]

How taking her makeup off changed the way she spoke 😮 And how beautiful is she without make-up

[@mymai5859]

All the make-up at a young age makes her look like a jaded 35 yr old & just like everyone else. Without the makeup she looks fresh, dewy & original.

[@MountainMunchkin-i2y]

Simon you're a jerk ☹️☹️🙁😤😤😤😤😤😥😢😓

[@diane4488]

I totally agree with Simon. She looks a million times better without all the make up. Fresh, young, vibrant. And more connected.

[@ayuyade]

There was no without makeup here lol The before and after are different types of a full face of makeup 😂

[@denimgurung1726]

Simon ❤

[@melindaharrington7588]

​@ayuyade Agree. Second face, was still plenty of make-up just different to her first look.

[@ralphyoung9296]

I hate to admit it.. Simon is right.. she is MORE beautiful without so much powder and paint.

[@shesaid20]

She needed a father’s opinion of how she was presenting herself to the world. Well done !

[@evelyndenise]

It's an AI video. Look at Simon "correcting" his shades... also listen to the way he speaks

[@danielhickmott5800]

Thank you , Simon. I have daughters and it’s important for them to feel comfortable and confident in themselves. For too many years we’ve taught girls they’re not quite good enough without all the trappings. Samantha has many years ahead of her and she’ll do all the better for having learned this important lesson. 😊

[@nicoleenquist366]

Simon is right! Let children be children for as long as they can!!! She looked almost 30 years old with all the makeup. She’s 17, she can inspire all the other 17 year olds that being yourself is enough. She’s absolutely gorgeous and sad to say it, but not everyone is as beautiful and can where no makeup and still be that stunning 🥰

[@margaritatequila5822]

Stop! Shevdidnt looknalmostb30 hater she's finecwithoutbit butbshesxa girl girls love make up its fine too😂❤🤷‍♀️

[@Geminimom22]

She was shy and unsure w the whole get up. Then she changed and her Authenticity showed big time ❤ Let it shine girl!

[@joewearsadroolbib7347]

And Simon had his entire face rearranged. LOL 😅😂🤣

[@taiwanbound5771]

Urmm he is much older and we all know who he is. She is 17 and looked 35 with all the witchcraft.

[@stacym2201]

I was tinkin d same ting. He looks weird 😳

[@Auditinggoa]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@fredb1973]

She definitely didn't need all the make-up, actually looks better without it.

[@Youngbleezy5]

Simon was looking at her like a steak. Ew

[@TommyLeeOscar]

Simon's comment about the makeup was the best thing to happen to her especially in this industry. She is way more captivating and naturally beautiful with less. Less is more and Simon's coaching and advice was spot on! That professional advice is legit absolutely priceless. It was honest and sincere. She is fortunate to have been told that at 17.

[@adrianaadnan9958]

Its crazy how people's opinions can really make people insecure and change themselves..

[@attorneyreid7]

She is gorgeous with and without makeup. She does look much older than 17 with the makeup. Without the makeup, she's youthful, dewy and vibrant

[@Ainaes-Feline]

We all do or did... that is the whole point at that age. They're trying to look older, beautiful and sophisticated...no matter what we old dinosours( aged 30+) think. Look at those 15 year olds strutting up and down catwalks or in front of a camera... They all look 21 going on 30.

[@eyes232]

Believe me, real men, don't need girls with ton of makeup 🤣🤣. I personally, can understand a little here, a little there, but to use makeup until to a point you look completely different.. Is dumb 🤣🤣

[@obedsmith3354]

She was shy and humble without makeups,but was confident and bold when putting on makeups,God have mercy on my generation

[@lynnevanvorce7727]

So much better, she’s just naturally gorgeous. Let that shine not many can say that, but her voice to. Wow.

[@shikorina6165]

17yrs old child looked more like 27 with all that makeup. She looked her age without the make up Simon was right

[@estellebooth1272]

She is absolutely gorgeous without all the makeup stunning 😍

[@juli-fz7ep]

she’s wearing makeup its just light makeup

[@lee4094]

She looks absolutely stunning without so much makeup. Beautiful girl.

[@TravisC.Brown82082]

She’s beautiful without all that gunk on her face! Simon is usually right on when he says something like this and he’s not saying it to be mean! He was 100% dead on with this one because she doesn’t need makeup to look beautiful! She is already naturally beautiful and she does not need any makeup at all! All makeup does is hide her true beauty!!!

[@jerryjamify]

These shows are staged, it's like the fake reality TV.

[@sirinetakieddine2580]

She looks so beautiful without the makeup! Gorgeous!

[@marianailiesi4228]

Omg the transformation its amazing, she looks so fresh and beautiful 😍.

[@teriwinegar8806]

He was spot on. She was beautiful without all the makeup. Amazingly talented as well..❤😊

[@lucindaarmour7422]

She looks great! Heavy makeup makes 18 year olds look like 28 year olds trying to look 18!

[@phwshopping1426]

STOP Let her wear what makes HER feel happy and beautiful who cares what anyone else thinks.

[@sumayabusur5527]

Its important to build her confident that she is beaitiful without makeup , to show her its unnecessary and she is seriously seriously much better without makeup some people dont fit good on makeup and have natural strange beauty without any makeup like this girl

[@nonosfavorites]

I think she learned a valuable lesson. She’s beautiful the way she is!!

[@phwshopping1426]

@@sumayabusur5527 Yes, but I don’t think a man giving his opinion on what she should do is acceptable and if she is expressing herself with hair, makeup, clothes then who’s to say that’s wrong? She absolutely can love herself and still dress anyway she chooses AND wear makeup. 💯

[@phwshopping1426]

@@nonosfavorites or men don’t need to give women lessons we do what we want.

[@sumayabusur5527]

@@phwshopping1426 may be better not consider him a man in this situation he can be advising her in the position of a father and yes she can dress and wear the way she wants but imagine if someone tells you "you are pretty without makeup , you don't need makeup "i believe that would probably make you feel good and this girl's situation is kind of telling her that she is pretty without makeup

[@lajuanaraye]

She is 100x more beautiful without all that makeup!

[@dawn132]

Much better, after natural beauty shines inside and out with amazing voice. Being real is priceless and she's a star

[@rudegyalvanilla711]

She looks beautiful and age appropriate without all that make up. Beautiful

[@mm5467]

She is still wearing a lot of makeup, minus the eyeliner and the eye shadow. But she does look more human without it. More innocent.

[@susanafoltz8283]

Simon’s fatherly side awaken. “I don’t want my daughter presenting herself to the world as a 30 year old. I want her to live fully in her teen years”

[@rickfreitag8085]

It's not the makeup, it's all about her voice.

[@guerline685]

I’m glad he make her remove the make up because she going think without the make up she not good enough

[@honeybadger8413]

put away all the insecurities, take off the mask.

[@jwaltower5836]

Simon knows his stuff 💪🏽

[@cemu1065]

Have to agree with you on this one. Can't stand Simon, but he was right, here.

[@bettygragg6732]

Simon was so right. Most teenagers wear absolutely too much makeup. Most are so much more beautiful without so much. Samantha is a perfect example of this.

[@GoogleUser-fh8ek]

When she returned without the makeup, not only did she look more natural, but she also behaved her age.

[@sherrellmccarthy2301]

She doesn't need that paste on her face. She is a natural beauty. ❤

[@heathers123]

She's seriously more stunning without make-up. I hope she always goes natural

[@MissterX]

How about Simon takes his new mask off?

[@marleneboyer6832]

😂😂 Right

[@karinlinakrauchi65]

Mission impossible😊

[@michaelopere5424]

He can't,because it has under gone several surgical adjustments.

[@MissterX]

@@michaelopere5424 🤣 He was aging just fine, IDK why he did that! Now he looks Rocky Dennis with those cheeks.

[@michaelopere5424]

@@MissterX You are right,his facial skin looks artificially stiff😀😀👍

[@StellaCor13]

I mean she's pretty either way, but the natural version of her suits her age way more in my opinion.

[@Chaos1976]

He’s correct. That is going to really resonate with her and she will always know she’s beautiful without all the make up and just feel more confident in herself. I think it’s a crime that women these days won’t even run to the store quick without having to spend an hr or so doing their make up. That says a lot. My gf wears make up once in a while. On special occasions and even then just a little bit. I think that is more beautiful. For someone to be comfortable in their own skin

[@tracywells9336]

Love him or hate him, he’s pretty much bang on being correct, and when it comes to the shows most of the Artists that came first were 5 min wonders it’s usually always the ones who don’t win that go on to have better careers.

[@EmbedGolf]

Cowell doesn’t even know who he is any more.

[@Noneyabiz411]

What a dumb comeback 🤡

[@traceygrimm4736]

She's absolutely gorgeous without make-up and she looks so much older with it, gladshe took it off 😊

[@doracampos2088]

He is absolutely wrong! Her makeup is her personality.. what makes her feel comfortable. What makes him think that he has the right to change her?

[@hannaneu8232]

Agreed. This emphasis on her outer appearance and the public criticism of her choice to wear make up is cringe. Her face. Her makeup. Her choice.

[@hellojacqui1]

Agree. Women, men, should be respected for whatever that feels like to be true. Simon got this one wrong.

[@mimimustermann1696]

💯

[@MsNanite1]

She's hurt because she spent so much time and effort on the makeup and probably thought that's what looks beautiful.

[@HollyLuYa94]

Just turned 17, and definitely does not need that much Makeup on. She is so beautiful with her bare and natural face! She actually looks prettier without the makeup on. I would've loved to look like that naturally when I was her age. There's nothing wrong with a teenage girl wanting to wear and play with Makeup. I did the same thing. But, in a professional setting, whether it be a job interview, singing contest, etc. Minimal Makeup is always the way to go, especially if you're very young. So I completely understand why Simon wanted to see her without it on. She looked like a whole new girl after. It really was a beautiful transformation.

[@ekeobinna2960]

Most ladies don’t know how beautiful they look without makeup……

[@LocatedLeech]

Yeah it seems like she reminded him of his daughter. So I totally understand the reaction I wouldn't want my daughter just plastered around with makeup, not anybody ever seeing who she really is. It's so bad for your self-esteem cuz you feel like you have to do it

[@elizabethwilk9615]

She looks so beautiful without the overdone look.

[@DP-1868]

Really beautiful without the make up and Simon was so right ! Bless this beautiful woman with an amazing smile and voice

[@ArielLovely321]

Except typically when you show up to an audition with no makeup on and casual clothes, your talent isn’t enough. You’re supposed to dress to impress.

[@mariamahismail9669]

Wow... she is real and more beautiful. Her talent speaks a volume than her makeup!

[@thelastminmom5251]

Well Simon’s opinion on this was 100% accurate. She’s stunning with out all that eye makeup. Shes was beautiful with it, and I didn’t think it looked bad. But when she took it all off and had that fresh face, she looked her age and she looked flawless ❤

[@namelessonewanderland3428]

Make-up can turn you into a much older person unintentionally.

[@JannafayeThompson]

I adore Simon. He has a super special gift. He knows exactly who he is. The difference. ❤

[@Barneyrubble241]

Honestly, she looks better without all that crap. Looks like every teenage boy's dream girl next door.

[@bonitobonita9263]

While having tons of plastic surgeries

[@Upndouin]

Still, whatever he told her was amazing because I am oretty sure she felt more comfortable and confident with how she naturally looks. Simon is not 17 😂 (but I agree with the irony, I just thought it was a positive advice he gave her).

[@dannytripper]

Looks so much better without the makeup. She’s naturally beautiful

[@kenfisher3373]

Absolutely gorgeous either way, beautiful voice

[@nealcook2868]

She's already a beautiful girl. If she wears makeup she just needs enough to accent her features. She doesn't need a mask of makeup to hide behind. With just those few notes I can tell she has a beautiful voice!!😊❤

[@iguessyouknow6285]

He bought out a whole new level of confidence in her.

[@mikemontazer8392]

Samanta, without makeup you look far more beautiful

[@vmc819]

Simon… we would like ke to see you without all the Botox and plastic surgery. 🤔

[@marleneboyer6832]

🎉😂

[@TheJanV100]

She looks absolutely stunning without makeup! A true stunning beauty!!

[@judgementday2291]

This society would say he’s wrong, but in reality he’s right guiding a young woman, he did her a favour she looks way better and sounds free

[@LucianoGuerra-rp4ek]

An if she's also the make up artist it's another arrow in her quiver. Very beautiful.👍

[@aletheabosley3853]

Well......he was right! He wanted her to look 17, not a 35-year-old 17.

[@EazyE_]

It’s freaky how good ai is getting

[@louisestyles879]

At 17 with natural beauty she certainly didn't need makeup.

[@jreneau369]

She's Beautiful- no makeup needed.

[@MariaGarcia-by8yg]

Simon's advice was like...fatherly, I think. Her beauty is appreciated now by herself too.

[@Lindableching]

I absolutely love that Simon did this. He gave her a wonderful gift! That she is valuable and worthwhile because of who she is not because of what she looks like. And now, her talent can shine- and if she wants to put on makeup that’s fine but she doesn’t need it in order to be accepted!

[@Colstan]

She has make up but simpler this time and she looks much better 😊

[@julieannejoolz]

Surely it's the voice that really matters!! 😳

[@amandadavis2906]

She has a beautiful natural face she dont just look better but she looks more confident

[@royfelton1937]

She looks better without makeup button ⬇️

[@juls1371]

He was right. I have an 18 year old daughter and another one that's like my 2nd daughter. When you're so young, you can wear makeup without it making you so look so much older. It's really the heavy eyeliner that was aging her.

[@Lionsmail]

Her initial smokey cat eye make up was cool looking, but it made her appear several years older than what she is in my opinion.

[@rosesakura6604]

Simon isn’t wrong. She look much younger without all that crazy makeup.

[@goshm]

Why didn’t she ask him to get rid of his silicone mask first and then speak?! Hypocritical behaviour, idiocy

[@sec2no153]

Natural beauty, natural talent. Simon Knew she was hiding behind all the makeup and wanted to not only see her, but hear her raw talent

[@ParkViewGirl5]

Simon was direct, honest and gently tactful. I wonder if this was about overall appearance and not trying TOO hard. The result very nice.

[@nanakellie]

She still has makeup on, but it’s natural looking as she is already beautiful & doesn’t need much. Oh and this is a singing competition…. Beautiful voice too ❤

[@mayanksangam9205]

Thats coming from the guy who got cosmetic surgery on his face

[@chefbongoutedge4194]

Simon was so right. Without the make-up she looks fresh and beautiful.

[@liamrochford3649]

So much prettier without the makeup. Girls take note if this, be yourself......

[@marisaanton1146]

She looks better w less make up....my opinion. She's beautiful either way. But to me the more natural look is incredible.

[@moizarshad1762]

Slutty to modesty Will give you success regardless of undressing or not

[@francaevans4326]

Way prettier without makeup her skin glows ❤

[@matildamaher1505]

She looks gorgeous without makeup

[@davidnewcomb2431]

I prefer her with no makeup! Wow shes gonna break a million hearts

[@elz433]

17 and with enough make up that you can make my 70 years old mom look like her.

[@charlenefisher2355]

They way she truly looks better without the Make up, stunning

[@savvysavvy5891]

Young girls do what they see famous people do when they haven't found themselves yet.

[@jeanrevolus5571]

She is 1000 times prettier without the makeup.

[@heidimanalo3890]

I don't understand why teens would put on a lot of make-up that make them look older! Even their outfits are sometimes outrageous. Why can't they just relax and enjoy life as teens?

[@annawalcott7487]

Now she looks like a 17 years old. The makeup makes her look beautiful but older. True natural beauty.

[@angelinaroyal9050]

Simon was right, shes gorgeous without all that liner

[@laxman2010]

Looking great without makeup…no need for anyone to hide themselves under make up