Sound in War Thunder vs World of Tanks

[@RussianBiasEnjoyer]

the echo in WT makes a pretty significant difference

[@sasdboy5799]

Nada aver

[@andreasaa2000]

There is also echo in WoT so?

[@fatje_pl3481]

@@andreasaa2000 but is 100x worse

[@i_nameless_i-jgsdf]

@@andreasaa2000 Didn't hear it so.

[@Usuario_-kx2yq]

@@sasdboy5799 entonces prueba el mod de sonido RCSM en WT live

[@alexshepherd1741]

Shots in War Thunder sound like shots, shots in World of Tanks sound like a drumbeat.

[@toasteroven6761]

Why do they all seem allergic to the realistic high-end (in sound's frequency spectrum) that most shots actually have and insist on making bass boost simulator sounds? This problem admittedly isn't as bad with WT, I get it when the shot is heard from inside a tank, HF sounds get reflected off the tank while low freq sounds penetrate, as a result a more bass dominant sound, but from 3rd person view, it shouldn't sound all bass dominant like that.

[@sasdboy5799]

Nada aver

[@seskorirkeashimrui3556]

@@toasteroven6761 From what I understand for some guns in war thunder, they record the Actual audio with high quality equipment then edit it to feel more "cinematic"

[@marveljeff]

i mean most of the sounds in wt were actually recorded irl even planes, so they probably do some little edit to make it more cinematic.

[@alexxu3004]

@@toasteroven6761 because the guns having such long barrel dont produce high pitch standing frequency?

[@oragessudvendee440]

World of tanks : you hear the shots War thunder : you feel the shots

[@SlideStreet]

no joke, that sh*t sound nice

[@gghajgghaj6755]

​@@SlideStreet like ur whole shitty life

[@zoltantakacs8401]

As a WoT player I agree

[@georgivanev7466]

WoT sounds are literally ancient at this point

[@hornet_13_90]

lmao exactly

[@sturm8115]

wot is ancient at this point

[@GregorianMG]

Ancient but very recognizable in the heat of battle.

[@SilvaDreams]

​@@sturm8115They are the same age, I beta tested both. Just WT has triedto be better where at WoT has just stagnated.

[@sturm8115]

@@SilvaDreams wt ground forces wasnt even released in wots peak. Their age diff was a lot for games in late 2000s

[@SanderDoesThings]

Firing a 76mm gun in War Thunder feels like you're king of the battlefield, shooting a 100mm gun in WoT feels like shooting a nerf gun

[@phi_ho6114]

Because it is, wot is an arcade based game, imagine you playing first person shooting games, one can kill the enemy instantly in a headshot, one only does critical damage, of course the one that can kill instantly feels more powerful, and in wot you need to shoot all the time to kill anyone, so the sound shouldnt be as loud and echoes as much, it would just be annoying, and to take into consideration with the wot bs spottibg mechanics, if an enemy is unspotted, you cannot hear them shooting, while in wt the enemies are always there, making the gunshots even more useful when its loud

[@dylannix4289]

Firing a 76mm irl: _EEEEEEEEEeeeeeeeEeeEEeeEEE_

[@大東亜共和国連邦-z4k]

@@phi_ho6114 Neutral and helpful opinions

[@arleneroanf.pajarin1761]

what about wotb 37mm to 183mm caliber

[@constantinouojoron5491]

0:35 was that a cat

[@kilroy9928]

Meeow!

[@14carrotsxx80]

I can’t unhear it

[@constantinouojoron5491]

@@14carrotsxx80 I can't either

[@GladiadoresRed]

gunner cat!

[@nghihuynh6631]

That does explain why they always comes back after getting disintegrate

[@sleyr_chenda6158]

War Thunder's sounds are "punchy" and aggressive, I would say. WoT is more like "arcady" and, almost cartoony, I would say. Still, both games have something to offer nonetheless. But still, it fits both games since, War Thunder (even though it's not always true, lol) is more realistic based, but WoT is more like an arcade game and doesn't really focus on realism.

[@FavkTheDemon]

i agree with you

[@longpham3939]

Im not a wt fan or wot fan becuase i play both, but wot player always said:"wow it so realistic and historical and accur" so the wt player don't want to here that

[@FavkTheDemon]

@@longpham3939 i think you heard that from players who have like 50 battles xd

[@longpham3939]

@@FavkTheDemon i don't know man, but some youtuber also say that

[@longpham3939]

But i don't want wot compare to wt, is different, if want to compare you need compare wot and amored warfare

[@josephstarling4609]

Imma be honest, they all just saying "boom" very fancy.

[@lo0fer13]

o7 LOL

[@Yeshayahu.]

That is actually a negative point in my opinion, it's not fancy irl and should not be in the game.

[@osmacar5331]

​@@Yeshayahu. I agree and disagree. More so agree and. my argument against is "it's a game." Guns are just boom with increasing bass, .22 is no different then 122mm, 122mm just has a lot of bass to it, from snap to crackle to pop to BOOM.

[@7ITZDANGER7]

Irl,it's like ear drum exploding sound from upclose so in war thunder it's sound should be increased so it's more then engine sounds and MG sounds It's like bòøőœm

[@stillans6424]

that's why WoT exist lol

[@RedVRCC]

War thunder is overall better due to much larger variety and the echo/reverb. Plus WT's other sounds are much better and more varied too, like reloads and engine sounds. Funny enough the 50mm exterior shots sound quite similar.

[@Valdien76]

As a tanker myself, exterior gunsounds sound infinitely better in War Thunder. Higher caliber guns sound extremely goofy in WoT. However I really like that you can clearly ear the breach recoil and open inside the tank WoT which I feel is kinda missing in War Thunder. IRL the breech is what you hear the most from inside.

[@SilvaDreams]

To be fair a good breach doesn't make a whole lot of noise. Plus WoT adds in a silly shell clank where it doesn't belong like on the 203 because it's a 2 stage ammo and there is no shell casing to drop.

[@osmacar5331]

​@@SilvaDreams old two piece ammo was just wax plugged brass not a bagged charge.

[@mrswimmytanker7422]

No you would mainly hear the shell clang after firing and the breech close when the shell is loaded

[@SergeantPsycho]

I noticed in some of the shots in War Thunder, you can hear the shots echo off the terrain. I'm pretty sure they modeled this in one update. I'm not sure if WoT does the same though.

[@franciscovallejo4434]

The echo of some shots was added like three updates ago( if not in even further updates ago).

[@samuelkutnar5174]

wot does have echoing off the ground but its not as loud, if you listen closely you can hear it, it starts from calibers over 122mm i think

[@kadirmertdurmus2316]

@@samuelkutnar5174 It's true, but they took the easy way out and added a few humming sounds and left it at that

[@operatorbinky5385]

Naah mate, long bofore that, it was added in early 2018 (update 1.77)

[@yevrra5012]

Just a quick correction, sound in a game isn't modeled since it's not 3d

[@normalyoutuber8234]

"Did you guys know,in warthunder the short 50mm has the most unique sound in the game

[@osmacar5331]

It does

[@No-le5fb]

Dont know, dont care

[@normalyoutuber8234]

@@osmacar5331 thats what said

[@normalyoutuber8234]

@@No-le5fb okay

[@john_wheels]

Until 2014-2015, the Is-2 with a 122mm destroyer had the most unique sound. It sounded like a cannonball hitting an anvil. A big boom and a ringing sound at the end.

[@antonov5463]

WoT sounds like nice movie shots. WT sounds like standing next to a tank

[@calebmenker988]

Idk, the real 76 on the sherman is way more impactful when you stand next to it compared to warthunder sounds

[@antonov5463]

@calebmenker988 Well, yes. However, any game in history never gets that "oomp" sound right. Just war thunder has closer sound than other games, not exactly accurate

[@nghihuynh6631]

In this comparison, WT is sound so much more powerful but in the real life test fires, the cannon is deafening and just dwarf the in game

[@Snicshavo]

I want my 122 plink back

[@plumpotato5642]

That sound has found it’s way into so many different games.

[@matyascech1810]

just download sound mod LOL

[@browniesfox]

The vodka glass klink :3

[@chems]

Bro how could you miss the world of tanks 128mm sound???? It’s literally the best sound from either game!!

[@Veilron_]

Remake this video yourself and upload it on the second channel

[@derpsturmpanzer1008]

Chems it's you!!

[@sibsnake]

holy crap and nobody even spotted him

[@melkisedekesilva7830]

A versão mobile do world of tanks o tiro do leopardo parece um instrumento musical chimbal 😂😂😂😂

[@Person_16362]

​@@melkisedekesilva7830*wot blitz *the leopard's not the only tank to have a 105mm gun

[@polo4228]

WoT sounds so muffled XD

[@Nacjotyp]

yeah, especially from the inside

[@No-le5fb]

WT one shot so not annoying, WoT shoot many times so it kinda interrupts your brain.

[@Nacjotyp]

@@No-le5fb wdym?

[@susah135]

​@@NacjotypIn WoT, you have to shoot enemies many times to kill them, so hearing a loud boom with every shot is getting annoying. While in WT, you only need to shoot enemies once or twice to kill them. So it's not getting annoying. Ex: WoT: BOOM BOOM BOOM BOOM BOOM 50X, silence for 2 seconds, BOOM BOOM BOOM 100X WT: BOOM, silence 10 sec, BOOM

[@Person_16362]

​@@susah135eh, not annoying at all for me

[@LettuceGayming]

God the clanging of the shell casing is so important to the weight of the shot to me, idk why, its just a little thing, but in gunner sight hearing the clang of the shell casing is just so satisfying

[@KristofKovacs-ul1gx]

the fact that bullet bounces off of ground in WT is amazing

[@Richard_T800]

There is a setting is War Thunder for Vibration, camera recoil... If you put it at 100% and fire a gun you will feel the recoil

[@しょーが-o1b]

In the case of warthunder, some of the sounds are actually recorded from actual vehicles from tanks that are still in use today, so please listen to them.

[@TigerOwO]

Worth to note here: Dagor engine (the game engine WT use) generate the sound individually based on the angle, camera distance and surrounding. The sound is actually quite different if there's a wall nearby.

[@annousa689]

Damn the warthunder panther's third person shot was awesome with the sound of fireworks at the end

[@thesheriffmt]

They both sound awesome in their own way

[@VictorLarsen-fy9ls]

War Thunder doesn't have an insane spread of shells.

[@Blozox]

The reason i do not like WOT gun sounds is that they all sound so soft and squishy. Like throwing a rotten tomato at a wall.

[@DatBom.]

WOT kinda sound like if you punch your bed.

[@panzer-v2f]

Yesterday they released an update to Wartander, where the sounds of gunshots were changed

[@user-Mx_Gricks]

Момент преодоление звукового барьера в Тундре у пантеры просто великолепен.

[@lo0fer13]

Do note that in World of Tanks you can play with mods that change the sound of cannons. Previously you could also do this in War Thunder, but they made using some of them bannable, particularly the ones that give you a competitive advantage. Edit: Thank you for the support tankers! o7

[@pheaktra_]

no they are only bannable IF they are used in tournaments. so any mode other than tournaments u will be fine

[@lo0fer13]

@@pheaktra_ If you insist, but I got my information from the official War Thunder forum. They only stated that if the mod does not gives a competitive advantage to the user, there should be no problem.

[@Hallvard0]

@@pheaktra_ Pretty sure nearly all sound mods were broken recently

[@TamamoF0X]

​@@lo0fer13sound mods are not bannable for normal players, they're only restricted for tournaments. There was a scandal a few years back where one team made their own sound mod which muted their engines and made the enemy ones really loud. WT devs said they will ban sound mods for all players but after a lot of backlash, the decision was reversed and only tournaments would have mods banned.

[@ixxxxxxx]

they added sound mod support and Epic Thunder sound mod is going very strong. adds amazing bullet cracks and just overhauls everything for the better really

[@lubitel_konstruirovania]

I agree with what ‘sleyr_chenda6158’ wrote below. Both games have a lot to offer players in terms of sounds. But personally my opinion is this: Some of the sounds of shots inside and outside the tank I like in both games In WT like the sounds of auto-cannon and everything that has a very high rate of fire (A10 entered the chat Brrrr), as well as the sound of recoil 125mm and similar guns in modern tanks. In WoT I really like the sound of 105mm gun inside and outside, and the sound when semi-automatic (or a drum for several shots roughly speaking) is about to load the whole cassette. P.s. Hi from Belarus :)

[@ざわわ-v6g]

WTの砲身から出てくる排煙が好き

[@artovod09]

Выстрел в war thunder звучит как выстрел, а выстрел в wot как пук

[@9SHAKA]

Аркада...

[@Sukhoi_57]

особенно на кораблях забавляют эти пуки, хотя корабельные орудия больше танка

[@kastuskalinovski4753]

@@9SHAKAлюди сравнивают звуки в симуляторе и аркаде

[@com2667]

Attack the D point!!

[@Gabriel_The_Königstiger]

Negative! **chat spamming**

[@Paniset7]

NEVER!!

[@DungeonMaster228-n6s]

Bravo!!! 1! 1!

[@Gabriel_The_Königstiger]

@@DungeonMaster228-n6s Attention To The Map!

[@ItsARandomDragon]

I agree!

[@hamzehhamed]

i like how you can hear the shell bouncing after firing in War thunder

[@ARDEN440i]

So overall War Thunder takes it in terms of depth, however I gotta admit the thunderous echo emitted from the 122MM ( 3:29 ) in World of Tanks sounds badass. Not sure it's realistic though

[@Geniusinventor]

To test 203mm guns in wt you can look at heavy cruisers in test drives.

[@iskan_15]

Вар тандер лучший поставьте лайки если вар тандер лучший 😊

[@ALigatidor]

The graphics quality on Boosteroid is incredible

[@MarcJorissen-j5r]

Boosteroid's low latency makes for an amazing gaming experience

[@-ALPHA_MDW2.1-]

You can also mod the sound and crew voice in WT quite a nice feature

[@Communisthaiti2]

Bro underated you need more views and subs

[@Radesman-df3]

I like the sound when u Aim the Shell when Drops in floor so cool

[@kenanmuhic8755]

thing about wot is that it is very competitive game, and gun sounds is something that players use to figure out who are they fighting against, or is some tank upgraded or not.

[@sskuk1095]

Man I miss the old WoT sounds so much!

[@user-nh5li7gn9s]

Boosteroid's subscription plans are very budget-friendly

[@rokasb9441]

Mmm war thunder autoloader asmr next ;)

[@KamelBargaoui-d3u]

I can't imagine going back to traditional gaming after using Boosteroid

[@Robs_Reef]

The FV4005 gun sound is so awesome

[@ReviveHF]

Warthunder‘s sounds are the most similar to the ones we can hear in Battlefield games.

[@DEMODErsi]

In WoT was Sturmtiger event 310mm. Or T92 HMC 240mm

[@anonim5759]

In WT Sturmtiger has 380mm

[@Gerald-g7g3o]

Boosteroid's performance is consistently top-notch

[@o5-998]

I miss the old wt sound

[@kaijugabriel1685]

One of the things that made me start playing World of Tanks was the sound effects and graphics. Unfortunately, today it's not enough for me anymore.

[@virtualtrucker26]

That 152mm from WT shatters souls.

[@FlyingPigeon-00001]

That 183mm sure hits hard

[@KorporalNoobs]

There is an arcade charm to WoT + echo, it's kinda satisfying in that sense, but it ain't quite right

[@msali-z4c]

Boosteroid's customer support is fantastic

[@_Bruno_32_]

Bro, no one has compared the sounds of hits on a tank from different guns yet. I think it's time to do it. The important thing is that the sounds are of armor not being penetrated, from the perspective of the one being shot at, not the one doing the shooting.

[@JesseEngler-n4v]

I love the freedom Boosteroid gives me to game anywhere

[@germaniaempire2829]

Just realized if your tank in wt has a 2 piece ammo (projectile and charge) you won't hear the ding Dinka ding

[@stingattack7951]

Oh shit, I never noticed that before! That makes total sense, because with 2-piece ammo there's no actual metal casing for the propellant!

[@quiverthorn2715]

One for one hit kill, one for multiple hit kill

[@TheNightlessFall]

The shots in War Thunder have a better echo effect and are less muffled and that makes the difference. But WoT never really change their shots sounds effec compared to WT who did work on it over the years. However, they both sounds like how they should sounds which is great even if WT hit harder.

[@kilianp.5692]

World of Tanks high caliber just sounds so good

[@piscesss1-g2i]

Boosteroid's game selection is second to none

[@CALAVERITA07]

The sound of WOT is not bad, but the sound of WT is much better, it really sounds powerful, the echo helps it a lot and the rumble it causes is incomparable.

[@vivivi..]

WT sounds have more personality than me🗿

[@ΟδυσσέαςΒαλλιανάτος]

100mm also has another sound effect in WoT you forgot. Still nice video

[@hirosimaona]

WT has definitely the better sound engine. Don't know how close it is to the real sounds, but definitely feels much better in the ears than WoT. WoT sounds are also very reused in my opinion. All calibers up to 107mm sound almost the same. WoT sound engine is definitely worse even though they advertise it back than as "very realistic."

[@Argillllll]

The most largest caliber you can find in War thunder is the caliber of the Sturmoser

[@sskuk1095]

Yeah, but you can't really compare that to WoT, since that game has no rocket launching vehicles.

[@sibsnake]

sturmtiger*

[@sibsnake]

@@sskuk1095 it did have sturmtigers

[@alexxu3004]

I miss the 122mm PING in old warthunder

[@JTA32011]

if you look closely at wot 75 nr 2 the muzzle flash goes out the sides more than wt edit:also on the 76

[@sillymilly-1]

honestly wot has more realistic scoped-in cannon sound except for the casings hitting the floor (but wt has RCSM, which is better than stock wt and wot)

[@hungryweebsg]

and the you can have user generated sound files in war thunder

[@samphardtake]

As a WT player im jealous of the WoT graphics

[@viki_kekw]

Графика не лучше, чем в WT. Она такая же. Просто добавили больше контрастности. В WoT хорошее качество текстур окружения, но вот ужаснейшее качества самого важного - танков. Это можно сравнить даже на этом видео. Это конечно не оправдание для 🐌, пусть работают над графикой. Но и в WoT графика = WT, просто с выкрученной на максимум контрастностью. Также 🐌 стоит увидеть карты в WoT. Улитки, взгляните на WoT. Тут есть, что спиздить. 😅 Карты - сильная сторона WoT в сравнении с WT

[@muizsp9525]

Even tho WoT graphics looks better, it also looks "stylized*

[@Talon.]

You're what? I swear WoT has such disgusting graphics I could never go back to play it instead of WT

[@Hallvard0]

Have you tried turning up your settings lol? The detail is way greater in War Thunder.

[@SilvaDreams]

​@@Hallvard0I don't think his PC could handle turning the graphics settings up if he think WoT looks great.

[@Instinktjagd]

WT : Realistic suffering WOT : Unrealistic suffering

[@bimbommcgee908]

War thunder's gun sounds are better but I far prefer WoT's shell loading sounds

[@kellerweskier7214]

iv been noticing that in WoT, when firing, the grass is knocked over from the shockwave pressure. and not in WT. huh.

[@iamd3ad_ang3l10]

I like the sounds of of the shot of world of tanks… shell ejecting in wt and the echo of wt… fv4005 sounds amazing in wt

[@jonathanpan6110]

A lot of the calibers you completely left out

[@sidewinderyt]

It fun to see war in comment

[@aljon5947]

Both games sounded pretty incosistent, sometimes the gun had a lot of echo or little, I think it all matters on how they got the sounds. with that said WT has nice impact and shell whizzing through the air sounds.

[@rokasb9441]

In war thunder many sounds (especially gun, qutoloader and engine ones) were recorded and later rerecorded, with complex multi mic setups, and some just copied between simmilar engines, which had meant that in early days of wt some tanks were really loud (esp japanese ones), as they were recorded with different gear.. also post processing.

[@WadoViceMan]

British 120mm sounds sooo good in WT

[@moktafizaman9077]

Not many people know about this, but WoT allows mods to be used, so if you want, you can just download a WT gun sound mod for WoT. If there's any available.

[@smokepole.-.2177]

Same as WT

[@moktafizaman9077]

@@smokepole.-.2177 Whoa WT also had modding?

[@quocvinhnguyen2063]

@@moktafizaman9077 uhh, yeah? WT already has mod since... 2013? Why are you getting surprised?

[@moktafizaman9077]

@@quocvinhnguyen2063 K

[@djisch]

sad that the is 2 doesnt have its "ding" sound anymore

[@Sans-iv1wy]

they all sound pretty much the same but if you compare them to the old Warthunder sounds Warthunder wins every time The old 152 sounds like a NUKE

[@AlRizz187]

if u are on pc get the rcsm soundmod from wt live. you can see the guy who made it here on yt the name is also rcsm soundmod. rcsm stands for real combat sound mod because you guessed it he took real sounds and replaced the stock sounds. its a night and day difference

[@6TheButcher]

The old WT sounds are super unrealistic.

[@everlyn.martins]

WoT is just the same sound, but with some reverb to different tanks

[@Cichencjusz]

That is why I use sound mod i WoT, big difference

[@alexandreborman2183]

WT pure sound effect is better and low caliber sounds are way better. WoT has a better deep sound, it sounds like you shoot with a silencer (which i don't find great), but they made a good job with the resonance of it while in WT it feels like you shoot inside a big building or something.

[@_MrModman_]

So the winner is bf5 sounds

[@stingattack7951]

The 85s were actually pretty similar, but I think WT won that one simply because of the echo.

[@AlRizz187]

not to mention wt soundmods like rcsm and stuff. miles ahead of normal wt sound and wot sound

[@BWmp_1]

The Shell sound is perety good🗿

[@_aquamarina9308]

The IS 122 without the boong sound feel very wrong haha

[@johnclement189]

WT sound effects are really punchy and full of weight, the smoke and the recoil really gave you a perspective of the velocity of the gun being fired.

[@Viz9r]

Скучаю по старому звуку ис-2 в ВТ, это мëд для ушей, как будто кто то ударил в металический горн и призвал Перуна

[@BrandonVonOtt]

In the 75 mm cannons and smaller, I found that I enjoyed the "outside of the tank" more in War Thunder, while the "inside the tank" noises from World of Tanks were more fun. That said, anything larger than the 75, War Thunder sounded better all the way.

[@shock226]

The realistic sound mod for WT make big calibers sound better then sex

[@HarTmanN_erik]

Its funny how the largest caliber in WoT the tank hasn't moved while the 183 in war thunder moved a few meters after firing

[@blokkiesotto5854]

If im not mistaken. I think its pretty logical that if a cannon is pointed upwards that the tank wont mive back

[@HarTmanN_erik]

@@blokkiesotto5854 Have you seen railway guns being fired? They practically recoil back after firing, and they way bigger guns than the 203 mm shown here

[@AurelionSass]

@@blokkiesotto5854 Nah, there's plenty of footage of real life artillery pieces rocking back after firing. A gun of that size (203mm) would absolutely move the entire platform it's mounted on.

[@LecAviation]

@@blokkiesotto5854 Have you ever seen Artillery firing? they fire into the air and still they have a lot of recoil.

[@lo0fer13]

Hello, tankers! I did some research (a.k.a. Wikipedia), and while the FV4005 does have a smaller caliber, it actually has a much larger propellant load. The FV4005 has a propellant load of 30.7 kg, while the S-51's cannon only uses 3.24 to 15.5 kg of propellant. So, that, along with the angle of the cannon, might be the reason for the lesser recoil on the 203 mm cannon. o7

[@thickboi7570]

I think the 152mm sounds amazing in wot

[@A_random_idiot15]

Ima be honest... WT gets a point for the shoots, and WOT also gets a point for the reloading sound too.

[@nathanzeyer4111]

War Thunder is a better game in my opinion but the ricochet sound in wot is so awesome

[@Yukino_Yukinoshita_is_perfect]

WT is trash

[@Bimo1205]

Wot: unrealistic suffering Wt: realistic suffering

[@Tarmink]

@@Yukino_Yukinoshita_is_perfect почему?

[@kahrislorenzoniles9227]

​​@@Yukino_Yukinoshita_is_perfectWhy? Explain

[@LecAviation]

@@Yukino_Yukinoshita_is_perfect Depends on what you are looking for, WT is an incredibly realistic game with amazing graphics, sounds and damage models/systems, WOT is more "arcadey", all depends on what you prefer, it's definetly not "trash" in terms of realism and graphics (the grind is painfully long though), If you prefer aracdey games then WoT is for you, if you prefer realism then WT is for you.