Stabilo Woody 3-in-1 vs Caran D’ache Neocolor II Review

[@serenityjewel]

The Woody crayon only goes down half the shaft of the stick, so you get half as much crayon with the Woody vs the Neocolor. Edited to add: Thanks so much for this comparison. I appreciate your effort.

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

What? That's such a rip off!

[@kathyhackney7950]

I had no idea. Thanks ❤

[@serenityjewel]

@@sketchingtheworldwithkat Yep. The Frugal Crafter bit the bullet and cut one open. I think it’s fraud.

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

It's really deceptive!

[@ritawilbur6128]

I think it's a bit much to call it a fraud. I think the purpose is that you will be able to use all the crayon inside and still have a chunk of wood to hold on to at the end. If the crayon went all the length of the wood, then you would get to a point where you physically can't sharpen it any more even with a knife, and you'd have at least an inch of unusable crayon inside. But it is true that you get less crayon in the Woodies compared to the Neos, and since the Woodies are already more expensive....

[@linda5809]

I was on the edge of my seat till the end! Seriously, thanks for the comparison video.

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

Glad you liked it!

[@Kreative_Rainbow]

Great comparison!! 🥰 The $ was very intriguing!! 👍 I have seen someone cut off the back end of one of the woodies. Half of the shaft is just wood, no crayon. Additional plus for the neocolor IIs is that if you sharpen the neocolor IIs, you can place the shavings in a container or watercolor palette and use it as watercolor paint. It would also let you create your own colors that way. With the woodies, you would have to sort out the wood to do that.

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

Thanks. I never thought of that because I never shave the crayons but yeah, I know a lot of people do.

[@Kreative_Rainbow]

@@sketchingtheworldwithkat You're very welcome!! 🤗😍

[@marielouiseweeksb33attitud33]

This was a great review and answered the questions. Thank you.

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

Glad it was helpful!

[@Scrabbledat]

Great review thanks!

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

Thanks for watching!

[@ChantelleArts]

fantastic video, watched and enjoyed till the end ☺☺

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

Thanks for the visit

[@oficinacaracolinho]

Nice comparison Kat! If I had to choose would definitely prefer the neocolors, but love both for different purposes 🤭

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

I totally agree!

[@krissy2321]

That was interesting, I’ve got some NeoColours but have never tried the Woodys. Thanks for the comparison Kat.

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

Thanks for watching!

[@UJB123]

Interesting. Childrens' art supplies vs adult art supplies. I use the black & white set ... fun. They're for kids so I don't expect them to be anything more than that.

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

Yeah I was quite shocked to realise that the Woodys are around the same price as Neocolours!

[@tarabooartarmy3654]

I have not bought the Woodies because the colors are too saturated for my taste. I prefer pastels and muted colors. That’s why I love the Neocolor II, because they have both saturated and muted colors available, along with some lighter tones.

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

The colour range of the neocolours is a real selling point.

[@chrisgregore359]

Thank you for sharing this information ... I have been wondering what the difference between the two of these are and you are so funny and entertaining. I love your personality. I have heard that the Woody crayon's pigment does not extend all the way through the shaft. So the Neocolor 11s have more pigment ounce for ounce.

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

That’s a great point about the pigment - I’ll have to do another comparison with a few different brands to see how the Woody 3-in-1s compare.

[@karenirving7088]

Sharpen with a knife or blade

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

Good idea :D

[@LisaLewis-p6h]

Look Stabilo is are not Caran DeAshe. Nor do they claim to be! What is the deal???

[@sketchingtheworldwithkat]

They are both water soluble crayons around the same price point and I was doing a comparison between the two.