J vs Ben: We FAILED More Harry Potter Trivia - REDEMPTION Quiz

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Join us tomorrow night, Friday, April 16 @ 6pm Eastern for our TRIVIA LIVE STREAM! Do you have what it takes to become the Ultimate Champion!?

[@ashplaysgames1120]

HEY BROTHER!!!!!!!

[@samanthahutson9261]

2nd reply whoooo yayy

[@samanthahutson9261]

And 8th like yayy

[@Mary_Studios]

If only I had the time to join otherwise I would love to see if I did.

[@brendanlosty7919]

I set my alarm don't worry ❤️

[@bridgetlynch2043]

I think a potato is actually one of the MOST magical foods. It can transfigured into so many things!!

[@lydiaquinones2546]

Mash em up, boil em, stick em in a stew ..... 😉

[@VannyBeumer]

The least magical food is cucumber

[@kaylieghskorner9650]

True!

[@justalurkerignoreme]

It can also be a weapon if your name is Dream...😉

[@josuevelizd]

Sasha is crying😭

[@markredcliffe9896]

When Hermione froze the Cornish Pixies with “Ze Grindyylowes” I lost it 😂😂

[@Bayesic]

Same lol

[@kayleighjones7669]

Every time they get to the question about what lupin showed in his office I always hear in my head the scene from deathly hallows where he’s trying to confirm who Harry is and he gets all aggressive asking what creature was in his office when Harry visited and Harry takes a minute all confused before he’s like “grindylow”

[@TheDanishGuyReviews]

I especially love that scene in the movie, because it was missing from that particular scene in the other movie.

[@timothygodwin7575]

Me too!

[@oldyavannahadafarm]

Harry should have shouted back, “ZE GRINDYLOWS!!”

[@Theprocrastinaterartist]

correction, ze grindylows

[@PiginaCage]

Dumbledore: After all this time? Snape: ze grindylows

[@weddinglist1239]

J finally remembered the difference between rookwood and runcorn now we just need ben to remember

[@AuthorZaraHoffman]

YES

[@Hannah_Riddle]

Exactly

[@futbol_rolf9624]

If golden baby unicorns WERE sold at the Magical Menagerie, my Gringotts vault would be looking a little less full...

[@radmilaromanelli6561]

are you Ama Wason

[@clarindamaher34]

baked potatoes are magic in their own way😂

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

There may some truth to that

[@PhilBagels]

PO-TAY-TOES!

[@chacopaco407]

@@PhilBagels Boil 'em, mash 'em, stick 'em in a stew! 🥔 🥔

[@kaylieghskorner9650]

Agreed! Especially french fry magic tell me y’all what are y’all favorite types of potatoes such as baked, mashed, etc

[@kaylieghskorner9650]

@@SuperCarlinBrothers hi super Carlin brothers I’m a huge fan! And I was wondering what is your favorite type of potato’s such as French frys, mashed, baked etc. I understand if you don’t respond tho!

[@lunalitbeams121]

I always took it as Hermione making fun of Fleur. Or at least she probably heard Fleur in hysterics shouting about them and was copying her. If I recall both Ginny and Hermione didn't like Fleur much to start, right?

[@DarthAxolotl]

Mrs weasly, ginny and hermiony all didn't like her until Bill was attacked and she still stayed with him

[@dylanbest7335]

I've always seen it as fleur in the books tells Harry that she was attacked by "ze grindylows" and then in the movie they just swapped the line to hermione

[@AnythingButCute90]

I've watched it in English and in German and they do the French accent in the German version, too. So it feels like it was specifically to make fun of Fleur 😅

[@joeltappenden4785]

That’s true but that was the sixth book they showed that I don’t know if the Interacted that much in the Fourth book and it didn’t change until bill was attacked

[@Sam_on_YouTube]

I want to see a quiz of questions that only J missed.

[@Maritotten]

I was looking for this comment so I could show my support and it was way too far down. Come on, that'd be great!

[@mqk1697]

🤩 woah yesss

[@srikarkotha6991]

And ben had to have gotten the questions right previously... oooohhhh I need that...

[@shiny_lock]

Petiton signed 📝

[@luminasillanpaa1742]

I honestly really need this to happen 🤭😂

[@laser8389]

I don't have the books on me, but I seem to remember "ze grindylows" being a book reference that was either explicitly or subtly a dig at Fleur.

[@weddinglist1239]

Fleur said he grindylows attacked her after harry surfaced but Hermione never told harry about it so it was only a movie thing.

[@Alis_Grave_Nil]

Movie thing

[@nudgificator]

I don't have my copy to hand so I could be wrong, but I think Hermione's line is actually written as 'ze Grindylows' in the book and is fully meant to be her making fun of Fleur's reporting of the situation.

[@beavanes5785]

Yep! I think you're right ;)

[@parttimesaint3165]

I looked for you. Hermione doesn't mention the Grindylows at all, but they *are* mentioned by Fleur as she explains to her sister what held her back.

[@nudgificator]

@@parttimesaint3165 Well then I stand corrected! Must have been Fleur saying it that I was thinking of. Thanks for clarifying. :)

[@rhuze9747]

I'm pretty sure in the books it was Harry saying "Ze Grindylows," but I don't think he was trying to be rude

[@mandipandi303]

I literally yelled, "No!" at their initial answers to question 3. They always confuse Runcorn and Rookwood.

[@kerenchoi6967]

Emma obv spoke with a French accent bc she was subconsciously preparing for her role as Belle in the 2017 live action production of Beauty and the Beast

[@sand747]

Obviously preparing 12 years in advance

[@shiny_lock]

Yeah duh. Same way Michael Jordan won a few NBA championships in preparation for Space Jam.

[@imnotadogbutihaveflower-ph6309]

Yes and that’s why she was born in Paris

[@lynnerose7891]

OR bc she was ACTUALLY BORN IN FRANCE so she speaks French.

[@andreabrenda1609]

Emma Watson was born in Paris, France. She can also speak French.

[@georgelloydgonzalez]

I'll never forget Augustus Rookwood, form the Department of Mysteries, because he was one of the people Igor Karkaroff snitched on during his trial in "Goblet of Fire". Also, he's the Death Eater that killed Fred Weasley

[@rhuze9747]

I remember him because he killed Fred, and I remember Percy screaming "Rookwood!" before chasing after him

[@imnotadogbutihaveflower-ph6309]

Rookwood is now my least favorite character other than dumbridge

[@mellow3995]

Fun Fact: Eldritch Diggory was a minister of magic, 28 ministers before Fudge

[@august1837]

I never thought that a Harry Potter video will make me crave baked potatoes, but here we are

[@eyebrow5915]

Lol

[@eyebrow5915]

My favourite food is potatoes

[@libbyann78]

seriously, I'm like I think I need a potato with lunch. I wonder what my mom is making making Sunday dinner (lunch). I'm 42 but we always eat at my mom's after church on Sunday

[@libbyann78]

well, we had tater tots and burgers. perhaps those are the least magical potatoes

[@Reasepuffz_]

The montage of Hermione saying “zee Grindylowes” over everything is absolute gold.

[@yntmir4539]

Friend: “Whats the hardest thing in the world?” Me: “Getting a heart from the supercarlinbrothers”

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

[@MegaMew204]

This man got 2

[@thecosplaycrafter8017]

Nah, getting a reply.

[@DarthAxolotl]

This mad lad went and got 2

[@ClassicalMusic2002]

Well congratulations you've gone and done the hardest thing in the world twice in one day!

[@rafisanders]

I live for these quizzes, thanks for giving me some amazing content during this pandemic

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

You are quite welcome! Good Luck!

[@rachbru]

Me seeing this posted and getting excited to watch this while eating my DELICIOUS baked potato:😊🥔 Me not even a minute in: ☹️🥔

[@noorykorky5056]

Why did you get sad a minute later?

[@yoda2495]

@@noorykorky5056 Can there possibly be a lesser magical food than baked potatoes? -Ben Carlin one minute into the video

[@rosaliamoon4525]

I just had a thought that the reason Harry likes potatoes so much is because Percy offered them to him. He lived with the Dursley. And I would be shocked if they had ever offered him any type of food. I’m pretty sure that they ordered him to give them food instead. 💔

[@livgeneral6487]

Also potatoes are filling and maybe Harry ate potatoes to stay full longer because they didn't want to feed him much at home.

[@rosaliamoon4525]

@@livgeneral6487 that possible. But I think he would’ve refused Percy then. He probably ate whatever was left over after the Dursley’s ate. Either in the pan or on their plates

[@lindsaycarr4354]

Aww, I love (and tear up over) that idea. It was no big deal to Percy because he grew up in a sharing household but it meant everything to Harry.

[@sarah7586]

The sorting hat stool actually has three legs in some books and four in others 🥰

[@DarthAxolotl]

Maybe the hat is picky and requires a new seating arrangement every year

[@redwheeler721]

I came here to say this! Thank you!

[@tegang6452]

@@redwheeler721 me too! i reread between when i saw the video this question was originally from and remember being very confused about the stool

[@Alis_Grave_Nil]

Which books say what?

[@sophoofarooqui1448]

Yeah

[@rileygilman9634]

Riley has really just become their own character at this point. It great!

[@jb888888888]

If he's wearing his "best quizmaster cape" that suggests that he has at least three quizmaster capes, this being the best one.

[@phraggers]

12:00 well, as a brit I can confirm, if a brit does a french accent, we're making fun of a french person or persons. If we use actual french words (usually pronounced badly) then we're trying to sound posh or sophisticated. (We have a long complicated love/hate history lol)

[@viiisworried]

french people dont exist 🎉🎉🎉

[@coltonyounger9724]

Could you guys do a sorting characters J vs Ben? Like Star Wars or Avatar or more Marvel characters? Or a regular Avatar quiz could be cool too

[@isadora9220]

it’s so fun to keep looking at one of them while the other one it’s talking, i really recommend

[@NoFacetheVoid]

We need a vlog series of J looking for the honey.

[@DarthAxolotl]

Yes half way, half point is everyone's favourite section. I love it

[@factsandstuff2832]

In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Hermione created a circle of protection by casting spells on the ground. Can any spell be used this way? Like could you cast expelleramus on the ground so if someone crosses the circle their wand would immediately go flying?

[@catpiratepewe-ah3136]

Wow I’ve never thought about that! That would be pretty cool 😄

[@factsandstuff2832]

@@catpiratepewe-ah3136 Yeah. That's what I was thinking. Like there's a lot of possibilities if any combat spell could be used this way.

[@DarthAxolotl]

I think the spells made like an invisible wall (as in thats an inherent property of the spell) rather than shes casting a normal spell but delayed

[@factsandstuff2832]

@@DarthAxolotl That makes sense

[@DarthAxolotl]

@@factsandstuff2832 that was at least my interpretation when reading although the idea of a delayed spell sounds interesting

[@shanirasor1161]

I just wanna take a minute to thank you guys for putting out such wholesome content. I've really been going through it these past few months, and you've kept me smiling every day.

[@hannahsmith2645]

You should hide a character name in the Patreon list every now and then and see if people notice! We love Easter eggs!

[@philgoad5587]

Rewatching the full J vs. Ben playlist and think that a really fun rule going forward for Redemption is if you give the same wrong answer as before, you lose a point.

[@n1s2e]

Potatos are magical! Like you can do so much with them boil them mash them stick them in a stew

[@Danielpeter2344]

The Sorting Hat stool changes number of legs from one book to the next. "Deletrius" is the spell that Cedric's father uses to get rid of the mini Dark Mark after he does Priori Incantartum with Harry's Wand. I believe "Difodio" is a carving/gouging jinx.

[@sevenseas4520]

Talking about how Hermione pronounced grindylows, “Why did she say it like that?” J: “Pretty sure she was making fun of floor” I’m pretty sure you are making fun of floor (I’m joking. I know they said Fleur, it just momentarily sounded like “Floor” to me)

[@sorin_markov]

22:16 NO IT DOESN'T!! I remember being just as mad at the answer as I am now. The *only* time we see the spell used in the Harry Potter series, it clears the figure of the last-used spell from the wand (Quidditch World Cup Finals, dark mark in the forest, that context).

[@lostschedule51]

I loved the Halfway halfpoint question. Scott is fantastic

[@fynndog6893]

6:24 How could you take his honorary Ben point?!?! You have no idea how long it took me to spell honorary 😂

[@ruthsodden730]

Why didn't you do the annual sorting quiz this year? It's the best part of January

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

We decided to eat lots of candy this year instead!

[@Legolic]

@@SuperCarlinBrothers good point

[@dannymcnamara663]

@@SuperCarlinBrothers can’t blame you I’m sure we all did the same!

[@trentmeikle8609]

@@SuperCarlinBrothers do it in September when the sorting actually happens

[@whytho1418]

You know what’s even better the wand and Petronas quiz

[@racheljensen3285]

Honestly some of my favorite videos because the humor factor comes in HARD 😂 gives me a change at redemption too

[@stuffingtonjfluffypantsiii]

I always remember the date of Harry's trial because my birthday is August 12 and bad things always tend to happen that day

[@LaurenBows]

it’s my birthday too!

[@dibblidyy]

"If you are new to the J vs Ben format.." I am indeed not new after all these years! Love you guys

[@alexaviertaiga3686]

I am literally looking at GoF chapter 12 “Professor McGonagall now placed a three-legged stool on the ground before the first-years and, on top of it, an extremely old, dirty, patched wizards hat.” THREE-LEGGED

[@work_smarter7336]

Yes friends, the description changes from book to book

[@Synthesyn342]

Fun fact: In the Prisoner of Azkaban, it is directly stated that the sorting hats stool has 3 legs. I can’t remember when, but it does.

[@viiisworried]

the amount of legs on the sorting hats stool is actually inconsistent between the books. in some it says three, and others it says 4

[@realbadger]

ADR generally means Additional Dialogue Recording. For a commercial I did, a few days after filming I got to do the off screen line/s, as depending on the spot, they had the different lines to use over the logo.

[@meredith1313]

Fun fact: the Brits call baked potatoes “jacket potatoes” because they “look like they’re wearing a brown jacket” 😂😂

[@dave9401]

I'm 27, I say both things. I've never given any thought to why it's called a jacket potato, they'll never be the same 🥔😂

[@tori_forte]

What if Jennifer Lawrence started dating a potato in a teal windbreaker

[@thegamerzoologist2705]

I never ate mashed potatoes for so long because of COVID

[@SarahTheTrekkie]

I'm a Brit and I say Baked Potato

[@orangecalamari1906]

Lol, in Russia we have something similar to that - we call it "coat potatoes"

[@PaulSurname]

13:35 1st book: "Harry quickly looked down again as Professor McGonagall silently placed a FOUR-legged stool in front of the first-years." 3rd book: "Professor Flitwick, who was a tiny little wizard with a shock of white hair, was carrying an ancient hat and a THREE-legged stool out of the Hall." 4th book: "Professor McGonagall now placed a THREE-legged stool on the ground before the first-years and, on top of it, an extremely old, dirty, patched wizard’s hat." All the three books above are Bloomsbury, edition 2004.

[@SvenStucki1998]

how and I mean HOW can Ben seriously not catch up on the fact that Hermione is making fun of Fleur when she speaks in a french accent?!

[@Sock-Monster-Simian]

The only reason I chose to watch this video was to see the Runcorn question that was mentioned in the polyjuice video. Now I realize what I was missing out on in the previous quizzes.

[@puppyjessicabunny]

y'all SERIOUSLY need to make a series where j looks for the honey!!! I'VE BEEN ASKING EVERY QUIZ VIDEO! MAKE IT HAPPEN

[@rileybender3655]

The quiz composed only of questions that Ben got and Jay missed HAS to happen now. Help a Ben out! :'(

[@qwerty_and_azerty]

Thanks, now I want to see a fan edit of all the movies where every spell cast is just “ze grindylows”

[@sand747]

"Nice one, James!" "ZE GRINDYLOWS!!" *Dies*

[@yoda2495]

When voldemort kills harry in the forest ZEEEE GRINDYLOWS

[@yawninglion1677]

It's Grindy-lows, not Grin-Dee-Lows

[@Corpsman01]

It’s a stable carbohydrate and we should all appreciate the potato. Easy to grow, substantial. It’s made a difference in many lives over hundreds of years.

[@saralee8996]

I appreciate Riley's comments! They're fun 😆

[@FoxbrushDraws]

The stool one is funny because there's a difference between editions on if it's 3 or 4

[@MegaMeg117]

We need a Janus Thickey Ward shirt. It could have its own logo with all kinds of tiny details hidden in it (like did you know it’s also known as Ward 49?)

[@KingofKarnies]

If it's food related you guys are usually uncannily correct. Watching this has me wanting to rewatch all the trivia and find out.

[@eyebrow5915]

17:03 J's smiley face is GOLD

[@eyebrow5915]

Yesssss

[@AbstractlyDelen]

Them- “I don’t think there could be a less magical food than a baked potato” Me, and intellectual- boiled cabbage

[@ThreadBomb]

I would have said anything involving carrots.

[@hannahsadie27]

Riley’s comments make this vid even better 😂

[@anabellezook8402]

Why do I love their commercial segments so much

[@markcamp1878]

Ah so you’re the reason the ads are a third of the video now.

[@marissaelliott6102]

Lol

[@codystork3008]

I am trying to decide if Scott has that cape from Dungeons and Dragons or for a video.

[@DarthAxolotl]

You mean playing d and d is an excuse to own a cape. I need to get on amazon

[@twilightraaaat]

Last time I was this early, these socks were still amazing 😔

[@futbol_rolf9624]

They’re still amazing!

[@michaelinthebathroom7560]

😭 I miss old SCB videos.

[@DarthAxolotl]

@@michaelinthebathroom7560 not to be pedantic or anything but with how the KZbin platform works you can just go back and watch said old videos therefore the idea of missing them is slightly odd.

[@alephanull1953]

@@DarthAxolotl big brane

[@tomkemp9465]

Hermione is making fun of Fleur, with “ze grindylows”, the same way they refer to her as Phlegm later in the series.

[@teadrinkerfication9160]

I’m low-key proud of J for finally getting Albert Runcorn’s name right for the first time eve

[@sylvy16]

Yay!! halfway half point is back!!! So excited

[@samantharandall4367]

Just gotta give a shout-out to Riley I LOVE your editing it’s hilarious

[@colingibbons6404]

I hope everyone seeing this has a great day! I also suggest you read Nevermore which is about a prestigious society in which in order to not get returned to her home where the main character was an outcast they must get into one of a select few slots in a competitive series of trials. Dare I say, it’s better than Harry Potter

[@amberharwood5651]

14:23 literally reminds me of a holiday in a tiny part of France where they have a Fête de la pomme de terre. Which was literally a potato festival. It was soo good, but weird

[@rubygracemoseley8144]

I know right! Harry gets to a magic school, sees all the cool food and orders a baked potato!!

[@yoda2495]

Maybe he was scared to try anything new

[@awittyravenclaw]

I only remembered this one specifically because in deathly hallows Lupin asks Harry as his security question what creature did I show a Harry Potter in my office at Hogwarts.

[@RandomPersonProbably]

What J.K didn’t tell us was that whenever he cast a pratronus he was thinking of a singular baked potato

[@Phallyle]

Yeah, definitely. She tweeted it a few years ago! The more you know...

[@vitality2155]

13:15 "The hat continues to carry out its duty each September at the beginning of the start-of-term feast, when it is placed on a three-legged (sometimes four-legged) stool at the front of the Great Hall". The answer is 3.

[@thegreatfusili4673]

Why does Ben want to die on that hill so bad? 😂😂 Hermione was definitely meant to be making fun of Fleur in that scene, her disdain for her is pretty clear in the book.

[@ecocentriclife]

Because she just sounds so cheerful as she says it. It's hard to believe her attempt at disdain when she's so clearly happy over Harry. It's incongruous and poorly done 🤷‍♀️

[@MarkHogan994]

@@ecocentriclife Lol, no it's not. She's cheerful because she's happy Harry made it. That's it. She's just having a bit of fun mimicking Fleur's accent while celebrating Harry's return. Simple, it's not rocket science. She's talking about Fleur so she's imitating how Fleur says "grindylows". That's all there is to it, it's not incongruous or poorly done. Maybe Americans just don't get this sort of humor but it's very common in Europe.

[@ecocentriclife]

@@MarkHogan994 no one said it was rocket science, just like no one stated any nationalities so not sure why you're off making assumptions. Yes, she's happy for Harry. Which is why happiness is in her voice, instead of distain. The very fact that there is this on-going argument around the scene kinda proves that the joke was poorly executed 🤷 But if it somehow garnered a chuckle when you saw it, hey great 👍

[@judywright4241]

---Hermione was clearly jealous of Ron’s attention to Fleur, not so sure why Ginny disliked her so much, she cited the work Fleur added to Mrs Weasley.

[@thegreatfusili4673]

@@ecocentriclife The joke isn't poorly executed at all. I seriously don't understand how there's even an argument about this. It's no different than Sirius' "Nice one, James" line in Order of the Phoenix. It's a line that's clearly meant to be a nod to a character trait in the books that they weren't able to showcase in the movies.

[@jamesahibbard]

Ben getting the same "Week from Friday" as last time sent me into way too much laughter. It seems way too specific to guess twice.

[@stephanieestelle9669]

Hi! Nice cap shield. Any Falcon and Winter Solider theories?!? I’m dying for your analysis

[@glennbob5093]

Oh, the "ze grindylows" bit was amazing. Thank you editors for your hard work.

[@tariktorgaddon9597]

Ze Grindilows 😂😂😂

[@lc2341]

Ok but Riley is hilarious I absolutely love the personality they add to this

[@thejaredsanabria]

yo the editor made this So much funnier! 😂😂 these guys are so fun, let’s link guys @supercarlinbrothers

[@MinecraftProGamingandmore]

Dude I remember Question 3's answer so clearly because I keep rereading the chapter of Harry, Ron and Hermione's Ministry infiltration to get the Slytherin locket.

[@jamcdonald120]

Just assume Harry was eating LOADED baked potatoes and you will see the magic

[@georg9598]

Shoutout to Rileys exceptional editing (and fact checking) 👏

[@3amDepression]

Ben: could there possibly be a less magical food then a baked potato Me: a normal potato 🥔

[@libra1882]

To be honest, if you were at a feast with a bunch of new people you would eat what is familiar with instead of eating something that may be gross, or grabbing a non food item thinking it was food.

[@AW-jx8qi]

It's always nice to get a chance at redemption!

[@septemberwalk]

i was just thinking last night, how awesome would a series be of the same exact timeline as the harry potter story but with dumbledore as the main character. It could start right around the time worm tail started passing info to voldemort and go all throughout dumbledores plan for harry, eventually ending in the same place the harry potter story did. he would interact with harry sometimes but the focus would be on dumbledores day to day and his interactions

[@unavailableun]

-From now on you have to overlay “ze grindows” for every line that Hermione is supposed to say-

[@anunaskedforopinion]

Thank you so much for the discussion around Hermoine's pronunciation of Grindylows because for like 10 years I've been confused as to what she was saying in that scene!

[@kayleighodonnell4766]

today was riley's day to shine🤩🙌

[@kevinkerwin4949]

Also, Hermione saying Grindylowes with a french accent makes a ton of sense, there is mention in I believe in two of the books about her vacationing in France with her parents.

[@bridgettes3998]

Your editor is absolutely fantastic 😂

[@jb888888888]

One time in high school the final exam for a class I took was just the weekly quizzes all rolled together. I got the exact same questions right and wrong in the final as I did during the semester.

[@eleanorjay500]

I have been being these quizzes with my coffee for the last few days

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

Are you beating us???

[@eleanorjay500]

Mostly but I understand your mistakes

[@marquesa.c]

I've been subscribed for years and I will never get over the slightly passive aggressive way J and Ben talk when disputing points 😂 Love you guys!

[@Luna-cs7kv]

Hi it's my 13th birthday! I love your chanel. i have been here for a few years and i just wanted to let you know that watching your chanel makes me smile😋

[@chloemae5618]

Happy Birthday sweetie! Have a lovely day x

[@Luna-cs7kv]

@@chloemae5618 thank you😁

[@sophieheifetz4964]

Happy very late birthday!!!

[@Luna-cs7kv]

@@sophieheifetz4964 thank you😄

[@lydiablackthorn9937]

I loved Riley’s commentary. Made me laugh a lot.

[@chacopaco407]

YAY!!! I'M SOO HAPPY!!! 💚⚡🖤🐍🖤⚡💚