What if Obi-Wan Didn't Die in A New Hope? Star Wars Theory

[@Cannonbolt101]

"With a look of shock on Vader's face" I don't know how to tell you this, but Vader has a bucket on his head

[@CataciousAmogusevic]

He can show emotions under that bucket but no one would see them

[@avaa1045]

beat me too it

[@ppekaaa]

he is a buckethead

[@thiccchungo1041]

I noticed that too

[@NeddySpaghettiEdits]

🤣🤣🤣😂😂

[@bundleization]

"If you strike me down i will become more powerful then you could ever imagine" "K then i wont" "Oh"

[@BrownSillyCat]

"K LOL"

[@NormALMann42069]

Vader: ...yah sorry about wanting to kill you and stuff so... even?

[@minecraft_slayer887p7]

lol

[@cattata01-_-38]

Vader:fine we will settle this in another way,pod racing. Obi wan:oh shit.

[@Ben-xz3bo]

cattata01 YT-_- it’s working!

[@ArlGrmes]

Missed opportunity to have Chewie and Yoda reunite.

[@azkera]

Here how the convo goes Chewie:ARGGGH,ARGGHWWUAAA Yoda:missed you,i do

[@lukewhite9237]

Yoda turns to Luke: good relations with chewie I have

[@waytogoa2076]

Iopwnesneluekkoosmssfssntmefssnvheluekktam

[@eptheman]

Enit

[@deasttttt]

Ketamine like in the good old days, we must do

[@theflock4916]

Vader: Master, do you know what happened to Mace? Emperor: What? Vader: He went out the Windu. Emperor: *chuckling intesifies*

[@DragonFGCdb]

Emperor: chuckling intensifies as it turned into a laugh of death, died by laughing

[@darthball001]

Lol

[@surinderdosanjh4369]

PelicanYT Official should’ve done *C H U C K L I N G I N T E N S I F I E S*

[@ilariapedatella2157]

@Martin Saxegård Olsen I dont think soooooo I think the avengers part made it great and also funny

[@ilariapedatella2157]

@Martin Saxegård Olsen it's about your own opinion so you cant persuade people to think something else buddy

[@nobs4565]

Palpatine: dies Disney: WAIT A MINUTE SOMETHING AINT RIGHT

[@patrickweber3954]

Me: Disney you're not Canon in my roleplays.

[@patrickweber3954]

@nicholascooney MAIN Disney must be destroyed.

[@eclipsethezorua1905]

@nicholascooney MAIN WELL THEN YOU ARE ENTITLED TO YOUR OWN OPINION!

[@nobs4565]

Eclipse the Zorua dude chill

[@COOLPEAK]

Eclipse the Zorua and your opinion if you think Disney is canon is not a fact.

[@LyviannaXIV]

Vader: When I left you, I was but a learner. Now I am the master. Kenobi: Only a master at getting caught!

[@ilordjesus3116]

Ketsueki How is he a master if He was on the council but never got the rank of master!?!?!

[@shellyalfianda7236]

@@ilordjesus3116 you didn't watch star wars animated series: the clone wars? So R/whooosh

[@Wincognit0]

You watched Obi-Wan Kenobi - Master of Trolling, didn’t you?

[@shellyalfianda7236]

@@Wincognit0 yes

[@kingnae5383]

"Only a Master of Evil, Darth"

[@94elbert]

But I bet Vader teaching younglings was definitely a supervised class 😂😂😂

[@jimskywaker4345]

luke was never told about that

[@Kate_405]

Oh gosh ur right😂😂😂😂😂

[@chainsawlizard9528]

4:37 "Vader turned to look at Obi-wan with a look of shock on his face." Wait

[@zorn1745]

Haha

[@regentwaynekerr]

Why is no-one else talking about this

[@ForeverGOATed001]

Truuuuuue😂

[@regentwaynekerr]

@@prqel1666 oh sorry

[@cmonmanyessir9808]

What?

[@ThatBloodraven0145]

Obi-wan "it's time for you to meet an old friend." Luke "who?" Mysterious figure " Ya wantta buy some death sticks?!"

[@thekodex1186]

Lmao

[@tylerjhackett6806]

You don't wanna sell me any death sticks

[@darylchurch2115]

@@tylerjhackett6806 I don't wanna sell you any death sticks.

[@MrOscar999]

@@darylchurch2115 You want to go home and rethink your life.

[@darthsion8081]

@@MrOscar999 I wanna go home and rethink my life.

[@TheBrickBaron]

what if vader wasn't honored that they could join him????????????

[@jg-zp9ft]

xD

[@emperorpalpatine3161]

Tommy Peli No intro

[@jg-zp9ft]

Emperor Palpatine lol

[@StarWarsTheory]

Then SWT would have a different intro lol.

[@alexandrkrupka1766]

That was my comment a few days ago, but SWT didn't like it. :'(

[@StarWarsTheory]

What if Obi-Wan Didn't have the high ground??

[@jona.o8098]

Star Wars Theory what if Maul killed Kenobi on Raydonia

[@97AsV]

Star Wars Theory hello there !

[@willismcintosh917]

Star Wars Theory was shme force sensitive and if not what if she was

[@rajav4929]

Star Wars Theory WHAT IF THE PADAWAN WHO SEABED SENATOR ORGANA SURVIVED AND WENT WITH HIM.

[@willismcintosh917]

What if shme sky walker was a Jedi and still gave birth to anikan

[@johnsalvi3870]

Vader: Kills a bunch of younglings Vader: "I'm good now, can I start a school with a bunch of kids?" New Republic: "Yeah sure!!!'

[@DugrozReports]

"You killed all of us as children!!!"

[@kylereece5439]

@@DugrozReports "awkward, this is."

[@Grilled-Cheese-Sandwich]

Hehehehe

[@user-bw9jo2iz5s]

@@Grilled-Cheese-Sandwich e

[@Maliq28]

@@user-bw9jo2iz5s double E

[@medditor3863]

*What if obi-wan crushed darth Vader’s breathing device with the force in “a new hope?”*

[@obi-wankenobi7886]

That is not the Jedi way

[@vegitoblue2187]

Watch the HISHE

[@Kuriboh1008]

@@vegitoblue2187 what if that's the reason that he made this comment

[@vegitoblue2187]

Domino Hevy 😂

[@Kuriboh1008]

@@vegitoblue2187 Makes you think, doesn't it?

[@itsRandomizer]

For some reason I believe that Yoda and Ben would've told Luke about Vader being his real father during his training in Dagobah.

[@Bowfella]

itsRandomizer I mean... They did.

[@ddsjgvk]

mihajlo525 in episode 6 after he fought Vader. But if Obi wan was in 5 it probably would of went a lot different

[@shoaibkayani1496]

@@Bowfella From a certain point of view

[@vampricyoda]

I feel like Yoda and Kenobi telling Luke about Vader and Leia would count as his "great trial"

[@hiro9253]

What if Obi-Wan Didn't Die in A New Hope? Star Wars Theory me: we would have more memes

[@masteryoda5237]

When I left, *you* had the high ground. Now *I* have the high ground.

[@jackmeds12]

Palpatine: kill him! Vader: WHAT? Palpatine: oh cmon! It’s the same thing you did to count Dooku! Vader: fair enough. Luke: never Palpatine: DEW IT

[@chickhicks3744]

DiamondStick Thank you for copying that from “How ROTJ Should have Ended”

[@jackmeds12]

A random Channel sry I didn’t know

[@alexdeghost2729]

???

[@illogical3516]

Diamondstick Droid tails I love it

[@mattdavis1376]

I like it

[@nesonite8925]

All this if obi didn't die!!!!???!!! DAMMIT OBI!!!!

[@thalassiccinder7382]

If he didn't die in a new hope the scene where he died would have been an episode 6 Return of the Jedi

[@charh7401]

I know right

[@obi-wankenobi7886]

What are you talking about I'm alive, see?

[@sars910]

Obi-Wan Kenobi Hello There

[@MELTEDBUHTTER]

Obi-Wan Kenobi what’s it like to have the high ground?

[@GameBoy-tm1rc]

What if Obi wan tried to save padme when Anakin was choking her instead of standing there watching.

[@26Y-E6X]

That would change the time line

[@zavaraninoveuhorky]

@@26Y-E6X absolutely maybe (i dont think so) Anakim would seen that anger is taking over him But at least... idk but it would change the timeline definetly

[@user00flaco]

@@zavaraninoveuhorky anakin*

[@BeanieDoggerson]

She died of a broken heart, not the strangling. Unless I’m wrong. But I never understood why he stood there 😂

[@adamhogan5442]

@@BeanieDoggerson he was in shock he knew about their relationship and still felt anakin could be turned back but lost most of his hope when he did that

[@franklindai4320]

He snuck into Vader's ship. After all, he was really good at this. 😂😂😂😂

[@barrettlong3293]

What if the high ground was made of sand

[@mikeoxsmal8022]

Barrett Long obi won would incase ankin in it

[@MELTEDBUHTTER]

Anikan wouldn’t have gotten his limbs cut off because he doesn’t like sand and he wouldn’t have tried anything dumb. My boi kenobi either would have left or tried to kill Anikan from the high ground jumping downward and probably would have died. So moral of the story if the high ground was sand Anikan would’ve kept his luscious hair. 😂👍🏻

[@huhaidkkdkd1396]

Barrett Long omg that would be a movie!

[@jaydee4861]

It was black sand dickbag

[@reddeath5791]

Than Anakin would be screwed

[@jahbama6202]

“Yeah, mace was pretty neat.” “What ever happened to him?” “I helped throw him out of the windu”

[@Unbrickme]

I feel like I've seen your profile picture before

[@Nahte5]

Stolen

[@starlight0313]

@@Unbrickme 2nfg

[@douglaspinheiro2345]

What if owen let obi wan train luke when he was a child

[@RealMGCreed]

Govito Great One

[@douglaspinheiro2345]

Thank you

[@Theemptythroneistaken]

Then vader would of found luke sooner.

[@cattata01-_-38]

What if obi just raised luke?

[@bigboy_can1834]

too op

[@fernandoreyes8011]

"Never.......I'll Never Unsub"

[@fernandoreyes8011]

"It Would Be An Honor, If I Also Got A Reply" :)

[@DrewZepp]

Soggy Yeti be careful not to choke on your aspirations.

[@DarkSaberGD]

DrewZepp Soggy Yeti

[@lukeskywalker7248]

Soggy Yeti Uh oh...

[@enkeksinimee6388]

Soggy Yeti same

[@harrisonkelly9964]

“With a look of shock on his face” HHHMMMMMMMMMM

[@WAVDNL]

What if Anakin didn't "Do it"?

[@WashuHakubi4]

No Luke and Leia ;-)

[@rebelassassin317]

They made one

[@ChrellMax]

*dew it dew it dew it dew it dew it dew it dew it dew it dew it dew it* until Anakin gave in

[@illogical3516]

Do it

[@huhaidkkdkd1396]

ya boi bizza barker then Palestine would have said I have the high “chair”

[@henrylangdon]

What if the sarlacc pit fell in boba fett?

[@ausername271]

Ah, a good one. I think it would happen that way instead of how it did.

[@nickgriffin7710]

Lol

[@hypergames2726]

Tell that to grian

[@hypergames2726]

Plus THATS FUCKING IMPOSSIBLE

[@levelstarfish194]

Iluminati conformed

[@WillTw12]

“With a shocked expression on his face, Vader turned around and ignited his lightsaber” How tf does Vader show an expression on his mask?

[@TheRealTaolf]

Will Tweed I just questioned that 😂

[@cattata01-_-38]

@Muntaj Gill hahahah lol

[@enbyjedi]

Watch this channel’s Vader fan fiction Shards of the Past part 1. When Sidious quips “Yet Skywalker’s powers DWARFED yours. Did they not?” and watch Vader’s reaction. That’s how.

[@Aquila476]

@Muntaj Gill great tutorial

[@simplysteve68]

Add expression emojis over the mask, in the editing process. Lol

[@noahsmind4009]

Yay, I love my Paw Patrol ads before my Star Wars Fan-Fic

[@johnnyklebitzrevenge4793]

Noah’s Mind Teen Titans Go here

[@-_Ella_--wk9ej]

*forever wheezing inside*

[@Tyler-f00k1n]

Your Star Wars fan fic will be there on the double.

[@the1hylander568]

I rather star wars ads before my paw patrol fan fic

[@nsx5022]

wait aren't ads based on what u watch..?

[@salaihsulayman1680]

"what if Asoka turned Darth Vader to the light side during their fight in rebels?"

[@GamersStandUnitedClan]

this.

[@jjvask]

Woah..... Nice one!

[@wingedbluj1674]

If that did happen, Luke's would become a traditional Jedi instead.

[@johannsebastianbach1649]

Big Boy Brutus oh shit that's a good one

[@Itsprincesweets]

Big Boy Brutus dewit!

[@theluckycan5764]

Vader & Luke: *makes Jedi school* Vader having to teach younglings: *heavy breathing*

[@user-yy2bs5hw4d]

I always see u at any star wars video.

[@tony8399]

What if Yoda hid in Tatooine?

[@WashuHakubi4]

He would dry out and die, like any frog-like creature in a super-hot and super-dry environment. "Always in motion is the future. But pretty damn easy to see, my death is."

[@mrspinner2588]

nope he would become brown

[@frankdees507]

WashuHakubi4 Nah in mos eisley there was probably every species of alien to be found in the galaxy, not to mention hutts are also frog like creatures

[@tiio2208]

Vader & Sidious would sense him

[@jowlorenz9555]

yoda sounds like grover from sesame street ---what if yoda had a twin brother that sounds like elmo?

[@pisteniilo]

what if Padmes name was Sandy?

[@marwan1414]

22pisteniilo 22 Anakin would tell her that he hates sand and that its coarse, rough, irritating and gets everywhere. Sandy gets offended (or affended?) and slaps Anakin in the face, and they never get married. The rest is yours.

[@katakisLives]

We'd wind up with a Grease/star wars crossover with musical numbers!

[@angelwhispers2060]

katakisLives ONly if we can go back in time and make Leo DeCaprio play anikin.... I'm NOT listening to Hayden Christensen sing.... NOOOOOOO!

[@akashshanmugam7162]

22pisteniilo 22 that was James Earl Jones

[@Itsprincesweets]

22pisteniilo 22 do it!

[@agentpixi6435]

If only Luke had two lightsabers he could have reflected the lightning back.

[@TheLalalaMan]

Mace needed 1, Yoda used none

[@kingmystery8425]

Rey skywalker:same

[@darthmarr3948]

Stfu

[@jennvioletkennedy]

Lol

[@dariusfarrel3228]

Yoda just used his hand, If only Yoda taught Luke how to do it before going there, Considering one of Palpatine’s main attacks is force lightning

[@Oktoayy]

What if Vader played amogus with Naruto from fortnite tho?? that would be CRAZY 🤪🤪🤪💯💯

[@loganeaton5367]

True

[@frentzen100]

No way, there was the Rule of 2.

[@zanevonholland4708]

He would only take one and keep him secret

[@firedragon9966]

The Sith Rule of Two will be broken so he can’t

[@jetttesoriero5096]

@@firedragon9966 palpatine did it

[@ProtoMario]

What if Jar Jar Binks was the Sith Lord in Episode 7

[@Calvin.440]

Jar jar is the deadliest sith ever

[@davidcorneil3654]

Jar jar does not even literally know how to be a Sith Lord but he still can be a million Jedi

[@pedroivog.s.6870]

@@davidcorneil3654 man Jar Jar is the most powerful sith ever

[@Wolffman109]

He would've been shot on sight.

[@gib2689]

Rey would die in 0 second

[@rhet_draws1914]

The only thing I would‘ve added would be a „hello there“ when he comes in the room with luke, vader and the emperor

[@Kate_405]

Hello there

[@rebelfriend9006]

@@Kate_405 general kenobi

[@rokuthegod9525]

4:38 really a look of shock on his face 😂

[@sanderjediknight1957]

Hello Roku the God😊😊🙂🙂😏😏😏👋🏻👋🏻👋🏻👋🏻

[@rokuthegod9525]

Sander Jedi Knight Hello 😄👋

[@sanderjediknight1957]

Roku the God How are you doing Avatar Lord?😐😐🤔🤔🤷🏼‍♂️🤷🏼‍♂️🤷🏼‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️😊😊😊🙂🙂🙂😏😏😏♥️♥️♥️♥️❤️❤️❤️❤️💕💕💕💕

[@jennyberger8229]

Sander Jedi Knight WHY SO MANY EMOJIS!?!?

[@jennyberger8229]

Sander Jedi Knight NNNOOOO THE EMOJIS

[@the_grim_gamer3039]

Hold on you said Luke's emerald lightsaber but the events of cloud city didn't happen so... wouldn't Luke still have his fathers lightsaber

[@degeindark3108]

that is a very good point

[@JaxJordan35]

Awesome Trey There are theories that the green lighsaber he got had the crystal from Qui Gonn's lightsaber.

[@maximumgames2990]

It is still tradition for new knights to make their own lightsaber, so maybe he was doing a dual-wieldy thing, or learning to do so, at least.

[@katakisLives]

He would certainly still have his blue light sabre at this point because he lost it along with his hand in his previous confrontation with Vader and in this timeline that event presumably didn't occur

[@hawkthephoenix4701]

He could've kept it as a backup. Luke: Never. (Discards his lightsaber) I will never turn to the dark side. Sidious: Then you will die. (Force lightning) Luke: (Draws the blue lightsaber) Vader: (Has ww2 flashbacks of him as Anakin) Luke: Did you really think I came here without a backup plan? Sidious: Yes.

[@leighton9469]

“Look of shock” he has a mask

[@ABCDyeahyeahyeah]

at least no snoke at the end, for once 😁😁😁

[@seahippo4902]

Yay

[@tyronglore5458]

ABCDyeahyeah he was ok doing Coke. Bud-um-crash

[@dragshan5255]

That's because luke would beat the crap out of snoke.

[@nobleregret5314]

Why do we need the information that snoke just exists

[@animegamerjace9851]

@@nobleregret5314Lol fr it gets a bit old

[@thetruebleu014]

“With a look of shock on his face...” I couldn’t tell. He looked the same.

[@GamingWookie]

Que Han Solo being smug that a blaster saved Obi-Wan’s life.

[@ThinWhiteAxe]

yeessssss so uncivilized

[@Commander_U]

What do you think would have happened if the hyperdrive worked well in the phantom menace, so that the Jedi directly went to corouscant and never found Anakin on Tatooine?

[@jesusoftheapes]

If that training had taken place Luke would have known Vader was his father . Yoda would have told him after he trusted Luke was strong enough to handle the bad news . Not only that a fully trained Luke couldnt bring balance to the universe because the Jedi were not training the correct form of Jedi teachings . Only on his path alone could he find the true teachings of the Jedi and begin a New Hope for the jedi !

[@diegoprodriguez]

From now on, every time a fan fiction ends, I’m gonna day out loud “And then Snoke comes.”

[@gg_ibi123ahd5]

That’s literally me

[@Kate_405]

Might as well

[@alponevanpaa722]

I didn't die! I am force ghost!

[@ye7170]

Obi-Wan Kenobi shut up u can't even fly a snowspeeder

[@obiwankenobi3933]

Obi-Wan Kenobi IMPOSTER

[@alponevanpaa722]

Obi Wan Kenobi No i am not

[@OnlyTimefps9]

CLONES!!!!!! 😵😭😩😧😦😮

[@ye7170]

Obi-Wan Kenobi clones

[@BlueGuy98]

Wow, a theory that's not based around Revenge of the Sith. That's pretty rare

[@kenneymitchell2179]

I thoroughly enjoy these alternate theories. The only problem that I have with them is that they would shorten the series quite a bit stop. Some theories probably wouldn't make it past episode 3 or 4. Keep up the good work and keep the videos coming.

[@notyourbusiness5530]

Wait, so if Luke doesn't go save his friends, Yoda trains him into a jedi master. But if Obi-Wan and Yoda train him at a much sooner time, he's only a jedi knight?

[@JasonGroom]

He was never made a master until after ROTJ events. He even says he is a Jedi Knight when he enters Jabas palace.

[@boiledcabbage5139]

0:30 Why does this part remind me of a YTP

[@stanknugget]

“A look of shock on Vader’s face.” lol.

[@thedukeofcraft1464]

What if anikan had a twin that was as powerful as him that was trained by yoda and anikan was trained by obi wan

[@angelwhispers2060]

THAT could be Epic! because seriously Yoda would notice something was off with (ani's twin) and go save their mom. Makeing the twins much Less susceptible to the darkside.

[@seanduarte5989]

What if instead of opening a new academy Luke is seduced by the dark side after killing Palpatine and he takes the mantel of Emperor.

[@danmichaud5506]

Well the Death Star literally blew up minutes after their fight was concluded soo....

[@Jvargier0]

Luke never killed palpatine

[@jenayafisher5504]

Sean Duarte i

[@flashbackfilms2466]

Sean Duarte Vader would’ve been like nope son I waited to long fir this shit it’s my turn

[@flashbackfilms2466]

Sylvester Cash so? He can still say it

[@zenron5149]

“With a look of shock on his face” ah yes, I can for sure see the face behind that mask

[@jdawg746]

but obi-wan let vader kill him so he could help luke better as a ghost without the limitations of the physical world becoming "more powerful than you could ever imagine"? You can tell he let vader win by the way he holds his lightsaber, standing still while vader strikes him down

[@dorotaallen9309]

jdawg746 Similar to the way Harry Potter let Voldy kill him in the forbidden forest in DH2. Harry and all those he protected with that action became more powerful than Voldy could have imagined.

[@flameshot4798]

It’s just a what if, for fun

[@anojamalalage7242]

1:55 when they see a frog like creature Yoda: WHAT?! Kenobi:It’s true Me:yeah Luke:ok then?

[@andrewmurray1550]

Frog like Creature? I can't imagine Yoda playing banjo and singing "Rainbow Connection" or "Movin' Right Along" in a Studebaker...

[@jaydenjimenez9692]

Would luke still have his original lightsaber

[@mowinnie4821]

J&M Those two kids most likely Jedi are to create their own lightsaber it would surprise me in the long time training Yoda and Obi-Wan had Luke create his own lightsaber

[@methadone1212]

@@mowinnie4821 how wasn't the kyber crystal planets dominated by the empire or destroyed the kyber crystals on it

[@wrysts4113]

@@methadone1212 hey, im here to answer your question 11 months later. so obi wan kept his masters Lightsaber,and luke probably found it whilst searching through obi wans stuff.

[@LavarBall4Real]

Can you do what if yaddle never left the jedi order -LaVar Ball

[@johnnymanziel9309]

LaVar Ball is your son the GOAT?

[@FrostByteFilms]

LaVar Ball she died

[@danielvincent9157]

BONZO LALL SUCKS

[@mansikkamehupoika8959]

LaVar Ball what if jedis used BBB shoes

[@jaywolf1998]

Pacers Forever she died in legends not canon.

[@tracilombardi5000]

Or if luke absorbed the lightning like Yoda did with Dooku I think it was Also I love that we see an emperor luke fight I’ve always wanted to see that

[@whizpartydoge4430]

"The battle would be the greatest the galaxy would have ever seen" But, there's only 4 people.

[@asukaifire2929]

What if Obi-Wan was the Chosen One instead of Anakin or What If Mace Windu was the Chosen One

[@matthewmann8969]

What if Palpatine found out about the death star blowing up while he was taking a dump?

[@laundrybasketgamers]

Obi Wan would’ve won if he had the high ground.

[@Kate_405]

Sad😂

[@MadzTX]

What if Palpatine got to Padmé first and recruited her to help turn Anakin? Also, what if Padmé and Anakin didn't get pregnant with the twins until after he turned to the dark side?

[@katakisLives]

I think Padmé could have been turned with the right incentive like galactic peace.

[@StillTrustNo1]

Somehow I think Padme would have noticed that he didn't have any legs and arms left. Maybe she wouldn't have been just as into the whole "ocean in motion" thing with a "semi-robot." - if it was working at all. Maybe losing the ability to an erection is what truly leads to the dark side :)

[@pro-gamer7391]

If Obi-Wan didn't die and the battle on Bespin never happened, then Luke never had a green lightsaber. It was blue just like Obi-Wan's.

[@randomtem5865]

He still would've had a green one, because the last "part" of becoming a jedi knight is to create your own lightsaber.

[@dorotaallen9309]

Pro-Gamer 73 Does the lightsaber crystal choose the force user? If a force user is using someone else's saber, is it still as powerful?

[@Justin-on8fi]

Dorota Allen this ain’t harry potter

[@commanderkittycat6513]

3:55 What ship? Han dropped them off at Dagobah and that was it, there was no other ship. The closest thing that Yoda had to a ship on Dagobah was the escape pod that was already used to get him to Dagobah in Revenge of the Sith. If they contacted Han again to pick them up, then he would have either been still frozen in carbonate or been fighting against Vader and the emperor.

[@obiwankenobi3933]

What if my apprentice had the high ground?

[@garudaboy8372]

Obi Wan Kenobi you force pull into the lava

[@butteredtoast6510]

Woulden't Vader be placed under arrest, turned or not? The New Republic would still seek Justice for Vaders crimes

[@michaelmargono]

I'd say maybe vader would take the mantle of emperor and strike a deal with the new republic and having systems hold elections on which side they want to join. Afterwards, he could step down and make a group of people in charge so multiple individuals have power instead of one single emperor.

[@juliethenderson6734]

real theory: what if obi-wan was a decent master and actually wanted to train luke instead of just dying??

[@xavierlauzac5922]

He did train Luke.

[@davidjohnson-gs9je]

ObiWan had to distract Vader or the falcon would never have escaped. Plus ObiWan knew he stood 0 chance against Darth Vader. Vader had been fighting ever since ROTS while ObiWan was being a hermit.

[@lucas.kotomski.4287]

You have to remember that Vader actually wanted them to escape because he knew that they would immeadiately go to the rebel base.

[@DangerZone200]

sooo.....your telling me Obi-wan couldn't just immediately force crush or break Vaders robot arms and legs and leave him limbless on the floor again

[@Kate_405]

Nah he goood

[@thatboy2504]

'Obi-Wan would enter the room, My Father was in rage, Obi-Wan turned to me, and said "There is nothing to fear, Luke" He ignited his lightsaber, my father striked Obi-Wan with the rage of a true sith, while i ignited, Palpatine ignited his lightsaber and dashed at me, i would parry all his attacks using the light side, Obi-Wan would slash my father, revealing his Apprentice's half face, the emperor finally got to me and electrocuted me with his lightning, Obi-Wan dashed to the emperor clashing with him, Obi-Wan got force pushed and i and him suffered getting electrocuted, my father quickly ignited his lightsaber striking the emperor down with no mercy, me and Obi-Wan rised, after that us three trained force sensitives, with A New Jedi Order

[@jizzmaster4144]

“With a look of shock on his face” HOW HOW DF DO YOU SEE THIS MANS FACE

[@strawraindrop]

9:09 Anakin: there was a Jedi who could harness the power of both the light and dark side. His name was mace windu. Luke: what happened to him? Anakin:... well um

[@sanyin3615]

Anikan: Uhhhh welllll I might had...threw him out of the windu Luke: you WOT

[@magnablocker]

You should make a second version of this theory, make it so that Kenobi didn't purposely let himself die at all.

[@kingpenguin1580]

What if general grevious had the high ground!?!

[@benbrunton1901]

Grievous: I have the high ground! Obi-Wan (to himself): he's right Kenobi then kills himself knowing that he can't win

[@reddeath5791]

Maul has high ground over obi wan=obi wan wins Grevious has high ground over obi wan=obi wan wins OBI WAN has high ground to Anakin logically should make Anakin the winner but=OBI WAN F#CKING WINS!!!!!

[@saltysimon67]

He did at one point

[@reddeath5791]

@J Lowndes true

[@ironstarofmordian7098]

He did. Then Obi Wan killed him because Obi Wan is the high ground.

[@commanderwolffe9737]

Palpatien: *dies* Disney: I THINK NOT

[@luthientinuviel3708]

Wait a sec. How does Luke have a ship when the millennium falcon left after it 'dropped' him off?

[@mayorkel]

yoda gives luke the ship he used to get there.

[@theoferro]

우현서 he used a lambda shuttle aboard the Death Star I think

[@reddeath5791]

Umm...m-maaaaaaaaaaagiiiiiiiiiic

[@BillyisAmongUs]

the falcon did not drop him off he went there with his own x wing

[@randy259]

What if Padme was force sensitive

[@dannychen9685]

Teaching a new generation of Jedi to train like Mace Windu, could've been a Grey Jedi Order while remaining in the Light! This is lovely!

[@Blackthorntribe93]

Dude I loved it and oh my gosh this was the best fanfiction ever! may the Force be with u ^^

[@lancebearden8782]

What if Anakin died on mustafar ?

[@WashuHakubi4]

George Lucas' second trilogy goes up in flames.

[@SifGreyfang]

Then the story doesn't continue

[@Sly88Frye]

That was a really awesome fan fiction right there! Luke being the one to defeat the emperor was quite a twist.

[@OdisDave]

What if Mace Window survive and meet Luke Skywalker...

[@WashuHakubi4]

Mace notices Luke's artificial hand and says, "I see you already met your father."

[@Bowfella]

Clockworks Gamer He only became Mace Window after the "incident".

[@thedeadlynose5127]

How's did mace die..... He was thrown out the windu

[@x_Bahamut]

Remember: The prophecy said Anakin would bring balance to the force, so he would have killed the emperor.

[@Kate_405]

Nah he was lazy Luke did it for him

[@MonzaniaStrike]

Just imagine Luke asking Vader “what happened to this Mace Windu?” Vader: “well uhhh....”

[@lauziyi5728]

Vader: Let’s just say he went out of the *Windu*

[@zaquhe]

I see a couple issues with the way this story goes. 1. In this timeline Luke and Obi-Wan got to dagobah on the Millennium falcon so where did the other ship come from for them to leave the planet? (the ship Yoda arrived on years ago?) 2. If Luke trained until endor does that mean Han was still frozen in carbonite? Luke was vital to the success of the original plan to free Han in the main timeline. also just as a thought, this could have ended with the "what if Vader survived return of the Jedi" fanfic.

[@agentnebraska4515]

What if Anikan had the high ground

[@anakinskywalker9773]

Agent Nebrask Now your talking

[@obi-wankenobi7886]

No. The High Ground is MINE!!!

[@gaiasguardian3564]

Obi-Wan Kenobi Hey Obi wan how are you?

[@WatcherCCG]

Not gonna lie, I do love how half the time Anakin surviving usually ends with the formation of a Grey Jedi Order. The Order of old never really understood what balance in the Force truly meant.

[@futuf2265]

0:35 when I left you I was but a learner AH

[@DaRealLunarVoid]

Mr F it’s I had much to learn

[@reubenmanzo2054]

"with a look of shock on his face" What face?

[@soupshrek4203]

4:52 Luke and Palps just sitting there like how was your day.

[@hannahhughes5446]

Vader: Obi-Wan never told you what really happened to your father. Luke: He told me enough, he told me you killed him! Vader No- *Obi-Wan stabs Vader* Obi-Wan: Oh well, guess you'll never know!

[@babil3185]

Underrated comment

[@david.lat0721]

You said “With a look of shock Vader turns to Obi Wan.” You cant see Vader’s face

[@enbyjedi]

Ok. For everyone commenting how Vader could show a shocked expression through his mask: This channel made a very good fan fiction Vader: Shards of the past, Part One. Whoever is playing Vader is emoting like crazy through that mask. I’d recommend watching it. Star Wars Theory accomplished something truly fantastic and fun to watch.

[@psychicx97]

If Cloud City never happened then Luke, wouldn’t Luke have his blue lightsaber?

[@c.dyr99]

Good point

[@anvos658]

Maybe, its also possible if he was more properly trained Yoda or Obiwan would have still had Luke construct his own saber, since that was part of the training.

[@dragoninthewest1]

You know you never quite explained how they (Luke and Obi-Wan) knew where the second death star was. My theory is that mon mothma pulled Obi-Wan aside before he left for Dagobah to ask him where he's going. Obi-Wan would let her know they're going to find Yoda and she would give them a means of keeping in contact with the alliance.

[@aaravpatel2208]

luke: what happened to my father obi wan:he wasn't good at playing the floor is lava

[@Kate_405]

LOLLLLLLLL

[@franklindelanoroosevelt7467]

Please do what if Count Dooku was on Nabo in episode 1 with Qui Gon Gin & Obi Wan Kenobi fighting Darth maul?

[@matthewmann8969]

Franklin Delano Roosevelt Dooku alone would be too much for Maul

[@DatMentalGamer]

very good question there man, I wonder why dooku was not in ep1 since he was in ep2 and was a jedi when obi wan and Qui Gon fought maul, this could be due to legends though I would love to see how dooku reacted when hearing about his padawans death, this sounds like a really good standalone movie after Disney make that Kenobi movie, if they ever do...

[@thomasjeanes6334]

With a look of shock on his face however you would have no idea from the dark mask he hid behind

[@DaniFilth87]

“With a look of shock on his face, Vader would turn around...” yeah...sure 😄

[@Endemall1]

What if padme did not lose the will to live at the end of episode 3

[@jennyberger8229]

Javier Rocha I thought it said palpiteen (sorry I forgot how to spell his name) lol

[@ironstarofmordian7098]

And instead died of something real?

[@thecreator625]

@@ironstarofmordian7098 So psychological trauma hampering recovery is not real?

[@ironstarofmordian7098]

@@thecreator625 psychological trauma hampers ones ability to survive giving birth? Really? The psychological trauma should've shortened her life. Maybe four years. But out right killing her? Gimme a break.