Singers FIRST TIME Reaction/Review to "Postmodern Jukebox ft. Haley Reinhart - Creep"

We're reacting to "Postmodern Jukebox ft. Haley Reinhart - Creep"
Original Video: • Creep - Vintage Postmo...
Support us on Patreon:
/ mareckproductions
PO BOX: (for letters and other small stuff!) (for parcels, please first contact me on Twitter or Facebook, because you cant send them to PO Boxes!)
MareckProductions
Postfach 11 07
95101 Rehau
Germany
Social Media:
Facebook: / mareckproductions
Twitter: / mareckproducti1
Ali's Twitter: / ialikut
Ali's Channel: / @hevsog
If you have any suggestions what else we could watch just write it down in the comments or contact us!
Thank you so much for watching!
Love you all
"COPYRIGHTS: FAIR USE, Title 17, US Code (Sections 107-118 of the copyright law): All media in this video is used for purpose of review & commentary under terms of fair use. All footage, music & images used belong to their respective companies."

[@autumnatic]

Left Guy emotional progression: Surprise, confusion, skepticism, guarded enjoyment, suspicion, seriousness, delighted laughter, more seriousness, questioning, disbelief, self-consciousness, letting go, entranced, taking back control, entranced again, coy smile, blushing, possibly drooling, resistance, denial, hooked, unhooked, incredulity, concern, groovin, shook, inexplicable Elvis face, guffaw, entranced again, pain, relief, disbelief, tuned in, confusion, skepticism, helplessness, giggle, denial, rapt attention, reflection, amazement, delight, acceptance, still can't handle it, trying to hold it together, processing how this is even possible, *giggle explosion* Right Guy emotional progression: Falls in love within 5 seconds, accepts and enjoys his fate.

[@dandurant4845]

Just amazing! You should be a writer/comedian.

[@liviusss]

I wish I could love this comment a 1000 times! Hope the guys will read it!

[@monieluvs4125]

Oh my, best spot on comment I have EVER seen! Where's the love button 💗

[@gloriaandrea2539]

Autumnatic you are very creative and funny!!!

[@memathews]

Yep, he heard Circe.

[@frankparoots2980]

As a huge Radiohead fan, this clip kills me everytime. She kills me with her voice. Makes me want to cry. You can feel it. Post Modern Jukebox is one of the best thing that happened to this world.

[@NatalieBoat111]

Frank Paroots same!

[@victormatautia1157]

Yes

[@twowongs8266]

Me too Frank, great version !!!

[@tammycenter8757]

Complete agree.

[@lucaorlandini5020]

im a huge radiohead fan as well, PMJ e Haley are just a miracle!

[@donhall6626]

She did that in one take on a day off.

[@marbienmaranan4927]

Don Hall

[@johnguttink]

Scott Bradley and Postmodern Jukebox only do one take versions of songs.

[@shashankiyer5751]

Not really, it multiple takes. This version got done in 3 hours

[@James.Stark.Ben.Edition]

They practice it a couple of times and then do a final take. They do entire songs in one single takes, is more accurate. There's no cuts or anything. Its one single take.

[@lauraguerra6450]

Not only one take. It was the first take. The first run, the trial run... perfection.

[@eswing2153]

Fun fact: this was performed in one take.

[@Johnny-sx2mp]

Carl Williams can't say i'm surprised, she has a beautiful voice 😌

[@bobbleslackmore4127]

All Post Modern Jukebox videos are one shots. It is a particular stipulation (among many others, such as: all playing band members need to be on screen) to avoid copyright law infringement.

[@mysredeyes]

She didn’t want to do it at first because she was sick. Scott Bradlee managed to talk her into it

[@markdemos75]

Another fact is she came in THIRD on American Idol. Idiots

[@eswing2153]

Mark Demos we all know this. And she’s all the better for it.

[@Station5Patriot]

You can always tell when something is good, because nobody says a word...

[@episkoposministries7003]

Episkopos Industries so true, it’s like eating a good meal no one speaks so to enjoy it 😂

[@sarahcoleman5269]

The guy with the beard took a trip. I mean, the whole time the song was playing he was not in the station. The song ended and it was like he finally took a breath. XD

[@kerristian3568]

If ever I am in the mood to watch two men with beards simultaneously fall in love, I come here.

[@nameless9060]

zionistah under rated comment.

[@Journeyman.71]

Every man (and many women) who watches Haley sing this song falls in love!

[@stuartcole4845]

Maybe one day it will be with each other !

[@AwkwardTruths]

The gentleman's reaction on the left is a 3 minute study in someone's mind being blown. He's shocked at first, then sort-of accepts it - while - he shakes his head no because he can't accept it. Shock replaced momentarily with confusion all the while muttering "yeah", then he remembers he forgot to breath the last minute of her song. Finally, the laughter...

[@aliefrusman7621]

Well, glad i read this

[@fava7753]

Phsycologist this guy .

[@aydengray6820]

This analysis is spot on.

[@autumnatic]

Haley Reinhart has the power to turn any grown man into an excited, entranced teenage boy. We ladies aren't immune either! lol

[@TheTrueAltoClef]

ay I've said it before, as a guy: ladies have something unexplainable going on

[@Letsbefriendsnow]

5 years later and I still have a gigantic crush on this women, that I can not shake. Can we clone her?

[@sonofalerik09]

Since the original will be forever beyond reach, put me down for a Haley clone.

[@celestialmanrichard8846]

Well said and completely true

[@aarontkacheve4595]

Yea pretty much

[@jamiesunshine8836]

When she got kicked off American idol....I vowed never to watch again if she didn't win....and I haven't watched it since. They don't know what music is. lmao She's freaking amazing.

[@reijoshualadjahasan]

SAME. I WAS SOOOOOOOO PISSED OFF THAT TIME LIKE WTH ??!! HALEY WAS AND WILL ALWAYS BE THE BEST ON THAT SEASON LIKE SHE SHOULD HAVE BEEN THE WINNER

[@reijoshualadjahasan]

@Marvin Munnzsame. Am not sure if you like Jessica but, I was so disappointed she's just the runner up. I mean she did so many crazy stuff.

[@TheTrueAltoClef]

That's a modern talent show, and they just suck

[@captainanopheles4307]

It's probably the best performance and song ever recorded. It makes me cry every time and I'm a 48 year old bloke.

[@BULLWRINKLE]

watch pmj all about the bass---smokin

[@lacrima9713]

Watch iron sky - paolo nutini abbey road studios

[@marvinboswell3820]

You are right .if you look up this version of this song it has like 85 million views . Unreal

[@rayhutchinson640]

Four years later, this is still one of my favorite reactions to this video!

[@victorsixtythree]

He didn't say anything but I know what Ali was thinking the whole time, "Don't bother me while I stare at the future Mrs. Ali."

[@jamesmorrison7847]

That was a masterpiece. She is in a league all by herself.

[@bringeroflighteternal9789]

I absolutely love the pure unedited totally raw and spontaneous reaction of these two guys reviewing this Radiohead Creep rendition by Haley Reinhart. The reason I say this is because, I was also completely left speechless after hearing this song. I was totally blown away, all I could is just gasp in awe. Instantly fell in love with Haley and her voice , seconds after this video.....

[@JazzPowerInitiative]

I love them shaking their heads. I do it too all the time with Hailey.

[@superjon78]

Dude on the right had the PERFECT reaction(s) while that song played! He was 100% in the moment taking it for its full face value.

[@maneljaballah2701]

I need a WWII era movie with this lady as the lead actress. Hollywood needs to make this happen.

[@davidlowe6960]

Oh man. I cried when I heard her cover the first time. I felt something in my soul awaken and tears just came out of nowhere when she belted those notes out. Beautiful voice and phenomenal cover! The way she sings it just puts all of my emotions and everything I’ve always wanted to say towards my deceased ex girlfriend into one song. It really is something to behold. ❤️

[@terrywood3518]

April Love I still cry, every time...

[@tamarakennedy4976]

Hailey Reinhart is the best singer of this century....she slays everything she sings...she has a sultry presence her movements are so dreamy with her complete control over her voice...

[@mubiadik32]

She placed third on season 10 of American Idol. She's phenomenal. If this is your first time hearing about her, then you should check her version of Bennie and the Jets, House of the Rising Sun and I Who Have Nothing. By the way, you two remind me of Mike and Sully on Monsters, Inc. Haha.

[@pokeyphillips9087]

Check out Can't Help Falling in love! Her version is beautiful.

[@Fvneral_moon]

how tf did she not win

[@nomms8172]

TornPaperYoyo i need answers

[@dariongreenlee]

they wanted a country singer to win and the judges hated her

[@transportrrt]

she was robbed, you could see it in her face when they announced the winner and it wasn't her.

[@katkaplesarova1446]

My favorite is "Seven Nation Army - Vintage New Orleans Dirge White Stripes Cover ft. Haley Reinhart" or "Oops!... I Did It Again - Vintage Marilyn Monroe Style Britney Spears Cover ft. Haley Reinhart"

[@adamredmayne1326]

7 Nation is my favorite as well!

[@Minxdrunky]

Katka Plesarová have to agree the seven nation army cover is magnificent

[@EduM8V]

Ok

[@JC-dg5iv]

Yaaaaasssss 💅💅💅

[@Marieq]

I love her new album! I love, Honey there's the door, deep water both amazing! Seeing her in Buffalo in October.

[@katemcalpine2836]

"You can count on us doing a lot more of her." That made me LOL.

[@jacsonmagno5013]

2:18 *when man fall in love*

[@kaylynhilson9932]

She is my favourite singer right now. She gives me goosebumps, and I love how unique her style is. From a sweet whisper, to a raspy kick ass voice. She’s incredible. She was always one of my favourite contestants.

[@donnilloyd1355]

I know this Post is a few years old but I never saw this one. Both of your reactions, AMAZING. Haley Reinhart is, Outstanding. Especially in this video. Great Post guys.

[@andyeql]

I love the way you laugh at the end. Not because it's funny, but because what you can possibly say after that performance! It was so good that there's just no words!

[@shannonmatabei1833]

She was my favorite in her season on American Idol. I practically had a meltdown when she didn't get into the finals. She's AMAZING. Her cover of Can't Help Falling in Love is a personal favorite of mine.

[@richiengawhika3384]

I don't know how many times I have watched this. I love their reactions, they have fallen in love with Haley. You're ruined. Have fun guys.

[@jllopez787]

The big dude looks like he's hypnotized lol. I love this song

[@doorran]

I've been listening to Haley's postmodern hits for years.. You really need to try her "Black Hole Sun" , "Oops, I did it again" or her "Seven Nations army" covers! :0) BTW, Haley did this Creep video in one take on her day off. Priceless reaction guys. :0)

[@docrichardson7034]

Black hole sun is another beautiful song by her

[@Midway_Midway]

Yep, Postmodern Jukebox is amazing (and so is Haley), so I'll add another suggestions, with another amazing artist (in my opinion)! Postmodern Jukebox: Take Me To Church - Piano / Vocal Hozier Cover ft. Morgan James

[@j0hnn13K]

and Maps, that song is great as well :)

[@yazannimri1623]

I’ve watched this reaction at least 50 times. Thank you.

[@mindylafler3456]

Yes, Marco. That is the exact reaction to have for this artist. She was a contestant on American Idol. No, she didn't win. She performs with Casey Abrams. Casey plays the bass, and they have a style that leads them in similar styles. My husband loves her. Thanx, Mindy

[@jeremywck8757]

Mindy Lafler Casey DID NOT win. Haley came in third behind two heehaw-twins who were preordained by the show power-to-be who rigged the show and ordered the judges (especially JLo and Randy) to slammed Haley’s performances for imaginary mistakes. Check Haley Reinhart in Wikipedia and see how many KZbin videos of hers they took down because of the millions of views and it embarrassed the American Idol bosses!

[@victormatautia1157]

Mindy Lafler If your husband doesn’t love Hailey Reinhardt and Casey Abrams, you need a divorce.

[@gynack]

@@jeremywck8757 It makes you wonder how many views she would have racked up by now if these videos hadna been taken down at all.

[@schumifannreins295]

Great choice, can't go wrong with Postmodern Jukebox! Check out Puddles (from Puddles Pity Party) performances with them as well - great guy :)

[@leob3447]

Oh Puddles is awesome as well :-)

[@DoggfatherUK]

Yes definitely

[@ehkika7]

I think you are trying to lead him to Mad World with Puddles and Haley.

[@lavyaisha1926]

Side to Side 70s soul cover feat. another non-1st winner of american idol lol i forgot his name but his skill is diviiiine

[@MrTkaczu]

check "all the small things" PMJ and Puddles...

[@Twykye]

When a voice is perfectly aged like whiskey in a wooden barrel...

[@jimithy47]

Haley Reinhart is phenomenal! I think she could sing the telephone directory and be as stunning. She and Casey Abrams have collaborated on numerous songs starting with American Idol contestants and many since. Love and appreciate your reaction to an amazing talent.

[@growselha]

I just love the uncontrollable smiles people have when reacting to this...

[@j0hnn13K]

Haley has been a favorite of mine for a long time, and its thnx to her work with Postmodern Jukebox, i also got to know a few other ridiculously talented singers, You really need to check out Morgan James as well (she's on par with Haley), the two did a few songs with PMJ, and some of those together as well. enjoy :)

[@agriperma]

Morgan James, cover of Dream on, sends chills down my spine.

[@j0hnn13K]

Yes, her version of Dream on is absolutly ace as well. Pretty much everything she touches turns out great :) i would like them to react to the maroon 5 cover "Maps" because the original song is ... kinda mediocre, but she and Scott turned it into a amazing piece of 70's soul.

[@Gizmo42Rodeo]

Those are my 2 favorite PMJ singers. Never heard of them before they did songs for them. I watch the covers from those 2 over and over.

[@transportrrt]

they did "All About That Bass"

[@algarcia4707]

They did dear prudence and killed it

[@donnawalker3910]

I'm watching your video in January of 2020 and Haley's 'Creep' video now has 73 MILLION views! And well deserved. Brava

[@jasminehenry2058]

I keep coming back to watch your reaction to Haley.

[@accylad8996]

I think it's so funny how you two are so gobsmacked after watching this :) It's one of my favourites too.

[@freshbrewedasmr3378]

The expression afterwards was like them two having the best ear-gasm and the euphoria 😂

[@leob3447]

I am SO glad you reacted to my suggestion, I had a feeling you would be blown away by her as well. She's right up there with Tori in my book too :-) I think I have a pretty good guess which video thumbnail of her's that caught you eye. Keep up the great work guys, love your reactions.

[@dropthehammer1360]

You need to listen to her singing Mad World. PMJ as well.

[@theuntimelyone3234]

Dude on the right is exactly how I was when I first heard this.... couldn't do anything but stare. Haley sings right into your soul.... you can't help but be taken by her voice. 10/10

[@DetroitNickel]

I always come back to this reaction by you two. I love your appreciation for her as the total package. I can't wait until this epidemic is over for her tour to come back.

[@aaronblossfield2095]

I love her so much! Her voice has so much power and range its amazing.. Her and Morgan James are such a blessing to listen to! Postmortem jukebox is so, so good!!

[@amanhasnoname4270]

Haley is incredible! Check out her Seven Nation Army cover for PMJ too.

[@victormatautia1157]

A Man Has No Name Little did he know, they would.

[@vincentscimeca3033]

Went to her concert. She is even more amazing live. Should be a legend! Listen to Baby It;s You

[@guylagalindo2430]

She placed 3rd in American Idol in the 10th season. She's an incredible singer. Loved your reactions.

[@hannahmore9118]

I know my reaction, as a woman, to this performance(awe), but it is quite amusing to watch all the different guys out there trying to do a musical analysis and end up with jaws on the floor and needing a cold shower. Its hysterical!

[@LtJackboot]

Your speechless reaction tells me you know good when you hear it. She's going to take over the world.

[@lydiasmith9842]

I absolutely LOVE Haley! She's got such a great voice. Thank you guys for reacting to this!

[@musicandmoviefan9217]

You two honestly make me smile with your reactions. Some fantastic choices I have seen from this channel

[@MrAxlfalcojesus]

I THOUGHT THAT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO WAS IMPRESSED ABOUT THIS GIRL, SHE IS AMAZING

[@jimward204]

Mesmerizing. You just can't stop listening. Thanks for the reaction to this version of one of my favorite songs!

[@Falindae]

This is a gem I have loved for years! So glad you'll be watching!!!

[@kimcassidy6429]

There is amazing magic in Haley's "Creep". She is transformative to the audience, who feel as if they've been through a life event in just hearing her. I've prob watched her sing it a hundred times. At least. And it's always breathtaking.

[@1Andelina1]

Best reaction to Haley Reinhart Creep video, she had you guys!

[@icyluna567]

Haley Reinhart competed on a season on American Idol. She didn't win that season. You should also check out "Seven Nation Army" by Postmodern Jukebox featuring Haley Reinhart .

[@kellianhunte5649]

it was season 10 when Scotty Mcreary won.....

[@Noveighmber]

She was my favorite on the idol.

[@HelloKittyFreak96]

Lol I loved their reaction!! Like they looked memorized! 😂❤

[@StreetTruckinTitan]

They should have lit a cigarette.

[@mr.b.5589]

Mesmerized.

[@Melissa-wx4lu]

So excited to see you watching Postmodern Jukebox, all their stuff is amazing, you need to react to more of it!

[@danielenriquepenaaristeo5850]

You should react to "Oops i did it again" by Haley Reinhart from Postmodern Jukebox, Too sexy to handle

[@hondansx1000]

personally i think that was her worst one she's done with PMJ...dunno if it was the arrangement Scott did or something, but it's pale in comparison to the other songs she's done with them. just my opinion though

[@SeanGelarden]

She moved effortlessly between five different styles, absolute mastery

[@transportrrt]

I was stunned too the first time I heard her do this version..

[@Wiley_Coyote]

Guys, here's the one you NEED to react to. Haley, who we just saw here. The Postmodern Jukebox band, who we also just saw here. And a giant 7 foot singing clown named Puddles. I am not joking. Here's the link. The song is "Mad World". kzbin.info/www/bejne/l4fIp6mYe7N-n7s

[@EmilyDawn1137]

I'm so glad you guys reacted to this! You both have fantastic taste in music and a great appreciation for it, you seriously can't go wrong with ANY Haley Reinhart or Postmodern Jukebox! Cheers from the U.S.!

[@polmabini8398]

Probably the best cover of Creep I've ever heard. You should also react to Postmodern Jukebox cover of Sweet Child of Mine by Miche Braden. A reimagining of the song.

[@rmstacy5295]

best version of Creep I've ever heard,,,bar none

[@valentinogrimaldi2103]

probably the best cover ever, probably the best singer

[@georgelynch6139]

Miche is phenomenal, she took “Purple Rain” away from Prince and made his version seem like a cover tune. Checkout PMJ Purple Rain👍

[@caseynicholson9190]

Mesmerizing....She puts a spell on you..World Class Talent!

[@heyclaire6894]

And this is, my guys, a “Haley Reinhart Reaction”.

[@Rellj16]

Still one of my favorite reaction videos to anything EVER! LoL It's so real and authentic...

[@justinwilton4603]

im a massive radiohead fan and i really wanted to hate this but this has got to be the best cover of a radiohead song or any song !!! the voice is on another level !!!...ive now fallen down the P.M.J rabbit hole and i got to say every cover they do is special :)

[@paularrowsmith9376]

She hooked you both ,reeled you in and mesmerised you pair good and proper, leaving you two "gobsmacked" .well done haley

[@AzaDio]

I just found thos but I wanted to say your reaction was great. I love the moments of silence. I have followed Haley from American Idol. Great video guys.

[@yvonneclaes5208]

I must really love you guys because normally I wouldn't click on a reactor's video unless it was PTX, Superfruit, Avi, etc. But damn! I'm glad I did. I love that you two are exposing me to great music. Thank you!

[@shannenleigh1677]

She does an amazing version of black hole sun too! Check it out!

[@shannenleigh1677]

^^^ pretty please. You will really love it

[@sheawhitey8631]

I HEARD IT TODAY...WOW!!! SHE IS UNREAL...AND NO ONE CAN REMEMBER WHO CAME FIRST ON AMERICAN IDOL THAT SEASON( SHE WAS 3RD)...THEY NOW KNOW..THIS SHOULD SHOW EVERYONE THAT VOTED WRONG... IS BEAUTIFUL OLD SOUL OF A YOUNG WOMAN..IS BETTER THAN SOME CRAPPY TALENT SHOW.

[@merryxmaswarisover]

I concur. I turn to this version time and time again. Such a lovely sound.

[@deadsexyradio7045]

I found Haley though PMJ. She is fabulous.

[@frankandvicky8337]

You guys are awesome!! I laughed at your reaction because it was so genuine.Haley is amazing!

[@earthsciteach]

Watching two dudes fall in love. LOL! Same thing happens to me when I hear Haley Reinhart and Morgan James sing.

[@JashanaC]

I love Postmodern Jukebox! I got to see them perform live (with Haley present!) a couple years ago. :D I've loved her since her American Idol days!

[@cheshirekatzlexi8865]

Lol love your reaction...she was unexpected to say the least! Absolutely breathtaking!

[@gracetrevett4846]

Really tremendous! Absolutely wonderful! Thanks

[@deannharris2424]

You guys look as mesmerized as we do. Haley Reinhart is great. Truly love her and it's so amazing because she sings from her heart. You can tell that she loves singing and she truly commits to any song she sings. Love your review and reactions!

[@jennyknits]

Love your review! You know Haley did this in ONE take! She is amazing!

[@lindaprosperie70]

You guys are right about Haley . When any person immulates Betty Boop, Marilyn Monroe, Jessica Rabbit in their body language , yes they ARE trying to be seductive and sexy.

[@dannunya959]

you are watching two men melt in front of your eyes

[@Tuclix]

Yeah. I get goosebumps every time I listen to any of her songs. Especialy this one. Her and PMJ's version of Creep is a true masterpiece.

[@outrobiscoito9552]

It's funny cause we can see on their faces they're falling more in love with each note she sings

[@stevebradbury1914]

Everybody who hears the SLAYER for the first time has exactly the same look of amazement on their face JAW DROPPING!

[@snezhana941]

Cooooool reaction😱😱😱 Your faces are amazing. Thank you guys 💋

[@sunnyleatham5435]

Loved watching you guys see this life changing event

[@ChileanRipliancum]

Wow, after that reaction to the amazing Haley Reinhart I had to suscribe to your channel right away. I hope that you'll continue reacting to her incredible talent.

[@mayiplantthishere2676]

This rendition gets me every time, it's so good man #GOOSEBUMPS

[@doorran]

gotta check out, "Jeff Goldblum & The Mildred Snitzer Orchestra feat. Haley Reinhart - My Baby Just Cares for Me"

[@lxhobson]

What a great reaction -- from both of you!

[@marykatedurett8285]

You two are phenomenal at reactions 😘. I LOVE watching your faces & then your truly honest opinions!!! Marco you are hilarious & so handsome

[@pedrotomcat8232]

I love their channel, good playlist to hear after work. So relaxing. 😎

[@steavenwalton9004]

She rocked your world boys!