The Secret Story of Wick Explained (Horror Game Theories)

[@mask938]

Travis stole the children’s keepsakes and scattered them throughout the woods and the children punished Travis for it by killing him. A few months later, Sam located all of the lost keepsakes and returned them to the children’s graves before dying (possibly from hypothermia) and the children rewarded Sam by basically accepting him into their family and becoming his new friends.

[@mysticfire5850]

That's a good theory!

[@flexsexflexsexs]

@@mysticfire5850 except you dont return the items to the graveyard... have you even played the game before commenting?

[@flexsexflexsexs]

Sam doesnt return the items, did you even play the game before commenting?

[@mask938]

@@flexsexflexsexs What are you talking about? Sam returns the items to their original spot, which was the graves of the Weaver children. That's how you get the true ending. Did you even watch this video before commenting?

[@flexsexflexsexs]

at what minute does this happen? ive played the whole game and this does not happen.

[@masterfulmoonlighter5402]

What if Mary killed all the kids in some way, burying Caleb alive, slashing Benny's throat while he slept, throwing Lillian in the well, possibly smothering Tim and Tom which explains the coughing and gasping, and finally burning herself alive in the house. To me, she seems to have some sort of mental illness she projects onto the kids, mostly Tim and Tom

[@Chronocide242]

Ok I like this comment it makes sense.

[@1WildArtist]

This makes the most sense, since their body's weren't found in the house, so it couldn't have been during the fire.

[@Quandry1]

Or the Father did... he does say everything was taken from him before he hung himself but he doesn't say how. And he did return from the Trauma of War. He may have felt those that were actually his children were turned against him. And the Mother and the Father's bodies were both found but we don't know in what state. The mother may have ended herself when she learned what he did. There's some ambiguity there.

[@iceyfriend1316]

It makes sense. Me and my friend though of this as well

[@kokichioma5176]

This makes sense

[@Dobbie.]

The player when he gets the bad ending: wait WHAT!? the ghosts: yeah we tried to kill you but now you're our friend : )

[@rydergranson4562]

favorite comment

[@yapyapthedestroyer2562]

Well, at least he has a group who won’t leave him

[@dianahessman2353]

Those kids are not friends anymore because they are friends now because we're just join them by in their killing spree to kill others

[@memeboi6942]

Imagine you just get bonked by one of the children, but instead of dying, you just get hurt.

[@darthmomo6548]

We were bad, but now we're good

[@lexilower2815]

I wonder if the accident that disfigured Tom was falling down the well, just like Lillian? If you look at Tom, his arms and legs look as if they have been broken, which could be caused by a large fall. Also, Lillian speaks of Jack and Jill, saying that Jack fell down then Jill came stumbling after. What if Tom somehow fell into the well and Lillian attempted to save him, only to fall in as well and die?

[@ALilCherry]

Oh wow that is actually a very good theory! It would make sense, tbh.

[@CrazyHawkeComics]

True, this seems legitimate.

[@danalynch118]

I thought Tom got polio and that was how he died

[@raybob8668]

Not to mention the hand that rises out of the well, it’s possibly Tom’s hand

[@ALilCherry]

@@raybob8668 Could be, it didn't look like Lillian's so we might have a lead on how Tom died. And maybe Lillian.

[@friskdacatarchival]

Just a note about Tom and Tim: Twins were considered a bad omen in those times, especially if they were the same gender. It would've been normal for religious families to take that as a curse and freak out like the Weavers did.

[@Clovenstone-Blue]

Also, Tom suffered from polio (since one of his items is a leg brace for treating children with polio), so Tim probably also had some sort of illness that made the weavers believe they were cursed.

[@justglitchmc4861]

@@Clovenstone-Blue Tim has asthma ( don't know if i spelled that right ) i think

[@Clovenstone-Blue]

@@justglitchmc4861 the likelihood of Tim having asthma sort of depends on knowing HOW Tim died, since his coughing might've been caused by smoke inhalation if he died due to the fire.

[@bektoonz9758]

I'm a twin,thank goodness

[@skullydynamo7159]

Not only that, but "changelings" at that time was the explanation for children with autism.

[@ognjenilic3001]

Tim & Tom: Overprotective brothers Caleb: Fast as shit human mole Benny: *C H O N K E R* Lillian: *Team Changed from “ Rabbit Lover “ to “ Animal Abuser*

[@yellowhouses]

I-

[@sprucebadger8229]

so you are saying that if one wants to survive they have to climb up the trees? think about it Tim, Tom, Lillian: out of sight, out of mind benny: can't wake him up if you are up in the trees Caleb: good luck climbing up here you damn mole wannabe so in short, Vietcong soldiers are most likely to survive Wick

[@ognjenilic3001]

@@sprucebadger8229 I can't disagree with this a single bit

[@yellowhouses]

@@sprucebadger8229 MOLE WANNABE- I CANT-

[@randomtechpriest2644]

@@sprucebadger8229 Tim drops down from the trees though

[@Azazreal]

For Lillian based on the clues i would say that she knocked her rabbit into the well and then went down in the bucket to get it back but sadly the ropes snapped and she drowned. It would make sense that her brothers would help her with it as well, they probably thought it would be great fun to send her down into the slimy cold dark.

[@Quandry1]

I did get the sense that it wasn't her that was doing what sounded like killing the rabbit. I think the Rabbit might have been her pet and was killed by another.

[@squeaktheswan2007]

It could explain why she always bursts from the ground and why her skin looks so clammy.

[@thegrandxbunny2073]

My guess: Sam (the player) wasn’t killed by the kids. By carelessly throwing matches everywhere, they set the forest on fire and burned alive. Stay safe around fire kids.

[@willow8932]

ooff

[@onyxth3ripper]

Good theory

[@Nolongerhere3712]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@juliannemccloskey1961]

Smoky

[@lokiruiz2246]

10x Combo: Toasty!

[@user-pg6de6dc2q]

Okay wait a minute. I thought it was suspicious that the teenager guy was suggesting this game over and over even when sam went missing/was traumatized. But after seeing this, I wonder if that teenage guy IS the demon. Maybe that’s why the souls of the kids can’t move on, and that’s why he keeps bringing in people to those woods to meet an unfortunate end.

[@justglitchmc4861]

The teenager who is suggesting sam to the forest ( his name is duncan ) is tbubber (travis burton) friends, duncan kill tbubber because he is mad because tbubber takes all the credits for himself, and duncan suggesting sam to the forest, maybe its because some sort of revenge, because sam is also a friend of tbubber, and the kids can't move on because tbubber disturb them by taking their item, which is belonging to them.

[@zb5690]

@@justglitchmc4861 But if Sam is a friend of TBubber, why the heck are the children still in the forest, and what the heck is Duncan still inviting more people to play Wick?

[@YunikuYosefMomoka]

@@zb5690 Because Duncan is evil

[@mask938]

@@justglitchmc4861 Where does it say that Sam was friends with Travis?

[@justglitchmc4861]

@@mask938 Idk, i think its on the wick fanpage, i forgot.

[@Sp00kyBones]

*5 children, 12am-6am, we have been through this before.*

[@willson8146]

"Hey I've seen this one, it's a classic!" "What do you mean you've *SEEN* it? it's brand new."

[@raulnieves5623]

Fnaf but different and cool 😎

[@raulnieves5623]

But fnaf is cool

[@raulnieves5623]

An so is wick

[@edifiedermine9247]

Ah, yes, *fnaf*

[@casdj906]

I think Duncan is the one behind all this. When you get the back pack, you hear a tape from him and an unknown interviewer. After the tape ends, another one plays with him having a distorted voice, saying there's no way out. Hmm...

[@justglitchmc4861]

"YoU'r tOo laTe anYwayS, thEreS nO wAy ouT". [ End of audio ]

[@casdj906]

Wow! Good one!

[@justglitchmc4861]

@@casdj906 Thats what the audio says.

[@justglitchmc4861]

Welp, atleast now sam have a group of friends who wont leave him.

[@hellokittywithguns2937]

His old “friends” were assholes

[@alexcollins1820]

That's true but his new friends now have a OLDER sibling to take care of them I feel bad for the kids

[@justglitchmc4861]

@@hellokittywithguns2937 hope sam( and travis ) got revenge on his old friend, especially duncan.

[@justglitchmc4861]

@@alexcollins1820 oh yeah, i just noticed that sam is older than them, hes like 15/16, and the oldest sibling (benny) was 14

[@POOPBANDITLEADER]

Fix your grammar glitch

[@ac0rn_official239]

Dude your voice is so calming in a weird way

[@itskorey577]

I feel the same way bro it’s so weirdly calming

[@noirexists]

Especially talking about death and murder

[@itskorey577]

@@noirexists and I love death and murder😈😈

[@noirexists]

@@itskorey577 Understandable, have agreat day.

[@itskorey577]

@@noirexists you too lol, have a prosperous 2021

[@forecastlotus3899]

"Its for when the bandages come off." God I hate that line because it means that that kids face got MESSED up Edit: I just realized the way that was said soundsike they are comforting somebody

[@totallynotabot7693]

I got Sally Face flashbacks when that line played lol

[@nicoangelo9928]

@@totallynotabot7693 me too

[@TheObjectCamper2196]

@@totallynotabot7693 me too

[@lunawolfandcrew5166]

@@totallynotabot7693 heh yeah me too

[@jadetheslime3140]

@@totallynotabot7693 same

[@Afish8me2china]

I don’t think the twins are bad, I think they’re actually pretty close with the rest of the kids. I think the Mom thinks they’re bad, and she takes it like she’s being influenced by them

[@mask938]

Or she's blaming them for everything wrong in her life because they were the product of her affair.

[@andrewfornes5320]

Also, back then in some cultures.. usually religious people in the Bible-Belt, they believed giving birth to twins was a bad sign; especially if the twins were the same gender.

[@the-flame-socker4200]

Bruh the "See you at 6AM,if you live!" part sounds like FNaF.

[@Olisdrawingcorner]

THE MAN BEHIND THE SLAUGHTER

[@dougdeeken4541]

Brilliant

[@damainortiz]

Because the game was partially based on FNAF I think.

[@scoutscoodles]

I always figured Tim and Tom had polio and asthma respectively. Also I thought changelings were children switched with demons at birth? The term was used to refer to children with developmental disabilities as a cause for how they are.

[@bookerfeniks180]

Close. They were switched out with faeries & not demons

[@bookerfeniks180]

Close. They were switched out with faeries & not demons

[@dummy1482]

tom has polio and vice versa m8

[@drawnwithlove3499]

Yeah I did speculate that the twins were just nd or something, as people back then believed mental disorders were caused by demons.

[@mask938]

@@bookerfeniks180 People would often leave babies that were labeled as “changelings” in the woods, thinking that the fairies would take the “changelings” and replace them with healthy babies. Obviously, the babies weren’t changelings and there weren’t any fairies secretly swapping babies. They were just regular human babies that were born with defects and illnesses, and the idiots who left them in the woods expecting fairies to take them and replace them with healthy babies were delusional and were really just leaving their kids to die in the woods because they couldn’t accept the idea of their kids being born with issues.

[@justglitchmc4861]

The twins wasn't the one who killed the sibling Benny : died in the fire while hes sleeping which is why the candle light will wake him up Caleb : Got buried by his mother ( because if you hear the voice while we take a look at the shovel, the voice sounds like a women) which is why he was digging from underground Lillian : idk, fall into the well and drowned? Or maybe she was stuck in her room while she was in the fire and screaming for help, which is why she use her scream when she kill sam Tim : Got killed because they though that he was posessed by a demon or died in the fire, which explain why he always coughing due to the small amount of oxygen. Tom : The same fate as tim, or he fell down in the well too, because if you take a look at the bucket, the voice says this "Jack and jill went up the hill, Jack fell down and jill come stumbling after". Which explain why hes leg was broken.

[@Mangle1218]

Sounds very likely

[@jesus_fox4919]

Likely but not set in stone

[@sukiiriinaa]

Maybe Lillian rabbit stands for Jack. In the Jack and Jill song. Her toy fell down the well and she tried to get it.

[@jesus_fox4919]

@@sukiiriinaa oh like 'jumping jack'!

[@pastelcreativity9595]

A theory adding on to yours: Around those times, twins were said to be bad omens even worse if they were the same gender. I've been reading and heard a lot of theory's on Tim having Polio. I have something to add to that, In very few Polio cases it takes over the whole body. When this happens, it becomes really hard to breath and usually it leads to the head being tilted to its last motion. For these cases, there are things called the "Iron Lung" which supplies oxygen to the lungs while keeping the body secure. Another use is when the body becomes paralyzed due to illness or accidents (Falling out of a tree perhaps?) and can't breath well. Iron lungs were used. That's why i think they breath so loudly, having had used an iron lung to breath. Give me feedback i taught it was clever!

[@Noshushpls]

Nah cos then they’d both be deformed and only one is also the iron lung leave u incapacitated so he would’ve gotten off it way way wayyy before dying

[@monroerobbins7551]

Here’s my thoughts: I think the mother killed Caleb. The person panting while digging with the shovel sounds like a woman, and how would Lillian, one of the girls in the game, be able to drag the body of an older athlete into a pit? Plus, why would the kids hang around the twins if the twins, one of the other options for the killers, were the ones that killed them? It feels weird. I think the mother, in a religious fervor, killed her daughter, who was being influenced by the twins, killed Caleb by burying him, perhaps he got hurt and she thought he was dead already, and lastly burned the twins, what she believed to be the cause of her misfortune. But it was not they, they were merely vessels, a punishment for the mother not accepting the consequences of her actions. Perhaps her children died, one by one, and in a final twist of fate, she killed the twins and herself. Maybe Caleb was the first, hence why he is skeletal. Then Benny, due to him showing signs of decay and rot, then the little girl (Lillian? Sorry, bad with names), drowned whilst trying to cleanse her of evil, and she not showing any sign of rot, merely death, and lastly the twins.

[@finn_in_the_bin5263]

actually Caleb is younger than the twins by about 3-4 years but otherwise thats a solid theory

[@monroerobbins7551]

@@finn_in_the_bin5263, how old are the twins? Thank you for the info, I appreciate it, but have the twins’ ages been confirmed?

[@finn_in_the_bin5263]

@@monroerobbins7551 as far as I've found, they're around 12-13, with Caleb being 9

[@BIGDADDUI]

@@monroerobbins7551 they say early teens and Caleb is 9

[@monroerobbins7551]

@@BIGDADDUI, my apologies, when I said older, I meant in general, not older than their killer. But, I did tweak it a bit, I feel I got a bit off track, focusing on the twins.

[@fishushu]

So, I might ve wrong, but by the drawing of Lilian and her objects, plus her audio, to me it feels more logical that she died by having her head crushed on a fall. Her stuffed rabbit probably fell down the well and she fell down when going after it by trying to lower herself with the bucket. This can be concluded by the drawing of her with blood dripping down her head from under the oncee she wears and the fractured skull of a rabbit.

[@Solar-496]

One of my friends, Spencer, actually tried to play Wick. But obviously, he survived and the only thing that was stalking around the woods that night were possums and stoats.

[@Solar-496]

@@madison8663 IRL. But he was rather shaken up. Havent spoken in a long as time.

[@onlyjust7250]

The teen who invites his friends into forest to play Wick is actually Dunken

[@paulflint4620]

From total drama

[@smithsoniansmith2433]

@@paulflint4620 ...No...

[@treasureh1119]

That is a possibility

[@smithsoniansmith2433]

@@treasureh1119 Hi!

[@treasureh1119]

@@smithsoniansmith2433 ello!

[@TheBonneter]

I couldn’t wait for someone to do a theory on this game. It’s so interesting!

[@emeraldtv9472]

İ mean this is a thory?

[@reecelast7924]

But hay this is just a theory and game theory

[@tracybush7582]

Cappy. You and Mario done

[@naturegreenr4757]

Same here

[@jamiestanway4530]

I could wait

[@NitePixieDust]

In my opinion, I like to think Tim and Tom were not changelings. They just had problems that were seen as unholy and possibly a curse. Because religion was strong in the community/family, I think because of Tom having polio and both him and Tim having other issues as well led to Mary and John keeping them mostly hidden and possibly spreading lies to their other children about them. I think Tim was also seen as evil or "demonic" due to his violent, (possibly rebellious) nature. Tim seems like the kid to enjoy hurting others or is willing to hurt anyone who gets in his or his brother's way. I also like to think they or at least Tim, had a place in their mother's and sibling's death, but that's just what I like to think.

[@eldritchcupcakes3195]

Twins were seen as a bad omen in these times, especially same gendered so even if they weren’t affair babies they’d still likely be treated badly.

[@jackwoods6863]

I wish there was a way to have set them all free. To think anyone would still participate in the game after so many disappearances is mind boggling.

[@YunikuYosefMomoka]

They came back after Duncan friend Tbubber disrespected their graves and put their items all over the place.. escapes then Duncan kills him then sends Sam into the forest of woken up angry child spirits..

[@mask938]

@@YunikuYosefMomoka Sam manages to locate all of the keepsakes and returns the items to the childrens' graves. Shortly after returning the missing items, Sam ends up dying (most likely from hypothermia) and is befriended by the Weaver children. Sometime later, Duncan and Sam's old "friends" are still bringing people to the woods for some reason, despite knowing that Sam "disapeared" in those woods and possibly being aware of how Travis "disapeared" in the woods a few months prior to when they brought Sam there.

[@DeadHouseMouse]

I feel like Caleb got injured doing sports stuff and fell into a coma, and the mom didn’t know what to do with him so she buried him in the backyard bc she couldn’t take any more of the stigma

[@YunikuYosefMomoka]

Right, she couldn't afford his medical expenses any longer and was probably told he was going to die anyway.. So she buried him early to end the stigma..

[@helloimarabbit4083]

Yeah. And the technology back then was bad so maybe while in his coma he was mistakenly declared as dead and put to rest only to awake later and die of lack of oxygen due to panic.

[@lichkinggamer5708]

Ah American health care

[@jesus_fox4919]

@@lichkinggamer5708 they're european tho-

[@lichkinggamer5708]

@@jesus_fox4919 shut

[@comfortloid2195]

its been years since ive heard anything about this game, and im glad someones finally looking into it more

[@HowliteHD]

Hi! Just a quick note about Benny-you said he most likely had Dyslexia but Dyslexia mainly impacts reading, what you provide were referring to is Dysgraphia, which is basically Dyslexia but with writing like mixing up letters and getting them backwards, stuff like that. Plus there's a few other things it impacts such as fine motor skills and hand writing in general. I may sound like I'm nit picking but as someone who has Dysgraphia i like to inform people of these things to make it more well known. Anyway, have a good day!!

[@shatteredchaos7088]

is it just me or is there anyone else that wants a sequel to this game

[@mask938]

I'd like to see a sequel where Sam is one of the ghosts that you have to run from. It would be awesome if they had an ending where Sam gets revenge on his old friend group. They could even add Travis' ghost and have him get revenge on Duncan for killing him (Duncan is most likely the murderer). There's no need to worry about designing their appearances because we already know what they look like. The missing persons report for Travis provides a very detailed description of his appearance. Travis was a 15 year old boy with black hair, brown eyes, light skin, and a left eyebrow piercing. He also wore wire-trimmed glasses, a red hooded jacket, jeans, black coverse runners, a gold chain with a small crucifix, and a gray backpack on the night of his untimely death. As for Sam, there's actually an early piece of concept art that depicts Sam's full appearance. He has long reddish hair and wears a red long-sleeved shirt, blue pants, and brown shoes (in the game, you can tell by looking at his sleeves that he's still wearing the red shirt). This piece of concept art even appears in this video! It's a colorful drawing of Sam walking above ground and Caleb tunneling underneath him with the words "Keep moving". The picture appears at 12:32 in this video.

[@bluedemon6663]

Omg I'd love to see a sequel it would be so amazing and just in general the game is great and I love the mystery and everything about it!

[@Alfredo_Gonzalez64]

If this game does get another prequel I hope it sheds more light on the children and we get to see sams new distorted form

[@raptorsuedemondrake4143]

just some quick notes about changelings and how they affect the lore. 1. Changelings were usually taken after being born once the parental bond was established. specifically a supernatural entity would kidnap the infant and take his or her place usually because they desire the easy life infants have. 2. changelings were usually dealt with through abuse and neglect in order to either trick the entity into revealing its identity or just make it so miserable it leaves of its own accord, which would force it to return the original child. point 2 is establishes as something the weavers were doing to the twins through various clips in the game. and perhaps the disfiguring accident that makes tom look mangled wasnt an accident, but rather the weavers attempting to drive out the changeling. the fact that tom and tim look and behave so differently in death suggests that only tom may be a changeling while tim was an ordinary boy given supernatural power in death. supporting this is the fact that iron tools were often used to abuse suspected changelings because wounds inflicted n them by iron would not heal, explaining why tom is mangled as a ghost and tim is not.

[@cinaluna4644]

That actually makes a lot of sense. I wonder if Tim ever had second thoughts about his brother. Even so that Sunday event in the game has brought up flags, I wonder who suggested the idea to kill the priest. Tim or Tom. Or maybe both?.

[@londonpowell6096]

I can’t wait until he plays little nightmares 2 and bendy and the dark revival

[@masked.fool.]

My life right here

[@somethingboutu8522]

The bad/true ending in a nutshell “The council has decided...you are friend :)”

[@d12tu25]

I think Duncan killed Travis because it says on the wiki that he knows more about the wick camp game than he's letting on and it seems he is very vengeful and he also acted suspicious when the police were talking with him.

[@dragondust5023]

Ghosts: *tries to kill you repeatedly* Also ghosts during bad ending: We were bad, but now we're good.

[@chaystonbrown]

Exactly my thoughts, like did they switch up? Possibly because they saw that Sam was doing them a good deed by collecting their scattered items?

[@itskorey577]

Idk why but I just love this guy’s channel bro

[@d12tu25]

I know right it's such a great channel and since I am a big fan of the horror genre I absolutely love this channel.

[@shawnspeedling5805]

Me too!

[@haynarasitori8087]

Me too

[@idk_12540]

Same here

[@cupcake_supreme6462]

Same im satifying of this vid🤔🤔

[@hunterwhittier1943]

When he talks about the no way out DLC you can hear the fear in Travis’s voice

[@brysongamer0625]

4:55 “ no way out. What does that mean?” B O N G

[@mask938]

- The famous last words of Travis Burton/TBubber.

[@callmenee-san1976]

Finding Tim's pocket knife: "You hurt him, and I'll hurt you." Benny: *seems to be slashed at the throat* Coincidence? I THINK NOT! Also, Benny was really religious, so perhaps he feared and even hated the twins due to them being born due to his mother cheating on his dad? That could have made him treat the twins badly, which then adds to them being violently protective of each other.

[@cawingcrows2072]

Ohhh... That's a good (well, not good, but you get the point) theory tbh

[@chaystonbrown]

That's a good point though ngl.

[@drama.enjoyer]

I have a theory that maybe Lilian didn't abused animals and the skull represents what happend when she fell. I'm sure it was possible for her to fell head first and crush her own skull on rocks. The rabbit skull would be a good choose for a symbol for Lilian since she even wears a rabbit pijama

[@smiththeinspiringanimator7042]

Hi! ^_^

[@drama.enjoyer]

@@smiththeinspiringanimator7042 Hi

[@smiththeinspiringanimator7042]

@@drama.enjoyer How are you?

[@drama.enjoyer]

@@smiththeinspiringanimator7042 Pretty good, what about you?

[@unfinishedzizzy7582]

I like to think that at the end of the game your character is adopted by the dead kids as a big brother (Well, almost all the kids. Caleb still attempts to munch on them) and the family kills the people who ditched Sam and left him for dead. I just like making happy endings for horror game protags that involve the monsters along the way.

[@eternalmiasma5586]

“They were highly religious... this was ultimately their downfall” sounds about right

[@whippersnapper8387]

Shut up

[@mask938]

Highly religious families often seem to have a lot of issues.

[@staceytetzlaff2822]

At least it doesn't take place during the Salem witch trials.

[@mask938]

@@staceytetzlaff2822 If it did, the mother wouldn't have needed to burn herself. The witch hunters would do it for her.

[@staceytetzlaff2822]

If only someone warned the family about that. Think the kids would have survived?

[@onyxth3ripper]

I think the reason that everyone looks worse in No Way Out, despite it being before Sam, is that the children's bodies themselves rose with their souls because of TBubber disrespecting them, while Sam didn't do anything, therefore only their spirits rose for him.

[@inichan8786]

Depite their religious upbringing the Kids seem to be close to one another, what if there was no real "evil" before and the paranoia over the consequences of his wifes adultery made the parents actually be the ones lashing out verbally as at times even physically around or even towards the children? The children might have had thought they have to protect one another, the twins probably got most of the short ends of the sticks due to being the product of their mothers adultery. I wouldn't be suprised if their deaths, if we think that some of them happened after the fire instead of before (however when I think about it even before would work and the father hanging himself after realizing what they became) that the pastor was actually involved in burying the wicked to cleanse his herd? What if he even was the affair partner and the mother just not dare point her finger at him? Just a thought since as much as Benny did repeat what his parents told him as fact, I don't see reason to belief that he was harming his brothers, which wouldn't be a suprise if he had done so in the situation and how "normal" it must seem to him. So...what if the accident, wasn't an accident? What if the parents killed one of their kids after the other, maybe even as a contest to punish the other. Also a possebility. I do agree on the "how" they died part mostly. Just the who did it and who was the actual culprit getting the more violent tendencies into the children I think was less a spirit, but more so their actual upbringing. I wouldn't be suprised if the children spirits simply feel wronged and want to "afterlive" their lifes playing and being for once at peace together. But people keep messing with their shit and forget to bring it back. Oh, also what if: The tuber actually set the stage for Sam? And the one hitting him with the shovel is the guy that keeps bringing kids up there? Also tying a bit in my theory that the pastor was the actual affairpartner, it would also work with another affairpartner since: What if the one keeping bringing kids up there is their halfbrother? IF we go with the twisted nature came from the affairpartner, it would be possible that he kept sleeping around planting "seeds". And the halfbrother figured out they were related and just keeps bringing his siblings "presents" to play with. But that is just a theory.

[@cartoonboyanimsv2]

A Game Theory.

[@jaywilliams8730]

There some videos by history behind the horror that give some interesting ideas about how the kids died also 15:16 aww even after death they stick together that shows they cared for each other

[@polterboo3515]

I've been waiting so long for you to cover this game it has such an interesting story (what you can figure out anyway) and your theories are always so interesting too! You really did this game justice!

[@Kajnake]

>"He ends up in a cabin where he meets a sticky end" >Crow gives him a side spin kick with a shovel

[@Jesse_69420]

I think these are the likely cause of death of the Weaver Children and Tbubber. Tim: Suffocation or Hypothermia Tom: Suffocation, Hypothermia, or Internal Bleeding (Think of why Tom gags out blood in his No Way Out) Benny: Stabbed with a knife,but survived only to die from his injuries few minutes later Caleb: Buried Alive (Suffocation or Starved to Death, due to Caleb being able to eat the player) Lillian: Drowned in the well Tbubber: Likely killed by Tim, as Tim was the only one of the Weaver children to be absent during the final chase in the No Way Out DLC.

[@pumpking1009]

so one drowned one suffocated two breathed in too much smoke one had his neck slashed and suffocated you see a pattern here it was all air related deaths i wonder why?

[@YunikuYosefMomoka]

No, one was literally buried alive..

[@Jurasakii]

@@YunikuYosefMomoka fire needs oxygen to burn 🤔

[@swarmfire3587]

@@Jurasakii you know it says buried, not burned

[@spacechase9705]

@@YunikuYosefMomoka Thereby suffocating due to lack of oxygen.

[@The_Gassius]

Who else feels that the bad ending is super sweet in a way? Lol

[@mask938]

I think it's kind of sweet too. Sure, Sam is dead, but at least he now has some new friends who won't abandon him. Plus, he can also get revenge on his old "friends" for bringing him to the woods and essentially leaving him to die.

[@end11ns.t.11]

So, it is the "good ending"?

[@dime-a-thousand8002]

I'm at 0:33 and I just need to say that I love the way SHB talks there's just something about it.

[@skeletonking2180]

I get the feeling that in the bad ending, one of the group members has a lit candle and you blow it out so that you and the other children can get revenge.

[@cleverusername2578]

15:10 Okay I know their actions are awful but honestly the way the siblings look after each other is kinda sweet

[@kattheslendytubbie7745]

Okay,theory about Sam.. What if he was a descendant or was in the family tree of the Weaver family..hence why he became a ghoul/ghost like the other kids,and he could be around their age aswell.

[@ShardtheWolf]

The story of wick: So theres this ex hitman, but his wife passes away and leaves him a puppy...

[@spacechase9705]

Then some people kill the puppy...

[@robertaalymer5743]

And then thanos snapped the woods and everyone died

[@cookie-kz6vv]

And a bunch of random kids left one of them to die

[@CreeketsCreek]

The fact that that man came back from war only to find his wife had cheated, waited for her to give birth to the other man's children, and THEN proceeded to impregnate her again as if a new child would fix their relationship though.

[@droidixbacon]

Christianity

[@brysongamer0625]

@@droidixbacon no more like insanity

[@naturegreenr4757]

I just watched buzzfeed unsolved video on the disappearance of the Sodder children and now I am seriously starting to believe it inspired this in at least some way

[@hyugalubbok7770]

Changeling are fairy offsprings, that were switched places with the real kids by their by their fairy parents...

[@wazzdakka6495]

Correct!

[@m0nster547]

Yeah but aren’t they evil if they know what they are or am I confused?

[@bookerfeniks180]

They're also the explanation people came up with for disabled & neurodivergent kids being born into a led neurotypical families, before we knew more about things like autism, cerebral palsy or ADHD Edit: abled not a led. Autocorrect strikes again

[@middaydraws3379]

For Sam I think he died of hypothermia or something related to the cold. He sounds like he's shivering at times. He might have candles and matches but that's not enough heat to prevent it. Edit: Here are the symptoms of Hypothermia! -Shivering. -Exhaustion or feeling very tired. -Confusion. -Fumbling hands. -Memory loss. -Slurred speech. -Drowsiness.

[@Perma_Tired_]

This game always throws me for a loop, if only for the fact that my mother's maiden name is Weaver. And they grew up, and some still live, in the mountains of West Virginia.

[@insanecreeper91]

I honestly loved wick and would draw the characters back in middle school. I saw you started playing it on the channel, but didn't think we'd see an explained video on it hah.

[@Ponpokemon]

Thank you so much for this video on our game! Your attention to detail is amazing!

[@spooket8464]

As a Sam i can confirm this is how I met most of my friends.

[@diethumperdie]

I was pretty sure that Changeling were a thing in Celtic mythology. Though it wasn't uncommon for Christianity to take old stories like that, and later say they were demons.

[@AnaxErik4ever]

The comprehensive summary of the plot, first person gameplay, creatures encountered, and character dynamics reminds me of "The Midnight Man" ritual creepy pasta and the game Slender: The 8 Pagesl, mixed with the abuse, manipulation, and heartless mistreatment of children in the hard-to-find PS2 game Rule of Rose. The ghostly children in masks and the sketches you find are similar to the Aristocrat Club and the stories you completed in each chapter.

[@lostbabyfox4465]

not trying to be mean, this really helped give me my own ideas and help my theories. However, you did mix up tim and tom a few times. im also pretty sure tom had polio hence his leg brace. Tom's the deformed one and Tim's the one that talks. Gj tho at everything this game is amazing.

[@staceytetzlaff2822]

Ok, can we all agree that MacAlroy's death is one of the most satisfying moments in horror game history? I can just imagine the few seconds after: Tim and Tom exit down the aisle while smirking at their dying victim, Benny is briefly spooked, but decides to just watch the fireworks, Lillian taunts the dead pastor, Caleb grabs a Hymnal and starts whacking the corpse's stomach with it, John smiles coldly, and Mary looks like she'll have a heart attack.

[@StrangeStorylines]

Just the mention of Changeling children got me hooked even more hehe. Though a bit different in this one, old legends being more about children being swapped at birth by Fae creatures, while the real human babies are off in another realm. Either way, Wick is an exceptionally unique and fun game, and thine video is indeed an amazing dive into its lore and story as well!

[@maksimlukamiletic6223]

Theory: Since Benny was really religious, he caused Tom to have that accident, so Tim sliced Benny's neck and thus we hear him threatening someone when examining the knife

[@MegaLpso]

This is still in my top ten horror games list. I love the story, and the charachters so much. I wish they would get a collab with other horror games, or games with horror like elements.

[@gl1tch3d_0ut8]

on my first playthrough of this game when i first encountered the deformed one i screamed so loud that my neighbor came rushing over to my house and asked if i was ok

[@rdfjfgjyfdhfghy67456]

Evergreen respect to SHB for being calm enough to analyse the area while playing these horror games

[@kailowo7765]

You know how hard I wheezed at "no way out? What does that mean?"

[@godofbears8472]

Moral of the story don’t cheat it always ends badly

[@smithsoniansmith2433]

What about the good ending? The one where Sam goes into a mental Hospital?

[@RaraZeCat]

So bad ending technically good ending?

[@smithsoniansmith2433]

@@RaraZeCat what do you mean? because it's the bad ending because he dies.

[@questionmark6652]

@@smithsoniansmith2433 Is it though? He get's into a new group of friend's, some that might actually care for him, AND his got a cool Demon Uncle

[@smithsoniansmith2433]

@@questionmark6652 but I'm pretty sure his other friend group cared about him... or do they?

[@justglitchmc4861]

@@smithsoniansmith2433 The bad ending/true ending is actually a good ending one, because sam became one of the ghost, so that sam can take revenge on his "friends" who leave him behind, and no, those friends never care about sam, the only friends that care about sam was the female friend one.

[@itsshad0wz614]

I remember knowing what wick was a long time ago I never bothered to look for it so I assumed that it was a dream I never understood it but hopefully this will clear it up

[@eueylumagui7979]

The demons/children in Wick remind me of Man of Medan: Little Hope where the doubles are based on how they died.

[@quartzskull8772]

Except none of it actually happened in little hope

[@eueylumagui7979]

@@quartzskull8772 point being?

[@quartzskull8772]

@@eueylumagui7979 there is little to no connections to be made

[@eueylumagui7979]

@@quartzskull8772 bruh what's wrong with me just saying an opinion. The words that you say make no sense. Try reading and understanding before replying.😒

[@Akazawa-San]

The start already is scary

[@alien_is_tired]

I have never heard anyone pronounce "Caleb" as "Cah-leb"

[@kittencaretaker8163]

People have accents-

[@YunikuYosefMomoka]

I do..Lol

[@topoman1113]

Nice to see you back in this kind of content, love your theory/story/readings

[@ashleyhaney1133]

Tim: trying to hide Tom from the real world Tom: sensitive demon Benny: lazy hulk child Caleb: outdoor digger Lillian: bunny baby

[@pattywattytaffy2707]

The bad ending felt like a secondary good ending because Sam along with the group might've got revenge on the people who brought him there.

[@SuperLovelessgirl]

I love your theory videos, and with Little Nightmares 2, FNAF Security Breach, and BATDR coming this year I can't wait for more play throughs and awesome theories 😁🖤

[@staceytetzlaff2822]

7:05 "And the pastor warned Mary that her twins were cursed." And that's why if I was one of the ghost children I would have gone for the pastor, I bet the twins would have given him a spiritual smacking.!

[@amongusinreallifesussus7711]

The way your voice is so calm makes it more scary

[@ToaHannah007]

Great! Can you cover Year Walk sometime? It's a really beautiful enchanting short horror game based on European folklore. That I honestly view as a hidden gem.

[@briarrose8631]

Thank you! I've been waiting for a theory video forever on this game!! It's such a lovely horror game. 🤩🥰 Also I feel like the bad friend who made Sam do this keeps luring more to play Wick in order to indirectly murder. Maybe hes influenced or connected to the kids in some way?

[@lunathebunni]

0:52 "See you at 6am... ...if you live!" *damn he sound like SuperHorrorBro tf*

[@Qu1dl]

Ah yes, I'm well fed today with some wick theories

[@HiraethStuff]

Let us all give a silent prayer to the poor rabbit who was slaughtered

[@coffee-ouji]

i like how in this channel , every month, it's spooky month! :D

[@reecelast7924]

Can u explain the story’s of every kid ghost in this game please I don’t care if u do one at a time or all at once

[@LoreTheRacoon]

he did in this video there isnt anything concrete on what happened to them so he used context clues the make a educated guess

[@RhysezPieces]

You should totally do a video on The Path! It has the same vibes as this one with collecting items.

[@mono._.1980]

I think Tom was getting bullied and Tim pulled out a knife

[@justglitchmc4861]

Its the opposite, because that knife had a name written on it "Tim"

[@mono._.1980]

@@justglitchmc4861 fixed it

[@jesus_fox4919]

Yeah probably because he has polio and it's known thst they both actually go to school so-

[@4563609]

13:29 WHY U GOTTA DO HER LIKE THAT BRO 🤣

[@rebeccadoyle600]

This isn’t my comment but: Sam may have died of hypothermia, not the kids. Sam sounds like he’s shivering the entire game until he dies.

[@rebeccadoyle600]

Another note, the only thing that is required for Hypothermia is going below 95 degrees in our body.

[@jesus_fox4919]

And he can't go 3 steps without losing breath

[@dragonx4225]

Hi am kinda early but I just wanted to say that this guys channel is asome. Also I hope everyone is doing good and staying safe 😁

[@christianparrish6647]

I seriously suggest you should play Fran bow.

[@literallynobody4237]

Oh my lord. I haven’t heard of this game in a LONG time, you just brought back war flashbacks lol

[@chaeminkim5914]

I hope we could play as Duncan in the sequels. Really wondering how Sam's ghost form would look like.