SIMON & GARFUNKEL - THE BOXER | STRONG! | FIRST TIME REACTION

[@peggybrilli2642]

This is where the live audience always joins in.

[@craigwells3655]

Surely, one of the most beautiful and yet, poignant songs. Brings the tough years to light. The struggles, the desperation. Also, there's something magical about a 'Hey Jude' type singalong section that has no message. An invitation to join in with the atmosphere created. Wonderful.

[@donna3465]

Musical talent is God-given and/or inherited.

[@charlesbarry971]

Paul Simon is the greatest lyric writer. The duo is among the best

[@carmenayson6821]

Nowadays, nobody produces the kind of beautiful music that S&G ever had. I was lucky to be born during the golden era of music during the 60’s.

[@emmaemery1099]

U guys don't realize how big these 2 guys were..Paul Simon is genius..

[@marthaleffew205]

The Boxer is my favorite!! It tells the story of Paul Simon when he was beginning his musical journey!!! ❤❤

[@oxford17]

My absolute favorite Simon and Garfunkel song. “I have squandered my resistance for a pocket full of mumbles.” That one line holds within it the human condition…our fatal flaw.

[@mstewart109]

This era of song writing was. Sublime. Told a full Story you could visualize. And the harmonies. Sooo good

[@SueProv]

The sound is a boxer getting hit .Lie la lie is the lies being told to him. Paul Simon's lyrics are as incredible as Dylan's. Art Garfunkel sings like an angel.

[@josephstawicki7265]

YES!

[@anthonyblakely399]

Simon & Garfunkel are among the gods of Folk Rock.

[@anthonyblakely399]

That "Bridge Over Trouble Water," album is Excellent.....and you guys need to listen and react to the whole album for your subs.

[@marilyn6446]

What talent, such harmony!

[@philosopher0076]

Next: "Bridge Over Troubled Water" - Simon & Garfunkel

[@edgarsnake2857]

Believe me when I say, I was just as blown away as you guys just were when I heard this over 50 years ago. Thanks for helping me to relive that moment through your ears.

[@joeblow8940]

I think that you would really like "Bridge Over Troubled Water."

[@kens32052]

1970 Grammy Song of the Year. It also topped the charts in 10 countries that year.

[@MaddyN999]

Love the live show in Central Park

[@johnpigg9240]

I think they reacted to that one..I'm not sure tho

[@breckrichardson390]

Absolutely! They should have STARTED with "Bridge Over Troubled Water". That's one of the greatest songs in history m, from any artist.

[@user-or1ye3iz6d]

Yesssss ❤️❤️❤️

[@nancyknoblauch9226]

Thank you for reviewing one of the most beautiful songs EVER written❤️🎶❤️🎶

[@RadCenter]

Paul Simon's impeccable guitar playing on display here!

[@han6276]

My grandpa told me about this song just before he died, now when I hear it I’m hit with all the emotions. Beautiful song

[@itsmadfar]

Simon and Garfunkle's "America" is brilliant. A must-listen. Yes, Paul Simon is America's troubadour!

[@brianconlon4744]

Love America cos absolutely none of it rhymes. Genius. 🤘🎸

[@tao4mike]

I second America, and I'd add Kathy's Song

[@rhondawest8027]

Yeeeees Absolutely!!!❤

[@beverlybrown2673]

They never did a bad song, every song on every album is a classic.

[@kishka7]

I Am a Rock begins with: "A winter's day, in a deep and dark December...."

[@AGDinCA]

Oooh, truly one of the saddest (yet beautiful!) songs ever written, in my opinion.

[@willasacco9898]

Always gets me

[@TheGreatGig73]

They broke up in 1970 and reunited in 1981 for a concert in NYC Central Park. I was there. It was beautiful and amazing! 500,000 people showed up. I'll say it again. It was Amazing. Check out the Live From Central Park Video.

[@DawnSuttonfabfour]

Its actually Lie lie lie; the protagonists in the song are lying to themselves. Also the big bangs represent both the hard knocks we take in life and the boxer getting hit. Still a beautiful story of a song though. I grew up with this being played constantly as it was my mum's favourite song of theirs.

[@jordan390a]

A brilliant take...!!!

[@DawnSuttonfabfour]

@@jordan390a Why, thank you. x

[@richardsmith5477]

That’s pretty accurate, except the boxer represents us all. One of my previous bosses had a employee tell him, I want your job in a meeting! A few years later he did.

[@willasacco9898]

Yep - a brilliant take and succinct summary. 🤟

[@kilgoretrout5895]

Interesting take but wrong.

[@shoy393]

One brother looks so happy and the other so bored.

[@robsutherland5744]

I appreciate that you don't pause songs you are reacting to. Love this song. Thanks.

[@danielkelleher2419]

This is arguably their masterpiece !

[@kev7161]

I think you guys would really enjoy Scarborough Fair. Honestly, almost anything by them is pretty great. I suggest you explore some of Paul Simon's solo work throughout the 70s and the 80s. They are pretty great, too.

[@annemaclean6634]

One of my favourites of Paul Simon's solo work is You Can Call Me Al. It's a great song, I think it was released in 1986.

[@kev7161]

@@annemaclean6634 It took me years to learn all the lyrics and be able to sing along with Paul when this song came on the radio. Breath control!

[@annemaclean6634]

@@kev7161 That's pretty good, I'm impressed!

[@RicoBurghFan]

I think this is their best song among many, many. You're next one should be America. Cheers bros you are these best.

[@aliciasaracino1233]

The power of good music.. it puts you in a trance and transports you to another place..what a gift music is.

[@happymethehappyone8300]

When It Comes To Beautiful Chill Music,, You Can Always Count On SIMON & GARFUNKEL,, AMERICA & BREAD..All Great Bands With MANY Classic Songs.

[@JerisEve]

Few people mention the brilliance of Paul Simon's guitar playing. He based several of his songs on Bach Inventionen and Synphonien, which he played with no apparent effort. His fingering was extraordinary. Often when you think you are hearing 2 or 3 acoustic guitars, it's just Paul. He had his own picking style that we all learned.

[@couplakooks]

Look up Fred Carter Jr. He was a Nashville session musician and did much of the finger-picking work on this album (not to downplay Simon's skills by any means).

[@jeffmartin1026]

Thank you for posting this on the 4th of July, Independence Day here in the USA. On the season opener of the TV show Saturday Night Live just a few weeks after the 9/11 Attack Paul Simon, a lifelong New York City resident, performed this song by himself while standing in front of several rows of the first responders to the towers that day. When he got to the line "but the fighter still remains" - well, hard to explain the rush of emotions and meanings that song now carries for me. It brings me to tears even now just writing about it. Paul's lyrics - "I have squandered my resistance for a pocket full of mumbles, such are promises" - pure genius. Carry On!!

[@lisamorrison2149]

Thankyou for reminding me of Paul's performance that night. I don't think there was a dry eye in the house..or nation.

[@scarletc.7055]

Wow, yes. I can’t believe I forgot that! I am a lifelong New York City resident as well. Thank you. It’s hard to believe that was 20 year’s ago this 9/11/21.

[@jeffmartin1026]

@Penderyn Lewsyn The revolution was not against the language or the overall culture.

[@rodciferri9626]

Simon and Garfunkel can do this live too. You should check out their live performance at Central Park in New York City. 500,000 people were at the concert, with the proceeds benefiting the maintenance of Central Park. The quality of their performance live was epic!

[@frankiebowie6174]

The verse about the boxer himself in the ring never fails to move me. Paul Simon made us all the boxer, all fighters who remain fighters after leaving the ring.

[@trudywolfe2795]

Their voices are so soothing and smooth. You can close your eyes and drift away. Very nice. They have many good songs. Keep listening.

[@757optim]

S&G. It was a time and what a time it was.

[@floydshambles]

bridge over troubled water is one of the greatest songs ever written, if you haven't done it yet.

[@TheMaRHarrison]

I LOVE this song. Thanks!

[@annemaclean6634]

One of my all time favourite Simon and Garfunkel songs - it's fabulous. Their voices, the gorgeous melody, it's such a beautiful song. I had that album Bridge over Troubled Water and I used to play it a lot. Other favourites are Bridge Over Troubled Water, I am a Rock and Homeward Bound, along with of course Sound of Silence which you've already reacted to. Thanks so much for reacting to this fantastic song, guys, much appreciated and thanks for a great reaction too!

[@angelagraves865]

This is such a beautiful song. I especially love the baritone sax.

[@randomperson-dy6kj]

That weird, deep sound towards the end? It’s such a cool sound! I read that it was a bass harmonica and was intrigued, so looked it up on YT... Yep. That’s what is making that unique sound. It’s the size of a dvd player, but even thicker, and it sounds almost like a didgeridoo.

[@angelagraves865]

@@randomperson-dy6kj Thank you! That's good to know. I love how it sounds. ✌💗🖖

[@IllumeEltanin]

Hi Giorgi and Patiko. It's probably too late to be done today, but as Independence Day is being celebrated today in the USA, Simon and Garfunkel's America would be another awesome reaction to see from y'all. Then, if you can, follow it with a reaction to Yes' cover of the same song. Thanks for considering.

[@glenndespres5317]

This reply may be too late but that was a brilliant suggestion!

[@mikew9999]

Paul Simon also did a solo song after the split up of Simon and Garfunkel, called American Tune, which is mostly forgotten these days, but was a great song and worthy of giving a listen to.

[@IllumeEltanin]

@@mikew9999 A favorite from There Goes Rhymin' Simon, nu?

[@doughaviland1729]

Paul Simon is a GENIUS. Bridge Over Troubled Water is SUPURB!🙂

[@ericanderson8886]

Best duo of the sixties, so many great songs from Simon and Garfunkel. Keep exploring guys.

[@FarAwayEyes69]

LEGENDARY ! MAGICAL MUSIC !!!!!!!!!!!! One of the high watermarks of 60's and 70's rock music ! The music of my youth . Those were the days ! PEACE !!!!!!!

[@lisamorrison2149]

"Those were the days, my friend, I thought they'd never end...."🎵🎶

[@joannparker1977]

Just an incredible song. You can’t beat those beautiful harmonies

[@robertakline9785]

"I AM AN ISLAND" is one you would really enjoy.

[@AGDinCA]

_I Am A Rock_

[@carolrademacher7002]

I am an island 🏝

[@willasacco9898]

And a rock feels no pain

[@amyk9175]

@@willasacco9898 and an island never cries

[@willasacco9898]

@@amyk9175 True lyrics - You can’t avoid pain and heartache only numb yourself and withdraw within a shell, like the narrator of this song.

[@maryhuhnke8496]

I miss New York❤ Their harmony is Iconic! Always was and always will be! Great reaction guys!

[@GEGE-bx3fj]

Saw them in concert...can't even begin 2 explain how good they were... Be well Fr across the waters Canada 🇨🇦 🐥❣️🐥hugs everyone

[@ronkrupovich7152]

"Bridge Over Troubled Water" is one of the best tunes of all time. I would also strongly recommend "Sound of Silence," in particular the acoustic version. Paul Simon's songwriting is second to none--truly poetic lyrics. I got to see Art Garfunkel sing "Bridge Over Troubled Water" live a few years ago--and it was fantastic. Sorry--I see you've reviewed "Sound of Silence." I forgot

[@joshuadeshaies7106]

Nice song bros!!! So unique! Hey you said it, music was just better back in the day bros! Thx guys for your reactions

[@jamesdignanmusic2765]

Another great Simon and Garfunkel song - and a deeper cut - is "The Only Living Boy in New York". Stunningly beautiful.

[@alansmith7626]

I lived thru when this was new...was so emotional to me is hard to hear sometimes, but I still do because is that good...even thru tears, can almost feel the pain, I never forget but is not somewhere I go on purpose because it conveyed, to me, so much pain...yet I still go, Epic tune....I doubt anyone will ever surpass Simon and Garfunkel, on many levels, was a time period thing yet still is relevant. Is like smiling thru the tears when I hear...Bridge over Troubled Waters is even more so...will kick your ass....Thanks Bros!

[@debbie7505]

Try some of Paul Simon’s sole songs. He has a lot of great one. Some suggestions would be 50 Ways To Leave Your Lover, Kodachrome , Mu & Julio Down By The Schiolyard, Diamonds On The Soles of her Shoes

[@debbie7505]

That should be solo not sole

[@garysteinert8040]

The Wrecking Crew is the name of the band. Incredible musicians, there is a great documentary about the music they were involved in.

[@couplakooks]

They were fantastic.

[@bwilliams463]

Charlie McCoy, who plays the bass harmonica here, was also part of an equally-famous group of mostly-country session players known as the A-Team.

[@couplakooks]

Fred Carter Jr., who played session acoustic guitar on this song, was my great-uncle.

[@markjones4997]

Hal Blain in a hallway on drums!

[@Fakeaorta]

One of my first favourite songs. I heard it when I was 10 when I went through my Mom's old record collection. Still hauntingly beautiful even 50+ years later!

[@markburnham7512]

Taking this song out of context misses the great grieving that was so much a part of the songs from BOTW. This was the end of a childhood connection, and it was evident in every song. Such longing and grief. A heartfelt human experience laid bare for us. Bravo.

[@theblackcat5416]

Can't beat Simon and Garfunkel ! Wore this album out and had to buy another one !!!! How about "Homeward Bound" or "I Am A Rock" next ? Thanks for all you do for us Dudes !!! Great memories !!! ✌💖🌻🐝😷🎶

[@jupiterschilde]

I was about to suggest the same two! Also, "Kathy's Song."

[@helenarcarvalho]

Try "For Emily Wherever I May Find Her" and "Song for the asking"...

[@SnowEfaust]

What a heartfelt reaction from both. Loved watching this!! Thanks so much!!

[@Gravicembalo-10]

like a good wine, great comments, cheers doods

[@evelynhoard2845]

My absolute favorite by them! The more you listen to it, the deeper the lyrics get. Also, an amazing assortment of instruments!

[@MaddyN999]

Bridge over troubled water, live in Central Park, please. You will be amazed by how beautiful they sound live.

[@talltulip]

Please react to something -- anything! -- from The Doobie Brothers. You clearly enjoy music from the 70s, so you mustn't miss out on the Doobies. They were a HUGE part of the 70s rock music scene. They were right up there with the Eagles, Fleetwood Mac, Chicago, Steve Miller Band, Steely Dan, Boston, Kansas, ELO, REO Speedwagon, Journey, etc. Note: they had two distinct eras, although they were always considered "rock". Early on, when Tom Johnston was in the band, there was often a stronger blues/southern/folk/country feel. Later, when Michael McDonald was in the band, there was often a stronger jazz/blue-eyed-soul/pop feel. I would recommend one (or more!) of the following. From their earlier years: Listen to the Music, Jesus is Just Alright, Rockin' Down the Highway, Long Train Runnin', China Grove, Spirit, Black Water, Eyes of Silver, Another Park Another Sunday, Tell Me What You Want, I Cheat the Hangman, Sweet Maxine, Neal's Fandango, Take Me In Your Arms. From their later years: Wheels of Fortune, Takin' It to the Streets, For Someone Special, It Keeps You Runnin', Little Darling, You Belong To Me, Nothin' But a Heartache, Here To Love You, What a Fool Believes, Minute By Minute, Real Love, Thank You Love, One Step Closer.

[@johnaldasch9966]

I'm a big fan also saw them 1st time in 1977 Syracuse War Memorial .Jeff Baxter was a member and they played Steamer Lane Breakdown and the crowd loved it.No words in the song.Saw them again a few yrs ago at the NYState fair and they were great.We were 5th row.Classyguys.

[@talltulip]

@@johnaldasch9966 Ooo I love Steamer Lane Breakdown. They have some terrific instrumentals on their albums. I'd love to see some reactions to it, but I find that most reactors usually tend to just react to the songs that are popular or get the most likes -- and those instrumentals are usually not that well-known. Besides Steamer Lane Breakdow, there is Busted Down Around Connelly Corners, Flying Cloud, Slat Key Soquel Rag, Precis, Larry the Logger Two-Step, and South Bay Strut.

[@s.k.m.8756]

you said it VERY well @Terri Wyatt! They don't make music like this anymore!

[@felixnorman9562]

I think they missed the lyrics "a come on from the whores on 7th avenue".

[@johnpigg9240]

Art Garfunkel came out with a tune in 1981..called All I Know.. Absolutely Beautiful 💐..You should definitely Reaction to that.

[@rebeccalipps8007]

One of my favorite parts is the bass harmonica chugging into the melody.

[@Dee-JayW]

Bridge over Troubled Water, Concert in Central Park IS A MUST PLEASE

[@SueProv]

You're reactions are fun . Patrick is chill and George is so immersed and expressive. Keep going guys.

[@douglasclore6244]

This is one of my favorite S&G songs. The part where the Boxer stands in the field wanting to leave but can't gives me chills. Thanks

[@JamesDKlr]

Inspiration. Simon Paul gave me courage to learn the guitar, as a vehicle for words that are true. You bros are a nice blend of opinions and reactions that balance. Peace.

[@user-or1ye3iz6d]

Simon and Garfunkel "Bridge over Troubled water" ❤️❤️ my favorite

[@ekorstanje]

Check out Bridge over troubled water you will be blown away by that song.

[@jimreedy1960]

I am so glad you had a chance to listen to this. you might want to check out their live concert in Central Park in New York on 1980. Half a mj

[@jimreedy1960]

million people came out for it and Simon and Garfunkel didn't disappoint.

[@kishka7]

I AM A ROCK !!!

[@jonsey156]

" I am a rock" - perhaps their most moving song ( well at least to me ) - Thanks for all you do guys !!

[@extracaliber432]

YES!

[@AGDinCA]

Agreed. Truly, one of the saddest songs ever written, in my opinion.

[@kishka7]

"For Emily" begins with: "What a Dream I had...."

[@KH-qv8tk]

Great reaction. You would love "Only Living Boy in New York".

[@cheshagibbons2850]

Absolutely do Bridge Over Troubled Water! Arguably their best. The live version is so incredible!

[@marshastapleton1148]

Great reactions! Thank you!

[@lenny_len]

This lyrics are pure poetry!!

[@candacemay7187]

A beautiful song! It always makes me sad though.

[@RAY_L_A]

Let's hear Billy Joel singing Just the way you are

[@2869may]

Great choice..!

[@RAY_L_A]

@@2869may right on, eh👍

[@carolrademacher7002]

This is a excellent song 🎵

[@nathanward3271]

"I am a Rock," "Bridge over Troubled Water," "Kathy's Song" should all be on the list.

[@franchk8372]

Amazing how Simon and Garfunkel can sound so smooth and understated yet powerful at the same time. A real fun one for a change of mood is when Paul Simon does 'You Can Call Me Al' with Chevy Chase. The comedic element is marvellous. :)

[@kishka7]

Also check out Paul Simon's GRACELAND album where he performs with a South African group called Ladysmith Black Mombasso - EXCELLENT - Check out their live of two songs: Diamonds on the soles of her Shoes -and- Joseph

[@carlosruiz-ob7le]

Hola Bros!, gracias por reaccionar a esta gran canción. Me encanta su letra, su melodía y la gran orquestación que tiene. Un dúo fenomenal, de la vieja escuela!

[@MisterWondrous]

Bridge Over Troubled Water, Kathy's Song, Scarborough Fair, Under African Skies (with Linda Ronstadt), and all of Graceland.

[@tedsmith4385]

You really need to listen to their earlier tracks. I am a Rock, Homeward Bound, America, Scarborough Fair

[@lyndagolding7290]

Every song I hear by them is fantastic but I feel Bridge Over Troubled Water is by far my favorite song by Simon and Garfunkel.

[@rhondawest8027]

This and Kodachrome are probably my favorite songs by them.... I think... 😂 I freakin' don't know they are so darn good it's hard to choose!!!smile ❤

[@vinniemoran7362]

Hearing this after years! What a beauty!

[@kishka7]

For Emily, Wherever I may Find Her --- BEAUTIFUL!!!!

[@micheledash7269]

Me and Julio should be next.

[@ramonaalvarez7559]

Hi George & Patrick. Hope things r good on ur end. Hanging in there here in Georgia. Awesome song & BroActions!! HAPPY 4TH to u & urs Peace Out ✌🏼❣️🤘🏼

[@lisamorrison2149]

Hi Ramona. Happy 4th of July to ya!🎆😎

[@ramonaalvarez7559]

@@lisamorrison2149 Awe many thnx Hun. Very thoughtful. I'm tipping my hat to ya my lady 💞

[@stephenhuber1219]

Hal Blaine was the most recorded drummer in the world

[@tracysnow349]

I like your reactions. Good. Really good.

[@kennyoconnor1523]

Paul Simon did this song on snl after 9/11. It was a turning point for our returning normal.

[@peggie52]

Not sure if you'll read this but anyway....I love the way you guys react to the music...the way very few do....you feel it! Simon and Garfunkel has been one of my favorites since...well a long time. There are a couple of lesser known songs by them that are very short (2 - 3 mins) but have really powerful messages and I've never seen anyone react to them: A Poem on the Underground Wall and The Sun is Burning! Hope you get a chance to react to those.

[@cindysellari4705]

I’ve always felt this song is my life story. I’m a girl but it still fits so perfectly 😊💕🦋🎶 I’m new to your channel. Looking forward to your next video 😊🎶