声压太强穿透灵魂！茜拉尚雯婕翻唱那英金曲《默》强强联手太好听了！

[@azeedahhasleezan1678]

If you watched the detail SMG video performances during singing with legend 6, there is clearly a music director for each song performance. And this music director will direct the singers on how the song should be sung. Clearly Shila & SWJ are performing based on what they were asked to. So why are some of you complaining the note is too high or too low. Just enjoy the music for God sake.

[@SongWithLyrics94]

真好聽，重複聽了好多次了呢，但是就算聽到多少次還是和第一次聼的那種感覺，就是好聽👌，誰在聽？🙋‍🙋

[@twenty3florist493]

Me from Malaysia..apa khabar semua?

[@jx9936]

Shila 贵为国宝歌后，倾情演绎扣人心弦，让人百听不腻余音绕梁啊！

[@BabyBun-rw6ll]

Even there are lot of ppl who did not like shila deliver this song....but for me, who cares....its not competition, so she can do whatever she like to perform her final stage and have fun....and they also only have 2 days practice together....what shila do is her own style...but at the end of the day "U LIKE IT OR NOT LIKE" is up to you....we cant please anyone

[@shaneshensanlim1603]

Don't be so arrogant

[@BabyBun-rw6ll]

@@shaneshensanlim1603 don't be dumb

[@BabyBun-rw6ll]

@@shaneshensanlim1603 don't be so dumb

[@BabyBun-rw6ll]

@@shaneshensanlim1603 don't be so du*b

[@clipload1396]

don't be a turd

[@wanmuizzmahmood]

This is so good. No bias. Is it just me? I feel everything in this performance. I like how they changed the sound of second verse to more upbeat. Shila’s harmonizing is the best thing ever and Shang’s low notes are insane she has mysterious legend vibes with her impression, her style and her hairstyle. Also goosebumps at 4:00

[@aiman7944]

The best Sheila performance in this program. (My personal favorite)

[@mariachristodoulou3200]

Sheila is such an amazing singer!!!!!!The next Celine Dion!!!!!!She deserves an award and recognition from around the world 🌍🌍🌍🌍🌍🌍🌍🌍 She's one of the best!!!What a magnificent voice!!!!!

[@mskukukill]

Bestnya lagu ni. Suka intro yg nampak suspend, bila Shila masuk terus jadi lain & note yg berbeza. Then masuk verse rock tu mmg on point sgt. Suara swj tu mmg power bersahaja je. Shila x overreact sebaliknya showmanship dia power menghayati lagu dgn baik. Sukaaa sgttttt❤❤❤

[@blackphoenix_02]

Based on the original title, lyrics, singing style and music video I get why some people might say they overdid the performance. But based on vocals, harmony and arrangement I think they did really great! I love Shang Shang‘s low singing voice and I always think she sounds a bit similar to Na Ying, Shila on the other hand has a very powerful and western-like singing style, which makes the performance more interesting and refreshing. Together they created something really magnificent and personally I think it‘s a little masterpiece 😊❤

[@mashedpotato3291]

ah my favorite duo. the combination of classical singing technique with the more modern technique

[@zackboyz1982]

Both got great & strong vocal , the harmony between them is in the high level, congrats

[@4KMusicHHLyrics]

明天要去簽離婚了，7年的婚姻，曾經以為一家三口會是一輩子，但努力了好久但最後卻還是失敗，說完全不愛是騙人的，但也知道再下去彼此眼裡只會充滿失望，很痛苦卻也不想要再惡性循環，他按著門鈴這一次我卻遲遲不敢再開門，因為就像歌曲說的我很怕我又不爭氣的想回到那個循環。 真的好心痛，心痛到聽著音樂一直流淚，為什麼曾經相愛的人卻用著不對的方式，一次一次傷害彼此，聽著歌想著的都是曾經的回憶，但明天一切也都結束了。 謝謝給我一首能，讓我好好痛哭的一首歌，紀念這一段7年的婚姻，也謝謝這邊的陌生人們聽我抒發

[@luna9651]

要学会向内求，当你对对方没有期待和要求，你就会的到解脱，也会让对方的到解脱。

[@zulaikhalau4926]

When 1 door closes, many more doors will open for you... Be strong, move on, may yr faith carries you on yr next journey in life!

[@wengleong2681]

这将是一段过去。未来另一个人生阶段，一定会是更好的自己。

[@徐子錚]

明天太陽依然會升起，當妳抬頭仰望星空一切都釋懷了。

[@yoyo571638]

加油

[@fhaizulbukhori]

Oh my goodness Shila you sound so beautiful ❤

[@wanrosli-x9w]

modern and traditional make this song more luxury.i dont understand the lyrics, but i really can feel the emotion from them.i really love it.

[@WENfavourite]

尚雯婕醇厚的聲音，尤其中低音真的很好聽

[@wingye6319]

我也很喜欢她独特的声线。

[@jamietkh5862]

FGS! Dont blame the singers nor make comparisons who's better at it or over singing it. Hello, its those musicians the composer (s) the music director of the show who rearranged the traditional song with modern contemporary twists, textures and flavours. Both singers were delivering, belting out the song according to the parts of the song score sheets🎵🎶🎵🎶 composition, the rearrangements given to them by the music director of the programme. This song is outside Shila's comfort zone, the high notes but really, she has the "ballsy" to take it on. For Shang, it's in her elemental comfort genre zone delivered effortlessly. Overall, like it or not, both delivered it fantastically well, sit back and just enjoy. It's entertaing albeit experimentally and experiencially quite challenging. Kudos!👏👏👏💐💐

[@izzalrahizam8865]

couldnt agree more!

[@zenkaishah]

Agreed.

[@galaxystarsflower2604]

Xila❤SWJ so amaxing❤❤

[@t.f.rechie]

两偶像同台超棒😎🤟🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@Black-Cat9]

let's rock yeah!

[@elhijazi42]

Power vocalists..💖💖 Another mesmerizing performance..🥰🥰

[@hafizh7922]

Shila ❤🎉

[@aideshengyin]

那旋律真是美得让人沉醉，无法自拔。💟🎶💝

[@AnitaMohadi-ie8kl]

Love shila forever❤❤❤

[@Softerhaze]

Shan wenjie is really a powerhouse

[@zenkaishah]

Idk about the original version techniq of thing song... But imo, i really like this duet performance. Felt so refreshing. ❤

[@WONGSHIAUYEN]

两位大唱将的合作，棒！

[@Mawicullens]

swj power sangat. nyanyi muka relax tapi suara sampai langit ke 7

[@desmondkhoo9656]

Dia nyanyi Move your body By Sia pun sedap juga dari Ride the Wind 2024.

[@Kkkllll-k1z]

Shila❤❤❤❤❤好听❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@bonda4170]

Excellent both of you👍👍👍👍

[@tambihabibi4298]

Two different styles of singing encapsulated the essence of this song. It’s apt. I can feel the pain and loss of an incompatible couple.

[@chownoonbee6809]

Super super good ,strong power ❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@mrasza1991]

Love this performance

[@annetteang3608]

Shila 👍👍👍👍👍

[@Gorilla1949]

A very good harmony voices.. one has a bright voice and the other has a middle voice

[@青春旋律_8]

這也太好聽了吧愛了愛了 願看到這條評論的人身材變瘦，痘痘會慢慢消下去，皮膚會變白，吃多不長肥肉，你/妳喜歡的人會向你/妳表白，身邊在乎的人健康平安，而你/妳會人想事成，還會暴富變美

[@Deezayhh]

太好听了，祝看到这条评论的每个人，健康平安，天天快樂，事事顺利，聰明有愛心，容貌英俊或美丽，有仁慈和笑容，有好听的聲音，祝福每個人愛情永固，永結同心，百年好合，多福多壽，生出孝子賢孫，定成聖賢.❤

[@shawnxie9472]

很高兴看到这样还追求声乐技巧的舞台表演。

[@wisernk8459]

Good singers, good performance n good improvisation

[@latifahithnin5846]

Go shila ❤❤yr voice..salute...

[@192shami]

Please listen to this part 2:04 Shila shila why so amazing

[@joycefun7243]

茜拉音色唱功超一流。尚文婕比以前有进步

[@hotcoklat79]

上次唱那个柠檬草的味道很不错， 这首只能说我个人不大习惯而已

[@tonyshihoutang6576]

Wow very powerful vocal ... 😊

[@4KLyrics2002]

如果你滑到這則留言，祝福你未來做任何選擇都不迷惘，天天都有好事發生，你和所愛的人事物都平安。

[@beautiful__princess]

Love shila🎉❤

[@wooliantong175]

A wonderful pairing ❤ in singing..,

[@nurwaltco2122]

this is first time i heard the song because it not from my culture. from what i listen and watch now. the performance is amazing and energetic. poetic lyric is perform with both singer own style and voices.refreshing and crispy... the song name silence but the silence is the arrangement of silent from the legends who make its own way from the hard way will leave trace all over the way

[@DenizIman]

Its just a matter of two different singing styles and there's nothing wrong with it. But which one blended much better with the mood of the song? I think it's the Chinese girl.

[@giseleblanchette6221]

Quelle merveilles!

[@Share4orang]

Both amazing!!! Shila amzah you can memorise that lyrics within 1 day???? You are amazing

[@dayangsenandung544]

Amazing voice ❤

[@Black-Cat9]

如果您不喜歡具有現代搖滾和傳統節奏元素的歌曲，那麼這不適合您

[@sharonchua2917]

应该挑战尚雯婕的成名作最终信仰，那首经典给她们尽情飙😂

[@misesnuha]

Sheila has a trademark.. bring always her style and also Malaysian style.... Always professional and a lil bit mistake at her pitching or overdose pitching for live performance is normal.. not too obvious.. its ok for me.. as long as my ears not damage😂

[@楊孟勳-s1g]

好聽! 星馬女王:茜菈!

[@Sseraromli]

If anyone can explain what the lyrics is all about? Half of the comments said that this performance is a bit over~ as for my ears and not understand any word of the song~ i like it

[@blackphoenix_02]

I don‘t understand Mandarin either, but I stumbled across the song two or three years ago and remembered it‘s a song by Na Ying called „Silent“. The music video also features a person doing sign language and Na Yings singing style is very calm and almost cautious. Maybe the lyrics also add to that calm and cautious atmosphere. So I get why some might say it‘s overdone and doesn‘t fit the song. But after all, it‘s their own interpretation of the song and I think they did great! I really love this performance! 😊❤

[@Sseraromli]

@@blackphoenix_02 thank you for your kind explanation😊~and now it does make sense why some said its overdone~ will check it out the original version

[@Black-Cat9]

if you don't like songs that have elements of rock modern and traditional rhythm, this is not for you

[@hacc_ley9839]

❤❤❤

[@Fouziah-z6g]

SHILA AMZAH💚💙💖

[@aidilfitri7929]

🤩🤩🤩👍👍👍👏👏👏

[@weipingtan1153]

我觉得还不错耶，后半段和原本表达的方式很不同

[@mahibebo7534]

It was like Canary 🕊️ bird vs. Tiger 🐯

[@Black-Cat9]

let's rock yeah! 🎵🎵🎶🎶🎸🎸🤘🤘

[@ezzraduali7579]

❤❤❤😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥

[@TeriTracyFifie90]

MALAYSIA 🇲🇾

[@nashalibraley8546]

what episode was this one i cant find it!!!???

[@evonnetiner6405]

不知道shila唱左手指月，效果会是怎样的

[@loganchoong6505]

❤

[@sebastianlam99]

好像鬼片 我一直莫名的被高音嚇到

[@zainormamzainalabidin9975]

Boths so good. Amazing voice. Congratulations 👏

[@chen-zhuqi4594]

歌曲內容和表現形式需要互相搭配，相輔相成。如果只是欣賞音樂，那還要歌詞幹什麼？你總不能欣賞她們高水平的演唱，并假裝沒有聽到歌詞吧？其實正是因為她們的演唱毫無瑕疵，才更容易讓人意識到表達方式與內容（歌詞的意境）上的違和。

[@蘿蔔高-s2s]

尚的音色跟柯以敏好像耶😮

[@fung5768]

翻車😂

[@m.mcreativitylife9039]

Ini pertandingan…. Bukan show biasa…. Mesti buat yg lebih advance…

[@kenkyolau6142]

中文歌很多時候唱的意境，尤其是“默”這首，並不適合太多的歐美轉音唱法，美感和意境就不在了，這是不諳中文聽眾所不能起共鳴的，實屬可惜。

[@Black-Cat9]

if you don't like songs that have elements of rock modern and traditional rhythm, this is not for you..bye,bye

[@wjfrv270]

♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍👍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

[@dragon.slayer..]

前半部编曲不行，乱

[@Black-Cat9]

if you don't like songs that have elements of rock modern and traditional rhythm, this is not for you

[@bounlathchantamart1873]

这个伴奏太难听了🥲🥲

[@stanfagreerd1500]

后半段唱得没问题，但是改得太难听了，硬是变成了一首互飙高音的炫技歌

[@chen-zhuqi4594]

看來，用西方歌手的表達方式難以呈現這首名為“默”的中文歌曲的意境，過於高亢讓人感到違和，過猶不及。不妨將這個表演視為一次嘗試。

[@Black-Cat9]

let's rock yeah! 🎵🎵🎶🎶🎸🎸🤘🤘

[@chen-zhuqi4594]

​@@Black-Cat9歌曲內容和表現形式需要互相搭配，相輔相成。如果只是欣賞音樂，那還要歌詞幹什麼？你總不能欣賞她們高水平的演唱，并假裝沒有聽到歌詞吧？其實正是因為她們的演唱毫無瑕疵，才更容易讓人意識到表達方式與內容上的違和。

[@huitan7041]

尚雯婕如果换个发型师会变的更美

[@wanmuizzmahmood]

Nah her hairstyle is legendary. She looks mysterious. Suits her very well

[@desmondkhoo9656]

翻车了！这首歌不适合欧美唱法而且颤音太多了 最好听的是张惠妹 男版是张杰

[@Black-Cat9]

if you don't like songs that have elements of rock modern and traditional rhythm, this is not for you

[@yukilee2109]

不管是合适还是不合适都好 但这首改的太过了 这首歌的原版是很温和 听了很舒服的 但是她两加了那么多高音的部分和用的斜音太多导致整首歌都不大好听 虽然我也是喜欢茜拉 但是还是要分一下音乐跟喜欢的歌手 总不能因为我喜欢这位歌手而什么都觉得很好吧？我写的这些只是我的个人看法意见而已​@@Black-Cat9

[@zainormamzainalabidin9975]

Excellent voice. Congratulations both2 of you. 🎉

[@terrymusic0108]

又一次失敗的改編 兩人還是分開獨唱好了

[@waynengzh]

你又知道失敗？這麼厲害那要怎樣才算不失敗呢？編曲家

[@linamahmud6136]

Which side is a failure, i winder

[@desmondkhoo9656]

真的！这是歌的情意无法投入，太多技巧了。

[@Black-Cat9]

let's rock yeah! 🎵🎵🎶🎶🎸🎸🤘🤘

[@shaoyu9875]

茜拉尚　臉上的填充物是不是越來越了？

[@admondxie8064]

她是发胖，生完小孩，瘦不下去

[@林燊秋]

劃蛇添足的感覺😅

[@Black-Cat9]

let's rock yeah!🎶🎶🎵🎵🎸🎸🤘🤘

[@chongtzehaw6014]

Shila oversing and Shang's opera-ish vocal didnt fit the song

[@caseyng2418]

Shila 从来没有失败过，但遗憾的是，这一次，她在这首歌中用力过度了。 听起来如此技术性和没有灵魂。相比之下，她的对手，这首歌更适合她。其实这首歌不需要太多的高音和技巧，你需要的只是将你的思想和灵魂沉浸在歌词中。

[@justinyang5609]

确实，感觉确实感情…但相比别的歌在这个晚会上，可以说是很稳很好了，至少能听😂

[@waynengzh]

聽完歌就說喜不喜歡就好，別評論到好像自己很厲害那樣，但卻沒人找你當評審

[@kenkyolau6142]

@@waynengzh 我倒是覺得樓主的評論很中肯。再說，不一定要是專業點評人士才能對歌曲表達意見，歌迷如你我皆可，這不就音樂的魅力&熱度嗎？ 每個人的感受不同，表達出自己看法，用理來說服，總比一句“難聽/不喜歡”來否定所有，而你也可以用你的論點來反駁回她，大家理性交流，文明的辯論本該如此。 *btw樂見樓主這樣的意見表達，我也不是什麼小號，還是樓主的朋友，就是今天路過的路人

[@Kcl-u3b]

我跟你的看法不同，谁说《默》一定要根据刻板印象来唱？我反而觉得茜拉跳出框框，表达到位，后段带出了“失去你”的歇斯底里和无法接受失去的精神崩溃。

[@Black-Cat9]

let's rock yeah! 🎵🎵🎶🎶🎸🎸🤘🤘

[@allenli123]

聲音和影片沒有同步

[@mohamadaymanbinmustafa1135]

Don't ever show me your new scary video again!😡

[@mohamadaymanbinmustafa1135]

Why did you do that to my good and friendly Shilalas with her long hair with your firearm weapon?!

[@mohamadaymanbinmustafa1135]

Do not ever shot my good and friendly Shilalas with her long hair again with your firearm weapons!

[@Zducky1998]

太用力了，技术含量搞砸了整首歌的和谐度，真心真的觉得不好听

[@Black-Cat9]

let's rock yeah! 🎵🎵🎶🎶🎸🎸🤘🤘

[@YilingLiew]

有本事你唱啊😀

[@Zducky1998]

@@YilingLiew 别说这些有的没的，大家都有自己对音乐的标准

[@KhemoTan]

浪费了。 用力过度

[@river5613]

你连说话的力气都没， 没浪费。

[@jamesting6286]

强强联手太难听了！

[@nickhun42]

Yr life seems bitter as yr FACE bruh🥲

[@mohamadaymanbinmustafa1135]

Now, look what have you done!👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎

[@msdanny0071]

真係夾咩？點解我覺得難聽！

[@mohamadaymanbinmustafa1135]

Why are you doing this?!😡👎😠😡

[@caseyng2418]

Shila overdoing this song.. sorry to say that. Most of the time, she never failed to deliver but this time her rival surpassed her.

[@MrSien-kk7fe]

Not really. Technically it was so good. My opinion as a musician

[@caseyng2418]

@@MrSien-kk7fe her technical skill was good, but lack of truest emotion.

[@waynengzh]

@@caseyng2418can u show us how to do truest emotion? don't just command, have to tell, show, try, do

[@nickhun42]

@@waynengzhIKR😂 funny

[@kenkyolau6142]

Agreed as a Chinese. Song's lyric and the way to express shouldn't be this much. As you can see majority mandarin comment here. Sorry guys, as Mandarin culture, lot of skills doesn't mean good & power. Sometimes simple is the best and the hardest to bring out to touch the audience. As this song title is 默(silence)

[@blueeyes5410]

两个都唱得有够难听😂

[@isabelletaing4893]

J'ai moins

[@horacechiu]

難聽 編曲弄巧反拙 兩個聲音互搶 各自炫技 吵！ 那些顫音幅度有夠誇張 特色吧 不欣賞 既然都修音了 為啥不修得自然點?

[@mohamadaymanbinmustafa1135]

Say it 😡! Say it 😡! SAY IT!😡

[@tky0414]

太多颤音了～听了很奇怪～这不是欧美歌，这首歌不是这样唱的。破坏这首歌了

[@nickhun42]

Then why listen?😭

[@Black-Cat9]

if you don't like songs that have elements of rock modern and traditional rhythm, this is not for you

[@kimkardashi-un2004]

Is not about the song..is about their talents