SOYEON X WINTER X LIZ - NOBODY | Line Distribution

[@amitkpoplds]

Some questionable parts ill answer for you: 0:13 is all not only soyeon 0:54 is all (i flitered the vocals and i heared soyeon winter and liz together) 1:09 is all not only winter 2:21 is only winter and liz (unlike 1:09 the singers are only winter and liz and then soyeon joins them) And about all the adlibs they are sang by a backround vocalists MARIAH MARCUS and SOPHIA BAE not LIZ

[@soobourhome]

You mean background vocalist?

[@akusukakm201]

and 0:16 is soyeon 1:10 is liz

[@amitkpoplds]

​@@soobourhomethe adlibs yes I meant backround vocalist and the others are all

[@TheCottonCandy707]

Soyeon is also hearable at 2:23 she joins a bit earlier than her uhoh

[@ValePokey]

Soyeon is also at 2:21, Let's just say her volume is lower, but it does contrast with Liz and Winter's voices.

[@jiusomnia_]

Since this song is heavily vocal based, imo I think Miyeon is a better candidate & then we'll have the main vocalists banger kind of collab but overall this is a good song none of them seemed lacking, it's just sad that they weren't able to film together

[@N.Lavender.12]

but the song goes better with soyeon's voice like really... since the voices of winter and liz are really sweet, soyeon acts as the voice contrast

[@Lili_in_k-pop]

don't forget about Minnie, whose vocal skills are slightly higher than Miyeon's in vocals

[@goldenhime8404]

​​@@Lili_in_k-popno way, Miyeon is better, she is og main vocal since debut, Minnie was lead vocal

[@Lili_in_k-pop]

@@goldenhime8404 no, you're confusing. Since their debut, Minnie has been the main vocalist and Miyeon is the lead vocalist. Minnie can hit a high note and a low note easily.

[@ruixuan6906]

@@Lili_in_k-popno but fr minnie was the lead n miyeon was the main but i can see ur point 🙏 with minnie in this collab however her voice can’t stand out cus of liz n winter’s soft voice nature but miyeon could

[@Ychae02]

I expect more rap part from Soyeon. Like they can literally choose other G-idle’s members (to sing) then if there ain’t gonna have actual rap parts.

[@chwnxv]

Soyeon: leader, main rapper, main dancer, sub vocalist, center Winter: main vocalist, lead dancer, sub rapper, fotg Liz: lead vocalist, visual, dancer, maknae

[@Cryforme-]

Liz & Winter ATE with thier vocals

[@sw_editz_1]

Soyeon def deserved more lines. but the combo of their voices was great! Lets hope they will collaborate again soon!

[@sammilo2501]

Love soyeon’ spice she gives but I personally think they should’ve gotten Miyeon to do this. Just image 3 vocalists can come together and make a banger song❤

[@dei_._]

Winters vocals really shined here, and the line distribution fits each person, i just feel soyeon should’ve got the “Nobody” part atleast once

[@sw_editz_1]

yeah I agree soyeon should've gotten the nobody part at least once and at least a main rap? cause she barely got any vocal/rap lines.

[@dei_._]

@@sw_editz_1 yea I think they gave winter and Liz the vocals because they are vocalists so I can’t really blame them, but soyeon has vocals also

[@JangWonyoung-c5l]

Yeah I agree soyeon should’ve atleast gotten the nobody part once.

[@mimidiiary]

0:15 sounds like Soyeon with her own armonies

[@amitkpoplds]

I filtered it and her voice isn't there, it's all

[@ceceproductions57]

They really gave Soyeon the same 2 lines. It kinda of felt like she was featured in Liz and Winter's song😭. They really couldnt have gave her a rap verse? (Dont get me wrong i really loved the song)

[@Kat-y_L]

But i really like her repetitive line...that part sounds so good ngl.

[@iamcarlosadrian]

This song needs no rap

[@luvkpoplution]

Literally I mean she can write one but they gave her just few lines because she's a rapper😭

[@ceceproductions57]

@iamcarlosadrian yea this song was definitely written for vocalist

[@hallooos7585]

@@luvkpoplutionthey should’ve just have put Miyeon in the group instead of Soyeon tbh

[@jenokpop]

Liz called my attention here omgg

[@_nana_nana]

Sameee

[@rsecherry]

her voice in 1:11 oh god 😭

[@yxnzyy_]

soyeon deserved more lines! though i do love this song!

[@andreafernandez8132]

Con 31.2 segundos Soyeon demostró el talento que tiene y su versatilidad para adaptarse a cualquier sonido y tono, te amo Soyeon ❤

[@BrendenBarlow]

I know a lot of comments say they would prefer miyeon and i love miyeon but her voice wouldn't contrast enough with the other two i feel. Soyeons voice brought the song together.

[@bunkersloco9559]

It's not about they prefer miyeon, but about how soyeon is treated more like a subvocal than a rapper. If you just need a subvocal why don't you collab with miyeon. That's the intention

[@rinasrandom]

@@bunkersloco9559 you just said what they were arguing against. you would prefer miyeon for this song. soyeons vocals stand out more.

[@bunkersloco9559]

@@rinasrandom My bad, if the producer will only treat them as a sub-vocal and neglect them. I rather they didn't have a collab. Like it's not fair... They didn't give her a single rap verse or even chorus... Like she only has half of the other members line distribution man. And it's not the other members fault it's the producer fault. I don't like the notion that makes Idle looks like a sidekick here.

[@rsecherry]

0:19 WINTERRR, liz and winter killed this song

[@gabsyoy]

it's giving 2nd gen vibe

[@luvkpoplution]

You're so fast, but happy you made a line distribution with this amazing song😭💕

[@LyNguyễn-s4r]

winter vocals really shined ! 😍😍

[@rsecherry]

LIZ I LOVE YOU

[@vespa_Kpop]

Soyeon - Leader,Main rapper,Sub vocalist(^F/F+),(Main/Lead) Dancer,Center Winter - Main vocalist(^C),Lead rapper,Visual,(Main,Lead) Dancer,FOTG Liz - Lead vocalist(^D/D+),Maknae

[@Nayeonmy178]

Soyeon should be main dancer actually winter have average dance level she is not really strong she is normal i think soyeon have better dance than winter Winter would definitely be a lead dancer

[@zdhv5]

soyeon is not a dancer at all lol she’s good but not for being a main dancer

[@mjgoat2366]

@@Nayeonmy178winter is a better dancer than soyeon. She was recruited for dancing not singing. I’m not saying winter is a amazing dancer but she is better then soyeon

[@Jerrika]

Lololol people who think soyeon can’t dance when dancers rank her higher than most main dancers 🤭

[@mjgoat2366]

@@Jerrika nobody said she can’t dance, we just think winter is better but soyeon is good too

[@diegoenmanuel6138]

Estoy tan acostumbrado ah ver ah soyeon siempre de primera o segunda en las línias distribución que me agarra desprevenido verla de última 😅

[@HiraiLine]

I think they should gave one chorus to Soyeon

[@Cryforme-]

It's a Vocal based chorus that's why she can't be given the chorus She won't fit it nd she is a weak vocalist- The chorus is made for Liz nd Winter vocals

[@HiraiLine]

@@Cryforme- so if they can't gave her chorus because of her 'weak vocal' they shouldn't choose her for the collab or just gave her a rap part 💀

[@Cryforme-]

​@@HiraiLine Miyeon would have been a better choice for this collab She got a small rap part in prechorus but maybe this song is more vocal focused

[@nicdoesntexistt]

​@user-friendly.848 cuz she's popular I presume 🤷‍♀️

[@levy5698]

​@@Cryforme-shes not a weak vocalist bro, actually shes a great vocalist just check some of her vocal moments

[@jrkln27]

Soyeon - Main Rapper, Main Dancer, Vocalist, Leader. Winter - Main Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, Visual. Liz - Lead Vocalist, Fotg. bias: Liz

[@watermelon1770]

Soyeon or Winter would be the fotg tbh

[@rinasrandom]

@@watermelon1770 agree, soyeon and winter are both more popular than liz, making them a better candidate for fotg

[@wonderfulrose477]

This could’ve been a perfect line distribution if Soyeon wrote a rap in the bridge or something to shake up the song.

[@krandomlyric8803]

I think the adlibs in the bridge is liz and the last chorus as well?

[@amitkpoplds]

It's a backround vocalist ❤

[@imtoodumbforthis]

Nah unfortunately its not, at the end of the actual MV in the credits, there's a background vocalist that they credit.

[@elsak2202]

I love Soyeon part

[@chwnxv]

1:11 i love Liz vocals

[@rsecherry]

1:11 LIZ, THE WOMAN U AREEEE

[@urveshmanvar6062]

This ie the best collaboration song since sm town wow thing funny that both have soyeon in common.

[@rsecherry]

LIZZZZZ

[@intermilan9761]

Liz vocal vibes ariana grande

[@xkalisha.06]

they could of given soyeon a rap or something

[@Cryforme-]

The line distribution is soo fair 🤩 Winter is best vocalist so she deserves 1st nd Liz vocals shined to

[@Xjmisael]

Soyeon just sings the same phrase every time

[@bunkersloco9559]

Man a slow rap with at least 4 lines will make this so much better

[@yiwwwwwwy]

Slay

[@Youth-l7d]

From 2:22 to the end, all members are singing.

[@imtoodumbforthis]

Nah, Soyeon's voice is very distinct and you can hear when she's singing.

[@syxfiq_xzmi]

I can hear lizz adlibs ✌🏻😁

[@amitkpoplds]

It's a backround vocalist imo

[@葵-h2l]

へぇ、声だけ拾うとこうなるのか！ MVではそれほどソヨンの分量が少なく感じなかったのでちょっと意外だ ソヨンはビジュアルのいかつさ、存在感が群を抜いてる人なんだな

[@alyamond]

2:04 is not only winter but it was all of their voices harmonized

[@kewoh2196]

Liz and winter my bias❤

[@rsecherry]

Samee

[@Hamie_dahh]

Liz literally make the song levitating

[@Сало-в2е]

Было бы круто если бы в конце Соен спела припев "Nobody but you" без второго куплета и песня бы так закончилась. (Написала в другом видео с распределениями повторю и тут)

[@JaspeeGangte]

It's not fair for Soyeon

[@mfthtrhee9766]

Sumpah gua seneng banget disini liz line nya banyak🥹 ayo starship line liz di grup aslinya gini juga🥹

[@kpopbroughtmehere]

can i ask why you counted the parts together in the end but not during the entire video?

[@avrilynicolas3247]

I still in doubt Why did they only showed together in the last screen 😢?

[@randomhuman-630]

All the members filmed their shots separately. The last pic was probably edited-

[@avrilynicolas3247]

@@randomhuman-630 It's really dissapoiting... It's a shame make a colaboration like this, looks like 3 girls making the dance challenge in a mix

[@krswizardsfreak7192]

​@@avrilynicolas3247well due to busy schedules lately. Aespa and Ive made comeback and Gidle world tour are the reasons they shot separately. I hope they perform together.

[@kxntolicious]

Kupikir soyeon 5detik, ternyata 31 detik😭😭 cukup banyak lohhh

[@johnsthetic]

The song is dreamy kind so I get why soyeon didnt have fire rap BUT BUT if they are gonna release another one gimme the rap verse

[@jessicawong9322]

💃💫💃💫💃💫

[@notyourtype7008]

Finally liz has a long part😭😭

[@mjzz813]

soyeon did not even rap. should have put miyeon, yuqi or minnie since it is vocal song.

[@rsecherry]

It's not all about soyeon

[@baho2397]

Is first time soyeon has last line😅

[@BlueSkyRecords03]

Doesn’t this sound like off the record, a little bit

[@cristianosantaremramos2427]

Eu gostei, mas não serviu o hipe todo não.... Pensei, pela colab e pelo todo suspense feito, seria melhor. E distribuição de linhas não foi boa... Queria ouvir mais da soyeon... Mas fazer o quê.... Mas mesmo assim gostei da música e também muito feliz pelas minhas cantoras favoritas estarem cantando a mesma música. ( Obs.: elas não são as minhas bias...)

[@chwnxv]

you forgot some Liz ad libs

[@midori26]

all three are talented, it just that the song is too boring, lyrics is repetitive. Song is too gentle for soyeon's vibe. Wasted the potential.

[@rsecherry]

It's not all about soyeon.

[@eldricke]

which is why they shouldn't have chosen soyeon if anything it should've just been liz and winter. soyeon ruined the song

[@YatoKpop]

The line up should have been like Liz from Ive, Karina from Aespa (For the Soyeon rap parts) and Miyeon or Minnie from Gidle

[@paunamidatta9000]

If karina was there the song will be more good because of her unique voice she will add more flavor to the song

[@iiwuri0]

Meh, and soyeon lines??

[@swtvic]

sm payola working hard to give winter most lines

[@elfy2006]

she was the best vocalist here so far

[@jvmmalv2493]

well she’s the best vocalist here 😭

[@joao.gu1lherme]

😂😂😂

[@_nana_nana]

Uhm whut

[@hannavang1594]

Winter Is Literally The Better Than Both Liz And Soyeon In Vocals, So Of Course Winter Is Going Have The Most Line!

[@winteroutsang]

Soyeon finally got humbled after taking all the lines in gidle

[@mjgoat2366]

Relax girl im a winter Stan too but u don’t have to be a asshole. U could say the same for winter who gets most lines usually ( not as much as soyeon but she still gets a lot). Don’t be toxic😅

[@SicaRun]

Winter get all the lines in aespa too, she's by far the most pushed member, get plenty of screentime too

[@rsecherry]

Exacly lol

[@ArtwithPRAGYA]

@@SicaRun maybe because in live she is more stable...I think from starting she was most pushed, karina got popular initialy so they started pushing her but after that they came back to winter. she was also the secerate trainee right..sm is wiered, in starting ning was most biased [and she has the most star qualities in aespa] but they never did justice to ning

[@kpopediting8312]

bad collab in the world😢, the line is like a trash in a mountain

[@scarletassasins218]

31 sec to soyeon PLSSSS