Singers Reaction/Review to "Forestella - If I Leave"

[@까꿍-d7d2z]

내가 본 유투버들 중에서 당신들이 제일 맘에 드네요. 꾸밈없는 모습에서 진정성이 느껴짐

[@esunkim5677]

WOW. Thank you for watching 'our' Forestella, again.

[@laurasmith3814]

My heart hurts. The music, the emotion, the voices, the perfect duets, the group dynamics... cant say which is better than the other. Full version is a must !! Thank you for this reaction

[@하루살이-j9w]

This song is about the death of Myungsung empress by Japanese mobs in Chosun dynasty(1895). We have very sad history by Japan's invasion. It is too sad for us to forget the case.

[@donnabouldin4391]

It is so sad that you like so many others had to start cutting your videos. But you still managed to give a true and fabulous reaction. Forestella certainly deserves to be exposed to more people. And more people need to be exposed to them. You put it perfectly. They are perfect for each other to give us goosebumps on top of goosebumps every time. Thank you for your reaction.

[@mariatetera6695]

Muchas gracias y felicitaciones por mostrar la belleza del arte de mi grupo favorito Forestella. Saludos cordiales desde Chile, América del Sur.

[@jennamcmillan3991]

Oh my god... Such a breathtaking performance!!! Thank you so much for doing a reaction on this!!! Forestella should really go viral!!

[@smk9033]

This song has the background of Korea's tragic history.When Japan invaded Korea, Japanese brutally murdered the last Chosun dynasty queen. And the song was made by a Korean who estimated the feelings of the queen at that time. That's why it's a sad song for Koreans.It's a pain for the times that have gone so .

[@Oh-r5r]

Yes, Our last Empress Myeongseong... :(

[@Number-777]

@sm k 고마워

[@호주-i7r]

and they still keeping the sword

[@divad4711]

Thanks for the informations!

[@청죽-v8u]

해외 리액터 중 내가 구독하는 몇 안 되는 분들. 감사합니다. 열심히 보고 있어요.

[@jiwonnia]

Both of you are speechless..Same here. Super-emotional. I am so blown away by their performance. 😭 This is an empress’s song predicting her own tragic death, originally OST from a TV drama based on real Korean history. That explains why this is so sad. Thank you for your reaction.

[@gregdaniels3656]

They should honestly be recognized by the entire world. Seriously.

[@JackieHarris-il2eb]

Beautiful

[@5607won1]

Whenever I listen to Forestella's "If I Leave" I can NOT listen to WITHOUT tears ! Really touch my heart ~! 😢😭💙🌷💙

[@ysc2917]

because of it is based sad real story about our last queen who was killed by japan!

[@BrendaJohnson-br8hy]

Had me in tears... Such an emotional and yet technically superb performance!!!! Wonderful reaction!!

[@자유대한-t4p]

관객이 눈물을 흘리는 건.. 이 곡의 배경이 있기때문인 듯 합니다.. 명성황후...를 왜가 시해하는 사건과 연관성있는 스토리( 드라마의 ost)였어요..찾아보심..더 진한 슬픔이 느껴집니다.

[@sniperkim-JK]

this song means.. Is one of the saddest events in Korean history. It is a modern event that Japanese people raided, killed, and burned the queen of the Joseon Dynasty into the palace. Japan still doesn't even apologize This song is ost "Go Me" fame empress by the world's best soprano Cho Sumi.

[@손오공-n1b]

저도 이 설명이 꼭 필요하다고 생각했는데 영어가 안되서 ㅜ 님 댓글에 속이 시원하네요

[@sniperkim-JK]

@@손오공-n1b 고맙습니다. 이 노래는 의미와 역사성이 더 중요한거니 짧은 영어라도 간략히 설명하려고 했습니다.

[@hildommar]

Great reaction guys and sorry to hear about having to cut the video because of KZbin changed requirements and copyright issues., but thanks for the link to the original …hopefully people figure out that they can watch it there in full. As many have explained the history of this song, I won’t repeat it but will say that despite not understanding Korean, Forestella has been able to convey to us the deep sadness and distress in this song. We don’t need to understand the words on first listening…when you listen to it via the link in the description box. For novices, you press the ..…more button just below the title here which takes you to the description box to the right of your screen…look for the little you tube icon which should take to the original video…it is the tv station this was recorded on that owns the rights to the video, not Forestella.

[@슴슴-n8c]

Shape of you - Forestella!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@5607won1]

Welcom back to your Forestella's reactiom ! Thank you so much for your reaction again. Forestella's version is the best one than any others "If I Leave" in my herat. They are really emotional!! I listen and listen repeatedly this song with much beautiful sorrow of Forestella's amazing harmony. Their expression of the music seems to be developing rapidly beyond my imagination! I really love Forestella ~♡☆♡~💙🌷💙💞

[@막내꼬나]

정말 몇개월만에 보로 왔내요. 두분 Hi. 영어로 멋지게 근황도 인사하고 방갑다고 말하고 싶어지내요. 다 잊어묵어서리 미안합니다. 그래도 간만에 와서 너무 좋아요.두분 더욱 번창하시길 바라며... 또한편으로 포레스텔라에 최근 재미있는 영상이 있어 소개 드리고 싶어요. Foreastella에 조민규 개인이 유튜버로 올린 Speechless In 8 Languages 꼭 들어보시길..

[@조영애-n2v]

포레스텔라의 애절한 나가거든을 리액션 해주셔서 감사합니다👍👍

[@chantellerose5224]

Can't describe it with words... such a heartwarming performance!

[@ritat7788]

Thank you for the reaction. Love Forestella so much❤️. Please react more to this group.

[@jina4673]

포레스텔라의 아름다운 노래 리액션해주셔서 감사합니다~^^♡

[@아자아자아자화이팅]

Thank you for the reaction. Their songs are sad and beautiful. It's really great. Thank you very much.

[@youngheelee6134]

It is so good to see you guys again with another Forestella reaction! First of all, I totally feel your pain with cutting the videos. I support you guys and I don't mind the cut videos if it means keeping your channel in tact. That should be the top priority. And Forestella's performance here was simply exquisite and extravagant in terms of musicality, interpretation, and harmonization. Bravo!

[@yunalove7561]

Thank you so much for the reaction!! Here is the lyrics; Underneath the lonely moonlight / If a shadow of me appears / Then shall I just tell you how I feel inside / So you can at least listen... / If all of a sudden a wind blows alerting the wake of the dawn / Shall I just ask like a gentle sigh / Why am I living? / I must keep on living despite the sorrow / I must keep on living because of the sorrow / I will only know after I have lived this life to the end / The reason why I came by this world / Those who remember me after I am gone / And my sadness / Tell me I was loved... / Like scattered sunset / If my painful memories have faded / Then will my heart be able to smile / About the nostalgic events in the past / A star standing alone over there / Perhaps it knows my loneliness / Because it can't leave me alone / It stays in the same place all throughout the night / I must keep on living despite the sorrow / I must keep on living because of the sorrow / I will only know after I have lived this life to the end / The reason why I came by this world / Those who remember me after I am gone / And my sadness / Tell me I was loved... / Please, in the distant future... / Those who are saddened after I am gone... / Even my sadness was happiness... / (Make them believe that... (even my sadness was happiness)) /

[@IreneMy]

Thank You for the lyrics in English 👍👍

[@gerdagrobler2485]

Thank you.

[@hildommar]

Thank you for the lyrics …it’s 2024 and I am a fairly new fan…❤only a few months old.

[@youngjang1264]

They said, "We practice 300 days of the year together." I praise you for your talent and enthusiasm!

[@davidk3422]

I admire the duo for remaining gracious under pressure, managing to come up with some decent reviews, not losing brain or running away from these totally shocked emotions. You are one hell of objective, analytical, and technical experts.

[@laurieanderson2221]

So emotional... So captivating!!! Thank you so much for your reaction!! Your reactions are always so genuine and enjoyable!!

[@오오옼케이]

Wonderful sing and wonderful performance they have done !! They're amazing !! They have personal style but they make for a perfect harmonies for their own cover of the best song. It's fantastic emotional moments to me !! Thanks for reaction with Forestella performances ~ I gonna wait for next time !! See you soon guys 빠이 ~^^

[@H쿄쿄]

I came back for your videos again!! Im always 100percent satisfied with you guys

[@stellaha]

Wow. Thank you for your reacting and analyzing Forestella. They did their job amazingly and I want everybody enjoy their performance.

[@김정은-t8f4s]

오늘도 두분 리엑션보러 왔어요 감사해요 포레 다른곡들도 블ㄹㆍ킹 풀리면 많이많이 해주세요

[@skwon0220]

MIND BLOWING PERFORMANCE!!!!!! Thank you very much for the reaction!

[@paigesummers2571]

You guys are back!!!!!!!!!!!!!! So happy to see your reaction on Forestella!!

[@라라이글]

두분 리액션 정말 감사합니다~~❤

[@yeolmaemini1580]

thank you for listening and reaction.

[@HK-qg8qb]

Thank you very much for this reaction!!!!

[@enoyue768]

OMG! They keep trying and evolving. It's an amazing Harmony. I enjoyed the video. Thank you for your reaction!

[@조해정-t5n]

I enjoyed a lot this reaction. Thank you!

[@haribo8080]

they are the definition of PERFECTION

[@amylee9190]

Wow I've been waiting for this, thank you for the reaction!The emotion of this song is too damn powerful, my eyes get watery everytime I watch this performance. Could you guys react to their live performance of 'My favorite things' from 'Open concert'?

[@5607won1]

Yeah! I hope too! "My Favorite Things" is excellent choice with Forestella's nice stage performance ~♡♡♡~

[@crystalh1495]

It will be amazing and satisfying . You won't regret it

[@neinsagerin]

Yes, this performance is worth your reaction!

[@sekyungkyun6279]

Their voices was so sad and gorgeous.

[@이성순-s4m]

포레스텔라 정말 멋진~👍 따라갈수없는 포래스텔라이네요~~~👍👍👍

[@seniorarmy2769]

I recommend Je Suis Malade sing by Forestella

[@sueg4298]

I love their harmonies and your reactions. Pls more react to Forestella, My Favorite Things, Sound of Silience, Magic castle(마법의 성), Speechless by 8 languages by Mingyu Cho(Forestella member) etc.

[@김정은-t8f4s]

내용을 아시는지는 모르지만 보는 중간에 일부 넘치게 오버하는 유투버같지 않고 진정성있게 들어줘서 고맙고 마음이 가네요 좋아요 꾹~~~

[@user-ch7do5pin2g]

Thank you for the reaction so much

[@hengout3293]

Thank you for the reaction. This song is so sad but so beautiful.

[@NeoTube-Earth]

It's not an ordinary song. They singing sad korea histoy with heartbreak. It was used as the background music for a case in which a Korean empress was killed by a gangster in an invaded country. Thanks for reaction. I like MA :)

[@행복이-y8l]

두분 다시 활동해주세요..😭😭🥺

[@yanicatblog]

Thank you for your reaction and you guys are one of the best..

[@hamster8103]

Thank you for your reaction ♡

[@user-mc2rw3sq9m]

이 노래의 배경을 알고 들으면 슬픈 감정을 더 이해할 수 있을텐데 아쉽습니다. 대한민국의 역사~ 조선의 국모가 일본에의해 잔인하게 시해된 사건. 그 사건을 배경으로 만들어진 노래입니다. 아픔 그 자체~

[@knowhow2327]

Thank you to all the foreign fans of forestella! I really hope many more people will know them 👍

[@김경리-f1s]

이 유튜버 분들의 리액션 들을만 합니다. 포레스텔라 리액션 감사합니다.

[@kaimitoyuko4900]

I swear!this is the most perfect.,wow!👍👏❤

[@shk5549]

Good, Thank you

[@estelapereira6366]

Esta canción me hace llorar y ellos la cantan de una forma tan especial que conmueve .Son GENIOS estos chicos ❤❤❤❤

[@ryanpeters8629]

Nicely done, Forestella!

[@abnewgemchoice1699]

If I leave, if I'm right this was covered by sohee, the very first time I heard this song I literally cried hard, it was so beautiful

[@rurujihye]

기다렸어요!!

[@하느리구르미-r9d]

굿! Good 감사합니다 Thanks 🙏

[@쮸뗌-b2s]

이곡의. 내용은. 너무나 슬프고 애절하기때문에 ...... 정말. 노래가 아름답네요...

[@김정은-t8f4s]

리엑션 항상 감사해요 💕💜💏💙💚😍

[@gracielaamaro3861]

Thank you for reaction. Amazing Forestella 🤗😘

[@soloist9164]

I swear , Everywhere. I miss you.

[@김은주-l4y3f]

This song is about the last queen of Chosun dynasty of Korean kingdom..she was brutally killed and burned by Japanese invaders....

[@이드니-b5z]

Wow~~~holy harmony.

[@gracielaamaro3861]

Wow amazing harmony.

[@정라온-u6l]

I miss your music reactions so much.. (From korea)

[@moonlim33]

Feeling so heartbreaking sad... Felt the tragedy history..

[@H쿄쿄]

Even though i am Korean myself i didnt know such an amazing group existed. This song is really wonderful song but also the one that cant be easily allowed to be sang by any singers because of the lylics and history this song is holding. I just want to suggest that it would be much more better if you can review the song with the knowledge of meaning of the lylics to more thoroughly and fully understand the song itself. Thank you for good video anyway i really enjoyed it😚👍

[@zinitaxozinitaxo1581]

Yeah, they are my most favorite group ever. :-)

[@SilviaScarlatta]

Lloro cuando la escucho, no hablo coreano pero transmiten pena y dolor. Es increible

[@ninalouisebernalte]

Glad you appreciate this group, Forestella. I am also a fan of great music, especially live performances. If you have time, can you watch Park Hyo Shin's live performance of Wildflower? That is such a great song. Heartbreaking and inspirational at the same time.

[@진달래-t8t]

오랫만입니다. 이 채널의 포레스텔라 리액션 기다렸습니다. 리액션 감사합니다.☆☆☆☆☆

[@달달한마늘-r2l]

여최예은 me too~

[@셀라-z4z]

Forestella / "Champions " please ~~ It's a greate song I've ever heard

[@줄눈하는두더지부부]

Thank you so much 😊❤

[@joem248]

AMAZING....

[@yysybc]

고마워요♡♡

[@dohykim35]

THANKS ~~~ 고마워요^^

[@송수아-t4l]

감사합니다❤❤❤👍👍👍😀😄😀😄😀😄

[@달료달료]

Please show a lot of reactions to the other songs of Forestella.

[@mul_ddang]

말잇못하고 있는게 왜케 웃기져ㅎㅎㅎ thx guys

[@쥬리-r3f]

There is a real history of Japan invading Korea. There was a case where Japanese samurai murdered South Korean Queen Myeongseong. This was aired as a drama. It's the theme song for that drama. Koreans are more saddened by this song.

[@dumdum2097]

Next time, I would like you to react to 'Speechless' by MinGyu Cho, a member of Forestella. (in 8 different languages ; France, Norway, Russia, Korea, Germany, Italy, Spain, America) I think you would absolutely love this. (KZbin - "FEMD9wFuI60" ) And 'My Favorite Things' by Forestella. It's like a musical! 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' style. It's an awesome cover! (KZbin - rmUb50nNTx0")

[@LunaVivo-fn4fx]

🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@greenheart1374]

Thank you!! Forestella - Nella Fantasia Reaction Please~~!!

[@jenny4901]

Nice reaction. Thank you!! Please react their 'my favorite things'.

[@Paul-dz1zd]

제가 제일 좋아하는 리액터

[@숲별2047]

Thank you for the reaction.

[@bortexo]

Admiro o trabalho de vocês,amo forestella.saudaçoes do Brasil.

[@hykim3180]

If you see this, and if you are willing to, plz plz check Forestella's other videos: Champions/ Shape of you/ Dell'amore non si sa

[@OoTalkeroO]

Thanks for the reaction, it was so enjoyable. :D They are masters of harmony for sure, but at least they are terrible dancers...so that balances them out I guess.

[@99s22]

forestella "parla piu piano" reaction please~🤗

[@laurasmith3814]

For anyone interested.... this is a love song about Queen Min, the last Empress of Korea who was assassinated. Her love for her people and their love for her. It is sung with pride by all especially on 15th Aug to mark the day of independance in 1945. My heart hurts even more now :(

[@k.joomihyun]

Assassinated by Japanese

[@쭈니즈맘]

전곡듣기해주세요~~ 훨신 감동적일꺼예요

[@gabri2828]

The background of this song is the incident where Japanese Yakuza raped,killed and burned the last Empress of Korea, so forestella would have tried to express that desperation.

[@francescastura4962]

Beautiful reaction! Korean musical phenomenon Song Sohee also sang this song, I recommend reacting to it If you have the chance.

[@dsdsdsdsdsds_s]

DIMASH KUDAIBERGEN New Wave 2019 ReactionThank you😊🌼

[@forekook3762]

들을 수록 좋네요 리액션 감사합니디