Skuld CONFIRMED To Be Subject X? - Kingdom Hearts 3 ReMind

It seems thanks to a translation of the Axel/Lea Character File from Kingdom Hearts Character Files that the Mysterious Subject X is confirmed to be Skuld from Union X, but there may be MORE to this revelation leading up to Kingdom Hearts 3 ReMind!
►Learn how to support HMK for $1 a month on Patreon! / hmk
►Subscribe! - kzbin.info...
►Become a Member! - www.youtube.co...
/ @hmk
►Twitch! / hmkilla
►Facebook! / hectichmk
►Twitter! / hmkilla
►Instagram! / hmkilla
Thanks to all my RAD PATREON SUPPORTERS!
Rocklee325
AxelLover95
Sarah M.
Vonder23
Matthew O.
Echovald
Dr. Drakon
Backstory Ben
Ventheguy
Jray
Chrissie H.
HappyRubberBand
!Joedan!
BaronParadox
Tee
TARawson
All of HMK's gameplay recording is done by Elgato! - e.lga.to/HMK
Gaming Metal Tracks - / @briann2911
#KingdomHearts #KingdomHeart3ReMind #KH3ReMind #KH3

[@HMK]

Has it FINALLY been confirmed that Skuld is indeed SUBJECT X, and with the memories of Lea / Axel can this lead to a haunting thought that existed throughout Kingdom Hearts? Lets get past 1000 Likes!

[@noahdean9685]

What if our player character stay behind as well.

[@sissterdarkness]

I was thinking and I may have over thought. But why is xahanort wearing a goat head mask? I can't find out why he chooses that form. I also realized why the whole group from that union cross game gives me odd vibes. There is a religious group in real life that meet in secret that wear masks. Though the group im thinking of is a bit darker by normally wearing black (hmmmm more rabit hole theories springing about in my mind now) they kinda carry the same vibe. Satanists. Look them up. Im an extreamly open Christian but to be honest, as soon as I saw xahanort sport that goat head I knew religion most definitly is in kingdom hearts even thou its not stated that it is. Maybe to figure out some of the mysteries we need to see what parallels between religious beliefs and certain aspects of kingdom hearts. Off topic; but I really want to have the liveaction melificent involved in the next kingdom hearts and maybe even see sora in her world sporting wings like her and seeing maleficent was never the villain we thought her to be. She is honestly one of the few Disney characters not confined to her own world and effects the core kh story line.

[@evilordoftheinternet4116]

It also adds to why Isa thought Axel was replacing him and Skuld with Rosas and Xion,

[@woowootube1348]

HMK you have the right idea about why xion is seen with black hair by Axel and Roxas but its half right. You got to remember why Roxas looks like Ventus to really get the full secret here. Xion is a mix of two important memories. One belongs to sora and the other to Ventus. sora's memory of kairi and ventus memories of skald. If kingdom hearts as a whole has taught us anything its that hearts contain memories and that those memories can bring back what we once thought was lost forever.

[@Zelink108]

woo woo tube You do realize that that “Heart” basically means soul right? The english versions got that lost in translation. “A lot of this revolves around the word "hearts". The word in Japanese translates to the effect of "What makes you, you." Which an English speaker might translate as "souls". However Heart is valid enough translation and with the various heart symbols it was kept. Which was well and good... until the Nobodies came. Who "Lacked Hearts". But were not the Heartless, who lacked bodies.”

[@nanamiokami7236]

9:20 well it’s true that Roxas sees Xion mostly as Kairi because he’s a part of Sora, but remember he’s also a part of Ventus. Ventus knew Skuld so that could be why Roxas sees Xion with black hair instead of red.

[@liquidsteel3190]

To further your point Roxas has Ven’s sleeping heart which also affected Axel so maybe that’s why they both saw the same person in Xion

[@AAbattery444]

With this info, I finally figured it out. Skuld is asleep in the data version of twilight town's chamber of awakening. That's where ansem hid her. It's also the only place she could be. In kingdom hearts 2, that area was also locked off and some kind of force prevented us from entering that location. So it's lore-friendly.

[@KibaNaruFan432]

I agree there it makes sense

[@darktheg.o.d5541]

Ansem didn't hid her tho

[@Paigemarie467]

Ansem didnt hid her or take her out of her cell, it was Braig/Xigbar/Luxu. Luxu took her cause he knew who she was

[@Paigemarie467]

And we dont know if she is asleep. From secret report 1, which she wrote, it seems that she is awake and living her life in some way. We just dont know where though

[@KHDecoder]

Skuld has a star earring. Skuld represents the stars, Isa represents the moon, and Lea represents the sun. The sun, the moon, and the stars.

[@blacksheep9834]

That is soo cool like how ven aqua and terra are wind, water and earth.

[@jose_montehappy]

7:52 HMK: ”Brain stayed behind.” *After that on screen we see Young Eraqus fall back in the chess in order to give hope to the present gang aka Sora during the Keyblade War* Past reconnecting with the future. Reconnect Kingdom Hearts confirmed. (Take this last part with a grain of salt LOL)

[@confessionconcession6757]

This is a stretch of a stretch to the reason behind Xion's black hair, but you can also give some fault to Ventus for knowing Skuld lol.

[@HMK]

I said before that it was gonna be a stretch when getting to that part! LOL Just let your mind wander!

[@veeegy2745]

Ahhhhh you beat me to it. Said the same thing but then saw your comment, lol.

[@sodathejunker]

Beyond Solace #9406 you know… Skuld was actually a genuine friend to Ventus, so it makes sense Roxas may have ties to her. He’s a byproduct of Ven and Sora, so his vision of Xion could be a byproduct of Kairi and Skuld. And Kanemaki is a HUGE point. He practically wrote the entire backstory to Vanitas as a character and his development from birth to forging the X-Blade. Not only does Vanitas also has black hair, it would make sense that while writing Days and onward they took special care to craft any characters tied directly to Roxas in a way that reflects Ven, not just Sora.

[@gracekim25]

Søda Meløn good point

[@wonderingobserver2231]

If you think of axel and saixs age skulld could be sora’s mom! It could explain where she’s been

[@doliteair]

Anyone who guessed it was Skuld before this confirmation, Pat yourself on the back, you deserve it!👍

[@kurosakikun96]

I genuinely thought it was Ava after the final scene of the base game, but this is actually even cooler in my eyes

[@lucapeyrefitte6899]

It made more sense

[@XArias21]

Yay I was right

[@ShadowXemnas13]

As others have stated, the Skuld-Xion thing might not be too big a stretch if the connection is via Ventus and not Axel/Lea. Xion's appearence to Axel is likely from his own memories, but Roxas is connected to Sora who is connected to Ventus, thus the chain of memories could cause Roxas to see Xion with black hair, mixing Sora's memories with Ventus' memories. Timeline may not 100% fit for Axel, but for Roxas? The connections are so deep that it is indeed possible.

[@NightwaveDarkKnight]

I literally had a feeling it would be Skuld. I mean, it seemed like the pieces were all there. So Axel/Lea's character file basically confirmed it right there. :P Also, haven't seen the ending part with HMK being norted in a long time. owo; HMK's dark side is baaaack~!

[@K_logart]

Now that Lauriam and Elrena are back to being somebodies, and Ventus is awake, I really want the dandelions to reunite, or at least to remember eachother (bc it looks like Ven still doesn't know a lot about his past); I'm pretty confident Ephimer died and didn't make it to the future, and of course Strelletzia is dead, but idk anything about Brain, tho I believe he's related somehow to Eraqus; oh yea, it's all coming together

[@kevindimas253]

Yeah I think brain may have stayed behind and eraqus could be a descendant

[@belmontking12]

There's one thing that still bothers me tho. If eraqus is related to brain, then why does he fear ven so much? Wouldn't his ancestors have passed on the knowledge of the five union leaders in some way? Is that why he fears ven and he has the suspicion of ven's true power/nature?

[@Doralga]

Thought Ephemer was a heartless that was dark inferno oddly given an X with DLC Wich would explain his appearance in the 2nd keyblade war if he was dead he have the white coat

[@FallenAngel8742]

Just a throw away but i really want brain to be related to einzo somehow.

[@browhat1161]

Kevin Dimas brain isn’t part of the first line of union leaders. The first line is the lost masters. I doubt that brain and eraqus are related, unless it’s a translation error or something like that.

[@matthewdickendasher1956]

I wonder how each Foreteller will reveal their faces in the future. I’m so excited! May your heart be your guiding key

[@Marx-XIII]

I don’t feel like the Xion - Skuld connection is that much of a stretch. I mean, obviously Roxas has pretty strong ties to Ventus. It could very well be that his perception of Xion was shaped by Sora’s memories of Kairi, and Ventus’s lost memories of Skuld.

[@BabyGirlTiny]

Roxas doesnt have a very strong connection to Ventus anymore than he has a bet strong connection to Kairi, they just look like each other

[@Zelink108]

Homez18 How so?

[@Zelink108]

Anthony Troiano What if Xion IS Skuld?

[@Marx-XIII]

Zelda Fan77 I mean, before KH III I thought Roxas was gonna be revealed to be Ventus.

[@MattManPlays]

@@BabyGirlTiny bruh. They look like eachother for a reason. Ventus's heart was in sora when roxas was created. Sora's heart became his heartless. Ventus's heart was in roxas. That was why he was able to dual wield keyblades. Vanitas looking like sora though is still bs ngl.

[@n16thekid]

I think this all is setting up the game/story for the Twilight Town crew. I believe you called it "Chain of Memories 2." 4 of our characters would have some connection with Skuld. Roxas looks like Ven, Isa and Lea visited her in Radiant Garden, and Xion (based on your speculation) has black hair because of her. What if Namine is able to find some of Ven's old memories of Skuld in Xion or Roxas while searching for Sora? This could cause conflict between the group because Isa would most likely lose focus on finding Sora, and instead become obsessed with what their memories reveal about Skuld. Perhaps this game could lead them to some version of Skuld who mistakes Roxas for Ven.

[@BabyGirlTiny]

I mean, considering g that Isa would only care to look for Sora because of Lea, I dont think him wanting to obsessed over a girl hes been obsessed with for 10+ years is anything detrimental

[@yangustavo2177]

The xion-skuld thing was always in my theories, I won't doubt, if it's true that skuld is subject X, then we can confirm that brain was left behind and he is the one who luxu gave the keyblade, however what's the point of capturing skuld? Maybe cuz someone from the past didnt make to future, since it needs someone to remember, but who? What's the point of make she remember? To bring who back? Maybe darkness?

[@Kirito843]

The facts are so close to proving this.

[@seansnodgrass8235]

Because you said they won’t give Ava black hair just to trip us up, now they are going to give Ava black hair to trip us up

[@girlintheicysky]

Sean Snodgrass Yeah, after the nameless star turned out to not be Strelitzia, I'm not taking anything for granted.

[@GE0RGECREWS]

I dont think ephemer board the ark. I think he falls into the world of darkness which is why he was in the dark tide. Also, we still have to find out what demyx & luxord’s connection to the ancient keyblade is & theres a chance one or both of them board the ark.

[@daisa1506]

Then, how the heck did he found Scala ad Caelum?! (how do you spell that?)

[@GE0RGECREWS]

@@daisa1506 My comment was a year ago.............................

[@daisa1506]

@@GE0RGECREWSoh yee 'ight

[@ElToland]

"You mean "poppet" has a connection with the ancient Keyblade War? As if!."

[@jtp-oi1zi]

you never disappoint man keep it up!

[@silentsky75]

Man imagine a game with Lea and Isa, something called Kingdom Hearts Fated X It would look beautiful in kingdom shader, it would be a good mix with less combat and isas combat and their transitions with their weapons and the relationship with each other along with snooping and discovering certain things while throughout their journey they could be journaling, going on missions in secret for the peak of curiosity and for xehanort. It could even show how lea and isa got their scars. They could have mini games within the confines of radiant garden, doing things for the townsfolk, and possible disney characters like " uncle Scrooge" and possibly depending on how it all aligns, we could see small story segments from other games crossing over while "fated x" Carrie's on with its story. This would honestly be such a badass came I can envision it now. HMK PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE make a video on this, I will be forever grateful if you do my guy! Your.theories would make this 10000000000000x better and who knows maybe square might listen to your video and get inspired! Omg that would be amazing. I feel the game would be really amazing almost like a mix between 3, 358/2 days, BBS and aquas journey. I think it would be absolutely incredible!

[@Moogle96]

Why is Zack Fair in the thumbnail background?

[@HMK]

You got jokes lol

[@caltounite5814]

I KNEW IT! Please confirm SKULD, Noruma!

[@ebonycaraebanks5852]

This game is a mess.... I love it!

[@tigerlight3930]

X2

[@Bell-gv2zv]

Where could skuld be? The only places I can think of is: 1: hidden in Scala ad caelum 2: the Badlands/ keyblade war 3: where the arc is 4: the realm of dreams/sleep Or 5: somewhere like the world that never was

[@Bell-gv2zv]

@Milkyway2099 exactly, and I also feel like he'd take her some place familiar until her reclaims all the new union leaders. So far he has skuld and possibly both elrena and Lauriam. So he's missing three, ven and ephemer. Vens with the crew and ephemer is most likely hiding himself because he knows someone. And brain can possibly be brought back from the past

[@talonoftheblueflame4900]

What if we got a game where isa and lea are the main characters

[@zoeanimations2186]

talonoftheblueflame Nice idea. It can focus on them trying to find Subject X.

[@neilmessersmith446]

@@yungbreezy36 HOW ?

[@roxasbaker]

@@neilmessersmith446 u should know why

[@neilmessersmith446]

@@roxasbaker I really don't I'm sorry why won't it happen

[@blxckjxck47]

roxas baker why

[@Gjallarhornexotic]

Three hearts inside of Sora's ventus, roxas, so I think third heart is ephumer's heart because in the keyblade graveyard he appeared and only Sora saw him and he said need some help so that could explain where ephumer is

[@SA9_]

For a long time when I known about skuld, I thought she a heartless taking a form as a human

[@Dogofwar9]

One thing im confused about is: if the daybreak crew and maleficent was trapped in a data world how were they able to travel to a real world in the future/different world-line.

[@SA9_]

Is no one gonna bring up the fact of how ephemer came out of nowhere i hope there's a video to explain that but for now im going to say he's the 3rd heart inside of sora

[@redx5605]

I FREAKING CALLED IT!

[@DHeart006]

I wonder how demyx (is myde his somebody name?) ties into the past since Xemnas does say Demyx is one that has memories from the union cross time?

[@Strike_Raid]

I wonder what transpired between Union X time were everyone had such small feet, to Kingdom Hearts time where everyone had such big feet.

[@terranortgaming]

I've been saying that since the KH3 came out and why does luxu have a eyepatch on his right eye

[@HMK]

That was speculation that many have thought, but NOW with some translations it looks like it is finally confirmed

[@KiyotakaVAL]

Didn't Terra damage his eye in radiant garden?

[@WindRaider016]

Terra definitely damaged his eye when they fought at Radiant Garden. Shot a dark projectile at him.

[@alialatrach9788]

I don't know why I love this madness and chaos and craziness of the KH franchise, but I do!

[@CarzaEditing]

Same as

[@doliteair]

Even square knew it was to obvious to fans at this point 😂, thx Hmk for the confirmation!

[@SasukeX53]

This was an interesting theory, I personally pretty much figured that Skuld would be the 'subject x' refered in the reports. If she was released when Lea and Isa was still young, then my theory is that Skuld is probably Sora's mother maybe? We never saw her face at all in KH1 and has never been referenced again. With her memories lost it could be possible when Destiny island was lost to the heartless, it could be possible that her memories returned with her and realizes what has happened. Leading her to try to find Sora. We saw Kairi's Grandmother in KH1 and seemed to have alot of knowledge about the light being in the hearts of children. My theory with the grandmother is that she could be Ava as she never went along with Luxu's plans and went her own route, which could mean she didn't follow through with the whole time travel process and not be brought back like the other Fortellers. Hmm alot is going on with this series and I am loving the theories that pops up now and then. We may have to wait and see what will the next installment to the series will provide. :D

[@Zoe-ri1bh]

I LOVE the idea of her being Sora's Mother! I would be happy if this is true. But my brain is doing a thousand loops, like we all do when it comes to theories. I can't help but share what I'm picking up. Lea and Isa would have had to be old enough, and clever enough, to infiltrate the castle on multiple occasions (we do see them getting kicked out once though lmao). If she escaped in Birth By Sleep times while they were teens, Sora was already 4 or 5 years old, and she was only about 15. I could be wrong though. What if she's older than we think, and had time to get off world, meet Sora's Dad, etc? With this game's lore, anything can happen.

[@SasukeX53]

​@@Zoe-ri1bh You do bring up a good point. Though we do not know exactly how long Skuld was 'Subject X' for. She could of been there for several years before Isa and Lea found her and sneaked in to visit her. For all we know she disappeared probably on the day they were kicked out, or before that. I imagine Isa and Lea being young and dumb when they first sneaked inside the castle found her and made some promise to find a way to free her. They trained hard to get their bodies in shape so that way it would be alittle smoother sneaking in and when they did she was gone and had a bunch of questions. But since we do not have that answer at the moment all we can to is theorize and speculate.

[@Zoe-ri1bh]

@@SasukeX53 You bring in some solid points too, and it's fun to theorize. That's why this fan base is amazing

[@SasukeX53]

@@Zoe-ri1bh Yeah! :D Any other points you wanna bring up?

[@Zoe-ri1bh]

@@SasukeX53 I can't think of anything else, can you?

[@creepykiller6078]

Hey i was doing some research in scala yesterday and found an interesting thing out apparently all the clocks in scala stopped at 10:00

[@red_astr0382]

Skuld? LETS GOOOOOO

[@shinyray01]

Never been this early to a video.

[@VidiaReePhoenix]

*Isa:* Moon *Lea:* Sun *Skuld:* Stars

[@Deathnote2539]

Kairi is obviously linked to Skuld in some ways. I can't quite put it in words well but it all happened when Kairi lost her memories and left Radient Garden. I believe Skuld is with her in a way.

[@vegapreferred9344]

What if subject X means subject (X)ion. That’s why Black hair. Etc. Xion could have been made. With skuld in mind.

[@GenAqua]

I even came up with a trio name for the 3 of them...The Celestial Trio, because Lea is represented by The Sun, Isa by The Moon, and Skuld by Stars. I think it fits.

[@javiervelazquezg]

Skuld is actually hidden inside Olette. Being so, Hayner would be Ephemer (handsome guy) and Brain, Pence (computing guy). The trio came from the data world where the Dandelions were and put into Twilight Town in the future.

[@rythimzygamez]

I think it would be cool if Xion had a bigger role. Maybe at one point in Kingdom Hearts 4, Lea will remember Skuld and start a chain reaction.

[@MrWalsh707]

What do you think if there was game where Isa(saïx) & Lea (Axel) continue their search for subject X with Roxas and Xion. That could bring Skuld back into the fold. Maybe they find her early on and then the game is about helping her regain her memories and finding out what happened to Daybreak Town. Maybe we could find the digital Daybreak Town somewhere, and get a 3d version of it we can run around in, and through that and Skuld we can get the current KH team up to speed with the Foretellers and Master of Masters.

[@BabyGirlTiny]

1. Why would Xion and Roxas be there when they have no connection to her 2. Why do we still want them to be looking for this girl they barely knew and Isa has been obsessed with for over 10 years

[@MrWalsh707]

@@BabyGirlTiny Well 1) Roxas & Xion would go with Lea because he asked them and they're friend. 2) We want them to because we know how important it is through meta. This is the reason Lea and Isa joined the organization so of course they would want to still look for her.

[@hassanshaikh5287]

Could the master of masters have used the machine to travel to the future? Hence his "disappearance" from the back cover movie?

[@terranortgaming]

I think that brain is luxord because he said xigbar what are you planning why do you want the box as if he is protecting it then he gives the wild card to luxu

[@Orion_TheyThem]

Except Brain and Luxord look nothing alike??? Also, there's a very probably theory that Brain is Eraqus' ancestor. Their hairstyles are very similar.

[@enricofamoso3116]

What if she was voiced by Erika Harlacher? I just thought of something before I searched on the Internet.

[@DarsanUchiha]

The Xion thing is a real stretch since she got her identity before she even met Axel. The whole point of Xion having black hair was just so that she'd be more distinct from Kairi since they have the same face, but I'd buy it if they said Ven's memories had something to do with it

[@philgaimz9847]

IDK, I've always seen Skuld's hair as dark blue?

[@ZacharyRojasMZ1]

I think Ephemer may have managed to use the ark along with ven, lauriam, elrena, and skuld, but I think something is going to happen to his ark during the trip that ends up placing him in limbo, hence why when we see him in KH3, he appears as a spirit of sorts, or his soul, to Sora to help him. And whatever this limbo state is, it results in Ephemer losing his heart and creates the Dark Inferno secret boss, the red one. That’s my guess anyways

[@sodathejunker]

Fiiiiinnnaaaaallllllyyyyy my girl has some main game relevance. Now that we knows she’s around I’m so hype to see her~

[@vanity1387]

When axel saw Xion's face for the first time he thought of Namine and they have some kind of connection not Skuld.

[@recordreader6091]

Dunno how big this is, but the Secret Reports (or, well, Luxu) specifically state that the "Five" were sent to a different worldline. Unless this report is somehow retconned, I don't buy the theory that Brain stayed behind. Yes, he unmistakably looks like Eraqus and thus he likely was the one who got the No Name Keyblade, but remember: there are six pods, one of them is just broken. I'm leaning more towards what Damo said in that Brain tried to repair this pod with disastrous consequences so all of them could escape and that's why Skuld doesn't retain her memories. And it would fit what Luxu said about passing down his Keyblade to one of the Five right before they were sent to the other worldline. I mean, what? Not even Brain armed with No Name Keyblade can't somehow avert the Break? Maybe. But at this point, it seems more like Daybreak Town was abandoned and that's what really caused the downfall. Maybe it happened earlier than we realize if everyone is stuck in the data Daybreak Town and the real one has remained empty ever since the Keyblade War. As for Scala, maybe that's simply where Brain ended up and rebuilt the world. After all, with six pods, all five Union Leaders and Elrena can escape the doomed reality. Now that's *another* can of worms and I can't think of any reason Elrena would not only agree but be allowed to be sent into the future, but it is Kingdom Hearts: I'm sure we'll get some bullshit excuse for that too.

[@madestmadhatter]

Didn't try to mess with us and say "the identity of subject X, is in fact, none other than... Zack!" Also remember, while not innately Ventus, Roxas is influenced but his heart that resides in Sora, so maybe the black hair also comes from the aspects of Ventus's lost memories that recalled Skulld, as in the last NA cut scene from union cross they do appear to be a little chummy, there by allowing for Skulld's influence prior to Axel's involvement.

[@yash_kapoor]

That Skuld-Xion thing is a bit of a stretch, honestly.

[@HMK]

You do know I make that clear before I go into it right? LOL

[@yash_kapoor]

@@HMK Oh I'm aware. I was agreeing with you. Sorry if it came off as anyting different :D

[@K_logart]

I would agree with you, if it weren't for the fact that it's Kingdom Hearts

[@gristen]

honestly it might not be. like subject x was being experimented on for memory stuff right? and xion was basically made to hold memories. it made me start thinking what if the results of the experiments done on subject x were used as the foundation in the process of making xion?

[@laith9989]

I could see them saying that Xion’s model had influence from the data they collected on “the girl”. That’s the only way i can see it making sense

[@Rakuyuki]

Only thing that doesn't add up is when Xion gets the hair, doesn't it happen before meeting Axel after he comes back from Castle Oblivion? Because everyone saw her as a member whose face was already covered. Not gonna rule out that possibility, it's just the timing doesn't properly connect

[@zekejaeger4848]

Sorry to disappoint the Xion theory, but if you read Roxas's diary in 358/2 days and read the "special diary" version you can read Axel writing that she first saw Xion as completely identical to Namine

[@mastertucker]

Brain had to stay behind. I mean there's the stuff you stated so far, Eraqus is a 'blueblood' from a line of masters. Brain looks like Eraqus and they chose to make that fact a sort of big reveal as he hid his face until that point. More than that though, we know for a fact one of the union leaders were bequeathed the no name and passed it down where Eraqus and Xehanort's master had it hanging up on the wall to assumedly eventually pass it to Xehanort. So whoever stayed behind to start this line of Keyblade weilders had to have No Name or else it wouldn't be there, and we know for a fact it was one of the new Union leaders that it was passed to. With Brain's big reveal being that he looks like Eraqus, and Ventus, Lauriam, and now Skuld pretty much proven to not have stayed behind, we either have Ephemer or Brain and I mean the choice is obvious. As for Ephemer though, I sort of imagined he was just dead and a spirit calling the other dead Keyblade wielders in the Graveyard to help Sora. I don't think he made it to the future in some weird different way from the rest. I think he may have stayed behind too.

[@wonderingobserver2231]

If you think of axel and saix age maybe skulld is sora’s mom! No joke it could explain where she’s been and Ava could be kairis grandma

[@RCDeschene]

I had always figured that Xion's hair coloring was because of Ventus' connection to Vanitas through Roxas. Where Roxas takes directly after Ven's appearance, some of Vanitas' cosmetic attributes subconsciously translated onto Xion.

[@crashboredom2]

If this is true, i want to know why "a man with an eyepatch(luxu)" would come to take her away. Why would luxu care about her? Ava could also have black hair....havent seen her without the mask. And luxu would have reason to get her out of that cell. Also, luxu seems suprised when ava doesnt show up. "Huh....guess ava didnt make it after all", sounds like he expected her to be there. As if he saw her and knew she was around, but still didnt show up. He doesnt even question her absence. What if skuld IS AVA!!!

[@crashboredom2]

To back this up. I cant fond a single scene of ava and skuld together. Talking or in the same room/scene together. Every other character has a scene where theyre talking to ava. If there is a scene with the 2 od them, please share!!!

[@SeanS96]

i support this theory way more! "One day, a man came to take me from the prison. I could not see him for the darkness, save that he wore an eyepatch" who is xigbar aka luxu. Tetsuya leaves many big hints for things that will eventually be revealed to us as always. No doubt these apparent hints show that its Ava..now whether ava is playing as skuld thats yet to be revealed. Knowing what color hair ava has under her mask would be a dead giveaway

[@crashboredom2]

@@SeanS96 the only piece of evidence i have against this theory of "ava being skuld", is that when ava attacked luxu and rang the bell to start the war, skuld was in town talking to Gula about the lost page. So unless the timing of events is off, or ava sent someone else disguised as herself to talk to luxu, this proves it impossible....HOWEVER, luxus secret report mentions "an imposter withing the 5", doesnt explain if he means the 5 union leader or 5 foretellers. It could very well mean the person who attacked luxu and rang the bell wasnt ava. But an imposter, and luxu let himself be found so he could kill the Ava imposter who was "a virus in the program the master so carefully wrote".

[@BrennySpain]

Oh man! That xion data org battle music from kh3 remind limit cut. That music is so epic!!! That fight was definitely one for the ages, truly intense, and she truly didn’t pull any punches either!

[@mulduls]

Remember, Ava’s hair color is never revealed, and she could have lost her mask and Foreteller robes if she jumped through time. Also, why would Luxu just save any old Dandelion? I can only imagine him doing that for one of his lifelong companions. Ava fits that bill.

[@roxas1382]

I just remembered that in kh2 finale mix when you go to the pod room there is a pod that says it has already been used but it’s not the one that Sora, Donald, or Goofy were in so maybe Skuld was in there at some point.

[@ZayKH]

Man starting of the video with this song is absolute GOAT made me really hype

[@Gjallarhornexotic]

Subject x could be ava if she has black hair or casted off her original form like luxu did because she wasn't in the keyblade graveyard at the end of kingdom hearts 3 when luxu reclaim his keyblade and called the other foretellers and it could be skulld because in Kingdom hearts 3 it did show ephimer so he could have been a hint towards skulld or something this is just a guess

[@sojannedos]

Dude, I think Brain is MoM.

[@scowlingmoongod]

My theory about Ava is that she's Kairi's grandmother

[@HyperShadow810]

If Skuld IS Subject X then holy shit this is an outstanding discovery that needs more detail

[@heronevans1585]

I do like the idea of brain staying in the past because for the ark to work you need someone in the future to remember you. So brain staying he could pass on there memories to his children and they keep passing it on so when the time comes for them to travel to the future it will work

[@TussalDragon344]

So lemme get this straight, Ventus knows Skuld, and became friends with Lea/ Axel, who’s been seeking Skuld for ages and is friends with Roxas, who Ventus is his blueprints... neat All Lea/ Axel has to do is ask Ventus about Skuld’s whereabouts/ for his help

[@JadenX1]

MaaanThis IS CRAZY STUFF HMK! My thoughts on this Revelation is pure bananas and this would also mean that everything is about to fit into place how the timeline goes. I'm sharing this

[@naveriie]

My gut has always told me it is Skuld. No one can convince me otherwise. I WANT THAT TRIO!

[@ZoRowArk3]

What if Xion´s Black Hair doesn´t come from Axel´s strongest memories but from Ventus´ Memories of Skuld, since Ventus´ heart is already in Sora´s at that point. Or does that not work?

[@NotAGrabbaghoul]

That Xion point is fucking brilliant

[@WayToDawn72]

I honestly did hope it was Master Ava but I think I could accept Skuld. Esp w a couple of these implications

[@lyriesen2980]

I think maybe Roxas sees Xion with Skuld's black hair because of Ventus's sleeping heart inside of him, just a thought! Buy I agree about Axel

[@leemyyyy]

Imagine your character in KHUx is soars dad

[@namerif731]

Heres a fun thought i had What if we do get Skuld revealed in KH4 but we also get the reveal of a long forgotten character Sora's mother. What if Skuld is Sora's mother not saying whatsoever its true but its a hilarious thought if we finally get to see Sora's mom and she turns out to be Skuld As for the argument of it being impossible due to timing i mean it has been stated that each world has their own passage of time.

[@skymaiden16]

This can work.. I mean.. It's KH.. Ava could have black hair.. Xion can be related to both Kairi and Skuld.. i just can't wait for the next Union X story.. I think i am more concerned about the Dandelions' fate more than Sora's tbh.. XD

[@Curtislp18]

Skuld could be where sora is at or somewhere right in front of our faces like like a KH to do

[@igl1997]

I know know if it's just me... but I can kinda see Brain looking similar to Zexion/Ienzo.... but it's very iffy if anything...

[@Orion_TheyThem]

They don't look similar at all. When Brain takes his hat off.....you see he looks more like Eraqus. Which fits in with him being Eraqus' ancestor (because it's been confirmed that Eraqus descended from an ancient Keyblade wielder who was alive during the Keyblade War).

[@veeegy2745]

Couldn't technically Roxas perceive Xions hair as black also because of Skuld, but through a different connection? Is it perhaps possible that Ventus' memories of Skuld from the time of KHUx influenced this? Eh, probably too much of a stretch. I don't think the bond between Skuld and Ventus is tight enough for that to be a possibility... At least not yet. But I think the idea is worth a comment.

[@leonmasters8059]

Xions death hit harder than aeriths

[@MegaManDBZX]

Well, somebody better pick up that phone. Because I f***ing called it!

[@Voulton_S.]

I wonder if Skuld was displaced by Maleficent's invasion to Twilight Town where she made, or at least design, the old Mansion and/or lived there. She might of made the basement lab to developed the memory pods in order to regain her own. Just an idea, just because we know Xigbar let her out during the final year of Ansem the Wise's reign before KH I. That gives about 8 years of time for the mansion to be built, used as a laboratory, and then eventually destroyed. And I wonder if Twilight Town was where Marluxia and Elrena were recruited into Org. XIII, because there was three memory pods that were discovered beside Sora and her gang's. Hmm...

[@gracekim25]

Guys Skuld can’t be Kairi’s grandmother because she was in that castle around The Time Of BBS

[@Iamkaiivibes]

I always thought the foretellers were in their mid 20-30s

[@mycolljuniordaxsalgadochav7522]

i started reading again the secret reports and i truly believe Subject X is Skuld due to the following reasons: 1.we know that 3 of the Dandelions leaders are in the present time or at least somewhat alive or showing and those would be Lauriam, Ventus and up to certain point Ephemer. 2. secret report number 1 is a POV of subject x and reads the following: I had no answer to offer them. Four friends, and a key...that is the sum total of my memory. I could not even recall my name. I was simply called "X" there. My only solace was the time I spent talking with the two boys the four friends subject X mentions must be the Dandelions. they must have been able to scape the virus-infected worldline using the Lifeboat and travelled to the future. that is why Ventus doesnt remember his past. just like Subject X.

[@mycolljuniordaxsalgadochav7522]

sorry guy HMK. i commented before watching your video completly

[@a_nervous_wreck]

FINALLY someone said it. I've had that theory at the end of this video for the last year; feels kinda cool to see HMK has the same theory I do :D

[@corinnebowyer6786]

wish xeanort, ansem the wise, axel/lea, isa/saiax, elrena/larxene, marluxia/lauriam, yozora, ventus, stretzelia, & ephemer possible with ienzo & even could have a chance to visit the final world & talk to the nameless star in order to see their reactions. if the nameless star is subject x & subject x is skuld then it would explain how isa/siax, axel/lea, ansem the wise, xemnas, ansem the seeker of darkness, & xeanort were unable to find her after she went missing.

[@ItsDaKoolaidDude]

Back to back apocalyptic scenarios: The 1st Keyblade War, The Break, Ansem: Seeker of Darkness and his quick little trite with Maleficent, Xehanort and his 2nd Keyblade War. Jesus christ its almost leaning towards WH:40K with all the events happening.

[@GE0RGECREWS]

I wonder if luariam/marluxia joining O13 had something to do with subject X. Maybe he went searching for the dandelions & its still not said why he turned on xemnas in CoM. My bad but I still have so many questions about the O13 members that KH3 didnt answer...

[@simpleandcleanedits3846]

I cant wait till the reveal of all things in the kingdom hearts multiverse

[@jamesdigennaro6705]

You always seem to blow my mind with every theory you have.

[@Orto-jj2di]

Skuld as Project X and Eraqus is Brain's grandchild?! Wow good news My theory : I think Lxu took her and holds her somewhere

[@randomanimefan0154]

Perhaps in "The Black Box" XDDDDDDD just kidding though.

[@gracekim25]

Otari Muradishvili not grand child . Very DISTANT decendant. UX is 10 years from the present it’s like a thousand

[@CrunchyMadoka]

Here comes the hype train!! BRING THE HYPE HMK!!

[@couver73]

I've been kinda under the impression (even moreso now, thanks) that Skuld *is* Xion, or at least what's left of her might be. It's a stretch but it's what comes to mind. If I'm wrong, I tried.