An analysis of the various theories on the fate of Subhash Bose | Anuj Dhar | Hindi

In this talk, Anuj Dhar, once again, tries to make sense of the waxed issue, one of the longest-running controversies of modern India and takes one through the three accepted theories about the fate of Netaji the official line being that he died in a plane crash in 1945. He examines a number of eyewitness accounts, documentary proof, and forensic evidence, to reveal the multiple inconsistencies in the official line and the conspicuous cover-up by the government (including the melting of INA’s treasure gold and being credited to Nehru’s personal account) make it hard to believe. The other two theories are that he died (or rather, was left to die in the cold snow) in Russia, and the third and the most plausible one- that of Gumnami Baba, who lived till 1985.
Dhar explores all the theories and smashes to bits, the Justice Mukherjee Commission’s cover-up of the case.
बोस 1939 में भारतीय राष्ट्रीय कांग्रेस के अध्यक्ष थे, लेकिन महात्मा गांधी और नेहरू के साथ राजनीतिक मतभेदों के कारण उन्होंने उसे छोड़ दिया। वह भारत से पलायन करने के बाद, पहले हिटलर की जर्मनी गए, और बाद में जापान, जहां उन्होंने 1943 में 40,000 सैनिकों की मजबूत भारतीय राष्ट्रीय सेना का पुनर्गठन किया. जो की 1857 के स्वतंत्रता संग्राम के पश्चात अंग्रेजों के विरुद्ध पहला सैन्य प्रतिरोध था।
ऐसा माना जाता है की, जापान द्वारा मित्र देशों की सेना के सामने आत्मसमर्पण के तीन दिन बाद, बोस की (48 की आयु में) 18 अगस्त 1945 को ताइवान में एक रहस्यमय विमान दुर्घटना में मृत्यु हो गयी।
उनकी मृत्यु के रहस्य पर वर्षों तक पर्दा पड़ा रहा। क्योंकि उससे सम्बंधित सभी फाइलें प्रधान मंत्री कार्यालय, सूचना एवं प्रसारण मंत्रालय और विदेश मंत्रालय के पास धुल खाती रही और आने वाली सभी सरकारों ने दशकों तक उन पर प्रतिबन्ध बनाये रखा।
अनुज धर, 'इंडियाज बिगेस्ट कवर-अप' के लेखक, ने पहली बार जनवरी 2015 में राष्ट्रीय अभिलेखागार में इन फाइलों को देखा।
About the Speaker:
For more than a decade, Anuj Dhar has devoted himself to resolving the mystery surrounding the disappearance of Subhash Chandra Bose. He has authored several books about Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and the theories about his death/ disappearance He has authored several books, like Back from Dead, Conundrum, Your Prime Minister is Dead, What Happened to Netaji, all revolving around the locus of the disappearance/ death of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. His 2012 bestseller, India's Biggest Cover-up (Netaji Rahasya Gatha in Hindi), triggered the demand for declassification of documents pertaining to Netaji. He is also the founder trustee of Mission Netaji, campaigning against the Bluff that the successive governments have fed to the people of India.
वक्ता-
अनुज धर ने एक दशक से अधिक समय तक सुभाष चंद्र बोस के रहस्यपूर्ण ढंग से गायब होने के मुद्दे पर शोध किया है। उनकी 2012 की सर्वश्रेष्ठ विक्रित पुस्तक ने बोस फाइलों के गैर-गोपनीयता की मांग को गति दी।
Subscribe to our KZbin channels:
KZbin English: / sangamtalks
KZbin Hindi: / sangamhindi
Follow Sangam Talk on social media :
Telegram : t.me/sangamtalks
Twitter: / sangamtalks
Facebook: / sangamtalks
Instagram: / sangamtalks
Website: www.sangamtalks.org
Donate: www.sangamtalks.org/donate

[@arunsaini208]

Anuj and team my respect to you. You are doing great work. Nation needs more people like you.

[@AAA.23.23.]

सच्चे राष्ट्र पिता नेताजी सुभाषचंद्र बोस अमर योद्धा को नमन।🙏🙏🙏

[@pratham5719]

Wow THE KING on subash bose issue is back on sangam talks Mr. Anuj Dhar i am his huge fan By the way if chandrachur sir would have been there it would have been super awesome.

[@kushalaikat3785]

He said he is coming live on another channel in same time

[@mrshadowcool174]

They both have their own KZbin channels. Follow if you need latest report by them.

[@sanjaysrivastava7928]

Khair Aapne jitni khoj ki survey kiya wo JABARDAST HAI ,Netaji ki AATMA aapki is koshish per jaroor prasann hui hogi.

[@sutapabiswasghosh193]

I am really grateful to you Mr Dhar. You are doing an excellent job. My strong support will always remain with you to have success in Netaji's matter.

[@ashutoshpandey2043]

A man ,who sacrificed everything, and went through terrible hardships, problems, sufferings, and challenges for the welfare of people.. Salute to you, Netaji

[@ABHI-ip3mu]

Thank you Anuj sir for bringing the truth forward. Great efforts. It is irony of this country that nation builder had to live in such silence. India would have be different if Netaji would have been our first Priminster.

[@tomandjerry9516]

Anuj Dhar Ji Ki Jitni Research Agar Koi Gandhi Par Kar Leta To Use Aj Bharat Sarkar Bharat Ratna De Deti 😂☹️

[@NativeVsColonial]

@Ram Prassada Their are movies already made on Subhas Chandra Bose and Lal Bahadur Shastri 1. Gumnaami (2019) 2. Bose: Dead/Alive (2017) 3. The Forgotten Army (2020) 4. The Tashkent Files (2019)

[@indiancoder8301]

@@NativeVsColonial one more Netaji The forgotten Hero kzbin.info/www/bejne/jZTdh5impJyZgdk

[@ved6961]

@@NativeVsColonial The Tashkent File is on Lal Bahadur Shastri

[@NativeVsColonial]

@@ved6961 Still a political mystery, so I shared :)

[@bhagatsinghnathuram7289]

Don't bring in gaddar like Gandhi in this programme.

[@Raj-mw9gb]

Great work Anuj. Its time Government under the able leadership of Modiji recognises Netaji’s stature in Indian politics and declare him to be the First PM of India. Indian freedom History needs to be rewritten.

[@mantechvlogs5902]

Modi ji declared netaji as father of the nation

[@wesleyteenwesley]

First Indian Prime Minister is SCB

[@subhashkumbhar100]

How you get energy ? Really hats off to your work. Yes no doubt Netaji was Gumnami baba. Jai Hind.

[@rakeshbambhaniya8836]

Netaji is still my hero!

[@tomandjerry9516]

*Still? He always was and will be 🙏

[@justarandomguywithoutaname8719]

Same here

[@rajatbiswas6850]

Respect to you, Anuj ji and team

[@neetusandhu8427]

Netaji ke sach ko le k aap intni mehnaat kar rhe ho ji 👍👍

[@neetusandhu8427]

Anuj Dhar sir. Proud of you sir.... 👍👍👍

[@vkbhatt1495]

Dear Anuj Dher ji *, Aapne Mahaan Savtantrta Seinani Neta Ji Subhas Chandr Bose Ke vishaye Mean Atyant Ullekhniye Kaarye Kiya Hai .*

[@susantaroy352]

Netaji ko lekarke is data bohothi strong he, salute my Hero❤️❤️❤️

[@shamsherbahadur8496]

As a aware citizen, It is our duty to uncover truth unbiased leaving no one as angel

[@g.mukherjee1103]

A Patriotic Saint.

[@rohandesai8369]

#MamtaStands4Subhash #MissionNetaji Dear all , its time to not let the issue die and irrespective of politics , to push the Bengali pride agenda on Twitter. Force the right wing Gandhi Bhakts at centre to listen. The Gumnami Baba museum in U.P. is still shut , it has 7000 original articles. The IB files are still not out. Politics is the necessity for change. " How could DNA tests be doctored? " " Political Science , the mother of all sciences ! "

[@abhinav7302]

Mamta sont anything now. Pressurise modi, he's the only hope.

[@Sunny-rh6ik]

Hats off to your work sir 🙏🚩

[@pnsingh8150]

Anuj sir, keep it up and keep your Flag flying,, after all odds you will win the race

[@dr.balwantshastri3228]

आपकी मेहनत को कोटिश सलाम । नेता जी उपलब्ध होने पर ब्रिटेन को सोंप दिया जायेगा इस तरह का कोई इकरार भारत सरकार की ओर से किए जाने का कोई प्रमाण है तो आप सार्वजनिक करें ।आपकी मेहनत व नेता जी के लिए श्रद्धा को पुन: सलाम ।

[@YashwantsinghShekhawat]

🙏 वाह !! श्रीमान अनुज जी.. बहुत स्पष्टता से प्रमाणिक तथ्यों रखा, बहुत सराहनीय है.. आपका मंगल हो.. 🎉🎉 .

[@princekay8263]

Ww

[@sushant3201]

Anuj Dhar has done amazing research on Netaji. Wish his presentation skill was as good. To someone like me, at 82 I knew very little about our heritage and history. Launch of credible social media channels like this one have helped been me learn factual narrative on भारतवर्ष। Sythesising long narrative covering essentials is an art. I find DH Dubey and AKTK are two channels जिनका प्रस्तुतीकरण सराहनीय और प्रभावशाली हैं। लंबा प्रस्तुतिकरण is unable to inspire most people to listen.

[@govindmohansarkar9113]

सर जी आपको और आपके चैनल परिवार को नमन । सर जी आपको और आपके चैनल परिवार से आग्रह है कि आप इसी तरह गद्दारों द्वारा देश से छुपाया गया सारे सही इतिहास को देश के समक्ष उजागर करते रहिए ताकि पूरे देश जान सके । जय हिन्द जय भारत वन्दे मातरम् ।

[@sapnaghosh6272]

Bahut sach samne aa gaya hai. Jai bharat .Mr.Anuj Dhar ji ka prayas safal ho. Jai bharat.

[@biswabhusan9331]

Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose is deserve the respect what he did for us. Anuj ji ap lage raho. Hum v tweet pe tweet kar rahe he pmo aur modi ji ko

[@vedashriram39]

Anuj and company, hats off to your grit and determination. It's tough to sustain it over such a long period. May you reach your ultimate goal and in the process enlighten us.

[@anupvkale1]

Fascinating story and great indepth presentation, hope we get to know the truth one day. A great person like Netaji deserves his due respect.

[@umeshgopalakrishnan1203]

Thank you Anuj. I came across a video last night about Netaji's mysterious death and then I saw your videos and I'm just hooked. I'm shocked beyond words. Thanks a ton for this brilliant journalism. I'm going to read your book now.

[@dr.o.p.saxena8309]

Very great revelations on Netaji's death mystery unearthed by Anuj ji. The truth which emerges from the theories put forward in this Video seems totally memorable and those who ruled India for 65years would be brought to books. Yet it should be done at the earliest and this can be done during the present Govt's Regime.Alas it could be done.

[@gaganhind8159]

I wish Netaji ki mystery jald jald se suljh jae shuljhi to hai hi but most of people don't

[@suchandrachakraborty821]

Excellent presentation. Thank you so much. God bless you. 🙏

[@Maitrastudyclass]

Thank you Anuj Dada... 🙏

[@kanika2686]

Anuj Da....we will never forget your self less affort to revele this.

[@chandanchatterjee9577]

A great sage who at last escaped from Russia to India through Himalayas and stayed a short.while.later again he took shelter in cave of Himalaya some shoulders have seen him in1987 and in deep trans of Tapsya he is only an immortal in modern time

[@kalavathydhanashekar9147]

Excellent sir keep up d good work god bless u sir truth will always make its way jaihind 🙏👍🇮🇳

[@Avenger62]

Thankyou for your research Anuh dhar ji

[@hinduwarrior123]

Anuj you have become my favourite addiction ! I loved your book too. Awesome work brother!

[@jayeshdube8448]

Hats of to your hardwork

[@BaBaDeepakUKwale]

Neta ji Subhash Chandra bose Amar rhen 💐🙏💐🙏💐🙏🇮🇳

[@ESP5576]

He should be respectful while addressing Netaji.

[@proliptabiswas8858]

Anuj Sir Zindabad

[@country9825]

Netaji was so handsome.

[@rakeshbambhaniya8836]

आप तो सबकुछ खोलकर ही दम लेगे।

[@malaashok173]

Too good presentation

[@tilaktalks6896]

Itna important issue hai dekhne wale hi nhi hai desh ke log is issue pe interested hi nhi hai.

[@depressedyolk897]

Commendable work!

[@hansparam]

Great work

[@medicalsupport5251]

You continue sir

[@BHATNAGAR]

Great work. Anuj pay attention to quality of sound and picture. Easy to loose focus on this very important subject. Cheers from Canada.

[@sureshrai6860]

Anuj Sir is also patroit and real son of india, Salute to Anuj Sir....jai hind..... Jai hind

[@mikesheth5370]

Great leader like Netaji would have come out in open if alive! He knew very well whole india was behind him. Even no Japanese General of Burma war theatre was charged by Allied powers! Netaji was never charged for war crime. Waging war against Brits could have been easily refuted by great lawyers of the time!

[@depanjalapgcl3603]

Remarkable

[@UmaChakraborty-kq9dr]

anuj sir now i am crying aapke sath mein jana chata hoo

[@mr.rajbosejee8280]

Truth

[@arupkumarseal9157]

Good news thank you

[@PremKumar-ry4fp]

You are true sir ❤️

[@gyansagar13233]

On occasion of 125 birth anivarsary of NETAJISHUBHASHCHANDR in my personal opinion contact to Tarak mehta ka ulta chasma team to make short video of netaji in last of program ( Shailesh Lodha last talk ) bcoz tarak mehta has huge fan following. Regards pranjal Upadhyay jai hind

[@knowledgehub5916]

That was bind blowing

[@heerachaudhary6748]

💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯Salutes to you man... Bravo Shabd kam padenge to thankyou enough....

[@UmaChakraborty-kq9dr]

anuj sir jai hind

[@archanayadav460]

Neta ji Subhas Chandra Bose ♥️♥️🇮🇳

[@user-jf9tg1fu1i]

!! सतयुग में हरिश्चंद 👏 त्रेता में राजा रामचन्द्र👏 द्वापर में योगीराज कृष्णचन्द्र👏 कलयुग में संत सम्राट सुभाषचंद्र👏 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 ~!~ नेता सब के सब नेता के नाम पर कलंक हैं ? नेता नाम हैं नेत्रत्व का !! नेता नाम हैं निर्भीकता का !! नेता नाम हैं विश्व को अपना लोहा मनवाने का !! नेता नाम हैं एक उद्घोष का !! नेता नाम हैं '' सुभाषचन्द्र '' बोष का !!👏 ~!~ जिन्हें अपना आदर्श मानता हूँ बस उनका ही मंत्र जानता हूँ , ~!~ ‘’ !! ॐ सत्य ॐ राम गोविन्द हरे !! ‘’ ~!~ आज के नेता तो वर्ड बैंक के प्यादे है इनको तो नेता नही कलंक ही मानता हूँ ! क्यों की नेता शब्द का अर्थ तो बस पूज्य नेता जी सुभाष चन्द्र बोष जी को ही पहचानता हूँ !! !! ॐ सत्य ॐ !! हो मंत्र जिनका जय हिंद का दिया जिन्हो ने नारा !! अपने प्राणों से बड कर हमको देश है अपना प्यारा !! ~!~ है हिंद - है सुभाष ~!~ ~!~ अमित आनंद ~!~ 23 -01-11 , 4:30 प्रातः

[@UmaChakraborty-kq9dr]

anuj sir now i am crying please you come very soon and i will go to with you

[@ahanandahvedsworld2816]

I don't understood much.. but I'm interested newses about netaji.. so i listen... something can grasp.. but more not... ha ha... salute netaji... salute you anuj and others behind this mission ( i am poor in english and very poor in hindi )

[@veefour100]

Can you give link for talk in English/video with Eng subtitles on the subject of *Netaji Subhadh Bose.

[@suvodipmondal7625]

It's not Subhash. It's SUBHAS. DON'T MISSPELL LEGEND'S NAME.

[@malkeetbarnala7926]

All our children know about Neta ji in their books is just that - Azad Hind Fauj ki sthapna Neta ji Subhas Chander Bose ne ki thi. That's it. Kaise ki, kyun ki, kisliye ki sari history blurr kar di gai.

[@dipasinha663]

#ModijiWeWantsToKnowTheDeathMysteryOfNetajiSubashChandraBose👏👏👏🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@Dinanath-iy6yc]

सुभाष चन्द्र बोस , लाल बहादुर शास्त्री , राजीव दीक्षित, ये तीनों अपने ही जयचंदो के मारे हुए हैं, भारत का यही दुर्भाग्य रहा है हमेशा से,,, काश आज राजीव दीक्षित होते। भारत ने कोहिनूर खो दिया 🙏♥️

[@PradeepKumar-df3gz]

Anuj Dhar ji se ek sawaal,itna mahaan yodhha Kolkata se Kabul,Russia,GermanyJapan phir INA aur 11 countries se recognition.Due to circumstances of WW ending, fate of Japan a news of plane crash in Taiwan.He hide himself dessolving INA all activities.Why he not appeared/came to light in India?Was Nehru so powerful that he and Gandhi would have handed over Netaji forcefully to England?What would have the reaction of mostly illeterate and KOI NRIP HOYE HAMHI KA wali soch wale BHARTIYO ka?Why Netaji had no faith on illeterate Bhartiya and chose to remain din dhin sanyasi and hide himself in his own India ?How painful is this to think and how Netaji faced all such things silently and not telling anyone openly that he is Netaji?

[@annamalayadevi]

Looking at over all point of view...it's really saddening....what i get from everything is....look at this...even if it is proven netaji was gumnaami baba....what does it infer....death of democracy, patriotism,passion, emotions....so sad ... situation of hopelessness arises....today's narcissistic world has made a tiger turn towards spirituality.... because a person like netaji also came to know...it's over....forget scope...there is no space for hope.....just observe...and see the aftermath and annihilation of this human race...🙏😥

[@sadanandpadala1042]

Full support

[@abcnews2856]

Azad hind fauj was formed by sardar Mohan Singh, and not by Subash Chander Bose, long before Subash Chander Bose.

[@bharatjain72]

i am convinced that bhagwanji was indeed subhas bose. But i am ashamed that the entire government machinery has colluded to hide the fact and give a true patriot his true share. for a flamboyant person like bose to live a life of gumnaami is dardevilry. once these facts are proved generations in india will find it difficult to believe that such a person lived in india.this also shows the congress governments in poor light. it is high time we recognise this true patriot of india. Modi govt must open their ib files and if needed get them from kgb also. my salutes JAI HIND

[@VishalKumar-uj4kn]

Modi is doing just politics. Don't expect much from this gujarati thief. Subhash bose is a true legend. We should pressurise the current govt. for adding the Subhas bose history in school curriculum.

[@binoysengupta8457]

It appears that Government of India knew that Bose was living in India.It was a mutual arrangement with the Government that he will live in cognito as a Sadhu not interfere in country' s politics. Netaji took all care not to be identified and talked behind the curtain. He also had to change places as per t said arrangement. The US , Britain USSR and Government of India jointly chalked out this special arrangements because Bose was in love of his mother land and wanted to live and die in his country.

[@shekharsrivastava7147]

Mr धर बहुत speed से बोलते हैं जो प्रभाव को बहुत कम कर देता है। काम शब्दों में भी ...तैयारी के साथ...बात को कह सकते हैं....बहुत जल्दी में लगते हैं

[@RanjeetKumar-rm3jx]

सर,जो महिला भगवन्त जी के साथ रहती थी वह कौन थी ।वह उनके मृत्यु के बाद कहाँ गई ।क्या उस महिला का वयान लिया था ।

[@UmaChakraborty-kq9dr]

anuj sir aap khub achhay ho

[@virbhadra7523]

The question is why he become gumnami baba?

[@monindrahajong1875]

Keep it up.

[@pranitbangar8314]

Kal hi mene gumnami movie dekhi 🤩

[@prabalbasu6458]

Kaisa laga Prasenjit Chatterjee ka acting??☺

[@97444gaurav]

@@prabalbasu6458 Movie dekh kar lagg raha tha ki use movie mein Prasenjit Chatterjee nahi hai balki hum khud Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ko jeete-jaagte dekh rahe hain. Brilliant piece of work !

[@mandakineesahoo6993]

Full movie konsi utube channel per dhikhari hen. Please tell me.

[@pratibha9919]

Subhash chandra boss jindabad. He is alive in our hearts 💕

[@veefour100]

Why can't you give English subtitles...

[@4z4d]

इस वीडियो को हिन्दी चैनल पर भी डाले

[@umachakraborty3911]

sirf mera anuj sir aap mujhpe daya kariye🌟👑💏💕❤💙💖💟💚💛💜💓💗

[@ngpradyumna]

Gist: DNA report of Gumnami Baba from many foreign independent labs would be a crucial step in solving the mystery.

[@samirmallick8194]

Jai Hind

[@sumitrak.c.paneru1829]

My question is that why he lived in disguise??

[@UmaChakraborty-kq9dr]

anuj sir mein khub dhukhi hoo

[@DhaSrma]

Hudge respect sir,,,

[@UmaChakraborty-kq9dr]

anuj sir aap kaha ho? anuj sir aap kaha ho?

[@shamsherbahadur8496]

Thanks Anuj to collect the evidences about Netaji ...I request you to compile all evidences in a book shape ... Leaving a evidences for others who want to forward this research ... It shall be available in public domain as document with bibliography

[@lakshaybansal2159]

It's already put into multiple books, "India's biggest cover-up" by Anuj Dhar, "Conundrum" by Chandrachur Ghose and Anuj Dhar

[@rahulghosh9528]

😂😂 kahan se ho bhai? Unka Books ko lekar film , webseries ho chuka hain.

[@prashantmathur52]

Netaji hamare liye ache honge, west ke liye he was a war criminal, wanted to collaborate with Hitler. This makes it more complex for truth to come out..

[@SurajKumar-mz6ev]

Jay hind

[@sateshwarkukreti1383]

Anuj Dhar ji you done great job regarding Bose.

[@pnsingh8150]

How can I will help 🆘 you

[@Hollyw373]

हमें एक योजना बनानी चाहिए इसमें सरकार कुछ नहीं करेगी जो करना हो अपन लोगों को करना होगा 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@saibalchatterjee4565]

Netaji is our first Prime Minister of Indipendent India. This should be declared by Govt of India. Instead of Gandhi, Netaji should be made father of nation bcoz we got freedom only bcoz of his revolution which England PM Mr Atlee himself confessed.