Stories of sodor theory: Mr. Hall’s plot (special)

[@VictorTanzig1]

You're half right...

[@雪者]

Ooooo!

[@leonarddrawsisback4718]

No wayyy

[@jwdragon6665]

if micky dies I am going to cry

[@eggmannega6895]

That oughta be a drinking game.

[@arenjtumastens]

knew you'd say that.

[@sagittariusneptune9330]

I see Thomas being the Ten Cents of the group, getting blowup but not dying rather in the works and it be a season cliff hanger that he's still at the works till its revealed next season on his update.

[@oliverhood1732]

Well we did also know that Mr. Hall has a twin who’s a troublemaker. I think you got it mixed up because I don’t think it was Robert who did this. It was his twin brother named Shawn. Shawn was probably the one who wanted to kill both Henry and Mr. Zorro for ruining his family and is planning to do an explosion at Brendam Docks which was where the Midis were commissioned at.

[@NarodowyPolski1864]

Yeah that's an interesting theory man. Robert Having A Tein Killing Zorro makes Alot of More Sense Then Robert.

[@Sudriantank743]

​@@NarodowyPolski1864twin

[@TatyanaRogov-k7y]

I think Shawn and Robert Hall are both bad guys

[@oliverhood1732]

@@TatyanaRogov-k7y No Shawn is the bad one and Robert is the good one

[@bluebellsfan8704]

I think Rob was definitely the one to kill Mr. Zorro, if not that he sent his brother to do it.

[@roaropgard8575]

Rest in peace Nigel Zorro Geoffrey and Peter😭😭😭😭

[@mlp-hot-rod5824]

You're missing one very important detail, my friend. Rob's identical twin brother, Shawn. We learn that he was a troubled kid who frequently got into fights at school and then we learn that their Uncle Greg took more of his anger out on Shawn than Rob. I believe Shawn is the real criminal and Rob is just a red herring. You know Victor and his twists. As for deaths, it'll definitely be Mickey, Sheffield and Benson going next. Donald? He was shown to be dead too, but I don't know if Victor's willing to go that far. But, as you said, we'll just have to wait & see.

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

This whole plot about one of the children (Shawn) of the gurad that was killed back in Season 2 who was literally an NPC enacting his revenge on what this railway has done to his family is amazing! I love the fact that events from like 5 years ago play such a major part in this. This is THE best part of the season in my opinion. And is one of the reasons why Season 5 is my favourite stories of Sodor season. Don’t kill me if you dissagree.

[@C21Productio]

I seen The Munitions Episode on Patreon and your gonna be surprised of the circumstances

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

I love the fact that all the music in this video was used at least once in Stories of Sodor!

[@Jetthehawk1994]

Mr. Zorro wasn't going to his house. He was going to a pub.

[@PCMan8922]

Two More Episodes To Go! Let's Wait and See. It Might Be Robert or It Might Be His Twin.

[@ALCO-C855-fan]

Micky WAS taken. WHY VICTOR?!?!?!😤😤😤😤😤

[@jakobnorman315]

I think it might be Mr.hall’s twin brother committing these heinous crimes because at the beginning of the 8th episode he got detention after school for starting a fight which clearly states he’s a troubled man who wants revenge

[@oliverhood1732]

I agree as well

[@jaedenvue3318]

In my opinion, I'm against Mickey not dying. But i do agree with you about Sheffield, because if you look closely, there are some engines who dont appear in the intro as well. In the scene of the Ffarqhuar Quarry, we dont see Thomas, instead we see Jinty. We only see Thomas at the end of the intro. And theres another thing. At the end of the season 5 trailer, we dont see certain characters. The only characters we see are Edward, Henry, Gordon, most likely Douglas, the S&M trio, Reginald, Samantha, Derek, Boco, Kate, Duck, Whiff, James, Diesel, Daisy, Emily, and Eric. We even see Annie and Clarabel. But we don't see Thomas, Percy, Oliver, Donald (seen in the munitions outcome), William, none of the peel godred branch engines.

[@jaedenvue3318]

okay. lets carry on. so. i do believe mickey will die. something that no one has said at all from what i have heard is that when you look closely at the munitions scene, you DO NOT see Mickey. You see Derek, Toby, Eric, Douglas, Edward and Diesel. Strange how Mickey isnt there, since hes the only other Fire and Rescue engine. and at the very end of the trailer, when Edward is at the scrapyard, we see the scrapped remains of a b12, a caledonian 812, a J94, and FR K2, the only two of those being Mickey and Edward, and since we see Edward at the Munitions scene and in the end of the trailer, it has to be Mickey. As for the other bodies, its starting to become clear. Donald may or may not survive, as hes the one that on his side in the trailer and only one of the twins is at the works next to Edward. I do believe that its Donald though as he's the one who Roberts Father was the guard of. The b12 is clearly Benson. Maybe in the next few episodes, he will be at Brendam, overseeing the munitions being shipped, being part of the ROD. He could maybe have risked his life to save an engine, maybe Derek perhaps as we see workman working on him in the scene of the munitions. The J94 will probably be Sheffield, as he doesnt appear in the intro as stated by SRT and several others. Plus, Samantha is seen with Reginald at the end of the trailer, so it can only be Sheffield. So, Benson, Donald, Mickey, and Sheffield are most likely to die according to scene at the end of the trailer. As for anyone else, Im not sure. The SCP's of Sodor take place in 2015, in which we see Bill Ben and Douglas, which also is evidence that Donald is the twin who snuffs it. But we mainly see Diesel, Iris, Salty, Barry, and Edward, which does make sense. As Edward and Barry both are converted through Steam Diesel Conversion. But suspiciously, we dont see Thomas or Percy in the last few scenes. We see with the others at the Munitions disaster, we can assume Mavis is at the quarry, and Whiff is at the end scene at the works. but thomas and percy never appeared then. Percy is only seen in a preview of "Training" Its weird how Annie and Clarabel are at the front, but not Thomas and Percy.

[@jaedenvue3318]

Oh, and well. Roberts brother was caught, but not robert himself yet. we know that Henry makes it out, hes seen at the end. I have a feeling that Benson will either save someone, or maybe, just maybe, be the one to find out that Robert is behind all of this, and tries to alert the others, but its too late, and he gets killed because of the explosion

[@ConcordeRIP]

My theory is what if it’s both of the brothers? What if Robert is the one obtaining all the information, and is relaying it to his brother who is doing the acts of violence?

[@michaelpascual3581]

I actually agree with this one

[@terancetan5503]

That's a possibility. It could be both of them, but maybe Robert was covering for his brother since he's the "respectable" one.

[@ryanclaydon4864]

I think he wants revenge on the last of the surviving Mines the most.

[@greenengine048]

Nice going, I think it's both Rob and his brother that are involved with this for all we know Rob's brother who we now know is named Shawn is the one doing the sabatoge and Rob is working behind the scenes, I think if its either Sheffield or Peckett that will die I think It'll be Peckett as he's not that prominent in the series right now but I won't take out the possibility that Sheffield could die, as for Mickey I was sure at first he'd die but you do make a good point on why he wouldn't it also makes sense why Rob (and maybe his brother) are setting off the munitions at Brendam Docks because it was the homebase of the LMS

[@TatyanaRogov-k7y]

I think your right about what's going to happen next, but i think Mickey might die as well as sheffield, donald, and benson.

[@ryanthenascarguy4871]

Mr. Hall should get sacked and life in prison!

[@savvadance7006]

Im so very sad that Thomas has died in the Explosion🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔

[@randoburr5201]

Robert Hall: imma ruin this island whole career

[@jacksprofessionalproductio9403]

While I agree with a lot of what you’re theorizing, you mixed up the twins’ names or kinda forgot there are twins. Robert is the good one trying to improve and help the railway, Shawn is the bad one who wants to destroy the railway and specifically kill some of its members, simple. At first I thought it was odd that Shawn wanted to kill Henry to avenge his dad, despite the fact his dad was killed by ACCIDENT. But now knowing he was a bad kid and had the worst of things happen to him and his family partially caused by Mr. Zorro, I can properly understand why he wants the worst for Sodor. Real proper villain development.

[@ThomasSirHandel]

Reginald and Samantha are stand-ins for Big City and Wilbert so will most likely survive. Pickett could go considering Victor rarely uses him. A scrap model of Thomas is seen in the leaked Munitions ending but it's possible it's a fake-out death.

[@andrewobrien8325]

11:40 My bet for who's going to die next is a character you haven't mentioned and tbh I think it'd be fitting, is Eric. I love Eric but I think if that bomb thing is going to have an impact, Eric is just the logical choice plus I think Victor may have given us a small hint in a recent Sodor Short where Eric gets a Girder through the smoke box. Maybe I'm reading too much into it but a ghost wouldn't feel a girder through the smoke box, Eric is an original character, he's one of the few characters who's done nothing wrong so it'd hit doubly hard and while we can see him in the opening, some trailers for shows, games and movies show a character that dies earlier as a way to mislead people....I'm sure Victor is aware of this and even though we see Eric, we don't see his face.

[@E2ForLife]

Eric is in the ending of the season 5 trailer, aka the ending of fallout the last episode of season 5

[@TheTrainTheoristOfficial]

Eric can't really die because we see him with Edward, Toby and Bruce.

[@railfanlynx]

I’ve been saying that for years

[@Trainlover1995]

Eric getting a girder through him and being unaffected isn’t foreshadowing. He’s just too stupid to be lobotomized.

[@andrewobrien8325]

@@E2ForLife Fair enough but I have a horrible feeling someone truly innocent is going to die in that explosion. A canon character that’d make sense is Boco or Thomas but I doubt it. My bet is Eric but my second bet would be Boco it’d just explain where he went like he was written into the railway series only to die in the explosion. Tbh I think there are 4 safe characters because Victor could be using the openings and other things to mislead us since some Sodor shorts now also conflict with the many line story((remembrance for example has Mavis and Adam but they never met) which shows, comics, books, movies and video games have all done before). Those 4 are salty, Bill, Ben and Edward because they’re present in the season 1 first episode where Edward is telling the story

[@karenfan010]

10:12 I think that’s what’s meant to make his death more tragic.

[@nolantherailfan5048]

I just hope one of the main cast doesn't get killed

[@Liam_Chase2024]

Amazing video ❤

[@Jayhsia1215]

Congratulations for doing this

[@estefanostesfaye5301]

I figured it was rob's dad was the guard that died in s2 i like how it all connected since it's was back

[@ETOW_19]

Could Robert Hall or Robert Creedy kill Geoffrey to use his parts to fix other engines?

[@SouthernFlyer1011]

I just finished to watching the munitions and then doing so I noticed something odd. When Terrence was talking about to the weapon used in the murder of Mr zorro mr Hall make the weapons connections to that of his own father's. This brings me to one of two theories either you're right and Mr Hall is the one behind all these acts of terrorism and it's just putting on an act to cover his tracks or it could be his twin brother and generally has no idea about who is behind this.

[@daylight39]

Congrats, victor gave you shoutout on his channel.

[@Steamer96]

I really hope Edward and whoever Hall converted to a diesel go back to normal.

[@ALCO-C855-fan]

I feel like you need a hug. Here ya go. (Hugs.)^^ And yes, screw season 5. Shall I rewrite it?

[@shadow6953]

Me who a patreon supporter : Well i have to keep my mouth shut.. Btw in revenge Robert say that he's twin brother Sean/Shawn/Shaun is punish at school for picking up fight. So in my perspective. Robert really want to save the engine while Shaun want to kill them

[@yoshidinosaur3070]

Don't forget there are two boys and are twins.

[@Tnpt_studios]

Is no one going to talk about the farmer that appeared after Geoffery's death? Good video though.

[@oliverhood1732]

That farmer called for help.

[@spyfan62591]

Revenge was probably the most adult ep. We've seen yet, but munitions will probably be worse. As in devastating. Not a junk ep.

[@madz4121]

really good explanation and theory you made

[@t-rex290]

I’ve seen the munitions episode on Patreon and let’s just say you’re not gonna believe what happens at the end of the video

[@brazilballgaming9947]

8:46 it could also be Glenn since he is also an Austerity, can't be Samantha since she shows up on the trailer i think more that Glenn could be the next one since he doesn't have anymore... well *Plot* like he already has a complete character arc and we never saw him again ever since the episode Nationalization (not counting the cameos on beeching, Etc), Sheffield didnt have many Appearances so i am kinda against that Idea of him dying i am more on his twin brother dying here is my theory (Criticise me cuz i am so bad at Story Writting lol): So after Peter's death, the fat Controller decided to call in a replacement for the big engine, he decided to call in Glenn from the Little western since he spent so much time in a coal Mine (this was said by Emily on episode Secrets) that he Didnt see much of the view, at this time Robert hall was still working on the bomb, back to Glenn he reunites with his twin Brother Sheffield and both have a good talk for a while, until Robert hall puts one bomb in each part of the Sodor to cause most mass destruction, he disguised the bombs as normal Tank Wagons (like Tar, Fuel, Etc) sadly in this tragic time Glenn was at the Docks just by a bomb when it exploded right next to him, killing him instantly (Similar to what happened to Lily) all the other bombs also exploded in all the other parts of the island that they were detonated, after this the police ended up finding out it was Robert hall who did all this and ended arresting him, all of the engines mourned the people that lost their lives in this fallout, but Sheffield was the Most Sad out of them all because he lost one of his Siblings and he felt incredibly sad (Just like Reginald was when Randolph died) but he got support by every engine on sodor (midis and Nor'easters) he also visited Mickey again for Counceling which again gave wonders for the Austerity, soon the island was able to be fixed, but the traumatizing year was still in everyone's mind *The End*

[@nolantherailfan5048]

I can't believe they killed geoffrey

[@spirit1369]

Robert has a brother "Shawn" which pretty much is his twin because they look alike, so he maybe the one responsible.

[@sirmatsdubois2509]

sorry to poke holes into your theory but I don't think it's Mr Hall. and my reasoning for that is because he has mentioned that he has a twin brother. and in this Latest episode we do learn that he has a bit of a troubled past of violence at school. so it's most likely him and not Robert. although it's only a theory it does make the most sense.

[@Ludi_Chris]

I think it’s Hall’s twin brother that’s doing the crimes.

[@Thomas_patrick1234]

Where did you see the episodes for season 5 in that screen shot you took?

[@alanabyss9246]

Dude congrats

[@VicarstownFilmProductions]

if thomas dies I am going to cry!

[@NarodowyPolski1864]

Yeah i am i bit sceptical about If Sheffield Is Going To Die In The Next Episode. Because I See Him as a good character ehy because at first he was grumpy but he became more soft overtime. Soo yeah i don't want another Great Original Character Die Again.

[@therailwaymen2203]

Sheffield is said to work on the railway in modern day as referred in the episode “secrets”

[@yolotimitoloy]

Did anyone find Henry's train, when he crash in seaon 5, to also be the flying keeper ? Given that it was the flying keeper was involved in their father's death, i would argue who ever is capable of pulling the keeper will be killed, so it won't be Mikey.

[@TGM_2018_III]

The plot twist, it’s the twin brother that’s causing the chaos, not Robert, hence why we think it’s Robert because they are identical

[@陳毅恆-v8x]

Well, since I've watched the final episode, it's actually his brother who did it,and alot of theories about thomas could be dtill alive (he is dead in the final episode)

[@andrewobrien8325]

6:36 Just quickly want to say I'd be surprised if he didn't have a hand in the death of Peter. I have to say I was angry about the murder of Peter, that German prat, I'm sorry I understand the why and I can understand the anger the guy would have felt but if that's fair then the same guy should be strapped to the train tracks and let Gordon, Bruce, Douglas and Edward run him over for everything they went through(I mean Adam too if Adam was still alive. Also James for Mr Star). I get it, Peter did something horrible but the German soldiers who turned the hospital into a fortress are more to blame! Peter paid for his crime, those Germans never did and yet Peter is the one that gets shot?! Prat. However the reason I think Hall had a hand in it, is just something feels off about it.

[@terancetan5503]

He could have given the guy the gun, maybe even smuggled it onto Sodor for him!

[@oliverhood1732]

@@terancetan5503That has nothing to do with it. Maybe he probably smuggled it himself.

[@terancetan5503]

@@oliverhood1732 The episode doesn't say, but considering that Mr. Hall's brother had a hand in nearly everything that happened in the season, I wouldn't be surprised if he did so to cause a distraction so that he could break into the munitions factory.

[@oliverhood1732]

@@terancetan5503 No I don’t think Peter had anything to do with his family dying

[@terancetan5503]

@@oliverhood1732 But he was a Middie, and worked for the same company that drove his mother to suicide, especially when one realizes that Sean Hall targeted everyone and everything even remotely associated with the destruction of his family (his father's death, mother's suicide and probably being adopted by a murderer and drunkard). After all, why would he target Brendam Docks when no one who was involved in his family troubles was working there in 1965?

[@JJTheJetPlane-iz2yz]

And like I said, why would he? Why would Mr. Hall do that? He was helping the engines most of the time that we see him. And they do say they're twins, so they look practically identical.

[@sabertooth3studioshq838]

Didn't Hall have a twin brother?

[@SoraFan23]

I saw the newer episode and oh my god Thomas has been killed off.

[@leoarevalo6786]

He didn't die, he just went out with a bang

[@WillyPanama]

I have a theory What if, and its a long shot, a canonical character is killed in the season finale. I know in the prologue we were shown the scrapped engines at the end, and one of them looked like Donald or Douglas. What if that scene was a red herring? As in, its supposed to misguide us. What if someone, like, Thomas were killed off?

[@TheTrainTheoristOfficial]

UHHHHHHHHHH........

[@WillyPanama]

@@TheTrainTheoristOfficial it's a crazy long shot theory, I know.

[@ahsirtucker2151]

Can you do a another theory about a story called untold story of operations highjump by daylight 3. Please 🙏

[@aplane9625]

Not everyone appears The peel godred bois didn’t

[@BSupreme2024]

Sup Everyone, As I am writing this, I want to warn you all that the Munitions episode was leaked earlier today. I unfortunately already watched it only to make sure if it was real or not and Unfortunately it is. I will not spoil anything cause I don't wanna ruin the hype for this episode but I ask you all to not watch it if you see it in you recommendation or if you search it up, wait till it officially releases.

[@trainlover74]

Nice job

[@SomethingJay]

4:51 Actually it’s Douglas not Donald you can tell by the name plate

[@JasonRoblesSembrano]

I have already posted two of the American engines for replacement in the Stories of Sodor: 1965 aftermath. I've already posted the replacement for Geoffrey just two months ago, David the 2-6-6-4 N&W Titan number 1218, and already posted the replacement for Peter just 4 days ago, Vernon the 4-6-6-4 UP Challenger number 3985. If Thomas dies in the next story, I'll have Kimberley the Burlington EMD GP-7 number 0101 as a replacement for him. At least, that's what I see if Thomas dies, and there's no one to take care of his coaches, Annie and Clarabel. At this fallout, Victor Tanzig will have no choice but to approve of the replacements after Mr. Robert Hall's act of revenge, following the devious footsteps of Phil Boggiston!!! Shut me up about American locomotives on British Tracks, and your insults will not scare me this time. For instance, if you think Murdoch will live at the Fallout, THINK AGAIN!!! He will die working in there, and there shall be no other replacements in Britain who will cover up for them!!!

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

You mean Phil Boggiston from Thomas1Edward2Henry3?

[@JasonRoblesSembrano]

@@tudorbrancuturcu5996 Exactly.

[@oliverhood1732]

@@JasonRoblesSembranoDude, they would be too big for the Railway. I’m sorry, but I don’t think it would be American Locomotives replacing them. It’s just going to be British Locomotives replacing them. Not American Locomotives. And how dare you say that about Murdoch, he’s not going to die! You are starting to sound very offensive towards the British! Quite actually, there will be engines from Britain to cover for them, not the American Locomotives!

[@creativeproductions7940]

Rob needs a phsycologist

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

“Ei, he does, and quickly”- Douglas, Escape

[@SheilahToroitich]

😢😢😢

[@jokelethkurueisner9229]

Two words: Shawn Hall

[@TheBrickWizard01]

hate to break it to you mate but you ain't right, robert has a twin who's behind all of this, robert isn't going to try and kill an engine, then try again and then safe it from death. it's stated he has a twin, it's even shown and you said it. this twin is behind all the havoc. victor keeps saing that people are "half right" half of a twin so not robert but his brother

[@DemolitionDerbyChaosShorts]

Good video

[@imaketrainzvideos]

I still don’t like the fact that Thomas died in munitions though

[@leoarevalo6786]

Talk about going out with a bang

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

Neither do I

[@E2ForLife]

Benson and Peckett, I think, are going to die

[@JJTheJetPlane-iz2yz]

that not mr hall twin brother sean cready why would Mr. Hall go through all the trouble of trying to do crime when his brother it was foreshadowed that his uncle did something worse to him? Maybe he sent him somewhere that broke his brother. We never know.

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

What episode is that: 10:07

[@edwardtheoldreliableengine]

It’s services from season 3

[@amandahoward1437]

thomas died :(

[@lesleyhobbs2527]

Dude u mean railway? 😂

[@SheilahToroitich]

Hello my name is Nathan soye basara l am. Using my mom. Phone

[@Sunsetcatcher-w5b]

What’s the game

[@nightmantis5154]

Thomas might die

[@dimitrismpouloumpasis8854]

He did died 😭

[@Trainlover1995]

Let me set the record straight regarding character deaths: Canon characters are safe. So far, the only characters who have died are either OCs (99% of everyone who has died) or characters who have canonically died (Dominic is the Spiteful Breakvan). The characters who therefore have death flags are Peckett, Sheffield, and Benson. As to why Thomas, Percy, Toby, and Donald/Douglas don't appear in the "Fallout" preview, it's because they're pulling the train, which I assume bears the remains of everyone who died. Regarding the ending, I believe what will happen is that the fallout of the Munitions disaster will lead to Sir Topham Hatt being fired as controller, and Mr. Hall taking over. Season 6 will be the North Western Region under his tyrannical reign, having Reginald scrapped ALIVE for talking back to him, and bringing in more and more diesels such as Bear and Joshua to completely dieselize Sodor. However, some of the engines band together to find out what actually happened in the Munitions disaster, and when the truth comes out, Mr. Hall is arrested, and Sir Topham Hatt is reinstated as controller. As his first act, STH declares Sodor to be a "steam sanctuary", as many controllers on the mainland have chosen to follow Mr. Hall's example and scrap their non-faceless steam locomotives (at least the ones that didn't undergo steam-diesel conversion) alive to save money on Black Water, leading to many engines making the dangerous pilgrimage to Sodor. Many are caught and killed, but a few such as Murdoch, Neville, Dudley, Winston, Rowan (Wildnorwester's newest OC), and Alice, plus maybe a couple of other OCs (I'm hoping to send Victor a few of mine) make it. Meanwhile, Joey goes to the mainland to participate in a manhunt for the rogue controllers, and discovers Burke was the mastermind of the entire operation.

[@mateoceballos3712]

I think thomas is going to die

[@ThomasSirHandel]

Reginald and Samantha are stand-ins for Big City and Wilbert so will most likely survive. Pickett could go considering Victor rarely uses him. A scrap model of Thomas is seen in the leaked Munitions ending but it's possible it's a fake-out death.