Reading YOUR Controversial MLP Opinions! (again)

[@michaelk5976]

🎶🎵 *The following broadcast is a public announcement!* 🎵🎶 🎙 _My dearest ponies!_ _Book abuse can happen everywhere, everytime and can affect everypony!_ _Please remember to look out and treat every book in your environment with respect, love and care!_ _In case you spot any book abuse, by anypony, no matter how little. Don't mind to inform your local librarian!_ _Every act will be prosecuted!_ _Thank you for your cooperation._ _Your book ponies!_

[@michaelk5976]

Ohh my gosh! 😁 I can't believe it. I never got a pinned comment ever before! This is sooo cool. Thank you. 😎🤩😆🥰💙

[@josef7525]

BOOK ABUSE? I've heard of Animal Abuse but what's Book Abuse?

[@PramkLuna]

Librara-bronies

[@BKinsberg]

i agree i do enjoy reading a LOT and my great grandmother would stay up all night reading novels my whole family are all big readers oh yeah and my aunt has a few published short stories in magazienes and on podcastes

[@tiffanybuckman765]

I can agree with some of it.

[@amymoon1295]

Unpopular Opinion: Flutterbat was Fluttershy’s most iconic character design and I wish we could’ve got more of it.

[@gigilohrmann]

agreed, i liked flutterbat

[@hunterculpepper1973]

I mean we could of her cutie mark vashied implying her to actually been a changling but since changelings were still known for being evil and only so many episodes till they fight tyireck of course they decided to not reveal flutteshy a changling and rainbow dash might be a changling or at least a shadow pony aka sombra daghouter or granddaughter making her father secretly be sombra and her would of been great especially since rainbow dash mother and father barely around because guess what rainbow dash was as rich as rarity it's just she didn't or never cared about money besides her massive castle like house us her belonging plus she's shown to have massive colot of her main aura and speed follow her color it makes sence why the brash Tom boy thrashes herself in makeup if she gags at the thought of wearing any wear else but her hair it would also make sence for the rose color of her eyes

[@Vici.Ritt_]

The fact we also saw her still having sharp teeth but never ever taking about it again in the show makes me a bit mad

[@aliyahphelps4871]

That needs to be a popular opinion

[@ItsChevnotJeff]

​@@Vici.Ritt_ The closest we got was when she tried to be scary during one Nightmare night Episode and found out she was too good at it

[@502ndtrooper]

Is it strange that Luna retires with Celestia? I find it odd that after being gone for so long just ending the career there. getting the chance to “mentor” or co-rule with twilight would have been an interesting dynamic.

[@Twinklethefox9022]

I would have loved to see it. And Luna doesn't seem to have ruled that long compared to her sister. She gets banished for a long time and then comes back trying to basically learn how the world works now. Clelstia could have passed the torch down to Luna.

[@frankyboy8513]

You mean miss i ruined equestrian school systems because i couldnt smile 24/7? Twilight would be mentoring luna. Luna is the antithesis of political drama.

[@brocoverbeygaming4714]

I agree with this, seeing the two together without Celestia would be good with character devolopment,

[@lalalemonleaf5807]

This is super interesting idea. I like it.

[@catbatrat1760]

That... is actually a really good point.

[@Heavilune]

Unpopular opinion Cadence is actually an interesting character, especially in the crystal heart spell. She literally is an orphan Pegasus who gets adopted by an earth pony village, and is loving and has that talent and that stops an evil enchantress and she was the first character to give us a clue that anypony not just unicorns could become an alicorn. I think she has the most interesting backstory however I can understand in a show perspective how she can be uninteresting.

[@Celeste_51]

Totally agree ❤ I think cadence and Celestia are so underrated

[@wind_scratch8387]

Yeah I think the main problem is that her backstory *wasn't* shown in the shshe. She kinda came out of nowhere to be honest.

[@sistinas]

​@@wind_scratch8387LITERALLY WHEN THEY SHOWED HER WITH TWILIGHT AS A FILLY IT WAS LIKE OH HEY ANOTHER ALICORN EXISTS 🫠 I love cadance but I think she was introduced in the wrong way for sure!

[@kanorune]

Cadence has a cool backstory, but in the show she's uninteresting and her design is clearly made to sell toys (even more than other characters). If her design wasn't so generic I would love her tho Season 2 finale is best season finale tho

[@evangeloevoxi]

I absolutely love Cadence, she's probably my favorite princess 🩷💜🩵 Edit: for misspelling

[@shadamyandsonamylover]

No idea if this is a hot take or not, but cozy glow REALLY should have gotten a backstory. She’s a little kid, literally middle school aged and she’s like psycho evil. What happened?!

[@Twinklethefox9022]

I think everyone agrees that she needs a backstory.

[@FreeSkyRebellion]

Agreed

[@llamawalrushybrid]

She seems more like a 7 year old where'd you get that she's a middle schooler?

[@shadamyandsonamylover]

@@llamawalrushybrid I know they only have like 4 or 5 different sizes to show “age” in ponies, but she’s the middle schooler size lol could also be younger but that’s what I was basing it off of.

[@kemonono]

I could've sworn Dash had the most mlp fans how on this earth is she UNDERRATED??

[@kingsfoil5844]

She’s definitely not

[@alexanderliu9376]

She's more overhated tbh. RD haters are so weird how they only focus on her negatives

[@aiuwapi]

definitly what i was thinking as well, i don't know if thise is still the case nowadays, but back when the fandom wad at its peak, Rainbow wad the #1 fan favourite, as well as being Lauren Faust's own fave.

[@nawnaw]

exactly ,she's everyone favorite despite her "bad" episodes. i do love her too but no way is she underrated

[@alias_undercover]

She is so popular that is equally hated and loved by fans.

[@_Kaotaja_]

Bold statement but Applejack was so levelheaded and reasonable they had to intentionally write her out of character when they wanted her to be the main focus of an episode. My prime example of this is “Somepony to watch over me”. Never in the show was she shown to be so obsessive and protective of any pony. She definitely cares for her friends and loves her family but was borderline psycho in that episode. “Applejacks day off” also makes her seem almost stupid. She is a farm worker, she would know how to optimize time and see when her methods are ineffective. I’m early seasons her conflicts and lessons seemed more realistic instead of forced. But biased because she’s my favorite of the main 6

[@alisonwallace5619]

You know, I kinda wonder how The Last Roundup compares in those conditions. Applejack is technically the main focus of the episode. While she might have been drastic about it, I don't think it's out of place that she didn't want to disappoint her loved ones and the rest of Ponyvile. Although you could argue that the rest of the main six were more of the protagonists than AJ. We don't even fully understand her motives until the end of the episode. I think it's been said that Applejack works best as a character when she's helping others. I think Mane Attraction is a great example of that. A good protag doesn't nessisarily need to create their own conflict. Applejack's stubbornness initially ruined her chance of reaching out to Rara, but that same stubbornness encouraging her to keep trying and find a different approach.

[@uniblack591]

Biased or no I absolutely agree. And I think BECAUSE she is your favourite character you spent way more time analysing her and her writing which makes your opinion in my opinion (lol) very valid. I definitely didn’t notice that but now I see what you mean. :) And it’s fun thinking of ways to make her flawed without making it seem out of character? As an applejack expert: do you have any ideas?

[@evangeloevoxi]

I always attributed her fear of leaving Apple Bloom alone with the trauma of losing her parents. I remember reading something years ago, someone came up with the theory that the parents left on the same dangerous trip that AJ was going on during that episode. If you're a huge AJ fan then you've probably heard that before lol. But it made sense to me that she was obsessive over keeping her little sister safe since she was helpless to save her parents. Also it's a kids show so the characters get overdramatized for things like that 😅

[@prcervi]

inflict a week or 2 of minimal sleep on apple and "somepony to watch over me" can work

[@warriorcatkitty]

It's been a while since I've watched the episode, so maybe I'm downplaying it in my head, but I personally think the reason she reacted like that was becuase of losing their parents, she's afraid to lose family like that again, however it might have happened. And it was the very first time Apple Bloom was alone completely. So ehh, idk. I feel like it isn't as out of character as others make it out to be but it FEELS jarring simply becuase we never normally see her like that. Although I agree "Applejack's Day Off" feels really. Odd for her.

[@UpdogBop]

This is more of a positive one, but I really wish we got to see Pinkie and Cheese have romantic development on screen. I loved that they ended up together and they are so cute - I know some people probably don't care but I feel like that would've been so sweet to see them fall in love.

[@thinkwithvideos2238]

if you want to see their romantic developement, then I guess you can read the comics. The start at season 10

[@hellothere1853]

@@thinkwithvideos2238There’s also a new “Romeo and Juliet” comic with Pinkie and Cheese coming next year for Valentine’s Day

[@frankyboy8513]

​@@thinkwithvideos2238"romantic development" equalling one issue where they dont even kiss.

[@ommie_]

@@frankyboy8513 not sure what u mean but they had a kid together

[@frankyboy8513]

@ommie_ yes. Offscreen. Implied sex is not more impact full than kissing. I'm saying their romantic adventures could've been explored better. Big Mac and sugarbelle had more onscreen romance than cheesepie. And they're side characters. Is a smooch to much for Hasbro? Cuz it shouldn't be.

[@Miuu2]

I hated how twilight just morphed into celestia, they should’ve given her a more unique design. Also the way they made her blocky bangs try and “flow” like celestials, looks really bad

[@hearmeout1767]

And Spike looked so bizarre all grown up

[@nikkiskaleidoscope3053]

Exactly!!! Like, I seriously don’t understand how she’s all big and tall now. It honestly looks odd to me

[@ViolentVincent565]

@@hearmeout1767 when i first saw s9 twilight and spike i thought it was fanon bc they looked so bad imo ☠️

[@kadiecrowley]

@@nikkiskaleidoscope3053 Because she had LOADS of power, and I believe was actually still growing.

[@chumby197]

10000000% agree

[@xyobug]

In my opinion Rarity has some of the best episodes, whenever Spike doesn't take a major role in them. I love seeing her artistic process and work ethic, it's almost relaxing in a way and her episodes tend to have important reminders for other artists. (Stand up for yourself and communicate when a customers vision is unrealistic, work on things you enjoy so you don't hit an art block, find inspiration from your surroundings, etc.) Also Twilight x Tempest is good but idk if that's controversial.

[@Starry_Waves]

I agree, rarity episodes are probably the episodes where I learnt the most from as a child, plus they were just really interesting and motivating to watch

[@bobatea1950]

oh i LOVE rarity episodes

[@Diamond_Jubilee]

Unpopular opinion: Princess Luna is the most powerful of the two sisters. She literally turned into a dark evil force that can penetrate basically anything. Celestia only relied on the elements to save her sister. I also think the two sisters should have been shown more screen time, being the literal MAIN CHARACTERS after The Mane Six

[@gabyzz1331]

I wanted to see more of the two sisters past How did they become alicorns or if they had any other friends back in the day.

[@bobatea1950]

I feel like Celestia is more powerful but they don’t show her ENOUGH. i want to see her fight. she’s the SUN. she’s fire, she’s destruction, and she’s light. I just wanna see her be cool.

[@yvindhagester9613]

​@@bobatea1950There was also the dream episode, were she turned into daybreaker, which can be interpreted as Celestial having a similar capacity of evil as nightmare moon. I think Celestial is stronger than Luna, and either right below or equal to nightmare moon. But daybreaker? If she actually turned into daybreaker i think she would beat any other character than discord (he is always beaten by his own hybrid, never because someone is actually more powerful than him) and the Mane 6 with the elements

[@UpdogBop]

We never saw a proper moment for Pinkie Pie to get humbled. The rest of the mane 6 got lessons in toning themselves down reasonably, but why hasn't there been a moment or episode where Pinkie needed to learn that not every situation is a laughing matter. Sure we got the episode where she kept butting in trying to make Maud and Starlight friends but she wasn't causing serious damage there. Or in the movie when she almost gets herself and other killed multiple times but Twilight was unfortunately framed as the villain in those situations. I would've liked an episode for Pinkie similar to how the others had to learn to chill out: Twilight taking Trivia night way too seriously, Fluttershy learning to be assertive but going overboard, Rainbow Dash's pranking episode, Rarity's over-generosity backfiring onto her, AppleJack accidentally being too brutal to the fashion competition contestants etc. There are more examples for each member but these are just ones from the top of my head - but it just shows that Pinkie never got to learn something valuable like the others, Griffon the Brushoff could've been adapted to have Pinkie learn something in that moment but Gilda ended up being the villain, and the same idea was recycled for Rarity in the last season instead of Pinkie.

[@sharingheart13]

I think the reason Pinkie Pie didn't get an episode where she learned that not everything is a laughing matter is because she didn't need that lesson. Even back in Season 1, Pinkie Pie was shown to be sad when a situation called for sadness, angry when it called for anger, and confused when she genuinely didn't understand what's going on. For the longest time, she was the one pony with the most varied emotions. Pinkie doesn't usually make light of heavy situations, and has in fact at times been the one to let someone else know when something is serious. A lot of people see Pinkie as the "lol random" character, but in reality, she's very emotionally mature (not perfect though). She's just has a bubbly personality and isn't ashamed of it, especially because, from the start, she usually knew when to tone it down. Plus, there were a couple of episodes where she was humbled and had to learn to reign in her enthusiasm for the sake of others, namely "A Friend in Deed" (Where she herself explains that friends sometimes just want to be left alone, and that's okay) and "Pinkie Pride" (Where she saw that her extremes were costing her friend's happiness).

[@Technilogica2019]

@@sharingheart13 adding onto this, she was also the only pony that took the parasprites seriously and took it upon herself to lead them out of ponyville. granted she screwed that one up _bad_ but the intent was there, actual ability is irrelevant

[@randomshorts6862]

Cleary you've never seen the smile episode and the rainbow dash birthday episode where she does indeed get humbled in both those episodes. Might be time 4 a rewatch :)

[@hellothere1853]

⁠@@sharingheart13what about pinkies pride she was pretty humbled for like half the episode

[@sharingheart13]

@@hellothere1853 I did list that and "A friend in deed" in my comment.

[@Scarlet_Dragoon]

I think that Sunset Shimmer should've been in the regular series. In the finale we see her in the background when all the characters are shown off, proving that Equestria Girls is canon. Even if it wasn't that often, I would've liked to see Sunset get to know the rest of the Mane 6 and become a part of her own world again. It just felt wrong that after she changed, she never tried to go home. Surely she has family, right?

[@cml6581]

I agree! There’s actually a comic about this in the official MLP magazine, but I would've loved to see it happen in the actual show.

[@retroradkat]

@@cml6581 what comic is this?? I'd like to find it

[@wrightcember]

@@cml6581dude, share the name!!

[@blaquerose121]

Sunset is my favorite character, if she actually became part of the MAIN main six, I would’ve felt so much happier. Honestly she adds a flare that Starlight lacks? For lack of a better term. Starlight wasn’t as compelling of a foil as Sunset was to Twilight. Sunset made the team feel well rounded.

[@Scarlet_Dragoon]

@@blaquerose121 I agree. Starlight was okay, and I am okay that she stuck around, but I wish that Sunset was given Starlight's role as Twilight's student. Or maybe even both of them. They could've been good long lasting friends.

[@lartcheche78]

Opinion : Twilight is still alive, somewhere, alone, with no friends, for the rest of eternity, doomed to watch the kingdom she created fall apart. 🙂

[@FlusteredBushStudios]

i think that’s the fallout like reality they say lol

[@Your_Local_Pacifist]

Okay satan

[@lartcheche78]

@@Your_Local_Pacifist 🤣

[@firerose_3605]

I actually agree with this a lot since it is well-known that àlacorns live for a long long time, so I hope the new gen does something with that but knowing it probably won’t 😭

[@purplepedantry]

​@@firerose_3605 'Sacré Bleu! Ze entrée! She is not cooked!'

[@jasonjasso666]

Counterpoint, having a well rounded character like Applejack in a group full of flawed characters makes her more interesting to me. Something about her dealing with the other ponies’ shit makes me go “She just like me fr!”

[@ashhaep82]

Unpopular opinion: I think they should have made a side series where Twilight and other members of the cast went on friendship missions that ended up resulting in failures. An example being if they were called to solve a friendship problem between two ponies who are upset with one another and fighting, but instead of solving the issue, the ponies go there separate ways and end their friendship instead of reconciling. I think this would have been a good thing to show, because not every mission or task that is faced can be a success. It would have been interesting to see the mane 6 and other characters experience failure for friendship problems they couldn't fix.

[@Drmikemf]

That’s actually a really interesting thought. I wish they touched on the concept of forgiving someone, but still not wanting anything to do with them yk.

[@ashhaep82]

@@DrmikemfIndeed. I think a good example of this could have been presented with Starlight's town. In the show they say all the ponies from her town forgave her, even though a number of them likely had a great deal of trauma from the ideology enforced on them by Starlight. There could have been an episode where Starlight goes back to the town after becoming Twilight's pupil and there would be an air of awkwardness between her and some of the other town's ponies. And when she interacts with them, they tell her their peace and their reasoning behind not wanting to be friends with her, and Starlight, though initially upset and disappointed in not being forgiven by everyone, ultimately accepts their desires, and everybody moves on. It would have been a good lesson to viewers that not everything can be solved with an apology, and even though some people don't hate or dislike each other, they still prefer not to interact with one another due to their rocky history and would be better going their separate ways.

[@summermelody7942]

I like this idea. All we see is every mission they go on being successful, implying that this world is truly perfect But no world is truly perfect

[@ashhaep82]

@@summermelody7942Very true, no world is perfect. One of the problems with FIM is that it shows a world where everything works out for everyone in the end, even though that is not how reality works. Of course, we know this show is meant for little kids, but it would have been nice to have episodes teach lessons about the imperfections of the world we live in and how things don't always go the way we want.

[@antonrueda1044]

I like that idea to an extent, but I disagree with making Twilight and the other cast's missions end in failure and only failure. Doing that will just make the other members of the cast look incompetent while making the rest of the mane 6 look like the only ones that can do things right. What you said at the end can solve that problem and I mostly agree with it. Have the other cast members and mane 6 experience failure. But the other memebers need to succeed too. Even if the mane 6 fails sometimes, making them the only ones to achieve any kind of success will still make the other cast members look incompetent while making the mane 6 look like the only ones who can do anything right.

[@Your_Local_Pacifist]

I've said this before and I'll say it again, Trixie does NOT deserve all the hate she gets. I feel like she's actually a great character and people should appreciate her more.

[@horsesarefuckinweird]

I agree, both in canon, and in the community. It really disappoints me when I see people say she's "selfish" and that she "deserved what she got" when those are far from the truth. She had her home destroyed and was ostracized for something out of her control. If Snips and Snails bringing the Ursa to town was Trixie's fault because she said she defeated one, then by that logic if I told a kid santa was real and they went to the North Pole and died of hypothermia it would be my fault. I will die on the hill that Trixie did nothing wrong in Boast Busters. In Magic Duel, however, it's admittedly harder to defend her, but I can't imagine being homeless, shunned wherever she went, and having her new home immediately vandalized did well on her mental state. Her return in No Second Prances especially rubbed me the wrong way. Despite Trixie and Twilight seemingly making amends at the end of Magic Duel, this episode basically throws that out the window. Twilight actively tries to stop Trixie from becoming Starlight's friend, which ultimately leads to Trixie seemingly trying to off herself. I'm glad things did end up getting better for Trixie, she gets Starlight as a friend, risks her life to help the changelings, and becomes a school counselor, but she should not have suffered as much as she did. Trixie was never a bad person, she was flawed and needed help.

[@Your_Local_Pacifist]

@@horsesarefuckinweird Said it much better than I could ever have

[@Redxboy]

yes

[@7y4ne33]

for me shes just too unlikeable especially in all bottled up it was unbearable to watch😟 i respect ur opinion tho ofc

[@Lucky_Lyra]

I love Trixie so much!

[@BlueBrightYT]

My Opinion: Sunset Shimmer, Starlight Glimmer, Trixie are in contention for Best pony because we see their development from “Evil” to somewhat relatable characters

[@pinkiepiebiggestfan6099]

Finally somepony sees the true greatness of the great and powerful Trixie

[@SunBeeSmoked]

They kinda ruined Trixie in the last couple seasons tho imo. I think one of my least favorite episode of hers is when she assumes Starlight is just going to give her the job of vice head mare of the school and Starlight is the one who ends up apologizing for “not telling her” or something like that even tho she literally did tell her multiple times that she can’t just give her the job and that other applicants are in the running. It’s like we’re supposed to believe Starlight has anger issues when really the only time we see her get that angry is when Trixie is acting like a selfish self centered bitch and Starlight gets gaslit to think she was the problem when most of the time it’s Trixie.

[@bertcarroll1243]

She’s not tickly evil it’s just that she was taken over by the crown

[@lartcheche78]

Definitly

[@TheDanteEX]

Even development aside, along with Starlight, I like that these characters are allowed to kind of be foils to the theme of the show while still being major characters. Of course the theme is friendship, but Sunset, Trixie, and Starlight get to kind of blur that line with the way they interact by being openly snarky, sarcastic, and lightly haze each other in ways the Mane 6 really just often don't. Since not friendships are built the same, it's good to see examples of friendships that don't fit the same mold the Mane 6 have. Same with Starlight and Maud who really just like vibing together, even if their interests don't really align. Most times when any of the main cast gets into a disagreement, they usually have to make an episode out of it instead of them resolving and compromising on the spot. In fact, one of my favorite moments is in "Testing Testing 1, 2, 3" where Rainbow and Twilight take out their frustrations on each other, but Fluttershy sets them straight and they apologize immediately and just move past it and that issue doesn't pop up again. That's so common in friend groups where personalities can clash and it's really good for a show aimed at children specifically to showcase a fight that can commonly happen and the proper way to deal with it right after. We forget the show was trying to teach friendship values for the first 4 seasons, so the moments that highlight good examples are often forgotten. I think season 1 is very valuable because of this.

[@SolarSkylark2002]

Cheese Sandwich was underused. If I remember correctly, he’s hardly ever mentioned, and only appears in three episodes, being voiced by Weird Al Yankovic in only two of those episodes.

[@Mystic_Warriors]

The thing that makes me most agree w this is that pinkie married him, like atleast establish him a little more before having one of the mains literally marry him

[@giraffegirl1691]

I want more Cheese Sandwich as much as the next person, but I think the reason he was so sparingly used may be because Weird Al was too expensive to keep around for a long time. IDK for sure though.

[@crabcakeenthusiast692]

Thats prolly because weird al is expensive but still yeah

[@orphaneater134]

Unpopular opinion: i really enjoyed the addition on donkeys and mules, i just wish there was more lore/significance for them.

[@SilverSpoonRiche]

Agree. I like Snails. I was pleased they gave him a natural talent for sports. Though I miss his Canadian accent.

[@aey3125]

I hated that they abandoned Flash's character, especially as a pony. I would've loved to see him actually developed and a real romantic love interest for Twilight. I may be biased though, because Twilight is my favorite and I was let down that someone she had feelings for was swept aside.

[@shadamyandsonamylover]

Agree so hard. Shining armor got to marry an Alicorn, let twilight love!

[@Carmiineh]

​@@shadamyandsonamyloverit could also give some episodes of a friend that is in love and don't have that time to hang out with their friends like before xp

[@idek-go3lt]

FOREAL Like we were literally ROBBED of this romance 💔

[@amandajohnson7797]

YASSS 100%

[@Twinklethefox9022]

I agree so much. I hate how much flash is over hated because of some shippers getting angry that they can't have her. (Yeah that reason has been confirmed for some...) And then others complain about how he doesn't have any personality other than being twilight's love interest. He was canceled before he had a chance. He could have had time to develop. Maybe even show what it's like being a royal guard for princess cadence and prince shining armor. Honestly if you think about it, he's the only royal guard pony we personally know about like name and personality but that gets thrown away because of angry bronies.

[@summermelody7942]

Not sure if this counts as controversial, but I wish we could have seen more of Ember and Thorax. Their first time meeting in “Triple Threat” gave the concept of them being very good friends an introduction. . .but that friendship all happened off-screen. It would have been fun to see the duo grow in their friendship on screen. The only other time I remember seeing the two of them on camera together at the same time was during the final battle in “Ending of the End P2,” but that doesn’t really count here because there were dozens of different creatures there as well

[@Juria316]

#JusticeforEmbrax

[@baymaxinarmor4133]

Well believe it or not, Some people in the fandom and community did start to ship Ember and Thorax after they met in "Triple Threat". Many would consider that controversial I mean I know your comment has nothing to do with shipping but I just wanted to let you know about that.

[@summermelody7942]

@@baymaxinarmor4133 I only think of them as friends, and nothing more

[@CherryPascalle]

" _Gasp!_ Wow.. that's a big responsibility. I don't think i could really be princess. I would rather stick to what I am awesome at and that's being THE AWESOMEEST PONY EVER!!" Rainbow Dash on character ai. The most real version of her you'll ever get.

[@giraffegirl1691]

Probably not controversial, but still incredibly interesting. I would have loved to see that too!

[@arabellanicolemunarriz4117]

Honestly, Moondancer doesn't have enough screentime. To me, she's an amazing character. And I really enjoyed the times we get to see her.

[@Kuxt0r]

she’s adorable

[@Melody_Gacha_272]

Ya she just needed more development

[@PPEFwatch]

Man I learned some new things: 1. Background characters being overrated 2. RD being underrated 3. Book abuse

[@Zerathina]

I genuinely believe we should have gotten MOOOORE of Countess Coloratura; I mean come on, she’s “the biggest idol pony pop star” and yet with ALL THE WORLD BUILDING, we see her ONE TIME- and she’s one-upped by Songbird Serenade in the movie. HOW did she get so popular? Was her “transformation” slow and rough, or swift and easy? Was her manager the only manager she had? How many songs did she sing? Too many questions, not enough answers- I want more… give me MORE!

[@isabellivasconcelos1580]

Yeeahh I agree, such a shame they didn't bring her back, considering her VA already said she'd have agreed to voice Coloratura more times

[@milkywaygame3924]

Yesss maybe more of her and AJ

[@amesstarline5482]

Diamond Tiara shouldn't have been replaced by her mom after her redemption- she easily could've been a better Chloe from Miraculous.

[@FeligamiAdrizoeSworaDooplivian]

I agree!

[@Spottedstorm27]

As a FORMER Queen Bee enthusiasts, I agree!

[@yay29823]

As a Chloe enthusiast, yeah 😢

[@nameynamd9212]

Really would've been nice to see more from Diamond Tiara trying to become better(the section in Daydreaming Derpy really made it feel unfortunate nothing really happened afterwards, even in external media).

[@alexanderliu9376]

Or MLP's version of Pacifica Northwest

[@crabcakeenthusiast692]

I actually think the cutie mark crusaders were much better handeled and written than the mane 6. The mane 6 were great in seasons 1-3 but afterwards slowly got worse with flanderization and walking their characters backwards to walk them forwards again, meanwhile the crusaders had their best episode in season 5 when they finally discovered their purpose was to help OTHER ponies find THEIR cutiemarks and mostly stayed in tact throughout most of the narrative.

[@kingmaxstatic]

Not sure if this is *unpopular?* But I think Cozy Glow should've been the one to leave the Legion Of Doom and not Sombra. Think about it: she's a new villain and she'd TRY to do everything on her own but fails. This also gives us another chance for Twilight to be like "Okay let me try to reform you this time.". It also would've made the group FAR more impactful in the end. But hey that's just my take. I still love the legion of doom as is.

[@foxzboi_z]

I've got one! Cozy Glow did deserve the punishment she received. I see so many people say she didn't, but she truly did deserve it! Not only did she conspire with two of the *most impactful villains*, but she also was one of the most impactful villains *herself*. Could she have been taught her lesson and been reformed? Probably. But Cozy Glow affected all of Equestria, and probably beyond. Gave the world the G5 crystals treatment. She absolutely deserved to be turned to stone (and be conscious the entire time like Discord was)

[@T_E_G]

Right like I know she was a child, but she was honestly doing the most with tricking the main characters and planning everything. Like this girl knew what she was doing, and at her age too! I'd be fine with her just being "evil/irredeemable" because of her age being "she's just a child" like children can't commit crimes? I just think it's interesting that we got a little kid as an ongoing villain in a show Plus, I'm tired of seeing villains being reformed

[@nixxdra]

She’s like 9 and clearly went through some heinous shit to have her turn out that way. She needs therapy, not to be thrown into literal hell with a dangerous villain. What about her parents/guardians/whoever is supposed to be responsible for her? Aren’t they the ones who actually need to be punished?

[@Tall_Order]

I'm not sure if this is a popular or unpopular opinion, but reformed Starlight Glimmer was a fun character. I enjoyed watching her keep making mistakes with magic, and then teach Trixie real magic.

[@mercyw2937]

i totally agree! she became a comfort character for me

[@freshcupofangst]

I love reformed Starlight. I know a lot people don't because her redemption was...Not the greatest in the series, but I honestly don't care. I think she's fun enough to make up for it

[@watermelon3266]

@@freshcupofangst ye especially since the show made making friends so easy, adding a character that couldn't make friends as easily was heartwarming. She reminded me of myself when I was little because I could only make friends with the social outcasts. (no offence maud, sunburst, and trix-) and thats ok

[@primordialpink]

I like her too but it has always buged me that they got rid of her banges

[@unripetheberrby6283]

Yeah some of, if not my most favorite dialogue and animation had came from Starlight. ^^

[@reyun9140]

To this day, I still dislike the way canterlot wedding plays out the way everyone ignores twilight's suspicion of 'Cadance' Also I think best night ever is incredibly frustrating to watch as you see the mane six essentially destroy this venue in an attempt to make their fantasies a reality

[@siddhianishkala4543]

Cadance*

[@milkywaygame3924]

Yess even shining twi's brother ignores her her friends EVERYPONY

[@Drmikemf]

I love canterlot wedding but i wish there was a moment where ALL of the characters apologized to twilight. I was so annoyed that Celestia was just like “this is your celebration too” or whatever she said, but didn’t say like “sorry for doubting you twilight.” Idk i just wanted there to be a formal apology scene bc they were rlly cruel towards twilight.

[@nixxdra]

⁠@@milkywaygame3924 Her brother ignores her because he’s being controlled by Chrysalis, her friends don’t have an excuse

[@milkywaygame3924]

@@nixxdra oh wait. Yea i kinda forgot i haven't watched it in a while 😅 but yea! Like it wasso frustrating to see twilight's friends just ignore her! Like isnt that a lesson they already learned in the parasprite ep. or was that after the calterlot wedding idk?

[@Miuu2]

If I were to rearrange the elements of harmony it would be rainbow dash=honesty Applejack=generosity Rarity=loyalty Rarity may be controversial, but every time rarity is faced with a problem she always ends up staying loyal to her friends and her ideals and her morals. Apple jack is also just, really generous

[@DinoTamer-22]

Agreed. I always thought Rainbowdash would make a great element of honesty.

[@thealmightydollar...]

I...grr.... respect your opinion

[@Technilogica2019]

actually applejack makes a lot of sense, she's literally a farmer that's the epitome of generosity

[@frostfiredirewolf8517]

You know what...I see that. It really does feel like Rarity gets tested on loyalty a lot more than RD.

[@warriorcatkitty]

@@thealmightydollar... me rn LOL

[@ShadyRK9]

I just realized something about King Sombra and why he's so OP in the Crystal Empire. And that his subjects are crystal ponies and from what we mostly see of them they're basically crystalized earth ponies. They have no magic, and can't even fly! So even if they decide to plan a revolution against him it's still normal crystal ponies AGAINST a unicorn WITH powerful magic! And even IF there was crystal unicorns they'd still need both dark and light magic to use the one of crystals in the throne room and on the door! And from what we know of dark and light magic it seems like ONLY the highest levels of unicorns and Alicorns would've been able to use that type of magic!

[@Spots_Racer]

I think they should have expanded on the whole "the rainboom was just a myth" thing. It seems so off that RD performs this supposedly legendary action and then it's never really brought up again along with the fact that she's able to perform it so casually. Like who first created the rainboom? Why is only RD allowed to do it? Ect ... Also I haven't read the comics which might explain it but IDK.

[@omniknight8514]

Unfortunately the comics don’t explain the legend around the rainboom

[@Spots_Racer]

@@omniknight8514 thx

[@Drmikemf]

It’s weird because like we never know if any Pegasus can perform one. Like is it just for rainbow colored pegasi? lol

[@catbatrat1760]

I thought the same thing

[@nightflame389]

Opaline is a really interesting character completely ruined by bad writing Chrysalis got flanderized hard in later seasons I'm mentioning this again, but Tempest's redemption arc was better executed than anyone else's redemption arc. Unlike literally all of the other redemption arcs that everyone says are good, Tempest had actual buildup (Sunset is my favorite character, but she's really lacking in that department) to the redemption that wasn't literally five seconds before (looking at you, Starlight). Unfortunately, the rest got relegated to the comics, which makes _some_ people think her redemption sucks. And of course, my hottest take, Tirek is far more redeemable than either Cozy or Chrysalis

[@ArthropodJay]

esp because his brother could be redeemed and was canonly nice. I imagine that scorpan himself couldve made an apperance and convince his brother to put down the power for once, and that destroying everything wouldn't be worth it in the end because he would be left alone

[@nightflame389]

@Dick_Faggotson Discord put them in the same room, Cozy truly brought them together, but it was Tirek who was most willing to _keep_ them together Cozy basically backstabbed them first chance she got by taking Discord's magic from the bell, Chrysalis was the first to bring up fighting each other the moment they were done, but Tirek did none of that. Closest he got was agreeing with Chrysalis that friendship is a disease None of them are going to reform, but if they were to, Tirek would be the first

[@MILDMONSTER1234]

Is he? He arguably did more damage then cozy ever did lol

[@nightflame389]

@@MILDMONSTER1234 we're not talking about damage here Starlight and Sunset did far more damage than, say, Suri Polomare, but who's more redeemable? Obviously not Suri Adolf Hitler is (nominally) more redeemable than Jeffrey Dahmer, despite killing several million more people and starting a global conflict

[@pinkiepielunagirls4541]

although sunset's choice to redeem herself is pretty instantaneous, i think that what they do with it afterwards is really interesting. i like how RR establishes that even though sunset's trying to be a better person it doesn't mean everybody's going to forgive her right away

[@lokiletsdolamp6137]

The first Equestria Girls movie isn’t as bad as everyone says it is. It definitely doesn’t measure up to Rainbow Rocks and Friendship Games but it’s still a relatively good movie.

[@Epic_Halfblood]

I remember that mlpeg got me into mlp a few months ago so i agree

[@delphilily]

It's actually my second favorite EG movie! It's much better than Friendship Games, that one was basically rewritten and the final plot was so butchered and boring

[@Technilogica2019]

im gonna hide in my basement for this one i kindaaa thought legend of everfree was the best movie they opened a whole new storyline that they didn't do anything with and i wasn't a fan of their outfits at the end but they felt the most in character while also getting thrown into situations we wouldn't have gotten to see otherwise. i also got a lot more strong about this opinion recently since not only was i in hs during the pandemic but i also get super bad panic attacks when i travel so i never got to go on fun trips for school. it's nice to live vicariously through the screen. also we will stand for everfree is better than unleash the magic and i won't apologize

[@delphilily]

@@Technilogica2019 I actually agree! Legend of Everfree is my favorite movie!

[@HavensCorner]

Justice for the books!! Also, background characters should get their own mini series. Like, I know fans can come up with their theories and that’s great and all, but making it canon would be even better.

[@MockiN6j4y]

I also really enjoyed the books! I read Twilight's, Pinkie's, Rainbow's, and Rarity's waaaaay before watching the show and I loved them

[@HavensCorner]

@@MockiN6j4y Oop, I was referring to the books Twilight basically destroyed, but that’s neat!

[@MockiN6j4y]

@@HavensCorner oh, oops lol 😆

[@pragyaabha]

unpopular opinion: "better way to be bad" is one the best, if not the best mlp villain song. the instrumental is so unique and catchy, the lyrics and dialogue are really funny and witty, and I loved the banter between the three villains. definitely deserves more recognition!!

[@PeacePetal]

Yes, I agree that Roseluck is a better partner for the Doctor! Controversial take: Unicorn magic in G4 is WAY too strong. It throws the unicorns out of balance and kind of pulls the rug out from under the other tribes (levitation stronger than earth pony muscle, teleportation faster than pegasus flight). The fact that only a few unicorns reach that power level kind of makes it even more annoying, like the 1% is baked right into pony biology. And on that point, it bothers me to no end that all of Equestria's rulers are a pony type that doesn't exist in the population. I *demand* a democratically elected earth pony president ruling Equestria. I won't settle for less.

[@nikkiskaleidoscope3053]

PERIOD!! I think that’s one of my main problem with Twilight being a princess. I don’t actually mind that she’s a princess, but, I don’t really care for her being an alicorn. Like, HOW, WHY??? Her whole family is made up of unicorns, where in the world did the wings come from? They are in her the whole time???? Wow… so a biological part that’s decided at birth just came out of no where for the sake of being a princess?Something just feels off about it to me, you know? I think I would have liked it better if she was still a unicorn and also a Princess.

[@makamiuseless1954]

I disagree but I can see your point, somewhat. First thing first for the Alicorn leader thing, Alicorns represent ALL pony tribes, so it's not far fetch to make them the leader. And most of them NEED to earn their alicorn-hood for accomplishing 'great worthy deeds' - quote from Rarity, for Flurry Heart's case she needs to prove herself worthy of becoming a ruler, or else she'll forever be a princess in title, no more. But also yes, Unicorns in G4 is pretty overpowered, I can imagine just Starlight and Starswirl alone are enough to wipe out stacked armies of any other pony tribes. One way to balance it out would simply to make the other two tribes have very powerful representives as well, like a pegasus with the flight power far exceeding Rainbow Dash, able to fly so fast that it's like they're teleporting, or an earth pony so strong and invincable that not even magic can affect them.

[@PeacePetal]

@@makamiuseless1954 The idea of alicorns earning their role is a nice one, but the only time we saw one do it is... problematic. Casting a spell that ruins your friends' lives and then fixing it isn't exactly a wonderful thing. Plus it kind of implies that only a unicorn can ascend to become an alicorn, which in turn just makes everything worse. That's also implied by the fact that Celestia (and Twilight once she becomes the ruler) spends all her time in a unicorn-only school. How did that not strike anyone on the writing staff as problematic??? 👀 Cadence's backstory from the chapter books does somewhat mitigate this problem, but of course it was never referenced in the show. Rainbow Dash and Big Mac are examples of pegasi and earth ponies who take their tribes' abilities to the extreme, and honestly, I wouldn't really want them to be any stronger than they are. Rainbow Dash's sonic rainboom is cool enough, I really don't need her moving like the Flash or something. And the Hulk but an earth pony... like, this is MLP, not a superhero flick. I would be much more favorable to nerfing Starswirl, Starlight, and all the other astronomical unicorns rather than buffing a few pegasi and earth ponies.

[@makamiuseless1954]

Cadence's origin as a non-unicorn was mildly implied in the show (though this is just probably me overthinking stuffs). First, during Twi's flashback about her, the scene when she cast a love spell, Cadence closed her eyes tightly and then proceed to be proud of herself afterwards, implying that magic wasn't her strenght (A unicorn's special talent shouldn't hard to translate to their abilities, seeing how Rarity could levitate bunch of stuffs in the air for her fashion purposes, meanwhile Cadence's acting like she's still learning about her own magic) which wouldn't make sense if she was a unicorn before being an alicorn. The same could be said in the first Sombra episode, she's exhausted to the core by casting the spell somehow manage to fly her way to rescue Spike and the Crystal Heart at the end, again saying that magic and spells aren't her natural talents. She's often seen using her wings and legs more than her horn, which striked as odd to me because I thought she was a unicorn before until I learnt about the book. For the only unicorn school thing though, yeah I don't have a counter for that, and honestly only now that you mentioned it... Yikes. ... Wait hold up I take back whatever I said- If Twilight was MEANT to be a princess because it's her "destiny", is this implying that ascending to become an alicorn is not something you can accomplish but have to be "destined" to have??? Dont' get me wrong Cozy Glow did became an alicorn but at the same time, it wasn't because she was destined to but rather something she acquired by force. If say any random pony, just literally ANYONE, a random earth pony with a flower as their cutie-mark or whatever, dreaming and aspiring to become an alicorn one day decided to set off and accomplish great deeds, but because they're not destined to become an alicorn, even when they checked off every single possible box on the list, they will never become one. NO WONDER FRICKIN' WHY FLURRY HEART IS AN ALICORN SHE WAS ALREADY DESTINED TO BE ONE GOSH DANG IT- Okay, we know what to comment in the next hot takes video now.

[@PeacePetal]

@usless1954 Well if we want to overthink Cadence, can we talk about how her powers *are literally mind control and go against the lesson that the CMCs learned in Hearts and Hooves Day*

[@lokiletsdolamp6137]

I actually like Sci-Twi (aka the version of Twilight who is from the human world). I’ve seen a lot of people say they dislike her but they never give any valid reasons as to why.

[@pinkiepiebiggestfan6099]

I agree, actually watching friendship games I thought that Sci-Twi would end up fighting against Twilight sparkle instead of sunset shimmer.

[@TheDanteEX]

I like her too. It was a bit jarring that they made her into one of those cliched "according to my calculations" archetype characters after films, but she still holds some snark and is consistently very smart in every special and short she appears in.

[@stvr.s5007]

FRRR

[@nameynamd9212]

​@@TheDanteEXMight've been interesting to see her delve into magic in that world with Sunset, possibly more so if human Sunset brought about the magic issues.

[@wrightcember]

@@TheDanteEXi think her whole cliche shtick is adorable! alas, opinions are opinions! this is why conversations like these are so interesting lol

[@thispersonloveschocolatemilk]

12:38 In context to this, I would like to point out how we barely got to see the pony counterpart of Flash Sentry. The fandom hates the human counterpart of Flash sentry because of how cliché and unnecessary his character was, and I fully agree with this statement. However, do you think Flash's pony counterpart would have been more interesting? Could he have more to his character than just being the cliché high school love interest, considering that pony Flash was a royal guard for the crystal palace? I feel like human Flash sentry does deserve that hate, because his character was just pathetic and there for the sake of giving twilight an insignificant love interest; while I also think that we should have seen more of pony Flash Sentry, he seems like a nice, not cliché dude with an interesting past. The show also hinted at pony Flash having a crush on Pony twilight, which could have made an interesting plot line in the show (and shippers' bait lmao), but unfortunately, it was never brought up again because of the lack of screentime pony Flash gets. This is where my unpopular opinion comes in; Pony counterpart of Flash Sentry is an underrated and unexplored character who deserves recognition. He could have been a significant part to Equestria, and just a fascinating character in general, unlike how he was in the Human world. Additionally, I definitely love this series, and I'd really like to see more of it, and I'm sure I'm the only one.

[@nameynamd9212]

Can't say much on pony Flash Sentry, though you've got me intrigued. But as for human Flash Sentry, one way they could've given him more would've been exploring him as an ex of Sunset's(it's an idea from fanfics, but the idea does at least bring in points to expand on both before pony Twilight went to Canterlot High and how they might have changed, which unfortunately, given the emphasis on backstory, may have been a story point if EQG got to address to what happened to human Sunset Shimmer).

[@rainbowthunder1128]

Yes! I want to see an interesting pony Flash Sentry!

[@thispersonloveschocolatemilk]

@@nameynamd9212 Yes, precisely. That's exactly what the comment in the video also suggested. Flash sentry just needs more character development in general. And although the idea of exploring him as sunset shimmer's ex seems interesting, it still wouldn't manage to capture Flash sentry's own personality, or like, who he is. Honestly, all I can say for human Flash is that his character was very unnecessary, and he only exists for cliché reasons. They could have given him character development, and maybe given him some personality of his own, which would have made him stand out as a character.

[@Twinklethefox9022]

Yeah it still makes me angry is that the fan cry is why we didn't get to see more of him. Apparently bronies who shipped themselves with twilight got angry that she had feelings for flash and then they (the producers of MLP) made him appear less and less. Now people complain that pony flash has no character.

[@MaddG_]

my opinion, as much as I do love the Kirin, I feel like it would've been better to expand upon some of the more ignored species in the series rather than add a new one, there's a lot of missed potential for world building with stuff like the Centaurs, Minotaurs, Zebras, Breezies, Kluge town, Abyssinians, Diamond dogs, Whatever the storm king is, hell even donkeys and mules, but sometimes it feels like they just add elements to the world building and just forget to expand upon them or only have them for a one off episode.

[@kurochi89]

I for one and SO happy that Chrysalis never was reformed. I think characters that are not able to be reformed are just so much more interesting because it suggests there is a REASON they were not reformed. Whether it is just pure stubbornness or decades/centuries of being an outcast/a monster it just adds so much more depth the them.

[@enderniffler628]

Possibly an unpopular opinion or two- 1. Luna probably would’ve made a good stand in leader for Celesta if she actually was more open with her sister, in fact they could’ve avoided the whole Nightmare moon thing all together if Celesta payed more attention to what was going on with Luna 2. Timber wolves could’ve been used and expanded on more in the show, they probably could’ve been a cool creature to learn more about- possibly through Flutter shy or Twilight wanting to study the magic behind them? Great video btw! All these different takes are so interesting from different angles! ^^

[@Twinklethefox9022]

I agree with both of these

[@SarahHirschkowitz]

I think the main six should have attempted to reform Cozy Glow but as for everyone hating the fact that she is a child, I think it actually sends a decent message across: Children can be evil too. Often times, evil starts as a child and it really should have served as a good reminder that correcting “evil” acts as a child can make a person better as they get older.

[@sharingheart13]

7:09 Cozy Glow apparently thinks that Derpy is overrated, so the stone imprisonment was a merciful judgement...

[@nameynamd9212]

Cozy's fate just seems like unfortunate circumstances as her first plan affected all civilizations, leaving only the dragons(maybe) and changelings as most likely to agree with reformation while the yaks may if they trust Pinkie's support and the hippogriffs in a similar way to the dragons, but less so to agrer, but the griffins most likely wouldn't unless Gallus could get them to. The second point could be worked around, but given that the offer of friendship and its values is usually how reforming goes, they'd have to determine and change Cozy's view on friendship and make sure she's not just using them for her next plan(kind of like the idea of Starlight doing the same after the season 5 finale).

[@warriorcatkitty]

@@nameynamd9212 Cozy is a... very interesting topic for me. We know NOTHING of her backstory. We have no idea who she is. All we know is that her cutie mark implies her talent, who she is, her destiny, is LITERALLY manipulation. The red chess piece has A LOT of symbolization. This is a fairly far-fetched theory but, a theory I have is that Cozy is not the age she appears. She could be an older pony that still LOOKS like a child due to that being... who she is. She manipulates others. Being born to forever have a "fake" appearance of someone who is innocent. It feels very fitting. WHY she was born to have a destiny of being evil is??? Confusing. The fact she is never shown to have parents is ALSO very strange. Again, my theories for Cozy are way out there becuase we don't have anything for her backstory so it's basically just a playground for headcanons tbh.

[@Twinklethefox9022]

I'm 50/50 on it. I kinda find it funny that a child was evil in the show but on the other half, I really wish they would have gone easier on cozy glow. I know her crimes are horrible but she's a kid, probably an orphan, who could have been manipulated into doing that without truly knowing what her consequences would do. Or maybe she's secretly an adult. We sadly don't know anything about her backstory. And if one more character could have been reformed, I wanted it to be her.

[@Twinklethefox9022]

​@@sharingheart13she's somehow typing beyond her stoney prison.

[@FeligamiAdrizoeSworaDooplivian]

Princess cadence was a great character until three's a crowd. Being a reckless idiot is not what a princess should do. Nor be okay with someone taking advantage of her.

[@quill_plays_sims]

What did she do? I don't remember her doung anything bad.

[@sistinas]

​@@quill_plays_simsshe didn't do anything bad lol she just said being the ruler of the empire can be repetitive so she had fun fighting that... Uh thing with Twilight

[@nameynamd9212]

The Tatzlwurm did backfire on Discord, though.

[@siddhianishkala4543]

Cadance*

[@FeligamiAdrizoeSworaDooplivian]

@@sistinas Respect opinions please.

[@StefonTV1]

I kinda wish they did more with the young 6. They had a good season and a half, but they deserved more time to shine. They were all well written, fun designed, and had great dynamics.

[@salemmaxwell570]

I don’t know if this is unpopular but it’s a headcanon of mine- sunset shimmer is or at least should be an alicorn, she plays the role twilight does in the human world and it would make less sense for her not to be one

[@retroradkat]

Sunset Shimmer should have been integrated into the actual show because it's what her character deserved. Maybe she could have returned to Equestria at the end of EqG: Friendship Games and become Twilight's student rather than Starlight Glimmer. I don't hate Starlight at all, but Sunset has earned that privilege far more! (As a side note, what I find most likeable about Starlight are just the same character traits that Sunset has, which are imo done better with Sunset)

[@Mystic_Warriors]

YES AGREED

[@Celeste_51]

I agree! I love Sunset shimmer and it would have been nice to see her as a pony more, maybe help Trixie reform to becoming a little kinder

[@Mystic_Warriors]

@@Celeste_51 lol a fellow mystic

[@retroradkat]

@MysticCeleste I bet Sunset & Trixie would have had a less toxic friendship than Starlight & Trixie too. Almost all StarTrix episodes involve them fighting or making each other mad.... whereas Sunset & Trixie's friendship in Forgotten Friendship seemed a lot more wholesome and constructive to me.

[@Twinklethefox9022]

I think starlight was handled better but yeah..

[@fotiniprotonotariou]

i believe that it would make much more sence if not all changelings were renformed and that Chrystalys would still have a few followers. And also that we should have been given a backstory for her and how changelings came to be. In my mind changelings are a whole species and it seemed a bit wrong how they suddenly changed their behavior and basically everything they knew after a random pony and another changelling (who basically no one rlly liked) said so.

[@Bombonribon]

Is because changelings and the good changelings are based on both dark faes and good faes; basically Chrysalis is the only one left because she still thinks that bein evil is goodand the other ones don't like that lifestyle so they changed. Though yeah, I see your point and I agree lol

[@catherinebaldwin6580]

I like to think the reformed look is their original or true form, and them feeding on stolen love and not shared love made them look like that. Maybe it was Crystalize, (can’t spell) or a previous queen.

[@Bombonribon]

@@catherinebaldwin6580 exactly. That's the way I view it too

[@catbatrat1760]

To be fair, Thorax did say there were a lot of renegade Changelings who didn't want to change.

[@lokiletsdolamp6137]

Flurry Heart isn’t that bad of a character. I know she was only created to sell toys but that doesn’t mean she’s a bad character. People say she’s spoiled but that’s not true, she literally acts like any other toddler would.

[@thinkwithvideos2238]

She literally acts like a BABY would.

[@CherryHotSauce]

did they even sell any toys of her? I don’t remember any.

[@MockiN6j4y]

​@@CherryHotSauceshe's a perfect toy opportunity, they definitely have

[@hearmeout1767]

​@@CherryHotSauce I have one

[@hearmeout1767]

I don't know why people hate Flurry Heart, I thought it was really nice when Cadence and Shining were going to have a baby. It added new dynamic to their family. I feel like the reason behind her being born as an alicorn should have been resolved and explored more. I also feel like aging up Flurry and the Cake twins, making them into small fillies, would have been SO interesting.

[@synsvids]

Background characters are underrated, kid me LOVED to look at the designs of them and see which ones resemble ones I've already seen

[@Hawbitten]

I think with Zephyr Breeze his fear of failure is what makes him try and give up multiple things. We see him trying to dig deep into himself to finish something at the end of the episode and how much it pains him. As for his behaviour, that's harder to defend. But it is clear his parents haven't done a good job setting boundaries for him, so it's not all on him. (Also his flirting with RD is hilarious and I love it. He clearly isn't being a creep, he really can't read her). I love him. Flaws and all. (I also like Zephyr x Limestone!)

[@nawnaw]

zephyr reminds me of my sister😅 so i think the creators made a good job of making him sort of a realistic character

[@SirLuckySlime]

People actually hate the Rainbow Power designs? I think the colors are lovely and fitting

[@Drmikemf]

Literally same!!! I’m a sucker for any rainbow power pony merch

[@doll9340]

Yeah but not everyone can handle colors and brightness. Especially those with sensitive eyes

[@pinkiepielunagirls4541]

i love the colors but hated the huge hair

[@tomato_1292]

I think that Prince Blue Blood could have been a good character if they had some episodes dedicated to him, they made his personality like a simple stuck up prince but there was probably so much more to him than what we got to see. We could of had episodes dedicated to him finding himself just like we got to see Celesta and Luna evolve as characters

[@catsareamazing3616]

I agree he's sooooo under used

[@catbatrat1760]

I've heard a theory that he was only pretending to be snooty because he'd had thousands of girls try to romance him for shallow reasons just like Rarity.

[@catbatrat1760]

@@catsareamazing3616 Yeah, isn't he Celestia's nephew? You'd think that would warrant more than one episode appearance.

[@MarianneStudios]

Newly established controversial opinion of mine: the Rainbow Power designs are GORGEOUS! The yellow does clash with Twilight and Rarity but the rest are absolutely beautiful, I LOVE the colours and big hair! 🌈

[@nawnaw]

it suits apple jack and pinkie for sure ,the hair looks a bit too big for flutter

[@Strawberrykoal]

1:03 she has so many flaws, she wants to be the best at everything that she does or else she feels like she’s not good at it at all, she wants to do everything by herself, even when she can’t, and she ends up overworking herself because of that, when somebody else can’t pick up the slack, she always doesn’t even when she’s pushing yourself beyond her limit, she’s not tolerant towards people who can’t put as much effort into things as she can, even though she knows she functions differently.

[@sunteeththegenderpunk6414]

for the chrysalis one: my gf and i actually talked about this and came up with a dumb little scene basically, the 3 start actually becoming friends, and during a moment of victory chrysalis starts transforming and her friends immediately start frantically talking her down like no no quick think hateful thoughts! hate! jealousy! and she visibly struggles and turns back also i think a redemtion arc with those 3 could also tackle stuff about toxic friendships and when your friends make it harder for you to be a good person? like some conflicts i can imagine are - they dont want to be seen as Weak in front of the other 2 so each of them acts Worse when the others are around - they enable eachother's worse impulses when theyre hanging out, like their other friends encourage them to Not do bad stuff but when they hang out as a group one of them will suggest something shittt and the other two are like yeah we Should

[@Tall_Order]

Roseluck is a pretty pony for sure, but when it comes to personalities connecting, Derpy is best for the doctor.

[@Dandelionsinthesky]

Well,they are siblings😂

[@jazzratoon]

​@@DandelionsintheskyWhat?

[@siddhianishkala4543]

@@Dandelionsinthesky No, they're not.

[@NigelBillingsley]

opinion, but not very controversial: there should have been an episode where we can see how the changelings live and go about their daily life. the mane six wouldn't be there, but we would see that chrysalis isn't bad, ashe just wants to feed her subjects.

[@catbatrat1760]

Any excuse to see the Changelings more is good in my book XD

[@lurlineart]

Unpopular opinion: I don't like what they did with Starlight's character. She worked so well as a villain. If she had just had a slightly darker villain origin story than one that downplayed her like her best friend moving away, and stayed a villain, I would've loved her so much more. I feel like she was reformed for the sake of being the Twilight/Sunset mashup we didn't need and for Twilight to have a student. Even when I was a little kid watching mlp, I never liked that Starlight instantly started becoming the new Twilight upon her reformation. I was fully expecting her to become a princess just to complete her Twilight replacement arc.

[@nameynamd9212]

The origin does feel a bit better responded to, though it might just be an interpretation view, but when asking whether new friendships would end up the same as with Sunburst, Twilight's response pushes both to give friendship a chance and put in the effort to have them not break, even in the face of sadness/despair.

[@watermelon3266]

SIlly, If starlight stayed a villain we'd have to kill her: *_Insert Star wars reference here_*

[@evanrhildreth]

I think the opposite. I would have liked Starlight to also, eventually, achieve alicorn status, and become to Twilight what Luna is to Celestia.

[@lucidfangirl1030]

I disagree, i’d want her severely punished for kidnapping Twilight and almost destroying the world. Why Twilight only princess with no guards?

[@DogDogGodFog]

Yeah, I mean, who becomes a psychotic dictator just because they saw their best friend get praised for an achievement? Like Starlight's character just doesn't make sense.

[@antonrueda1044]

5:15 I agree. The dude in the early seasons was this menacing force of nature who brings fear to the ponies around him. The way a crystal pony got a traumatizing flashback of him just as she was trying to remember what happened to her shows how deeply he affected the Heart Kingdim.

[@jinglesthedeafcat9238]

Opinion: I honestly wanted more Nightmare Moon, instead of her being in only the two pilot episodes (not including that one episode with Daybreak in a later season) I wanted Nightmare Moon to be a bigger big bad kind of like Chrysalis but still being reformed before bringing Discord in

[@skysiren4113]

Here's my unpopular opinion: I feel like the Grogar twist could've worked if A. The real Grogar showed up and stayed as the big bad while being the one to reveal the twist by using the bell to drain Discord's powers, as well give the Cozy Glow, Chrysalis and Tirek the redemption arc they deserve B. Have Discord realise that he's the reason that all the stuff happened in season 9 and have him try and actively fix his mistakes but also face consequences for his actions. I'm not saying he needs to be turned to stone again, but having where everyone including Fluttershy finally loose their trust in him and think that he can never change since he AGAIN helped one of the villians take over Equestria (though unintentionally this time) could be that push to fix his mistake and grow as a person. And C. Have the twist be revealed much earlier so we can build up to the real Grogar showing arc and have time for Discords arc to be paced well I think the twist could've been good for Discord's character and show that he can still make mistakes even when he doesn't mean to hurt anyone but it failed due to poor execution and rushed pacing

[@Technilogica2019]

also season 9 was mostly filler which felt like a slap in the face

[@Twinklethefox9022]

I have not seen a moment where tirek can be redeemed. Give me your reasons.

[@skysiren4113]

@@Twinklethefox9022 in the episode Frenemies we see the Legion of Doom start to grow close to one another and even though they say that they would go back to destroying one another after they take Grogar's power, you see throughout the episode they to an extent they grew close to each other It could've been interesting to see them grow more close and actually become friends, now of course that wouldn't change the fact that yes all three of them did terrible stuff and tried to take over Equestria, but Discord did also try to take over and even after he was redeemed he's what caused everything in season 9 to happen. They don't even have to be redeemed even having it where they make a temporary alliance with the heroes to stop Grogar but still decide to stay as villians could've worked

[@theAstarrr]

Yes I really like Rainbow and hate the character un-development of characters in season 8/9 (who wrote "2 4 6 Great"....Rainbow didn't respectfully disagree, Twilight didn't consider what could happen if Rainbow truly hated cheerleading, etc etc.)

[@LegoMiester14]

I think Starlight Glimmer is way underrated. Most people see her as a copy of Twilight or Sunset, or think she took the spotlight from the main 6. I personally think she was handled well and can relate to her a lot. She has a lot of character traits that help her stand out.

[@trikid42D2]

What if Sombra made the memory potion that Zecora gave to Twilight in season 4? Twilight had to use dark magic just like his to activate it. He also stole memories from the crystal ponies, so he obviously knows a lot about memory magic.

[@melpomenes]

My opinion is that Sunset Shimmer deserved to be an alicorn. She proved herself worthy of so by redeeming herself and being able to help keep a control of Equestrian magic in the human world. I wish there was more of her, especially in the final episode at Twilight’s coronation, but of course that didn’t happen.

[@bendysans1473]

I like their rainbow form Though they didn't need all the little details I do like them The big hair, the massive elegant wings, the colors even glow You will know if the main 6 win from miles away when they are in this form And look at pinkie Hair so poofie it looks like something you can sleep in I like them for the fact they make things bigger and brighter Though wish it had more of a practical purpose Like making book hores smarter or having pink be able to cook faster or something

[@catherinebaldwin6580]

I too liked the rainbow powers idea. And I’m weird. My head is like, that fine, cool. And my artist heart is like, the crap! This is what?! Ga!

[@MockiN6j4y]

The only thing I don't like about the rainbow designs is the tone of blue green they put in Fluttershy's hair. It's too dull in comparison with all the rest of the colors

[@bendysans1473]

@@MockiN6j4y agreed

[@alysia8214]

I don't know if this is considered as controversial but I think Discord caused more damage after being reformed.

[@giraffegirl1691]

Idk if it's controversial either, but my take is yes, he caused more damage overall, but not proportional to the time he had. In a single afternoon, before he was reformed, he had corrupted the wielders of the Elements of Harmony, had turned Ponyville (and presumably parts of Canterlot too) into the chaos capital of the world, and had turned countless citizens into functionally dogs with cartoon physics for his entertainment. While he did manage to cause a lot of problems after his reformation, it seemed like a once a month thing at most. Seems like he spends most of his time just chilling in the chaos dimension doing whatever and only screws with the protagonists on his days off. Especially since everybody seems really surprised to see him at all the first couple of times he shows up.

[@Ich-Existiere-Nicht]

Almost everyone agrees on that but we all also agreed to ignore it since he only acted like this because the new writers destroyed his character.

[@nixxdra]

True. At first all he did was turn Equestria into wonderland. In the final season he released three dangerous villains and a child into Equestria.

[@JZJ7777]

I definitely agree with that.

[@SolarSkylark2002]

Celestia is an irresponsible ruler. Even in the first episode, let alone the whole show, she had shown absolutely no concern for the safety of her subjects, and when Nightmare Moon returns, she sent Twilight, her top student who she has planned to make her air to the throne, to take care of what is debatably her responsibility with the help of a bunch of strangers she had only known for a single day to get to know, while she’s who knows where. She’s lucky that she’s a monarch of a cartoon show because if she had pulled off her antics in the real world, she would have been assassinated over 30 times.

[@DrawciaGleam02]

"she had pulled off her antics in the real world, she would have been assassinated over 30 times." I thought a similar thing, but not with anything MLP related. I felt like that with King Dedede's plan to steal all the food in Dreamland in the very first Kirby game. After pulling a stunt like that, realistically the Dreamland residents would've tried to overthrow him and establish a new ruler.

[@kingstar5494]

Ok when you put it in that context, I have to agree with you. Despite Celestia being one of my favorite characters in the show, she makes some questionable decisions sometimes. But she is a better leader than the ones we have in the real world. After all, Celestia made sure her kingdom was prosperous for more than 1000 years.

[@alfaseng]

Generally the only reasons why an overthrow did not happen is because they revere her too much as a goddess and the evidence that her domain is quite "prosperous" (Don't exactly show how she made her domain prosperous)

[@EmpressEveningGlow]

@@DrawciaGleam02 facts

[@meiulleyl]

That's literally what happens in almost every story. (I.e: harry potter, Percy Jackson, miraculous ladybug, so many more.)

[@cydbee.]

Celestia is underrated and overhated and personally one of my favorite characters. She had to raise the sun and the moon every day and night. I feel people don’t take into consideration that, that probably took a lot of power from her since raising the moon was not something she was meant to do. I do agree they did her dirty on the canterlot wedding I really wish we could’ve seen more of her full power. Also one of the criticisms against her is how she always needs the mane six. The reason why she always needs them could just be her training them to rule equestria. I can’t share everything right here because it would be too long. Also I feel like Applejack is really underrated and unappreciated and the finale could have been done better.

[@evaskiess]

hot take: I would’ve liked to see one (or more) of the Mane 6 (specifically Twilight) with a romance subplot. Yeah in the finale we see it implied that some of them ended up with a special somepony, but I think an actual plot would’ve been interesting. This is very biased though, because romance is one of my favorite genres and Twilight’s my favorite character 😅

[@Schleichshet809]

I absolutely love equestria girls. The songs are absolute bangers every time and it kinda gives the same characters new personalities. Where I don't really like rarijack in the show, it's my favourite eg ship (also the shorts, especially rollercoaster of friendship do so much for aj's character)

[@Bombonribon]

Unpopular opinion: the fandom tends to analyze the lore of the show wrong and only decides to understand it when its convinient, one great example of this is EQG that is based on the theory of multiverses (being the type 1 very rare in MLP and EQG being a type 2 and 3 kind of consideirng the temporal anomalies) and on the Reflections comics of MLP, and people claim is a direct copy of the FIM universe when is not, considering the Dazzlings are older than Celestia and Luna but they are teenagers in EQG, there is no human Sunset, Starlight is older thsn the the girlx in EQG even though they are all the same age in MLP, and so on, like is a distorted timeline and NOBODY talks about these importsnt points, and just says things like: "is just MLP but human duhhh", when is said that if two universes are the same in MLP with little to no differences they crash and cease to exist, unless one of the universes compensates for it woth things that do not make sense, like in Reflections, when Derpy is the element of harmony with Trixie, Chrysalisand others, but the majority of bad guys in there are good in FIM and vice-versa, though Derpy nor Hooves were never evil in FIM, but in there they are also good, mesning the universes DO NOT dorectly mirror each other... They analyze the show without even knowing the lore and it just pisses me off. And this is coming from somebody that doesn't even like EQG, but just decided to do a quick Google search to see if I could piece the pieces together.

[@nameynamd9212]

The chosen age group tends to be odd as Sunset should be older than Twilight and both are teenagers despite the kind of lives the Mane 6 have being closer to adult ones and as you mentioned, the Dazzlings should be way older than that(it's still kind of true, but the cancelled part of EQG apparently was going to address human Sunset Shimmer). The parallel points feel offset a decent amount by the human focus in the EQG universe that counterparts to main characters seem possible(to push for story if nothing else), and at least for human Sunset, if it did cause an unbalance, it would give pony Sunset a difficult choice for the sake of that world.

[@Bombonribon]

@@nameynamd9212 yes, because as I said the way MLP parallel world works is just like any other one, with there needing inconsistency to work; nobody says anything about Spiderverse not having logic about all the different spoder men not being all peter parkers, and why?? Because it's a multiverse movie, and that's the point of multiverses: making no sense IS the only consistent thing in there. People are analyzing the show as if it was a direct parallel to EQG, when that's not the case, and that's the problem. And yes, MLP season 9 was supposed to end with Celestia, Luna and Discord dying at the end, but it was changed to Discord trying to help Twilight (which honestly I think is better considering everything else, and that is been proven that Celestia in a comic does nothing because she wants to teach Twilight a "lesson" just like Discord does; and in the end of EQG Sunset was supposed to go back to her world with the girls forgetting about her, and all her impacts in the world so actual human Sunset could live her life from where she stopped since the magic from EQG that leaked from the portal was actually her trying to go back home :(

[@IzzyMoonbow648]

My controversial opinion is Starlight and Trixie have an unhealthy friendship. I haven’t seen all of the later seasons but every episode I see of them they’re arguing about something. Like that episode Trixie kept like pestering Starlight and messing things up and Starlight bottled up her anger until it exploded onto her. Or the episode where Starlight SELLS Trixie’s wagon (literally her home) without asking her and doesn’t even care when trixie is obviously upset

[@winter-starlight]

I agree. When Trixie kept screwing up, she didn't even seem to care that much, even after Starlight exploded at her. It's why I don't ship them at all.

[@IzzyMoonbow648]

@@winter-starlight yes

[@4zy1]

naw the mane 6 have treated each other infinitely worse, they make trixie and starlight look like housewives in comparison

[@4zy1]

@@winter-starlightthey're both socially awkward mares that don't always properly know how to act or pick up on social cues, they're flawed.

[@IzzyMoonbow648]

@@4zy1 how so?

[@blearywall5179]

in my opinion, we could have had an episode where sunset goes back to the pony world and tries to stay there for a day to see what twilight goes through, or for her crowning at the last episode honestly i just loved sunsets character and never got enough of her

[@braylin5003]

My somewhat unpopular opinion: They ruined the Starlight Glimmer character in the last two seasons, only because of how she kept forgetting lessons she already knew but how overpowered they made her.

[@TheCommenterDragon]

Thank you for reading my comment and giving your opinion on it Star Strike and I'm happy that my comment made it into the video! And I agree it definitely would've been interesting if they did a season finale episode where Chrysalis pretended to be reformed in order to take back the Changeling kingdom and you're right we'd still get to see what Chrysalis would look like a reformed Changeling even though it would just be a disguise the design probably would've been gorgeous!

[@AmicaSecret]

4:49 I prefer roseluck, since in the last problem they are seen together, and well... I think in some scrapped episode it's implied, and in the show Derpy and Doctor were written to be siblings??

[@SunBeeSmoked]

2:25 thank you for saying how awful Zephyr is. He’s a creep. He harasses Rainbow Dash essentially. And there’s no consequences for that, Rainbow is just made to feel uncomfortable and no one does anything about it. I hate it.

[@pittygamer2536]

Going to say this as a Rarity fan (but also just liking the unicorns in mlp a lot just rarity being my favorite) i wish we could've seen more magic in the show (especially considering we got to see some of rairty's "gem magic" or when she made that shield that was shaped like a gemstone in the finale I believe) it could help expand the magic element for not just the Unicorns but the world of Equestria. Maybe not just unicorns but maybe earth pony abilities and even pegasus (like talking to animals, super strength, Controlling the weather are a few examples of what they can do but what if other stuff like Making plants grow faster or a more sturdy body to resist magic/Fighting if any danger happens in their lives, for Pegasus it could be Controlling not just weather but maybe elements around them by flying fast or their feathers? It's just interesting to think on what else these ponies could do)

[@Jamseth_Ingramious]

A lot of earlier setups- Pinkie's mental instability, the returns of Sombra and Flutterbat, the power of Celestia and Luna, Scootaloo's lack of visible parents, etc.- were heavily underutilized or just downright ignored later on.

[@travelpanda7899]

I would of absolutely LOVED to see an episode on Sombra's past, like who he was before he became a villain. I also just love his design, I feel like it could add more lore building with how he looks and why (idk i just find him very interesting)

[@amandapen]

Ikr, his first appearance and backstory in the comic was so good, I'm so disappointed with what they did to him in the show

[@IamAster888]

If I remember correctly his backstory was explained in the comics. I Don't know which one because I haven't read any of them but still. It would have been cool to see it in-show too tho.

[@magomayhem3122]

If it was the goal for twilight to become an alicorn in the beginning, it should have been the main 7. Twilight becoming an alicorn threw off the balance of the main cast. Before it was all equal, then unicorns lost one. This was one issue Starlight Glimmer did fix, where she made it balanced, but she wasn't apart of the main cast because she wasn't an element of harmony. Also I want more stuff with the bat ponies, they were so cool and I'm mad we only got Flutterbat and that's really it. Luna's guards aren't bat ponies, as shown in the alternate reality with Nightmare Moon, they're enchanted Pegasi.

[@DogDogGodFog]

But having three unicorns for 4 seasons would also be imbalanced.

[@magomayhem3122]

@@DogDogGodFog Im not saying for there have been 3 unicorns from the start, I'm saying you should've brought another unicorn in sooner- around season 5ish, with the proper foreshadowing as well.

[@team_lila]

hot take: Sunset shimmer should have been the "friendship conecter" for EG instead of a 2nd twilight.

[@travs_eleganza]

Rainbow Dash is not a bad character, she's just written wrong.

[@ok-zf5sw]

As a kid, I LOVED rainbow power! I used to think the colors added to the manes were very aesthetically pleasant, and the transformation was also so hype and cute back then 😭😭

[@sharingheart13]

7:09 Of course Cozy Glow would say this. I no longer feel bad about her stone imprisonment.

[@thinkwithvideos2238]

2:50 Yeah............ Just because she's the reason the Main 6 got together in the first place, doesn't mean it makes her worthy of being an ALICORN. And I seriously have NO FAITH of her being a good princess.

[@hearmeout1767]

Tbh me either, she couldn't even coach a cheerleading team so why would she be able to rule a country 😂 I think RD makes more sense as a Wonderbolt and is really good at it, rather than being a princess

[@NightCloudI]

Yeah, it would make more sense for this person to say that Twilight should be the one causing all the others to get their cutie marks. However I like it just how it is and wouldn't change anything. :)

[@thinkwithvideos2238]

8:47 Hahahahahaahaha. Who would've thought that TWILIGHT SPARKLE, a book lover who loves her books as children, abused so many books in the show.

[@DogDogGodFog]

Funny, I loved the Rainbow Power designs. Especially the merch. That Twilight + Breezie set was literally one of my favourite childhood toys. Besides, the designers _had_ to design some kind of super-powerful forms for the mane 6 for that scene. What else would super-powerful forms look like?

[@Pop_Candyz]

Opinion: I think that the songs at the end of the EQG movies are underrated. Most people don't really seem to pay any attention to the credits, but I think people should. Great examples being Shine Like Rainbows, which also has its STUNNING end credit art, and my personal favorite, Right There in Front of Me.

[@pinkiepielunagirls4541]

shine like rainbows always made me want to bawl as a kid but i sat through it every time so i could watch the post-credits scene

[@rangerrobinson5034]

Opinion: Chrysalis is not a villain (at first). Her goal of taking over Equestria isn’t so she can rule over it. It’s so changelings can have easy and reliable access to food. Only after changelings were reformed did the purpose of her goal change from obtaining a reliable source of food for her species. To getting revenge for what she felt was betrayal by her own kind.

[@hearmeout1767]

Facts

[@hannahlamagna]

10:42 The Rainbow power is cool and think they look pretty but glad they brought the element’s back

[@TheCommenterDragon]

My next opinion involves Gabby and Spike, I mean I as well as many others ship it but I know that things like the age gap is still in affect when it comes to them. But I still prefer Spabby over Sparity because at least Spike and Gabby have stuff in common and more importantly Gabby would never take advantage of Spike or his feelings like Rarity does. I mean I know just because Gabby treats Spike better and they have more in common that doesn't mean that a romantic relationship between them would work out, But I'm just saying those are the reasons why I prefer Spabby rather than Sparity. No disrespect to any Sparity shippers though.

[@Twinklethefox9022]

Wait, people ship Gabby and spike?

[@TheCommenterDragon]

@@Twinklethefox9022 Yes, It started after Spike and Gabby's interactions in the season 9 episode "Dragon Dropped." They may not have interacted romantically but many people including myself think that Spabby is more compatible than Sparity.

[@xX_epicgamer69420_Xx]

/)

[@gellyjeb]

Unpopular opinion: Applejack x Rainbow Dash shouldn’t have become cannon, it should’ve been Applejack and Rarity

[@abbyelectric]

you're just correct man

[@imaginations_animations4928]

Idk if this is an unpopular opinion but Imma try so here it is: I love Tempest Shadow from MLP: The Movie, everything about her from her character design, her color palate, the character arc. Everything. I just wish that we got to see more of her in the actual series. I wanted to see her in Twilights school of friendship and reconnecting with her old friends. I wanted to know if she would continue to look for a way to fix her horn even when she was travelling all across Equestria and beyond to spread the word of the Storm Kings defeat. I'd even like to know more about her backstory than how her horn was broken and her relationship with her friends and other ponies torn. And why does she always like covering herself? We never really get to see her cutie mark. I want to know so much more about her character than what we're told and shown. I just love her so much and idk how many other people are out there who love her too.

[@kaisertrinityt.m.i.s1607]

in my eyes, the season finaly against the mean 3 should have ended like that they, as an accident awaked the real grover, and making story short, defeat him with the mane 6, BUT they wouldnt be "good" like the mane 6, but instead stay neutral and trying to build up a new life in peace