Sims 1 vs Sims 2 vs Sims 3 vs Sims 4 - Campfire

Sims 1 vs Sims 2 vs Sims 3 vs Sims 4 - Campfire
Sims 1
The fire pit in the Sims 1, comes without wood. When your sim goes to light a fire, they will manually stack individual logs in the pit and light it up using a match. Sims can sit around the campfire, roast marshmallows, tell a story. In very rare occasions a ghost named Green Beard the Ghost may come for a visit and and scare the Sims that are listening the story.
Sims 2
When you buy the campfire comes with already stacked wood. So your sim will just light it up using a lighter. Like in The Sims 1, in The Sims 2, sims sit on the ground. Up to 4 people can sit by the campfire. Sims can warm hands and they can also roast marshmallows.
Sims 3
There are Portable Fire Pits in the Sims 3.Sims will light the fire using a lighter. Up to six chairs can be placed around a fire pit. Unlike the previous games, Sims don't sit on the ground. They will automatically place a chair and sit, except when a sim is telling a ghost story. Sims can poke the fire, warm themselves and roast marshmallows. But they can roast any kind of food that is in their inventory. When sim is telling a ghost story, other sims will sit on the ground. Sims can also burn herbs. Unlike the previous Sims games, in The Sims 3, Sims can put out the fire.
Sims 4
Campfires in The Sims 4 come already stacked with wood. Sims light the campfire using a match, and sometimes get burned in the process. If there aren't chairs available, your sim will stand by the fire, except when they are roasting food. You can add log to the fire. Sims can play a guitar and sing songs if they have at least 3 skill points. They can burn money,
play with the fire. Tell group stories: adventure stories, fairytale, and after 7 PM - ghost stories
Sims can Roast five different kinds of food - marshmallows, hot dogs, veggie dogs fish and beetles. Like in The Sims 3, Sims can extinguish the fire, but with a bucket of water.
Who is your winner?

[@chyrchhella7804]

It’s amazing how old and simple the Sims 1 is, but so much work and love was put into that game ❤️

[@AstarionWifey]

and then they fell so hard

[@badreedinedjellali1328]

I honestly I'm playing sims 4 and it's such dewengred from sims 2

[@ma3nafsi496]

​@AstarionWifey actually EA games became greedy after making sims 3 and sims 4 and that's why it's lackluster

[@r.s.wihananto5203]

You miss something! Campfire in the Sims 2 can be extinguished... by male sims... by peeing on it.

[@alinnkagf]

really?? didn’t know that!

[@lauracasero2849]

Me neither

[@tintaverse]

haha I think they can also pee in bushes

[@talkoutside]

@@tintaverse how about trees

[@YellowBriefs]

I think only sloppy male Sims can do that

[@loverhouse13]

ngl the sims 1 killed it

[@LitrallyAJ]

The Sims 1 has some of the coolest object interactions. The mechanics may be overly simple now, but I feel like most of the time that actual objects were far more interesting and had a lot more effort.

[@Gingeries17]

It's also still the hardest Sims game too, since it's so hard to keep their needs up and to build friendships. That and the no weekends.

[@Gumbier_Than]

​@@Gingeries17 You are so right, brings back great memories too. 😊

[@nurazieranatasya8307]

The uncomfortable silence and the stares as the sim in Sims 3 warming herself kinda make me laugh yet awkward at the same time😂😂😂

[@aeoligarlic4024]

The most relatable and realistic bonfire experience tho 😂

[@auzzpanda3497]

sims 1 wins for me. the interactiones between the sims around the fire feels realistic and natural. sims 3 and 4 have more options but I hate how they just sit around detached from one another, like robots. In that regard, even though sims 2 has little options, the way they automatically start chatting also gives it a realistic and cozy feeling like sims 1

[@hiimfelicia2929]

"The smacking :(" comment took me out 😂😂😂

[@tintaverse]

haha I can't stand loud chewing, so I found it a bit triggering 😂

[@aeoligarlic4024]

He's REALLY into that marshmallow 😂

[@sarahhunter5757]

I love the Sims 1 singing.

[@Momoirokagami]

The sims 1 group campfire songs interactions are so wholesome. Four iterations into the franchise though and I am still waiting for the option to make s'mores at a campfire. Even if I turn to mods I don't think I have ever even heard of a mod that makes that possible.

[@autumn_west]

There's definitely one for the Sims 4

[@Momoirokagami]

@@autumn_west As this is a showcase video of how campfires work in the different versions of The Sims I doubt that's the case straight off the bat. So you must mean through mods and to that all I can do is sigh and say "Well, at least someone finally made it a thing."

[@autumn_west]

@@Momoirokagami Yes, I meant a mod, sorry I thought I made that clear. It's a pretty old one actually as far as I know

[@Momoirokagami]

@@autumn_west Nah no worries. I think it's great that it exists at all though it is sad that modders had to do it. There's so many people who simply have no idea how to install mods never mind installing them correctly and yet that's the state of affairs with The Sims quite often. If not to fix bugs then to add content that should realistically speaking already be there.

[@kameronfarris7672]

Miss girl in the sims 1 runnin for the hills😂

[@titanblade3706]

I think Sims 1 won. Not only does everyone look like they’re having a good time, but I love that everyone song songs. Sims 2 did great too. Sims 3 I like they have more food options. Sims 4 it’s fine too

[@Lautnerfan415]

The Sims 3 university life came with another bomb fire pit, with added interactions and the bonfire party option. I liked that the fire got bigger the more logs you threw in and that throwing test tubes in could change the color of the flames.

[@tintaverse]

Yess, the bonfires! Maybe I'll make a separate video on them

[@Sonjayu]

And you could also add herbs to it to make it smoke and produce fun effects

[@fueyo2229]

The Sims 4 also has another type of campfire added with Get Together where you can't roast food but you can dance.

[@bratzbabyjoy]

LMAO she ran so fast from that ghost

[@CaitlinCoy-uq2jg]

And the others were not amused 😂

[@SuperPalamara]

Greenbeard the Ghost scared me when I was younger, no lights on, in the middle of the night playing the computer. I like the realism in Sims 1 when the sim has to add the logs.

[@tintaverse]

The sound that plays when he comes out was so creepy 😂

[@StrwbrrySmmr]

the sims 1 is really cool but the singing sounds like when everybody doesn't *quite* know the lyrics to the song but they're trying their best anyway.... But the sims 3 outright feels so damn awkward lol Nobody is talking or having a super fun time... it feels so weird and quiet

[@christinestone391]

Forgot the Sims 4 part where sims usually just get up and leave after a few seconds instead of participating or interacting, making the campfire not very fun. Sims 4=the fun killer

[@GameQuirk]

Honestly... It's hard to determine an exact winner. Each game have their own special quirk. Sims 1 - I love how the Sims actually build the bonfire. Also, I love how the character takes off running from the ghost story lol 🤭 Sims 3 - I loveeeeee the visual effects when the Sims tell a story; absolutely amazing!

[@RGSuperfan]

I think that on the sims 1, if you sit by the fire with kids and sing, the kids might laugh at you. This is hilarious

[@nn992iv5]

That butt shake 😂

[@reidasplataformas9397]

I love songs of campfire in Sims 1

[@tintaverse]

Same! My heart felt warm somehow

[@estebanquito6779]

2:55 we know who survives in the horror movie

[@Gumbier_Than]

I know, she booked it right out of there! 😂

[@Ballora1965]

Sims 1 did it the best!

[@oliviamills2285]

Sims 1 singing sounds like they don't know the words

[@Gumbier_Than]

Or like they were on something. 😂

[@Sav22]

6:04 how they staring at her warm her butt in the fire😂

[@johanrey1416]

In Sims 4, while this is random but Sims can make S'mores while roasting marshmallows.

[@xbjrrtc]

Ah, yes, roasted bottle of honey. Just like mom used to make

[@nicholasgerry6931]

God, The Sims 2's animations are top notch. But The Sims 1 win on this one.

[@Holidayflowergirl]

TS1 wins here, for sure. It’s so cozy and sims are actually interacting and having a good time. I feel like TS4 tried to take after TS1 here; they are interacting, singing songs, playing music, then there’s the ghost summoned by the ghost story. Nice try, TS4. But as usual the cozy atmosphere was still lacking, at least compared to TS1.

[@plumpydayz]

The Sims 1 kind of looks like it's a horror game, or something like Don't Starve XD

[@talkoutside]

i can litterally understand she will be coming around the mountain

[@lukas2.036]

5:45 horse jumpscare

[@nn992iv5]

I love the vibe in Sims 2

[@gyppygirl2021]

I was always somewhat disappointed that The Sims 3 only had a fire pit, not a true campfire (not counting the bonfire as it's a separate thing). That being said, it'd probably be easy to make one as custom content. lol

[@Lovlyb35]

Sims 3 had the bond fire too, which was clearly missed in this video. Also that you can throw bonfire party with kegs and sims can play music, dance and throw test tubes in the fire.

[@OfficialToxicCat]

The sims 3, I use to keep food in my sim’s inventory for the fire pit and even made them throw herbs in the bonfire pits for Rebel influence.

[@thiago64]

for the first time, The Sims 2 was the worst

[@mrabidos2173]

In terms of what, how dare you ?!! 😂

[@thiago64]

@@mrabidos2173 The Sims 2 had less detail compared to The Sims 1, 3 and even 4, But only in this video

[@mrabidos2173]

@@thiago64 Fair enough, but TS2 for me is still the best overall

[@prudencephoto8225]

TS1 is the best in campfire! It's very cozy and singing together is amazing! Also I like atmosphere in TS2 : how they're sitting on the ground in different poses and talks! ♥ Warming butts looks like very lazy twerk 😂 thank you for video! perfect as always 🔥

[@tintaverse]

Thank you so much dear! ❤

[@lynfletcher7744]

the fire is so unrealistic .

[@walruswilson]

​@@lynfletcher7744 no it's not unrealistic

[@farahhbisyirr]

I appreciate your effort on shooting on different angles and showing us the details! ❤ very nice work!❤

[@tintaverse]

Thank you so much dear! ❤️

[@flare90]

Sims 1 was pretty much the best 😂

[@Jenzzyuk]

I love how when you clicked for Karen in sims 2 to warm her Hands, she stood up and she warmed her Bottom 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@mrabidos2173]

I do really wanted myself to have my sims girl groups going on on a camping and have themselves sit over on around the fireplace but i'm just plainly scared that they are going to caught in fire so i don't trust it 😂

[@ville666sora]

4 would be the best if my sims didn't catch themselves on fire EVERY SINGLE TIME THEY USE IT lol

[@bixbysnyder-00]

These videos illustrate all too well the decline in the AAA gaming industry

[@Fama_11]

The campfire song in sims 1 so awesome...i hope sims 4 have it

[@blistlelo1700]

Hmm I wonder what roasted bottle of honey would taste like! Melted glass and burned honey on a stick!

[@christoferdrewrocks1]

4:45 nice transition :)

[@tintaverse]

Thank youu ❤️

[@montymontridge]

Thank you so much for this series. It's fun to compare all the games. Sims1 wins this round for me, though Sims 2 is my favorite of all the games. I recall how disappointed I was that my sims couldn't sing around the fire anymore. (I also got the ghost once and that was too cool! lol) I never played the campfire in Sims 3 or 4, but I enjoyed seeing both and I thought both were pretty awesome. I liked the story telling in 3 and 4 brought back the guitar which made me happy.

[@magesticalmysterium6856]

also the Ghost Scare in TS1 will cause Sims who have Low Bladder to pee themselves, as Onlyabidoang had mentioned in a Easter Egg video for The Sims 1

[@QoSwords]

The ghost coming out the fire in the sims 1 😂 I had no idea even after all these years that could happen! Its hilarious

[@LoleexRU]

I love your outro! Nostalgia, funny, great editing! :D

[@nn992iv5]

It’s soo funnyyy 😂

[@tintaverse]

Thank you so much! ❤

[@espesita2487]

This video made me snack on a cookie with marshmallow

[@echostar2007]

The sims 3 ghost story part made me lose it with the floating skull head. XD

[@Paramurasaki]

Just combine The Sims from 1 to 3. Throw Sims 4 in a bin and VOILA! The perfect game.

[@cah1-wm3nv]

2 is the best

[@michaeljbowker9782]

sims 1 did it better Ghost stories in sims 3 was part of Generations thy will tell Ghost stories any where doesn't have to by a fire

[@adrianblake8876]

I'm pretty sure it came with World Adventures...

[@michaeljbowker9782]

@@adrianblake8876 no ghost stories did come with Generations

[@elizaandreadaki9942]

If the pack where from ehich the interactions came from matters then sims 3 should win cuz campfires are base game. It doesnt matter though

[@cow6irl699]

I like the variety of options in Sims 3 and Sims 4, but I personally think that Sims 1 is the best because they all participated in a sing-a-long

[@gabrieleferrari6524]

1:03 I'm laughing ! 😂

[@Reeseychoo]

I like The Sims 2 and 1 especially 3.

[@nissan_sunny_club_brn]

1 и 4 часть в этом хороши. Но 1 душевнее, как мне кажется.

[@Salliewalker]

You forgot the bonfire dance!

[@tintaverse]

I did a video on the campfire. The bonfire had different options ❤️ ❤️

[@nedrane297]

Sims 4 SEEMS like it would be better but functionally Sims 3 is better because can roast anything.

[@Persona3Yukari]

I like both sims 1 and 4

[@pavel5129]

Wai wah grilled watermelon?

[@samgaming943]

a nice family campfire bond then you see grandma warming her butt a really akward moment

[@Bbtwink]

The sims 3 camp fire was realist animations but random items

[@mariafyodorovna8362]

Waiting for Stockbrot Dough roasted on a stick, till it's eatable bread

[@itkahsramal4983]

It be great telling ghost stories in S4 if sims were scared of ghost😩.

[@lynfletcher7744]

they can be scared of ghosts

[@itkahsramal4983]

@@lynfletcher7744 in my game not at all. Not even one Sim is scared of the ghost. And it drives me batty to see a ghost DJ!

[@ville666sora]

They are lol

[@fdboodles]

Finally something in the Sims 4 is better

[@TomasinoT]

So much detailes in this games are 🙂

[@jennadelena]

Shes Not Worming Her Hands Must Be A Prank Sarcastic

[@ikaryu99]

love these videos

[@lynfletcher7744]

sims 4 now sit on the ground to roast since horse pack came out

[@CaitlinCoy-uq2jg]

Could you please explain how you manage to play the old sims games? I’ve only been able to play the sims 3 and 4

[@tmmaston]

17:36 Slapped all the way to The Sims 4

[@AzzAra09]

I prefer Sims 1 and 4 for this one

[@adriancab8810]

the only time when sims 2 was the worst

[@456loveluck]

Sims 3 too😢

[@mariairibarren8985]

2:56 that's me when I have to pay my credit card

[@deinemudda6104]

On the sims 2 male sims with a low bladder need will always use the fire if they are outdoors XD

[@tintaverse]

Yes! So funny, they will even do it in the bushes ❤

[@deinemudda6104]

I know , smh. I had just spend half an hour building the most beautifull rosegarden (bathroom was next on list) when the sim of my bf p**** all over it. MAN get some manners sim that looks like K. XD

[@aulettemartins4995]

The sims 1

[@huDAVE1]

Sims 4 is not bad here and Sims 4 has the best looking sims but they look soulless and drugged. it kills the campfire mood...

[@456loveluck]

Sims 1 was lively 😂

[@keixavauri2277]

If u buy and use the other campfire thingy (the big one) in the sims 2, you can tell stories with your other sims! Well the interaction looks like them hanging out tho, nothing that special

[@tintaverse]

yess! that is the bonfire ❤

[@456loveluck]

Sims 1🥇 Sims 4🥈 Sims 2&3🥉

[@radosawbazejewicz8033]

4

[@VincentGeraldoYT]

1:11 17:10 On top of old smokey

[@456loveluck]

To be honest, those songs almost sound like gospel praying songs 🙏🎶🎹🎤

[@anyaforger4096]

Sims 1 the Best

[@slainesheils6032]

Sims 4

[@KJC.76]

2:25 💀💀💀

[@g.e131]

Sims 1 killed it. Sims 4... ehh.

[@LaraCroftEyes1]

Sims 2 campfire outdoes Sims 4 campfire.

[@jackofallgamesYT]

Can I ask why? Aha all they can do is sit, warm themselves and roast marshmallows. In 4, they can sing, tell ghost stories with real ghosts, play with the fire etc. Sims 2 actually has the least gameplay in this video 🫣

[@crazyfrog5552]

@MirenaVlad Sims 2 campfires are awful lol, what’re you on about.

[@lynfletcher7744]

sims 4 is way better

[@456loveluck]

​@@lynfletcher7744 boring crowd 😂

[@lynfletcher7744]

sims 4 is the best .. 1 and 2 . omg worst

[@kiki_davis]

I just realized that the songs in the sims 1 sound more like English but its actually simlish