Spotlight Back On Netaji-Gumnami Mystery | The Debate With Arnab Goswami

[@tusharghosh644]

Hats off Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose

[@vasudha857]

Netaji was a big fan of Swami Vivekananda, so I think in his later days he motivated himself to the spiritual world and that is quite possible for his personality......

[@AmyPatel]

These are the exact words I told my sister today abt Netaji 🙂

[@a_man_jaiswal]

@@AmyPatel same thought I got yesterday 😊

[@thedroidbha]

And why not the focus be on Netaji? Instead of the 3 idiots who presented themselves with Bharat Ratna awards (Nehru, Indra, Rajiv - fake Gandhis).

[@utubetruthteller]

Mullahs may give Rahul Bharat Ratna very soon.

[@abhishekraj4635]

well said...

[@anujmediaworks]

@Paki Terrorist true...

[@thedroidbha]

@Dinesh M Not only Nehru and MKGandhi betrayed Bharat, but the first ever SCAM of Willies Jeep import to India for Army was also done.

[@RahulNM2308]

Yessss

[@mahendradangua6758]

We have got independence only due to netaji bt history is silent

[@Sona-hl5yb]

True

[@JustAWatcher73]

He was pak sponsored

[@Ranjan_Mohanty]

@@JustAWatcher73 Abe chutiye, tu jaake allah kutiya Ko chod !

[@JustAWatcher73]

@@Ranjan_Mohanty 😂😂😂😂 you are also pak sponsored.. Modiji is father of our nation. Not netaji. Chutiya tera baap!! 😂😛😛😂😂

[@samnigam3451]

Exactly he hid followers n INA brave men n women fought hard for our independence during WWII not anti national Congress thugs.

[@punitnaik]

Gumnami baba was Bose. Hand writing proof can’t be wrong one. A man can’t copy someone’s handwriting for 30 years in English and Bangla. He was Bose 💯.

[@sanjaynautiyal9476]

No dear, I think this thoery was created by congress to minimize the story of Late Subhash Chandra Bose in general public

[@phoenixj1299]

@@sanjaynautiyal9476 Sorry but it's impossible to copy the handwriting that's why people express authenticity with signature. The evidence of handwriting proves Gumnami Baba was Bose .

[@njoy51]

He was already banged up abroad in Yakutsk, cell no.43, died in Russia

[@phoenixj1299]

@@njoy51 Nope. Makes no sense. He came to India and lived as Gumnami Baba.

[@njoy51]

@@phoenixj1299 yet another coverup to save Nehru co.

[@hari7priya]

Netaji should be declared Father of Modern India.

[@sayakdeb8251]

According to me this will be the biggest insult made to Netaji!!!!!

[@kaivalyadeshpande2939]

@@sayakdeb8251 So what to take of evidences

[@alivewell1145]

Yes he is the real father of India.

[@mukulmukherjee5460]

Netaji...The real hero

[@Ganga459]

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@curiousmind5137]

It's disappointed to watch the daughter speaking, supporting the Previous Govt blunder mistake and ignorant behavior to the legend real hero our Netaji. We belive Bhagwan ji= Gumnami Baba = Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose

[@Shaina_singh_amrita]

She is trained to speak that way ! Its not her fault she is doing what she z been told. Her mother and she lived in isolation without husband and father imagine their situation! She must be either pressures or simply told by her mother that he is dead !! And one more thing when he became gumnaami or the one who is not known to the world than Howcome his doughter and wife would come to know about him being alive sitting in a foreign land miles away from India ????

[@Salman786yes]

Netaji SC Bose will never die.... he will always live in our hearts and minds....

[@mukeshsaini7795]

According to Geeta, living being takes another body after leaving one body. So Netaji came back and he is somewhere between us and will complete his task. Gandhi-Vadhra watch your ass which gonna be beaten black and blue mercilessly by "netaji returned" this time.

[@SanatanWorld-q1z]

Very true

[@suseelavelamakanni2486]

@@mukeshsaini7795 kkl.

[@seturamaspari7958]

What happened to the remark made by Seth rollins free yesterday

[@dr.kailashchaurasiya3098]

⁰

[@banerjeesiddharth05]

Conundrum book by anuj dhar and chandrachur ghosh is a must read book for every indian citizen...nehru was the biggest traitor of independent india...mi5 of uk wanted bose to be caught .

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

Not only CONUNDRUM but also WHAT HAPPENED TO NETAJI ?

[@sria8163]

Yes ..there was a conspiracy.

[@banerjeesiddharth05]

@@SAFFRONINFERNO ..True

[@paadipanta2607]

@suvadeep banerjee Bose lied that he had not married but he has been honey trapped by J3wish and she is his real daughter..

[@arunchandramathi9572]

Nehru was Flirting with british royalty while india was burning

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

Lal Babhur Shastri's death is also linked with Netaji's disappearance SHastriji was going to make a BIG ANNOUNCEMENT after his return from Russia which someone didn't like and eliminated him in Russia

[@user-sq4pg5yv1j]

Watch a movie called "the Tashkent files"

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

@@user-sq4pg5yv1j Already did..

[@arpitahore95]

Absolutely right

[@Alove11111]

Exactly! The Nehru Gandhi family got him killed! So that he couldn't bring Bose to our country who was declared to be a traitor of the country! Shashtriji was about to bring netaji with him!

[@melodymusic2020]

@@Alove11111 I just want to say that there are lot of people who has such lookalike of any individual.... Still, I smelt conspiracy between the British and Nehru- Gandhi, by the way, did Netaji used the same process by growing beard and coming to India as he did while escaping India?

[@asifvlogs3617]

So much mystery hidden in our country history...its time to sort it out once n for all...for the legend late Netaji Subhash C Bose....🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@gmchander142]

In other developed Countries people don't worry about past incidents nor do they lament about it. They tend to remain techno savvy bringing in new technologies for the betterment of their masses and future generations. Only in this Country do they rant about past achievements which are not only hollow but based of fictitious stories.

[@rohitmanohar2733]

Shri Lal Bahadur Shatri ji death also a mystery

[@akhiljain5197]

@@gmchander142 Kisne kaha ye fictitious hai bey ullu k paththe. Lagta hai Congress ki dukaan band hone se tujhe bhi nuksaan hoga. Jo desh khud ko or khudke past ko bhool jaega, uska vohi haal hoga jo 1000 saal pehle akhand bharat kaa hua. Jo abhi europe kaa ho raha hai(many people have forgot christianity and adopted atheism) and will happen for USA in near future.

[@akhiljain5197]

@@gmchander142 tere jaise log jo apne itihaas par shak kare, kalank hai is mulq par.

[@sushmitatiwari1307]

@@akhiljain5197 leave it Akhil see there are chutiyas then there are bigger chutiyas and then comes this gm chander he loves licking boot policy leave it he won't understand what it means for a country to run with true history and to respect their country's real heroes

[@dyotiniroy3335]

Sad, that Anita cannot understand the sentiments of India...cheers to Anuj & Chandrachur 👍

[@vikaspanchal8015]

NETAJI will remain alive in our hearts, Always. No matter what coming generation will always remain getting inspiring.

[@sghosh4141]

Neheru and his family are the greatest traitors of our country.Neheru was the person who informed the British about Chandrasekhar Azad's movement after Azad returning meeting Neheru. Never looted the INA treasure. Made Subah Chandra Bose a War Criminal,Abolished Netaji's name from the history of India.We the foolish Indians treated Never family like God.What a disgraceful fate. Jago Bharat basi.Crush Never family and criminal politicians , Indians think how these politicians made millions of Rupees and property. Save India .

[@rajeevkartha9343]

Netaji and Bhagat Singh will Always be Remembered by Every Indian 🚩🚩🚩🙏🙏🙏

[@user-qc9ht7fh5d]

Netaji is a legend and always will be the greatest indian

[@PRIYAJAY-SHETTY]

Silent because no one other can take his teachings how to organize themselves like netaji in slavery times

[@shaktimajumdar3058]

When I arrived in Belgium in 82, I had met an elderly german on street who said he was sharing his house with Netaji in Germany; I did not believe him then, even though I invited him to join us & spend the evening at our place after just meeting him on street; now after so much of happenings i wish I had given more time to accompany him to Germany to see with my own eyes if Netaji was there.

[@ShriKshetraPurusottama]

Netaji had been the first Prime Minister, now it would have been complete different India ... he is the only person who united India from South to North

[@rs50726]

Anita bose cannot relate to our feeling to netaji. Seemed she is not interested at all. But truth should be out

[@Utkalputra2024]

She is hesitant to reopen to unearth truth, which may go positive or negative.

[@ashalata5610]

Is she really Netaji’s daughter ?

[@santanubiswasboshu]

ANITA PUFF...(NOT BOSE) IS NOT AT ALL DAUGHTER OF NETAJI SHE IS A DAUGHTER OF MOTHER WHO'S THE DAUGHTER OF "SCOTLAND YARD OFFICER"

[@rohandesai8369]

He disappeared when she was 3 or something. She only knows him through the family.

[@ggeo1364]

yes you are absolutely right,she do not have any emotion or interest

[@samarpitabanerjee6353]

Kudos to Anuj and Chandrachud sir for having dedicated 15 years researching about Netaji and still doing so. Cannot just discard those undeniable records! Unbelievable that Netaji's death is still a mystery! But, Truth has its way of coming out! Netaji, alive in our hearts forever 🇮🇳

[@sree6214]

Nethaji....is nethaji.. We did lot of negatives to that hero... even his soldiers were not recruited in Indian army.. then political leaders considered him as enimy lik british did...they afraid of nethaji... What a brave man he is...courage and conviction..intelligence..leadership..dedication to motherland.. Rare mix of all qualities...

[@DAIM_AKASHBJ]

Anuj and chandrachur were on fire with those undeniable records 🔥

[@sagyadesh]

Anuj and Chandrachur, take a bow and more power to you. We are all waiting for the truth.

[@randeepsingh3516]

Why do we talk about Netaji only on specific occasions? This should be an continuous discussion till all the details don't come out

[@alivewell1145]

Absolutely

[@RahulKumar-vo8kt]

Absloutly

[@abhishekmurudkar5084]

Yes

[@tusharsubhramondal]

I think Netaji family is hiding something... NETAJI WAS ONE OF THE GREATEST INDIANS... Jai Hind

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Anuj Dhar is trying to insult Netaji.

[@vijayavani8003]

One book was written in Kanada by the author, Srinivasachar(If my memory is correct) long ago on Subhash Chandrabose and there was mention about Gumnami baba in that book.

[@manjuvaradaraj2158]

What is the name of that book

[@atulshendge7476]

Name of the book?

[@upadhyayrathiraj1518]

The nephew is either lying or under some pressure. Or trying to prevent sharing of property?

[@ajitghosh7806]

Or maybe he is jealous

[@AtiMahaRathi]

He is pro congress

[@OrlandoMazzotta007]

NONE OF NETAJI'S FAMILY MEMBERS SEEM TO BE HAVING ANY TRAITS OF HIM AT ALL! THAT'S VERY SAD. SHAME ON THEM!

[@omanam3799]

That must be one reason why he could never come out to the light as he wished..

[@Shaina_singh_amrita]

🤔

[@shubho_dutta]

,💯💯💯💯

[@haimantidas754]

@@omanam3799 he didn't came out because he wanted privacy and that's why gumnami baba denied about his Austrian wife as they could be in danger as a British organization was looking for him. And he might be suffering from PTSD as he said that America bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki to defeat Azad Hind which shows that he was suffering from trauma

[@omanam3799]

@@haimantidas754 That doesn't suits or matches with the personality of this great hero. A hidden marriage is really strange for a courageous personality like him when he had already denied many proposals for the sake of his responsibility towards his country & love for spiritual life. And how is it possible that, he is ready to put the life of others close to him in stake, but not his wife and daughter? Really unacceptable. If Purbi Roy sticks to her Siberian version, then Chandrachur Ghosh is fighting for his version and proofs. Seems somewhere Nehru is getting whitewashed very much. And if Bhagwanji could get into covet activities, then is his meeting with his daughter & wife a big deal for him?? Many have said his daughter is too insensitive about him while we younger generation Indians aren't that insensitive about him like her. May be what Chandrachur is saying is not the final version and there are other missing angles too to be added by some others with passage of time. Chandrachur depends on evidence, and India is the best place for getting manipulated fake evidences. Accepting Netaji as Bhagwanji, but not all verdions of Chandrachur.

[@truth_seeker1234]

Anuj dher,thanks alot to work so hard for years n years.

[@hrithikjena1969]

I personally don't consider Gandhi as the father of our nation....

[@oldmonkwins2083]

Gandhi is never a father of the nation. He is a thug

[@standalone886]

I respect Netaji above Mahatma Gandhi. Netaji is in my blood, in my emotions, in my spirit...If Netaji had come back as Gurnami Baba , why would he hide behind??? He would have worked for the betterment of Independent India. Great leader Netaji Zindabad ...

[@ranjanavishwakarma6352]

He and his soldiers did not fight for divided india and fool people were gandhis bhakt for whom he should have done struggle again.

[@informaticsglobal]

Netaji was declared a war criminal and when the pact for independence was signed they agreed to hand him.over to the British dead or alive so he had to live a life of seclusion and sage..they conspired against him

[@kushanchoudhury1942]

Gd bakshi sir with all due respect this is not india Pakistan howling debate... Ur up against anuj and chandrachur who have dedicated more than 15 years researching this mystery... So please come prepared!!

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

Bakshi Uncle looks interested in hushing up the issue just like Bose's relatives WOnder Why? There is more to this mystery than meets the eye

[@indrason6974]

He Bakshi wrote two books about netaji and thinks he was killed in ussr by Nehru's request which is possible because we have a gap in information on how we got to India as babaji

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

@@indrason6974 Coming from Russia to India ain't a big deal in those days. Even borders were open at that time

[@indrason6974]

@@SAFFRONINFERNO he was in Siberia in a gulag coming from there threw tibet and then not getting caught specially when half the raw is after you is really hard

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

@@indrason6974 You are talking about older times.The RAW or IB thing had cooled down after joker Nehru had died.Nepal India Border entry is easy, Russia- China- Nepal - India There is no need for him to escape as such from Gulag when the dispensation softened their stance and allowed him to leave.

[@arpita3956]

Republic tv.... great work!

[@vivekaguy]

Are you from West Bengal?

[@naveenjoshi8205]

Arpita jokar sale

[@arpita3956]

Naveen Joshi joker! You... ! Your mother giving birth to you sitting in Shaheen bagh... !

[@arpita3956]

Naveen Joshi empty headed gutter

[@arpita3956]

Naveen Joshi your pakistani father with 18 wives!

[@somik2000]

"I, many of the Bose family and millions of Indians have long been of the firm view that Netaji did not die in a plane crash at Taihoku Aerodrome on 18 August 1945, for the simple and excellent reason that there was no plane crash at Taihoku Aerodrome on 18 August 1945…On 22 September, I appeared before the “Gumnami Baba” Commission of Inquiry. Deposing as Commission’s Witness no. 1, I stated on oath that the nameless saint might well have been none other than Netaji…" Jayanti Bose Rakshit, Grand-niece of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose."

[@jadumanisaha2458]

There are many undeniable proofs from Gumnami Baba theory but no proof from any other theories, only speculations! So our natural choice is Gumnami Baba and personally I feel that situation compelled Netaji to do so for not being killed or for not to be handed over to Russia or America as a war prisoner! He wanted a stable non Congress govt to come to power as an ideal situation to disclose his real identity! Unfortunately it didn't happen!

[@srbhanja]

Ardhendu Bose, A Bose family member admits that he knew about Gumnaami baba, when no body knew it. How uncomfortable he was when he was countered by Arnub Goswami.

[@vishalsrivastava8450]

Exactly

[@amitmaurya1486]

Somehow I feel that they were -the family threatened by pseudo Gandhi bastards to me he looks like lying under some pressure jus a thought

[@SamvedIyer]

@@amitmaurya1486 True. I, however, cannot fathom why he would have to hide facts pertaining to his uncle even today in 2020.

[@ishanghosh4385]

Suresh Bose and many others were aware of gumnaami baba ! I think sarat Bose was also aware

[@SamvedIyer]

@@ishanghosh4385 Not possible. Sharat Chandra Bose passed away in 1950. Gumnami Baba is supposed to have entered India in 1953.

[@informative1009]

Netaji is great

[@sulatasarkar8771]

Hindusthan wait kor raha kob Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose ka picture Indian Rupees mey niklega..

[@ajitghosh7806]

Thank you for raising the issue ! Netaji is alive in our heart ❤️

[@Randomstupidthings]

Even name give me goosebumps

[@ayushdwivedi6892]

The handwriting thing really fascinates me...I mean 12 matching characteristics is very intriguing.. it can only be done by super humans

[@surarnab]

It is very conclusive that Gumnami Baba is Netaji.

[@swapnachandboral9790]

Republic.. hini...repub...Bengali..famous...news..is..

[@puspashreepandamishra8782]

I remember when I was a kid there was an article on gumnami baba in a weekly Hindi magazine called ‘ dharmyug’ that my mother used to buy . Some more articles on gumnami baba being Subhash Bose had come up in other magazines & news paper too .this was either late 60’s or early70’s . Much before he passed away. So the panellist mr Bose is lying when he says he didn’t know anything about gumnami baba before his passing away .it’s suspicious

[@user-qc9ht7fh5d]

Yes they all knew about it.....

[@arnablahiri7023]

🇮🇳Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose🇮🇳 All of us, every indian is from Bose family.

[@ihithasrinivasan4568]

15:38, 16:38 Good Qs with No Answers in this Debate. 1. How Bose Family knew about Gumnaami Baba before he Died in 1985?? 2. Why did the Bose Family Lawyer said that Subhash Chandra Bose is Alive??

[@ihithasrinivasan4568]

Personally I think Bose was Captured by the RUSSIANs, if he ever came back to India then HOW will be a very Interesting Q for these Researchers to find out. 👍

[@familyghalsasi5251]

Radio broadcasts in 1946 is known. Mahatma Gandhi sent telegram to family asking not to perform last rites.

[@indranilzee]

@@ihithasrinivasan4568 Maybe Russia is not interested to dig the fact. Russia , Japan and America may have the truth.

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

1. Sarat Chandra Bose (Netaji's elder brother) was informed of Netaji being alive by his close loyalists Sarat informed his Mother and both went to their grave knowing that Netaji was still alive.It's possible that they might have even met secretly or had communication somehow.That was the reason Joker Nehru was using IB to Snoop upon whole family. 2. Family Lawyer must have got instructions from the Family Heads to stick to the stand of Bose being alive . Even Crook Gandhi informed the Family that Subash wasn't dead.Gandhi also informed Nehru the same.Nehru was a power hungry crook started getting schizophrenic and used all means to stop Netaji from coming openly with the help of British and Allied forces including Uncle Sam.

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Some of them went there to meet him after they have heard of the rumour..

[@subhrajitbiswas1149]

Thank you so much to open Netaji's chapter. All time great freedom fighter

[@ajitghosh7806]

Anita Bose with due respect how gumnami baba is insult to netaji! You never met him! You were never proud of him ! But we are and we are eager to know his story

[@jvidyaranya]

Nothing would be done for netaji as for her daughter..let her daughter to take care of her Germany and we'll care for INDIA..

[@aniksen9898]

How do u know she is her daughter?? And she and mother was not a nehuru implant

[@pabitranandan3114]

Vidyaranya J, fake wife and doughter.

[@bhaskarkhan4107]

@@aniksen9898 true brother...We also don't believe netaji could marry....

[@IMMABUSTYOURASS]

@@bhaskarkhan4107 There were pictures of Emily Shankle and Netaji together....do you even know what the hell are you saying?..

[@IMMABUSTYOURASS]

@@pabitranandan3114 How illiterate are you?....and you are taking pride in being that way that is what shocking me

[@dibyendugupta4127]

Nation stil waiting to know original facts of netaji after so many decades.come on

[@divineray7822]

His family has turned traitors to him. Listen to Anuj Dhar talk on Srijan Talks.

[@arjundey1814]

It is very well understood that Bose family is doing 2 things: 1.) They are aware of something... 2.) And they just don't want to talk about it..

[@25Ashoka]

Excellent answer Anita Bose Ji Best Wishes Shubhkamnayen 👍

[@phoenixj1299]

No it's not.

[@utubetruthteller]

Handwriting evidence is very strong. Netaji family cannot set aside evidence like that.

[@monojitmohapatra7112]

Heard till 47.25 and I am surprised that all have been blind to one thing. Netaji, even if he survived and went to the USSR and perhaps was to become the Baba, had to stay underground simply because he couldn't be tried as a War Criminal for fear of reprisals in India. It was the most acceptable arrangement between the Congress, USSR, the British, the USA and Netaji himself!

[@savipasu6662]

I wish this debate lasted some more time and Anuj Ji was given more time. Loved the closing statement- Perception Vs Facts - doubt if ashes are Netaji’s ashes

[@Satyam0701]

Came only after seeing Anuj Sir first 👍🙏

[@g.unihongo8721]

Dear Arnav very interesting & informative debt . Thanks.

[@ashapurnamukherjee]

Bose family: Sad!! U r part of his family and talking such nonsence.The problem is Anuj and Chandrachur is doing reserch on fact not on their believe and thats why they are able to bring out so many solid proof and they accept that many links are missing which makes them non partial. I hope there might be some good reason for the bose family for talking such baseless,proofless things.

[@vidyabharatisinha6073]

Anuj Dhar and chandrachur ghose are amazing

[@NSinghad]

Yes Arnab ji we say all have very hard work and respect and encourage

[@samratdey6878]

And Thanks to Chandrachur and Anuj they gave their life in the name of Netaji just they want us to know about Bharat mata's greatest Son which we don't know about.. The dark truth

[@kushanchoudhury1942]

Agar yeh cheez disclose ho gaya to Congress ka na Jaane kitna aur gada murdha nikal aayega. Saala poora expose ho jaayega sabke saamne..!!

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

Bacha kya hai expose hone mein sabhi khangressi starting from Gandhi and Nehru were gutter scum

[@catlover9865]

Infact whole Government of India will be exposed. Its not only the congress party, but the government of India who were Hunting for Netaji.

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

@@catlover9865 That Gov was under Joker NEHRU

[@suryaprakashmohanty9888]

Dear Arnab sir pls bring this issue once again here

[@abhishekchandrajha6526]

I dont know how The Gumani link up of Netaji is insult to Netaji

[@EntertainmentCricketNews]

Apna INDIAN koi to link hai usse....bt gumnami is not netaji.

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

There is a link between Netaji and Gumnaami Baba You don't know facts

[@hari7priya]

Anti-Hindus and anti-nationalists would never want to accept Subhash Chandra Bose taking a path of Hindu Sanyasi!

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

@Hardrisht Chawla Chutiya Tu Hai Netaji ke baare mein kuh padle he was a TANTRA practitioner He was already a Sage when he was leading INA. Don't vomit crap here

[@debarghyachattopadhyay2614]

A man like him would not live in shadow... but then again if I was was him I would do same because I would not trust Nehru

[@sunitasharmadevansh2074]

🙏🙏🙏

[@akhiljain5197]

All must watch Video lectures by Anuj Dhar on Netaji . I watched and now I am totally out of the Gandhian Narrative of Independence.

[@swaralipi29]

It's a SHAME, that after 75 long years of his disappearance we are still fighting to know the truth of a fighter who gave everything so that we can stand where we are today. We, the people of this country, deserve the truth!!! Every politician who has tried to hush this, is nothing but a traitor to this country and its people! Netaji will forever reign in our hearts. Stop the lies, tell us the truth and pay homage to his deeds!

[@arijitnaskar8151]

Great initiative..thanks republic..

[@dharmendrakumarbajpai9581]

Anuj ji and Chandachur ji great research....keep pursing the case...

[@vidyut682]

What is tried hard to conceal is more visible. Nataji family members knows quite well that Gumnaami baba was none other than Netaji, but they all stupidly attempting hard to deny reality, that is real mystery

[@rimilraveendran2194]

First pm of free INDIA 🇮🇳 NETHAJI 🐯

[@macmurphy1122]

We even don't know history of that person who made history.This is bizarre,very shameful

[@thesourav9741]

Salute to Anuj sir

[@veereshamaragatti9876]

Happy to see well mannered debate again on Arnab's show 😀😀

[@mirroruniverse9331]

Because it's a debate between intellects 😁

[@bappabiddu3296]

Kindly answer the following questions: 1. Why wasn't Netaji's wife convinced that HE died in a plane crash? 2. Why are Netaji's files so classified? 3. Why does the Government hesitate to de-classify Netaji's files? 4. Why does the forensic Laboratory dismissed the records? Now, 5. How on earth in the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s an Indian sage residing in a rural area of UP possess the above mentioned items like a binocular made in Germany for German military,... possess so much knowledge in English and denied to show his face and the unmentioned ones such as books about the world, military tactics and many other things (yes, I've done a research on Gumnami Baba) that wouldn't be of any use to the sage. Remember, during those days there were neither internet nor Amazon. Answer? 6. Why would Gumnami Baba keep a photo of Netaji's parents with him when it's in record that he has never claimed to be Netaji ? 7. Why will that sage possess intense and immense military intelligence and knowledge ? I mean how can? 8. At the beginning of the debate, Mr D. Bose claimed to have known Gumnami Baba but he never justified the fact when (in the later portion) he was repeatedly asked that by what nomenclature was Gumnami Baba addressed, he was clearly uncomfortable... 9. Why was Gumnami Baba so fluent in different languages, presuming he's educated, but the level of proficiency Gumnami Baba possessed in each language known to him was unprecedented. How is that possible for just an educated sage? Moreover, let's get it - one doesn't possess education to be a sage. 10. Why is the government equally protective about the identity of that sage and why, yes why, did that sage had visitors from various domains of high level government and military dignitaries? Answer but research about Gumnami Baba. Let's hit some facts: 1. GD Bakshi - Sir, I'm a fan of yours and yes I've never donned the prestigious and highest uniform but there's something I believe you're familiar with - Espionage. Netaji was a master at espionage. Certainly the greatest. It's like a walk in the park for him to escape from Siberia to INDIA. He was never accompanied by anyone from INDIA but Afghanistan. He was actually a Ninja. Facts. Moreover, as a former Army, you should know that he laid the foundation of The Army which has been dissolved but still every graduating batch shouts the same slogan of INA. 2. It's very disheartening to see that alongside the most dominant political party (since post Independence till the New Government came into existence), the family has turned a huge supporter in favour of that party whose early founders were directly responsible for his hiding. It's shameful, disgusting and disgraceful. Had Netaji been someone in My Family, I'd have never sold myself to any power for any amount of favour. 3. This brings me to Netaji's hiding - well, like I said that He was a Ninja and trust me, it takes immense amount of courage, resolution and strength to do what He did. Moreover, He was fearless, non-greedy and never power hungry. His vision and objective was way way ahead of his times. He dreamt of a bigger, powerful, technologically advanced INDIA. He's THE FATHER OF THE NATION. A selfless person. Tell me, why is the Bose family divided about the theory of Gumnami Baba as Netaji? Can you smell it? Some sold themselves while the rest stood firm. 4. In 1955, when Clement Attlee visited India, he was asked that why did he leave India even after having won the Second World War - he said three words, SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE. Imagine, the type of impact he created to remove a 200 year rule. I don't think I even need to talk about that. 5. He kept himself in hiding because he was never fond of illustrious power. Moreover, He didn't want to jeopardise the lives of His family members by coming back to Kolkata. The government was after Him. Those people never wanted Him to come to the forefront as there will be a national outcry because He was the hero of the mass. He still lives in the hearts of billions and trust me, it's a suppressed emotion. 6. He rejected the ICS exam offer even after having secured a position in the top ten. He was a true leader and patriot. On a different context, Lal Bahadur Shastri was supposed to announce something big but he was killed so that no-one ever knows what was that about and after that Gumnami Baba came into existence but Netaji knew that those power hungry rascals will not even spare his family so just to add, he went into hiding as this is absolutely one of the major reasons. I believe I've clearly yet briefly concluded my views but I've a request from the Government of India, which is to kindly A. Authorize Subhash Chandra Bose as The Father of The Nation and let the upcoming generations know the truth about Their MOTHERLAND, INDIA. B. Yeah, not just notes but please replace wherever Gandhi is by Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. The new generation needs to know the truth. Jai Hind.

[@bappabiddu3296]

@@TRA these are facts hidden from the Indian public.

[@2ayonsarkar]

This is Not Gandhi vs Bose. This is Gandhi and Bose. Deep respect to the father and Dada of our nation.

[@sarojpradhan2125]

Jay sanatani

[@dhrdhr8581]

She knows the truth i guess. Paid to keep quiet. She is showing no interest in netaji

[@ShailendraKumar-eq6wz]

भारतपुत्र नेताजी को सादर नमन।

[@ShailendraKumar-eq6wz]

मथुरा मे 1973 मे अफवाह थी ,नेताजी जय गुरूदेव आश्रम मे आते थे।मेरे जानकार एल आई यू के अधिकारी से पूछा।उन्होने बताया "जव भी अग्यात आश्रम मे आते थे ,आश्रम मे सुरक्षा इतनी टाइट होती थी,पक्षी भी पंख नही फड़फडा़ सकता था।उस व्यक्ति के जाने के घंटो के बाद एल आई यू को इस के बारे मे पता चलता था।

[@darmarbera]

Anita ji sorry doesnt have any idea about Netajis lifestyle and thought process...she doesnt have any clue.. We have more emotional attachment than her it seems.. sorry to say... Even doubts is there about any wife our Netaji had ever.

[@ajitghosh7806]

Yea she said in one interview That what is thr to be proud of him! We are eager to know his story!

[@mirroruniverse9331]

@@ajitghosh7806 WHATT

[@PRIYAJAY-SHETTY]

Good Arnab for the topic🙌🙌🙌

[@historicalfactsdzz273]

our true national father 🔥nethaji🔥 real hero❤

[@RomaaBose]

Thanks Arnab Goswami 👍

[@bharath5666]

I believe Gumnami baba was the Netaji,Bose wanted to emulate Vivekananda,ramkrishna paramhansa and wanted to live an anonymous or Ascetic life!!

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

Not really He couldn't come out cause he feared for ALLIED POWERS and it's possible impact on indian public as he was declared as a WAR CRIMINAL

[@hari7priya]

Both the points here are correct!!

[@ranjanavishwakarma6352]

@@SAFFRONINFERNO only fear of possible impact on public actually according to me fool and selfish public nothing else.

[@apuravkumarpal2903]

Jai hindurashtra I support your channel and thoughts bharat mata ki jai vande matram jai hanuman

[@MRRoy]

We want to raise this issue again ...

[@DhaSrma]

Anuj sir gave the facts, blind people can see but these people are not convinced

[@arpita3956]

Clear the mystery and expose nehru .... please government!

[@prabhumahalingam7617]

Yes nation should make things public

[@Alove11111]

Undoubtedly he was netaji! Everyone knows everything about what happened! But people feared to come out and speak because everybody knew what would be their fate or of their family if they spoke ! The ruling government and the infamous family I should say who divided India, earned millions, and lead a lavish life, I must say even today they lead the same life!they were behind all this! It's high time the nation should know who was the real father of the nation in all sense! It's high time we put pictures and story and life of the unsung heroes of India in our history books so that children can get to know who was behind the independence of our nation! It's high time people acknowledge the fact that they already know!

[@karunawatatoo1694]

🙏🏼🙏🏼Soubash chandra boss 🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@abhirupsaha5587]

In my opinion what came out of this debate is that as far as knowledge of Netaji is concerned, all seemed child before Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose...

[@saikatsen3659]

Totally agree. And to hide their inconsistency they are demeaning the effort and knowledge Anuj and Chandrachur has done and has come to conclusions at the end.

[@AnilKumar-tk3bm]

Exactly sir. Completely agree with you..

[@rajkumarchauhan9881]

Netaji is my real HERO.. SALUTE JAIHIND NETAJI. NAMAN AAPKO NETAJI. NETAJI WILL ALWAYS REMAIN IN OUR HEARTS WITH FULL OF RESPECT .

[@sanjibchowdhury4468]

Netaji is not a person.... Netaji is the heart & soul of every true Indian

[@surarnab]

Please take up this issue once again. 🙏

[@dev4911]

Trivia: "From the Mumbai studios...." narration is done by actor Kamal Hassan.

[@vibhore4503]

ARNAB PLEASE DO DEBATE ON THIS TOPIC AGAIN

[@rahulsreekumar6079]

If somebody is hiding the truth of even revealing his after life after freedom its very clear that netaji knew many things that might shatter the image of many leaders in our country .

[@UMESHBHARTI]

अभिनंदनीय वंदनीय प्रशंसनीय प्रस्तुति

[@nishmethashetty]

Gumnami Baba was Netaji! The family itself had politics!! He didn't wanted to be noticed because of this! Even after so many evidences the family refuses lol Bose is a true Indians "Father of the Nation"

[@mezelfnikhil]

Intro is Awesome.... I like it.....👍👍👍

[@chandrowtiesingh137]

Netaji did exist, he did remarkable things to free India, he was with Congress, was with Gandhiji . He left Congress. He was loved by everyone. Let us remember him as a great hero, a great freedom fighter. A great son of India and close this chapter about his death. Pandit Nehru definitely knew about his death. Why Nehru Government was always silent of his death for so long ?The file record was removed. The Indira Gandhi Govt. did not say anything about his life also. She was silent. No one can doubt about his struggle to free India. The Gumnami issue is creating new doubts. Hope it it is true.

[@kaustavdey2284]

Netaji was accompanied by Bhagat Ram Talwar in Peshawar. Not in Kolkata. G.D Bakshi , is giving false information. Nothing is impossible for Netaji. He is a warrior . He is a Samurai.

[@pushpagarg2054]

Very good conversation

[@manish5058]

Love u so much for this ...one... I love you so much......like anything... bcoz of u making video on Netaji. ,. I pov d netaji.....like anything....meven far far far far far far far more than modijii