So Freaking Proud | ATEEZ - Turbulence MV | REACTION/REVIEW

[@Iix.d11]

mingi said that the song is about the pain of beginning, the anxiety and emptiness that we feel in real life, and the happy kind of pain that we can feel in our age i love mingi so much, hearing him convey his thoughts and feelings of when he went through a hard time makes my heart tremble, im proud of him for overcoming them and i just want him to be happy😭

[@sans6985]

did he write it?

[@leahshum970]

@@sans6985 he did write his verse in which he speaks of his own experience while on a break tho i don't know about the song as a whole

[@sans6985]

@@leahshum970 thanks!

[@springlyamir2652]

Omg really? This is soo heartbreaking😭 Even im not their fan but i love this song all by my heart ✨ this is their second song i like after aurora ❤️

[@kpopscenario1406]

Hiiiii

[@jerico6851]

they probably have tons of potential comeback title tracks in a vault somewhere

[@theresat988]

Lol for real every time one comes out I’m shook they’re a bunch of masterminds

[@jjongvbes5251]

NOT THE VAULT LMAO

[@justshuttfup6282]

(ATEEZ's Version) (From The Vault)

[@Lavenrius]

I mean, yeah! A good example is there's clips of them recording Answer while they were in their Wave/Illusion era

[@jo5206]

Ateez next comeback: From the vault 😍The beginning

[@secondcoolest]

This song is a masterpiece.

[@starseedgaon]

no bcs this song evokes so many emotions just from the fact that the opening melody was teased in fever pt 3, the references to fever pt 1 and the fucking wave melody at the end and of course what makes that especially emotional is the fact that they got their first win with that song. a big part of what makes ateez songs so heart tuggy for me is when a snippet is teased and they release it later. i remember when they teased answer at the end of the treasure ep fin album and it was literally just san singing his iconic part, without any music in the background. and then the teaser came months later and i immediately cried. i was a relatively new atiny at the time and had no idea they would do that. this song and answer definitely hold a special place in my heart which is unsurprising considering that both songs are the end of a series

[@unicorn_swag4331]

The references to the wave melody at the end is where I broke

[@starseedgaon]

@@unicorn_swag4331 for real, it's such an iconic and melodic part of that song and in wave it sounds happy and carefree but here it gives a nostalgic, bittersweet feeling

[@unicorn_swag4331]

@rbwkpop exactly! It brought me back to 2019 when It came out and the happy summertime. However it was very bittersweet because of the last two years and how things were simpler back then idk I'm emotional

[@gemmasmith1667]

Turbulence is joining the One Day At A Time and Mist duo of songs that make my cry on cue but also immediately went straight to the top of my favourite Ateez songs and favourite songs of all time.

[@Lavenrius]

It's joining Star 1117 for me 😅

[@NmixxKyujin29]

Not too late also

[@hakunamatataya]

All I can say that Wooyoung's favorite song is every ATINY's favorite song and it is Turbulence

[@dafnid7294]

Your username and prof pic is everything

[@sv402]

'Ateez make some of the most meaningful music', yes!! Tell the truth. I got so emotional seeing this song

[@manvi5234]

"I like this group" "i like that group" " wow! they're so good" But....... Ateez and their music is everything to me. ATEEZ!! STOP SLEEPING ON THEM STILL PEOPLE

[@potato_staytinyxelf2405]

Tbh I hope they don't become WAYYYY too popular... I mean look at BTS and stray kids.. (Their fandoms have become toxic due to the amount of popularity.. And BTS has kinda lost themselves in making a lot of English songs. Speaking as a ex army)

[@potato_staytinyxelf2405]

But don't mean I hate them.. It's just I can't look at them the same way b4 their popularity grew... I still respect them and no hate 💯💯✌

[@syedaasmafatima8731]

The fact that they continuously make music after every comeback... Like literally what is rest at this point? And the recent interview where Eden disclosed how they put 10000% thinking that it's gonna be their last comeback. I'm so proud of stanning them. And fact that this year was a so soooo exhausting for them. I really hope they take plenty of rest in 2022 after the tours.

[@leviberg2377]

I think Eden meant Edenary's last comeback, not ATEEZ's. Also, he said that to show how he thinks about every project, every project he makes it like it's the last one, with a lot of passion. That's what I got from it anyway.

[@RY-rw9ih]

@@leviberg2377 i think he means for both of them. because if ateez didn't achieve much from a comeback they might not hv the financial ability to continue dropping the next comeback. so both edenary and ateez hv this mindset of thinking that everytime that'll be their last cb so they always put out quality work and won't hv any regrets on any of them

[@leviberg2377]

@@RY-rw9ih Ahhh ok. Makes sense.

[@idkwat_toname]

This song literally gave me chills! I can't describe the emotions that they made me feel through this song... This song made me cry a river 😭😭😭 I'm proud to be an ATINY!! 💙💙

[@frcsc_iyah]

20:00 onwards WHAT THE ACTUAL HECK, I DIDN'T EVEN REALIZED THAT THE ENDING OF TURBULENCE IS THE FASTER TEMPO OF INTRO IN WAVE!!!! I LITERALLY GOT CHILLS, BECAUSE OF YOU CAITLIN I HAVE DISCOVERED SO MANY THEORIES IN ATEEZ AND I AM THANKFUL FOR THAT, REALLY. NOW I JUST NEED A WEEK SO I CAN CRY MY EYES OUT BECAUSE OF WHAT I HAVE DISCOVERED, THANK YOU.

[@zulfadlirosli]

SAME AND WAVE IS THE FIRST SONG I HEARD FROM ATEEZ! 🥺

[@eclyde4405]

I haven't finish the video yet, but I bet you'll cry listening to this. Cus gurl, I did LMAOOO! Update : Yes, she cried. AHAHHAHA!

[@rogerdgol8698]

The MV is even more sadder and has more meaning if we have watched Zero: Fever Part 1 Diary Film. I agree with you the Zero: Fever era is kinda ending on a bittersweet, the same way how the Treasure era ended. These boys are something else! And it sucks so much how they have been working this whole year non-stop (3 korean comebacks, 2 japanese comebacks, 3 song collabs, 1 project collab, Kingdom, Imitation and all the fun content they have given us) only for them to get one nomination at Mama for WWFC or just being not nominated at all in some award shows.

[@YoursTAngel]

Ikr! I wish they get more appreciation...they deserve it ❤️

[@rose0613]

i love hearing hongjoong singing 😩 and you're right they snapped with the vocals with this song 💙 thinking back to when i became an atiny (with say my name), i can really see how everyone just improved so much (even if they were already amazing), i feel like their skills got better but also their confidence in those skills ? if that makes sense haha

[@rose0613]

not sure why but every time i see/hear mingi i'm instantly in my feels haha he makes me so emotional x)

[@noeh6295]

the reason I always watch your reactions apart from the fact that you put so much effort in your videos, like the editing, the bg music, the graphics, is also because you take the time to really interpret and appreciate the song. from the vocals, to the performance, the production and the artists themselves. Thank you so much for your reaction to this song, it was very meaningful 💓

[@starrryowl]

This song is so emotional and I fall in love with it the more I listen to it 🥺 thank you for your reaction!

[@beomgyubearz5344]

this is the first kpop song EVER that keeps making me cry every time i watch/listen to it, thus why it’s a little hard for me to listen to this song. many of us can relate to these lyrics and the way they sang it, the way this was filmed, their acting. everything. i cant help but cry because i relate to these lyrics on such a personal level. it’s the most beautiful song, i’m broken. 🥲

[@erjinson]

i genuinely started weeping while listening to this because 1. the musicality is insane and the track itself is absolutely incredible and i love the little inserts of their old songs in between and 2. god the lyrics hit so close to home

[@manarf2442]

I'm just so glad to have experienced this comeback already as an atiny, bcs I feel like although this song and its lyrics would evoke emotions on anybody, being able to capture all the small references from their previous work it's it just adds to the nostalgic feeling of this song.

[@leggo5650]

If it weren't for you I wouldn't have realized that a new Ateez song had come out, thanks for your reaction, the song is amazing

[@pia__universe1024]

this is one of my favorite ATEEZ song EVER!!! THIS song hits so hard through my heart T-T

[@leahb1178]

SIS i lost it at the exact same part as you... Passion Young Fever. This song entered my ears, went straight to my heart, slapped it around a little bit, went to where my soul is supposed to be, GAVE ME A SOUL, and then leaked out my eyeballs and I'm still not okay

[@jamlessmee1751]

ateez never failed to amaze me. they always do something beyond my expectations and this song made me so emotional to the point that I can't stip crying while listening to their voices and absorbing the lyrics of the song.

[@Avi.joyyy12]

This song is so beautiful and the LYRICS!!!!!

[@rise1996]

I love that ATEEZ have always been proven to be great guys themselves from old school peers, so when they are constantly giving us tracks that make us feel understood and comforted (as well as the damn good hype tracks lol) it just hits different, you know they sincerely mean it ya know?

[@kimschmieder4552]

This is the only song this year that made me cry besides my ults ONEWE (because I cry for every of their songs) but turbulence really hit deep 😔

[@qraee]

ateez. just…ateez. I’m literally mindblown by them. This song is perfection

[@amaliafrhrf4294]

this song hit me hard. i watched it for the first time when i was having my lunch yesterday. and let me tell you i was crying really hard while munching my food, i’m not lying. i have been dealing with anxiety since this pandemic era started. i’m not used to being at home for too long. because i used to go to boarding school for 6 years, and being away for several months from my family is an opportunity for me to breathe. so when i had to stay at home for a very long time, it feels like i couldn’t breathe, my chest is crushed and i can’t even cry properly. this year has been really hard for me especially in college. tons of assignments, group assignments that burdens me so much because i’m the only one who work on it alone. i’m tired..

[@kitzerin1564]

This song, every time I hear it, I tear up, because there's just, there's so much here I relate to so hard.

[@jlynnie94]

I am just now seeing this reaction, but I have to say... THIS RIGHT HERE is just one of the reasons why you are my favorite reactor. I have been listening to k-pop for over 10 years, but I am discovering new music thanks to you. I'm familiar with ATEEZ because of Kingdom, but I haven't heard much of their music until I started watching your reactions to them and now I just LOVE them. Thank you for expanding my horizons!

[@yovitapc2942]

I want to surprise you more that they already tease this song in Illusion mv. If you listen carefully, at the end of the mv (the tease for wave) before 'open your eyes', you can hear someone say 'we have turbulence' in pilot voice when they took off :)

[@melissaumuhire7804]

WHATTTTTTT

[@pshphj45]

Omg whaaaat

[@yovitapc2942]

@@melissaumuhire7804 just play it and listen carefully 😁

[@yovitapc2942]

@@pshphj45 Play it again and listen carefully 😁

[@pshphj45]

@@yovitapc2942 i did and I'm SHOOK!

[@mari1058]

the papers flying around hongjoong are a reference to the diary film (3:00) when the objects float above him

[@BriBee1235]

You know you're an Atiny when you get up at 3 am to watch an MV lol. Seriously thank you SO MUCH for reacting to Ateez. Your reaction to Fireworks was on of the things that got me into and I am so grateful because I love them so much now! Keep doing what you do!

[@polly1472]

This was the quietest review I've ever seen Caity doing lol

[@caitlinbensonn]

Well it was 4am in the morning 😂

[@polly1472]

@@caitlinbensonn makes sense lol also could be the shock of how ateez SLAAAAAAAAYS. Love your reviews, keep going

[@melissamarshall4597]

Girl, I got the notification for the MV at 3 this morning. And I'm pretty sure I woke up my neighbors cause I was bawling my eyes out watching this! And you got this uploaded fast! Wasn't expecting it! Love all of your videos!! Keep working hard! Sending love from Louisiana! 👍💜💛

[@ceba_army819]

This song lets me feel so many things. I was enchanted and had tears running down my face while watching the MV. At the same time i really felt like my soul is flying. And the reference „passion, young, fever“ it threw me back to Fever. And that is my ATEEZ comfort song. I think Turbulence is my new ATEEZ favourite. It just has everything. The music, mv, lyrics and the voices. Just amazing 🥺🥰😭

[@melissa_7166]

This was the first time ATEEZ has made me genuinely cry. It's what I needed to really connect with them.

[@sv402]

THIS IS A PURE MASTERPIECE!! I'm so proud of them!!❤

[@stacey1136]

Turbulence had me in tears almost immediately. It's the kind of song that makes your heart ache. At the same time, it's one of those songs you need to hear to remind you that everyone experiences these emotions. ATEEZ never misses, no matter what they do.

[@Callmetainted_]

I just can't get enough of ATEEZ. they're so good I'm so FREAKING proud

[@marianella022]

We talked abt the fact that Jongho and San have harmonized during the high note

[@briansilver5062]

This is one of the most beautiful songs and music video ever. The production is on a whole different level and the lyrics are just omg I’m so proud of them

[@poypoy1894]

I'm crying with you sis

[@urfav509]

i didn’t even realize the end was from wave until you said it. that’s insane! ateez are literally some of the best artists in the game.

[@bbyetini4996]

8:07 actually ateez’s producer, Eden said that when an album is released the next day their team will discuss the next upcoming album for ateez. So I guess they do this for every comeback:0

[@kazza3282]

It's an hourglass but known as a cromer in Ateezland!

[@sell1784]

Welp. I cried. This song happened to drop on a day that I had been dreading having to get through for months. That morning, I was on KZbin trying to distract myself before heading out that morning and saw that the surprise thing Ateez was planning to release happened to be this song that I’ve been looking forward to since it was teased in ‘Deja Vu’ 😭 And it literally reassured me that things would be okay that day. The lyrics in this song absolutely took me away and when ‘Wave’ came in at the end I literally started sobbing, because even though ‘Wave’ is a very upbeat song, the lyrics have always hit me more emotionally. So to hear that song in THIS song just. Here they go again being there for us 🥺😭❤️ Thanks for taking the time to react and upload this one Caitlin, I know you’ve been so busy and spending lots of time and energy on the channel, especially lately with finishing up First Look season 2! We appreciate you! ❤️

[@lilliannaavery3960]

It's so rare for you to not pause even once during a reaction to talk about your thoughts, that's how I know this hit you hard. Me too, girl. Me too. Had to hold back those tears myself.

[@reyminramen]

After Deja Vu and Eternal Sunshine came out and I still had my heart set on 0X1 LOVESONG as my soty, Ateez decided to release Turbulence. Literally 3 months after their last comeback. It's almost as if they wanted me to choose them. Hongjoong, I want apologize for looking at other oppas, I will not make the same mistake again 😔 The only other kpop song that has ever made cry to the extent Turbulence did is Spring Day, so I mean, if thats not saying something...

[@unicorn_swag4331]

My 21st birthday is tomorrow and this song just made me feel all of the things I've been really pushing down and hiding. I'm so thankful for Ateez in my life

[@Virk92]

Happiest b'day Atiny :) stay happy and healthy

[@jessicabarrett3631]

I was literally JUST thinking about the way One Day At A Time made me feel, my first listen to that song..I was having a horrible week. It was perfect timing. And now with this song. My week has actually been normal, nothing too crazy, I did not think I was going to cry this morning but this whole MV and the entire song completely swept me right up into my emotions yet again. All the nods to past songs of the era like Inception (the classroom) and Wave (the melody at the end), really just made me emotional and remember when I was still a wee baby Atiny. The acting doesn't seem like acting at all and knowing their journey, that just touches my heart

[@MIMIEL99]

I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH EVERYTIME WHEN I LISTEN THIS SONG MY TEARS FALL PROFUSELY WHEN I HEAR IT 🥺🥺🥺🥺

[@rose0613]

I love this song, it's definitely going to be on repeat for the next days ! I can't wait to see how it will all ties in the album they're going to release on dec 10th !! thank you for this super faaaaast reaction 💙 love you x

[@ohlookmarki]

If you noticed, the ending of Turbulence is the beginning of their other song Wave

[@caitlinbensonn]

I did towards the end of the 2nd viewing where I broke everything down! ☺️

[@Barbay3]

It's the way I sobbed a lot while watching it the first time and sobbed again with you watching ur first viewing

[@myjoy5430]

Vocals! vocals,! ATEEZ excels when it comes to vocals, this is such a simple video but then the song and the lyrics hits it hard for me, I'm overhwelmed with such emotion that my tearss just fell after listening the 2nd time.........Only ATEEZ does this to me ........

[@astridliee]

Wait I think it’s the first time I don’t see you pausing on your first reaction on a M/V - The power Turbulence holds is amazing 👏🏼✨

[@lauraalbinacallejas5928]

esta canción me rompe el corazón y me lo vuelve a unir .... es increíble como puedes hacer sentir todas estas emociones con sus canciones y mas con las letras de ... ATEEZ I LOVE YOU

[@thatsnoticecreamitsabutter3461]

thank u for ur reaction!! 🤍 i'm so amazed by how u managed to catch so many things by just the second watch??? these lyrics really hit me especially hard this time round 😭😭

[@ruzenaprivett3161]

Love this reaction so much. You pointed out so many small things and really made me appreciate this masterpiece even more. I cry just about every time I watch this music video. It's so powerful. The first time I watched it I legit just lost it at Wooyoung taking off. We had seen the preview and thought that might be happening but when it really did I just... yeah. San singing his heart out in the phone booth also touched me. You could say he's a really good actor but anyone who has taken the time to get to know Ateez will know that's because he's not acting. I feel like I'll never be the same after seeing this but I'm not upset about it. Ateez is just so special.

[@lr6218]

Fact: This song is a Masterpiece and they are UNDERRATED!

[@tona2616]

20:08 was the moment you were done with everything 😂 loved it I really appreciate you breaking down some of the musical elements. I would miss some of these if it weren't for you! 🙌

[@marjaleena8289]

I was looking forward to your reaction, you always notice so many things that I struggle to see XD I love your ateez reactions always. I feel so safe watching your videos

[@lovefaith2230]

I feel you Ateez does that. 😭😭😭😭😭

[@eclyde4405]

I've been watching few other reaction videos and almost none of them catch that wave reference at the end of the song. BUT YOUUUU, YOU NEVER DISAPPOINT ME!! I LOVE YOUUUUU! LMAO

[@merryannamita1223]

Exactly my reaction when I first saw the MV

[@maisarahkasnoor8115]

i really appreciate your explanation about this song. I really dont know about their theory and so on but watching your reaction makes me understand and just woww. how clever you are

[@fisokuhlemkhize8077]

Bra u pay attention to detail it's mind blowing i didn't even realise that was from wave

[@sarasimao2508]

This was me after waking up and seeing that they uploaded this song. I feel you, I do, they have so many touching and relatable songs. I've always been a sucker for touching lyrics and good melodies, that's how I pick my music and Ateez has rapidly achieved a league on their own on my playlist.

[@jelder25]

Just happened to come across your channel and went down the rabbit hole of Ateez reactions (because homies literally snuck up and put me in a chokehold last year and I’ve been Atiny ever since). I love your energy and how your brain works! You point out things that I didn’t even realize and it’s like discovering the guys all over again. I love love love it! THE END OF TURBULENCE BEING THE SAME AS THE BEGINNING OF WAVE?!?!?! I yeeted myself across my bed because WHAT?!?! 🤯 I’m fighting air sis!!! Consider me subscribed and a fan 😫😮‍💨🥹💙

[@micahlazo8011]

I was ATINY by the time Fever Pt. 3 came out and I'm so happy for ATEEZ. I love how Rocky is like Win. And it felt like the best timing that I absolutely loved Mist and Take Me Home, right before Turbulence released. One Day at a Time is also so precious to me now So glad to be here Turbulence really hit me hard. Watched the teaser but I still wasn't prepared for how much it made my cry. So proud of Mingi especially. The ending was absolutely beautiful and emotional. Jongho high note we love every time he does it. I adore the back and forth of Yunho and Yeosang. When you talked about movement, isn't San in an elevator in that one scene? So that's up and down movements too. There's a certain kinda feeling seeing our captain Hongjoong all by himself on the bridge and when the lights lit up after the flying paper planes was *chef's kiss And the fact that the climax of the song is as Wooyoung is running to take off and fly is perfection

[@plushesetmefree15]

Everytime jongho's highnote and wy flies, it's so hard not to cry lol

[@eba.videos]

As I think about it more deeply, the fever era was all about them putting themselves "on fire" cuz it was such a diverse and brave era for them to burst themselves out in every single cb we got. Now ending this era with this song gives me chills a lot cuz it feels like they just kicked themselves out the door and crying out for a sense to be embraced as they evolve in their journey. I feel nothing more than proud and seeing their growth and them getting mature hits me on another level.

[@kokochen5754]

I'm not kidding when I say Turbulence made me stan

[@anch1117]

Welcome ♥️

[@whomstdve]

THANK YOu for noticing the fever reference and wave melody

[@CarmeloAlipayo]

I thought my tears would stop here.. Then I heard the next song on the album Be With You ohmygawd that killed me

[@unhppi]

yes! i relate to how their songs can break you, but also comfort you before the song is even over ^^ their songs are very healing!

[@samutzamenager5649]

The minute she said “wait a damn minute@ she sent chills down my spine coz we all know what she noticed 🤣🤣

[@eshakhan6238]

As always Caitlin this was another amazing reaction! Please do take care of yourself and do rest when you can! We appreciate you so much ❤️❤️

[@esterwootaegi2644]

the fever series is a prequel to everything, and turbulence theyre all separated and in wave is when they finally unite

[@shellbaeon]

I worship the ground Eden walks on at this point. This is 100% their best song quality and production-wise. It's so well done and so well written that I was shocked the first time listening to it. I'm shocked every comeback they do because they only keep getting better and better.

[@multi4831]

It's not over yet, they're going to drop another MV in December 10th!!

[@gladysboekhoudt4179]

Thank you for reacting, loved it! And I love Mingi too!!!!

[@parksanhwa8904]

Watching this again with someone, while dealing with the ongoing issues in atinyville right now, it hits so much harder when I hear ATEEZ sing "As if the world only wants me to fall" T_T

[@kristinabow323]

Ateez my favorite group, they just special to my heart 💙 Thank you for reaction)

[@emilym3416]

I love this comeback! This song is so powerful and meaningful to ATEEZ and ATINY. I’m extremely proud of them on how far they’ve come, and I’m excited for what they have yet to show us! ❤️

[@humbleandkindness5765]

I saw a comment on the MV that says this was the first time none of them were together, and thats why there wasn’t any choreo🥺🥺 they found joy again when they find each other later on😭

[@Ergolamia]

omg when you played the wave intro.. the chills i got!! and the tears!! omg 💕😭

[@mitchie_7551]

15:18 there’s a familiar scene like this in the fever part 1 diary film! u should definitely watch it !! it’s on youtube on KQ’s yt acc!

[@angelinagore5067]

These lyrics are so powerful. A message everyone needs right now. I cried. ❤️❤️❤️

[@winryrockbell9894]

I love SO much Fever, that b-sides it's so beautiful and they included it in Turbulence, this is my fav song this year!

[@tatyanamitchell1420]

I love your reactions, you always have me laughing with some of your facial expressions , but this song is so beautiful! I love being a Atinyy!

[@MariaJose-nb4wl]

Seonghwa said that it really makes him think about the past a lot when he was a trainee and felt alone and that he always get emotional when he listens to this song :((

[@SunflowerGal1]

GIRL!!! The part with the papers floating around and that intro - BAM! Wow I got chills!! :D

[@hongjoongarson2069]

also, fireworks, deja vu, and eternal sunshine involve both the city and the train!

[@jiaojwoo2329]

SIST I LIKE YOUR REACTION AND THE TIMING 😭😭👍👍👍

[@artinyedits1556]

Your reaction was so cute, and the way you found the details was so good☺Especially when you realize wave melody🤭🤭💓💖

[@sukanyaguha9234]

did you notice that the song ended with "Wave"? I was literally crying and screaming about it yesterday 😭😭

[@caitlinbensonn]

Yes I noticed towards the end of the 2nd viewing when I broke everything down 🥺😭☺️

[@Adonisfactor20]

Your emotion is so captivating. I can tell how true your reaction is, since It impact me in the same way.