What if Palpatine killed Rey and Ben on Exegol? - Star Wars Elseworlds

[@mitchellshuttleworth3204]

Interesting and well written as always. I liked how it was more of a what if history rather than a stylized story like you usually do. In the end, the Sith Empire is rebuilt and ultimately rules the galaxy, its a very bleak end to the Skywalker Saga with no hope left. But I like it. I especially like how you introduced Darth Talon and made her Palpatine's new apprentice at the end there. Overall a great video!

[@Alienwarez567Epic]

This is sooooo much better than the real thing

[@TheGreater-ScopeVillain]

Very well written. I do believe that Emperor Palpatine would have been able to defeat all the enemies that he would come to face. Darth Krayt, the Yuuzhan-Vong, and even Abeloth. I reckon that Darth Sidious would be able to overcome them all. Darth Talon being his Sith Apprentice was also a nice touch.

[@locoarticwolf2181]

Once more the Sith shall rule the Galaxy, soon we will have Peace.

[@ITZKXG]

IMPERIAL MARCH INTENSIFIES

[@MILO.....]

Yes we shall

[@Doyoueverwonderwhywerehere]

Wait but aren't you the reason he failed last time

[@musekiller65794]

I hope this happens, i never liked the jedi, i will always be loyal to the emperor palpatine and i know he will time travel and destroy this goddamn and cursed new timeline, i want to see palpatine killing everyone she ever loved and spend a eternity frying rey with force lightning, this would make me happy just like i was seeing palpatine frying maul's brains out

[@fictionverse7292]

@@musekiller65794 dude, that’s messed up. This is the worst possible timeline ever

[@theserpent8667]

So in short, "The dark side will blind you forever!" quite literally happened. Damn, what a dark, yet well-written short story.

[@AirbenderHawk]

Let’s go!!!!!! Palpatine even in AU is not to be taken lightly, even in Clone form. It’s ALWAYS a great day when Star Wars Elseworlds upload on a Friday that is today. The force is definitely strong with this one, and if you haven’t subscribed to him already, just DEW IT! I’m a sucker for dark endings so this will be fun.

[@AListProductions]

Awesome work bro!

[@RyanTheDark]

This would have been ironically the better ending, perhaps building up to another trilogy or allowing Anakin to finish what he started.

[@muigokublack6487]

Though with the idea that force ghosts can interact with the physical world, could just have Yoda appear, summon a bolt of lightning and have ourselves some Kentucky Fried Sheev. God TLJ was so stupid...

[@debutriah2854]

@@muigokublack6487bold enough to assume he would be stronger than this version of Palpatine

[@krane1155]

Or preparing for the arrival of the Far Outsiders

[@ReySkywalker2]

This would’ve been a horrific ending for the saga.

[@glauberglousger956]

I was going to mention that that would require bringing him back, but eh, why not at this point Why not just have everyone become a force ghost and just random stuff

[@Elemento0420]

Crazy theory time: Darth Vader, using the World Between Worlds to save Padme, created an opening to the World Between Worlds, which Grogu from the Jedi Grievous timeline found. Sith Eternal Sidious finds this opening, intending to conquer all of reality as he once planned. To stop this, heroes from Elseworlds's other timelines must work together to save all of reality. These would include: Redeemed Anakin along with Leia from the alternate ending to ROTJ. Luke from What If Anakin didn't burn. Jedi Maul Obi-Wan from the timeline Vader altered. Momma 'Soka

[@StarWarsElseworlds]

Interesting theory

[@procyon6370]

He didn't

[@drishalballaney]

Yess this would be absolutely insane

[@Elyseon]

Might as well bring in Jedi Grievous and Jedi Superman from the Legacy of the Red Sun trilogy.

[@Happysecret180]

Want this, I do, the same opinion regarding this, we all do, created this must be

[@EcoNationalSyndicalist]

Now that’s how it was supposed to end, it would’ve been more realistic that way. Hail Palpatine!

[@jordancox8289]

This is a pretty dark and interesting what if story. Great writing as always! I'm really excited for the light side version of this story with Jedi Finn!

[@jshrhrgahhuehtnmppl]

I love how people say nobody’s been through more pain than Rey but being electrocuted is the worst pain she’s ever felt lol. So many other characters have been electrocuted and felt the same pain as her, but have been through much worse.

[@Elyseon]

Of course Ma-Rey Sue would want even her pain to be special.

[@musekiller65794]

I don't give a crap about rey, it would be my happiest day to see palpatine electrocute rey and every fucking bad character from this goddamn new trilogy to death

[@SamCaiman14]

Yoda in the afterlife *bops Luke in the head with his cane* Luke: Hey! Yoda: Kill yourself just to send a force projection, had you?! Luke: H-hey its not my fault! Kylo and Rey were still there! Yoda: Leave the fate of the galaxy to a girl with months of training you did! *bop* *bop* Anakin: Hey son dont you think this dealing with the emperor should had been a task for the Grandmaster with my potential? You knew about Exegol after all, you looked for it. Even if you didnt know Palpatine was alive, you knew something bad was out there. *bop* *bop* Anakin: Hey! Yoda: Shut up you will! Your fault all this is!

[@TheStinkyGhost69]

How about, what if Qi-Gon hadn't died in episode 1

[@staarfinger7322]

Hed train anakin and anakin wouldnt turn and finish off sidious by episode 3

[@FirstNameLastName-dw9pm]

It always bothered me how easily Palpatine dies in ROS. Here's a guy who is one of the smartest guys in the galaxy and is stronger than Maul, Vader, and maybe Yoda in the force, but he doesn't know when to turn off is lightning when its being deflected.

[@nitoginko2187]

I guess then you don’t like ROTJ and ROTS as well

[@kyleellis8665]

Hate blinds simply truths

[@debutriah2854]

@@nitoginko2187 those are both different cases. Especially ROTJ. Luke pissed him off so badly that his entirety of focus was on him. He couldn’t even sense Vader

[@glauberglousger956]

To be fair, being electrocuted leads to uncontrollable actions But it makes me wonder why he was even fighting her in the first place if he wanted her to kill him My theory is that he lost all his brain cells some time ago, and is now just a senile old guy that has immense power

[@brandonogden2210]

This What If story is like a plot point for The Ninth Jedi in the Visions universe.

[@konstantinlenz1057]

I loved your story very much, one of my Favs from your Channel. You gave me new ideas and Stories, thank u.

[@memeboyr6177]

Didn't expect this one, but I'm glad I clicked it!

[@StarWarsElseworlds]

Hope you enjoy!

[@DalekOfChaos666]

Hope we see more Sequel trilogy what ifs

[@godemperorofmankind3.091]

Nothing would be left to get in Palpatine's way. he would establish an iron fist around the galaxy's throat and rebuild the Empire. Although he still needs to find a younger body to put his soul into. Maybe he'd go hunting for Finn after sensing his force capabilities.

[@hansolo5912]

Fin died tho

[@godemperorofmankind3.091]

@@hansolo5912 i was creating my own scenario, not following off the one in the video

[@staarfinger7322]

Na hed literally make more clones of himself

[@prbrain]

Dude! That was awesome! Better than anything Disney could put out.

[@starcabal2006]

Rey i would've been fine about dying as I never liked her but Ben Solo is underrated so his death is impactful

[@korven6134]

This Palpatine could fight against Tenebrae/Vitiate/Valcorian

[@dapperduncle1972]

Secret good ending

[@brycekayski9284]

Respect for doing one of these channels and doing it VERY DOPE 😤💯 new sub

[@joe3019772008]

interesting and very dark take on everything. as for the light side one you were talking about at the end, would that also involve if ben had lived as well ? would he, rey and fin begin rebuilding the jedi order ? would rey and ben have a child or children of their own who would become future jedi ? so many posibilities when it comes to the multiverse of the else worlds.

[@StarWarsElseworlds]

Ben wouldn't live in that one, you'll see when it comes out. Glad you liked this take!

[@gabrielgreen580]

sidious would become extremely powerful and could definitely become a great match up for darth Krayt but abaloth is on a whole other level even the father couldn’t outright kill her but had to trap her and legends luke also failed to fully defeat her so I doubt palpatine could defeat her and most likely abaloth would go on to destroy the galaxy.

[@deadmonkey6835]

Another great what if stories and may the force be with you all

[@lightnihilus]

Great video and amazing well written while interesting. Can you do a video about the Bedlum Spirits ?

[@SemISkUIZTheRaccoonSpider1st]

Just like in The Old Republic era Seems there is too much Sith... All hail the Sith.

[@muigokublack6487]

Sith happens!

[@theforcedragon3781]

The Sith actually never came back bc Palpatine said ‘nothing will stop the return of the Sith’ so yes if Palpatine would’ve won then Vaders sacrifice would’ve been for nothing but he did destroy the Sith and his kids were there to keep the balance but they didn’t. God bless you all ❤️🙏

[@muigokublack6487]

Well the galaxy would be boned though really it was already screwed so Papa Palpatine taking over again wouldn't be all that different. EDIT: Now having seen the video this would make an excellent setting for a Star Wars RPG campaign.

[@dianesinger9729]

Damn what a bastard he was. Palpatine really did take over

[@splashnskillz37]

In my headcanon the villain of the post sequel trilogy would kill Palpatine for interfering with it's plans

[@No.1GodzillaGlazer]

Mesa not very heppy with yousa

[@staarfinger7322]

This would happen realistically. No mary sue energy = rey death and thats a W.

[@johnhoran9840]

Sidious was 10 times as powerful as Rey and Ben combined.

[@xdj2a2]

This is so good 🔥

[@phaserface]

Nice Job!

[@StarWarsElseworlds]

Thank you Lord Vader 🫡

[@michaelhill693]

The good timeline I see.

[@Daniel22208]

Best ending

[@bignelly9476]

What if general grievous got all the fine additions to his collection?

[@Ashin-Jast]

I have an idea for an else worlds story. What if Darth Malgus' rebelling had succeded? If your familer with SWTOR and the Battle of Ilum, thats the point im talking about.

[@lolomolgames5500]

This would be a better end to the sequels and would set it up for another trilogy

[@miguelangelcarrollperez4233]

Darth Sidious The True Dark Lord Sith..... I Want More For This Series, I Have A Sugerency What If The Entire Jedi Council Members Episode 1 Discover Sidious And Plagueis In The Phantom Menace REMEMBER Members Of The Council Are Adí Gallia, Eeth Koth, Saesee Tiin, Yaddle, Yarael Poof, Even Piell, Oppo Rancisis, Plo Koon, Kí Adí Mundi, Yoda, Mace Windu And Depa Billaba, The Place Is The Apartament Of Palpatine Seen In The Phantom Menace Itself Thanks You

[@00martoneniris86]

What if Darth vitiate returnd during attack of the clones

[@luciferneverchanges5841]

I would send him a fruit basket and a thank you note for getting rid of such bad characters.

[@muigokublack6487]

tbf I already consider the Disney Trilogy the darkest timeline where everything went wrong so Papa Palpatine taking over is pretty much the logical end result.

[@randallrona9618]

With Palpatine killing Rey & Ben Solo and rule the galaxy, he would be the Final boss like Ultron-Vision in What If? show while the Force or Bendu might summon the characters from the Star Wars Elseworlds series similar to Guardians of Multiverse, to fight Palpatine in an epic climax fight.

[@knightmare_edits]

Full Potential Anakin would be like Strange Supreme, carrying the entire battle against the Sith Emperor.

[@noxus1238]

Let’s say Ezra survived the emperor’s attack and went into hiding, he encountered Bendu, they create a plan to locate the world between worlds and summon strong allies to fight the emperor as well as any remaining forces from the unknown regions. They recruit Full potential Anakin Jedi Knight Ahsoka Jedi Grevious Inquisitor Starkiller Grandmaster Qui gon Jedi Maul Master yoda Survivor Plo koon Clan mother Assajj Ventress Luke skywalker legends timeline Jedi knight Leia

[@glauberglousger956]

​@@noxus1238 Include the old Sith too, Nihilus, Bane, Vitiate, Kreia, Revan Not the best idea, but I doubt they want competition, and a chance to take over the galaxy again would be a too good offer to refuse If all else fails, Abeloth works too, plus, any galactic invaders will also lose

[@glauberglousger956]

​@@noxus1238 Include the old Sith too, Nihilus, Bane, Vitiate, Kreia, Revan Not the best idea, but I doubt they want competition, and a chance to take over the galaxy again would be a too good offer to refuse If all else fails, Abeloth works too, plus, any galactic invaders will also lose

[@kaysoda3874]

This what-if sent me into a spiral about the force. For example: if Palpatine were to win in the story, then that means that the prophecy about a chosen one bringing balance to the force never would have been made, right? And if it was never made, then the events of the original trilogy and prequel and sequel wouldn't happen. No Anakin, no Luke, no Rey. Right? Because the only reason Anakin was brought in was because of the prophecy, right? Man, maybe I'm just over thinking it. There I go again, sucking my own enjoyment out of something.

[@00martoneniris86]

What if Darth krayt killed Cade Skywalker

[@00martoneniris86]

What if Palpatine executed order 66 in attack of The clones

[@GabeSchmitt]

This is the better ending. Darth Sidious wins in the end, the Jedi are destroyed, but this time, for good, the Sith return and take over the galaxy, and the Skywalker bloodline is finally vanquished. This is the better ending, but I would have Sidious seduce Kylo Ren back to the dark side and become his Sith apprentice, so that Kylo Ren could kill Sidious and become the true Sith Lord. Long live the Sith! P.S: I think once Rey and Kylo Ren are in the afterlife, all the past Jedi there (Luke, Qui-Gon Jinn, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Mace Windu, Yoda, Anakin Skywalker, Ahsoka Tano, Kanan Jarrus, Adi Gallia, Aayla Secura, and Luminara Unduli.) will be disappointed in their failure to stop Sidious and prevent the return of the Sith. This should have been the ending, that way our beloved Emperor can finally have victory over his enemies. Those who thought they can stop Sidious were wrong, and that the Sith will always return. Long live the Sith!

[@18KTray]

What if the Jedi ruled their own empire?

[@nikidesignsolutionsandgami1518]

I wish you had had palpatine voiced in this one.

[@Steve-em5xt]

What if Ray was Luke Skywalker's daughter that would be a interesting what if video

[@QQ1-rien]

Finn could not sense Marey Sue's death because he is not Force sensitive. But I'm discussing à fanfiction where Han returned as a Force ghost.

[@StarWarsElseworlds]

He sensed her death in the movie because he is force sensitive…

[@ZillaFury2542]

@@StarWarsElseworlds this timeline is the most nightmarish with no one to fight the Sith Eternal Empire.

[@enadasa]

Gooooood!

[@floppyinc2968]

Better than the crap we already got

[@gretanolansmommy2186]

What if Darth crate and Abeloth and the yuuzhan vong Killed Palpatine

[@trx_ced1142]

i actually believe anakin would be resurrected by the force and destroy palpatine

[@kinararazan8222]

What if obi wan killed anakin on mustafar but palpatine killed yoda in their duel on the senate chamber?

[@stephenquinn3447]

What if Darth Sidious killed Maul instead of Savage Opress?

[@Xx_meamer_xX]

Dude croissant was destroyed by star killer base

[@procyon6370]

*Coruscant, and no, apparently that was a planet called Hosnian Prime.

[@NelkaelVehuiah]

Great, you have Bulgakoved the main characters ❤

[@furious_pie466]

I can imagine the Empire would thrive until Abeloth and since Palpatine has never shown to acknowledge her existence he probably wouldn’t see her coming and since Abeloth can possess people The Empire would probably slowly but surely crumble until she kills him herself and then unleashes her own power against the Galaxy

[@Crackmiser]

Then we would’ve gotten a more satisfying ending

[@connorj4219]

Does this one sound a cool one to make is What if Rey died instead of Ben in The Rise of Skywalker

[@encounterplus1299]

Hey… Why don’t you make a “What if The Galactic Empire Invaded Wakanda!!!!?”

[@cambuxton6835]

What if Sidieous is actually the Mother (Abolith)?

[@gutergoy9053]

the good ending

[@BoredGamerGuy115]

This is what should have happened Or Rey Joining Palpatine either way we could have gotten a better ending. Cause I can't be the only one who got endgame vibes from when Rey beat Palpatine.

[@MosileZ]

Still a better ending than what we got.

[@MisterHDGaming995]

Good alternative and narration maybe fake but you do best alternatives I also dream of sith stories I have few ideas dm somewhere?

[@DjDeadpig]

NGL, if I was Sidious, I would’ve made Snoke my apprentice, cause at least he’s far more intelligent than either Rey or Ben. Realistically speaking Sidious could just fire the high council of the final order and replace them all with Snoke clones.

[@darthjader77]

For the Empire and long live the Empire and the Sith Empire

[@AndyDanny47]

A timeline where the sith has won! No one will oppose them.

[@krane1155]

Expect the Far Outsiders and the Chaos Bringer

[@Nmagg1776]

Gragu could have stopped him with his Jedi and mandalorian training

[@00martoneniris86]

What if sugestions What if the Jedi Council traind Anakin Skywalker What if the Jedi executed the 12 dark Jedi of Ajunta Pall What if Jedi revan and Jedi malak killed Darth vitiate What if Darth revan and Darth malak staid under Darth vitiate mind control what if the Sith Empire won the great hyperspace war What if trilla killed Cal kestis cere junda on fortress inquisitorius What if Cal kestis killed Darth vader on fortress inquisitorius What if Darth Maul killed Obi wan Kenobi Owen and aunt Beru And Luke Skywalker in Star Wars Rebels What if Darth vader killed Ezra and Ahsoka and Darth Maul killed the Ghost Crew and kanan and Darth vader What if goerge Lucas dident sole Star Wars Tho Disney What if Dooku dident kil sifo dyas What if Darth revan joined bastila shan Kotor 1 Ending What if Darth Plagueis traind Mace windu instead of Palpatine What if Darth Maul died on Naboo

[@dk6419]

Even better if those awful movies were never made.

[@LouisTravieon]

Palpatine/Sidious is THE most powerful and EVIL character in Star Wars. All hail The Senate!

[@rodey6416]

The whills are gonna interfere

[@Endrgamr262]

Ngl I prefer this over the real ending

[@bronykingamethystrain5676]

Still better than what actually happened.

[@jclau77]

16:26 r/ihavereddit anyone?

[@DARS_04]

Ah yes, the good ending.

[@kianvandenberg6364]

Based timeline

[@ericdentry9236]

If only he had

[@aranha6285]

Then the Sequels would have actually been good

[@huskyamethyst6541]

I feel like if u take away plot armor for Rey and kylo he definitely would and should have killed them

[@rebornskeleton5232]

The good ending

[@thepandasamurai228]

The Good ending

[@leon-uc3wc]

The good ending.

[@chromxrobinandcorrinxcamil9031]

Dark Sith Empress Rey Palpatine Skywalker > Rey "Skywalker".

[@Plaguegotarrested6573]

Emperor was completely butchered in the sequels he was dumb and week this outcome makes more sense

[@defnothankjwimbleton3475]

If only…

[@jaieregilmore971]

Wait Rey and Kylo is dead? Tragic…. 😐Wow Anakin should had stayed his ass to the light side.

[@freethinker77]

I find the new Star Wars stuff to be cringeworthy, but this was bearable.

[@J09.10]

The waffle house has found its new host

[@knightofwind2929]

would be better than the trash movie we got

[@Paul-yw3yj]

Promo sm 💞

[@rgaming2165]

this is not even star wars anymore

[@vandergamer8682]

Episode 9, but it's realistic

[@boundlessaether392]

Yeah. Supposedly ten thousand Xystons (according the novel of TRoS) is somehow able to be defeated with 14,000 ships and Rey beating Palpatine in spite of only one year of force training.

[@muigokublack6487]

@@boundlessaether392 Let's be honest, the Disney Trilogy is best ignored. It brings me no joy saying that but it retroactively harms the previous six movies in ways we're still seeing today.