Chicken Embryo Development Time-lapse

🐣🐓🐤 PLEASE OPEN ME AND READ DESCRIPTION!!! 🐔🥚🐥
This is a science experiment made for educational purposes!
Time lapse of day 3 through day 19 (death). 1 picture taken per minute from day 3 to day 19 of development using GoPro camera.
Day by day development video compliation:
• Day by Day Chicken Emb...
Research/Journals Used:
free-journal.um...
www.ableweb.org...

[@Frithgar]

Several people have pointed out the space around the developing embryo, but I would also add that in a natural environment (inside the egg) they are constantly being moved around, the bird doesn't leave them in one position, but rather moves them on a regular basis. I'm curious if the embryos not being moved around contributed to the infections and also to the death of the last one.

[@Frithgar]

Artificial incubators for eggs move them constantly as well, they also keep the atmosphere humid. Perhaps if the eggs were placed in a clear sphere of some kind? The difficulty would be ensuring the oxygen supply. I'm subscribing to you and look forward to seeing the next attempt!

[@aleksandars9254]

Agreed, thats why egg incubators have rolls to move the eggs around for proper embryo development.

[@dovemaiden333]

If you bought a even a Hovabator that had forced air and an automatic turne, you could use buy the goose-egg size egg-rollers and place the covered cups in those, I believe. I don't know how much your school has available for budget, though. They ran about 150.00 (US) last year; that's the Georgia Quail old-style styrofoam ones. I have not had very good success with FarmTech myself, another company. A "Happy Farm" hygrometer for water runs 14.95 with free shipping on ebay and is essential for your humidirty. They run on a single round battery. I'd recommend borrowing a Georgia Quail cabinet style if you can't afford one ---they are about 600 and up, but occasionally someone might lend one out for a project like this and you could place the cups easily in the larger turning trays. In regard to the question of whether or not the turning/lack of adequate turning contributed to embryo death, you are working with 'way too small a number to get an accurate statistical result to base it on. You'd need to be working with large numbers of these eggs to get a meaningful answer on that. People who buy eggs from ebay and are successful hatching them often move them very little, if at all---they'll leave them for days in the upright position, turning off the auto-turning mechanism in an attempt to get the embryo to implant on the inner membrane which has usually been compromised during shipping. Some of them manage to pull off up to around a 30% hatch if the eggs aren't too badly damaged and haven't had to travel too far. However, you'll see this weird "horse-shoe or saddle-shape" when you candle the eggs---the embryos implant, but in an abnormal way and some of these hatch, some don't. I don't know if lack of turning or the embryo's implantation is the problem. It would be good to find out.

[@jaysay9099]

Next time try tilting the container side to side at least 3x daily. In nature the egg is flipped on a recorded tally of 20x or more a day by the mom. Just left there like the video the chick does not get enough exercise to grow strong and was probably uncomfortable laying in same position for 19 days probably a contribution to its death. Awesome video though looking forward for a successful hatch next time.

[@AkinaWaters]

When I was in grade 2, we did the eggs in an incubator thing. I know we had to turn the eggs over. Not sure how often it was done, but I remember we all took turns doing it. Though I just watched a video before this one where they grew chicks in cups like this, and they survived.

[@william2154]

Thank you little chickie. Your time on this planet was so short, but we have been able to learn so much from your sacrifice 🙇‍♂️

[@eetuthereindeer6671]

It doesn't feel right to see any animal like that. If theres any smaller chance to birth than a real womb i dont want it

[@truelyseen7050]

Will Tang you mean from being sacrificed right I want you thanking the one

[@kristingallo2158]

Not really, we've known for a very long time how birds develop in eggs. This has zero to teach. Ffs with tiny cameras we can watch human babies develope inside the mom. This is a waste.

[@mikel143]

That's a murder not a sacrifice 😳🤫

[@Nobody-qk5fc]

Ur scaring me...

[@TheDailyEgg]

Do not let this distract you from the fact that I post a video of am egg every single day

[@elishauy1844]

The Daily Egg your the best

[@unkn0wn3ntity86]

And do not let this distract you from the fact that the Roman Empire MUST BE REFORMED

[@GabbaGandalf-fo7cg]

@@unkn0wn3ntity86 ofc, Germany is bored ;)

[@valtaep1ece796]

🍳🍳🍳🍳🥚🥚🥚🥚🥚

[@migueliguel3539]

WTFF😅😂😂

[@fyrhead1978]

I GOT A KFC AD BEFORE THIS WTF

[@cleo8543]

Yummy

[@thetwogordo1065]

Punch Daily FINGER LICKING GOOD

[@d.resarr]

LMAO

[@LeRacoon]

I'm Hungry

[@xXLoLBasketXxIS_SO_AWESOME_LOL]

Rylan Chudleigh because.... we can? Plants are living things too🌝

[@jovanechapula8105]

Just a thought.... How abot making a clear egg shell that way it can be rotated like the hen does. I would love to see that

[@jovanechapula8105]

I would suggest looking in the chocolate molds ..

[@jovanechapula8105]

www.amazon.com/dp/B01NAP8DAX/ref=asc_df_B01NAP8DAX5438336/?tag=hyprod-20&creative=395033&creativeASIN=B01NAP8DAX&linkCode=df0&hvadid=191977601220&hvpos=1o2&hvnetw=g&hvrand=3505174561041560542&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=m&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9033662&hvtargid=pla-303144469588

[@whickur]

This is an amazing idea.

[@GreenSensation]

jovane chapula You just read my mind cause I was just thinking of that 😂😂

[@brayancamargo2048]

Penguin eggs are transparent

[@montageoomph9736]

Bro the last one was so close to living.

[@LivingBreadHomestead]

As soon as I saw the blood vessel pop... I knew it was over for the embryo. Maybe too much space for movement as well as loss of moisture. A few days before the hatch date, an increase in humidity is key to a successful hatch.

[@Mittzie]

Yup humidity needs increased to at least 60% I'd wager over 75% for this hatch method since you don't have to worry about drowning in the air-cell of a shell.

[@leibaladad1916]

oh god. whilst watching the process, I felt so attached to them, I was upset when the second one died. but i had hope for the last one... rooting for it, trying to talk to my mind like nemo's father; "there, there, its alright you'll be okay."

[@ocular4925]

Lovely Baladad bitch what the fuck its a fucking chicken "felt so attached" WHAT THE FUCK.

[@leibaladad1916]

eight uhhh.. i don't think theres anything wrong with what I've said and what I felt. a chicken is a living thing. you can get attached to an adorable cat/dog but all of a sudden its a whole different thing when it comes to chickens and other animals??¿¿¿?? aside from that, i totally respect your response.

[@harleedenzel8081]

Lovely Baladad omg sameeeee girl, I felt like I lost ma bby

[@danaputra97]

well they all died

[@thead-skipper2095]

kakean cangkem cuk

[@zenumberonelollipop]

(This will be long but if you want to know why it didnt work) Animals that are developed in an egg have to stay that way because when the animal gets too big but still isn't fully developed the egg keeps everything from falling apart another reason is because of bacteria, bacteria will affect the animal also the heat we dont know what heat it needs now that there is no shell around either it needs more or less because we also dont know if the shell protecting the animal is holding the heat in or preventing too much heat even if the animal had became fully developed it wouldn't live long or it will be disformed. Tho this is a great video because we need to try before we know (I know this was sent a year ago but if you see it please dont get me wrong i love seeing people TRY new things or we would get no where in life)

[@RIPPER95D]

You read my thoughts :)

[@zenumberonelollipop]

;)

[@emoololo]

👌👌👌

[@moondreamer6698]

Actually they have done this before and their have Ben lots of successfull no-shell chick hatchings

[@zenumberonelollipop]

Been* and sure im sure that at some point in humans time we where successful but how successful?

[@SAKSOON]

It makes me think a lot. This formation of new life is so magical 🌠

[@connorkim7306]

I keep seeing your comments

[@brunopereirapimentel7888]

It was dead, then life grows slowly

[@StupidhappynesS]

I'm a subscriber too!

[@AH-il3no]

Yea except they all died because of research

[@CookieTheOcelot]

It died

[@anusha2353]

fun fact! Human embryonic development is very similar to a chicken's. The only difference is the distribution of certain parts (i.e. the chicken embryo has a larger yolk compared to the human embryo because the yolk will be forming into the placenta later on), also the allentois is smaller in human embryo since it has the mother as the source for gas exchange whereas in chicken embryo it's larger)

[@SuKimm]

interesting!

[@kyliecross9124]

In English please.

[@gagokaba817]

WTF are you saying

[@hayblut3595]

Yeah totally understand.....😑😑😑

[@ptbot3294]

That's is about as similar as saying there are cells and DNA involve. -_-

[@jacklowe74]

*PETA wants to know your location*

[@jacklowe74]

@@r0ckerchick666 THATS THE FUCKING JOKE LMAO

[@amagos18]

Ok I made a comment and had to change it several times because my comment changed itself to 'PETA wants to know your location' how tf did it do that and why?

[@theoneoutalive0w042]

@@r0ckerchick666 r/whoosh

[@slvrrgld9]

@@r0ckerchick666 r/wooosh

[@nickidenise1102]

Shannon Streahorn-Viau when they say r/woosh that means you missed the joke

[@Stylomagic]

This embryo died because it had no eggshell. Without it, it couldn't develope correctly. The eggshell is responsible for bone and muscles growth.

[@dovemaiden333]

The missing eggshell provided to the growing embryo in Calcium Pentahydrate ( 250 or 500 mg, I forget which) which was added UNDER the egg and yolk in the plastic. This provided the proper nutrition for the chick in terms of Calcium. This is demonstrated on the other KZbin video.

[@Helpmereachsubs-nr1en]

Stylomagic The japanese people did this experiment and it was success

[@Nine05mafiA__ttv]

secondly it drowns in its own fluids that way

[@missanthropist5806]

What's your point...

[@1snivy10]

A shame the experiment failed, but take a look at the embryo (somewhere before the halfway mark) where its got that long tail. Thats a remnant of its dinosaurian ancestry! So cool!

[@shaes9031]

A Heracross good eye

[@SageWolfStudio]

All embryos even humans have that tail part lol

[@FemkjeMW]

Humans have a tail bone

[@FantasyAddict95]

When it comes to experiments, the only time they have failed is when you learn nothing from them. I'm sad they died, and it did fail to see them to 'hatching,' but we did get to observe and learn a bit about the process of development and risks that can lead to eggs failing to hatch.

[@greenergrass4060]

T-Zay of course we dont sweety. You had evolution wrong ;)

[@jellicoe3755]

It looked like it was desperately trying to get out but then it drowned

[@tatecore]

Was not developed enough to be attempting to hatch

[@_Aidelweiss_]

Sadly :(

[@luisafiladelfo]

Churrasco é bom caralho

[@TheTempest73]

lol what?

[@marioaugusto9764]

@@luisafiladelfo kkkkkk

[@aestheticcur]

As much as I hate seeing things die, this is some good knowledge right here and I am okay with seeing people break boundaries like this to learn more about evolution as well as simple growth. I would love to see more experiments like this, hopefully with less dying

[@aestheticcur]

Mendoza Juan Have you ever looked at the growth of any baby vertibrate? They all look the same in their egg up until a point which can signify a common ancestor. If no one started having fish-like sperm in the Cambrian era, none of us would make that observation and perhaps we wouldn't even be vertebrates (seeing how incredibly simple a tail and head is in the vertibrate world).

[@thehonestorange713]

Why 3 and why did it die. I think there are people born like this and they don't die. Its a hospital in New York I think. Not totally sure don't hold me to that. I'm not mad really, but I'm offput that the chicken may have suffered through all of it. Nonetheless this was a very interesting video

[@michaelgriffeth85]

Rudi Barczewska so basically you are saying that you are the same as a chicken ....

[@michaelgriffeth85]

Rudi Barczewska Darwin’s ‘theory’ of evolution has been proven false btw...

[@pooppoo9741]

I'm not. It didn't get a chance to live

[@vietlorax2856]

i would just like to that say experiment is perfectly fine, even though they died, it was a very good attempt. there are far worst experiments then this. This wasn't even a cruel experiment. so all you people hating on this person for testing an experiment, don't be so ignorant. her experiment is probably better than anything you've done in your lives. the first attempt failed but she can learn from it and retry the experiment. that's how you learn. if you don't believe in science or education, welp you're sad. things grow, live and die. it's nothing new. get over it. nothing last forever

[@vietlorax2856]

SuperKamek Plays! son is that you

[@lordofsandvich3630]

I suppose assuming that the people who do these experiments don’t know their chances of success is a little backwards, hmm? :P Thanks for helping me catch myself.

[@CheshieD]

You say nothing last forever but that's not completely true. The human race's destruction of environments and species will last forever because humans have no way of creating a creature that is long gone from the earth.

[@vietlorax2856]

CheshieD then the universe ends and destroys everything and not even darkness will exist ;D

[@janedupree2327]

There's no cruelty here, this is simply the nature of life and death.

[@tonis.3311]

I remember when I was in the 2nd grade, we incubated chickens in our classroom all 9 of them hatched successfully. We were of course second graders so they told us that they were going to be sent to a farm, where they would grow up and lived a happy rest of their lives, but I wasn't stupid and I know I probably ended up eating one of our little buddies. 😂😂😂

[@burninginhell9512]

Well... They did live rapidly for the rest of their lives, if you think about that lmao

[@acatofmanylives-ashe6973]

I'd like to note that eggshells are porous and let in water and oxygen- perhaps the seal created to be bacteria proof was their demise, the better sealed ones dying first from the slow suffocation. Without proper humidity an egg can't mature, after all. Also the eggs are rotated because the yolk will stick to the inside membrane of the shell. Overall it isn't necessary but overall contributes greatly to hatch rate.. if you'd like to view development past this then I'd suggest looking at ordering white eggs and candling them!

[@GalacticThot_745]

Amber Foxwing the tubes are for oxygen

[@hendrik6720]

is it true that the outside of eggs have a thin dried "member" of "mucus" or something of that nature? Maybe, like keeping a babies environment too clean, that its not about the absence of bacteria but what *types* of bacteria are present? Sort of like how gut flora in people help protect from outside infections by hogging all the space where foreign bacteria might otherwise grow?

[@GalacticThot_745]

Colorado Guy membrane? Yes they have a membrane but it's not mucus

[@ezequieladrianminniti6252]

Also the egg shell prevents hazardous light radiation to damage DNA of the little chicken

[@tatecore]

A chick also absorbs nutrients/calcium from the shell as it develops.

[@MohammedAslamtit-bitsoflife]

Exactly at 12.02 the blood vains burst and the end.

[@sarahchristensen9740]

Arctic Circle so it died :(

[@dolangonzales8631]

And it stops moving at 12:28 #Rest In Pice (sorry for the misspelling in the moment of silence).

[@dolangonzales8631]

Don't click on the rest link! I don't know what it is!

[@richardusdanangjaya1181]

:(

[@TheOpelkoenjas]

12:11

[@aa-jm7js]

I wonder what would have happened if they did make it to full stages of development. There is no shell to break free from. They say that the process of cracking through develops vigor for life. It's interesting, but also so terribly sad.

[@June_815]

see this video, the chick hatched here successfully. kzbin.info/www/bejne/q3aTpn6siseWnNk Thank me later

[@paid4life276]

HI. A A

[@Struudeli]

The problem is that chicks belly is still open when it starts it's hatching, it will slowly close. It's possible to help chick to hatch but you gotta do it very slowly. My baby rooster was born with help (he had too big legs to hatch himself) and it took six hours to do safely. He growed to be healthy and handsome toffee colored rooster.

[@fabianastacia3350]

My mom used to help the weakest chikens to hatch, and they always grew healty. I think it turns out fine if you do it the correct way.

[@ZomBeeNature]

Unlike all these other bozos here, I don't think not turning them had anything to do with it. Eggs are turned so thr embryo does not grow attached to the petmeable shell. But in your case it is in either glass or plastic so it wouldn't attach. At the halfway point there was a drop in the humidity and it began slowly drying. Then at about 8 minutes the drying accelerated and continued accelerating. Once it dried out too far the membranes couldn't support themselves and broke. So when you do it again, make sure the humidity stays high.

[@hendrik6720]

is humidity a general requirement or is it just 'x ounces of water over the growing period? Would an egg, submerged in a bath of neutral ph (and neutral temp) still grow?

[@ZomBeeNature]

@@hendrik6720 it is a general requirement to keep the egg from drying out because the shell is porous, not solid. Take the two extremes of an egg in 0% humidity and the water evaporating out at a fast rate and the egg drying inside, and at 100% humidity and the water in the egg does not evaporate out at all and there is no drying. I can see some difficulties with an egg submerged in a buffer, but I wonder if they could be gotten around. One is that egg shells are not sterile so when you put them in the solution it would make it easier for germs to grow and you would grow a stew of germs that kill the egg. Another is oxygen diffuses from air across the shell as fast as it is possible to diffuse, but getting from air into the solution, and then from the solution across the egg, would be slower so it might not be fast enough to keep it alive. Another is the egg has the right concentrations of chemicals for development and when you put it in the solution, osmosis would alter the concentrations in the egg to match the solution (because it is porous, not solid), so that might prevent development if they were not the same. Those are things that come to mind. But I think someone should test things out to see if these things are a problem and can be overcome if they are. It would be interesting to see. I even wonder, in the experiment shown here in the video, if they had added an extra egg white, would that have kept the embryo from drying out long enough to develop the full time, or what that would have done? By the way, I think it's amazing it didn't get contaminated for so long.

[@hendrik6720]

Zom Bee Nature additional eggwhite sounds promising Maybe they could grow multiple chickens in one container so the worst and the best properties average out, or supplant immunity by adding a drop of blood from a donor (full grown chicken) to the container. aerogels might make good support, high potential oxygen volume, but very low density. not sure about ph though.

[@ZomBeeNature]

[pictures conjoined chickens with a thirst for blood resting on an aerogel mattress]

[@13thMaiden]

Part of me feels like it was a combination of both factors, but you're right I think the humidity was the main part, as it broke the homeostasis of the 'egg'. As for rotating, I wonder if they could make a circle clamp that would allow rotation, just to see if there's any benefit outside of keeping it from attaching to the shell (which in this case it wouldn't attach anyways but we could see if the chick needs the rotating for any other reason.) I wonder if those 'dino chickens' could be grown this way for better study? (Since most never make it out of their eggs)

[@gavincurtis]

Very educational video. I recall somewhere that a martini glass works very well by keeping the embryo movement minimized so it doesn't destroy itself. Awesome to see them grow like this. Spectacular when the final result is a fluffy peeping yellow chick that follows you around.

[@paulgreene7424]

The Dollar Guy "I'll buy THAT for a dollar!"

[@tcd3077]

The embryos need movement though, hence artificial incubators have rollers and in nature the egg will be rotated by the mother

[@georgeboi7681]

umm, the chick in this video died people...

[@cbgaming08]

Yeah its not beating anymore hahaha

[@James-rg1pp]

GeorgeBoi he knows, he’s just saying it would be a good end result

[@checkit6593]

Wow I'm incredibly amazed by a chicken/chuck developing outside its own shell

[@minecraftgameplays8148]

Chick not chuck

[@TB-cc1ct]

Wither boy 2 Minecraft gamplays some people say chuck or they might of misspelled

[@checkit6593]

Eh sorry guys I'm on mobile I can't type well 😅

[@kjetilmikhailov7477]

I think a smaller catalyst will increase your success rate. It's moving around too much. If I had to guess, i'd put it between malnutrition and stress death. It appears as though environmental stimulation triggered more reflexes than normal resulting in resources burning instead of nourishing. But meh, I'm no scientist or medical guy, just a nobody really. haha I can't even name more than 3 elements xD. It's just my guess.

[@SuKimm]

you could be right. but this video was sped up! if you want to see how fast the embryo moved in real life, you can watch our other video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/j6DGdZeraN2amK8

[@XOXO-mb2vh]

Kjetil Mikhailov I agree. I also think opacity protects something during development. The calcium in the shell provides something important too.

[@Sifar333]

its not stress the movement is normal embryo activity, but its clearly very dry at the end the blood vessels exploded and I guess some fungal infection occurred that white substance.

[@jeffwelshJedidivemaster]

like sleep

[@sarahchristensen9740]

Kjetil Mikhailov the lasts one's blood veins bursted and he died

[@Mango-xn8sd]

Wow they all died and I'm sad now

[@daishisetsuko9743]

Jelly Bubbles relax, if they did survive they would end in someone's plate x/

[@daveno8432]

this is life.. And death.

[@JessicaGarcia-me4hh]

Daïshi Setsuko who are u ...to judge ..anyone for eating anything stfu...

[@Lauren-ri9uh]

i'm sad too

[@jackh9034]

😭😭😭😭

[@TWOSU_NEWS]

Congradulations: you suffocated the embryo at the last stage of development by use of the saran wrap placed over the embryonic fluid...did this same experiment in high school science with a successful fledge...at the final stage in development, it believed that the yolk and developed chicken starts using oxygen absorbed through the shell, and just prior to hatching you can actualy hear the chicken chirp

[@PikaPetey]

Wow! Crazy

[@MelodyHarmonyCreeper]

Honestly didn't expect to see you here. ^^ can't blame you though; it is pretty fascinating.

[@gleef9237]

Oh hi petey

[@SuKimm]

thank you!!

[@dasplaudagei6060]

Pikapetey Animations You are everywhere!Help!

[@DerangedMallard]

A wild pikabutt appeared

[@StoicVeR]

fresh comment on an old vid. I would imagine sterility, light exposure, and typical movement of the embryo via egg rotation were all key factors neglected in this experiment. When mammalian's (excluding monotreme's) are gestating, the embryo is in a sterile environment, same as with the egg - ecoli or Salmonella infections occur due to contamination from the egg shell understandibly, it is difficult to achieve a sterile environment for this experiment. The same with sun or light exposure - the UV or illumination is too intense for an organism meant to develop in a pressurized, and contained environment. most notably, egg rotation is essential for circulation due to avian eggs (unlike reptile or amphibian) being anchored within the egg. This is a complex procedure, for a fetus that is meant to be 'laid' and develops over a period of time.

[@animeaunty]

TheVeR01 I was wondering about the sunlight. I was also wondering about the air permeability of shell vs this set up? Do shells breathe?

[@StoicVeR]

shells breathe. If you submerge an egg in water, the chick will suffocate

[@animeaunty]

TheVeR01 I thot so. That's means there prolly where many unaddressed factors n this experiment. I read she had a fish pump for air but obviously air was only on one side of development. Stress factors have to b VERY high, too much exposure & I don't think ambient humidity was correctly controlled either. I also think I remember that hens move the eggs around alot too. This embryo made it much further that one would think possible under such trying circumstances! Perfecting this method may b the answer to some shipping issues? Very fascinating!

[@DesudesChan]

i0.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/273/444/fe3.jpg

[@hendrik6720]

wonder how many generations of breeding successful offspring of this method, would be needed before the infections become a non-issue. also q - why dont they anchor to their shell? is that ever desireable?

[@jozyhernandez]

Wo it got so far . I'm still trying to figure out what what went wrong did you remember to poke a few holes in the Saran Wrap or did you rotate it or tilt the cup every once in awhile. And all was a nice video showing detailed development of a chick

[@Trapper-John]

You should try this again and see if you could get them to last longer, or even become cute little chicks!!

[@jasonmoney3280]

That's cruel don't do it again it's like ur killing aborted chicks

[@sebastianaruisi5556]

They do survive when cultured in this way. Just in this case they didn't. Relax

[@smolgok384]

Jason Money have you ever eaten eggs or anything with egg in it? You've eaten aborted chickens. You're cruel dude

[@j.6902]

^ this is not true at all.

[@enchimoon9938]

Noelle Morris

[@Heheh.681]

Makes not want to eat eggs anymore

[@sonilapapa]

daniel avila it's okay not all eggs are fertile...they are checked before they are sent in the shop. But that doesn't mean that they aren't fertile... Some times they are fertile sometimes they aren't...

[@alohamissnana4863]

daniel avila also me

[@homk24]

daniel avila im already *Not* eating them

[@KryptidShadow]

Same...

[@boltblue5532]

Then go vegan lol

[@Semibytes]

It showed a egg food ad before the video started. What a coincident.

[@maryanaflores8978]

Actually it’s not, they base ads off the video your watching

[@vinchelofourie]

I'm going to assume that the people whom say that this is "cruel", have never been in a biology classroom, where such experiments are conducted.

[@RmRoyalflush]

it still is cruel to make experiments with life, doesnt matter in which form. but humans have a cruel nature so it okay for many of us i guess

[@pshuckle7488]

So Royalflush... Are you a vegan or a hypocrite?

[@RmRoyalflush]

i'm pretty hypocrite, i know whats objectively right but dont always follow it. but hey atleas im vegetarian, thats something

[@jessicapillow5854]

Phijkchu Shuckle I'm a vegetarian and I don't find this cruel whatsoever. I think it's amazing. It's incredible to see how things develop inside of the "egg". And I'm not upset that they died. Stuff like this happens on nature all the time.

[@razvanradoiu]

How does it make it any less cruel...? "it happens in biology classes so it isnt cruel" lol I dont think thats how morality works

[@Comet1808]

Su Kim, First of all, this was so very interesting! As far as the contamination is concerned, I have a few questions. I was wondering if you had taken any cultures of the white spots afterwards, as you believe that this loss could have been from contamination? It might help in further attempts by narrowing down the actual contaminant. It was something to see how the white specks appeared and then rapidly spread, so I do agree that this is the likely reason for the demise. You had mentioned that you had used distilled water. I was wondering if you had sterilized any of your equipment/water? As far as the Cling Wrap, it is possible to use a UV-C light to kill any bacteria or viruses. If there is anyway to sterilize your equipment as much as possible, it could help narrow down any outside contaminants. Also, did you break the shell of the egg directly over the container? I would first consider gently washing the egg shell surface, rinsing it in 2 different sterile water baths and drying it with something sterile, prior to breaking it open. If this were me, I'd have everyone involved wear a mask and cover their hair and done sterile gloves when handling the equipment. I'd culture everything, just prior to the beginning of the experiment, to see if there is any growth. Then if this same thing were to happen, I'd culture the inside of the chick's membrane and see if there is any matching bacteria. This would help narrow down the contaminate. As a viewer, I thought that the movement of the sun & everyone else, in front of the incubator was a bit distracting, but then thought that it could be much worse for the chick. Would you consider some sort of cover for the front in the future? I'm sure that there is light detected thru a normal shell, just not as much. I'm thinking that it's probably pretty dark inside the shell, especially when the mother hen is sitting on her eggs and lighter when she leaves during the day. I'm hoping that you will be able to repeat this experiment some day. I genuinely love this type of work!! Thank you for reading my comments.

[@joeymama2681]

Comet1808 ii

[@wolvenar]

I agree, light may have played a rather significant roll here. Maybe if you or anyone else tries this again, very low light and a good low light cam, or ir light only?

[@legaleagle308]

I found this video really amazing! You never get to see what’s happening on the inside of a shell and you got some good footage of what that process looks like. It is sad that it didn’t survive, but really interesting all the same!

[@kristleblux3151]

Its weird because I felt really sad when I saw one by one the containers were being taken out because of the birds-to-be were dying, I guess seeing them grow would make you sad, especially since it was almost completely ready for hatching but sadly didn't.

[@comradegarrett1202]

What if you designed a cup had harder walls? it looks like near the end, the chick's movements became strong enough that it ruptured its blood supply and died. if there was a hard wall preventing those really strong movements maybe it would go better. the trick would be providing good air supply though a hard shell and also keeping contamination under control.

[@angelawolf1938]

I didn't know the heart was the first to develop! This is a really interesting video!!😀

[@aniket5611]

Same with us,we also develop the heart first in the womb👍🏻

[@CheesecakeDevourer1350]

...... I hate to break it to you but .... that’s not true

[@jonatanvela5905]

I've never seen an experiment like this, it's really impressive you should try it again, I'm sure the next time will succeed

[@photon6490]

No need for killing another innocent baby chick

[@Nobody-qk5fc]

I’ve seen something like it 3 years ago

[@raceface_m2579]

Balut! Haha jk. This was actually a wonderful thing to witness. Thanks for taking the time to film this.

[@rafi4821]

i love balut too

[@vanillaramen640]

Me too

[@adelinemae7191]

who doesn't!

[@seltaro]

raceface_m Ayye a fellow Filipino!

[@gracella92013]

Nope

[@dilawnapancitcanton8017]

What happened to the other egg...... I have aalot of questions

[@ombretta507]

It's died

[@dunns8962]

It died

[@tuningourlivestojesuschris6193]

For your lot of questions..... Here is Ur answer In future u will become a researcher

[@85Terezka]

Deded fren

[@angelicakzapata]

Omelette.

[@anonimouschicka3930]

Oh no! I was so excited to see full development 😓 but still really really cool

[@justabbii]

The real question is...what came first the egg or the shell?🤔 Btw who's watching in 2k18??🙋

[@deadaccount3859]

Im in 3018

[@arariira]

Shell

[@genji5675]

Everyone?

[@isabelcabrera4469]

Im in 8293938488383882939388828383838939384847474747389394929391003939399

[@chia1071]

EGG. The eggs are the ones that mutate into the chicken

[@TheCho5enJuan]

Smarter Every Day led me here! Soooo crazy👍🏼

[@peerbrent]

Yeah

[@johnielotero5180]

Me too

[@AdriMB86]

why are the blood vessels breaking and bleeding on minute 12:00? maybe is related to it´s death, poor baby :/

[@berywildbrielle]

I’ll probably never eat eggs again * presses play *

[@christinaramirez1173]

Brielle Dior The ones we eat aren't even fertilized, so it's not like they could've lived anyways

[@chantesse]

Spooky Purple Spider actually people have done this to store bought eggs too sooo....

[@sherlockbones6702]

Zohe Usher most eggs are pasteurized sooo...

[@chantesse]

Sherlock Bones some* not most otherwise how do people successfully incubate store bought eggs lol.

[@abdalwahed2013]

are you sure ?

[@princessleia9283]

Too bad. Three eggs. None of them survived.

[@randysaypanya8174]

The question still remains, which came first, the chicken or the egg?

[@hiveforone]

Randy Saypanya dinosaur? Yes, im pretty sure its dinosaur

[@sonderdonder8266]

Randy Saypanya What about duck?! FUCK

[@gartengeflugel924]

The egg

[@lizacastillo4164]

chicken,because God create this creature as a chicken

[@FollowmeonInstagram904_gabbyyy]

Chegg

[@tabithahaas5349]

Su Kim, why do you think the last one died and do you think that this was a difficult experiment? Have you seen anyone have a successful hatch without a shell?

[@kuraraShotai9]

Su Kim by around the 12:03 mark a small blood spill on the bottom left side of the yolk, so that probably started the weakening of its body, maybe making the other veins weaker as well?

[@woomi9486]

This is so weird and cool at the same time! It tells a lot how a chick grows

[@badatthegame1333]

Does no one realize that they all died?😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😨😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@lastcommentor558]

Ysabell H i spotted the non crying emoji

[@meadowrayne2718]

Some Kind Of Rodent no they all litterally died :(

[@DM0505]

Guillaume Loiseau they can

[@rachaelc4571]

There's a difference between the reality of immortality and just creating to suffer. I don't know the situation of this scenario but these comments are oddly detached.

[@michaelochoche5804]

Ysabell H even the last one

[@YOKAIRAVE]

Will you ever try this again to see if you're successful?

[@8lackz]

Su Kim i got to this video from a same experiment in japan from like a dozen they succeed to make one chivk live healthily...

[@8lackz]

Try #YoBNl4bXt9w

[@picklesdill9138]

Su Kim why duck?

[@shortyfry85]

So close! It looked like bacteria set up shop and spread from the right. Maybe try to identify the source of contamination and avoid/prevent it next time?

[@aponiaa]

Very interesting! I think if the embryo had a more porous enclosure and possibly was rotated from time to time, it would've made it to term. I grew up on a farm and we had many chickens and lots of lil chicks hatching in the spring. Although the eggs can be fertilized anytime, it seemed that spring was the time when most of the hatching happened. The yolk of the egg seems to be the embryo's nutrition? We had chicks hatch that still had the yolk sack attached to their stomachs. Sometimes they reabsorbed it, sometimes they died. The miracle life is always amazing. Unrelated, I'm really hungry now for some reason.

[@ytrewq6789]

I hope one day you will get them to fully develop this way?, that would be really cool to see!... Keep up the great work!.

[@crzymnky47]

So cool! I've been into birds for a while now and I've always wanted to know what this looks like.

[@LoyaltyLyrics]

Great research experiment.and .. i would like to know that the intention of you study! And the other thing... during the development (natural) hen changed the position of egg intermittently. . And whats the alternative strategy did you do in this research!

[@kritikasharma5647]

One of my fishes died today..i never thought it would be this emotional and sad for me to bury her/him (yes fishes are persons like all animals)..i can understand how u must have felt

[@StarryKitsuKat]

kritika sharma Just wanted to say, it's great of you to also care for fish and the chicken. Not many people care for other animals that aren't cats or dogs. Keep spreading that good energy and don't listen to negative people who tell you otherwise.

[@bethanysmith5856]

i never knew the embryo moved around so much as they devoloped

[@paintingwithtastefromcanva7165]

This is great! I'm just wondering if you had to turn them three times daily for the 21 days?

[@xZShaneRemeydZx]

The embryo white its dead? How called the music btw?

[@danielv.6415]

Jayde Jay that slide tho

[@Rakuziio]

Dankeater Midir hahaha...

[@Rakuziio]

†ღxZ- I N S A N I T Y -Zxღ† Yes it died. I don't know about the music though I can't help you with that but let me make it up to you. *How called your snap chat?*

[@danielv.6415]

Rakuzen damn yall niggas thirsty af

[@Rakuziio]

Dankeater Midir That I am bruh... Hopefully she'd quench me of this thirst.

[@Super_vic]

You should really try this again

[@alstongaloyo2342]

Slayin It I agree I would really love to see a chick be born that way.

[@oldchannel2519]

Alston Galoyo yeah

[@justkibby5959]

Egg shells are porous to allow oxygen to the embryo. If it's sealed tight in a bowl it won't get oxygen. It needs to peck through the air pocket (fat end of egg) just before hatching (day 18) to beginning breathing before pipping and hatching. I think this is where it went wrong.

[@dovemaiden333]

What humidity did you maintain, and how were you able to measure humidity inside the cup medium? Also, were you able to get an O2 reading from the bottom of the cup where the oxygen was being funnelled? How did you supply oxygen to the incubator and what was the rate of application? Thank you so much for doing this experiment and sharing the results!

[@animeaunty]

I was wondering about the O2 as well. Do shells breathe?

[@Mittzie]

Yes eggshells breathe room air would likely be fine for the process because that is what they get in the shell as well.

[@animeaunty]

Mittzie Problem was this egg was surrounded by glass & plastic, not eggshell.

[@RubysZoo]

Please try again and post videos! This was very informative and helpful. I currently have 3 of these that I set today in the incubator. Wish me luck!

[@Sophia17R]

Any update??

[@83loveanimals]

I think is not right to do that..i am not surprised none of them survived

[@linkinsmommy7908]

Valentina Moro No one really gives a shit what some random idiot on the internet thinks. Now, go read a science book.

[@WonderGirlVlogs]

Wow! This is so cool!! I love watching experiments like this because it is cool to see how it develops.

[@vinchelofourie]

Su Kim Quite interesting. If I would stipulate; I belive that the last chick died from infection, possibly bacterial, as certain plastics are porous, and thus bacteria may have entered. If I may suggest, use latex instead, and increase the amount of O2 available, because chicken eggshell is porous for gaseous exchange, and latex is not so more O2 is critical. However this is quite a brilliant experiment.

[@vinchelofourie]

Su Kim I appreciate your response. :)

[@dovemaiden333]

Yes, good job. See if you can get the same type of wrap used by the original authors. Also, as someone who has hatched eggs for many years, I wanted you to know that the first five and the last three days are the crucial ones when it comes to survival. If there is anything genetically wrong with the embryo, the highest termination rates occur in those time frames. If you read on incubation techniques, this is often mentioned---everything looks great when you candle them, then at the last three days, final mortality can transpire with any embryos that have problems; it is disappointing, but happens with every clutch. The same thing happens in humans, for example, when a spontaneous miscarriage occurs because the embryo is not genetically viable for whatever reason. Therefore, it is possible that the embryo had something wrong that had nothing to do with the hatching technique; it may not have hatched even if it had been in the shell. I've had many eggs show wonderful growth until the last three days when sudden death terminated the gestation. Just something to keep in mind.

[@dovemaiden333]

Su Kim, in the Japanese Poultry paper, they had a ten- egg control group. I just took this as a cut and paste from the article: Intact Egg Control The hatchability of the intact control embryos was 70% (7 out of 10) and no abnormalities were observed. Two eggs were dead with pipped eggs, and another egg was dead at hatching because of damage in yolk sac" This is the direct quote, and illustrates my point about those crucial last days of hatch; the ones that died while trying to pip out, and the one showing yolk damage in the final 19th to 21st days. This is a normal hatch rate and is in the control group and they still lost three at the pipping stage. So don't let it get you down that it didn't hatch; it may not have made it anyway. You just need a larger number to work with to accurately get some statistics on hatchability for shell-less eggs; one is too small a number to make any real hypothesis, although the fungal growth definitely played a major role.

[@thatonejerry9092]

Wait were they getting air from micro holes like real eggs in the wild? If not then thats not to good

[@hendrik6720]

whats the diameter and density of holes in a chicken egg, vs say, glass (I know it's porous, I just don't know the details)

[@thatonejerry9092]

Su Kim ok thanks for the feedback. Love the vid

[@SrbijaCG]

I've just realized that a chicken embryo is more precious to people than a human embryo.

[@beblepebble3096]

This, children, is why you don't let an embryo grow in a cup.

[@brianpurdun6808]

Coffee Man This, children, is what you call an experiment. Learn, improve, progress, it’s the way of life including to various mammals, insects, reptiles, etc! We all learn and without education we could have never been at the present. It’s actually how a certain species of ants learn, improve, and progress on how to grow fungus and become the notorious farmers we know today. So, please stop telling people non-sense.

[@beblepebble3096]

Ok... This is why you don't kill a chicken in a cup

[@beblepebble3096]

Or something like that

[@Mittzie]

This is why when day 18 hits you increase humidity to a minimum 60% increasing humidity was not done in this experiment so the blood vessels dried and became fragile.

[@mr.yeetersons31]

Dude I see you everywhere

[@circussystem9451]

The other 2 died? This is pretty painful...

[@Dawesenm]

Kawaii Alexa Gaming You're weak.

[@circussystem9451]

Brandon Mayoral How? I just said that it’s sad! Plus, bich don’t call me weak when you ain’t even know me or my pains.

[@MrPablosek]

Kawaii Alexa Gaming They all died

[@circussystem9451]

Mr. Pablosek ;-; Ik...

[@HSdirectioner5]

Brandon Mayoral how is he/she weak by saying that was painful? You don’t even know the person, or if he/she is weak or not

[@thatnamelessperson7887]

Who atcully watched this without skipping through half of it? *Not me*

[@shax5532]

Not me

[@JohnathanBach]

Me...

[@chrishkawaii]

Cool video! It's just sad that last did not survived 😭

[@starsable2221]

Chrissia Loreine it wasn't dead it just wasn't fertilized

[@mingolingo4740]

Chloe Bustin Are you stupid? If it wasnt fertilized then non of that would have happened idiot. If it wasnt fertilized then it wouldn't have "died"

[@reeganseabury5504]

I know people are sad it dies but this is most likely for a science experiment. This was supposed to happen thats why they did it; so they know what to do better next time

[@dolangonzales8631]

reegan it seemed like everything was fine untill the veins burst making the embryo die + it would be about 21 days just for an embryo to grow up nearly making it but being unable to get through the plastic = what we learned is when your "science project" works don't pop it's veins and kill it .it's practically chicken egg abortion!🐔☠

[@dolangonzales8631]

*19 days*

[@dolangonzales8631]

(If you are taking it from your science teachers then it would make sense for them just wanting you to have the growth mindset)

[@clayman648]

Damnnn that sucks at the end I doubt there was anything you could have done :/ I’m currently doing the same experiment in a convection oven temp at 37 degree Using glad wrap close to the water in the bottom of the dish and holes on the inside of the lid And also water on the bottom of the little oven I really hope they go alright

[@NikkiD1999]

I have got to know how it went, like seriously it sounds destined to fail but I'm so curious.

[@eetuthereindeer6671]

Dont do it...

[@truelyseen7050]

clayman648 you could have no open the damn eggs they weren't innocent in this

[@clayman648]

Didn't work out, I think I had the wrong container and wrong style but same principle

[@LoyaltyLyrics]

When you make holes... there is high chance of contamination. .

[@mariaengel730]

I was eating an egg sandwich while watching this...

[@bartimaeusnathaniel3856]

LOL...

[@ほだ冕匙ぇ]

Im eating KFC :P

[@abhimanyusingh9184]

So both the brothers died the same day. RIP.

[@AbsoluteAbsurd]

Im eating my thoughts

[@AbsoluteAbsurd]

Mmmm bacon and eggs uwu

[@damiengries4983]

They needed some mama vibes

[@blackclamslammer9715]

I own a tropical bird. I would like to learn how to assist with the creation of life at home. Can you please link me to a Journal for the experiment?

[@Akblackrose907]

Poor thing. It dried out on top and that made its blood vessels rip. At one photo per minute you can see it slowly die. Really saddening.

[@Akblackrose907]

It starts drying up at about 40 seconds from the end.

[@itsmanicbear8500]

KZbin reccommandations stroke again

[@authornim7606]

I have a question.. If the last one, or all of them survived, finished developing in the egg, ready to get out of the "shell"...how? Because that "shell" is plastic, and those chicks wouldnt be able to rip through that... I think that chick was able to survive. It kept kicking, and looked healthy. It couldnt get out and symply drowned in its own yolk.. Thats cruel

[@hypnoticdreams6918]

That's just horrible. I know it may been interesting and all but I fell like those chicks could have grown to be normal instead of just used as a science experiment. 😭

[@hypnoticdreams6918]

@@clayestscience3546 how is it better? Either way they will die. It was not possible the way they were doing it. So the chicks would die anyway. 🙄 man, everyone just wanna look at a comment and post something along the lines of negativity

[@lijemayne4287]

@@hypnoticdreams6918 there is beauty in the death of these chicks. This science experiment may seem harsh to you, but in the end, it will contribute to better understanding life... and may even save several lives in the future. Either as an egg (to become food, which contributes to the 10% rule of energy pyramids of life, being a contributor in the world's continuous life stream) or as an embryo (for science), their death were not in vain irregardless. You're the one being negative here. 😅

[@lijemayne4287]

@@clayestscience3546 I'm a lady though. *curtsy 😊

[@85Terezka]

Eh the more humans know the better

[@KD-bk7gd]

Better to advance science, than to be pooped out after a McNugget binge.

[@Blueshark8O9]

Does this count as a disruption of privacy?

[@sunakshisharma6388]

It should

[@BiggerCityYT]

Hey so for future videos, can you please put maybe what time and day it is, thank you!

[@RicardoOliveiraRGB]

What happened at 12:08 ? It's like some yellow thing explode

[@adventureswithmiriya265]

Ricardo RGB a blood vessel popped and it died :(

[@monca1222]

The membrane became too dry and broke open unfortunately ☹

[@MoonSarito]

What happened to the first one that was removed at 0:48, why the second went white at 1:50 and what happened to the last one? I'm rather intrigued by why they died

[@therestorationofdrwho1865]

Did it die?

[@eintreich1014]

@@therestorationofdrwho1865 of course

[@zort1933]

God Can’t Believe That Spoon And That Plastic Cups Are There For So Long tsk.... Such Lazy People xD

[@kathy-leew3989]

I remeber when I was in i think 3rd grade (it was a private school ), they showed us a timelaps film with explaination of a chicken egg that was fertilized and it's developement inside an egg (with a small hole) I found it so fascinating as a child that I became a nerd for Biology and I am studying Biotechnology now

[@thev.u.p5971]

*Asian heavy breathing*

[@subhendumurmu018]

Last week I had exam on Preparation of a temporary stained mount of chick embryo of 72 hrs and I could see the heart beat

[@heathert5455]

That is cool. What are you studying to be, a Vetrinarian?!

[@subhendumurmu018]

@@heathert5455 no it was included in my syllabus..biotechnology

[@Storm-uk4rd]

Without the chicken growing in it, imagine how many dessert this egg could help make

[@jyotsanakataria4835]

What's the purpose of experiment..The bird died in the end..I thought it will survive.

[@rossbob6484]

The purpose is to see the development of the egg, how it grows etc...

[@mbaihaqi30]

And why the embryo needs to be in their shells as they developed.

[@ecjjce7315]

He's wicked.

[@SAMMIsLIFE]

Aww,poor baby

[@kevinlobo2695]

Why?

[@dco5181]

Yeah exactly, why?

[@kevinlobo2695]

Nevermind he died

[@Petiellee]

What I learned today: Eggs, I KNEW THAT KZbin HAS IT ALL!

[@adeshjahazi4205]

Why its stopped moving in the end?

[@SuKimm]

it died

[@lastcommentor558]

Su Kim was it due to infection?

[@SuKimm]

maybe. there was a white solid substance that formed that we thought may have been mold/fungi/contamination, but we're not sure

[@cleanserofnoobs4162]

It's arteries stretched too much too fast and ruptured, bled out internally.

[@Glitchlover87]

CleanserOfNoobs How do you know this?

[@Toby-yz7wt]

OMG SU, THIS VIDEO IS SO AWESOME. IT IS NOT ONLY FUN BUT ALS VERY EDUCATIONAL.

[@carmelopascual9691]

The heart is the first to develop while the viewers slowly loses their heart while watching in amazement how they play with life...

[@scharlesscalvin]

12:26 Respiratory malfunction

[@jennyding6054]

Heyyyyy Su :)) great job with the video

[@robynalice879]

Su Kim !! My old high school has attempted this method due to your fascinating techniques! 😀 Greatest thanks for being so educational-- Nova Scotia commends you for teaching such young students how to at least make it half way to a successful hatch. 👏🙏❣

[@yeetusfetus5117]

There ia a video that the baby chicks actually survive