Star Wars Movies and TV Tiermaker - 2025 Edition

[@ihodga]

Cheers for sharing your thoughts and opinions on the overall content so far, I'm a grown up and I totally know that these are your preferences and I respect them. The respect is earned further as you are constructive in your feedback and also able to like what you like, without worrying about what the rest of the fan base think and being blinded by "what should be where'. Grand stuff.

[@FloydIsMySon]

totally agreed on RotS. Love it, great movie, some of my favorite moments in all of SW. But the pacing isnt great and i honestly find the whole Kenobi/Greivous storyline boring. Kind of harsh but I just think Kenobi couldve been doing something more relevant/impactful. Do you have a favorite season of Clone Wars??

[@reverendsaul]

Man, I have to be honest. I tried watching Andor, and I never got past the second episode. So I obviously can't give a full opinion on it, but I thought it was kind of boring and disappointing. I think a lot of that was of how hyped this show was from so many people, as the best Star Wars show.... Mandalorian took less than 5 minutes, and I was hooked. Andor, when I was done with episode two, I was still thinking, when does it get SO good. LOL I will give it another try, but I feel like I may end up being a minority with that show.

[@cubcos]

Andor has a VERY different structure to it. It has very defined episode arcs - the first three episodes should be watched in one sitting in my opinion because those three form the first full arc. I believe that is why they released all 3 at once when it started because an episode on its own wouldn't really do much. I can understand it is not everyones cup of tea due to this slow burn pace and structure.

[@reverendsaul]

@@cubcos Ah ok, well that gives me some hope then, because I obviously want it to be good...

[@ihodga]

@@reverendsaul Andor is quite a different vibe from the rest of the series for me; it’s more etched in the reality of rebellion. It’s very much a slow burner. Personally, whilst I do love it and rate it high, I wouldn’t say it’s the best and think a lot of why that is said is because it’s not only well planned out and written, but also is was a much needed 12 part story so has time to grow and develop. It covers a year in the timeline so can really flesh things out. It was originally going to be a season per year up to Rogue One but now the second season will be covering the remaining years (4 I believe). It is worth a watch and really ramps things up in the second half of the season with some epic performances and new characters. I feel season 2 will be a much faster pace and hopefully more action. Also, it’s fine to not like or gel with a series even if it’s hyped up like this show has been. Oh and a lot of people were jokingly calling it And-bore when it started; so you aren’t alone. Peace out.