SOLVED: The Lin Family Murders

Go to casetify.com/bella today to get 20% off your new favourite phone case!
earrings are by @hungrylaalaa
Instagram:@isabella_fiori
Twitter: @IsabellaLFiori
Spotify: goo.gl/PjzzPq
Contact: [e-mail]
PO BOX 642
MORNINGSIDE, QLD, 4170
AUSTRALIA

[@RaeaXo]

I hope that operator got fired. That’s disgusting to treat someone like that

[@novasummer7976]

i hope so too, if anyone has info on that let us know

[@novasummer7976]

wowzer hold up.... who mentioned racism?? Tf

[@kimberlyortiiz]

wowzer being rude to someone who lost their family isn’t the same as racism.

[@jasmine3288]

wowzer uhm...maybe by telling the woman to stop screaming and telling her to stop telling the police to come... even Bella said it’s rude.

[@emmelinesb4698]

@@clubsnatcher he was impatient and curt with a woman clearly in shock.

[@user-xk9dq3xp9k]

It’s shocking how so many police operators are so rude and uncooperative to people who are in shock and are traumatised... literally so many calls like this one

[@noodlesauce2553]

I know! Somebody just went through something shocking and traumatic, have some fkng patience dude😠

[@imguilty6688]

You should see Susan Powell's case the operator, are worst than this case

[@victoriaj9462]

Brooo the way he was speaking to her was so fucking rude

[@nicolemeneses3323]

Yes! That infuriated me, if you cant treat scared people with respect and calm them down, FIND ANOTHER JOB

[@akayriirose651]

He was so damn rude

[@theglamdude1459]

The officer that took her call literally made me so angry. I get he has a job but that woman was distraught and the way he talked to her made me feel so helpless omg 😢😢

[@zoerassati1943]

I agree he had such an attitude, I get he was trying to information, but he was so disrespectful, she was traumatized and had every right to stumble on words or being distraught

[@babycow9994]

wowzer no❤️

[@imaan9246]

@@clubsnatcher Get lost. He was being rude

[@imaan9246]

@@clubsnatcher "We are driving there. Don't say quick" when she asks police to come quickly. This devasted woman who has discovered, at that point, four dead bodies. She has witnessed gruesome scenes and she is obviously beside herself. He did not attempt to calm her or console her or speak NICELY at all. He was a rude git and for what. I understand he needs to know what happened but there's a way to talk to people and I'm sure as an emergency line operator, he's been taught what to say and how to say it

[@reaganmorris2154]

wowzer he was so rude good lord not a single bit of reassurance in his tone at all.

[@laurakatharina5010]

As soon as she said that Robert usually sleeps in late but was awake that morning cleaning his garage he was my prime suspect.

[@samorachannel2093]

An then the fact that he straight away stated he would Adopt Brenda..

[@wahdae7655]

the fact that people are capable of these things is just mind blowing to me. i can’t believe he really bludgeoned them w. a hammer ... it’s just all sick.

[@callmewaves1160]

Truly is. His own family. Over jealousy.

[@MadMaddi21]

Yup, and not even just one of them in a spur of the moment decision. It was calculated, he shut off the power, pre bought a weapon where there were no cameras, killed them all 1 by 1, even the children. Makes me feel so sick and sad

[@mayabracamontes6904]

especially the boys they were so young and had a long way to live. such a tragic story :( 💔

[@anu480]

I absolutely CAN NOT believe that Cathy stood by her husband when he killed her own brother, sister, sister in law and nephews. Like woman ? What? Seriously ?

[@emilychavez8674]

Not to mention the sexual assault of her niece.. makes my blood boil

[@caroverse3508]

and didn’t he kick her own parents out of their house that was given to them by their son. Wow, just wow. Absolutely sickening

[@lal530]

its very likely that cathy has been under his husbands abuse for years now. when your in it its very hard to realise what the abuser is doing to you and ure usually scared to even attempt getting out of it. imagine your sexual predator and killer of a husband having full control over your life and threatening your life if you dont follow along with him :( im not defending cathy defending the murderer but we rly should consider every scenario in these cases :((

[@amarfakhredine591]

I feel like she has something to do with it.. I don't know but what kind of people is she??

[@amarfakhredine591]

@@lajebenjamin8492 omg that makes a lot of sense!

[@dulapeep420]

I feel so bad for Brenda. She was sexually assaulted by the person who killed her entire family and she had to live with that same person while she was mourning the loss of her beloved family. I really can't imagine dealing with sth like that. I really hope she's doing okay and is somewhere safe.

[@catb0ykyo]

i know :( what she went through was horrifying

[@chrissy3875]

yeah, I hope she’s doing well 🥺🥺

[@SophieKaye1]

and the fact that her aunt never took her side afterwords and backed her husband in saying he wasn't guilty...even though she knew he'd asaulted Brenda :(

[@pixiehopper8]

I know! It’s so sad and sick. I feel horrible for her.

[@sindu3]

@@starr2870 don’t want to assume but she looks like she’s doing well. Curious as to why she doesn’t have a single family pic up though

[@hemanshikumar2179]

I know Brenda through mutuals as she went to a school near me. This story is horrifying. She is doing well and has started her new life years ago. She has a beautiful dog and graduated 2 or so years ago. She is so so strong.

[@freya1710]

wow really? has she got a boyfriend or kids??

[@hemanshikumar2179]

@@freya1710 Not sure, but i hope she is doing okay. I haven't seen her updates on any of her socials.

[@freya1710]

@@hemanshikumar2179 okay thanks

[@000S1-d3h]

Hemanshi Kumar aww hope she’s doing good 🥺💕

[@melanieresutek1403]

I am so happy to hear that she graduated despite everything she went through! You are right she is strong! Thank you for letting us know!

[@Mclovin123878]

Spoiler: I knew it was Robert as soon as she said he left his wife at the scene.. smh.

[@heatherbrookesanchez2046]

Right!! I just knew it!

[@virn4699]

I knew as soon as she said his restaurant failed.

[@jennacampbell7759]

When I heard that he was jealous of his brothers success , failed at his own work , lived so close and that he was up unusually early, I was like: that’s him. Robert fuckin killed them.

[@Katie-pb1iq]

I knew when Bella said it was most likely a close family member and the shoe size.

[@duminimahanama5066]

When she said he used to be an ENT in China. Usually a sense of very low self esteem overwhelms you when you suddenly lose your status.

[@abaig3855]

As a person from an immigrant family, the way he treats Kathy is not shocking, its normal. They always treat people with accents like that. This time it jus got recorded

[@aztre]

A Baig - Fucking racists. That’s so disgusting.

[@annnguyen3960]

A Baig they talk to us like a frustrated two year old

[@tomiefilms]

Violeta D that’s true! but smth white/white passing people don’t face is being immediately spoken to like a toddler in a condescending tone purely based off appearing ‘ethnic’ or ‘oriental’

[@lisagentry2210]

I have always tried to be extra sensitive to people with English as a 2nd language. Some people just suck. Fuck racists

[@michellep1555]

racistm is everywhere unfortunately. even if you have a perfect accent, but once they know you are not white that is when they treat u differently.

[@AlexandraNavarro]

I feel so bad for Brenda, she lived with the person who killed her family and she didn’t even know :(

[@shaydouglas]

AND he molested her and she felt she couldn't do anything. Poor child.

[@AlexandraNavarro]

Cheyenne Douglas yeah i feel so bad :(

[@pixiehopper8]

Oh I know! Right when she said that he adopted her, I thought, “oh hell no!” Totally gave me chills.

[@PoopeecacaValerota]

I SHOULDN'T HAVE LOOKED IN THE COMMENTS

[@starr2870]

i just saw her instagram and shes doing so well now :))

[@Hanniekinz]

It was definitely a mistake having Brenda move into Robert’s home so quickly. And when they started to suspect him as being involved, the police didn’t take Brenda out of the house right away, they set up cameras. Wtf so much trauma could have been prevented...

[@saharmahmud5214]

I agree!!!! Such a careless move on the detectives part

[@alejandrab1989]

They legit used her ...poor child she must have been traumatized

[@2scorpionzzz182]

Are they vaccum cleanears ? 😂

[@time2livelife]

Yeah, they definitely should not have let her stay with him while he was a suspect. Could have prevented so much sexual abuse.

[@michellep1555]

if they set up cameras, don't they have evidence of her sexual assault, shouldn't they also charge that too or at least let the inmate knows so he can get proper punishment inside

[@ashleyheart123]

the real mystery: how her earrings went from vacuum cleaners to lamps

[@wynona7372]

3:01 in case anyone is wondering where they change 😂😭

[@taraoldham3155]

Ashley Lamborghini yes I am glad I am not the only one to notice that

[@IW21]

Yeah i was thinking the same

[@natylights2394]

LOL!!!!!

[@marissathomas9327]

Right i was watching in the beginning. Then started cleaning and just listening to the video I turned around and she got another set on . I said I know damn well im not tripping lol

[@sm1i1thy47]

She obviously can’t see her brother if she’s saying “I’m not sure” 😤🤷‍♂️ frustrating stuff.

[@luciedonze7368]

Or can't identify him, so probably a pretty shocking scene is going on

[@MadMaddi21]

Yeah I mean, if I walked in on a scene like that, I wouldn't be poking around every single room to make sure every body was there, one look would have been enough to make my stomach turn. I think "I don't know" is a very fair response to have, like considering she saw the rest of the family she can probably assume that he would have been dead there too, but because she didnt see him she said idk. That operator was so rude. Like I get that "idk" is a vague response, but he could have gotten the information he wanted with a better question rather than just repeating the same one and being rude about not getting a yes or no answer. Like ask instead, "did you see his body?", that way she could say no, but it would still leave the possibility that his body was there and she just didnt see it

[@MsPuckerupButtercup]

@@MadMaddi21 I agree. At first I was confused by the “I’m not sure” but it totally makes sense she obviously is in no condition to go and examine all the bodies to identify if he is there. Poor woman. I just wish she had not defended her husband so much but in case he was freed she probably didn’t want him to go after her for not supporting him %100. Idk.

[@udontunderstandthebeautyof4033]

From what I’ve heard u couldn’t even recognise them that’s how bad it was. The operator didn’t even let that girl breath.

[@aromaladyellie]

I think it kind of speaks to the goriness of the scene that she wasn't sure.

[@iCOOLIE]

My partner was in jail for a few years, and his cell mate was originally cellmates with Robert Xie for a while, and apparently he still maintains his innocence and convinced Cathy that he was wrongly convicted. Deserves to be locked up forever since he shows absolutely no remorse.

[@이하나-m2h]

Omg!

[@chowfurnowmeow]

Good. But then again if he gets out the immigration would have sent his ass bk to China anyway.

[@nejonmcbride-stubbs2218]

Honestly, he has 5 life counts. He’ll be in there for awhile, go ahead and just admit it

[@anjo2672]

ngl, the operator seemed very racist t me. he could clearly tell she was of an asian background cause of her accent and so there is a language barrier. there's a certain way racists talk to people who don't have the best English; in a very condescending and patronising manner. then there's the addition of him just being rude all together cause she's clearly in shock.

[@SapphireCookie]

i know exactly what you mean and i totally agree with you

[@ju-qw8nd]

@@b.5795 it was literally just an opinion and the vibe that the original commenter picked up. Personally, I also picked up that energy from the operator. He wasn't taking her very seriously and was very hostile to her despite the clear state of shock/trauma. There is definitely a specific way that racists talk or interact with people which feels degrading. His tone was exactly the same tone that I hear when direct racist attacks/comments are made.

[@zeinabadam958]

I defo agree that's why so many of us who can put on a "white voice" just standard English basically

[@zeinabadam958]

Summer Brooks you don't understand our various experiences of racism so just listen instead of being bitchy and judgemental, listen, understand that's it. If we say it might be true it probably is. You'll never know that's privilege

[@maddyschaper4536]

I thought the same thing because of the way he was being so patronising! I can't see any other reason why he would be so rude to someone in distress.

[@inken2113]

I really hope the operator was fired immediately, this call made me sooo angry.

[@CoralBlueNmbrFive]

Excuse me? Excuse ME?? FOUR TRIALS AND EVENTUALLY A BAIL? This is disgusting. The fact that he killed his own FAMILY is disgusting. I am so sad for the Lin family. They seemed like they were really good people.

[@amya5369]

I went to primary school with them and they really were so lovely and sweet to everyone. It made my blood boil that justice wasn’t being served and we were all so sad and frustrated. We were just relieved when it finally was.

[@lilybrown5388]

It's better they go through 4 trials and successfully convict him. If they don't follow all rules and procedures he might be acquitted on a technicality

[@ethanqian8492]

he was sentenced to 5 life sentences at the end, bail means that you're released until your next trial date not that you get off scot-free.

[@kattttt9585]

Ethan Qian yeah but it stills means he was released for a time where he could possibly sexually assault brenda again

[@lila7735]

@@amya5369 i went too the same primary school as you then!

[@MysteryAvalanche]

Poor Brenda! Why the hell was the murder all over social media before the police got in contact with her? That's so beyond horrible.

[@mollyfoxxx]

God, he did not just say “don’t say quick” after she said please come quick😡

[@MissBelle127]

I hope he is fired because I’d sue him for unnecessary emotional trauma and unprofessionalism!!!

[@ayybibi]

MissBelle127 he was fired i believe, rightfully so.

[@cecilewong5765]

Shame on him.

[@atesah]

Racist Aussie white dude. We have too many here, the way he spoke to here was so familiar to me as Filipino Australian

[@leensalocin]

Racist Australians. What do u expect

[@ziefra555]

„Someone killed my entire family!“ „Why would you think that?“ Why would you ask that? Is this a normal dispatcher‘s response on something like that?

[@ziefra555]

Ga Xx What kind of person would joke about it?

[@ziefra555]

A B Sorry, we might see that differently because of different cultures. English is not my first language, so that could explain why that phrasing irritates me...

[@theelolicious9302]

@@ziefra555 it irritates me too and English is my main language. I was very frustrated by that man.

[@ayybibi]

Jang Xx i- no, even if it was “fake” you still remain professional. he shouldn’t be in a job like that if that’s the case.

[@ayybibi]

Jang Xx not even just professional but EMPATHETIC atleast.

[@caramonoxide4026]

that operator was SO RUDE like isn’t the whole point of the job being able to extract information out of someone in shock?? not just be nasty to them when they’ve found their family dead

[@MissBelle127]

Exactly, it makes me sick how impatient and rude he was. She literally just saw 4 family members in such a horrific and violently murdered!! It’s so disappointing! I hope he was fired from his job bc he was not taking her seriously and was very condescending

[@ms.dreavus2446]

I have never had such a visceral reaction to an emergency call, oh my gosh. My whole face got hot with anger. That was truly atrocious. As someone who has had to call 9-1-1 before, I would have been absolutely horrified if the operator responded to my situation in that way. I was already traumatized and shaking and upset. I'm so glad there was someone kind and empathetic on the other end.

[@rachelw9462]

Yes! Agree completely. I’m reading these comments hoping to see someone posted an update that he had been fired.

[@MissBelle127]

CaseyandRachel house W thank god!! What a piece of shit. So unprofessional and terribly condescending!!

[@saraa1741]

@@rachelw9462 yes, someone posted an update. If I find it I'll link it. He was indeed fired.

[@luckylucifer]

We don’t ring 911 here in Australia we ring 000

[@vergodagoat]

As someone who’s parent had a heavy japanese accent, that was absolutely aggravating when that operator was asking her stupid questions when she was clearly in shock and scared. “Is there a body” isn’t the most important question when there’s clearly no one left alive in the house

[@atesah]

ikr my mum's Filipina and I feel the same

[@bulgogibongs]

Me too, my mother has a strong Korean accent and it enraged me simply. The amount of times she’s been yelled at and told to “go back” just because of her accent, history, and birth place.

[@nicksmith3746]

Nah, the operator was trying to ascertain a situation, and she didn't make sense. It was made worse though because at that time she couldn't see her brother's body.

[@min.h1142]

How could the police operator keep yelling "YES OR NO" at a traumatized perosn

[@andreaarchaeology]

I had to skip the emergency call cuz as soon as I heard that operator's tone, I was so upset. How DARE you talk like that to someone who just found their family murdered. 🤬🤬🤬🤬

[@taylorlivengood341]

I love my nieces and nephews like they’re my own children & I could never in a million years hurt them, so seeing a man who viciously murdered BOTH of his nephews just to sexually abuse his niece makes me sick. What a heartless, heartless man & his wife is just as bad for lying for him.

[@taylorlivengood341]

Kmartgirl26 that really doesn’t matter. My husband’s brother has a little boy & I’m not his bio aunt, but I still love him just as much as my sisters kids. He still murdered his nephews and abused his niece, bio or not.

[@karinatt]

This is absolutely terrible.... while I do feel super super awful for Brenda and can’t even FATHOM what she’s gone through, one of her little brothers put up a struggle before he was killed and this really hit me so hard like damn.

[@ayybibi]

Haniyya Ejaz social media doesn’t tell you everything, im sure there’s a lot of trauma there.

[@user-kq2hn3zo4f]

“Don’t say quick” ughhh the audacity of that operator!! Disgusting attitude

[@nimrodgrrrl]

I’m sorry- but the risk assessment? saying that he poses no threat to her? Imagine the psychological trauma of living with the person who butchered your entire family. That’s insane!

[@jesss4234]

Bella I HIGHLY RECOMMEND looking into the West Memphis 3 case that happened in Arkansas in 1993. I don’t want to spoil what happened but it is really interesting and technically unsolved. I’ve been looking into it a lot, the case is about the murder of three 8 year old boys and it is so frustrating!! Love your videos!❤️

[@constanzacabello7241]

OMG yesss i've been investigating about the case as well!!

[@jesss4234]

Cons Cabello IKR?! It’s so crazy!

[@angiescott9692]

I remember when this went down, the Satanic Panic here in America at the time was rediculous. Evangelicals are killing America and its freedoms

[@jesss4234]

Angie Scott totally agree! The case is so unbelievable!

[@kenziiefaith]

i’m from arkansas! about 45 minutes from where this happened. i’ve always been so curious about what really happened!

[@ariannavillarreal810]

I love her vacuum earrings they are so cute Love how she had vacuum earrings on then changed them to lamps

[@elliesharp401]

That call taker is very unsympathetic and rude. He could be more compassionate, she’s clearly distressed. He definitely went the wrong way about it!

[@patriciap.5587]

~*°Spoiler°*~ the moment I heard that robert had a failed business and min had this successful business I knew that that he was the killer

[@danielleowens6443]

Jealousy kills are becoming too reoccurring. People are sick.

[@pickles4742]

Instantly I thought the same and then as SOON as i heard he left his distraught wife at the scene i was 100% certain

[@MissNatssySunshine]

Yes this and the photos shown of them! Definitely looked like outside of court photos which wouldn’t have been taken of them unless he had something to do with it

[@goku9791]

Honey Wilson same!!! i was like??? why would you leave your wife at the murder scene alone balling her eyes out?? and to get her parents? you couldn’t have called?? knew it was fishy

[@5h3lby52]

dude can you like,,,, put a spoiler warning please

[@mariaj2756]

As soon as she started talking about the way Robert left his wife so easily after seeing what they did I instantly got the feeling that it was him. literally so disgusting how could someone do that to a family.

[@karenskinner9529]

Extreme jealousy & a vile person

[@d_rami444]

I can't imagine someone belittling me after finding out my brothers family has been brutally murdered. I hope whoever that operator was realized how messed up that was

[@caro8463]

I literally don't understand how he felt "he was an embarrassment for them" so he thought killing the whole family would make it better 😐👀 liiiiike.... really??????

[@time2livelife]

Unfortunately, you can’t apply logic to crazy people.

[@chowfurnowmeow]

Na. It's just an excuse for him to say that. Obviously a sh*tty one.

[@ishitasharma4000]

Can we just take a moment to appreciate Bella’s earrings?😌

[@adrianalonso7357]

she never fails to pop off

[@Faith-pb8rw]

I know right, their always so interesting 😂

[@joyboy4]

She has the most iconic earrings

[@cb8199]

Lmao😂

[@grneyez2005]

What the heck are they? Looks like vacuum cleaners😃

[@shaydouglas]

Poor poor Brenda, I can't imagine the horror of what she went through. Her uncle is a creep and I feel so sorry for her

[@youboring4219]

I swear the emergency operator is racist or something. He should have lost his job. It’s not some customer service line it’s an EMERGENCY LINE

[@kelceebreanne4807]

PERIOD.

[@lisad5177]

It was so frustrating to listen to

[@rhyan19]

I saw another comment saying he was fired but I’m not sure how true that is

[@aromaladyellie]

Customer service lines have more manners than this.

[@SelBsful]

I believe the main reason was jealousy. His brother-in-law had everything he always wanted wich was success. The whole family moved to another country but only Min succeded. His frustration and jealousy drove him mad. I feel terrible for Brenda she even had to live with her family's murderer who was also a sexual abuser.

[@audreyc8225]

Rumor said that Kathy was actually aiming for the property of Min’s agency. And also he wanted Brenda. Or else, he could’ve just go back to China to become successful.

[@nicksmith3746]

A jealous person is always dangerous

[@amberreid1059]

Brenda saying she didn’t reveal the info on the assaults because she thought Robert was innocent of the murders...I’m so sad. Was she thinking it would bring more negative attention to him? Was she groomed in some way? There are so many ways to break that little bit down.

[@TB-jg2oq]

I’m surprised she stood by him even after Brenda shared what he did.

[@MissBelle127]

She looks like she is scared of him tbh

[@karenskinner9529]

In denial

[@chowfurnowmeow]

It depends. I am thinking that she is either financially tied up so had no choice to pretend to be on his side. Or she hasn't got her PR or Australian Citizenship - yet - being his wife (since it's the husband getting citizenship through his brother) she can have that chance, she might be sent bk to China if she divorces him w/o citizenship status.

[@mingramagoti2409]

@@chowfurnowmeow but she was Min's sister he was the one that was the brother in law🤔

[@leahryd8309]

I think Cathys husband maybe forced her to stand by him. He could have threatened her to stick with him or she would be killed as well.

[@MissBelle127]

I think so too

[@jillianjansson4098]

also when you are abused it look so different. you think she would of wised up but it is not that easy when you are being emotionally manipulated and possibly mentally and physically abused.

[@karenskinner9529]

Yes I think she's completely and utterly in denial

[@RascalHooligan]

Wtf lol they really thought to themselves "ionno if hes the murderer yet, but theres like a 90% chance he wont kill Brenda, so ya, lets just stick'er there for now. See how that goes." Jesus.

[@time2livelife]

Agreed, but it’s possible they thought that moving Brenda would aggravate him and cause him to kill more family members.

[@RascalHooligan]

@@time2livelife more family members? They were all already dead, no?

[@time2livelife]

@@RascalHooligan the grandparents were still alive

[@RascalHooligan]

@@time2livelife sorry its been awhile and i dont remember any details. It just seems like an odd sense of rationale, to risk a childs life so directly for a more indirect reason of trying to save the grandparents? Wouldve made more sense to just keep Brenda away and to protect them all with police officers.

[@time2livelife]

@@RascalHooligan Agreed

[@saram7358]

The second I heard he left Cathy alone after finding the bodies I had such a bad feeling about him

[@jhasmines1208]

As soon as you said his restaurant failed I automatically suspected Robert. In comparison to Min he jus seemed like a failure, so I thought it could be possible and would you look at it it was a possible motive. Even tho they are family jealousy can really make people switch up on you which is really disgusting and a sad reality. I also feel like Cathy was manipulated in some way which is why she defended Robert but it could’ve also been done out of love who knows. Great video tho!!

[@ferishak17]

11 minutes in...the killer has to be Robert . How can you leave your wife in the house where her entire family was just murdered? Couldn’t he have called the parents?

[@julieng794]

right! like why would his first thought was to bring the old folks to the murder scene. Sick.

[@bobdabuilder7650]

Tbh I thought it was the person that lost the badminton match until she said about the shoe prints guy like they have to know the family, they know Brenda is away, AND is very likely to be a tall man and from the photos he looks tall

[@hannahr4007]

I literally cannot BELIEVE the nerve of the 000 operator. "Don't say quick" - are you kidding me?! Imagine being panicked and begging 000 to come quickly to help and being told this!! I hope the operator lost his job or at the bare minimum was incredibly reprimanded. So disgusting and not something you can just blame on being frustrated or "having a long day". You are in a profession dedicated to directly assisting people in their most vulnerable moments of panic.

[@juliacatone9038]

That wedding photo is gorgeous what a hard working beautiful family :(

[@cindynguyen8982]

a lot of robert’s off guard photos shows him staring straight into the camera and it just creeped me out... boy what jealousy could do to a person. pure evil

[@vanessavaldez28]

This is just devastating! the two little ones, breaks my heart 😓

[@angiescott9692]

That operator should have been fired and maybe even fined. What a nasty human being. He was obviously racist against her, he knew she was an immigrant. Shame on him.

[@b.5795]

Literally what proof do you have that he was racist? He was rude but there was no indication of racism?

[@ella-gl3gi]

Summer Brooks he could probably tell she was of asian background. he talked in a very patronising way towards her, as if she was a child and didn’t understand. it’s more common than you think especially toward ppl of asian descent and in aussie

[@angiescott9692]

@@ella-gl3gi truth

[@angiescott9692]

@@b.5795 she clearly did not have an Australian accent, he 100% knew she was Asian and had zero empathy for her. Please dont be so naive

[@b.5795]

ella but my point is how do you know he doesn’t talk to everyone like that? You’re the one pointing out that she’s Asian and saying he’s being rude because of her race so how does that make you any better? I still stand by my point, you can’t just *assume* someone is racist without proof, you add to the problem when you do that.

[@elletristan]

The fact he evicted the grandparents, which forced Brenda to live with him sends the worst shivers down my spine. That’s so creepy and disgusting

[@emmadionne264]

I watch true crime frequently and for some reason this one hits rly hard. Im crying this seemed like such a happy family. They deserved the best

[@karenskinner9529]

Yes it was absolutely disgraceful

[@DemiDonnelly]

Them earrings! Wow I love them. Can’t wait for this video

[@IANONYMOUSLYI]

So the most intriguing thing you heard or saw in the video was earrings 🤖☠️

[@jordangraybill1374]

@Augustine isn’t that not what they are

[@cheyennetamou182]

Omg it's Henry!!

[@TheGrandy123]

I totally agree the operator was insensitive and rude 😡 what a shame!!!

[@dimik7488]

What a complete and utter dick! No compassion whatsoever.

[@oliviawilliams-ur3ju]

You should talk about the April Jones case it happened in Wales and it’s completely heartbreaking. I remember watching it on the news when I was like 7 it was just so sad.

[@deannacampillo798]

Just a curious question - why do they wear those old-fashioned wigs in Australian courts?

[@abbiejones262]

Doesn’t make much sense, but they wear them in the UK too and it’s supposed to make the judge or lawyers more ‘anonymous’ and distance the personal involvement. Very weird but just another old bizarre tradition 🤣

[@shreyanand9368]

Not sure about NSW but in Victoria, there has been reform in the supreme court (?) that wigs would be abolished in order to allow for the parties to feel comfortable while in court pursuing their case.

[@thanyachavez6300]

They look like sheep 🐑 😂

[@이하나-m2h]

I just scrolled over your comment when i saw the picture haha

[@ommmeke4797]

이하나 same

[@s3nfl0wer11]

The 911 operator was literally so insensitive and it made me so mad like if I found my whole entire family dead of course I would be screaming I wouldn’t even be able to form a sentence.

[@AR-sv2fz]

One of the pictures you showed had a caption saying that Robert said to Kathy "don't look" before entering the crime scene!! That is insane to me!! How would he know to say that if he weren't guilty? It's undeniable.

[@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE]

This one was shocking. And the wife not believing is so frustrating 😵

[@daniwarr]

I love watching these but after I’m scared for my life👁👄👁

[@aryyy4136]

Legit i'm so stupid when i watch just before going to sleep. Dont do it😂

[@mdz7229]

So did i can’t go to sleep 😟

[@annabelvillarreal2322]

Yea... it’s 3:50am in Texas and I just woke up by accident and I’m not going back to sleep

[@carolbaskin1857]

Same

[@jacqueline4203]

This story is incredibly tragic and heartbreaking. Such a beautiful family. May the Lin family Rest In Peace ❤️

[@TootieFruutie]

this video should be retitled: Robert applying for bail but getting denied for 33 minutes and 35 seconds

[@Michellecrossan]

HENRY HOOVER EARRINGS?!!!! Legendary❤️🤣

[@Faith-pb8rw]

That call is so- ugg! That operator needs to be fired honestly 😐

[@mads4449]

Your earnings girl 😂 I didn’t realise what they were at first I was like cuuuuuute....oh.....but still cuuuute 😂

[@ristixli]

It's little vacuums right? Lol

[@shanr0berts0n]

Brittany Rodrigues Henry hoovers!!!

[@ristixli]

Now they are little lamps lol

[@helloiamtiredallthetime.631]

Brittany Rodrigues I- I thought it was like a watering pot and there was water coming out of it

[@ayybibi]

Hello! I am tired does sound like smth bella would still wear tho

[@10103e]

this happened when I was in primary school... the kids went to my school and lived in my suburb... this was such a hard time for everyone around our town and especially their close friends. seeing this video pop up brought back very unpleasant memories... bless them, they really were amazing people.

[@jadeantoine4239]

bruh the racism in that operating call. 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@jodifoster9820]

Y’all think anything is racist

[@ayybibi]

Mya Holmes it literally is, there’s a certain tone that racists use against poc or immigrants. onviously you would know nothing about it so (:

[@jodifoster9820]

taz bibi lmfaoo a “certain” tone, explain the tone

[@mia-lo3zj]

Kmartgirl26 lol she never said white people cant be immigrants. She said, "against poc OR immigrants.”

[@jodifoster9820]

@Anjali Thapa Magar no y’all just sensitive

[@sophiaamezcua3525]

I feel terrible for Brenda she went a trip that was supposed to be enjoyable and she comes home and her parents aunty and two baby brothers were murdered I can’t imaging what she went through

[@bea-xq3uu]

as soon as you mentioned robert and showed his picture i knew it was him...

[@amarfakhredine591]

Same

[@oonaghomalley9052]

that emergency call is an absolute disgrace. the whole job description is to handle and take care of traumatised people and victims and if you can't do that then you shouldn't be in that job.

[@nikitakaay4518]

This happened just a suburb over from me, and I’d been in that news agency more times than I can remember. I still get chills thinking about the whole case now. Absolutely devastating

[@madig9152]

I can't imagine the hatred that brenda probably feels for her Uncle!!! What a sick man!!

[@emilyfrancis8243]

There could be an entire series on 911 calls that could make your blood boil, it's so awful how many I've heard.

[@gizemerkan90]

Dude Imagine someone moving into that House... I could never ever after knowing this.

[@leensalocin]

Right…

[@chelseebarber894]

I sure hope the dispatcher was immediately fired. I understand he was trying to get her answer important questions she wasn’t giving a proper answer to, but he handled it very unprofessionally.

[@sabrinamcgrath9641]

Dude...the instant you said that Robert was (basically) a failure in comparison to Min and that Robert had been "cleaning" the garage in the early hours of the morning after the murder, I KNEW that he did it.

[@amberm1841]

Was literally just watching old Bella vids and this one popped up

[@LisaBabe85]

I can't believe how rude that operator was!!!

[@DemiDonnelly]

Oh my god the earrings changed I died

[@Wynter_Heat]

OMG ME TOOOO!! I saw your comment and thought you were trippin. So I apologize lol. ::faints::

[@misswinters9239]

This absolutely breaks my heart, it’s hard for even me to watch. Absolutely sickening, may the family Rest In Peace and Brenda live her best life with all the support she needs

[@sam18.]

The phone call made me so unbelievably upset. :( I feel so awful for the girl.

[@emelincruz4516]

I thought the fact that he was all ready to adopt Brenda just like that was suspicious already. I don’t know how someone can do this to a family.

[@stevenjames3455]

*advertises phone cases* “ok so let’s go ahead and get into today’s case” she did that on purpose x x

[@vivitrumanto]

After finished watching this, I feel so grateful that I had a really good childhood, despite some ups and downs in my family, but definitely not something horrible like this. I also did not know what kind of person I would become if I had to go through such a painful and horrifying experience like her. I just wanna say how brave she is and her case would always remind me to be grateful and to be a kind person. I would like to give her a big hug!

[@luce9470]

I understand that dispatchers have a hard job but that is no excuse for being a revolting prick especially towards someone who is clearly traumatised and frazzled.

[@Zenithanderson]

When Bella said that He automatically wanted to adopt Brenda I just felt like it was foreshadowing something

[@cassidysoller]

the first responder that answered the calll should be fired. he's fired.

[@missylizt]

I met Brenda at uni a few years ago. She is such a strong and brave girl 💕

[@blackiemwe1481]

Why do people do this?? Pretend to know the surviors.

[@muls9571]

@@blackiemwe1481 why do you think she's pretending to know her?

[@natashawebb8153]

Robert was a successful ENT so he decided to try and open up a restaurant

[@callmewaves1160]

This is my thoughts exactly! Why wouldn't he try for a specialist centre or hospital?? He set himself up for disaster.

[@mhastings6578]

@@callmewaves1160 I don't think his qualifications from China allow him to work as a doctor in Australia.

[@Lisasanti1]

@@mhastings6578You’re right, they don’t.

[@kottonkandy0962]

​@@mhastings6578 - still, i wonder why he didn't try to earn his australian certification instead of going into a field he has no experience operating

[@rickietasina7119]

in labor with my first daughter and so thankful i remembered you posted a monday mystery !! love your videos 🥰

[@Kweela]

Omg I missed so much!! Love to have you back 💁🏽‍♀️ Such an inspiration 😘😘

[@sfietomlinson8534]

I feel like the brother in law is guilty of the murders 100%

[@trixz22.]

For real

[@karenskinner9529]

He is.

[@ArielStar]

So terribly tragic. Poor family, may they rest in peace/paradise. Condolences to Brenda and the family. I just don't know how someone, like his own family, can do that...psychotic

[@hippis23]

My mom and her sister got in a fight one day in high school, my aunt left the house and got in an accident (she was okay) and my mom thought that was going to be their last interaction. Ever since my mom told me that story, I make sure to hug my family extra tight and tell them how much I love an appreciate them. I don't think I could ever live with myself if something happened and I hadn't got to tell them. Hold your loved ones tight because you really never know, these things can happen to anyone

[@emmya113]

HE NEEDS TO STOP APPLYING FOR BAIL!!!

[@sabriguzman]

did the operator think they all had paper cuts as a cause of death? if someone is saying THEY DONT KNOW could they take a second and think about how disfigured a person could look and at how blood can cover any type of clothing?? not to mention the smell of iron in the air??

[@angehokay]

i started to cry when the part about brenda finding out came up i couldnt imagine finding out like that